Exclusive content, privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/

My maternal grandfather served in East India company by changing his surname to a non-Brahmin one because of the requirements. He had documented his service in World War 2 (in Italy) and was active during the partition in Punjab and Jammu-Kashmir. He retired shortly after, retuned to Nepal and living a long pensioned life of almost 6 decades. He passed away at the age of 90.

Agnipath is a 4 year graduation course with stipend ( no pension ) . Politicians get pension after 5 years. No other job in India gives pension after 5 years.

One of the finest Regiments and soldiers. Only people who have never served with them will not understand their commitment. I hope the government understands their legacy and retains these fine soldiers.

The most informative half an hour video on the Gorkha regiment.

Glad to have someone like Shekhar to explain on topics like these , love and respect.

The finesse with which our dear SG seamlessly integrates hard historical facts with rare insights from our military heritage is absolutely brilliant. Anything related to military and SG delivers with elan and class.

When it comes to defense related matters, SG sir with his plethora of knowledge and interesting facts always at his best.

16 lak crores collected as Income tax 19 lak crores collected as GST 3 lakh vacancies in Railways, 2 lakh vacancies in Defence Where is our tax money going ? Adani ??

He explained all story without being biased boths Indian And Nepalese side.really appreciate it.

To editor: in future when you enunciate words, have the team flash the words on the screen. It will be more effective in transmitting the message. Words like "Nepali" and "plural: Nepalis"; "Nepalese", etc.

The men of Manipur, both from kuki and meitei, i m sure they are brave enough to qualify for this given the right training and some tweaks in their mentality

very informative talk on gorkha history.Gorkhas are a brave and loyal people

Very informative as usual! Thanks Mr Gupta for explaining us the “Martial Race” theory. As I am from Bengal (East), British Indian Army didn’t have any Bengal regiment because of their distrust of Bengali race as they were the ones who were involved in the terrorist movement against the British. Thanks again for enlightening us as people of our land known so little about ourselves!!

Thank you for the video

Nicely explained on the characteristic, structure n cultural values of different gorkha regiment. I think only few Indians know how the recruitment is carried on in gorkha rifles from different regions n caste of Nepal n how they r assigned to their respective regiments established since two hundred years.

My uncle who was commissioned in the Indian Army, 2/8 Gurkha's in 1958. He was my Dad's course mate in NDA. He died in 1962, he was the Adjutant of the Unit. I am proud of his service and of the Indian Army Gurkha's. By the way Field Marshal Maneckshaw is a Gurkha, 8 Gurkha. 'Jai Maha Kali, Ayo Gorkhali'

The Gurkha units are known to be the most decorated in the Indian Army. They fought wars won badges and awards like Battle Honours in Uri sector in 1947/8, Ladakh in 1962, Jammu and Kashmir in 1965 and 1971. Additionally, they have been awarded three Param Vir Chakras, 33 Maha Vir Chakras, and 84 Vir Chakras. Not only this, they have played an important role in the Indian peacekeeping force in Sri Lanka, and have been involved in the UN peacekeeping missions in Lebanon and Sierra Leone Apart from the awards above mentioned, the Gurkha regiments have won 26 Victoria Crosses (highest bravery medal in Britain), among which 13 Victoria Crosses were awarded to British officers who served in the Gurkha regiments and the other 13 to Gurkha soldiers. Additionally, the Gurkha soldiers have also won two George Cross medals, for acts of bravery outside combat. More than 46,000 Gurkhas have died fighting for the British Crown. The Gurkha regiments have fought both World War I and World War II. The total participating soldiers were over 200,000 where more than 20,000 were deemed wounded, died or went missing in WWI and more than 23,000 in WWII. As of 2020, there are approximately 32,000 soldiers serving in 40 battalions under seven Gurkha regiments. Out of all regiments, 1st Gurkha Rifles, 3rd, 4th, 5th, 8th, 9th and 11th Gurkha Rifles are serving under the Indian Army with around 800 soldiers in each of them. Likewise, 2nd, 6th, 7th and 10th Gurkha Rifles are in the British Army.

It shows that sir is intelligible, aware and factual when he gives the clarification between the Nepali Speaking Gorkhas of India and Nepalese of Nepal, to remove confusion. This shows that he understands our nation and its people well.

Thanks, for explaining.

During the period from 1800 to 1820, the British Empire was involved in several wars and military campaigns across different regions. Here is a list of some of the significant conflicts: 1. Napoleonic Wars (1803-1815): The British Empire, along with its allies, fought against the forces of Napoleon Bonaparte's French Empire. These wars were a series of conflicts that spanned Europe and other parts of the world, including naval battles, land campaigns, and colonial struggles. 2. Anglo-Maratha Wars (1803-1818): The British East India Company fought a series of wars against the Maratha Empire in India. These conflicts resulted in the gradual annexation of Maratha territories and the establishment of British control over large parts of India. 3. Anglo-Mysore Wars (1799, 1800-1801, 1803-1804): The British Empire fought a series of wars against the Kingdom of Mysore in southern India, primarily led by the ruler Tipu Sultan. These conflicts resulted in the defeat of Tipu Sultan and the final annexation of Mysore by the British. 5. Fourth Anglo-Dutch War (1780-1784): Although it started before 1800, this war continued into the early 19th century. The British Empire fought against the Dutch Republic, resulting in British victories and the capture of several Dutch colonies, including Cape Colony (South Africa) and Dutch East Indies (Indonesia). 6. Anglo-Nepalese War (1814-1816): The British East India Company engaged in a war with the Gorkha Kingdom (Nepal). The conflict ended with the signing of the Treaty of Sugauli, which led to the cession of territories to the British and the recruitment of Gorkha soldiers into the British army. 7. First Anglo-Burmese War (1824-1826): Although it started after 1820, this war is worth mentioning as it was a significant conflict involving the British Empire. The British fought against the Burmese Empire, leading to the annexation of territories in present-day Myanmar (Burma) and the imposition of British control. These are just a few examples of the wars and conflicts in which the British Empire was engaged during the period from 1800 to 1820. The British Empire was involved in various other military campaigns, both within and beyond its colonial territories, during this time. As an expanding empire then, it was dealing with one of the conqueror 'Napeleon', who did not trust the British, on its boundaries. It was a different situation as Europe was very unstable back then. British recruited militaries from nearby regions, such as Gurkhas, Sikhs. They were always loyal. They played important role for British as well as for the establishment of the present India. At present, the world is multipolar and we see multiple geopolitical issues with neighbouring countries. Now, we need to understand 'daju bhai ko jhagada ma bahira ko manche khusi'. Those people who conquered India and recruited Gurkhas were always on the profit side and still following the same story. They are on the advantage side as always. We need to think how to utilise those energy to build our own countries. Jai Nepal Jai Bharat BRING BACK THE GLORY OF ASIA !!!

Nice update on a matter of critical importance. The Gorkhas have been loyal soldiers and india will continue to need their services against the Chinese.

Well researched, in chronological order 👍 Wonderful insight, hope the issue gets resolved amicably.

SG sir you’re a star in explaining news to the common people like me. Gurkhas are extremely respected and have always served us. Indian government should do negotiations with Nepal government to resolve their concerns and get them recruited in our great Army. Always indebted to them for their services

Who's this guy? Very well spoken and speaking pure facts about the history of Gurkhas. Glad to have found him and writing comments in the middle of the video. Bravo 👏👏👏

The new map Nepal issued 2 years ago is not a counter to Sugauli Treaty. That part was always Nepal and Nepal king let Indian soldiers to stay for awhile during Indo China war. Later those soldiers didn’t left the area and in modern days they are claiming as their own.

Pure knowledge I love these detailing of subject.thankyou very much.Its quality time when ever I listen to print

Very educative!

We should go for more Indians and Indian gorkhas in army recruitments .

Government does not want to make a differential between Indians & Gorhkas - Both have to be treated in the same footing !!!

More than the present crisis enjoyed the factual story telling. You are great at it. Thank you so much.

Very informative...i throughly enjoyed all the info about the Gurkha regiments. Thanks

Wow. What a great episode. Thanks Shekhar sir for this brilliant information.

very informative and refreshing of my knowledge. Special thumps up for this episode

Well Explained sir ❤

Amazing analysis. Hats off! 👌🍻

Firstly, Agneeveer needs some tweaking. Well-trained soldiers should be considered for police service or other wings. Secondly, the British preferred Marathas, Rajputs, Sikhs/Jats/Punjabis, and Gurkhas because of their belief in the nonsensical "MARTIAL RACE THEORY". Maybe, It's time India reconsiders this British-era thinking and divisions. Ukrainian Farmers are raining hell on Martial Ruskis.

So many nepalis are in india..they are ready to join indian army

Very informative in regard to the agniveer and it's impact to gurkhas serving our country. I had the privilege of attending two weeks of attachment at 58 GTC Happy valley, the 5th and 8th GR has a fine service history. Thank you for the further enlightenment.

Guptajee! That's a very good and illuminative programme!

I genuinly dont think its a Crisis. But, whatever helps getting those clicks

Shekarji, One little mixup regarding physical stature of various Gorkha ehnic groups. Limbus (who are from eastern Nepal) are definitely NOT taller than Gurungs. Gurungs are not only taller than Limbus, but also generally brownier. There are, broadly speaking, two Magar groups - Thapa Magars and, Gurung Magars.

Thank you, sir, you described in a well manner and very intelligently.... lots of love from Darjeeling.

Thank you Shekharji for bringing to attention that's been ignored by typical mainstream media

No problem Gorkha Regiment should be filled with Indian Gorkha instead of giving employment to people from Nepal

Talk about Gujaratis not joining Indian army. Nepalese not joining is hardly a problem for India considering the population..stop creating so much misunderstanding. Nepal loves India. To give their human resource is their choice. 🇳🇵🇮🇳

Dearest SG sir, a heartfelt thank you for bringing out such really amazing videos. Watching these videos has truly enriched my life and helped me understand many aspects of our country and the world so much better. Thank you so much!!!

Very informative

I am a indian gorkha from darjeeling i will fight and die for my motherland india ...jai hind

Excellent presentation on the history of the so-called 'martial races', the new Agniveer system of recruitment and its consequences, such as the Nepal Givernments refusal to permit recruitments under the new scheme.🙏

episodes like this one is the reason why there is no other program like Cut the Clutter

Good info sir

@Shekar ji, apart from highlighting issues it would be better if you could briefly outline possible solutions to the issues that you discuss in the various episodes.

As science and technology advance, it is crucial to prioritize the development and deployment of weapons such as drones and other essential gadgets. Recent conflicts, like the Russia-Ukraine war, have highlighted the pivotal role of drones in warfare and border inspections across various terrains.

Yes finally it was my dream now we need to build our own army

very good information. excellent.

With all the respect to Gurkhas and their fighting abilities and their sincerity,Best is when the son of the soil defends its borders.I will be the happiest when Indian Army raise The Gujrat Regiment

Mr. Gupta, Chhetris are Rajputs and not the Brahmins. Brahmins in Nepal are termed as Bahun. You have also forgotten to mention the Rais( Limbu, Tamang. Magar, Gurung and Rai). These are the Janjatis of Nepal who are mainly recruited in Indian Army.

Excellent narrative, Mr Gupta

I am Nepali but I will happy fight for India if needed 😊😊 hope they come to peace and end this problem soon

With all due respect to Gurkha soldiers i don't believe that it's a crisis army should focus on achieving technological superiority not just overwhelming valor. I mean we have enough volunteered soldiers in our own country.

Presently sitting in Raxaul returning from a visit to Nepal. The resentment among the Nepalese people against India is visible. They are refusing to take Indian currency, the atmosphere is quite anti Modi if not not anti Indian. There are Chinese infrastructure projects like highways, tunnels going on all across Nepal all the way from Kathmandu to Pokhara etc. Don't know what's our government thinking...

Excellent, informative episode. I believe India has weighed up costs and benefits of this 5 year agni path scheme, but it's introduction has definitely caused headaches to the military planners. Who came up with it in the first place?

Another very informative piece Sir. I was particularly taken by your explanation of the "Martial Races" theory, and wondered if that might not be extended back in time to the raising of the Scottish Regiments after Culloden in 1746. In the years following the defeat of the Jacobite forces, with England embroiled in a new kind of warfare in the forests of North America, they sought out Scottish soldiers because of their particular prowess in this kind of environment? It would also have removed a sizeable body of otherwise potentially troublesome soldiers out of Scotland as you noted was a consideration for the offer to the Gorkha's. Just a thought. Thanks again for you and your team's superb journalism.

Its a humongous 'fall-in' opportunity for Gorkhaland and Indian Gorkhas spread all over North India specially U'Khand, as unemployment is rife.

Since Nepal politicians have good relations with the Chinese govt, don’t be surprised if this crisis is due to the Chinese pressure as this will weaken the Indian army which what the Chinese govt wants. Next, China might set up it’s own Gurkha regiment as it can afford to give good salaries to them.

Very detailed...

This one was a great episode, especially the detailed explanation on the “martial races”

Historically, the terms "Gurkha" and "Gorkhali" were synonymous with "Nepali", which originates from the hill principality Gorkha Kingdom, from which the Kingdom of Nepal expanded under Prithvi Narayan Shah.[7][8] The name may be traced to the medieval Hindu warrior-saint Guru Gorakhnath[9] who has a historic shrine in Gorkha District. The word itself derived from Go-Raksha (Nepali: गोरक्षा i.e., 'Protector(रक्षा) of cows(गो')), raksha becoming rakha (रखा). Rakhawala means 'protector' and is derived from raksha as well.

Very informative. Thank u. Problem is our soldiers and Officers in the army still believe in this flawed concept of martial races

Sir, Please.... please declutter the Indian Armed forces structure like under a new series "Know your Armed forces". Regiments, their base and training centres, Commands, battle formation etc.. Meanwhile suggest a source where we can get the most up to date information.

I wonder if u could do detail Video regarding Gorkha troop during WWII. How they suffered and how they succeed. I would be really thankful. Loved the thank you

While identifying races for their phenotypical traits might be highly politically incorrect, we can at least say there are cultural distinctions that make some very amenable to hardy & physically demanding roles that can be observed in other countries of the world.

Recruit more from Laddak and other hill areas. Jai Hind

Very good analysis. Thanks SG for valuable information 🙏

@ThePrintIndia please explain battalion, infantry, regiment 🙏

My learning from this episode. The British were cunning and exploitive but in the end seems like they deserved an empire 🥲

Smart people the British: 1. Identify self-interests 2. Find people who can help them achieve those interests. Label them. 3. Declare that label to be better than others. Labelled people get happy and ready to fight with unlabelled people. 4. The British realize few talented among the unlabelled people. 5. Attach new label to these talented people and propagate new theories about these newly labelled people. 6. Go back to pt 3 above.. and keep repeating. 7. Meanwhile the British keep track of progress in pt. 1 The labels are like the appreciation emails you get from your boss! Makes you work like crazy after you get them and yet those labels don’t help you pay off your mortgage or credit card bills! All it takes for the boss in achieving wonderful results is few strokes on a keyboard!

That's a blessing in disguise !

Awesome ❤ video

Shekhar ji ..(with a lot of respect and love for you) now is the time to discredit this martial races BS and raise a Gujrat regiment and a Bania regiment of Agniveers ..and see if they can give all Indians an occasion to celebrate their courage and bravery when they get back 100s of square km of our land grabbed by Chinese. You should lobby Modi ji to undertake this and other social experiments.. to replace Gandhi ji's "experiments with truth".

Actually, the British genuinely believed in the ridiculous MARTIAL RACE THEORY. Lord Roberts was its architect. It was not just incorporating vanquished forces. They genuinely considered tall, fair, blue-eyed individuals to make better soldiers (not just as warriors but also discipline-wise). Hence, Pathans, Rajputs, Sikhs, Gurkhas and Marathas were their preferred stock. The Indian army was reformed in 1956, but British elements remained. Even in the current scenario, the North has more representation in the army. That said, one needs to understand that the rest of India has had better economic opportunities in other fields, and the army is not the sole benchmark of patriotism.

The world's best and toughest soldiers yesterday today and tomorrow..

With due respect to our nepali brothers, my view is very firm on this that indian army should only recruit indian gorkhas. We have 4 million gurkhas which are indian citizens.

Don't worry we have Indian Gurkhas as well as people from Nagaland, Manipur, Arunachal Pradesh, Mizoram who also fierce warrior atleast give us chance to prove our abilities.

Don't worry..we the gurkha more than 50-60 lakhs live in northeastern part of india.n.we r pure indian citizen ..jai gurkha

India gov must over agnipath schemes . These schemes just destroys indian strengths, many of my friends who were willing to join indian army are now trying to do some small work instead of joining indian army

Splendid hack job Shekharji!

I have seen lots of immature comments like Nepalese Gurkhas will be employed in Chinese PLA. It is not feasible as PLA is army of Communist Party not of China it cannot allow any non communist to serve in it. Nepal govt is simply spreading this rumour to bargain with India. Additionaly any Nepalese does not require permission to take job in India. They can just travel to UP or Bihar and join the Agnipath scheme.

But do we still need them? We have a sizeable population and our people can do what these gorkha soldiers did. Don’t forget they were all trained in India. And people who got acknowledgment from these regiments were not Nepales.

Thanks sir

thanks

It is just silly for anyone to say that British considered Nepal as a buffer between them and Chinese power. China as we know, including Tibet, wasn't even in existence then. The Himalayas are so mighty to penetrate even now, and in British times they must be delusional like the propagandist that it could breached by some empire far away in China. Bringing in caste etc shows an agenda here. This episode is bookmarked by me. Will be forwarded to whoever needs to look into.

Nepali gorkhaon ko sena main dalne ki jarurat bhi nahi ladhak, skkim aur baki northeast state k logon ko dalo in gorkhas k badle

Gupta ji, you have not covered the subject which is the title of the video. You have delved into the history of the Gurkha regiments and the martial race theory but not said a word about the fallout of the non availability of recruits from Nepal for the Gurkha regiments. The Indian Army had foreseen this possibility and nowadays the shortfall from Nepal is being made up by recruitment of hill people from Garhwal and Kumaon (who are of similar ethnicity) into the Gurkha regiments.

Sir, Thank you atlest saying Indian Neplai Gorkhas as we dont have a state in India but we give our life for our motherland.

Being a Nepali, I was always surprised about the fact that why British always recruit magar, rai, gurung etc. Since the name "Gorkha" itself came from district Gorkha or Prithvi Narayan shah's Army. Those army was composed of mainly Magar, Chettri and some brahmin like kalu pandey. Other than magar, castes like rai, limbu, gurung never supported the campaign of prithvi Narayan shah. Never assisted that campaign. In different Anglo Nepalese war, more than 95% were Chettri, magar, etc. How come other castes came to known as Gorkhas. I think it's British divide and rule policy and conspiracy.

Captain Manoj Kumar Pandey Sir PVC(posthumously) mine all time favourite. He belonged to 1/11 GR.😈🔥❤️

The Agniveer recruitment particularly is one of the many policies that have not been thought about!

Inspite being Parents from Engrs nd Medical my Son chosen Gorkha regiment.❤