Once again, we didn’t see this coming! Normally we like to comment as we watch a music video but this time around we were completely locked in 😅. We’ll be a bit more vocal next time! More videos coming this week!

The theme for this song is “the first death of a dancer is when he stops dancing. And this death is the most painful” Bts talk about how they’re scared of stop loving to make music and they question themselves of what will they do if/when this happens. It was lately found out that during this song bts actually went through a situation they were describing in Black Swan. “No song affects me anymore; the heart no longer races when the music starts to play; no longer makes my heart vibrate” They weren’t satisfied with themselves as artists and didn’t feel very happy and enjoyable about their lives. Therefore, this song coveys their struggles and worries about life of an artist and the consequences of an artistic burnout.

Highly recommend their live performances if you want to check out their vocal range. 2021 FESTA BTS Room Live will definitely show you their vast discography. They do have ballad songs where the vocal line truly shines, such as "The Truth Untold" and "House of Cards". Excited to see more of your BTS reaction videos!

'Film out' is an amazing ballad with all members. It's in japanese and has a complex, poignant melody.

Jimin in Black Swan is mesmerising. His expressiveness while dancing is just exquisite 👌

*Jimin* (blue hair) is the only guy in the group who is trained in contemporary dance, he was #1 in his school of arts. He took lead on the choreo in this MV, teaching the other guys how to move. Next suggestion: - "Blood Sweat and Tears" - "Not Today"

Black Swan has an orchestra version, when you look it up it's the one Art film title. I would definitely recommend listening to that version too. You don't even have to react to it but definitely listen to it.

Would you believe that they are even better live?

Jimin is the one playing the black swan and doing all the contemporary dancing in this video. He's so talented and makes you feel so much ❤️

Been loving your reactions learning about our boys. Jimin is the one who majored in contemporary dance for about 1-2 years prior to joining Big Hit. Black Swan was several years later and I think it's a testament to how good he is to still be able to dance like this, since they mostly focus on hip hop style of dancing. For ballads I love House of Cards live with English subs, The Truth Untold, Film Out, Your eyes Tell, Stay Gold. They have beautiful voices, and ranges. Enjoy your dive into the rabbit hole💜💜💜💜💜💜💜

You guys want to see vocals?! Check out these two Japanese singles: “your eyes tell” and “film out”! Their slower songs will show more vocals if that’s what ya into. “Born singer” and “for youth” is really good too. Do the live performances for these four songs. Not the MVs. These definitely will blown ya away! Love the reactions. Keep ‘em coming!

If you're looking for vocal range watch your eyes tell live. Its amazing

BTS is whole package, they have 3 rappers and 4 vocalists. Their music had so many genres including: - POP (boy with luv, dimple) - EDM (Best of Me, So What, DNA) - Latin pop (Airplane pt.2) - R&B / Jazz (Singularity) - Urban (I need You) - Hip-Hop (No More Dream, We Are Bulletproof pt.2) - Moombahton Trap (Blood Sweat & Tears) - Dance Pop (Just Dance, Go go, EGO) - Ballad (Awake, The Truth Untold) - Rap (Chyper 1, 2, 3, 4, Outro Tears, UGH) - Light Dupstep (Fire) - Rock (Danger, Fake Love, Run BTS) - Light Trap (Save Me) and many more >_< Their voice in every live performances are so amazing, you can clearly hear their real voice without any lipsyncs. I suggest you guys to watch their live performances to see their vocal range starting from : - BTS Tiny Desk Concert 2020 - BTS Room Live 2021 - BTS Proof Live 2022.

U guys should react to some live versions because the boys are insane live !!!

A few minutes into the video and I see you've mentioned ballad. BTS do have ballads...two popular ones with music videos are 'Spring Day', and 'Yet To Come'. There are others that are sung by just the vocal unit and also solo songs. 'Spring Day' is one of their most successful songs in South Korea. It's a nostalgic, longing type of song. Most importantly, it's a favourite among korean listeners because it alludes to the Sewol ferry tragedy (2014) that took the lives of 304 passengers most of whom were young students. I can't help but cry whenever I listen to it. The song has been charting on SK's Melon Music charts for over 258 weeks now. It's the longest charting song in Melon Chart history.

If you want a Ballad song from them, I recommend “The Truth Untold.” They don’t have a MV for it, but a live one is really good. 💜

I'm a huge fan of Cold play.. and I accidentally watched BTS cover of their song fix you... Their cover hooked me to listen to them more

This song is related to Martha Graham's quote, “a dancer dies twice - once when they stop dancing, and this first death is the more painful.” Black Swan is about their fear of losing passion for their craft. As RM rapped - If this no longer resonates, no longer makes my heartbeat, that's hen I die my first death. Also, if you want to hear more of their wonderful vocals, i love these: - Born Singer - Louder Than Bombs - Film Out - Magic Shop (this song helped me when I was in a deep dark place) Love your reactions. Keep it up!

For the singing aspect, I would recommend: -Crystal Snow (japanese song, My personal Fav) -Your Eyes Tell (japanese song) -The truth Untold -Magic Shop -Film Out (japanese song) -House of Cards - 0 O´clock -Butterfly -Answer:Love Myself -Spring Day -Dimple And many more.....

You should react to "Festa 2021 Room Live" and "A Guide To BTS members: BANGTAN 7" by Taylor. Festa is basically a mixup of their songs from their debut till 2020. The intro docu will be more centred towards the members individually and their artistry.

Your being silent during the video was actually very telling… they are stunning in their performance and it is so easy to be mesmerized! This is one of my favorite performances. And in most of their music there are several versions and you continue to discover something new each time you watch. There’s never enough and they work so hard to present their best! 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜

If you want vocal centric songs “Crystal Snow Live” & “House of Cards live”

Thank you for the amazing reaction! Since the last two songs were very different in genres I would recommend you to see Airplane part 2 next. It’s also completely different from what you’ve seen so far!😄 from their iconic songs it’s of course Fake Love and Spring Day, but spring day has to be watched with an explanation coz it is veeeery meaningful to people and is based on real life events.

u guys should react to bts room live festa (make sure to turn captions on!) it’s not super long and it showcases their insane voices and talents as well as their great mix of genres not to mention the goofiness of the members 😂😂

Thank you for the great reaction as always guys💜 if you want to hear their vocal, I suggest you to react their japanese songs since the vocal lines in those songs are crazy like hella crazy! I think reacting to "Film Out" MV would be amazing! Oh, also, in case you didn't know, yes bts also have albums and songs in japanese too (the members are all fluent in japanase). they usually have japan comebacks after they released the korean one, mostly the songs are just japanase ver of the original songs, but they also have some songs that originally in japanese and don't have the korean version of it(such as Film Out, Let Go, Your Eyes Tell, many more!) Also, when you learn about their vocal line (Jungkook, V, Jimin and Jin), you will be amazed at how their vocal have different characters and compatible with each other (their rap line is also like this too tbh). Their technique, range, style is just *chef's kiss👌*

if you like more singing you should check out your eyes tell live please :) 🤍 thank you for your reactions!

I love that you don’t pausing every few seconds .. I actually listen to your comments after the video!! Keep it up!!!

You can watch the truth untold live

BTS live performances are greatly recommended! you can check a few like 'BTS Room Live', 'film out - live' and to hear more from the vocal line I really recommend 'Crystal Snow', 'Film Out' and 'Your Eyes Tell' !

Please react to Airplane part 2 it nice it Latin pop vibe and react to Dimple and Pipe piper live performance from 5 muster magic shop concert

Song recommendations to get to know their vocal range (watch the live performances!): - Your eyes tell - The truth untold - Film out - Crystal snow these are just a few but they are great to start with :)

live shows ballad type songs where there vocals shine are----- truth untold, your eyes tell, film out, stay gold, magic shop, hold me, propose

Jimin is trained in contemporary dance which shows in the way he moves and even stands in many of their videos and dance practices ( which are not really practices) and he also studied ballet, traditional and hip hop at his performing arts high school and dance Academy in Busan. He and the other members showcase contemporary a lot in this video- the dance style and bare feet. There is also an instrumental Art Film version of this song with the contemporary/modern MN Dance Company from Slovenia(not BTS) that was released before this one- it is so beautiful. 💜

I suggest you watch some of their live performances too! 💜

From what I've seen and read, you are watching them as they grow into these 7 amazing talented young men who have touched the world

BTS is highly dynamic, that's one interesting thing about them. You just don't know what to expect!

In the MV they display the meaning behind the track, Jimin shows it through his solo freestyle dancing reflecting as their shadows since he’s the black swan and brings out his wings (which wasn’t part of the original choreography) this particular dance was done by brailizan dancer which Jimin helps the others since it’s more his element with assistance from Hobi and JK. I also noticed Jin’s reflection didnt move within the mirrors when he turned around 👀 on top of them all dancing barefoot. *The song is very sad even though it may not appear that upbeat, it’s about a dancer who dies twice (not literally) but inside when the artist stops performing which is the first death is most painful* BTS and all of artist fear of one day they may lose the passion for music and dance, making them die their first death.* *FUN FACT: After watching Black Swan movie a couple times RM got inspired and decided to write a song about the sacrifice an artist makes when they lose the passion or stops performing which is the hardest thing to do the first time around.* #BlackSwan #BTS

The lyrics are always very important when in comes to BTS as they have deep messages and sometimes inter-connected.

Thanks for reacting guys, please Watch their live performances you’ll see how talented they are. 💜

You should watch the black swan live. It's insane live, some great live performance are -Jimmy Fallon -permission to dance on stage LA/LAS VEGAS -MMA 2020 -before watching the live react to the art film first

You’re faces were sooooo mesmerized……just the kind of reactions BTS Army loves💜. The main dancer doing the solos is Jimin…..and he is a trained contemporary dancer…..along with hip hop and popping. The song was about what happens if you lose your passion for music and performing……it would be, for them, like their “first death”. All of their songs have very deep meaningful lyrics. To hear their voices without dancing…..I suggest NPR Tiny Desk Concert or live performance of Your Eyes Tell or Film Out (both of those are sung in Japanese and English). Hope you are enjoying your journey……

I recommend Film Out (it's a Japanese song), House of cards and The truth untold ( Vocal line songs), Outro Tear (A rap line song). If you want to know about their solo songs I recommend to begin with Epiphany, My time, Filter, Singularity (vocal line), Ego, Joke and Daechwita (Rap line). They also have covers of other songs. I also recommend the Room Live 2021Festa that shows their vast discography. And for when you're ready for a guide, I recommend The Bangtan 7 by Taylor.

They each have individual songs that showcase their talent

Black Swan is just majestic, amazing, incredible ❤️ Thank you for your video ♡

BTS has a lot of songs, one more different than the other, they tend to explore a lot. Keep reacting, I'm loving it!

Pls react to BTS proof live performance thank u❤️❤️

I like this channel because some other channels only prioritize the quality of their voices, and don't prioritize the quality of the singers they review,good job👍🏼✌️

You are going to find our guys mind blowing musically, vocally, choreography and don’t even get me started on their individual personalities…the only thing I know is the world cannot be without BTS…they are special 💜💜💜💜Introduction to BTS is a 30-40 minute clip depending on how many times you pause that will give you that shortcut to learning about them before you take on a lot of the music making it easier to see their purpose

WATCH BLACK SWAN LIVE I BEG JIMIN IS ONE HELL OF A DANCER and this is in his element ( hes the one in the darkness dancing with the blue hair, hes the black swan and the contemporary dancer of the group)

i would like to recommend (film out) for live version

I think this song is beyond the level of an idol group. That's why BTS is so popular all over the world.

Thank you for being respectful to our boys. You guys still have a veeeery deep rabbit hole to explore. Enjoy your journey 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜

Fake Love or Blood Sweat and Tears would be good good choices for your next reaction. Looking for a ballad ? The Truth Untold live (from the vocal line ).

Since you guys asked for a more Vocally song, a ballad, im gonna recommend you guys "The Truth untold" by the vocal line (vocalists of BTS) Vocalists are: Jin V Jimin Jungkook (also used to rap in older songs of BTS) If you guys are interested in just Rap i recommend Outro: Tear live by the Rap line (rappers of BTS) kzfaq.info/get/bejne/i6qllK14vsucdYU.html The rappers are: RM Suga Jhope

So with pretty much with all BTS music, they have a video, dance choreography video, and a live performance video. each one is a different level.

I know this comment is late, but NOW that we know (from Jin sharing in his "The Astronaut" V live), that they collectively decided to enlist in the military after releasing MOTS 7 (where this track is included)... the message of this song makes more sense. Namjoon (who wrote Black Swan, primarily) has been vocal about saying he needs to "find his purpose", multiple times during the 2 years of the pandemic... not knowing if he is an IDOL or global ambassador (watch his Rolling Stone interview with Pharrell) gives the lyrics to this a whole other level of meaning and gives a glimpse into the turmoil that must have been going on in him, at the time. Black Swan is about losing one's passion for something, for their art. And now this makes so much more sense. Cannot wait for RM's solo project, "Indigo"! I hope you guys can go check his other solos "RM" and "Mono" before Indigo comes out, or at least listen to them on your own time. You'll get a deeper appreciation for him as an artist.

A theme you’ll see in a lot of BTS videos/songs, is the dichotomy between good and evil ( the black and white outfits in this video and also the theme of the Black Swan movie). It’s about facing and accepting all parts of ourselves, no one is ever just one thing as humans are complex, I personally love the honesty in this message because it’s vulnerable and real. Many people wear a mask and don’t feel comfortable accepting all parts of themselves or rather it’s not acceptable to show all sides of yourself as in when you’re angry or sad someone will always tell you to calm down or cheer up. Down the road, when you get to their Map of the soul album, the songs are based on Swiss Psychiatrist Carl Jung’s theory, the lyrics inspire introspection and growth. I love that BTS touch on these topics and although some songs are just fun, most have a deeper message. Also in this video, they’re talking about, as an artist, fear of losing passion for their art. A reference to the quote by a dancer Martha Graham-“a dancer dies twice, once when they stop dancing, and this is this first death is more painful”. For vocals, House of Cards live, Truth untold live I believe that even BTS’ many genres represents their message the best- as in don’t be afraid to follow your heart and passion where ever that leads, they just love music and don’t have to follow patterns or be boxed into any one lane just because that’s what has always been done. Their message is of self love and being true to yourself. I love hearing all of your perspectives on the reactions, can’t wait for the next one!💜

Perfect reaction!! If you want to see more of their vocal range, I suggest you to check out live performances of "The Truth Untold" and "House of Cards"! These two are songs from the vocal line. I promise you won't regret, those are simply incredible!! Stay well 💜💜💜

It's based on a Martha Graham quote. “a dancer dies twice - once when they stop dancing, and this first death is the more painful.”

I love watching people discover BTS

please react BTS Proof Live, their vocal is amazing

ARMY won't really mind if you guys rewatch the video or look up lyrics after watching their MVs. If you're going with the latter option, I would recommend doolsetbangtan (she has a website) that has a complete translation (with context) of all BTS songs, one of the most reliable translators in the fandom. :) Their lyrics are one of the biggest reasons why BTS is where they are today.

NPR tiny desk is what I recommended for listening live performance.

Black swan live shows true emotions and dances! U guys should watch it

Black Swan is about BTS fear of one day losing their love and passion for music. At the time they were really burnt out and were actually intending on taking a break and doing solo albums after their world tour in 2020. But the pandemic happened and the entire tour was cancelled, so BTS held off their plans and made some fully English songs to cheer people up and recorded their album BE during the pandemic instead.

I watch you guys from the very beginning and I commend you for giving a raw and authentic reaction. I really love it. Since you watch some of the MV’s, I highly recommend you guys to know the BTS more. The best video is “this is bts: introduction to bts” by xceleste. More power guys ❤

BTS doing Cold Play’s, ‘Fix You’ on MTV Unplugged was beautiful. And Untold Truth

BLACK SWAN HIGHLY TALENTED CHOREAGRAFI OF BTS..THEY PRODUCTION IS.. NEXT LEVEL..BRO.THEY CHANGED ALL THE TRADITIONAL STYLE TO THE NEW ERA. BTS_ARMY ✌️

Yesss I was waiting for this one!! Please react to : Fake love Fire Dope Not today For song where the vocal line shines listen: Film out The truth untold House of cards Room Festa (2021) Can’t wait for the BTS introduction 💜😆 Also, please guys comment the lyrics a bit more, BTS’s lyrics are so profound and beautiful, they are the lyrics BTS :))

Their videos have a short behond the scenes shooting sketch and a lot of their tracks have dance practice videos. Black Swan dance practice is great.💜

Best live performance of Black Swan is at the James Corden show (outside their recent concerts ofc). The set and performance are so emotional and haunting you will hold your breath from start to finish

I completely recommend you watch the dance practices to this and also all the others you do 😭

More info, Kim Soek-jin never sang a note before being recruited by Big-Hit for his visuals. He practices constantly, so much so that he went from small segments in their songs to solos. I cannot imagine not hearing that beautiful, lyrical voice. When you can, watch House of Cards and Truth Untold, just the vocal line and you can then appreciate the diligence and hard work these then boys, now men put into their work.

tiny desk conecrt for more vocals!!!

Definitely recommend BTS’s tiny desk concert from NPR.

yes blackswan is really one of the best songs ever

When you posted the teaser yesterday, I knew that you’d be reacting to Black Swan 😂😂 BTS’ range is limitless. It’s a very emotionally charged song, since this was intended to be their last single/album before going on the hiatus they’re currently on. Not to mention the role this song plays in their Map of the Soul series.

Please react to BTS Performance on MMA 2019. That was one of the best live performances I have ever seen.

You should check out their Black Swan live performances! Especially their recent concert performance in LV! Also some good ones to check out are blood sweat and tears and louder than bombs!

Ironically, Black Swan was what made me get into BTS music a long time ago. Cool group.

Мне всегда очень интересно смотреть как люди знакомятся с BTS. Интересно, какой клип они посмотрят следующим? И мне кажется, они будут немного шокированы, если посмотрят No more dream, ведь парни там совсем мальчишки ещё, внешне ОЧЕНЬ отличаются, да и сама песня тоже отличается от того, что они слушали 😃 С нетерпением буду ждать следующей реакции на BTS! 💜

Yay! My intro to BTS! Black Swan! It's Okay if you want to run the video twice - once without lyrics and then again with the lyrics. Most of us will watch it through both times. Also, this is an absolutely stunning performance Live in recent concerts. If you can find a fan cam from their LA and/or Las Vegas concerts (late 2021 and April 2022, respectively), please do watch that even if you don't react with us. It's amazing! I do recommend Festa Room Live 2021 next so you can hear vocals and raps on a variety of songs. Then, if you want Ballad, please react to Live of House of Cards and/or The Truth Untold (with English subtitles). Zero O'Clock is another good one if you can find Live with English Subtitles. These 3 will be Just the 4 vocal line members. I left a long list a few videos back, so I won't repeat. Thank you for continuing on your BTS journey.

The concept that Black Swan is based on is :An artist's first death is either when the thrill of performing dies and the artist is lost, or if they still have the passion but they physically cannot perform anymore be it because of circumstance or age.

“Truth Untold” is my personal favorite if you’re looking for ballads. Having said that, there’s no rapping, just the vocalists of the group. I think that you’ll enjoy the variety of ranges throughout that song.

방탄소년단의 뮤비를 처음 볼땐 상당히 바쁨니다.집중해야할 것은 노래,가사,춤 그리고 뮤비해석까지 방탄소년단은 뮤비에 숨겨진 것도 많고 스토리가 있습니다.그들은 화양연화라는 주제를 계속 해왔습니다 이런점도 흥미롭습니다

Film out - the go to live song to hear their pure vocals 💜

House of Cards live will give you the best ballad that shows off the Supreme talent of the vocal line. Zero dancing, all vocals, and absolutely brilliant. Jazz feel.

I highly recommend NPR Tiny Desk. BTS live vocals are no joke. You'll be immersed in the performance.

Wait 'til you see them perform live :)

Please watch House of Cards! love our reactions!

OMG blackswan yess!! i've been loving your reactions 💜💜💜💜

You guys gotta see Festa room live 2021 and proof live 2022 their voices are absolutely incredible

Thanks for reacting! React to their live stage performances🔥

hope you guyz watch MV and Live perfomance at the same time you will see how incredible they are more than the Mv 🔥💯

Jimin is the owner of all solo dances and shadows ❤🔥 He is the best. I love BTS

The Untold Truth is a beautiful ballad.

Es unos de mi vídeos favoritos x el trabajo de producción, talentos individuales en especial el baile de Jimin!! Eso es BTS.

Definitely suggest the Japanese songs: 1.YOUR EYES TELL and 2. FILM OUT for the vocals. You can also do the live version of both the songs to see for yourselves how they execute the vocals in real life. Borahae 💜

Blood Sweat & Tears is another MV that gives you an even different feel! It’s an army fav for sure. And for live, bts festa room live is super fun and gives you a feel of their different genres.

Black Swan live performances are all art,masterpieces. the concert ptd black swan is really chef’s kiss