I don’t kinda like the griffin door since I want it going straight in I’m also following along with the book

What form would the boggart take for someone who has that condition where they can't feel fear?

Cosi season it's 90* in NY right now it's not Cosi season.

🧹🪄@SuperCarlinBrothers🪄🧹 Lord Of The Rings Film Theory Video.?🎥🙏🙏🙏🎥

I don't think voldemort could appear before any of the other students as they have no idea what voldemort actually looks like whereas Harry does

Don't make me cry

WOAH. Good eye. Poor George...

Well thanks for THAT heartbreak.

Also shows that even their mother hardly acknowledged they were 2 persons, not one.

I literally cried when the twins were separated I’m actually holding back tears right now.

Yeah, how did no one do anything after finding out how badly Neville feared him

And keep in mind Nevelle's parents were tortu red till insanity, yet he finds Snape more scary. On a side note I do find it odd that Lupin doesn't gets concerned about what Nevelles could be unlike Harry, because if he manifests extreme torture, be it him being tortured or his parents, that would be so disturbing for everyone in the class and Lupin would have been fired on the spot.

I mean, who is the 'Student Councilor' at the very least? "So, Harry, how does facing Voldemort alone in a room with naught but a Mirror... make you feel?" What LITTLE we see is Dumbledore checking in on Harry Potter when he's in distress, occasionally. Unless it is 'normally' the Responsibility of each Head of House, which we don't really see either. c.c I think it'd quickly lead to Dumbledore being kicked out IF there was a Councilor to go '...what are you doing Dumbledore?' Contrarywise, councilors weren't common in schools in the 1800s as 'Head Shrinking' wasn't very respected, and Hogwartz is VERY much like an 1800s Boarding School... this is because it wasn't considered a 'serious' health issue back then. >.

@@Alex-cw3rz That is true given his traumatic history, but if you recall Lupin does ask him in the beginning what he(Neville) fears the most and Neville confesses that his worst fear is Professor Snape.

​​@@Alex-cw3rzHonestly I don't think this is the smartest lesson to have even without the threat of war. I mean, imagine how many students would have to witness or experience various forms of death, torture, imprisonment, and shame from the boggart.

Completely agree with you on both. He shows fear of the unknown and fear of showing weakness. At best I'd say Lupin meant Harry was afraid of being afraid , especially if others knew he was afraid, though I don't really see how that's wise. This line has always bothered me and the video didn't really clear it up for me, but your comment did, so thanks 👍. Whenever I read the books I kind of cringe when this line comes up. It always felt like a line the author thought sounded good so she put it in, but it doesn't really fit.

@@antoniocalado7101 I always looked at it as a line not so much commenting on Herry's being afraid but on how people view voldemort compared to Harry. Voldemort is the biggest baddest evil in the imagination of the British wizarding world. So much so that the mere mention of his name causes almost all of them to have a physical reaction to it. Harry choosing to fear what the Dementor does to him and Lupin's line to me always suggested he is saying there are greater evils to be afraid of then Voldemort, who is still just a man.

Very well put, and I wholeheartedly agree.

I disagree and agree with you. I agree that fear, vulnerability and the unknown are tied together for Harry. It stems from that traumatic moment when he felt incompensible fear as a baby when Voldemort killed his parents/guardians. Harry has a good heart and feels protective of many, but have you noticed that Harry feels that paralyzing fear when it regards protecting a guardian or perceived guardian? When he has to protect himself, Sirius (and Hermione) from the Dementors, "a paralyzing terror filled Harry so that he couldn't move or speak". With the inferi, Harry doesn't immediately fear it, he thinks they're "a horrible idea" when Dumbledore explains what they are. Nonetheless, he panics in the moment when he has to protect himself and Dumbledore from them. With the Department of Mysteries event, he doesn't act with that wisdom we know him to possess but loses sight of how to confirm if Sirius left Grimauld place or not (could have used the mirror) because he believed Sirius to be in danger. I think Harry is very relatable in this terrible lesson as most of us have to work through facing our insecurities step by step. It's no coincidence that Harry refuses Lupin's help in Deathly Hallows when he does to Grimauld place and says he'll be joining the trio to complete the mission Dumbledore gave them - Harry doesn't want to be the cause of Teddy growing up without one of his guardians and having a semi-guardian on his journey. I disagree that he doesn't overcome fear, vulnerability and the unknown - he overcomes it when he willingly goes to die in the forest. He says bye to most of his guardians in the forest, and says bye to Dumbledore when he's in limbo. I think this is where Harry's boggart could change into any of his other fears. Harry's paralyzing fears are situational - it includes fear, vulnerability, the unknown and his guardians. On the one hand, Harry is admirable because he innately appear to be brave and overcomes fears (which he feels like anyone else) that would otherwise paralyze others. On the other hand, this trait may heightened due to his experience of pure fear at the most vulnerable time in his life, that other forms of fear cannot compare, unwittingly giving him a kind of wisdom to see past fear and cherish and perceive clearly that which others would otherlook (to slightly borrow from Hermione).

Personally I think Lupin should have been just as close to harry as Sirius if not closer as he got to spend nearly a whole term having lessons and extra lessons with Lupin. While he talks with Sirius a whole what 10 or 20 minutes at the end of book 3 but Sirius is the one Harry decided to keep in contact with while he seems to barely speak to Lupin.

The third movie in general is fanastic with stuff that doesnt happen in the Book imo.

@@conormurphy4328 I think a lot of that was that Sirius was more the of ‘wild, rulebreaking, fun’ whereas Remus was more mellow, methodical, and conservative. I think Sirius’ qualities appealed to Harry more, and he therefore related to him more. Sirius and James were also closer than Remus was with James and so I think that also made him feel more connected to Sirius.

​@@kaylahshaylene1617There's also one small, nuanced point. Sirius is Harry's god father. I think it was only mentioned once or twice, so I can why you'd leave it out.

3rd movie is imo the best adaptation

Also a bigot, arrogant, egotistical and short tempered. Though I guess flaws do make for a real person.

People are strange... they will say Colin Creevey before Harry ... just to sound "not basic"........

Especially since Harru ultimately finds a way to close his mind for Voldemort, using his love for others to lock him out.

I agree - Harry was able to eventually block Snape during the lessons, he had a spark just he had that spark of being able to resist the imperius curse. He just needed someone to nurture that spark and help him learn, and also be respectful about his memories, it's very intimate to let someone go in your head like that, you need someone trustworthy like Lupin or Dumbledore

Oh my! That's a very good theory

Makes sense

Headcanon now.

*boggart

@@taylortdf5459 Thanks. Fixing it now.

exactly, if someone was truly afraid of fear itself, maybe that would be the only way to get a boggart to show its true form lol

INDEED

@@SuperCarlinBrothers yessir

Facts

One of the greatest lessons I've ever learned. Bravery is not the absence of fear but the courage to overcome it! But alas I don't remember who said it😢

Because the thing Harry fears is not the Dementor itself, but actually the feeling he gets when he encounters one. He fears the fear of experiencing those scenes again.

Seems legit

It's definitely possible

Sure, but I think we can come up with better ones, Leonardo da Vinci. He's pretty cool. FDR was wheelchair bound. If he was a wizard, he would have fixed that.

@@keithg460 If your father was in a weelchair that does not mean that you are also in a wealchair.

@@geenkaas6380I think they meant if they were wizards they wouldn’t have needed the wheelchair because they could make things to help him walk if not just straight up fix any issues.

Should have been a separate room each student come into one by one with Lupin inside teaching/monitoring of course.

Young people can have pretty legitimate fears though (even some that follow into adulthood). Imagine you're a closeted member of the LGBT+ community, your greatest fear (younger or older) would then be "someone outs you". This isn't just a fear that someone will dislike you for your preference/identity but also that someone could physically harm you or reject you outright for just being you I understand that the boggart is just a plot advancement point to Harry learning the Patronus Charm so not a lot of thought went into how damaging this lesson could have been; the focus was mainly on teasing Harry about the dementors but many other students could have been terribly bullied as well. People are cruel.

​@@you_already_have_itsee, I kinda disagree here. Yes, outting everyone's fears in front of other classmates might be a problem for potential bullying, but watching your friends and classmates overcome their fears can help rally the next student that they can do it too. On top of that, knowing that other people that you can trust are nearby can also help.

@@torazely it's not just bullying. Worst fear is like dirty laundry of your mind. And then it's out for everyone to see. Students should have an option to choose going inside alone or in a group. Again of course with teacher inside to guide and help. I would choose option to go alone for sure.

@@you_already_have_it I wouldn't. The idea of having to face the thing I fear most all on my own would be even more terrifying. I'd RATHER have my friends, the people I trust, with me to support me.

You're not wrong

It was an unsettling one. They could have easily made it a funny clown

I'll take a giant CGI cobra over whatever that clown was. That thing makes Pennywise look like a Care Bear.

@@thedragonwarrior5861you can’t have a funny clown tbh

I can see it

More just anyone who knew the truth... So people starting to tell him they know the truth, that Ariana... it is a form of the 'Ego Death' for certain.

I think his boggart would become something more straightforward: A clear vision of him killing Ariana.

The Drink of Despair also lends credence to this theory.

Ooh that's a good theory

😂