It's occurred to me that my wording of 'getting away with murder' here criminalises Sebastian in a way that I didn't intend. Whilst the cutscene deliberately stages it so that Sebastian didn't NEED to kill Solomon in that moment, the term 'murder' may not be the most appropriate here, given the fact that this was during two-sided combat. The intent of this video is not to pass any judgement on Sebastian either way (I personally chose not to turn him in though). Rather, this is just exploring what happened around the events of Solomon's demise, which prevented other characters from asking further questions, and explained why he was no longer alive. I may do a future video exploring the morality of Sebastian's decision, since there's evidently a much wider debate to be had there, but this video is not it. It's merely designed to explore and inform. Thanks! Edit: Also just found Solomon's grave. It's shadowed by the fence and log pile to the right of the front door of the Sallow Residence. The soil looks fresh and there are some flowers growing on it. Anyway, I shouldn't imagine anyone would be suspicious over his burial regardless, as by the sounds of it there's no question that he didn't die in his sleep.

i go around killing a bunch of people all of the time, and no one bats an eye. Sebastian kills his uncle ONCE and suddenly they want to send my boy to azkaban? not on my watch

There's a fresh dug grave right next to the Sallow family house. I found it when I returned there to loot the house... err, I mean check on Anne.

I don't understand how Obliviate isn't an unforgivable curse, it literally takes away your memories and therefore who you are

The thing for me is, my character is in Hufflepuff, and therefore actually went to Azkaban and saw what happens to those who are sent there. Seeing an innocent person suffer at the hands of dementors and completely lose herself, I decided my character could not bear the thought of Sebastian suffering the same fate, and therefore decided not to turn him in.

I'm sorry, but the night at the Restricted Section when Sebastian took the fall for MC was the very moment I decided I would die/kill for him.

Plot twist: When Solomon takes the relic and touches it with his wand, from that point on, NOT ONE of the infiri attack him, they only attack the mc and Sebastian. (If you take that at face value, like you do the "pause" between the actual fight and the killing curse, then Solomon was using the infiri to attack us) Story wise, I wouldn't say it's "murder", more self defense, from the second Solomon starts attacking you and Sebastian, he is out to kill you, he isnt using spells to stop you (it's not like he couldn't use a non lethal spell to stop us in our tracks), nor does he listen to reason when the MC and Sebastian try to talk to him several times during the fight. The only part that IS bad, is the end of the fight/beginning of the cut scene, where, idk if its for story reasons or editing reasons, Solomon is "stopped" and Sebastian uses the killing curse. Had there not been that "pause" It would have been 100% self defense. Sure, using the killing curse is bad, but Seb was under attack by a superior wizard, an auror no less and he only has limited knowledge compared to his uncle, he acted in a moment of instinct and self preservation.

I couldn't turn him even on an evil playthru... the guy's like... 15...16 at most and if you turn him in, you're literally giving him a life-sentence to azkaban. it's too much-

It would be interesting if the sequel is Sebastian trying to harvest our ancient magic in order to save Anne, since we never agreed to help him do it.

So not turning Sebastian in is canon.

I was quite surprised at the "end" of his storyline because it didn't seem finished yet. Ominis said "whatever comes next, we must face it together". If I remember correctly, Sebastian also said something about meeting again (I didn't turn him in) and then... nothing happened. That was it. So there will most likely be DLC or even a whole sequal to this. The fact that this is only the fifth year and they kept stressing our character being a fifth year throughout the whole game makes me think that they might even turn this into a trilogy, otherwise they could have made MC a seventh year. Such story telling decisions usually aren't made arbitrarily. And there are still so many unanswered questions that would really be... ambitious to tackle in a shorter DLC. What happens with Anne, especially now that we know who cursed her? What about Ominis' friendship with Sebastian, will he pick a side between Anne and Seb or find a different way? What about our MC's ancient magic powers? The story ended with us still barely understanding what we could do with it and where it came from (MC even told Sebastian that they still don't understand how it works after they finished the triptych and knew what Isidora was doing). I'd be really surprised and kind of disappointed if they just left it at that.

MC *kills 100's with the unforgivable curses* okay Sebastian *kills his uncle in a moment of rage* Not okay

Sebastian is still 100% loyal to you even if you choose to betray him as he could’ve easily turned you in to the Ministry of Magic as well for using the three Unforgivable Curses.

so much more interesting than our main storyline lol

I feel like the cutscene taking place after the boss battle makes it appear more uncalled for, but if you consider that perhaps the cutcene was in the midst of the battle canonically, it would definitely come across more as a spur of the moment decision on Sebastian’s part, making it appear more like self defence. And like, even though he claims to have done the right thing, he seems genuinely remorseful about it still. He actually seems to have a hopeful looking future if you don't turn him in.

There IS a grave behind the Sallow house.

I believe Sebastian's story is complicated. Solomon was horrible. He didn't want Sebastian to even bring fruits or whatever to keep his sister happy. He, for some reason, banished Sebastian for saving Anne (Imperio). His madness is what caused Sebastian to get crazier, and try to dive into the Dark Arts. However, killing his uncle, I believe, was too far.

just my two cents but Solomon has no redeeming quality and I don’t pity him once. That guy was just pure bitterness. He was bitter to not only Sebastian but also his parents. And his adamant refusal for Anne being able to cured is extreme behavior. Makes me kinda think like he knew something about Anne’s curse and unilaterally decided if St. Mungo couldn’t cure her then so shall be it. anw, please let it be a DLC about the Slytherin trio 🙏

Question: wasn't there something regarding using the relic and an ultimate sacrifice? I knew going in to that catacomb that someone ended up dead but wasn't sure who, and I assumed Sebastian would kill someone as a sacrifice to the relic in order to save Ann. If a sacrifice really was needed, that fact was completely forgotten by the game plot and adds another layer to this conversation because Sebastian seems immediately stunned that he killed his uncle, and if a sacrifice to the relic *was* needed and he knew that...*who* was he planning on that sacrifice being, if not his uncle? 🤔

What annoys me is that it could’ve been avoided had Solomon made more effort. You’re trying to tell us that an adult, let alone an ex-auror, couldn’t find any solution to keep a 15 year old away from dark magic ? Sure, maybe talking and reasoning didn’t work since they’re both stubborn. But Like, I dunno, take away his wand ? Alert someone about the book? Get more supervision at Hogwarts? Therapy? Ask him to leave Feldcroft and stay by Anne’s side for the remaining time they have instead of doing it behind his back ? Because pushing him away and chasing him out of his own home sure didn’t help, it made things worse. I still don’t understand why Sebastian would react differently depending on who tells him about Rockwood. It sure is a way of telling us what’s canon and what’s not but whatever the decision I don’t think Sebastian can avoid what’s coming to him either way. Once he’ll realise he’s completely alone, maybe that’ll push him to redeem himself.

I love reading comments and logic people use to argue Sebastian’s fate. Like seriously if the developers don’t give us some kind of quest where the MC gets to argue his case either for or against in a ministry court, it’s a big missed opportunity.

For me personally, this choice would be hard to make if the MC had at least some character and awareness. When it comes to Hogwarts Legacy the main part that makes me somewhat mad is that our MC does not have any personality at all. They do not reflect or question their actions in any possible way. If they do something questionable or evil, they do not get any negative feedback on it even from their professors (come on…). I remember similar choice in life is strange game, I think in Seb’s quest the devs tried to make logically same morality choice. However, the LiS choice hit me hard, since my character had personality, showed attachment to her friend and was at least somehow aware of the consequences of what she did with the power she got. In Hogwarts Legacy we, in fact, have a somewhat psychopathic MC that goes killing (by game logic that make our rivals vanish after we defeat them) poachers and dark wizards (=people), goblins, etc here and there. and ALL the thoughts that they produce is something “oh my, no one to share my victory with”. seconds earlier: possibly uses all unforgivable curses at once on one person and just continues living. Why should i turn in some boy but still can’t send the MC to Azkaban by that logic if we are talking about ✨morality✨ in general? And remember, this is our character who in fact “defeats” Solomon boss (which by game logic should be finally meant as killed) so all this thing with Avada casted by Seb doesn’t make much sense to me. And due to that the final choice of turning in or not doesn’t make the sense that the devs tried to imply, too. *sorry, I am just so disappointed in what the storyline and character part turns out in this game, I can’t…

All the witnesses like Sebastian more than they liked Solomon. Plus that village is under constant attacks by dark wizards and goblins because of Isadora. No one is gonna bat an eye at Solomon's death.

The game made the player complicit in a murder. We are all Dark wizards.

Who’s to say that you didn’t in fact kill Solomon Sallow? After your fight with Solomon, he’s seen slowly staggering about holding his guts in with his arm, perhaps mortally wounded. All Sebastian does then is deliver a final blow to an already dying man. In this instance Sebastian would merely be an accomplice to a homicide that was actually committed by you.

I'm lamenting that we didn't have option to tell Seb/Anne/Solomon about Muggle medicine. Up until 15-16 year MC lived as a Squib/Muggle, so they knew about it more than wizardkind and could just bring up this idea. Maybe Anne's curse was no curse at all? Maybe it's just a bad internal trauma that magic couldn't properly heal. Rookwood didn't curse us when he tried to kill us, y'know There's so many missed opportunities and I have a lot of questions to Seb's questline. I wish there were choices that would allow us to have a better ending than the one we got. Like, during the attack on Fieldcroft we could just Depulso that goblin into oblivion before Seb could use Imperio on him. Yes, I just want everyone to be alive and slap some sense into Seb without needing to sacrifice someone to make him see the wrongs of the path he walks😒

I felt in that end fight that Solomon was hiding something and out to maim Sebastian to the fullest. I actually thought in the midst of the battle that Solomon was actually one of Ranrock’s followers. This seemed to make more sense of his anger at Sebastian. And Sebastian was fighting for his life against his uncle…totally self defense.

Seems more like Murder isn't really the right description for the actions here. If he killed his uncle out of desperate defense of the means of her restoration then that would be look smacking someone with a fire poker when they go to smash a vile or rare medicine that would be irreplaceable before someone died... one assumes he's on the clock here and also has only the one dark arts book so threatening that is like taking away someone medicine knowing they'd be unable to get another dose so the murders (from a certain point of view) is the Uncle not the Nephew. Also knowing what I do about abusive relationships it looks like the Uncle is in some ways or other not a nice guardian. As the feeling and claims of loving the abuser is a common troupe in abusive relationships, as is blaming the one who "failed to protect them" so her resentment and even Sebastian's actions may well be hinged entirely on a subtext the game isn't owning up too for fear of triggering some unpleasantness in it's audience. I would wonder though, what happens if you partially engage with him or never speak to him at all except if forced too by the plot. does he still show up at the end or is he removed ? I would suggest it might have been fun to set a trap for the Uncle so he's encapsulated some how and prevented from interfering and Sebastian's actions are successful... that would be an interesting trick ending to have. Heck it could even be used to "convert" the Dark spells to light ones as they react to being used for good instead of evil. something like that could be a fun revision perhaps and a way to add extra content too.

There's too much evidence to support Sebastian's innocence. Every Unforgivable Curse he cast was in an act of desperation and defense. Solomon had it out for him, like somehow Solomon managed to blame Sebastian every time something bad happened to them. Sebastian was bearing the weight and responsibility of his twin's life and no one helped. Healers said no, his Uncle said no, the Ministry said no, and the Professors are too busy to see the pain, stress, and fear he's crumbling under but they were quick to stack up detentions if he tumbled out of line. Should he have killed Solomon? No. But he was under duress, his twin was dying he was losing 1, possibly 2, best friend(s), and his Uncle was assaulting him and his friend, along side the inferi. Obviously the killing curse being his knee jerk reaction to a state of intense duress doesn't look good but it's likely a fresh spell that he likely learned an hour ago.

I mean his Uncle did try to harm- if not k!||- his nephew and his friend (us as the MC) severely. 🤷‍♀️

Jokes on you ive murdered 1000000 poachers and im fine

He is both a desperate boy at the end of his tether and someone who is interested, unhealthily, in the Dark Arts. But I think he craves that power because horrible things have happened in his life that he couldn't control and that deeply affects him (Anne's curse & parent's deaths). Add to that a very strained relationship with an uncle that never bothered to connect with him or teach him in an effective way, and you get this tragic mess. Whilst Solomon didn't deserve to be murdered - and has good intentions - he could have approached all of this a lot better too.

Yes!!! This video literally explains everything I’ve been thinking. For those who turned Sebastian in, there’s NOTHING stating that Ominis brought up the use of an unforgivable. Hence why I think Sebastian would return either way. All he has to claim is that his Uncle tried to kill him when he was trying to help his sister Anne. If he plays his cards right, he’ll return to Hogwarts! All of these people are saying they sent him to Azkaban, but I distinctly remembered that Ominid said he was facing trial at the ministry… NOT that he was going to Azkaban.

The unforgivable curses are very useful. The imperial curse is great when you are fighting more then one enemy you can use that smell on one enemy to help you fight. The avada kadavra curse is good for the hard to beat enemies like trolls or if you bump into a enemies that is a bit higher level then you.

I didn’t turn him in. In order to understand darkness we must research it. And Sebastian’s uncle kept thwarting his attempt to try and help his sister. Would I prefer him not to kill his uncle especially with the curse? Mostly yes. Was it justified a little? Yes.

Actually what Sebastian did to his uncle was NOT murder. Murder is killing an innocent human being, but his uncle destroyed the relic, making a whole bunch of Inferi attack you and then attacked you at the same time. He was trying to kill both of you, Sebastian acted on self-defense.

I’m Sebastian’s defence, we as the MC have bombarda-d multiple humans, goblins, spiders, trolls and some even cats and no one batted and eye. If he has to be sent to Azkaban for his uncle’s death, I guess we have to book a whole week for dates with Dementors full of kisses 🥸

Couldn't turn him in. Hufflepuff playthrough... He's a friend and that demands loyalty! Plus, I've SEEN Azkaban. Seen what happens to someone who's been there since she was Sebastian's age until she was an old lady, tormented for decades. It's not a prison you send people to. It's actually Hell. Eternal suffering... Couldn't do that to my buddy. Though Anne's note to him was terribly sad...

I must admit...I was against dark arts at first..until I used the first of the three unforgivable curses. I just felt..invincible. I felt power..well maybe it's just because I was so just immersed.😅

Thanks for highlighting these dialogs and letting me hope that we’ll be able to see Sebastian return in the almost-certain-sequel ! Sebastian being quite the charming and well spoken boy I want to hope he’ll manage the trial if turned in. Also do you condemn a kid to a miserable life of full despair and suffering in Azkaban for what could be seen as a duel that went (awfully) wrong ? I want him so bad to come back, learn about his mistakes and be a romance option on year 7 when all characters can be of age !

I didn't turn him in, but I also didn't learn AK until after the main quest line ended for role play reasons. idk Solomon did show up and just start hexing BOTH teenagers-even though the Player Character was clearly not involved with Sebastian's shenanigans, The fact it gets covered up and ends up the same is a bit wtf.

The vilain ending is to turn in Sebastian & keep the ancient magie for ourself.

Though I cannot abide what Sebastion did myself, I sympathize with him, and I believe he was just trying his best to help his sister when everyone else gave up. I can't fault him for any of what he did.

I feel sorry for Sebastian. I really dislike his uncle, but Sebastian would have needed someone to save him from himself. His obsession with saving his sister ist understandable but definitely took him off the deep end. And his uncle acting against him and giving up on his niece definitely made it worse. We don't get the full picture but he seems to dislike his nephew even before Sebastian dabbles into the dark arts. Wish there had been a dialogue option to influence him unto another path. I really liked him before he got obsessive.

If you look at the back of the house where Soloman and Anne lived, there's a grave there. From what I recall, it doesn't say whose it is but I'm not sure if it was there before Soloman died.

This is why MC couldn't use Ancient Magic to cure Anne: It is heavily implied that not only does Isidora take away their pain, but ALL of their emotion which is the consequence of using that type of magic. If MC did the same thing to Anne, inevitably she would lack all emotion and just be a shell of herself which is worse than the Anne who is cursed. That is why the keepers stopped Isidora and why the trials, especially the third, implicate that the light and dark balance each other and just because you can get rid of the darkness doesn't mean you should.

Sebastian did the things he did with the best intentions. But as a wise man once said. "Some of the worst things imaginable have been done with the best intentions." I wouldn't be surprised if he would become the main antagonist of the serie.

I love how it is turned into this huge debate on the internet..bottom line is it is everyone's own decision, being hypocritical or not. With that I think it is important, why the whole storyline is included in the game in the first place. It is to show a very similar route that Isidora takes. Both Seb and Isidora started of as passionate people, trying to do anything for the people they most cared about (whith those people practically being their only family members). They both saw their means justifying their actions, eventhough both were told not to do that by a senior person of authority (their master or uncle), and they both went against this. And when they were tried to being stopped, they both attacked these people. Now, based on each player, the story told through Sebastian is supposed to tie you closer to or push you further away from Isidora, leading you towards either one of the endings - basically the only decision that has some effect on the story. So how they decide with Sebastian is everyones own decision, and I think should be respected as such. I turned Sebastian in, one because I played as a good character, and as such I always tried to be supportive of him, as a friend - but this was where I drew the line. For one, Ominis did make us promise multiple times that we stop, and Seb promised each time, just to ask for our help right after that. Also while Seb is a charming character, and is not inheritently "evil", he still did and said some things that made me raise my eyebrows. In the beginning when we were visiting the restricted section of the library, he said something along the likes of liking when his friends are in debt of a favour to him. Also I felt he was very manipulating, and if you didn't support him, he would come with the "please do it, if not for me, then for Anne" while Anne clearly knew she could not be helped, and I think even told Seb to let it go. Also does it help Anne that Sebastian killed his caretaker? I also found it weird how Sebastian also "happened to know" the unforgivable curse that was needed - which he taught himself alone. While I did learn Crucio and Imperio, I never used them in the game, and even I would not have betrayed Sebastian if he avada kevadrad a poacher, a troll, a goblin, whatever. But a family member? I felt while I did not like Solomon, Avada Kevadraing him was not called for. And if he did that to his family member at 15-16 years old, how would that not happen in the future? I still felt like shit betraying him, but it seemed like the right thing to do. Also true, he showed some remorse, but that doesn't mean he would not do it again - just as he never kept his promise to Ominis to stop with dark magic..who is supposedly his closest friend. Also I would like to state this again, this was just my opinion (I also have had my personal share of manipulave people, and in my experience "once a manipulator always a manipulator", so I probably wasn't as forgiving..)

Where do you get that white robe in 5:20

Theory here but ominis gaunt has always said he is not scared to use his family ties so maybe he is the one keeping it hush cause he would still care for Anne if not sebastian.

Sebastian did NOTHING wrong. His Uncle deserved years of Crucio, not the quick and easy route. His Uncle practically destroyed every single idea and chance for Sebastian to attempt to help Anne. He was relentless to the point of even attacking us to stop Sebastian. I actually expected to find out the uncle himself was involved in her curse, that's how much I hated him. Believe me, if Sebastian hadn't killed him we would have. His uncle was a piece of shit, and got exactly what he deserved.

3:21 right next to Sebastian and Anne's house is a grave after the mission.

actually popular misconception about the scar is that it was left by the rebounding killing curse but in truth it was from Voldemort's soul fragment latching itself onto him.

Anyone think Sebastian’s story is similar to anakins one in revenge of the sith the music here 1:05 even reminds me of the song anakins dark deeds

So, I was originally going to turn him in, but I thought about what ominous had said so I ended up letting him off the hook, but I do not know if ominous nor I will have as much trust for him in the future, as much as I love Sebastian in my current gameplay I am doing what I would actually do at hogwarts.

What really adds to his desperation for me is that they've already lost both their parents and Anne isn't just his sister, she's his twin. We all know twins are close and on top of that her being his last family member (let's be real, Solomon doesn't treat him as family, at all) makes it just so much more understandable. I want to save Anne *for* him 😢

it’s like a reincarnation of isadora. she was trying to do the exact same thing but with her father. now sebastian doing the same thing to try to save his sister. lol weird way to take it as, but that’s how i think of it lolol

Perhaps that’s actually true, honestly I didn’t expect you to bring up Hot Fuzz

Sebastian was the best story by far and easily the hardest to weave into the story going forward, going to be interesting to see how they do it.

Then to story arch would be like Dumbledore Greenwalt situation. Close friend turned enemy.

I think people "forget" that he is a teenager...teenagers brain are not developed,no impulse control and I feel like Solomon was abusive to Sebastian. He yells at him about shrivel fruit , destroys it and then uses his dead dad against Sebastian. I don't really like Anne, I know she is in pain but she doesn't seem to have any courage whatsoever. She is very whiny and very judgey. I think Azkaban is wrong for a teenager.

I will always stand by my boy Sebastian.

The uncles reactions towards the attempts of healing Ann need more of an explanation than a fear of dark arts. And the game does not go into other healing magic or arts.

Ok I thought I was the only one that wanted to cover up for Sebastian! That’s my brother! ✊🏾✊🏾

Gryffindor using unforgettable curses? Wormtail senior even the looks

His uncle convinced a weakened Ann that she could not be cured, Seb had to search for him self. Not only did his uncle not support him but actively worked against him and being unreasonable angry at him. Don't forget, Seb is still a teenage boy. It's not weird that Seb becomes a bit of an unguided projectile, making wrong choices in desperation. Then his uncle, instead of letting him rage and cast a few spells he goes full berserk against Seb and you (while you were innocent). That uncle did everything he could to drive Seb mad, psychological abusing/mistreating him, physically attacking the mc (actively bringing mc in life threatening danger with the inferno's around) and therefore makes the minor aged Seb not guilty.

2:12 ""Has somebody done a Hermione's parents"" LOLOLOLOL

There’s so many little hints about how you would be a great Auror I hope that’s where the next game is leading.

I wonder if Anne and Sebastian met after, and Sebastian used the artifact to cure her. She realized their uncle was wrong, not necessarily at fault or evil, and forgives Sebastian. She then tells Sebastian to leave and devises a lie to cover up the death.

When Sebastian says "Oh Anne, what have you done?!" I feel he's talking to Anne, but himself as well after what he just did.

I would love to see Sebastian but evil after just escaping azkaban! We then have to fight our ex-friend with ominus and try to make him realise what hes done!

There is a grave next to the Sallows house, it’s to the right

There is a tomb right next to her house

Anne's letter there is absolutely amazing, honestly, she really handled this in the best way!

i always thought that the uncle was in league with rookwood

Tbh he could have used a different curse, but it was self defence I tried doing it myself but it wouldn't work.

She burriee hime next to their house. U can see the gravestone there after he dies (some time later)

What would be a cool dlc is visiting him in askaban or in a future game he becomes a dark wizard and main villain

personally feel soloman's death could have been avoided if he just talked to sebastion even in the fight itself he doesn't even try to talk

I actually want the second game to just be a continuation of what happens next and the main character’s story can be the B story

I personally identify a lot with Sebastian because I too would go to the darkest darks to uncurse my sister if I was him.

With the dlc you visit Azkaban to break him out or his sister took the blame you and Sebastian have to break her out.

The Devs HAD to find a way to introduce the unforgivable curses into the game, and they used Sebastian Sallow to do it. Im sure I was not the only one to get some Star Wars Episode 2-3 Anakin/Darth Vader vibes off of Sebastian during the game. Almost every quest with Him, He became more unhinged, and the words "I have to save Padme, er I mean Anne, yeah Anne, thats what I meant to say." Were in every quest with Him after a certain point. Even knowing this part of me wanted to turn Him in, but I didn't. I mean the part where you choose is coming up next and I am not going to. But this is one of those choices where either way, there are arguments for deciding the other way. I love imperio, its fun and strategic, and of course the killing curse is OP with talent buffs so yeah. But I have not yet used crucio in spite of learning it, and I do not plan on using it because it is not strategic or OP like imperio or the killing curse. In fact I would have my doubts about the sanity of anyone who said crucio was their favorite spell. Personally I think Bombarda buffed with lvlIII traits is my favorite spell. l)J

I can’t both want him to go down the dark arts path and then turn him in for wanting to do what we both want him to do. He was an eager participant and boy did I find those curses fun. Would be rude to turn him in when he actually regrets his actions and I’m a murder hobo.

Was it just me who did everything to support Sebastian right until the very end? Like I turned him in after the murder... Mental storyline

As a Slytherin, I was "Ride or Die" for Sebastien and Ominis. We crossed the point of no return when we entered Salazar Slytherin's private chambers. I was not going to punk out on Sebastien because he took so much heat and got his hands dirty. He really believed he could cure Anne and Solomon squashed every hope simply because the old man was complacent and didn't want his way of life to change.

I have already played this game three times and never passed Sebastian, not only because he is my favorite character, despite the fact that I have never been a fan of the Harry Potter universe. I'll tell you my thoughts. Even before the start of the game, life had already battered Sebastian: he lost his parents at an early age, presumably, relations with his uncle were not going well even before Ann's curse, he mentioned that his uncle claims that he never cared about them, even though during the battle with Solomon, uncle himself says that he and Sebastian also cares. When Sebastian's sister was cursed, the boy clearly wanted to help her, but did not know how, even more gnawing is the fact that no one gave him emotional support from the family. The lack of support drives Sebastian to despair. And it's his desperation that makes him even more immersed in Dark Magic. I think my character (MС) would not want such a life for Sebastian, who lost everything and drowned himself even more in grief and guilt in Azkaban. His possible catharsis is yet to come.

Speaking of hot fuzz the star of that movie voiced

What you mean ? Sebastian is a good lad teached me good spells. That spell got my attention XD.😆Those who turn in sebastian, they are snitch. Ezy

Solomon's death could have been covered up in numerous ways. He died in his sleep, or he was ambushed by a dark wizard. The latter is entirely believable given all of the activity in the area. It's also not 100% untrue.

Obliviate should ld be an unforgivable curse because for something to be a unforgivable curse it must A. Kill or torture something and cannot be undon and B. Messes with your free will hence imperio witch obliviate messes with gour free will

Okay but hear me out. What if the book was a horcrox and coerced sebastian into killing his uncle. Even though anne destroys it, if you go back and check the catacombs after these events, the book still sits there, in tact

What really makes me wonder is how the developers are going to handle that situation in the next game? Because it's really hard to integrate theses vastly different storybranches and develop a NPC around that. From what I'm seeing, they have three choices : reduce Seb's role drastically to one optional side quest if you don't turn him in (doubt that considering he is the best character), ignore our choices and pick the one that fits them best, or converge the timelines

I actually have a headcanon that his uncle locked up Seb and Anne’s parents in their library cellar where they died of CO poisoning. I don’t know why they couldn’t open the door to their own cellar. Plus it’s canon that Solomon hates Sebastian’s father and that’s why he hates Sebastian. This could somewhat justify him killing his uncle. (Plus his uncle also using Unforgivables while he was in Law Enforcement.) Its like he got even angrier when he got Sebastian and Anne in his custody. Solomon was an awful man. The way he spoke to Sebastian showed it too.

We NEED DLC for this Game. I want more companion Content!!

I’d also say it’s canon that Sebastian doesn’t go to jail. Even Ominis says they won’t send Sebastian to jail on a technicality of his age but at the very least they’ll punish him a bit. (Real ones won’t even let that happen though.)

his uncle used fiendfyre in that fight, which is a form of dark magic, all while being mad at his nephew for using dark magic. that man is a huge hypocrite.

Solomon didn't deserve to die, but my god was he a total ass hat, he wouldn't even entertain the possibility that anything could help Anne at all. Just "nothing can help her, i wont even investigate any possibly solutions you present" [closes book]. And that attitude pushed Sebastian so hard to get more an more reckless, and thus we reached this conclusion

I sent Sebastian to Azkaban, I never learnt an unforgivable spell and nobody seem to care how good of a wizzard I am.

I turn in Sebastian, I felt he went to far. I hope they bring more games out, as I don't want it to end