We need to stop saying "lobby" and even "get the money out of politics" and start calling it what it really is - corruption.
@nicklang767016 күн бұрын
And Bribery
@CantankerousDave16 күн бұрын
Legalized bribery made legal by the people accepting the bribes.
@fadigobran471916 күн бұрын
Lobby = legal bribe
@tuberific45416 күн бұрын
I find the term "soft corruption" is more appropriate since hard corruption involves breaking actual laws. So, for example under so-called "corporate personhood" what we understand to be corruptuon is perfectly legal. Also, with the Janus scotus decision in 2018 that stripped public worker unions of political speech, the idea that "corporate personhood" is about free speech falls flat.
@fadigobran471916 күн бұрын
@@tuberific454 legal bribery?
@chriss229516 күн бұрын
The rich should just pay their taxes like the rest of us instead of playing loopholes.
@DeathAndTaxesAbolitionist13 күн бұрын
They don't do what the should, that is why they are rich.
@andrewj228 күн бұрын
The existence of a loophole means there are no taxes which are "theirs" to pay. What does it mean to pay your taxes? It means paying what the law requires. If there's a loophole in the law that reduces your tax bill, then "paying your taxes" just means paying the lesser amount.
@rodsmediaroom8354 күн бұрын
Very true @andrewj22 - however, the laws could always be changed to reduce the number of loopholes. But since it's often the rich that influence these laws, they keep the loopholes in place for their own benefit. Not that I believe that all rich people are only out for themselves. There's at least some that actually care about humanity and their fellow human beings... not sure if it's a very high percentage though.
@andrewj224 күн бұрын
@@rodsmediaroom835 The greater a person's lifestyle is beyond what's necessary, the less it makes sense to say they care about others. In other words, the rich are inherently sociopaths. Only a sociopath would hoard that much money when it could be used to do so much good for others.
@helios7212Күн бұрын
Bingo. Bezos pays less a percentage in his income than you. How does that make you feel?
@stuward337416 күн бұрын
You didn't mention exploiting workers.
@KevinThomas-ok2ev16 күн бұрын
That’s called hiring employees. You can always quit, or simply not take the job to begin with.
@scifirealism594316 күн бұрын
@KevinThomas-ok2ev not everyone can do that?
@KevinThomas-ok2ev16 күн бұрын
@@scifirealism5943 The only time I’ve found myself doing a job that I wasn’t allowed to quit, was when I wore a shirt with patches saying “US Army” on my chest.
@scifirealism594316 күн бұрын
@@KevinThomas-ok2ev half of the population is in poverty, millions have no savings or healthcare or college degree.
@user-hy6yq4uk8e16 күн бұрын
Even multi-millionaires and millionaires exploit workers.
@lady_draguliana78416 күн бұрын
“When the people shall have nothing more to eat, they will eat the rich.” - Jean Jacques Rousseau
@Michelle-hh5de10 күн бұрын
Apparently the rich didn't learn their lesson from the French Revolution.
@lady_draguliana78410 күн бұрын
@@Michelle-hh5de TBF, since then, they've been untouchable for 120yrs now... they regularly slip passed every possible consequence for every possible evil they commit... they have private security, bunkers, private jets to escape with; far as they're concerned, they are and will be untouchable, and they will believe that right up until they're disabused, which is unclear if it will happen anytime soon, even if it IS inevitable...
@EJDubbz16 күн бұрын
These animations are fantastic. So is Robert.
@jjhpor16 күн бұрын
Quote by Honoré de Balzac: “Behind every great fortune there is a crime.”
@dvdv819716 күн бұрын
Fraud should amount to CRIMINAL CHARGES, not a SLAP ON THE WRIST, which is often then considered to be "the cost of doing business".
@LordWaterBottle16 күн бұрын
If the punishment is a fine the act is defacto legal for the rich.
@jneff645616 күн бұрын
Fraud should have a mandatory minimum jail time.
@kevinmetcalfe712616 күн бұрын
There should be restitution, something towards making it right for those harmed by their actions. Or just taking care of the workers versus the shareholders in the first place. Funny how money corrupts. Everything is for sale including Extreme Court Justices!
@P.S.-rf6mc15 күн бұрын
@@LordWaterBottle EXCELLENT observation....
@GoddessPallasAthena11 күн бұрын
@@kevinmetcalfe7126 ABSOLUTELY! At most, people generally get a few dollars for years worth of lawsuits (even if what the company did was illegal). The cost to do the wrong should should be SO EXPENSIVE that it's not worth it. And I also agree about jail time. OR if corporations are PEOPLE (yeah, we need to fix Citizens United) then CORPORATIONS should be in jail for bad stuff done on their behalf. If not literally, then they should LOSE a LOT of rights and privileges. Those who know businesses and economy better than I do (it's sooo convoluted now) would know the best way to do so with minimal pain to most of the workers and hold those who made the bad decisions (or who mandated it) pay.
@jneff645616 күн бұрын
Add to all this that Billionaires just sit on most of their cash... and when money stagnates, the economy suffers. A healthy economy requires the movement of money.
@andrewj228 күн бұрын
I'm in favour of equality, but I'm not sure this particular argument makes sense. I doubt most billionaires are keeping piles of cash under their mattresses.
@Avery_42728 күн бұрын
"A healthy economy requires the movement of money" -- I agree; there must be a healthy circulation of it. That reminds me of the line from Thornton Wilder's play, The Matchmaker: "Money is like manure; it's not worth a thing unless it's spread around encouraging young things to grow."
@andrewj227 күн бұрын
@@Avery_4272 All money, except cash stuffed under your mattress, is circulating.
@dvdv819716 күн бұрын
"The selfmade billionaire" is a myth.
@shadowmancer9916 күн бұрын
How it s a myth? I can cite athletes, entertainers, as well as business man who have achieved this. You are a naive and silly fool to disparge the efforts others have made just to make you feel less small...
@danielwilliams834616 күн бұрын
Even if It MAY have started out that way at one point, why should they make SO MUCH MORE?
@chaosopher2316 күн бұрын
Or a really popular artist. J. K Rowling (for a short time, anyway) comes to mind, and so does Sir Paul McCartney. If he's not a billionaire he's really close and could be tomorrow if so desired. Two in 8 billion... I'm not that good with a keyboard or a bass.
@shadowmancer9916 күн бұрын
@@danielwilliams8346 Who cares....I dont care about the success of someone else if they did it legally. That is why when people attack Bezos I laugh or Gates or Jobs...these guys pioneered whole industries and they DESERVE the money they earned. They are a goal for others to reach. But its not just them, athletes can make Billions, so can entertainers, like Swift. Are you telling me, THEY dont earn their money? Course not. So people need to stop with the jealousy and desire to steal...
@KevinThomas-ok2ev16 күн бұрын
Yeah, that Taylor Swift is such an exploiter!
@TheGreatAtario15 күн бұрын
You forgot one: exploiting large numbers of workers
@tfde116 күн бұрын
So politicians on both sides become millionaires by helping the rich become billionaires.
@andreah637916 күн бұрын
That much is true. But add one stark truth: CONservatism in both parties is our problem. CONservatism= No taxes on the rich, but definitely tax & screw the regular folk in our country! THAT'S WHAT "TRICKLE-DOWN IS!"
@bonquiqui87415 күн бұрын
Bingo
@davidlafleche114210 күн бұрын
Everybody should pay one flat tax of 10%, regardless of income. "Thou shalt not covet" (10th Commandment). We must cut Federal spending 70%. "Thou shalt not steal" (8th Commandment).
@RevLeigh556 күн бұрын
@@davidlafleche1142Nope! That’s regressive and unfair. 10% is chump change for the filthy rich but it’s a hunk out of a poor person’s meager income.
@laughingalex75634 күн бұрын
@@davidlafleche1142 generally it should be poorer people pay a lower % of there own income, richer a higher %, as poorer individuals really cannot afford even smaller taxes while the ultra rich can easily sneeze away a much larger percent and still be fine.
@Craxin0116 күн бұрын
Greed destroys everything.
@isnamthere469016 күн бұрын
And for over a decade, Rush Limbaugh trained the right to believe that greed is good.
@scifirealism594316 күн бұрын
While i make $10.50/hr as a cashier, $900/semester as an intern, can't afford community college, and use welfare, and 43% of the population lives in poverty, then no, I'll never support the existence of a single billionaire.
@douglastovey268516 күн бұрын
Fill out the Federal Application for Student Aide. If you are as poor as you say you are, you will qualify for the PEL grant. $7400. That will pay all books, tuition, fees at any community college with money left over. Then live off your 10.50 and hour and intern money. Keep doing what you know is right and good things will happen. They always do.
@scifirealism594316 күн бұрын
@@douglastovey2685 I lost Pell grants because of bad grades. When I first went to college, I had to rely on Medicaid because higher education doesn't offer healthcare. But because welfare isn't an unconditional cash transfer, I couldn't use my health coverage to take care of my sick mom. She was sick for six years and ultimately passed away. The stress from this caused my grades to drop, lose financial aid, and not get it back despite the financial aid office knowing what happened to my mom.
@scifirealism594316 күн бұрын
@@douglastovey2685 I was able to win some scholarships allowing me to attend school and fall full time(cover the tuition). I'm not giving up
@scifirealism594316 күн бұрын
@@douglastovey2685 my replies are gone.. GONE. DAMN KZfaq I TYPED SO MUCH.
@sfi380716 күн бұрын
@@douglastovey2685it's me scifirealism.
@BMinus059316 күн бұрын
Much better to have 1000 millionaires than 1 billionaire. The disproportionate amount of power a billionaire has cannot be overstated.
@Nemesisnxt16 күн бұрын
So $999M good, $1B bad? Makes sense.
@Tahoza16 күн бұрын
@@Nemesisnxt It's clear they meant 1,000 people with $1,000,000 considering that one billion dollars is 1,000 times greater than one million dollars. Have whatever opinion you want but intentionally obtuse bad faith arguments don't help anyone.
@BMinus059316 күн бұрын
@@Nemesisnxt 1000 individuals @ 1 million vs. 1 individual @ 1 billion. It’s a very simple concept.
@mikjb16 күн бұрын
@@BMinus0593 Like the difference between a government and a king.
@Nemesisnxt16 күн бұрын
@@timfuscaldo3024No, they don’t hoard their money. How do you think they increase their wealth?
@speedingpullet740016 күн бұрын
Personally, I think if you can't make it on $100 million, you're doing it wrong. 😎
@jtl928316 күн бұрын
Yep. It's about power at that point. Not whether they can make it or not.
@Sgwaos16 күн бұрын
😂
@andreah637916 күн бұрын
Woah!! You are making waaaaay too much sense here. 😊
@2cartalkers16 күн бұрын
Criminals in expensive suits.
@andreah637916 күн бұрын
Well said!! But, BUT way too many ppl, especially in our capitalistic society are swept away, idolize whoever the person is driving that exotic car, wearing designer clothes, sporting big chunky gold jewelry and truly believe they must be god sent to earth. Tell me I have this wrong. I dare you.
@ginetterainville865216 күн бұрын
Great question. No multiplied by billions
@Shawn-gr5ww16 күн бұрын
I see Robert Reich didn’t say anything about millionaires. Probably cause he is one.
@mbjasniewski16 күн бұрын
@@Shawn-gr5ww I see that you are spewing your shyte from a shiny new (April 2024) YT account. Does being a corporate stooge at YT pay well?
@jamesdelcol370116 күн бұрын
Nobody has a problem with billionaires, just people that skirt the system. If you skirt taxes with off shore accounts, you're not supporting your country.
@karlaboerger361916 күн бұрын
As in they have right to live. Yes. They have right to have all that money. No.
@Shawn-gr5ww16 күн бұрын
So you believe we should just take money from people who you deem have too much? Ok commie
@Psuedo-Nim16 күн бұрын
if they don't have a right to their money, then neither do you have a rignt to yours.
@karlaboerger361916 күн бұрын
@@Psuedo-Nim Read the part of all. They can have some. But not all of it. They have way to much in comparison to rest of us. You are on the billionaire side of things.
@Psuedo-Nim16 күн бұрын
@@karlaboerger3619 I'm on the individual freedom sort of things--letting the envious mob turn on everyone with more than them is a recipe for disaster
@karlaboerger361916 күн бұрын
@Psuedo-Nim okay. Don't complain one day. You only have pennies. And trillions of dollars are hand select few.
@peterbedford261016 күн бұрын
Familial wealth has created a neo aristocracy. A super upper class of people that seem to grow wealthier every year. And they use their financial power in many ways. This is completely counter to our belief in a meritocracy and the benefits it bestows upon our society.
@dvdv819716 күн бұрын
Billionaires shouldn't exist. Any property above 1 billion should be taxed at an EXTREMELY high rate. Watch them pay their workers more fairly if that happens.
@Qoordheere7716 күн бұрын
When you failed to become a billionaire your thoughts is this...😂
@chaosopher2316 күн бұрын
'property' is one thing. You can't liquidate $100,000 worth of a factory and make a down payment on a car. But that much in stocks and other volatile financials? Perhaps these should only be available after a tax man signs off on the transaction, buy, sell, or trade. Close loopholes, no shells, shadows, wights, ghost, or wisp corporate entities... and a fair tax.
@MrShoblang16 күн бұрын
@@Qoordheere77"failed"? What does any individual need billions for? Why would you want to become part of the problem?
@dvdv819716 күн бұрын
@@Qoordheere77 then why aren't you thinking the same thing and instead are simping for people who will never care about you? 😂😂
@lazaruslong9216 күн бұрын
@@Qoordheere77 My all the cockroaches are crawling out of the woodwork here. Yanks like you make me proud to be Canadian.
@RextheRebel16 күн бұрын
Ban hedge funds and monopolized industries.
@MPaulCezanne16 күн бұрын
100% correct.
@harrydecker873116 күн бұрын
Jim, Rob, and Alice Walton are each worth more than $60 billion. Here in Western Pennsylvania I have seen with my own eyes estates inherited by heirs of fortunes made in steel, coal, oil, gas, timber, and beer. These people have their own private clubs and frolic at upscale resorts. Never have to work a day in their life. Don’t have to make mortgage and car payments. Much of the wealth hoarded by the elite, regardless of its source, could be very useful to the non-elite who want to go to college or start a business or buy a house at an affordable price or get their teeth fixed or pay for a much-needed operation. Serious reforms need to be made. There really needs to be a cap on how much wealth an individual can have.
@scifirealism594316 күн бұрын
Yes. You are CORRECT.
@scifirealism594316 күн бұрын
I'm a poor, self supporting college student using welfare to get by. If I had a full ride scholarship or grant, I wouldn't need welfare and could compete with rich students.
@marcsyrene378115 күн бұрын
Their is no pie. Except mother nature. That is the pie. A wealthy person can be greedy or not. A poor person can be greedy or not. Just because a person is wealthy doesn't make them greedy and just because a person is poor doesn't make them not greedy. Money is a tool we freely use to trade for this and that. Great invention really. My experience with bartering always usually leaves a little bit of a bitter taste in my mouth as if I have been taken advantage of. With money I can easily decide what works for me in terms of the value for my work. Sooo easy. And as a side note and a good practice to put things in perspective, the next time you think something is expensive try and make it yourself from scratch. I mean mining the material, processing that material, engineer and design it, throw away your mistakes, remake it 10 more times until you get something you can use and make all the tools you need to build the thing. You get my point. It's a matter of perspective. Things are actually too cheap that we have become a culture of greed and entitlement. But somehow we are not fulfilled as a whole.
@Mkundera11 күн бұрын
A bunch of whiners like I've never seen. Go out and make your own money and stop counting other people's money and waxing on about how much of that you should have. Just pathetic. Create something!
@dvdv819716 күн бұрын
MONEY OUT OF POLITICS NOW!! 😤😤😤😤
@justinwilliams348316 күн бұрын
Yes
@anitahaslam230216 күн бұрын
In early twentieth century Britain there were limits on what could be spent for an election campaign. Go over the limit-automatically disqualified.
@dvdv819716 күн бұрын
Fraud should amount to CRIMINAL CHARGES, not a SLAP ON THE WRIST.
@JosedeJezeus16 күн бұрын
Our economy is a game. The people caught Cheating in the game should not be allowed to play it.
@limsalalafells16 күн бұрын
It does as long as it's not white collar fraud....
@Mom4cool16 күн бұрын
If it is true, that many billionaires are psychopaths, nothing said will effect them. It would take hard work, commitment and persistence. They won’t go down to poor multimillionaires easily.
@eileenfidler643016 күн бұрын
Billionaires get billions by buying Supreme court judges as well it seems
@badpuppy0916 күн бұрын
It's obscene, no one deserves that much money. 900.000 million max, excess goes to public services to make life better for ALL!
@trollman888816 күн бұрын
that would be utopia, unfortunately greed is a core trait of humanity
@matthuck37816 күн бұрын
No. I think once you make about 20 million, you should be given a "I won capitalism" trophy, and be unallowed to make any more money. They won! They're done.
@scifirealism594316 күн бұрын
Lol.
@doggy91116 күн бұрын
I think you’re exactly right!👍
@douglastovey268516 күн бұрын
That’s coming from a “what about me” point of view. If all the people who created wealth quit at 20 million where would that leave us. What companies would remain. I believe Robert has watched too many movies where the evil Corporations and Billionaires are involved in conspiracies to rule the world. Most take pride in product a good product that provides something consumers/the masses want and need.
@josephg16016 күн бұрын
I still don't get how people believe that billionaires earned their money even though in reality they don't.
@juniorgod32116 күн бұрын
because they earned it, people like Robert Reich and you just don't like to admit it because you're not one!
@rogaldorn475916 күн бұрын
@@juniorgod321 You truly seem to be a junior. Try actual arguments.
@user-pn1fe6sg2w16 күн бұрын
@@juniorgod321 unga-bunga 🦍
@brucebasile508316 күн бұрын
@@juniorgod321 Another corporate bootlicker spewing nonsense.
@Nemesisnxt16 күн бұрын
Whether they earned it or not, it’s their private property, and you have no right to it.
No one should have Billions as profit. Money is a scarce resource yet essential, no one should horde billions when most have so little. We are on the hand of extreme rich people ever since the dawn of society and the world is always shit.
@winterwalsh560116 күн бұрын
Much love Robert,I adore you and use many of your videos to educate my teenage kids and their mates.
@power2me116 күн бұрын
please show them thomas sowell too, so they don't grow up to be little victim whiners.
@nychris225816 күн бұрын
I think they should be allowed to exist but tax excessive wealth
@Tatefootball8315 күн бұрын
If we had ACTUAL taxes on the rich and we fixed loopholes, I believe we'd still have billionaires. But THESE billionaires would much more likely have either done something tremendous for society (via hard work and or creativity) OR benefitted from some rare stroke of luck/act of God that they wouldn't be able to perpetuate the myth of the "self-made billionaire." The way we currently have it, it's more about exploitation and gaming the system than hard work or innovation.
@Shadow1-cf7nw16 күн бұрын
I like your thinking here. The tax laws in this country need to be changed to force the ultra wealthy to pay their fair share.
@Psuedo-Nim16 күн бұрын
the wealthy p[ay the majority of all taxes.
@shadowmancer9916 күн бұрын
They do pay taxes, and I want people to stop using idiotic terms like fair share, and ACTUALLY define what they mean...WHAT do you consider fair. Dont use a slogan, use a number or percetange. THEN meaningful discussion can happen.
@nnonotnow16 күн бұрын
Even Warren Buffett agrees with you
@Shadow1-cf7nw16 күн бұрын
@@shadowmancer99 Did you not watch the State of the Union speech where Joe Biden gave the percentage income tax that billionaires pay compared to the average American. I don't recall the exact percentage for billionaires, but it was ridiculously low.
@techcafe016 күн бұрын
that's what the Trudeau government in Canada is trying to do now, make the very wealthy at the top contribute their fair share to the common public good. but sadly, as expected, the greedy rich are vehemently opposed and have unleashed their media attack dogs and far-right wingnuts, accusing our government of being 'fascist' 'communist' 'dictator' blahblahblah 🙄 as if asking the super rich to pay a teensy bit more in taxes, instead of hiding & hoarding vast fortunes and not contributing is somehow is akin to communism 🤷🏻♂ considering they are millionaires & billionaires who can easily afford to pay up, and still be obscenely rich.
@mrfuzztone16 күн бұрын
Great analysis. The huge amount of money billionaires have came from somebody. Think about all the regular people working hard with low wages to produce things.
@meeraj-477416 күн бұрын
Yeah from their customers which they voluntarly buy.
@mrfuzztone16 күн бұрын
@@meeraj-4774 Right. Like 25% interest on credit cards. It is true that a lot of people got a big advantage with good education and family wealth. And once at a high level there are plenty of ways for the rich to get richer. Regular people know very little about the complex financial system possibilities and scams. They are not in that world. I would be somewhat satisfied if public education was properly funded and there was a medicare for all type system so everybody could at least get medical treatments when needed. Me. I am not complaining for myself. I am doing OK. I have no credit card debt but a lot of guitars. Maybe $1 billion is enough for one person.
@technicoloryaya54916 күн бұрын
Sure. As long as they are held to the same standards as mom and pop up the street. Pay the same 13% fed and 8% state taxes. If they go to prison when they break laws. And there are anti-corruption laws that are enforced.
@briseboy16 күн бұрын
Unless income is taxed in a graduated manner, as percentage, increased as income increases, the wealthy become increasingly free to spend amounts far beyond, exorbitant compared to ANY OTHER INDIVIDUAL. This is Not in the interest of a community, as the wealthiest wields autocratic power.
@Pete_R6316 күн бұрын
How much is enough? At some point, it just gets so absurd. When you die with all that money that you did nothing with, you could have just pretended you had all that money and accomplished the same thing. Do some good in the world with it.
@robertnapier62413 күн бұрын
And they have enough to last multiple lifetimes. Not one lifetime. Multiple lifetimes.
@user-hy6yq4uk8e16 күн бұрын
My biggest gripe with billionaires is the undo burden it puts on an economic system. It creates imbalance. Probabilities and statistics (and chaos theory?) will tell you that a NO system can survive or run smoothly until it reaches an equalibrium. And they have no redeeming social value. We you get that big/rich, you're screwing over somebody.
@hezigler14 күн бұрын
"We can have democracy in this country, or we can have great wealth concentrated in the hands of a few, but we can't have both." Louis D. Brandeis
@JohnSeward-mm4lo16 күн бұрын
No “ Eat the rich “
@1906Farnsworth15 күн бұрын
Careful. "Rich" is subjective. Compared to many in the world YOU are one of the rich. We need freedom and honesty, not class envy.
@minskysfeedbackyianni130216 күн бұрын
A 'NO' vote from Scotland.🤔
@jeannedouglas991216 күн бұрын
No meaning what?
@davidlafleche114216 күн бұрын
However much money anyone else has is none of your business.
@dbrxsdgo16 күн бұрын
Love the way you think, Robert. And you always explain and lay things out for even the most simple of us to understand. Thank you for all you do to educate us and expose the fraud, waste and abuse. Been thinking this same thing lately. Exactly how much financial (and material wealth) does one need. Pure greed. 🤑
@thomasrice407816 күн бұрын
Of course not! Unequal distribution on wealth harms and limits the future of the economy.
@DoremiFasolatido197916 күн бұрын
There's only one question to ask...and only one correct answer to it. Which is better for an economy, all conditions being equal; 100,000 individuals with $100 million each, or 100 million individuals with $100,000 each?
@aaronblain637716 күн бұрын
Capitalists spend their money on increasing their capital, and in buying the state. Only a very small portion of their profits go into productive investment. This is especially true because financial speculation and usury is more profitable than industry. That's why we are dismantling all our industry, our roads are crumbling, etc. Working class people spend their wages on the necessities of life, which increases demand in the real economy. However most of our wages actually go to landlords, monopolists and usurers, which causes a spiral of decreasing demand and a slowing economy. Which is why more than a few political economists are arguing that our present system is becoming more like feudalism in several respects. It's all geared toward unproductive rent extraction.
@DoremiFasolatido197916 күн бұрын
@@aaronblain6377 They don't really buy capital, but for the most part, you're right. But what's your answer to the question posed?
@aaronblain637716 күн бұрын
@@DoremiFasolatido1979 I was speaking colloquially. What actually matters is the allocation of society's finite labor. As command over that labor naturally concentrates, the result is an increasingly parasitic, empty economy, and a state apparatus ever more firmly in the hands of a ruling oligarchy. We are watching the West de-industrialize and collapse as finance continues to cannibalize society, and usher in a second medieval era. We could give 100k to each of 100,000,000 people, and although that would make things better for a time (eg the mid 20th century), it wouldn't change the underlying mechanisms and we'd end up here again in time.
@Rtzoor16 күн бұрын
how do we actually break the vicious cycle?
@NoOligarchs16 күн бұрын
The org RepresentUs helps people bring small changes to their towns, like anti-corruption laws, with the goal of achieving nationwide critical mass. Like eating an elephant: one bite at a time.
@piku563716 күн бұрын
Worker owned co-ops and unions. Protests.
@scifirealism594316 күн бұрын
Raise the minimum wage, welfare, UBI
@Ratigan216 күн бұрын
You just gotta appreciate the animation they put alongside the facts he's preaching. It just makes it so much easier to digest of what would otherwise be a bland economics lecture
@bradsillasen197216 күн бұрын
Even 100 million is obscenely rich and undeserved by anyone, perhaps aside of such noble souls who actually reduced net suffering in the world. Too many to name but never enough. What I wonder is, why do these billionaires keep wanting more money? They already have all they could ever spend. I say, take a few million, and live the rest of your life doing something courageous, or at least, mind expanding.
@samhavoc106616 күн бұрын
The tax rate for the highest income bracket was 93% under President Eisenhower. We need to bring those tax rates back. With a caveat that money paid back into business growth and employee profit sharing will not be taxed. Incentive to invest their money back into the business to be in a lower tax bracket.
@meeraj-477416 күн бұрын
What if i tell you people like bezos still be Multibillionaire coz his income is unrealized capital gains which is not a taxable income.
@keep-ukraine-free5285 күн бұрын
@@meeraj-4774 That can also be taxed, in a fair country. Change our tax laws. If/whenever unrealized capital gains (UCG) are leveraged financially in ANY way (let's say by taking a "loan" against the UCG's current value), then that UCG becomes fully taxable at the value it had at the moment it was "used" (taxed on the UCG's value exactly when the "loan" is initiated).
@meeraj-47745 күн бұрын
@@keep-ukraine-free528 that fair country doesn't exist.
@Georgina70516 күн бұрын
I'm so happy I made productive decisions about my finances that changed my life forever,hoping to retire next year.. Investment should always be on any creative man's heart for success in life
@findingpath836216 күн бұрын
Thanks for the advice! I'm new to financial planning and wasn't sure where to start. Any tips on finding a reliable financial adviser or resource to guide beginners?
@tryleraaron924416 күн бұрын
Truly, investing has changed my perspective on how one can succeed in life; working multiple jobs isn't the optimal way to attain financial freedom and unfortunately, we discover this later in life. Currently earn as much as 12 grand weekly and this has improved my financial life
@LindaHarmel16 күн бұрын
YES! that's exactly her name (Stacey Macken) I watched her interview on CNN News and so many people recommended her trading skills, she's an expert and I'm just starting with her....From Brisbane Australia
@Kristenshwan16 күн бұрын
This Woman has really change the life of many people from different countries and am a testimony of her trading platform .
@charles239516 күн бұрын
Wow. I'm a bit perplexed seeing her been mentioned here also Didn't know she has been good to so many people too this is wonderful, I'm in my fifth trade with her and it has been super
@johnhyde729716 күн бұрын
Why do people in government think they know more than anyone else....???? I'll wait for an answer Robert......
@edwardmeradith241916 күн бұрын
Simple answer: NO. Not good for anyone, really. The gulf between how we monetarily reward ‘a job well done’ - ANY job I assert - is obscene. No one’s time is worth that much more than anyone elses. The most valuable thing we have is time- and no one knows how much of that we have, including ourselves. There should be a ‘maximum wage’ as well as a ‘minimum wage’ and the difference should be at a scale we can all understand.
@scottsledgister187716 күн бұрын
So you love communism is all I get from your post
@keep-ukraine-free5285 күн бұрын
@edwardmeradith2419 I believe you may not realize the wealth of billionaires does not come from wages. It comes from "interest" income they receive from investments (like a stock's capital-gains, dividends, etc.). Sorry to say, capping wages using a 'maximum wage' will do almost nothing.The world is complicated, and requires complicated solutions -- like *taxing **_unrealized capital gains_** (UCG) when they're leveraged financially* in ANY way (let's say when leveraged by taking a "loan" against the UCG's current value).
@edwardmeradith24195 күн бұрын
@@keep-ukraine-free528 ‘the world is complicated and requires complicated solutions’ Absolutely- and you understand elements that I don’t pretend to understand- I wasn’t attempting to address unearned income and, what in my limited understanding, a ridiculous tax structure. My statement is more abstract in that it was meant to question how we put value on human’s limited amount of time here and reward the spending of that time working
@jogb951516 күн бұрын
I thought this was going to be an anti-capitalist rant, but very good points.
@frances-if5fp13 күн бұрын
R.Reich never rants...he proves the validity of his assertions.
@jogb95156 күн бұрын
@@frances-if5fp Pfft, even here he talks some rubbish: Amazon has a monopoly? Ever heard of Walmart, aliExpress, TaoBao, Temu, Target...the list goes on.
@jackcarraway470716 күн бұрын
If hard work is what makes you rich, construction workers would be the billionaires.
@JohnAntonacci116 күн бұрын
Those that say "This person became a billionaire or multimillionaire even though their from a humble background". Sure, but they were born with phenomenal talent in business, entertainment, sports or tech that the overwhelming majority of us weren't born with. I'm not advocating laziness, & people should reap rewards from their labor. Once they reach this financial success though, they should not be allowed special tax breaks or other conduct that comes at the expense of others.
@VeryAnnaBerry16 күн бұрын
I believe there will come a time when extreme wealth will be regarded as obscene and criminal.
@camwatters64416 күн бұрын
People have a natural instinct to kiss up and revere those that oppress them.people kissed up to kings and queens.
@chieftain557116 күн бұрын
Thank you! Its how a lot of the financial, crookery, and even political crap goes on.
@johnlynn854316 күн бұрын
Ha! Just before I was watching this, I was watching Infographics Show on North Korea. It would seem you are correct.
@agwhoneedsaphd264316 күн бұрын
How does this not just make everyone a debt slave to banks?
@johnlynn854316 күн бұрын
Actually your money is a note of debt.
@dwarlord371615 күн бұрын
The national debt is 34 trillion. Not only are we slaves to the bank, but our children's grandchildren, will be slaves to the bank. We are living in a guilded cage, only with an illusion of freedom...
@kengilliland72716 күн бұрын
Thanks for all you do to keep us informed.
@Vendavalez16 күн бұрын
The point definitely stands and I agree that “billionaire” is the best and most concise term to describe it right now. But I tend to dislike the term when talking about this issue because, with inflation bad enough, everyone could be a billionaire. Or at the very least, bad enough inflation could throw the proportions of what is being talked about out of whack. I wish there was a simple and understandable way of talking about relative wealth. Someone making 40 times the minimum wage may be reasonable under some circumstances, but not 300 or more. And that’s regardless of what the actual numbers are in dollars or in any other denomination.
@silverXnoise16 күн бұрын
That much personal wealth is immoral.
@spankyssurprise136116 күн бұрын
Why?
@KevinThomas-ok2ev16 күн бұрын
According to whom? Where does this moral authority derive from to begin with?
@scifirealism594316 күн бұрын
Yes.
@jpe116 күн бұрын
I don’t know if “immoral” is the best term… I think the individual wealth of billionaires is better described as “harmful to society” rather than “immoral.” Morality is subjective and difficult to define precisely, but the harms of excessive concentration of wealth is easily demonstrated, while the benefits to society are elusive, so one is on much more solid ground arguing to redistribute wealth to reduce the harm to society, rather than arguing to do it to be morally correct.
@matthuck37816 күн бұрын
We have a minimum wage, we should have a maximum wage.
@KevinThomas-ok2ev16 күн бұрын
Where does it authorize this in the constitution?
@matthuck37816 күн бұрын
@@KevinThomas-ok2ev Please. 99.9% of all US law isn't explicitly IN the constitution. Where are semi-autos and cartridge ammo in the 2nd amendment? Wanna be literal? OK. Then only melee weapons and muzzle loaders are protected by 2e.
@scifirealism594316 күн бұрын
@@matthuck378exactly.
@scifirealism594316 күн бұрын
@@KevinThomas-ok2evit can be in the constitution.
@KevinThomas-ok2ev16 күн бұрын
@@scifirealism5943 Not without the constitution being amended, and we have a process for that. Good luck in getting it passed. It’d be an idiotic change, to impose either a minimum OR a maximum wage.
@nickc907016 күн бұрын
Love the video concept. I wish some examples had a few more details to drive the points home better
@insidejazzguitar811216 күн бұрын
Bravo! One of Robert’s best and clearest videos
@KingOfErehwon16 күн бұрын
Robert, I have a couple books of yours and agree with you on everything I have seen you write and on your videos -- except this one nitpicky point: You suggest that if capitalism was working, we wouldn't have billionaires. But even Adam Smith in his Wealth of Nations admitted that unregulated capitalism leads to wealth inequality. His only recommendation was that societies consider a wealth tax to mitigate it, while admitting he had no solution for it. He was admitting that this was a fundamental flaw of capitalism itself! It certainly isn't something that libertarians will admit, since, as Maclean pointed out in her book, Democracy in Chains, the very intent of libertarianism itself was to provide an intellectual justification for maintaining the wealth inequality that benefits the privileged. But you are right on all else: Billionaires shouldn't exist and your own suggestions for eliminating them are important. Thank you for bringing this, and so many other wrongs in our system, public.
@justinwilliams348316 күн бұрын
Billionaires should not exist. You dont need a billion or more to be happy. That money should be taxed and used for the common good
@KevinThomas-ok2ev16 күн бұрын
From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs?
@scifirealism594316 күн бұрын
Not even $100 million.
@power2me116 күн бұрын
Communism is a tempting philosophy for losers.
@astronautical108216 күн бұрын
@@KevinThomas-ok2ev No, its a matter of maintaining the implicit social contract which holds society together. Greed and greedy people share much in common with pathogens.
@misterfunnybones16 күн бұрын
"Billionaires are a policy choice." - Anand Giridharadas
@stevebrien104116 күн бұрын
Sometimes first to a business model like Amazon or Facebook or Tesla
@OscarHernandez-xx2je16 күн бұрын
No. Next question
@Shawn-gr5ww16 күн бұрын
You are literally watching a video about someone who is in the 1% complaining that there are people richer than him.
@justinwilliams348316 күн бұрын
@@Shawn-gr5wwnope try again
@mbjasniewski16 күн бұрын
@@Shawn-gr5ww Slimy corporate troll-bags attack the messenger when they can't attack the message. Like MAGA...
@Shawn-gr5ww16 күн бұрын
@@justinwilliams3483 “Why do some people have money when I don’t. It’s not fair, they should give that money to me.” And you guys say billionaires are evil, you literally support state sponsored theft.
@85201Jz12 күн бұрын
Millions of Americans who dont have a pot to piss in vote for (R) who will make things even worse for them. Dumber than dumb.
@JamesOliverHenry15 күн бұрын
Most rich people stay rich by spending like the poor and investing without stopping then most poor people stay poor by spending like the rich yet not investing like the rich but impressing them
@KristinSGresley15 күн бұрын
People prefer to spend money on liabilities, Rather than investing in assets and be very profitable
@DaveMckman15 күн бұрын
You are so correct! Save, invest and spend for necessities and a few small luxuries relatives to one's total assets ratio.
@metyismu15 күн бұрын
Hello how do you make such monthly ?? I'm a born Christian and sometimes I feel so down 🤦 of myself because of low finance but I still believe in God.
@ohiodrifter15 күн бұрын
After I raised up to 325k trading with her l bought a new House and a car here in the states 🇺🇸 🇺🇸 also paid for my son's surgery (Andy). Glory to God.shalom.
@BExup-yj6us15 күн бұрын
Hallelujah God is still working wonders, l place myself in position for such a miracle.The best thing I've seen today on KZfaq thanks a lot..
@ozziepilot289916 күн бұрын
Well said !!
@ronkirk509916 күн бұрын
I've been reading 'The Spirit Level' by Wilkinson and Pickett about how the extreme income inequality (second only to the U.K.) in the U.S. makes us a very sick society by nearly every measure. What good is it to be a 'rich' society when the way we divide this wealth makes us a sick society?
@Nemesisnxt16 күн бұрын
Does Robert really need $4M, or can he survive on a measly $900k?
@user-rk7it2dw8t16 күн бұрын
Cheap houses in California now cost a million. I can drive through a whole neighborhood that you'd call middle class in my city and every single house is either close to a million or over. In some states that's nothing. We're talking about the extremely wealthy who have taken their wealth by hurting their workers destroying the Earth.
@Nemesisnxt16 күн бұрын
$4M is top 2% in the country. Is robert really better than 98% of the American population? Should we not redistribute that down to lift the other 98% up?
@KevinThomas-ok2ev16 күн бұрын
@@user-rk7it2dw8t You need to choose better heroes.
@flfb16 күн бұрын
Four minutes and thirty-eight seconds is a long time to say "no".
@lmacdonald128116 күн бұрын
Tax advantages in the tax code go well beyond inherited weath. Also privilege built in for certain classes of individual perpetuate wealth.
@j.c.maxena535216 күн бұрын
Thank you! This was a much-needed discussion on why it is so difficult for regular folks to survive. It explains the connections between our political-economic landscape and why capitalism has failed.
@meeraj-477416 күн бұрын
You think govt money printing has anything to do with it?
@viveksmom16 күн бұрын
The estate tax should be a no brainer for everyone. No one deserves an inheritance and it is a just and straightforward way to fund reparations as well as the general ledger.
@spankyssurprise136116 күн бұрын
So someone who has worked their entire life shouldn't be able to pass that along to family or whomever they choose? So just take their money when they die?
@kittywalker294416 күн бұрын
Of course billionaires have a right to exist. Some people just can’t help making piles of money. What would be great would be them paying their fair share of taxes, as well as being outrageously charitable to the needy. That just keeps things in balance. 🇺🇸💙
@edpatterson378916 күн бұрын
Absolutely true!!
@player62716 күн бұрын
The federal government did not bailout J.P. Morgan. As with many recipients, the bank did not want or need the TARP funds it received. In fact, in March, 2008, it was permitted to buy Bear Stearns, a bank that was in trouble. Regulators don't let banks that are in trouble buy banks that are also in trouble. J.P. Morgan paid its TARP loans back early, with interest, resulting in a profit to the government (and the taxpayers) of $795 million.
@timothybarrett900516 күн бұрын
Nope...you hit a billion dollars and you have 30 days to decide: your money or your life...reset the balance for the good of free market capitalism!
@bkbland162616 күн бұрын
The existence of billionaires endangers us all
@user-mk1us4wd9q3 күн бұрын
We need to hire Top financial experts from the Best universities. Big industry pays these people $millions of dollars to start. We need to hire 100 or so of these very smart ppl and pay them millions and bonuses on the money recovered.
@samsondavid359516 күн бұрын
Absolutely not
@charliegordon-qh2ll16 күн бұрын
Yes. The answer is yes.
@Nemesisnxt16 күн бұрын
Yes, they should exist.
@jeffs985015 күн бұрын
Only temporarily. Taxes should be high & especially estate taxes.
@donnygrande366216 күн бұрын
Excellent think-piece Mr.Reich !! So true , they Can live with Less money , They still earn more in One Day than most of Us Shall See in a Lifetime On this Planet🌏... One Hopes they are Thankful + have thought + Care for the weak + Lower Classes in Society .... Thank You for Your Work Sir !! 🕊️🇺🇸💖🕊️ 🕊️🇨🇦🕊️ 🕊️🌏💖🕊️
@catherinekasmer990516 күн бұрын
We need a way to get the money back. They stole it from US.
@Qoordheere7716 күн бұрын
You failed to become billionaire and you started talking about billionaire's 24/7
@markmyjak773916 күн бұрын
Please define a fair share.
@jpe116 күн бұрын
A starting point for defining “fair share” would be to acknowledge that there will always be a “richest person” (or a small group of similarly very wealthy people), and there will always be a set of “poorest people” who have essentially nothing, and with that knowledge, we can devise a progressive tax system with the goal of redistributing wealth from the top, back down through the rest of the population such that the top 0.1% have no individual net worth that is more than 5,000 times the median net worth. (In practical terms, this would allow for a handful of billionaires, but not many, and should result in zero multi-billionaires) I don’t see how allowing for individuals to have *more than* _five thousand times_ more than the median person would be _more_ fair than what I’m suggesting, so I think my proposal is a reasonable first attempt at defining a “fair share” as no more than five thousand times the average share.
@donaldsmith141511 күн бұрын
It was originally said that monopolies were not supposed to exist in the United States because it denied free enterprise!!!!!!!!
@RusShiro16 күн бұрын
I feel like Oprah may be the only one that "earned" it. But I'm ignorant.
@KevinThomas-ok2ev16 күн бұрын
J.K. Rowling? Or is she being cancelled now?
@5353Jumper16 күн бұрын
@@KevinThomas-ok2ev both. She wrote great books and got adequately paid for starting a franchise. And she is a bigot.
@KevinThomas-ok2ev16 күн бұрын
@@5353Jumper And who is the arbiter of whether or not she’s a bigot? Because she doesn’t agree with the fascist Newspeak that the current crop has agreed upon? She’s entitled to her opinion AND her money, the vast majority of which she’s donated away.
@RusShiro16 күн бұрын
@@KevinThomas-ok2ev yep she did it honest i guess.
@piku563716 күн бұрын
Manitoban🏴☭🇨🇦here and nope.
@Shawn-gr5ww16 күн бұрын
Good thing the opinions of communists don’t matter.
@nicklang767016 күн бұрын
I am from Canada, I say Billionaires should not exist.
@dr.debbiewilliams42639 күн бұрын
I don't relate with that,since it's not my personal experience. The "Tax The Rich" dress cost more than I made in 2022, and was about four times my salary in 2023, yet I am still not a sex worker.
@user-ql4zu1ph3f12 күн бұрын
No limit, Comrade.
@ittaiklein854116 күн бұрын
One of The greatest problems in the USA is that too many speak in admiration of the rich for the sole reason that they are rich. Many even so much as vote that person to be president of their country even though he has no merit whatsoever - just riches (much of it unfairly gained).
@bryanwebb903616 күн бұрын
I think that billionaires may have a _right_ to exist but only if achieved fully legally, ethically, AND morally. However, billionaires still have the responsibility to support our government and society at least as much as the rest of us, proportional to sources of income and wealth.
@nadominhoca12 күн бұрын
"ethically, AND morally"... this might be one of the most idiotic ideas I've seen in a long time... Just tell me, who defines what is ethical and moral?
@erwinb341216 күн бұрын
Extreme wealth ends up in extreme power . That is undemocratical . Because in a balanced democracy there is , or should be , a counter-power for every power . And there is no counter-power to extreme wealth . The result is then always , sooner or later , abuse of power . Unchallenged power (without counter-power) corrupts .