I may have gotten a little emotional remembering this story... goooood times

That is probably the best story you have told! that was so sweet! :P

How come you don't have a podcast I could literally listen to your storytimes all day :)

I'm curious if he went back to women. Andrew says he is in a relationship but doesn't mention the gender of his partner.

$10 dollars to first one to search Andrew's instagram history and find a picture of this man.... go!

This story took me right back to college, except, I was the guy being hit on by my girlfriend's ex boyfriend. He walked me back to my apartment, after a meeting, one night and kissed me in the middle of the campus quad. We ended up dating for the next year. He truly changed my life.

Thanks for this story. First I need to say that I’m not openly gay but I believe that people can easily figure it out or at least assume that about me. I live in a country where homosexuality is a crime and culturally not acceptable but showing affection between men to some extent even kissing on the chicks is acceptable and that can be very confusing for someone like me to figure out whether the other person is flirting or just being friendly. I’m going through the same thing with this really hot straight guy for over two years. I’m crazy about him and every time we meet I fall in deeper and deeper. We’re constantly flirting every time we talk. He lives in another city but every time we meet, we’re together amongst friends yet still without feeling shy about it he literally fights others to grab a sit next to me, hold my hand or wrap his arms around me. He likes to touch my skin but then not to seem sexual or awkward he asks about the lotion I use. He voluntarily asks to give me a back rub or jokes about kissing me on the lips but when I reach he pulls back. When we get drunk or high, things take a different turn. He becomes incredibly protective of me where he pulls me into his arms and cuddles me cause I’m normally wasted and it always feels in that moment that it’s only the two of us in the world even if we’re at a party cause we both don’t care if others are looking at us or judging us. Maybe that’s why he always wants to get me drunk cause it has always been amazing and felt incredible, emotionally connected the most when we’re drunk. He gives me loads of mixed signals and every time that I feel like there’s hope, he says something or does something to shatter all my dreams. Last summer I was there for 10 days and things were going better than ever specially when we were high. I said something silly cause I’m even more clueless than usual when I’m high and he was laughing so hard and as he was laughing he looked me in the eyes in a very adorable way and asked if he could kiss me. Of course I thought he meant on the lips cause of the way our eyes were locked at each other and how he was looking at me and the tone of his voice when he asked but I don’t know whether because we were amongst friends or simply because I miss read him he just kissed me on the chicks and instantly looked away. He surely does not want to be known or be called gay and he has said that he’s not gay to others “naturally “ a few times. We always joke sexually about the things that we’re going to do to each other but that summer when I was 100% sure that he was into me and it was a done deal, in the car on the way to his house as we were sexually joking again I told him that you always joke but you never act. Suddenly his mood and posture and tone changed and in a very serious way he said “ well cause I’m not gay and I’m just joking. “ I tried to compose myself and not show my emotions and keep smiling but deep down what he said and how he said it was like a sharp ice cold dagger that went into my heart. I couldn’t breath, it felt like there was a lump in my throat and all I could hear for the rest of the road was his sentence “ I’m not gay. “ in my ear. When he got off the car and we drove off, within a few seconds I lost it and broke down into tears. I was crying so hard for an hour like I’ve never cried before. My other friend who was driving the car was shocked and didn’t know what has happened or why I was crying. My heart was destroyed and the pieces were exploding out of my chest. I wanted to rip my throat and chest out so that maybe I could feel less pain. When I got back home from that trip I was depressed for weeks. I went to bed crying and woke up in tears. This sick cycle still continues. I try to forget him or ignore these feelings but we text every week and meet every 2 months and the flirting and mixed signals still continues and I feel weak towards him and pathetic cause even though l’m almost sure nothing will ever happen between us, with every text my heart beats faster, every time we meet my knees start to shake and I don’t feel like myself when I’m around him. I daydream about us everyday. I can only wish we would have an ending like yours cause this for me is not a fling, I truly love him. I’ve tried to convince myself that he’s not that great or tried to find somethings to hate about him but there’s none. I’ve been in other relationships but I’ve never felt love the way I feel for him. Please pray for me. 😭😭😢😢🥺🥺💔💔

Wow when you’re so all around attractive you’re able to "turn" a straight guy! Imagine... can’t relate.

How does Andrew find all these not so "straight" boys that actually work out for the better?!? Good story telling though!

As someone who has been harassed and bullied my entire life, I am just now beginning to figure out who I am. Self-doubt, and being an introvert has cornered me in every aspect of my life, but I want to thank you. You’ve opened my eyes to accept myself, as someone who’s never been in a relationship, I can believe that being alone doesn’t have to mean forever. So thank you, even though you’ll probably never see this, thank you for inspiring me as a 32 year old.

What a cute Walt Disney type story. Thank you for sharing.

Seeing you expressing your feelings is so beautiful!! Thank you so much for sharing your emotions with us!

These stories really put into perspective how much time has passed! I had a thought if I could remember anyone from the start but the first bf you ever showed us was Logan I believe. Crazy to think I’ve been watching what you show of your life on here since I was 15 and now I’m 20. Feels like yesterday I watched your introduction video!

So happy story time has returned! 😊

I LOVE your "Story Time" stories!!!!! Thanks for sharing!!!

I really enjoy it when you tell these kind of stories they're just so authentic real and fun so keep it up. It's nice to see that you're still having a great time I hope you have a great year.

Such a great feel-good story. Thanks for sharing! ❤️💙

What an adorable story! So glad you shared. And really impressed by how happy you are for him now!

Brings up some memories ...even a few tears ! Thanks for telling that story !

Andrew, I loved that story, thank you so very much for sharing. It was so sweet!

You are a remarkable storyteller! Thanks for sharing this experience.

So good to see you back and thanks for sharing your story with us. Big love from the UK🥰😁

This was such a great story, thank you Andrew.

Andrew that's an amazing story. If things are meant to be they will be. You tell these stories so well and so respectfully. Thank you for sharing. We're always here after too if you do get emotional and want to talk.

THESE are the gay relationships we need to hear about! Thanks for sharing something so special, xoxo

Mark and Ethan were among the first LGBTQ KZfaqrs during my early days on KZfaq. Your story was rather sweet, even if it didn't work out as it helped you to grow :)

Thanks for sharing! Enjoy reading the captions what you were saying.

Oh man, You have the best stories

Andrew, I love hearing this for it brought back a few good memories from a date or two. I haven't had the long term that you have for as you know the Southeast can be harsh, especially in the 80's and 90's. Glad you had this experience and hope you can find others or your long term one day. I too am looking and pray that it he comes my way soon. I miss the companionship, etc during Covid being safe and just being. See ya next video. Stay safe man.

Adorable story, I'm glad it had such an impact on you. It's always nice seeing you dish a bit and also just put it into context of how it shaped this attractive, smart, and dorky guy you've become 🙂 [also vitamin d you say]

This is a first time getting to comment on a video so early but I really enjoyed this storytime especially showing a sensitive side to you make you more such a nice guy. I would like to hear more about these stories.

Oh how I missed your videos so much. I let others hear that I support in the behavioral health realm to give them encouragement and motivation to help them with deal with sexuality issues. You're quite the hero to many.

This is a beautiful story Andrew thanks for sharing.

LUV your dating stories Andrew. Have an awesome & flirty 2021 😋

Hi Andrew, I just wanted to say that you are so amazing! You're the most honest and natural KZfaqr ! I've been watching your videos for a couple of years now, and they have really helped me to understand myself a lot. Sometimes it's tough as a gay college student to be fully open about myself. You really have the talent to comfort people about who they are! Anyway, thanks a lot for making me laugh every time I watch your videos! :)

This was a great revelation for the community.... A healthy, beautiful, loving experience that you look back on fondly. Thank you

Love a good story time!

Excellent story. Love it

I would read a book about all of your stories. Much love! 💙

You have the best boyfriend stories. They are always so sweet and positive.

Wow Andrew that blast from the past made me so moist. Thank you bro. Please make more of these vlogs.

Andrew, just love your videos. They are always so upbeat. Your energy is amazing. 👍👍👍

From one Andrew to another....you remind me of myself...a happy go lucky guy that is a positive person by nature. I am mostly new to your videos but watching them helps to remind me in this day and age to smile, be kind and look on the bright side of life and be a better human being. Thanks Andrew. You are a COOL dude.

Loved the story king 👑

Nice story, Andrew. Made me feel kind of warm inside. Just the opportunity to be with someone you adore, for many reasons and not only the physical one, it just a great experience. He found you very attractive and so it just took a little time, patience and understanding to make it work for so long. It means so much more than just the desire to hook up or even friends with benefits. I'm glad you have nice memories about this man and your relationship.

I just came across your page by accident and immediately subscribed...i love your candidness and your natural masculinity and beautiful spirit...and yes u have a great voice...keep singing and it will get stronger but u have a great vibrato..your so normal and not sterotypical at all..your just an overall cool Brodsky...everything about u is so cool...

5 years! Wow that's a long time. Glad you guys had what sounds like a good influence on each others lives. Also you're giddy excitement reminds me of myself with my past relationships haha. It's cute.

Great Story Andrew! Actually, quite Beautiful!

This literally got me through a 3 hour long wait in car. Such a great story, thanks for sharing

I love your stories so much!

Happy New year Andrew , awesome video , hope you have many wonderful days & Years filled with lots of happiness , joy & laughter

Have to say that was a nice story that ended very sweet.. I enjoyed your facial reactions and knew by by the way you were telling it that it brought you right back to that younger time in your life. It's interesting how we keep certain memories to ourselves because they mean so much to us.. thanks for sharing...

I love it when you share these beautiful memories. Love ya buddy. ❤️🙏

Such a good and funny story at the same time 🤣❤️

Oh my God! I put off watching you for so long because I was scared that when I came to your channel there wouldn't be a new video! But I came back by chance and there were two new videos!!! 💖💖💖 Welcome back Andrew, love you, miss you and please always come back, at least until life become to large for your KZfaq community 💖 Which we will undersunderstand 🥰

I love Andrew stories. 😊

Love the super subtle Pokemon low-fi music in the background

This story is very very inspiring... good on you mate... you are a seriously amazing guy... wish I could have you in just about any way...

Aww this was such a touching story andrew 😭

Your first true love always has a place in your heart no one else can ever touch in exactly the same way....its always special in it's time and place, and helps to make you who you are today. I absolutely loved this video because it took me back to the first time my first love and I kissed...I had a wife, he had a girlfriend...and we decided that we could make ourselves acceptable and happy by having the women for society and family and each other for us. Needless to say it did not work out exactly that way. We lost touch after we broke up and I thankfully felt the need years later to call him to tell him how important he was in my eventual coming out and being happy with myself....it turned out, he was in the final weeks of his life (AIDS in 1992)...and we spent the final.month of his life talking and reminiscing and getting him ready for the journey he was going to go on without me. He passed in Jan 1993...and I think of him often and smile...and that when it's my time, I hope he will be greeting me on the other side.

You actually lived the gay fantasy that so many missed 🤣 10/10 all the time with you, even you strike out it's still a home run 🤣🔥💖

omh this was the cutest story I really enjoyed it a lot especially when he kissed you in the woods your chemistry together must have been so incredible 5 years is a long time and you went through a demanding time in both of your lives together supporting each others journey.

aww what a beautiful storyyy❤😭

YES! Another storytime! *Me wondering how long it will take for Andrew to take his shirt off* *Once Andrew's shirt is off* 🔥😏

This was a fantastic story. It sounds like both of you had fun and a good relationship. I am glad that you are happy for him and his now relationship. It is good seeing a new post from you. Do you have any idea as to when you will be back on the road again seeing patients?

Loved this story, reminds me of my own

Great story, just loved it.

This is an adorable story ❤️❤️❤️

Five years with you and you were out. Surely he came out during that time, especially with you for support. You are an inspiration for lots of people. Keep it up.

Really cool story. But I don't agree with the part in wich you said "the experiences will come for you" - that's simply not true, if you don't go out there and try to meet people and just "don't worry about it" you will probably end up not having any relationships or cool experiences - talking from personal experience.

That was a very sweet story. Thank you for sharing.

That was such a sweet story. I just loved it.

what a sweet story! it really reminded me of my first real boyfriend. we met in middle school, he went the year over me I had just started in 8th grade. he went to 9th grade. I remember the first day of school, everything is new and exciting and I came into the schoolyard, and he was actually the first person I saw. I actually fell in love only after the first sight of him. I ran across the schoolyard to reach the first hour and not be late. then it rang out and I went out and met my best and oldest friend at school, he had said he would help me get to know new people. we sat on a bench and waited for a person. then he came and my bff said hello hello to Kenneth he started in 8th today. and there was HE !!! we got to know met ov became head friends. we started hanging out as a group of friends, but also alone. we went to the cinema, cafe and trips together as friends, once around Christmas time we went for a walk together only he and I. it had snowed and was a little slippery. I slipped and hit my knee. he came and helped me and supported me until we got home to the one who was closest. he helped me to his bed, picked up an ice pack and put it on my knee. if I was not in love before then I was you at least then! we talked together all that night about a lot of different things. I was openly gay, he asked me very carefully at the end of the evening if I would stay overnight. you were Christmas vacation. I said it's okay for me called home and told my mother about it. she said it was all right. we lay on his bed and talked, watched movies and then it just slipped out of me how I felt for him, before he answered I said. you do not have to feel the same just do not break the friendship! he said he was in the closet but felt much the same. I told him that I actually fell in love with him on the first day of school before 1st grade. we stayed together that night and the only ones who found out were the group of friends and the family. we were together for 6 years, and today are still the world's best friends, and we agree that we have helped shape each other. today he is married to a lady and has come out of the closet as bisexual. and we still hang out a lot!

Andrew we need more videos, it's been a while. Miss you! 😭❤️

I love listening your stories,your voice is so cosy.I can't wait for next video :) Unfortunately I don't have ay experience although i'm after twenty :/

Wow that's very personal and beautiful story Andrew ❤️

Andrew...thank you for always bearing your soul. You truly are a special individual. 🙋‍♂️😊

New to your platform,,,,,hugely impressed with your work life balance,,,,, keep entertaining us 👍👍👍

Aww...thanks for sharing the story. I'm not sure you ever totally get over a love like that.

that's a lovely 1st love story, good to see you again Andrew. xoxo

Being a hopeless romantic, I found your story very touching. Thank you for sharing.

3:24, hahaha lets hear one for the theatre kids!!!!! balancing crazy rehearsal hours and academics!!

YOU ARE A CUTIE. I ENJOYED THE STORYTIME !

Awesome story

Great story!

so sweet. Thanks, Andrew! You were glowing half the time. You didn't tell us if he is still gay or back with women...

Gee thanks Andrew! Now I'm bawling my eyes out!

I love you Andrew...your story brought back memory's of the most amazing three years of my life! I miss him to this very day...that was forty-two years ago...yikes! Thank you! Yes old people watch your channel...lol! Your an amazing young man thank you again! Be safe, be well! Shalom

A great story and personal growth tale.

Thankyou Andrew.

Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaah there is a mini Arbor when he points the shelf, too sweet. Love the video of baby Arbor he had on instagram.

Awesome story Andrew neighbors and don't worry you will find the right one 💜.

You look flawless ❤️ Your skin is glowing

Your story got my reminiscing about a simulator story from my earlier years and just wondering if it will ever happen again in my life?

I love your videos and stories.❤I think it's amazing how you share your experiences on here with all of us. Also, you remind me of a young Christian Bale. 😍❤

You are so brave and so cool person! Well done Andrew.

I did enjoy this story! 😊

I saw the notification and I was like this is going to be SUCH a good video😂❤️

Hey Andrew! Can I ask you for some advice? P.S. I absolutely love your videos, streams, and your posts. You are amazing and very talented!

The amount of glowing boyish wonder in Andrew in these story time videos though ☺️