Having watched the video...option A, B, C or D? Which one would you go for? Big up to Bondibot for creating these visualisations as it makes it easier to imagine for us United fans. Make sure to check out the full video, link is in the description.

I’ve been a civil engineer for 15+ years. It doesn’t matter that those technologies exist to enable the building of the stand above the rail, the issue is with the daylight for the housing behind. I can promise there is no real solution that enables both parties to be fully happy. The only option for Man Utd to fulfil all its ‘wanted’ stadium ideals and criteria is with a new stadium. Don’t forget refurbing old Trafford just means that in 20/30 years you are asking the exact same questions of the design, if you build a brand new platform and infrastructure, new ground with fold away pitch etc you have an infinitely more upgradable stadium in 30 years time. Modern Stadium requirements have simply outgrown current stadium location, it is not suitable any more.

Option C, its not just the stands, internally the whole stadium needs modernising, so might as well start from scratch

Option D, but with a similar design to OT. Having both stadiums having an element of symmetry, would be incredible. For me it would keep the history embedded in the area. I'd deffo keep elements of OT in any new design. Less of the bedpans 😂

Option A full stop. Old Trafford is way too iconic to be looking so much like Spers stadium

As much as I love old Trafford I would like to see a brand new stadium ultra modern 100000 plus. But as you said Sam the steel works on the roof is iconic so would love to see that incorporated into the new stadium for sure

Last one option D looks the best to bring all level of teams together

D for me. Just expanding the south stand and fixing the roof doesnt address the legroom etc in the other stands. Capacity wise, they need to look at the season ticket waiting list and add 20% to that.

You're a natural on camera, keep shining!

From what Sir Jim has already said he wants to build an entire new stadium that makes it among the best & biggest in the UK & I think further down the line it'll be far more profitable in terms of match day revenue & with entertainment complexes built in so that families can have a good day out aswell as watch football. Also our stadium could then host many events which will bring in revenue aswell. Old Trafford has been neglected for many many years it'll need alot more work than many think. Also building a new stadium plus having hotels on the grounds & all that tackle will help with the local area creates job oppertunities etc. Time will tell

Let me say concept A is the coolest one

lol imagine living in those houses with that stadium towering over and turning your back yard into giant cave. They have to build a new stadium, it's the only viable long term option with the least amount of impact on football operations!

For a refurbish I'd pick A. But I'd like either a significant refurbish or a rebuild. I don't like the bedpan look either. But what if it looked like Allianz Arena - might be able to keep some of the white steel options and light it up red. Love the acoustics in that stadium - would love for the new Old Trafford to be that loud.

If the south stand was built to mirror the same capacity as the north stand (including the quadrants), we’d get a capacity increase of 18-19,000

Loving the content, Sam. I think option D is the only one that Man Utd could take and not have to look for another ground to play their games at.

If Option A is feasible with the platform over the railway line, then 100% that's the option to choose. It'll be cheaper to build an extension over one stand than a full stadium. Also If the south stand mirrors the north stand + quadrants that will easily add 15,000 capacity, which means OT will hit the magic 90,000 capacity, whilst keeping with the heritage and character of the current stadium. It ticks all the boxes.

Option C could be the best with new style and advanced technology and equipment.

Like option A. Should be able to double stand size at least, push 85/90 tho. 92 thousand be fitting. Maybe a few other touch ups on exterior, raise roof, sort fan services to enjoy the experience more

New stadium

Could you add a 3rd tier to the Stretford end, and a 3rd tier, to the score board end as well.

I’d imagine be more like 90 with south stand mirroring the north

What a Video Sam, thanks for that 👌👏🏻

If you want to reclaim the title of biggest football club in the world, you need to build something bigger and better than both the Camp Nou and the Bernabeu. It also needs to look wild. Forget keeping or copying the roof on the current stadium. You either build bigger, better and new or you don't bother. Of these options B is the best because it looks space age but I think the architects should be let off the leash and build something completely crazy. Something that's never been seen before. I know some fans are worried about tradition but remember, today's cutting edge is tomorrow's tradition.

IF JIM ACTUALLY BRINGS SOUTHGATE IM FUCKING DONE WITH THIS CLUB

Option C but would prefer a totally new state-of-the-art stadium of about 95 to 100k capacity. OT can be redesigned and repurposed...

Option A is by far the best. It is imperative to keep the roots of Old Trafford.

Need a new modern state of the art stadium

Option A - you can replace the roof with a new one. Option A looks nicer, keeps culture and is cheaper. You can use the other land for “regeneration” (make your money)

Option A - classic look. Fix the roof and update the amenities.

If the roof is fixed, option 'A is great.

Has to be a new state of the art stadium.

Option C I’ve never been sentimental over bricks. Old Trafford has been rebuilt after WWII. It’s changed under the Martin Edwards/Gill redevelopments…. They’re essentially 100yo plus footings and infrastructure. If ur redeveloping the area then a New Stadium is a must. The design should incorporate the stylings, features and statues/memorial tunnel of the old. And when they reduce the old Trafford for use by the academy and women’s team I’d love It to look just like a mini OT of today… But a less sterile non bedpan 100k seater mega stadium is THE Statement of we’re back!

Option A; North stand is 25.5k, south stand is currently 11.5k so assuming they are mirror images, that adds ca. 14k and would bring the stadium just shy of 90k.

Sam, the houses at the back will stop option C. ‘Right to Light’ for residents etc. A or D for me

Love Old Trafford. I first went there with my uncle in 1967, and was a regular visitor up to joining the RAF in 1976. I would be very sad to see it go, but I feel that clinging to the past is not the way forward, and a new ground is the best way forward I think. having said that, none of the above suggestions fill me with awe!

Option E 100,000 capacity Retractable roof and pitch! Current stadium. Downsize to 20-25k Then build hotels, restaurants and flats around the current stadium.

The white steel cantilevers on old Traffords roof were supposed to resemble the old cranes that were once on the docks there.

option b will have isssues like the large building in london that reflects light etc option A,but more seats and new design keeing the old roof style

I'll take option C. Looks amazing and your looking after Women's and youth teams by adopting land on original Old Trafford site.

A Manchester United fan since I was 10, really hope they gonna build a new cool stadium that has some giant screen in the near future

I remember Fergie mentioning this years ago exactly the same as that. Going beyond the rail track and having a station to drop off fans underneath, and I believe he said this would increase OT to 88k

1:59 according to the tour guide in old Trafford when I was there 25 years ago he said It’s not because of the railway it’s because of the sunlight. The grass needs sunlight and a roof would block the majority of sunlight. So they can’t build on that section the stand. The Aviva (Landsdown road ) Dublin has a train going through the main stand. The Amsterdam Arena has a duel carriage way going under the stadium The opposite side was developed for Euro 96 and without the corners gave an additional capacity of 12,000 supporters. Each corner would give an additional 2500. So the capacity would grow to be 91000 making it “the Wembley of the north”

I've been to OT on the train many times with station outside the South stand. Think it shut in the 80's

Let me start by saying I’ve never been to OT. I’m an overseas Red since 97. I’ve planned many times but life and circumstances caused changes (birth of kid, job change, pandemic). If feasible I lean toward option A. The look of OT is iconic and every football fan knows the stadium just by seeing it. Modernize the interior. Upgrade facilities. Increase capacity and build up the South Stand over the railway with a platform that allows easy access. If a new stadium is chosen I think they should keep the look of the roof structure. The white steel is just part of OT. I hate the bed pan and bowl looks.

Option D, it's more financially reasonable for looking forward in the future. Modern stadium that can look as upgraded version of Old Trafford, not completely same but visual aspect of it would work.

Them gardens at the back of the South stand saying goodbye to daylight for good.

if you extended the south stand replica to the north and SE and SW quadrants then you’ll achieve over 90,000 capacity. if you then add a 3rd tier on the west and east stand and the quadrants you could achieve close to 100,000.

I personally think a massive regeneration of the whole area is what will happen and i think it will take several years to get to that point. new stadium, hotels coffee shops apartments and retail units.. Basically disney land with a football stadium instead of a rollercoaster. Somewhere for tourist to spend all weekend there and spend a small fortune. To become more commercially profitable you need attractions not just once a fortnight on matchday.

Redoing the Main Stand to mirror the SAF standvwould take the capacity to 94k, however the seating wouldn't be to modern spacing, redoing the seating to modern specs would then reduce the capacity back down to around 82k x

Ratcliffe talks big to get fans on his side but ii is the glaziers shout in the end

At present The Old Trafford Stadium is still incomplete & needs is an upgrade of the SBC stand & East & West quadrant to be completed first before you can sort out the roof. This Stadium has a lot of potential & can be one of the best stadium in Europe if not the world with the original design cos it has authentic & character with the potential capacity of at least 90K, all it needs is an refurbished & some TLC. Take Note: The Stadium Expansion Must Not Exceed the rail way track! Man Utd 's Old Trafford 'The Super Bowl of Stadiums known as 'The Theatre of Dreams' is unique & a Colossal of a stadium.

Sam, all of these options will lead to a significant ticket price hike. With a refurbishment, there's still going to be stuff that breaks because it's old. We need to rip the band aid off and build a new stadium and have the infrastructure around a new stadium to create more revenue to create more money to comply with FFP / more signings.

I think they will build a new one next to the current ground. It will be about 85000 capacity to begin with and room to expand over the following summers while Old Trafford is taken down and the area rebuilt. That way, the cost is spread out and the team is in the ground earlier making the club money.

I just can't see the refurbishment working with the houses and railway so close to existing site. It has to be option C (the new stadium) as they then have a blank canvas to work with.

For A + B you would have problems with the planning permission for the stadium as there would be a lot of objections to it

Option c is amazing❤

What if old trafford was turned into a museum/mall/concert or auditorium?...the museum would serve as a memory to charlton,best,Fergie and all those amazing memories. I'm sure it would bring in a revenue year round

Id like option A or something similar but brand new world class stadium as there is no space in parts of the ground miles away from the pitch

D, with a different exterior design, that seats at least 90K

Capacity with developing the south stand would take it to between 87 and 90k. I dont the residents in those houses would want that wall of steel at the end of there back garden

I love the idea of keeping the pitch and building a new stadium around that, but extending the south stand and replacing the roof isn’t enough if we are to be best in class. We need to sort out that drop off the pitch has since it was raised for undersoil heating - it’s a death trap. Hospitality and executive boxes need to be better (only for generating the income we need to pay for the work). We need better/decent tv screens and the seating needs to be better spaced as it’s too cramped in some sections. I love Old Trafford and still think it looks great - went in December and it’s had a fresh lick of paint, seats are being upgraded and still better than 80% of the stadiums in the PL, but we need to think of the next 50-100 years and match the standard of the tier 1 stadiums elsewhere in the world.

Option A if it's doable. A new stadium is now my preferred choice. I've come to terms with that and if they are able to down size OT for the womens and U21s etc then i'm happy with that

The issue is the seats, these need improving as it's so cramped. I would go for A if it also meant changing all of the seats.

Option D, but not that design for the new and current OT. Got to be able to keep some history. Maybe build a hotel etc there.

The extension on the North Stand gave 11,500 additional seats. Each quadrant added 4000 seats each, 8000 in total. Thats 19,500. If you replicate the same for the South Stand and quadrants you get a Capacity of 93,810. Todays official capacity is 74310. If you lifted the roof and add the same height as the South Stand all around the stadium you will end up with a capacity easily over 100 000. Potentially overgoing Barcelona's new stadium at 105 000 capacity.

I like the 1st one but I think a new stadium might be the way forward

Only a new stadium makes sense. Expanding south stand to match east & west would only add a maximum of 10k seats. Adding those extra seats, whacking a new roof on, and a new facade, and tarting up the concourses would cost about £1b. There would be about 8 years of disruption where parts of the ground are shut down, or maybe the whole ground shut down. When finished increased revenues would cover financing with a bit to spare. A new state of the art 100k stadium would an extra 20k standard tickets plus 5k exec/premium. Cost £2b. Increased revenues would be 3 or 4 times any financing costs. The space where the old ground is, and around the new stadium (the "stadium district" part of the Trafford Wharfside project), could then be redeveloped into a fan park, bars, eating places, community stuff etc. A new mini stadium for the ladies & youth team can be built somewhere on the plot. None of this wider project can be done with the old stadium where it is. There's only one reason for just redeveloping the old stadium rather than a new stadium, and that's our emotional attachment to the place. The question is, is that emotional attachment to the old ground more important than all the advantages that a new stadium would bring to the club, the supporters, and the wider community? I'm glad I'm not making the decision.

A refurbishment of Old Trafford would need all the seats ripping out and redoing for more leg room so Option C for me, to take us into the future.

It's going to look fab

Like the idea of A as someone who disable a train straight into tge ground yes please😊😊

1 major problem with option b Where are we supposed to play when the renovations are taking place?

Option D. Build a 60-70k seater stadium next to Old Trafford on the car park like in option C. Build the new stadium with downsizing and repurposing in mind. This stadium becomes Man United's home stadium for a few years then the current Old Trafford gets knocked down except for the old tunnel. And a brand new 100,000+ seater stadium is built on the same site with the pitch in the exact same location. And as you said with a white steel roof. Once it's built the other stadium gets downsized and repurposed for the academy and youths etc

Maintain the buildings intergrity and the face of it. Option A for me. If you can refurbish the south stand then keep A

Complete new stadium for me Its all about the next 100 years and beyond History is History looking forward to the new future is a must......

I'm a little confused about the homes across the railway England is so far north that I would assume the sun is usually going to be more south. Those homes are on the south side so they should still get sun

if you want too, the new stand could have 30.000 seats, but sponserboxes and stuff like that will proberly take up some of the space

I think if they were going to build a brand new stadium you would think they would actually have a roof. Marvel Stadium (in Australia, Melbourne) have a roof that opens and closes. I would love to see a big club in the Europe to do that. No more wet football matches 🙌🏼

A because sorry the other looks like a massive bed pan , the older video you did had some quality looking stadiums

Sam= Quality 🎉

Option D is the long-term solution and the future of United.

If it were to be a refurb, then it would definitely have to be option A out of those 3, I certainly don’t like the bed pan if it’s new or refurbished

D for me plus it will be a 100 thousand seater plus shops restaurants cinema many thing. Plus easier transport home for home fans and away fans.

Interesting

Those 3D animations and designs are pretty cool to see. I say, keep Old Trafford and build a new stadium next to it but with a design that's closer to OT and not these bed pan ones.

The problem with the steel you like on the roof is that you can’t then add a sliding roof

Option D new build and with old Trafford being down sized and the museum stay there etc and youth and women’s teams being played there 👍

Sam just checked the figures on the stands The N Stand holds 26k, the S Stand holds 10k. That's an increase of 16 k alone mate. The 2 quadrants also added an extra 8k when they were rebuilt. Mate that's an extra 24k seats making the stadium 98k, wow! There was also a plan to increase the N Stand to 34k by adding another stand in 2019 agreed with Trafford Council. That would take Old Trafford to a mammoth capacity of 106k. You won't be building a new stadium anywhere near that size, not chance.. Sort the Theatre of Dreams, which is already iconic & as we saw last Sunday still class, defo the best option. You know it's the answer mate❤❤❤

Option D is most suitable for me but well lets wait and see

I like opt A & opt C ....... the best will be opt a with oerall change interior wise .... like new toilets and canteen !!

Option D For me, i like the idea of a new stadium

I think we got to go new stadium!! Maybe not in that style, but new and the best in the world. 90-100k capacity

Option A 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥👍

My heart says A+B but the time frame, reduction in revenue and lack of suitable ground to play in while the works done makes it unlikely

You could Build a tunnel for the trains beneth the stadion

From these options, I like the A option, just because I don’t like the design of B and A+B. As much as hate the idea of losing Old Trafford, which is bound to the history of this club, with the memories of every single moment of its history, I think SJR will more likely build a new stadium. That’s my feeling

First one is amazing. Keeps the character of the current stadium.

Retain SBC South as an historic connection. Listed status. Poss' retain pitch for a smaller stadium, so current OT would be partly retained. New OT 105k, best in world. Raised pedestrian walkway to Manc city centre to get 1,000's in/out. Call it the Red Walk.

Doing the south stand and increasing the capacity is the best short term solution, increase revenue and save money for modernisation later. Borrowing money with interest is going to cost more in the long-term.

I'm sure the house owners of option C would love the view and lack of daylight

Bondy Bon? It sounds like Fone Jacker 😂😂😂