The Drowned Tridents should be animated as if they had Loyalty. That way it explains why you can't pick it up & why drowned can keep chucking them

Copper should go into powered rails, not gold. It's really obvious gold was just a stand-in for copper anyways. "Power" is carried by copper way more often than gold, and it just makes people less willing to use rails.

I love how minecraft has all those inconsistencies but mojang won't add fireflies cause they're poisonous to frogs.

5:36 You could potentially petrify wood by having dripstone with a water source above it drip onto your wood, since wood petrifies from groundwater and the minerals in it replacing the organic material. Maybe you would need dripstone to be attached to a raw ore block to supply the minerals? But it would give dripstone even more use and allow you to fireproof all your wooden bases!

16:30 big salmon literally sacrifices himself for you there. Truly blessed addition to the game

Every slab, except for endstone and the wood ones, has the same blast resistance of 6. As a result sandstone slabs have more blast resistance, than sandstone and even funnier is that you can put two of those slabs together to make a sandstone block that looks the same, but still has a higher blast resistance.

Another thing to add on to inconsistent crafting recipes is the different recipes between Java and Bedrock. The biggest 3 are boats, barrels, and tipped arrows. On bedrock, boats need a wooden shovel in the center to make the oar, meanwhile Java doesn’t. On Java, you need full wood planks instead of sticks on the sides of the barrel making it a fat bit more expensive too. As for tipped arrows, Java forces you to make them using lingering potions for only 8 tipped arrows in return (which effectively make them harder to make and not worth your time), meanwhile bedrock lets you easily make a lot more by putting any potion in a cauldron and the amount of tipped arrows you get back from it ranges from 16 all the way to a full stack depending on how full the cauldron is (1/3 full = 16 tipped arrows, 2/3 = 32, and a full cauldron gives you 64) which actually makes it worth making them

Another inconsistency: why can you fit 64 eyes of ender but only 16 enderpeals an eye of ender has more material in it!

Nether wood sticks should be how you make soul torches, it's pretty straightforward

1 Wood = 1 Button is the worst deal in the whole game

The reason they don't let you put meat into the composter is because generally speaking, you shouldn't put meat in your compost.... Yes, it can compost, but it also can turn very nasty very quick. In the sense that you now have a compost full of maggots now. Meat tends to attract flies which creates maggots which will eat the meat. Generally speaking, many experienced composters will tell you to just not fool with putting meat in your compost.

19:54 the Blindness effect can be obtained using suspicious stew made from an Azure Bluet flower.

Using different wood types to make different workstations actually makes a lot of sense. Aside from making obtaining them more interesting, the real life equivalents for the woods are dramatically different in strength, so it would make sense that a smithing table requires stronger wood than a loom or fletching table

I really like the idea of having things you hold not dealing damage if they are soft. Literal Nerf toys. Wonderful idea!

I’d love to have an old style/new style mob texture option. Have players choose whether they prefer their mobs detailed or classically stylised. I hear the call of a new blockbench project…

for the potion inconsistency.. what if the items you use to make them are the flowers you use to craft the sus stew, and the effects can't be buffed with redstone or glowstone? this could also create a use for mundane, long mundane, and thick potions example: a golden carrot gives you saturation, right? but a golden carrot also brews a night vision potion what if you just use a different base (like mundane), to get a saturation potion..? that actually sounds kinda dumb using saturation as an example and a golden carrot... but maybe you could use the flower that makes saturation stew for a saturation potion

I think it would be cool if there was a Petrified Forest biome from which you can get the stone-wood from. It would be nice if there was some sort of mob that existed there too, perhaps one that's responsible for petrifying the wood, like a cockatrice or a basilisk or something.

I heartily agree with like 90% of these. Mojang could really step up their game is this regard. Sometimes they seem a bit too hesitant to make these important changes.

2:13 cartography table and barrel cries in a corner because Toycat doesn't believe they exist

5:55 Also why aren’t we able to craft a STONE pickaxe using STONE ?

12:29 i’ll be honest this caught me off guard and i laughed way too much

The stairs recipe makes sense. Since each stair costs 1 1/2 blocks, it is clear the recipe goes something like this: Step 1: cut 1/4 off of a block Step 2: discard the additional 3/4 of the block, it's unnecessary Step 3: attach the 1/4 block to a 1/2 block It's completely logical!

Btw, you actually can craft Mossy Stone Variants with the Moss Block, weirdly obscure knowledge somehow

Another inconsistency about walls : we have polished versions of blackstone and deepslate walls but not andesite, diorite and granite ones. Also we don't have walls for stony blocks that have stairs and slabs, like quartz, purpur, prismarine bricks (because we have bricks, stone bricks, blackstone bricks and deepslate bricks ones)

Fun fact: you actually can craft mossy blocks from moss or vines! (At least in bedrock, but probably Java too)

20:53 Notice how when he bone mealed a flower, that made more of the same type of flower. This is unfortunately not a feature in Java Edition.

The cauldron is a magical block, explaining how the sponge doesn’t work on it and how you can place water in it in the nether

"You should make baby mobs breedable" - Toycat, 2022

In terms of mossy things, I would also want mossy wood types. Frustrating that you can't make wood more appropriate around bodies of water where it's far more likely to rot.

great video. also is anyone else playing bedrock edition having it constantly lag, freeze and crash? it's so messed up it's unplayable. i love 1.19, but I really hope it gets fixed soon. i was having so much fun too.

Maybe add sawdust from to make up for the stairs and trapdoor recipe, which then could be turned into pellets for smelting.

"How would you petrify a block? Put it near a sculk shrieker." Toycat could be a dad at this rate.

would be hilarious if someome actually made a mod for this whole list, specially the water part

15:12 wait I don't remember baby _bats_ existing?! like I knew there were baby dolphins and squids (and glow squids) on bedrock but bats?

Cauldrons are clearly magical, duh! Witches brew potions in there after all! Sarcasm aside, that’s the best explanation I can come up with for their odd behavior with water. Also, maybe the ambient temperature of the nether isn’t actually _too_ hot, but the air is just almost completely dry? And that’s why the ice doesn’t spontaneously melt, but the open water source blocks instantly boil off? Like the air is in that sweet spot to not melt or sublimate the packed or blue ice, which has unique atomic/ molecular structures that make it more resilient (different types of water ice actually exist in the real world, some which much more resilient properties!), but it’s also just warm and dry enough to instantly boil or evaporate off the liquid water?

you raised some good points but here's another one. The stone cutter has a saw that can cut through stone and give you 1 for 1 stairs that doesn't work on wood and you still have to use that wasteful crafting table recipe for all wooden stairs. Where is my wood saw? And where are the sideways slabs? How an I supposed to make arrow loops on a castle without sideways slabs?

Some other stuff that just don't make sense: -warped and crimson planks can't be smelted but can make sticks that are smeltable -bowl uses 3 planks A boat uses and additional 2 planks -can't make soul torch with charcoal on bedrock -cant make redstone stuff with blackstone or deepslate -use cobbled depslate on stonecutter to make bricks but not cobblestone cause it only makes cobblestone stuffs

Why doesn’t the ancient city have a map? Why are diamonds pre chiselled? Also, Wardens don’t have a health bar, although he isn’t a boss and he’s just the guard of something else.

I love how the font used in the inconsistent Minecraft intro is ironically "inconsistent" itself.

additionally: 1. regular stone can be crafted into multiple different types of stairs/slabs/etc, but regular deepslate cant. cobbled deepslate turns into like 5 different types blocks, but regular deepslate turns into nothing. 2. every single tree uses saplings to grow, except mangrove and azalea. 3. every tree has a unique shape except oak, jungle and birch trees. 4. nether wart blocks are crafted from nether warts, but warped wart blocks are crafted from ??? 5. most new blocks use unique sounds, but the old blocks are left untouched. for example: there is no audible difference between stone and prismarine, but there is an audible difference between tuff and deepslate. 6. new and old music 7. there is no difference between adult and baby turtles/bees other than size, while most other animals' baby version are different to the adult version (like larger head to body ratio) 8. only 2 tree types have root blocks

33:46 I just realized that you can finally make those light that opens when you get near them with the Skulk Sensor now!

I gotta say, having items be one specific type of wood only and not being able to mix wood types is so annoying sometimes, especially for items like chests that require a large amount of materials and only link up with another of the same type. If anything, minecraft needs more materials to work interchangably. There's so much clutter around with all the types of blocks and items.

0:21 I think they really need to add wood typed chests, barrels and ladders for consistency, theres alot of kinda of inconsistant about minecraft they need to work on

Fun fact about the Trapdoor thing, there's a Datapack for Java called Vanilla Tweaks that fix the trapdoor craft. They also changed stairs to give 8 when crafting instead of 4, and can be crafted back into planks.

This is one of those videos that your face cam you have worked well on. Those fun opinion videos are perfect for that.

haha you made me cry by laughing when you said the something about trusting wolf's and foxes

You forgot the fact the Most forgotten block, Quartz Bricks are crafted with FOUR QUARTZ BLOCKS and only give you ONE! I love the block but it’s hard to build with this because you can’t get it out out of a stonecutter so it’s really annoying to get. People need to talk about Quartz Bricks more.

It’s weird seeing the same skin I often use on servers (because skins from the skin creator don’t render on servers when playing on console or at least Nintendo Switch) in someone’s KZfaq video.

I would like more textures for mobs like wolves cows sheeps and add dogs like they did cats when they could use the ocelots

This comment will probably get lost but I wanted to put this idea down somewhere so my brain can relax. Being able to wax concrete powder means you can use it in water without it turning into concrete

Maybe there could be an inconsistencies update. Where they fix everything.

Toycat, for your bit on the coloured sand, you are not actually wrong. There is white sand that naturally occurs (due to shells from various creatures being ground up into the sand with age. It also is much easier to get sunburnt on a white sand beach) and if I'm not wrong, there is also black sand that occurs naturally

I didn't expect him to be bridging with obsidian blocks.

"Inconsistent Mob Sizing Is Inconsistent" *Ah yes, the floor here is made out of floor*

Upside-down Ts will be crazier with placeable milk

imagine if sticks were from different tree variants and stone pickaxes had variants you could make a "deepslate jungle handled pick" or " blackstone birch handled pick".

Fun Fact: horses' height is measured in "hands" . . . a pony is under 14 hands. A 'hand' is approximately 4 inches, or 10 centimeters. Vaguely related: 10 cm is the number laboring women are waiting for their cervix to stretch to for it to be time to push the baby out.

the cartography table is also always dark oak

Since everybody wants vertical slabs We should have an option to use sneak and place a slab on a vertical and horizontal face of a block depending on which side the cursor is pointing at

I think the reason jungle and swamp villages have not been added is the villagers and/or pillagers might not be able to move properly. I think there was a problem where pillagers were not able to move in sea grass. Swamps also have lots of water which might cause a few problems. Jungles have vines and lots of trees which might also cause a few problems.

the transitions are absolutely amazing and i completely agree with the content lmao

You can stack 16 eggs. But if you put them with pumpkin and sugar you yet a stack of 64 pumpkin pies.

15:27 “Make baby mobs breedable” That’ll happen in the upcoming Discord Mod Update

I understand not adding full on villages to swamps and jungles but why not add villager campsites with a couple tents and campfire and wood log stacks

When I first played minecraft as a child I was so annoyed that I couldn't make a pool of milk, like I could make one of lava or water and they're both in buckets but milk is a no go apparently

For the record, petrified wood is a real life thing. And it is in fact made of stone.

0:24 bookshelves have this issue too!

if 6 stone made 8 stairs it would render the stone cutter useless, so yeah I see why it’s there

Since amethyst shards can be placed on any solid surface block We should be allowed to do that with echo shards and quartz crystals First have them naturally spawn as gems growing out of their respected source block and for us to collect them Also doesn't make sense for diamond and emerald to not have crystal shard types If Mojang are planning on adding new crystal gems the same concept applies

The petrified slabs are bassically renamed alpha slabs. When slabs were first introduced in minecraft, notch made the base id for wooden slabs the same as stone slabs and only added a variation. When multiple wood types of slabs were introduced, the alpha slab just remained in the old worlds as one of the secret blocks. They still had an id and still existed but you couldnt obtain them anymore. Then, 1.13 came where all the id system was completly revamped. When the devs saw the alpha slab,they decided to not remove it from the game, but to add it in the creative menu as petrified oak slab. There arent multiple variants for the petrified one because the oak one was the only one that actually existed and i guess because of tradition.

Armor stands should have a customization GUI Where you can: - make your own pose for the stand - change the wood type or color the stand - custimize the size of the armor stand (baby armor stand, iron golem sized stand, enderman sized stand) - make any limb invisible and stone plate -let armor stands wear banners or elytra on shoulders without taking chest plate space

minecraft has so many inconsistencies too many to name but it can’t be 100% perfect

the “burnable” woods are “oak”, “spruce”, “birch”, “darkoak”, “jungle”, “acacia” woods the “unburnable” woods are “mangrove”, “warped”, “crimson” woods

the problem with the swamp and jungle villages is that the terrain messes with the pillager ai causing problems with raids

-make blackstone pickaxe -enchant it with efficiency v -name it "netherite pickaxe" in an anvil -hand it to someone to mine their diamonds with

And you say that they don’t want to mess with our existing structures BUT they can Easily fix this by allowing you to keep your world on your current build version. You can upgrade it with a warning box that says “if you upgrade to the current version, your builds and textures may change”

You see how you can dye water in a cauldron But when you bucket that dyed water The color goes away when you place it in the world We need to be able to bucket dyed water and place it in the world And be able to freeze it as well

Yo! The speed of this video is causing anxiety/messing with my eyes. ALSO...as a side note.... I think its amazing you have over 6100 videos on this channel! You creativity far exceeds the masses. ❤

I don't understand how azaleas can be trees, I work in landscaping in the south eastern US where they are insanely popular, they are always bushes, they don't have any large trunk to hold itself up and they top out at like 7 or 8 feet

for the number 9 I gotta say that they tried making horses more minecraft consistent with pixel and model bits they changed and people firstly yelled at them for doing so and later never said anything positive about it all together so it feels like they will get yelled at if they touch some of the mobs.

If I am correct the reason for the sand not being able to be dyed, is because it gets its color from minerals in the sand. red sand being, dont quote me on this i dont know how this works to well, from high amounts of iron oxide. And to go and dye sand it is usally a more indepth prosses then just crush flower put flower in sand and then mix. From what I can tell you need to get the dye in a liquid form, so in minecraft it would be more like, dye cauldron of water, and then place sand in it. So the reason why sand is not dye able is because the red sand is not dyed sand, it is sand with high amounts of iron oxide in it.

Petrified wood is actually just the old version of wood, that had the same code as stone or whatever, and mojang kept it in the game as a memory from the old versions of minecraft. Thats why there are no other variants

Yesterday I built a 7 layers vanilla mod farm, most of the wood went of trap door's also wood pressure plates...

They should add black sand, and white sand; then add a means of coloring the white sand.

What was the background gameplay for? Is it harrison grey's world or a realm review world?

mossy blackstone should use the crimson and warped stems

I imagine if all of this inconsistency are going to be fixed, MCPE would be 500mb download size...

19:29 I couldn't see ur hotbar in that scene and I legit thought you just milked the spider and had to rewind 💀

vines really should be removed from the “mossy block” recipe’s and made into its own thing (for example) Rope? -which could allow the player to climb down, opposite of scaffolding 😱

16:33 RIP Salmon

When you use a stone cutter, because it points upwards, you'd have to cut it vertically, meaning you always make verticle slabs and then turn them round to be horizontal

Toycat’s editor is responsible for the biggest inconsistencies when it comes to grammar.

the funny thing with the food inconsistency is: STEAK IS CALLED COOKED BEEF IN THE COMMANDS

Breaking leaves with a tool makes me cry 🥺

30:38 are there 4 variants of the Bastian? I always thought there were 4 variants of the bastion remnants and a single bastion before it was destroyed would have all 4 structures inside it

8:37 this is the last place I expected to hear an Alex Jones reference lmao

We do have slightly larger zombies, they're called husks.

5:26 The oak slab that you are showing is the petrafied oak slab "wooden slab before 1.13". The older version of the normal oak slab.

I HATE the door recipe you either get 1,2, or 4. *Where the hell am I supposed to use this third door at (or second) , that wouldn't look weird*

9:40 you shouldn't be able to make mossy blackstone but instead weeping and twisting blackstone (using nether vines); that would be a truer parallel. In addition, sculk cobbled slate and lichen cobbled slate