I love the idea that Ethan is one of the kids MIss Holloway helps because when he gives Hannah his hat in Black Friday he says the same thing about it and that it was "gifted to me by a great warrior".

So, Nightmare Time is called that because it's litterally Hannah's "nightmare time". It's all the different possibilities that she saw, like Uncle Wiley mentionned.... Right?

Starkid sure loves putting poor Hannah in near-death situations

I think you might be underestimating the mystery here buddy. This is pure theory fuel, we get some new concepts, we got the lords in black and two new characters (two perfect characters I love them Kim Whalen Jesus Christ). I don’t think you missed anything, I think we just don’t have all the pieces yet, especially with the part in the starlight theater. So this is my second favorite story and my favorite episode, I love your reactions so much!! I don’t have any friends that are starkid fans and my family does not enjoy their stuff, so it’s kinda like I have someone to “talk to” without them rolling their eyes with you. Thanks for that! You make life a little less lonely for me.

I screamed when wiggly popped up when I was first watching this seeing how Wiggly knew her despite this can't be the same universe as Black Friday was terrifying.

Still here waiting for season 2 reactions. 🥰

I just realized, the first thing wiggly says to hanna is the same thing the hive tells paul after not your seed

Now that season 2 of Nightmare Time is fully out on KZfaq, I am anxiously waiting your reactions to the episodes. If you thought season one was good and weird . . . I am not sure if you are even ready, haha. Plus, they teased Nerdy Prudes Must Die which will be the third installment of the Hatchetfield (staged) series. Hope to see those reactions soon (also waiting for reactions to Little White Lie . . . but no pressure, haha).

so I think what they are hinting at with wiggly and Uncle Wiley is that the black and white is outside all universes that is brought up on black Friday. So the emperors in black aka Wiggly and his brothers there are not alt-universe versions of them they all reach out from the black and white to attempt their plans. Wilbur Cross (also known as Uncle Wiley) may also only exist in the black and white and therefore every time we see him it's always the same one or every Cross serves the emperors in black and they just make sure he knows everything they need him too. As for Hannah, I can't tell if cross says she sees it all or he sees it all the captions say he but then he says her mind is vast so not sure. but that could mean she sees the things that happen in other universes or timelines. I would guess in her dreams which may mean she has seen black Friday. If not there are still a lot of things that could explain her knowing them or at least her reactions. The witch may have shown her this while tormenting poor Hannah. or Wiggley has a way of doing it. another idea is that she didn't know who they were she just knew she should be scared. though I think the best idea I have is Webby. Since Webby is very protective of Hannah it's likely that she told Hannah about her brothers. also since both Hannah and Lex are Psychic that gives them a lot of things they may be able to have. Psychic powers cover a large range of things. Also fun thing in case you didn't catch it the first time because I didn't. the first one the witch pulls out has a rock face with blue goop if that maybe reminded you of anything.

Can't wait for season 2 reaction!

rewatching this and even more excited now to see you react to nightmare time 2!! do you know when you'll be checking it out?

not sure if you’ve done it yet but can’t wait to see your reactions to the second season! a year late but followed now can’t wait to see what you think of the hatchetfield series!!!

The confusion on your face is probably pretty identical to mine when I first watched this episode LOL. It's definitely a lot to take in and to be honest I'm still a little confused. Loved to see Wiley here, he's probably my favorite Joey villain.

This one is the best yet, in my opinion.

This one is also not my favorite, but Kendall (Hanna) sure is amazing. My favorite episode is 2, because Forever and Always is the perfect amount of cute and weird and Time Bastard is one of the most amazing things they have ever created in my opinion. The only doll they haven´t shown in a story is the one with a mouth for a face, I hope it comes up soon. Great reaction as always, and yes, this was a weird one. :)

this is my favorite one. I think Hanna is amazing. i love miss hallway

My interpretation is that in universes/timelines where Black Friday-esk events are happening Uncle Whiley and Ms. Hathaway end up fighting. Half the time Uncle Whiley wins leading to events like that of Black Friday and the other half Ms. Hathaway wins leading to stories like this one. As for Hannah knowing Uncle Whiley and Wiggly, maybe she became aware of them before Ms. Hathaway successfully prevented Wiggly's plans in this timeline, or maybe Hannah's gifts give her some awareness of the other universes or her life in other universes. Either way I'm excited to see where they go from here. Especially in Hatchetfield stories Starkid have been masters of foreshadowing and leaving us begging for the next clues.

Holloway has got to be a reference to Dick Halloran. The whole psychic mentor motif and the similarity of the names and all.

These Hatchedfield stories have a lot of similarities, but none of them can happen in the same universe (except NT Ep 2 parts 1 and 2). Which means they all happen in Hatchetfield, but in parallell universes and timelines. And Time Bastard backs this up with time travelling making a parallell universe. The one thing that will connect Hannah to Uncle Wiley however is Webby. In BF Hannah talks about what Webby has told her about the black and white, and there's no indication that Webby didn't tell her the same in this episode. As mighty as Webby and Hannah are, you can't dismiss them being able to see worst case scenarioes, especially during Nightmare time where worst case scenarioes are meant to scare her. Before Nightmare Time, there was a wildly popular theory to connect TGWDLM and BF. The triggering of the parallell universes was Jane's crash, as that's the only true parallell between the shows and the meteor at the end of BF is the same as in TGWDLM, they just didn't notice it in the same way as with the musical appocalypse as Wiggly manipulated another appocalypse in it's place. Honestly, we don't know what connects the stories, and your guess is as good as mine. And to me I feel like all these stories are what happens with fanfiction; New stories in a set world who adds some new protaganists to make a parallell to the real thing.

I can't wait until season 2 comes to KZfaq in 2022 so you can react to the stories. I think you will like them, but your mind may be blown.

please do more starlight express reactions!! i texted u on ig a few months ago but ive got no respond xd i can recommed vids too!

Please react to Trail to Oregon!!!