Claire also looks the most accurate

yep

he really nedded to be taller

He was way younger in the movie for no apparent reason.

Yeah he was definitely the most, but he was also just like way younger for no reason at all.

😂

Lol

Sarah Bobara I was there for the stream, we were all shouting at her to put the sand back when she removed it

@@hop7295 oMg, y'all are big brain >:))

*furiously puts sandy acorn on hair*

She can just levitate and almost flew into the sky exactly 3 seconds after being born. Canon.

They turned my favorite girls into Mary Sues 💔

Yea it made me pissed honestly 😭 I was so confused on why they switched Olive and Emma’s powers. I was also annoyed

And olive is a little girl

You’ll float too

may i have that knife

*K i n f e*

k i n f e

K i n f e

kinfe

I remember reading somewhere that Tim Burton said the boots fit his aesthetic more than some "fire powers," so you're spot on XD

In the special features where they were talking about production Burton stated something along the lines of fire powers being over done and not as interesting anymore so he convinces the author to let him swap the powers to make it more unique.

I’m not trying to!

Okay but I would wear them so u are definitely right

@Olive But it wasn't just their powers, Emma lost all her personality and just became a Disney princess. It would have been fine to just switch their powers. Also Olive was like 7 in the book.

You know what. I hate sand it's coarse and rough and gets everywhere.

Which is funny cause the color she chose is too dark lol

@@marvinverbeck1530 it's treason then

@@marvinverbeck1530 I'm wheezing

Marvin Verbeck I would like your comment but it has 66 likes 😳

In the movie he is all handsome but when I read the book I was like "omg he is a little kid" *sorry my bad english

In the movie he’s hot and brooding teen heart throb but in the book he’s chubby, greasy, and rude. And I wouldn’t have book Enoch any other way

Bronwyn's age got messed up too, she's supposed to be like 15-17, and then in the movie she was a little girl.

@@CGFillertext i cri

*Percy Jackson Flashbacks*

For real, Emma in the books was a more brave pocahontas type character, then in the movie she become some damsel in distress Cinderella

Actually, Ransom Riggs, the author, was there with Tim Burton. He gave Tim the permission to do these changes.

@@viawood289 it's still frustrating, even if it's permitted.

but then the author said he wished he had written it that way to start with... so if he things it's better than his own idea then it's ok with me.

a preference? almost every tim burton movie has a blonde love interest so.....i dont know if its a preference or fetish at this point lol

@@MephProduction No he didn’t XD, Ransom Riggs is very happy with the original Emma, and he also agrees that the film did her and Olive dirty. You can see in an interview he is talking about the peculiarities being swapped and his face just looks so annoyed lmao. He, just like Rick Riordan, has had his amazing story ruined by an adaptation that he only agreed to to get his story on the big screen.

I mean. _We can count ourselves lucky that Helena Bonham Carter, especially in Sweeney Todd, would have looked like a ghost with light blonde hair._ oh right the wife character was a blonde.

@@hibikiotonokojishslvocalis7550 And his daughter too! I believe he didn't turn Ms. Lovett into a blonde because she was supposed to be a "bad person", meanwhile the wife and daughter are supposed to be "innocent". Most characters in his movies portrayed with these features have the image of innocence.

TheDragonflie LaNgUaGe

Want it's been a year?!

it’s already been a year?? wow

Bro I just recently saw her Percy Jackson one. Coincidence? 😂

Some one check the facts! 😂

Facts- they did my girl dirty

She threatened murder in the books to save her friends, they literally only kept the name

Yea. :I

I know right. I was literally looking for a comment who said this

Hey gotta use a reference somehow 😂

Asa Butterfield is a really good actor! But yeah, the accent he pulled off was probably a bit too much on him. This movie was his worst one yet.

@Fake Emotions yes

Fake Emotions mhm!

@@straightchlorine5331 YES in hugo and enders game he was such a great actor fuuuck

He's also in the boy in striped pajamas truly recommended!

I thought that the series did a good job.

Atlas191 Yeah I’ve read the books many times and the series does a rather good job. It’s the movie that failed at adapting the books

Actually, I liked the movie waaaaay more I liked the series. I felt like the movie, even if the plot is not strict to the original books, carried more genuine and intense feelings, similar to the ones suggested by the novels. The series looks too much surreal and childish, but I just started it and maybe it's just a bad first impression

I was just about to ask that lol

yess! i read all 13 books and i really liked it, the ending was underwhelming though :(((

Someone who ships jake with olive instead of Emma and was like yeah no this is all gonna change

Basically My Immortal: The Movie.

Samuel L Jackson was also great and he really hams up his performance as the villain. But yea, the movie adaptation was mid, but had some great moments: Eva Green (she is absolutely charming), Samuel L Jackson (for reasons aforementioned) and having the perpetual levitation quirk include a small wind/air manipulation ability

Tbh I loved all the actors and actresses in the film. I actually loved the film so much before I found out the movie was an adaptation.

IKR Heck with historically accurate, we want all our female characters to look like porcelain dolls, even if they're not meant to be. (I'm being sarcastic btw)

your profile sums up with your comment

Oh I bet he'll love Bloodborne.

It was swept to make it more 'poetic' Tim Burton showing his romantic side. Even the author said he wished he had done that way to start with.

Yeah it makes meh mad >:(

The creators of the movie said that it whould be more ironic if a kind hearted soul has such a deadly power which i thought was okay but WHEN THEY CHANGED EMMA'S PERSONALITY THAT I COULD NOT FORGIVE

@@dogethebootifuldog3121 Meh, Book is the book, movie the the movie and the tv show will be the tv show.. if they ever make one. All will be different.

I read the book first and I've always been confused about that! I always just assumed that I mixed the two up when I was reading the book but I kinda hate it ngl

@@xamwithanx53 HAHAHA SAME

omg yes

Yes. Yes he is.

Your damn right

*Screenshots*

Emma*

zainab abdul jalil I really recommend the books, I enjoyed them a lot more than the movie! :)

I remember the reason I wanted to read the books was bc I saw the trailer and I was like “oh shit a Tim Burton movie about the Victorian ish era and the kids have super powers and Asa Butterfield is the lead? Sign me up” so I read the first book and omg I’m so glad I did bc it’s just sooo incredibly different than the movie. When I read the book and realized that they had switched Emma and Olive for no god damn reason in the movie, I didn’t even want to watch it anymore and I’m so glad I didn’t lol bc it would’ve ruined the story for me

@@discount_dora Burton changed Emma and Olive because it was more poetic, and thankfully the author thought it was a better concept and loved it. You say there was no reason to do it but as you've not seen the movie you're not in a position to say it was done for no reason, if you watch the movie it's very obvious why it as done, so it had a purpose. Good film, i'm glad it's nothing like the book! i would however like a proper tv adaptation of the books instead.

I've never read it either... I want to though...

I watched the movie but I didn't read the book and I'm really irritated that that happened.

I have the DVD and in the special features they said something like "It would give more beautiful scene's" or something like that which is a real shame

@@jassbunny4653 and untrue

*Me an uncultured creature that barely reads stuff, standing here and admiring Lavander's work while thinking about how bad of a movie adaptation was The Avatar: the last air blender and still being upset about that because the animation was better*

Swapping the powers I can understand a little bit, considering the roles of the characters within the movie, but I don’t see why they aged her up aside from, as you said, adding a romance subplot.

grandpa got cucked

I always thought that was weird too-

Actually it’s clearly because a white man couldn’t stand a female being strong and powerful and have a personality and could have an attitude and not depending on a boy saving her...

And yah it’s because she was projecting her feelings on him and they broke up when they realised... and he basically immediately got with the newbie girl (who is one of my faves so no shade there) as if he NEEDS a romantic interest all the time... wtf...

i was so glad during the reading of a map of days

Yes exactly!

Hyena Hearts, exactly

Um... there were quite a few kids in this movie. Unless the main characters are supposed to be, like, pre-pubescent, then there's no problem with adding a couple years. Additionally, it's a Hollywood tradition that actors in their late teens, early 20s play younger kids because of contract hours. Minors can only work for a limited timespan. Adults don't have those kinds of restrictions.

You thought those guys were hot though?

DigiDestined13 Edgar was 10 in the original and Olive was 9...they just aged them up so they could shove another couple in the mix

Pls don't remind me I weep

yeah i hated that too...but like the twins are literally nightmare creatures that were killed in the earlier hollowgast raids and like...why are they main characters!?!?! I personally think Bronwyn was done the most dirty bc she was supposed to be "more of a mother to the young ones than even Miss Peregrine" and in the movie shes literally a little girl. and olive and enoch??? like they're cute in the movie but they're both supposed to be like 10 and 11, and nOT A COUPLe. I have a lot of thoughts im so sorry

LMAO YES. i remember watching the movie and loving it, then going to comment section of the trailer for the movie and literally finding hate everywhere. i was like *whAT??? BUT ITS GOOD* so i read the books and *gODDAMN IT BURTON WHY THE FUCK WOULD YOU DO THAT*

I was watching the movie expecting my beautiful fugh and Jesus were Fiona and Hugh done dirty like they hardly tAlK in the movie!BUT THEY BE SNOGGING EACH OTHERS FACES OFF ALSO WHERE ARE THE BOOTIFUL GOGGLESSS

@@claradyson3625 Enoch is supposed to be 12-13 and Olive is 4 😳

Okay but they could have at least got people who were a similar age. They changed millard from 17 to 8,

@@amaraotiim3979 I agree with you on that! Though I do prefer movie Enoch over book Enoch

@@evil-mf5bi I guess he is just more aesthetically pleasing

@@amaraotiim3979 Yes that, and I think the couple years added to his age in the movie make his humor and personality make more sense to me, it's hard to picture a 13 year old saying the stuff he does even if he's actually over 100

@@evil-mf5bi Well yeah, but we know that the characters are aware of their age, because of that scene in the book where they were telling Jacob their real ages, although they don't act like old people. I think Enoch is one of the few characters that actually seems more mature than his physical body, and even Jacob thinks it's a bit unusual the way Enoch speaks and acts. There is this scene in the book, where "Dr Golan" found Jacob, Bronwyn, Emma, and Enoch with Martin's corpse in that fish place, and Enoch was saying an excuse. And Jacob said something along the lines of Enoch sounding like an actual 12 year old boy for once. Also, apologies for the long reply.

book Millard is one of my favourite characters, who usually is in the main group in each of books and here he told maybe 1-2 sentences and thats all ://

True, though in the one of the latest books a hollowgast DOES eat H’s eyes... but why does nobody talk about this 😂

@@tpwds7900 I wonder when is 5th book comming out, I can't wait to see what happens next

@@katarinateofanov it’s out already I think! I’m halfway through! That is if you’re referring to the Conference of the Birds (the latest one that just came out!)

@@katarinateofanov It came out around January and is really good so far!

@@tpwds7900 Oh really! I'll try to find it in local library, but i dkn't thing they have books in english, and it probably isn't translated yet...

EXACTLY olive was like 6 or 5 and aged her up into 16! and now emma is just a side character that doesn't add anything big into the story anymore :(

Innit I loved Emma so much in the book and I was very disappointed when they made the switch because I was looking forward to her in the movie

The books are amazing trust me!!!

YESSS 👏👏👏

YESSS 👏👏👏

Shiinie I mean it looks cool

You just gotta be *accurate*, you know?

Isn’t that Emma lol

That’s Emma... Olive has light brown hair...

Samee

Same

Whattacatch Dannie Same

Lmao

sameee

And Hugh, Fiona, THE FUCKING HOLLOWS

It felt like they swapped millard and enoch in ages and it just sucked

Viii !!!! To be fair, Fiona was decently similar (ofc she does talk tho.) Hugh was more or less the same, though they did literally add in 2 extra characters (the gorgon twins) that were photos in the book. Edit: I meant Horace!!! Not Hugh!

Weren't Fiona and Hugh way older? I remember them saying and stuff in the books and I always pictured them maybe even older than Jacob

They made him 17 not the obnoxious 13 yearold he is in the book.

then again it feels really weird if u have to rethink everything you thought of because in the sixth book there's a small description that ruins evertything

This is how i usually do it when reading books so when a movie cones out, it's terrible trying to sit through it XD

Unless you have aphantasia, then you’re just left with nothing

try reading homestuck and having to come up with headcanons for everything

I read it when I was 12 I went half way through the book thinking the main character was a girl and had a girl love interest. I was so let down when I realized.

Let's be honest it still looks good lmao

Still love it maybe she just ha the same idea

Accuarate even in the littlest of the details! Be grateful that they didn't say drippy eyess or something like this. 😅 Actuly... This gives me a ideea for a character!

All artists honestly

"Jacob was a skinny person." Eye color? *Skinny.* Skin color...? *Skinny.* WEIGHT? *Skinny.*

Kate MJS omg ikr 😂 i luv Life is strange

Sarah- Jill life is strange is forever superior lmao 😂

Shaka brah

I have "hella strange" written on my arm rn lol I love life is strange :3

Yes please

I love that musical never read the book tho

idky i heard the line "let me introduce myself" the same way the line is said in the vocaloid song monsters

FINALLY FOUND SOMEONE WHO DOES IT TOO CAN WE GET MARRIED OR SOMETHING

and who the hell was alita again-

I hate Alita just for that. Big big eyes spook me

Why hello there person with the same pfp as me

ScreamingAllTheTime huh wdym “wrong”?

Yup, I agree

@@rainchuu9704 Basically the entire movie failed at representing the characters from the books. Just look at a comparison of the hollowgasts.

Yes, please!!

It just not failed in representing the characters, it failed completely in telling the story

Goldfish actually remeber very well. Mabye your brain is a Muscle's? (The water animal)

Naomi Pleasant ah yes!! I guess I forgot goldfish have some pretty good thinkers, very on brand of me. Maybe I have a jellyfish memory since they don’t got any brains in the first place :0!

Absolutely same

Did you know that there's a fourth part??

I can agree with you. I really think that her movie design fit's better with the way the hous and all looked in the movie. I might even go a little farther and say that i loved both, movie and book. (I'm sorry) :3

100% i agree i love the book but i love the film as well, i think the actress portraying Miss Peregrine brings her to life and i kind of have to say i prefer her film adaptation to the book in many ways

HEY! I JUST WANT TO TELL YOU BOTH that your opinions are perfectly valid and there's no reason to feel ashamed or guilty for sharing your point of view with others :)

Carla Carlilla Walfas pfp? Are you a Touhou fan?

I agree,personally I thought the movie was good. I think Tim Burtons only bad movie is Charlie and the Chocolate Factory or whatever it's called

yes. Just, yes.

y e s

OH MY GOODNESS YES PLEASE I read the book and loved it, but I couldn’t even make it through to the end of the movie. It even got the main plot wrong. Shame...

OMG YES! I HATED the changes that the movie made. Totally took away the charm of the book.

I really liked the movie but the book was so much better. It does take a bit to get used to the movie but it was very well made even if the changes were very drastic.

Sounds like me with Shadowhunters. They messed up the series soo bad..

I didn't read the book but I liked the movie

I'm pretty sure my parents wanted to strangle me after the movie was over because I pointed out every flaw that the movie had when compared to the book. I pointed out the Emma that the movie placed as a side character and said, "That's the love interest, she's amazing!" only for the movie to place Olive as the main character. I also started screaming when the ending hit, because they pretty much smashed the books together in certain aspects and added completely new things. Just like the adaptations of Lemony Snicket's A Series of Unfortunate Events.

Yeah, I went to watch it with my dad and brother after reading the books and I got so pissed at the name changes and I was complaining the whole time

Dude same

Ollie Foxx just looking through the comments trying to find one that pointed this out before I comment it myself

Ya, lol...

YASSSS

Yes! The book clearly said that Lucy was blonde, but in the film, she has dark hair and this annoys me.

Yeeyee

YESSSSSS

Hoodie Ninja Lucy was blonde?? Ah heck, what is it with movie companies turning blondes into brunettes?

you go be him!

As a Bnha fan ... Kami already kinda does? Soooo yeah.

If your talking about Kaminari, then not really. Sure he’s very energetic, and very goofy and good-natured, but he doesn’t give of the same chaotic yet well-mannered vibe that Willy Wonka does. Honestly, the character that gives off that energy that most would probably be Gentle Criminal. His name literally describes a gentle (like a gentleman) person who is a criminal, and a criminal is usually a person who does bad things, and usually in a chaotic way. Denki is just like the idiot everyone wants as a friend. Sure he doesn’t think his way through things, but he’s a great friend/ally to have on your side.

Willy Wonka approves cannibalism

WaiT bE mOrE ChIll WaS a BOoK

Also I think the adaptation of Wizard of earthsea has characters different from the book

THERE ISNT A BMC MOVIE YET BUT ITS COMING SOON

Oh yeah bmc the musical vs bmc the book have MAJOR differences Ex: Michael

@@chalkydusty WAIT WHAT

ThePottingArtist yes!!!! The book and movie are so different!!!

I'm in the process of reading that book but it's so different from the movie so far.

@@xpennyx It was an anime, so I'm not surprised. Animes are well known for making the characters look unique.

@@xpennyx absolutely agree! I always liked the movie but i absolutely fell in love with the book!

I really hope she would make this, Howl's moving Castle is one of my favorite ghibli movies

I agree! I loved the Mortal Instruments series, but the movie and tv series fell short big time 😬

If Haley did do TMI, I think it would be much more interesting to use the Shadowhunters series; that one actually did a pretty decent job at adapting the characters

yessssssss

@@psalmsart the series is actually good, it just feels more inspired by the books than copied

OMG HELL TO THE YEAH!! Agree like 100%

At this point, it's kind of an insult to say it's an adaptation of MPHFPC. They're practically two seperate things

@@onlyoddity So I always write the whole title out so when I saw MPHFPC as that I read it as MPHHHFFFCP and it took me a second to realize that wasn't an angry grunt

@@nzamudio9921 wait it was an angry grunt? I thought it was text tall, I literally wasted 3 mins tryna figure out what it stands for lmao

Tombie Wolf no it stands for miss peregrines home for peculiar children. I was saying like it took me a while to figure out it wasn’t an angry grunt

@@nzamudio9921 ohhhhh, *I feel dumb now*

Eva Green is amazing I think, as well as Asa Butterfield (he was already cool in Merlin :')). But for me, I actually like the movie, but see it as another project than the books... Cause everything is different, the whole plot. Still, I like the movie, its interesting and they pictured things quite well. With a completely different story, though, and I think the ending of the movie isn't as good as the "ending" in the books was like.... :(

Do you know Kingdom of Heaven? She plays very well there *and is pretty handsome, too*, and it's a nice movie to watch, an interesting portrayal, even though a lot, especially about her Character isn't historically correct.

@@projectasher1 Fair point

Man I wish I could study the miss peregrine novel series.

She actually wore a similar costume in the penny dreadful show... which now that I think about it may actually have been a reason for the change(?) Like, maybe they didn't want people confusing the characters or smn.

I guess we know why

Oh I once knew a girl who's style looked VERY similar to Lavender Towne's because she watches so much

I think instead of a gray/black shading, she opted for a dark blue/purple because it gives a closer sensation to dark black, rather than maybe a neutral black (like a browser in night mode).

um. it's a really dark shade of blue which is much better than black, what's the problem?

@@yuumifloof7156 there is no problem, I just found it funny.

I think it's because of the black lineart. Dark blue was also used as black back in the time of black and white films to gain contrast between shadow and light. This is still pretty common in the film industry.

u wouldn't be able to see the drawing's detail if it was in all black - and some shades of black (esp old fabrics) tend to fade and have that blue shade sometimes

I haven’t had the chance to read the Coraline book yet, are the characters largely different if so that would be sad since the movie didn’t even use people for the characters

@@lavender_milktea2810 Coraline is one of my favorite books, and I absolutely think you should read it regardless of whether it's like the movie! They add and subtract elements from the book in the movie such as Wybie, but it all contributes to a really melancholy and grim feel to it. It's different, but you should definitely read it!

@@ananonymoushuman8258 ok thanks for the input :)

@@lavender_milktea2810 no problem, really enjoy recommending books!

I love the book, and I think the movie is phenomenal. Phenomenally different, yeah, but I still adore it.

Seriously. Tim Burton messed up big time.

Everyone getting aged up in that movie.

Gremlin except for mis peregrine who looks much younger cause we can’t have old women in movies, god forbid

Well, sometimes we can’t always get what you want, and sometimes finding the right cast in acting skill is better than looks.

Yes! That was a majorrr turnnn offff. Actually, the whole movie was if you've read the book.

BAYBE LEECH The graphic novels are my favorite! I remember reading those in school!

There are graphic novels? I thought Percy Jackson was the only main book series with a Graphic novel (And they did mah boi Will terrible in the PJO graphic novels, so-)., and Artemis Fowl (I don’t even wanna talk about it.) I should check out the Ms. Peregrine’s graphic novels, hopefully they’re good!

@Moodie thx lol I’m stupid

@@eebertdeebert you won’t be disappointed 😉

THERES A WHAT?!

Yup, now Noor’s on the scene! 😂

I really like Noor alot and think the break up was done In a super healthy and real way.

WHAT NO WHAT I DIDNT KNOW THIS?? NOOOO I SHIPPED THEM SO MUCHH AAAAAAAAAAA

@@priffy. Noor is really cool though. You'll probably like her.

@@priffy. Noor is pretty awesome, but quite different to Emma. Just wondering, have you read the books? Bc if not you should totally read them! And if you have, read the newest ones with Noor!

It was great yassss😆

I couldn't see the sandy hair, the video quality was too... grainy.

I’m being beaten at my own game I can hardly *sand* it

Sands when are jokes bad?

@Isabella Van Ginkel You guys are just ashore ing me how bad and good puns are

Have you watched season one of the HBO series His Dark Materials yet? Much, much better adaption of The Golden Compass than the movie.

Woleres Agree! Characters are so wrong!

I was about to recommend Inkheart! It's my favorite book and the movie was a huge disappointment.

Oh, Inkheart. It's a sin what they did with that film. I adored the books.

In addition. The 'I Am Number Four' movie absolutely butchered the Book series.

The ‘fire girl’ switch annoyed me too. Did Emma and Olive dirty, and I literally hate the movie now. It also rubbed off on me, cos whenever I read the books now I find Emma sooooo annoying, I started to hate her. I’m 100% team Noor now.

@@tpwds7900 I mean, I still like Emma, but I also like Noor.