Comment below with your own priority order list - who are the 5 players it is most important Man United sell this summer and why?

1. Marcus Rashford 2. Marcus Rashford 3. Marcus Rashford 4. Marcus Rashford 5. Marcus Rashford

There's only a handful that are good enough to stay at Man United. Hojlund, Fernandes, Garnacho, Amad, Mainoo, Martinez, Dalot. The more sold out of the rest, the better.

Sam frightened to call out Rashford being sold , he’s bang average with Sancho’s attitude

How on earth is Rashford not on this list? Should be 3rd.

I think it’s fair to say that if Chelsea managed to sell Mount and Havertz for £54m and £64m respectively, we should get atleast £50-60m each for Sancho and Greenwood.

The big problem I can see is we need to sell so many players, replace those players, allow the new replacements time to settle in, revaluate as not all will work then go again. That's 2-3 summers. Next season won't be great, better than now yes probably but still not great, that means whoever is in charge needs time but I don't see the fanbase, media and pundits allowing that, really is a big job and huge overhaul

Rashford, Rashford, Rashford, Rashford and Rashford.

Just keep 6-7 players - Kobbie Mainoo, Alejandro Garnacho, Rasmus Hojlund , onana, licha, dalot,

This is everyone I would sell or give away. Maguire Varane Wan-Bissaka Fernandez Williams Casemiro Pellistri Van De Beek Forson Martial Rashford Antony Sancho Shoretire Greenwood I don't even care if we finish 10th as a result. I want an end to ridiculous wages for average players. I don't want any mega stars bought. A new philosophy and a fresh approach. Please, I'm fed up!

1.Antony 2. Sancho 3 Rashford 4 casemeiro 5 Lindeloff I would keep Mason personally and am also happy as a pig in muck that Martial won't be seen again at OT.

Varane before Maguire is crazy. Even this current form Maguire shows why he’s not the player we need. He’s great rn but his style of play is not winning us the league.

The question is why would they leave when they know they can't get similar wages anywhere else? There has to be incentive for them to leave

Like you said, Varane and Martial are a given, Amrabat does not get an extension. So it's AWB, Sancho, Greenwood, Casemiro, Malacia in the first tier. Second tier is Maguire, Rashford, Eriksen - players with value who are not going to be part of a rebuild. Onana, Antony - just haven't shown to be effective/good enough in the PL. VDB and Hannibal - forget they were even still on the books, they have to go. Luke Shaw is a perma crock now, he has to go. Hard to rank these top 5, they all need to go.

Rashford in place of greenwood!.

I would sell Maguire ahead of Lindelof purely for what we could get for him and wages. I personally think they should both be sold, but for me, it’s not the end of the world if Lindelof stays as a 4th choice CB

Harry should be sold. I agree that he has played better this season, but this is the time to sell. He does not fit out profile of CB that we would like.

I don’t think Ineos is selling Mason Greenwood, I’d sell Rashford before I sell Greenwood

More than 5players u mentioned needs to go, most of our players are average players

I can’t see anything like those valuations , I’m struggling to see who would want to buy them

The club never moves players on because we pay ridiculous wages to average players.

With the incompetence of past seasons in the market, we need to be careful how many players we ship out because we all know it takes us 6 weeks to sign a player.

I think we must sell atleast 10 players

I agree with 4 of the 5 players that need to be sold on your list. The only exception is Victor Lindelof. He isn't injury-prone like Shaw, Varane or Malacia. He has been consistent at the center-back position whenever Varane or Maguire was unavailable. Sam, you even said that Lindelof earlier in the season is one of the best center-backs that we have. He has been solid and consistent in his play for United whenever he has been fit and healthy. He has played more games than Varane, Shaw, Malacia, or maybe even Maguire this season. How many times has Lindelof missed games because of injury this season? Not a whole lot right? So even if you don't see him as a first-choice center-back. He can be a backup player off the bench.

Keep mason and get rashford out!!!

Eriksen:- 10 million Shaw :- 10 million Lindelof :- 10 million Maguire:- 25 million Sancho :- 50 or 45 million Greenwood:- 40 or 45 million Casemiro:- 20 million Hannibal :- 10 million Mc tominay :- 40 million I would love to add Rashford but no one will come for him. So that gives us 220 million roughly. Buy Dan Ashworth first then think about buying players. Add VDB too :- 10 million which gives us 230 million.

1)Sancho, he's had enough chances from both Solskjaer & Ten Hag to prove himself & he's hasn't lived up to the hype, he'll likely return to BVB 2) Casemiro, you can see he's no longer at the pace for the premier league, his leg are gone & Saudi Arabia will offer good money 3)Lindelof, I haven't ever seen a defender more afraid of the ball than him. bought him in as a ball player & he's more sideways in passing than McTominay. his International career will probably be the reason why someone would pay money for him. 4) Van der Beek, he's had opportunities to take a spot in our shambolic midfield since Solskjaer bought him & many times he's been so poor he hasn't even made the bench. he's not even a squad player at this point, but he's still relatively young & can rebuild somewhere, possibly back to Holland 5) Eriksen, he's just not been the same since Carroll's tackle, he needs to play in a league with less midfield intensity like a Holland or Italy where his football IQ can shine. Definitely think it's going to be a bigger clearout, with either Shaw or Malacia going, possibly AWB if a new contract is not agreed soon. Amrabat going back to Fiorentina. probably likely McTominay if we get a £35m & Maguire if it's £20m. Varane & Martial going on frees. & Greenwood probably leaving for the good of the club. Benfica will likely take the option to buy Alvaro Fernandez, but I think Hannibal won't be wanted by Sevilla, but still sold on. if PSG makes a huge offer for Rashford I would possibly take it to rebuild, we has Garnacho who can play there & could either stick with Antony or try to find another winger/inside forward in the summer

Varane, Amrabat, Martial gone on a free, probably Heaton and Evans too. So 3-5 on a free. Maguire, Lindelof, Eriksen, Malacia, Casemiro, Rashford, Antony, Alvaro, Williams, Van de Beek, Sancho, Pellistri and Greenwood, plus potentially Wan-Bissaka, McTominay and Mejbri to be sold That's another 13-16 gone. Total 16-21 players that need to go.

I would get rid of Maguire as well, let's not be fooled this guy had too many years failing as captain for man united and I still disagree with him being in the starting 11 even with his current form.

I will say we loan greenwood for another season he would improve his value to 60 mil atleast and if we have a good season there would be less toxicity and he might come again we should sell maguire also as a priority we might get money of him because he has been solid this season and it would be our last chance to sell him

Rashford, Shaw, Maguire, Scott and Onana

Greenwood for 25mil is crazy 💔

Where is the financial or football sense in keeping Slab and selling Varane? Just false economy and poor squad managment.

Maguire dam it! Those 5 I will give away for free if the next team willing to pay what they want.

One thing that boggles my mind is the expectations of Erik ten hag + the perception of our squad. Most people would agree that ETH was one of the hottest manager prospect around when we got him. And a lot of people can see some of his successes as a United manager. Although the frustration from our performances clouds the successes and amplifies the bad. There are still problems that are clear for all to see. But people want to sack ten hag, blame him for our performances and where United are now. And at the same time would want 10-15 of our players to be moved on and replaced. I’m no expert. But if 10-15 of your first team squad needs to be moved on, you cannot blame the manager, sack and replace him, and then hope for better outcomes. You still have 10-15 players whom need to go. You could argue: Varane, malacia, wan-bissaka, mctominay, martial, DvB, sancho, greenwood, casemiro, eriksen, amrabat, lindeløf, williams, mejbri, pellistri and evans. And some rashford. That’s 17 players i just listed. Some would argue maguire also, so 18 players. And yet so much of the talk is about Ten hag, or the frustration week in and week out for our bad performances. Whilst taking into account injuries of martinez and shaw, argueably the 2 most important players for ten hag’s style of play. It’s clear what needs to happen, and it’s to back Ten Hag, and overhaul our squad.

Would you just look at sellable assets. Lindelof won't bring in much money and I'd expect around 15 to 20 million but it's Maguire who will be very in demand after his performances this season and you would get at least double for what Lindelof would bring in.

Hopefully this is the beginning of a new era and a new Manchester United 🙏

IF United could get this squad to play next season that would be a great step towards success 📈!!. The preferred formation is 3-5-2 since we have too many inverted wingers in our strikers aren't getting much service. GKs - Onana, *Matěj Kovář* & Heaton. RCBs - *Todibo* & Varane CBs - Lisandro & Kambwala LCBs - *Nico Schlotterbeck* , Maguire & Jonny Evans LWBs - Shaw & Malacia RWBs - *Frimpong* & Dalot CDMs - *Amadou Onana* & Casemiro RCMs - Mainoo, *Aleix García* & Daniel Gore LCMs - Bruno, Mount & Scott Holding ST - *Ivan Toney* & Højlund ST - Rashford & Garnacho

1. Sancho 2. Greenwood 3. Rashford 4. Casemiro 5. Antony 6. AWB 7. Donny 8. Hannibal 9. Pellistri 10. Williams Frees/failed loans Martial, Varane, Amrabat People will say its not realistic but half them dont play anyway. If we want to be successful we need to get as many of these gone as possible.

Selling greenwood for that price would be a travesty whether you want him to stay or not he's a top quality player better than any of our current front line and would get into most teams in Europe

Lindelof is a decent back up and servant to the club. There are so many others just not good enough, it’s frightening how much surgery is needed.

Sancho, Rashford, Greenwood, Casemiro, AWB, Lindelof, Donny Hannibal, Antony, Erickson, Tyrel,

Maguire is not good enough to play in a high system for United but he has been a better player this season which is why he should be first out the door, we will never get more money for him than we will this summer

Fair points. True, the timing of contracts play into this prioritization. I'd place Anthony in the top 5.

I would swap AWB for VDB and Lindelöf for Maguire. Otherwise I agree. Maguire can bring in much money and earns more than Lindelöf. Besides, Lindelöf are more flexible across the back-line than Maguire.

The new era ITS COMING SAM ❤

whats frustrating about this, we overpay for players then they go for free or we sell then cheaply and make a loss

I think 35m for Sancho would leave us breaking even on him as per FFP because his ~70m transfer would only be half paid off on the books by this summer. So that doesnt really add to the kitty for this summer

Sancho absolutely needs to go. He's thoroughly embarrassed our club after everything we've given him.

Why do we have to make a top 5 list!?? 🤔🤨 There's player who has to leave no matter how or what: Sancho, Martial, Varane, Donny, Brandon, Eriksen, Casemiro, Lindelof, Hannibal. There's player who may leave with the right offer: Rashford, Maguire, Scott, Alvaro..maybe Pellestri & Antony And Greenwood case totally depends on Sir Jim

1. Harry Maguire. 2. Scott McTominay. 3. Marcus Rashford. 4. Bruno Fernandes. 5. Antony.

The one player I disagree with is AWB. I think he's good backup for Dalot and if you don't want to let him leave on a free you can just extend his contract by a year this summer

This list is too generous. Maguire has to go as well. We are unable to play a high def line with him. Antony is another must sell, his level is below premier league level

I think its more important to get rid off rashford than selling greenwood

We could easily sell 15 players this summer. If 5 is over £100m, imagine how much 15 players would be. Nothing controversial either, just getting rid of all the useless players we have in the squad. Whether it’s due to age, injuries, not suiting the system, or just not being good enough. There could honestly be even more than that.

Probably you've ever done what greenwood did or someone close to you will and it won't be online you'll understand why Greenwood should stay.

I think we all get too focused on the transfer fee, but what's more important are the wages saved. Also areas we need to focus on is Defence & Midfield so apart from Varane & Martial {Saving £30m a year in wages} going for free the below need to leave, but can take a hit on the transfer fees. 1. Casemiro (Save £18m a year plus £5m in bonus) 2. Sancho (Save £10m a year plus £5m in bonus) - Take lower up front fees with lots of add ons. 3. MG (Save £2.6m in wages) Contract expires 2025 - so has to be sold this season. Take lower up front fees with lots of add ons. 4. Eriksen (Save £7.8m in wages) Contract expires 2025 - so has to be sold this season. 5.1.AWB (Save £4.7m in wages) Contract expires 2025 - so has to be sold this season. Take lower up front fees with add ons. *5.2. DvB (Save £4.7m in wages) Contract expires 2025 - so has to be sold this season. 5.3.Lindelof (Save £6.2m in wages) can play RB & LB - (but not an issue seeing him go if we keep Maguire) Contract extended in Jan 24 to June 2025 - so ideally has to be sold this season. **Wages saved based on Free departures and the first 5 is : £83m Plus Transfer fees ***We wont get more than a few million up from for DvB & Lindelof but will save more on wages £11m.

*Sell* 1. Casemerio- he have been expose in ETH system 2. Lindaloft 3. McTominay- not DM discipline, need to be converted to a SS or CF 4. Erikson 5. Matial *Loan* 1. Rashford- Being saying the G need to be loan, he need to miss ManU and come back *Keep* 1. Amrabat- I don't think we use him to his true potential and what he can deliver 2. Anthony- have a lot of pride and want to play for the club, maybe ETH need to change up the play that suit Anthony

If EtH stays, Rashford needs to go.

Forgot about van de beek

If Greenwood has been acquitted from the charges, has apologised to those effected and changed as a person... why can't he play for Man United again? We could very much do with his ability, and how do you know he hasn't changed personally behind the scenes? Antony got arrested and yet no one is calling out for him to be sold for that reason.

Rashford, Casemiro, Eriksen, Sancho, Donny

@UnitedPeoplesTV are the podcasts no more or they have been moved to members only?

United fans should stop worrying about what Ten Hag is doing and just be hugely excited about this project. You cannot compete with City or Liverpool by just having a great manager. INEOS is about to create the foundation for a hugely successful project, and Ten Hag may or may not be part of that in a season or two. I think you will really start to see what Ten Hag can do once some fundamental structures are in place, including recruitment. Personally I think 4 cup finals in two years and CL is a tremendous achievement, especially with the amount of injuries, and it's only going to get better and better.

1. Sancho 2. Rashford ( he is an acady player but its time to say goodbye ) 3. Casemiro (same reasons as you said) 4. Eriksen (he doesnt have the energy to play football) 5. Shaw (he doesnt play but we can get some good money)

Id keep Onana, Dalot, Martinez, Mainoo, Garnacho and Hojland. Anyone else can go for the right price. Id have a list of potential replacements we can reasonably aquire for a good fee. After that fill the gaps with academy players and see if they sink or swim. Put a style and plan in place and stick to it. Aim for a top 10 finish next year, top 6 the year after and hopefully challenge for the title a couple of years later.

Selling Greenwood to get someone that can’t lace his boot is baffling

Harry Maguire. Let's not kid ourselves.

1. Maguire. is a liability every game. He is slow, clumsy, and cannot read the game. Also massive salary.

I disagree with your statement because Harry Maguire will not good as this season for sure so many club will want him on good money if we didn’t sell we’ll probably have to sell lesser than lendelof so maguire is priority plus as a tactical POV he doesn’t suits in high defense line role

We need 2 Center backs with pace. Maguire has massively improved. He’s great in the air and has fight in him, but he just doesn’t have the pace. He can’t play the high line that we want to play.

mejbri - 17m pellistri - 12m greenwood - 18m lindelof - 15m sancho - 25m van de beek - 7m malacia - 18m varane - 0 martial - 0 TOTAL: 112m

Maguire before Varane. Rashford before Mason

Need to leave this summer: Casemiro, Maguire, Wan-Bissaka, Sancho, vd Beek. Together with Varane and Martial not signing a new contract and walking out of here. Need to come: RB - Denzel Dumfries, CB - Todibo, DM/CM - Frenkie de Jong or Joao Neves (?) and a striker: Oshimen, Vlahovic

We are going to have a good season think we are getting somewhere everyone gets there hopes up the glazers get there money from shirts and tickets then the season after next it will be the same old story where lack of effort the manager will get shafted and then we will say there is always next season and the cycle will start again and again and we have been in this loop since 2013 it doesn’t matter who we bring in unless the culture changes and the grounds get done up and we don’t have a run down training ground it’s just nonsense and the same old story every other year but I just hope this time it will be different due to Ineos but I doubt it since the club is still 1Bn in debt and all the other issues are there.

#1 rashford #2 malacia- injuries #3 sancho #4 Martinez n varane #5 casemiro The premier league is obviously too much for Martinez. Barely see the dude play

The shorter list is who would you keep. Maguire, McTominay. Wan Bisaka and Greenwood i believe will all be in the last year of there contracts in the summer, whats stopping them from holding out all season and leaving themselves for free. No money for United in, paying out wages and then having to replace them as well with zero funds.

Mine is: 1. Sancho 2.rashford 3. Maguire (think there may be some value in him, plus he’s good but he just doesn’t suit our play at all. 4. Mctominay 5. Wan or shaw (I know shaw is absoloutely amazing when available but I feel we should cut our losses with him because he’s so damn injury prone which is a huge shame m. I rate him very highly but I feel injuries are just going to keep getting worse.

Players to be sold 1.Rashford 2. Maguire we better cash in on his while he's playing better now cause we all know that he's only playing better than what is available since our best defenders are out injured 3. Sancho 4. Greenwood as much as I like the player but for peace sake.. He should be sold 5. Wambasaka 6. Casamiro.. We need someone young, fast, strong and with hight footballing IQ 7. Varan and the reason is he's always out injured and that's why we are always struggling at the back and he's old now 8. Evens needs to be released to open space for new players 9. All the players who were loaned out so to really work on bringing quality players in

We have got several summers of exiting. Rashford should be top of that list, Sancho, Casemiro, AWB and Greenwood

Agree with 4 out of the 5. Don't think AWB is anywhere near high priority - UNLESS he refuses a 1 year extension. If PSG come in with a decent offer for Rashford, say 80+ million, let him go and immediately reinvest that into the midfield or central defence. I don't think Antony has done anywhere near enough to warrant another year, and I can only see his value decreasing if he stays. Ultimately, we have too many that need to go and too many that need to come in, without a structure in place yet, without the funds we need to pay for it all, with no Champions League to offer, a manager who may or may not make the start of the coming season and on the back of a woeful season this season. Not only do I think we will struggle to sell, I also think we will struggle to buy anyone of any real quality given our current circumstances. It's almost a perfect storm of disaster frankly.

Good thing about this: if we can offload these 5 players+ free agents leaving, we can offload almost 90m of salary. Almost 50% dead wood of the book. Good opportunity to restructure our wage structure.

I understand the reasons why Casemiro should be sold But I just can't help but feel that MU could have gotten more out of him. Must be difficult to choose who is going when the club is going threw alot of changes. Perhaps such changes can make a player better. I guess its smart to keep the younger ones with you in that case.

United need the biggest squad overhaul of all time, and unfortunately most clubs know this. Therefore be prepared to be lowballed over every player. Many of those you mentioned unfortunately will still be here next season. We are saddled with them.

1.Antony 2.Rashford 3.Lindelof 4.May be VDB I don't know why you talk about Casemiro... Because we haven't replacement, Sancho plays well in Borussia.

C'mon Sam, if you think that £30m for a player of Greenwood's ability is a good price, you have been sucked into the United mentality of paying insane prices and then selling at rock bottom prices. I understand that Greenwood isn't the £100m player he was a couple of seasons ago, but he has done ok in Spain, and will be better next season for having had a season to get back into regular matches. If we sell Greenwood, we should be looking at a minimum of £50m and be trying for closer to £70m. Also, if your figures are accurate as to what we will get, we are not going to be doing a great deal of squad improvement over the summer because we need to be mindful of how much we can spend without getting into FFP problems.

As much as I think Rashford should go this summer, we have the same top 5 list, maybe Eriksen over Lindelof. It is highly possible that we couldn't get two quality CB at single transfer window. We might not have the luxury to get rid of Lindelof next transfer window. I don't know if anyone will buy VDB from us and I am not sure if PSG really will go for Rashford.

Rashford @ 50, Wan Bissaka @ 20, Casemiro @ 35, Mactominany @ 25, Lindelof @ 10 Total =140 m

That £105m should be invested into the stadium as the fans are the lifeblood of the club. They are far more important than hiring employees (aka players on the pitch).

Letting players go is one thing, spending in FFP is another ! Major headache coming

The agenda against Greenwood is insane. I can understand people wanting to sell him (I don’t want to) but come on man he’s not the top priority to sell this summer at all. In terms of how this team has performed he’s had nothing to do with. We can easily loan him out again, boost his value and move other players on. Personally, I’d keep him but if we do sell him we should be looking to get way more than 25-30 mil.

Sancho , Casemiro , Donny van de bak , Rashford, Greenwood can't be brought back for obvious reasons ... Really need 10 players sold or leave on free contract .I can't see INEOS Making the same financial mistakes of the past , ridiculous contracts on insane wages for show ponies who don't want to put a proper shift in each week .Look at Man City , everybody on that pitch puts in 100% every week, depth of Squad is a huge plus hence why they will P.L.champions again this year 2024 !! Go the REDS❤ and support EtH !

The problem is, who are going to buy them? Their salary is rocket high and no one want to take pay cut. Which club is willing to pay such salary? So, be realistic. All those players will stay in Old Trafford.

Anthony should be on top of this list… He is one of the main reasons, if not the reason United looks like a paper tiger…

Buying Caseimero for 65m then sell him for 20m is a 45m loss to FFP, add Sancho what is left owed on those players will result in a FFP pure loss which is going to hurt more

Fantastic interview with Nick Cox on Sky tv about our youth academy, definitely worth a watch.

These players should go this summer if we are serious about this rebuild Sancho, Antony, Casemiro, Varane, Lindelof, Wan Bissaka, Erikson and Amrabat are gone anyway, Martial gone, Rashford should be sold, he’s no longer a youth and we can’t wait for him forever to be that player we keep imagining he can be. VDB should go, I think Pellestri would never establish himself as a united player and must be sold. About 11 players minimum must leave

more than 15 senior players need to leave the club , Rashford , Lindelof , Evans , malacia , Varane , both Anthony , Scott mactonmy , Casemiro , Ericsson , mount , Sancho , Green wood , Hainbal , Lastly squad doctors .

I think the quick and shortest list should be "who stays" list of those who stays.

Considering we would get maybe 25 mio. for Maguire and 5 for Lindelöf and we need to sell to buy and both are only kept to be backups, I'd sell Maguire. We need to sell quite a few players that are actually considered to be worth something. If we only buy one centerback then by all means keep Maguire, but I hope we get two.