That's not really it though. They don't get to go to "the best place imaginable" until they've been redeemed, which is the whole point of the hotel. Hazbin Hotel itself is still in Hell, so in your analogy it's more like the person that killed your family is still in prison, but the prison is actually doing something to rehabilitate them instead of making them suffer forever. Also the prison doesn't know if rehabilitation is actually possible.

@@SpiritOfGotham I didn't say I disagree with Charlie entirely but it is understandable to detest sinners in Hell if they were the worst humanity had to offer. Besides I don't think it would go well if a sinner was redeemed then met one of their victims in Heaven since then they would be like "the fuck?!" I know if someone brutally killed me or something else like that I wouldn't be very happy to know they were let into eternal paradise.

​@@SpiritOfGotham Although they forcefully made him a villain and took the extermination of sinners and the refusal of those to ascend as a pure whim of the angels, he was right, they had a lifetime to repent but they did not, how many innocent lives? would they have ruined? whether murdering, raping adults and children, among other atrocious crimes. Hell in the series was just another slightly ugly place, it's not like they were tortured or anything like that, it's the very existence of the sinners that makes it even worse than it is. If the hell in the series really were a "hell", the sinners should be happy to finally be able to put an end to their "suffering", but that doesn't happen, right? Why aren't they suffering? Do you know what's the funniest thing? That in the series, IN THE WHOLE TIME OF HELL'S EXISTENCE NEVER BUT NEVER was there a sinner who had redeemed himself and had done ENOUGH to ascend to heaven before Mr. Pentious, it is not as if the angels blocked that way but rather we saw that There was always that option. The plot of the series is too forced On top of that, Charlie wants to use that method that has proven to be one in BILLIONS, to reduce the overpopulation of hell. How many sinners die every day and at what rate is it even possible for sinners to be redeemed? It's not even remotely feasible.