If the Eagles may be miming - Who else? Could I have watched concerts and not realised?

Рет қаралды 3,565

Ай бұрын

In my video a couple of weeks ago I looked at some evidence suggesting the Eagles may be miming. I received some comments asking to look into whether any other big artists are miming. I looked for footage of some of the artists I've seen live to see if they may have been miming.
#eagles #donhenley #reaction

Пікірлер: 43

@russellr1677 Ай бұрын

Brilliant! Isn’t that Bill Bruford manning the throne alongside the chunkier you?

@grahamnunn8998 Ай бұрын

Robert Plant has been very good a re-arranging songs to fit his voice as he has aged.

@MikePhillips-pl6ov 3 күн бұрын

Very well said. It can be done!

@markoman5267 Ай бұрын

For a moment, I thought I was watching Gary Oldman. Excellent video, I like the playing at the end too.

@MikePhillips-pl6ov 3 күн бұрын

"It's not cool to name drop - Mick Jagger told me that" 😂

@johnsurrey7426 Ай бұрын

Re Dolly. I was listening to her set on the radio. She sang some of her classics. Then she improvised a song about people in the mud. Her voice then was totally different. I recently watched some of her Glasto set, and there are occasions when her mouth doesn’t match what’s coming over the speakers. Miming? Definitely!

@karenwalker3770 Ай бұрын

I'm GLAD you checked out Fil on his channel, Wings of Pegasus ". There's NO POSSIBILITY that a real vocal could be IDENTICAL several years apart!! As for Elton, I had noticed that he did change his range on certain parts. And during the PHENOMENAL LIVE AID concert, Freddie Mercury was having throat trouble, & his Dr. actually told him he shouldn't perform! If you listen, he has a couple notes that kind of crack a bit. The GREAT THING IS THAT ITS GENUINE!! It makes a person REAL & AUTHENTIC!! Im very grateful to have been born at such a perfect time for music!!

@Swedishchef70 15 күн бұрын

Did you ever wonder why these classic bands from the seventies and eighties are suddenly all touring! Technology cant have anything to do with it. No no way!

@tonepilot Ай бұрын

I think older singers should drop a semitone or a tone. I was playing along to a U2 track the other day and wondered why I sounded so off (other than being normally shite lol) and had to drop a semitone to get the sound right.

@user-no8ki1vx8p Ай бұрын

Great ❤❤❤

@jonchilds1637 Ай бұрын

Quite ironic really; lots of years ago, the Musician’s Union required acts to mime on TV. Fast-forward to the late 70’s and the (same) MU mounted a ‘Keep Music Live’ campaign. Now here we are, back with miming but not it’s ‘Live’ performances!!

@peterbradfield2288 Ай бұрын

Thank you for alerting us to who is miming. I have just had to watch Eurovision! I Shazamed every track and got a result in seconds. I guess that means they were all miming. Can you use your platform to expose this fraud? My bet is on Vanilly Manilly for 2025!

@werner.x Ай бұрын

Another by the way - since i'm just watching this video and my other comment basically was about the other eagles video from three weeks ago - 04:14 musicians are forced into miming since the 70s professionally, so everybody should be good at it - and these days technology should be also good enough to add just enough overdub to let some impurities in for the suspicious listener. I won't never ever trust the show biz - would be a big mistake. I'd just take the fassade as it is and enjoy the music.

@HarrisonProductions Ай бұрын

I bet that drummer Bill Bruford, if it is you lucky sod, must have been some experience playing with him

@johnsurrey7426 Ай бұрын

Who else? Dolly Parton, Madonna, Kiss, The Spice Girls (they didn’t even try to hide it), Motley Crue

@frannyp46 Ай бұрын

Artists should be forced to say what backing tracks they use at a concert just like you can read the ingredients and additives in food before you make a purchase. Vocal miming is akin to Botox in my view. David Bowie would often change keys if his voice wasn’t up to it and he always sounded good. He even pulled off headlining Glastonbury with laryngitis.

@MikePhillips-pl6ov 3 күн бұрын

Good idea. Could put the list in the programmes for sale at the venue

@sungodrah Ай бұрын

Yeah the Eagles miming considering their prices.sad ..you should check out Pat Benatar in Austin City Limits ,I think in 23'.there is a full concert the tube her vocals seem pre recorded live ..strange !

@annoyingbstard9407 Ай бұрын

I was never sure about the Archies.

@strothermartin5368 Ай бұрын

Roger Walters got caught in NY doing sheep the chant part.

@MikePhillips-pl6ov 3 күн бұрын

Roger Waters has a pre-recorded track that he sometimes sings too as he's live mic, sometimes mimes to, but I cut him some slack. Because, when you see a Waters gig, it's a Floyd-esque show as much visual as audio; he never had a great voice anyway; he and Floyd were pioneers of live rock music and live improvisation. He's done his time in live decades. Also, because it's a show in synch with multiple graphics and effects, everything has to fit the timing perfectly. This isn't four lads anymore at student unions doing live 'Ummagumma'. He also plays to a click track. But he has backing singers and other band members doing vocals. And I don't think it's any secret among Waters fans. Unlike the Eagles, who pretend to do everything live, don't have major graphics that need to be synched, etc., and did not pioneer live rock music and live improvisation! p.s. I saw Floyd play and sing The Wall live in 1981, so have seen Waters do it for real as a younger chap!

@KEITHJOHNPAUL Ай бұрын

Does it matter, fans expectations are high, they want the same sound as the record, they are on stage live, so who cares.

@EdubertoPalitroke Ай бұрын

So... The no news news report.

@irisrieslinetanguera1672 11 күн бұрын

Great video . yeah Elton Johns apperance in 2020 was a bit froggy, he was better at Glasto. . Rod isnt that good anymore - he was better 10 years ago. Chris Stapleton is great - grreat blues androck voice . Please check Cliff Richards last concert video ( Sapphire tour ) - he is certainly miming there - i have been to four concerts and he sounded the same in each of them , Plus he missed beginning of the lyrics. please check ( I adore him and he is great entertainmer , he was great in the tours before 9 especially 2019/2019 which was complety live ) but he was certainly miming quite a lot in the concert , not in every song though .. .

@Menyhard Ай бұрын

Everyone gets Older

@werner.x Ай бұрын

I've heard recently - because everyone get's caught right now, thanks to youtube and smartphones - that it's the companies, which are insisting on the artist miming to playback tunes, because they want at least good sound for the extraordinary ticket prices these days. And from that perspective, it's understandable. Most old artists don't have a voice anymore - if they play without playback, it sounds nowhere near the album tracks, we're expecting to hear. I've seen some terrible stuff on YT from 80 year old Gordon Lightfoot, for instance. By the way - usually men's voices get higher with age, womens voices get deeper, as far as i know the state of this science - and you also often hear the evidence in radio talks too. But, of course, that doesn't mean, the high pitched voice of an 80 year old singer sounds good or hit's a tune - it just sounds like a young boy. I bet, 90 year old Willie Nelson needs a lot of electronic help these days too not to sound related to dying Johnny Cash, but keeping a bit of tonal volume.

@HumbleTrader001 Ай бұрын

Elton John’s voice got lower, not higher.

@werner.x Ай бұрын

@@HumbleTrader001 I'm sure, it differs anyhow. Tendency seems to be, that the pitch of the normal men's voice gets higher with age. Since most people don't sing in their normal voice anyhow, so it may even be irrelevant, what Science says here. I'm sure, no older man reaches his headvoice later, when he had decided to use the headvoice for his singing career. Voice get's also thinner with age, the other problem. I can see, why they insist of using playback with fossils. TV uses playback since the 70s at least as their standard anyhow - to get the show on screen in the most cost effective way. TV is the least, where you find something real - that's why every musician, who got through TV-shows, should be used to mime, since they force him to.

@HumbleTrader001 Ай бұрын

@@werner.x Yeah, some singers voices get thinner and lose depth of tone as they get older.

@MikePhillips-pl6ov 3 күн бұрын

Plus, most big shows are very precisely timed now to have to finish exactly before some local time restriction. They can't go on and do extended parts for fear of running over. So they pre-record songs, and/or click tracks, to play along to.

@rustymackemingrancanaria6360 Ай бұрын

Better that they pack in altogether. It's sad and ripping people off ,once the voice has gone .pack it in.

@MikePhillips-pl6ov 3 күн бұрын

Roger Waters can still legitimately get away with it as fans don't go to see him singing and playing while just standing there and nothing else going on around him. It's a huge audio-visual event, plus his band all singing and playing. So you get your money's worth. Everyone else though, I agree with you - or adapt to the musical styles you sing, within your range - like Robert Plant.

@tonepilot Ай бұрын

Ginger Baker :) lol

@tonepilot Ай бұрын

Holy cow, you've been to a lot of concerts. Hmm, you could have had a Fender Custom shop instead :)

@emersonleao Ай бұрын

Is that BILL BRUFORD!!????

@_RZ____ Ай бұрын

Looked to be!

@user-pz6ge7hf4x Ай бұрын

In the industry it's called "flying their vocals" it's been a common practice for years Moving right along...

@candelise Ай бұрын

Can't you tell when a musician is playing in the right key without checking out your instrument? Do you not have good pitch? Elton used to make a deal about Madonna miming and that he was still playing many songs in the original key.If a player chooses to lower the key to save the voice, so what? If a singer riffs on a well edtablished melody, so what, to a point. They are trying to find a nuance or expression to add to the million times that they have sang the song, as you know, I'm sure. As for miming, that's a no no!!