Another moment of judge bias being emotional.🙄 He already had his mind made up as soon as that girl opened her mouth. He didn’t let the father speak or elaborate on anything because anything to do with an absent father triggers his emotions about his very own past. Not enough details and barely any evidence. This case should have been dismissed!

She is very irresponsible. She has one child already and the father is not in the picture. She is moving from house to house (homeless), now she pregnant again, by another man and living with her father in a one bedroom home.

Why didn't the fathers of her children do anything about her situation especially with her being homeless 😒

I believe the father, she was 100% being childish, wanting to be grown but acting like a child…… doesn’t have a pot to piss in and she gets pregnant again…..; very irresponsible

She has no stable housing, no employment, no committed partner, no savings but adds another child to her temporary household.

That was irresponsible on her part to get pregnant again while living with her father in a 1 bedroom apartment. The men don't have a place for her and her son.

At the end of the day, she still has 2 kids to raise, with 2 deadbeat baby daddies, with no stable place to live, and she has burned her bridge with her father, who could have helped her down the line. Did she really "win" this case?

She's lying that a locksmith broke down the door. We know dam well it was the baby's father number 2... Pops said you gotta go. There's a reason why her mama only allowed her grandchild to stay😂😂😂

Living off the system and keep getting pregnant and y’all saying he too tough on her,?? Shiiiddd he wasn’t tough enough

I see absolutely nothing wrong with a parent telling a grown child that they can't have company if they are not paying rent. This girl needs to grow up and live like an independent ADULT!

So she was bringing broke bums around thinking they gone lay up on her Dad?!? How dreadful 🥴

Dam. Judge had it out for him. Fully supported the daughter who was clearly irresponsible with having kids shouldn't even independently do for.

JM needs to be ashamed of himself for this one you can clearly tell from the beginning he didn’t like the father.

The plaintiff needs to grow up! It was irresponsible of her to bring another child into her Fathers one bedroom apartment!! The defendant has some anger with the plaintiffs mother that he uses against the plaintiff! I really hope they seek counseling! They both need it!

And than she smirking with no house of her own

The moment JM didnt allow this man to give any background we knew what time it was

I believe the father she seems very disrespectful no matter what the situation was, and she didn't like his rules she shouldn't have moved in

She sure had a lot of negatives to say about that man. Where was mom? Where were her siblings? Why didn't she move in with baby daddy? Obviously he's not a great father but he can't be that bad if he was the ONE person that helped her.

Seems to me that she was trying to get her father locked up so she could take over the apartment and move her new baby daddy in. Why would you keep calling the police on your dad that let you move in with him? Even going as far as getting protective orders against him. She’s a liar and very sneaky. I wouldn’t look at her as my daughter either after all that. Judge is wrong for siding with her. How you gonna get pregnant immediately after moving into your dads place? Judge should’ve chewed her out.

JM didn't want to hear the defendant smdh.

I know this might be against the grain but I don't blame him for saying she can't have like male company because you are already with a little boy there had in there to be living with somebody and get pregnant again with no job

This man abandoned his daughter and has some nerve to be acting so arrogant and authoritative. She’s lost and has no idea how to find her way…she needs guidance and support but if she’s not willing then she needs to be on her own.

I’m sorry but I feel like the daughter needs to be accountable for herself. If things weren’t working out she should have moved out. It was her dads house she PAID NO RENT and thought she could do what she wanted. That was wrong. Your an adult and you want to do whatever then get your own space. Especially if you have kids.

He’s like Good riddance…lol Hurry up & Bye 😂 she is a disgrace.

Now since the new BD stayed in the same apartments, why couldn’t he help her get all her stuff??? Why couldn’t she stay with him, instead of having of having to live with her mom?!

If everyone is putting you out who is really the problem, the biggest issue is they didn’t even get to know each other before he allowed his daughter to move in. Another issue why you having babies by someone that can’t provide for you, that’s a red flag right there

Men love to use the mom as an excuse to leave their children. There r courts in place to enforce the father's rights but they rather stay away and blame mom. Disgusting.

She's a piece of work. She has 2 kids, she needs to get a job and be independent.

JM always taking up for women who create these situations for themselves by making the man pay for it. I’m not for it at all. Women need to be held accountable for their choices. This girl is clearly the problem. I’m glad the dad made the choice to accept that no relationship will be between them. She’s just running around creating out of wedlock children and angry that he isn’t helping take care of them.

JM already had his mind made up . He rules off of emotions not logic, evidence or facts.

I had to come to the comments because I’m like here goes JM again. I’m glad to know I wasn’t the only one thinking JM responded with emotions and not facts. You can always tell which litigant he favors. The judge be in his feelings a lot !!

I lnow a woman who has been kicked out of everybody house across 5 states. Parents, siblings, kids, ex-husband, boyfriends, friends, sex partners. This is over a decade period. And if you ask her, its everybody else's fault.

The men that she laying on her back for can’t provide her housing? She seems very entitled and trifling. This man invited her to live in his home. She called the police on him several times for “assault “. Why would she stay in the home if it was true? Why would she get pregnant again with another baby and can’t provide for the first one and homeless.? She’s not too bright

THE DEFENDANT LOOKS HATEFUL AND MEAN !!😮😮

JM to Def: Give me some background. Def: *starts giving background* JM to Def: I don't need to hear that. Let's talk about the case.

Well, at least we know what her momma's favorite store was.

The man I won't say father or dad....he has no love for his daughter and grandson...

Yeah when JM gets upset case closed lol

Hmmm judge Mathis was wrong on this one the daughter seems to be for the streets and probably disrespectful to father after he allowed her to come stay with him

This female is a piece of work. She is a ingrate. Her father had every right to be upset with her. She doesn't seem to understand what she caused her father- to be evicted-trying to help her. She knew the rules when she moved in and agreed to it. I can believe the father that non of the other siblings wants to deal with her. If she had been evicted from every place she has been says a lot right there. She needs to stop having these kids out of wedlock and expecting someone else to always help her out of a situation she put herself in. JM gets into his feelings too much at times and this was one of them. This was a 1 bedroom as well which shows her father cared about her and her child. 3 people living in a 1 bdrm? Whew!

She's trifling and a bum. The Judge however always seems to give a pass to women no matter what.

HEY, JM FAMILY ...Stay blessed

Regardless of how she is, her father was ABSENT and clearly was not their to help guide her. He wasn’t a father because he DIDNT WANT TO BE. If he wanted to, he would have done everything to make sure his child grew up with him. Let’s be real.

Men always use "the mother kept me away" as an excuse.

The fact that the father didn’t acknowledge her child as his grandson!. He is evil and I know his type.

I know thats his daughter but. I wouldnt have moved her in. She probably secretly hates him. Then she's getting pregnant in her position. She needs public assistance if thats the behavior she plans in continuing. He doesn't reaaly know her. Let her fend for herself. She seems problematic.

She look like a sweet girl but ummmmmmm she have issue stop havin these men get y’all prego without even havin a pot to piss in 😩

why u move in with a man u said abandoned you

Her relationship with men is the result of the relationship with her father.

She come off as entitled and bitter..she seem rude and ungrateful..just live with your boyfriend..o he probably dont want her

Wth would she allow herself to get pregnant AGAIN in a 1 bedroom apartment with her father that was very irresponsible of her, i hope she gets her life together for her kids because obviously she cant keep a man around

She will learn her lesson dad my have been wrong here but she’s has some growing to do

He really ought to be a shame! 🙄

How did JM not hold her accountable to her irresponsibility ways. He should be as tough in her as he is with the young boys now the father do owe her for her belongings though.

What a great man🤮 and that daughter shud cut ties and go

He can’t be absent then expect her to respect to your parenting style when she is of legal age. I have seen this a lot with absent mothers who come back. It’s too late to tell her she’s looking for love in all the wrong places, show her the way.

Good to see the Judge shutting down that excuse, a lot deadbeats use! 😮

In 2nd case ...JM always shows his hand....JM was against the dad immediately

Sad how the defendant says “her son “instead of saying “my grandson “. Sad how the father is so hostile towards his daughter.

Notice the father never denied hitting her. I wish she would have filed assault charges and had his ass locked up. After abandoning his daughter most of her life as a child, he then physically and verbally abuses her as an adult. To add insult to injury he does all this while she has a young toddler. He's a real piece of $%#$#^.

I believe he did lock her out. However I do believe he told her no company because shes homeless with a child and didnt want her to make more. They were basically strangers which is sad.

I don't know how so many BM blame BW for all their failures and not be embarrassed. To be clear, men take responsibility for their lives and don't blame anything or anyone for the outcome.

She would probably have a better relationship with men and be more responsible if her father didn't walk out when she was a child

Lady that wants to b an adult you and your boyfriend get your own want to lay in someone's house and continue getting pregnant 😢

The father sounds like a piece of work🤔he seems to be cold and his daughter is angry because he hasn't been there when she was little 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽😘God help them

The girl lacks resolution skills.

That grown, get your own place

JM could of just gave him 30 days to return the property

They are quick to say the mother kept the child away. You know between night and day, our country has a legal system in every state. Just admit you didn't want to take on the responsibility. It's sad beyond reason our children have to suffer the consequences of foolish grown folks. Judge Mathis knew what he was all about when he opened that mouth. .

So sad when father and daughter cant get along.

Judge need too be ashamed on this one she’s a Blayton liar

This case reminded me of a saying that a child will burn down a village to feel warmth.

Too, too bad about their relationship. I don't feel like the plaintiff proved her case. Why can't she woman-up and get her own place! She gives terror vibes!

Im glad others had a different opinion as well. JM seemed to align with her off the bat rather than listening to the dad

How come women don't want husbands anymore? They all want to be baby mamas now.

Judge Mathis be in his feelings WAY TOO MUCH!!!

She came on tv & actually mad a fool of herself 🤦🏾‍♀️ Young lady you should’ve kept that between you & your dad

Why she ain’t staying with her mama or better yet have her own

Judge sassy got his feelings fast as usual... Misandry in court is a big problem.

Some families are broken...its so sad to see...

They were complete strangers. N him saying that the mom kept her away, is an excuse. Go through the courts for what’s RIGHTFULLY yours

Wow the plaintiff beating the hell out of this broken system!!!

I wouldn’t have nothing to do with her , if I was her father !! let those bums help her

Anytime Judge wife is in the audience he act so ignorant

JM should look back to this show and feel sick to his stomach for being wrapped up in his emotional state of mind when he tries cases involving his demons. The father never had a chance

JM wasn't for the bs today... he was so short with them

Wow! So sad.

I refuse to help an able bodied grown person that has the ability to think for themselves. I'm no savior and won't pretend to be.

Judge knew what company meant; should have anyway,lol

Mathis loves to take up for chaotic women! There has been many cases where he'll let the agent of chaos get their story out but won't let the man defend himself properly or minimally! He screwed that father by caping for the adult female toddler!

Did she say she was pregnant by the boyfriend that lived upstairs from them? Girl leave your dad alone!

I knew he was Doomed from the get go when he said her mother kept him away, the judge cut him off quick!

You are not staying in my house calling the police adult kid's

My daddy and his oldest daughter 😂😂😂😂😂

She will need him before he needs her. Never burn your bridges ladies and gentlemen.

Whytf you having more kids and don't have ur own place is beyond me

Judge Mathis seemed unconcerned. He didn’t even look at the police report she had!!!

Judge Judy would have given her property back and nothing more.

The plaintiff is definitely irresponsible for making a child in a situation where she's already struggling, but you can't really expect her to respect someone who wasn't there during the duration of her childhood. Trying to be a "father" all of a sudden after making excuses NOT to see your child and treating someone else's children better than your own is wild. People always blame the other parent for being an absentee, but if you want your child, you're going to make the effort - man or woman. People don't be fighting for their kids, just be making up any excuse they see possible.

She should be ashamed of herself!! Wow just wow 😮 I wouldn’t speak with her anymore