"If Harry Potter's wand can make decisions, why can't Thor's hammer?" That must be the best argument Penny could have said...

“How could Red Hulk be worthy?” “YOU DON’T KNOW HIS LIFE!” That needs to be on a T-Shirt

"But if you put the hammer in an elevator?" "It would still go up" "Elevator's not worthy"

I love how slowly this shifted into an argument. They just dismiss it as stupid and then when on cracks a joke about Thor's hammer and is corrected and says how it makes even less sense, it starts turning into an argument! It was honestly so realistic!

Bernadette: YOU DONT KNOW HIS LIFE 😂😂😂

"If i go to a bar and pick up a guy and he picks up a girl and we all leave together. Did i pick up the girl?" Pennys logic is epic

As a teenage nerd, none of my fantasies about girls were sexual. They were all like this. Scenes of girls deeply giving a shit about the stories I loved.

Amy killed me with the "I can't even take you serious" line 😂😂😂😂😂

"If Harry Potter's wand can make decisions, why can't Thor's hammer."

Well, Penny HAS a good point...if Harry Potter's wand can make decisions, why can't Thor's hammer?

"How can Red Hulk be worthy?" "You don't know his life!" This has been out there for eight years and I still can't get over that exchange. Makes me blow-milk-out-my-nose laugh.

Actually Penny’s question about Thor’s hammer in space was actually answered at one point in the comics. I forget how it got there, but Thor’s hammer was in fact lost in space and Ironman was the one who found it. But he was unfortunately never worthy of it, so all he could do was “push” it through space. He couldn’t wield it or bend it to his will, but he could push it through space since there was no up or down. That being said he had to avoid basically all fields of gravity until he was able to get back to Thor.

"If your going to start comparing wands and hammers"....lol

"You don't know his life!" Gets me every time!

I love how Amy transitioned from a girl crush on Penny to a more balanced friendship with her. "Giving you a head start." LOL

The writing in this is so good. Even though all three girls are debating about comics, everyone is still believably in character.

Bernadette kills me in the end :D

Penny:oh yeah! then how does the sun comes up everyday Amy:hard to argue with those kind of street smart 😂😂👏🏼👏🏼

"Elevator's not worthyyyyyyyy." -Steve Rogers I don't know but I was reminded of that scene.

Are we not gonna talk about the girls opening Sheldon’s comics, would love to see his reaction to that

YOU DON'T KNOW HIS *LIFE!!!!!!!!*

"Maybe Thor's hammer is a new color of nail polish?" 😂😂😂

When they go into the apartment, I would've loved seeing the look on Sheldon's face at them opening his precious comics. Lol

-How could Captain America be worthy? .You don't know his life!

"If I go to a bar and pick up a guy, and he picks up a girl, and we all leave together, did I pick up the girl?" xD

the harry potter reference tho

I wish this would had become a regular thing in the show, I really LOVE to see the girls being pattionate about geek subjects.

“YOU DONT KNOW HIS LIFE!” ~ Bernadette.

At the expense of sounding like a total nerd. 1. Mjolnir is like 48lbs. 2. Thor is not the only one that can use it. 3. Yes. Red Hulk has done it. 4. It is Odin's magic, so it would be Odin's requirements. Even Thor had to pass several trials to even be given the hammer. 5. Red Hulk is kind of a dick.

"How could Red Hulk be worthy?" "YOUDON'T KNOW HIS LIFE!" I'm soooo luvin this lmao!!!

This is so hilarious. I especially liked the part where Bernadette says, "You don't know his life", and all the guy's reaction. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Girls: How do they argue for hours about things that don't exist? Also Girls: *Hold our beers*

BEST of the BEST line ever. " YOU DON'T KNOW HIS LIFE ". The way she said that.

Wands in Harry Potter are quasi-sentient. That's what Penny was going for.

They should have included: “But if u put the hammer in the elevator” “It’ll still go up” “Elevator is not worthy!” And them trying to pronounce mjolnir

As a female comic/superhero nerd, I found this episode hilarious. I wish there was more girl geek stuff like this in the show.

"The Transitive Property of Picking Things Up" LMAO!

Can I just say that I love how Amy is sitting in front of Sheldon's spot? I love it so much

8 years later and I can’t get enough of this episode and scenes… 😂

Hilarious! And, this is totally unrelated to this video, storyline, but notice, @ 2:30 when Penny is getting her keys to go over to Leonard and Sheldon's; the keys are in a bowl, which goes back to season 2, when Sheldon locks himself out of his apartment... Looks like Penny took Sheldon's advice, and got her own 'key bowl.'

0:55 "Its like Sheldon and his toothbrush" Raj: "Maybe I am worthy"

-"You don't know his life." Most of the time, it reverberates in my mind. The tone and the words make it a masterpiece! Bernadette is a hell of an actor.

"Hard to argue with those kinds of street smarts" damn Amy can be a real savage

The only time watching this show that I didn't feel insulted as a nerd.

And I'm having so many flashbacks right now about the many arguments I've gotten into over that Red Hulk fight it's not even funny.

I love the reactions from the guys with hearing them talk about comics 🤣👌 especially Leonard's disbelief and Howie's justification.

I know they're mocking it, but this is exactly why I love comic books lol

"There is no up in outer space" "Oh yeah well how does the sun come up everyday?!" "Hard to argue with those kinda street smarts"

I can't discuss about comics with my GF. She believes that World War Hulk would beat Thor and I believe the opposite. This is a kind of disagreement that can kill a relationship!!

Amy: in space, there is no up! Penny: oh yeah? Well then, how does the sun come up, everyday!? Amy: Can't argue with street smarts. Love that part! 😃

“Is space there is no up” “then how does the sun go UP everyday”😂

the show NEEDS more episodes with the girls arguing about comics. they raise interesting questions

"You don't know his life!" Idk why that made me laugh so hard😂😂

"You don't know his life!" 😂😂😂😂 Melissa nailed it!

"you don't know his life" 😂😂😂😂

Best argument ever LOL

3:32 maybe Thors hammer is a new kind of hair polish😂😂 Look at Howard's face right here

I love how years after this ep aired the problem of Thor's hammer was addressed in "age of Ultron" film. I guess it is endless debate

Well, Amy was wrong about the who decides who’s worthy question. After Endgame, Captain America lifted the hammer.

2:03 best moment..ahahha

These are amazing actresses They can memorize a lot and make it sound like it’s a real conversation

It’s Odin’s enchantment, therefore Odin decides who can lift Mjolnir. Think of Mjolnir as a combination lock and worthiness as the combination as defined/decided by Odin. Odinson knows the combo because he is worthy, but when he is not, it is because Odin has changed the combination.

2:35 they went so deep that Amy left Penny's apartment with the door open.

3:36,when Bernadette said "you don't know his life" I died laughing😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

watch 1:35 ,, that subtle change in penny's expressions ,,, great acting ,,

2:56 reminds me of a joke. A teacher was teaching math so she said A=B=C then A=C Then suddenly a student stands and says : Teacher, I love u, U love yr daughter so I love yr daughter. 😂 😂

Penny's Questioning skills are Legendary!😂😂😂🤭

I loved this so much! Such a shame it never happened again.

“You don’t know his life” 😂😂 Im dead 😂😂😂

2:05 don't forget, he has an axe now.

“ you don’t know his life” I died laughing

"If Harry Potter's wand can make decisions, why can't Thor's hammer ?" I'm WHEEZING 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

“... He picks up a girl and then we all leave together. Did I pick up the girl?” I fuk’in LOVE her! 😂😂😂

"you dont know his life!!" Gets me every time

2:13....I have dealt with people that have thought the sun was a planet....I feel for you amy

I wish they had continued the discussion after the guys entered the apartment... it would have been so funny.

Bernadette is the queen of sass. Long may she reign.

2:11 This is really killing me. Oh yeah, then how does the sun come up everyday. SAVYY 😂 😂 😂

"YOU DON'T KNOW HIS LIFE"

"Whoever holds this hammer if HE be worthy shall possess the power of Thor" Does that mean that no female can pick up the hammer?

“Hard to argue with those kind of street smarts” 😂

Wait till they find out Captain America picks up the hammer

This pretty much nails it. Reminds me of every argument relating to comic books, sci-fi, horror and fantasy that I've ever participated in or observed. LOL

bernadette: "it's crazy, they spend hours arguing over something that doesn't even exist!" them 1 min later: *arguing passionately about thor's hammer*

Girls: "Comics are so stupid" Thor hammer's: "Ight I'mma make comics cool"

I would love to see Sheldons face when he opens the door and sees aaaaalll his comics on the floor, tabel and sofa between food and drinks 😅😅

"How could Red Hulk be worthy?!" "YOU DON'T KNOW HIS LIFE!!"

I always crack up every single time I watch this and The Pictionary. I love them 😂😂

Amy=sheldon Bernadette=howers Penny =Lenard in the conversation each one sounded like there significant other

Howard sounds to innocent ! 3:27

“The slow reader used science- SUCK ON THAT!” Lmao

0:48 Amy reminds me of Stuart when he says "no no" too..

It's very simple really: There are two versions of Thor's hammer, the MCU version and the Comic Book version, in both cases the hammer chooses who is worthy based on a number of traits, so yes, the hammer does make decisions, it's magic and it's in a comic book, don't try to make it realistic. However, there is a difference between the MCU and Comic version, in the MCU, if you are unworthy, you can not lift it, end of story, in the comics, if you are unworthy, the hammer will rapidly increase its weight, this is why Hulk is able to lift the hammer, he grows stronger faster than the hammer gets heavier. There are a few loopholes to this rule, if Thor or anyone else who is worthy of the hammer is holding the hammer in any way (including the strap) the hammer can be lifted by anyone, this is how Red Hulk was able to lift the hammer, and no, Red Hulk is not worthy. Finally, the argument Bernadette made: Pick up Thor holding the hammer means he lifted the hammer, is wrong, that's not how it works. Just put this here for anyone like these 3 girls or that knows nothing about comic books.

0:10 ... Well, reading a comic book is not about reading texts in it... its about watching the pictures....analysing them.... looking at every detail... when I used to read comics in my childhood.. I used to take hours to read 1......

1:50 right there with you Penny 🤣🤣

can we all stop and appreciate this series. what a masterpiece. they not make much series like this anymore. all comedy now has F words and cursing only

In space there is no up…Oh yea? Then how does the sun come UP every day? Hard to argue with those kind of street smarts! 🤨Just brilliant 🤣🤣🤣

1:30 I'm like penny in group reading sessions. 🤣

Ok. before 2014, Thor was able to pick up the hammer because of Odin. Odin was the one who wanted the hammer made, he's the one who put part of his own life force energy aka the Odin Force into the hammer and he's the one who later put the "who ever holds this hammer if he be worthy shell possess the power of Thor" on the hammer. So the hammer decides who is worthy cause it has some sort of will of it's own that came from Odin in the first place. Before 2014 Odin never had any problems picking up the hammer if anything he seemed to have more control of it than Thor. First instance once when Thor was flying through the air by using the hammer he fell to the ground because Odin had called it and the hammer flew away from Thor towards Odin and in the story Fear itself when Thor and Odin talked about leaving Earth and Thor hit Odin with the Hammer, Odin said drop and Thor was unable to pick up the hammer. And the Odin force is in the hammer cause in 2007 to 2008 when the hammer was damaged because Thor used it to kill his grandfather he with Doctor Strange's help was able to repair the hammer cause they used most of the Odin force that was in Thor to repair the Hammer. And the Hammer does decide who is worthy even if that person does have the Odin Force within Him cause in 2001 to 2002 when Thor possessed the Odin Force and decided to take over the Earth he could no longer pick up the hammer. If Thor is holding on to the hammer, including the strap a person could pick it up or if they were in outer space. I say before 2014 cause at the end of the story event The original Sin. Nick Fury told something to Thor where not only he but everyone including Odin were unable to pick up the hammer, which means that the Hammer does have some form of will of it's own which is similar to Odin's mind since it was based off it and as such upon learning whatever Nick Fury said decided that only Jane Foster is worthy and that one time when Loki lifted it because his moral compass went 180 on itself along with many other people due to a spell that the Scarlet Witch and Doctor Doom cast.

FUN FACTS: - Thor is actually a redhead in the original Norse Myths - Mjolnir can only be wielded by those who are strong as Thor, it doesn’t matter if they’re worthy