They needed to make enough time for cringeworthy Josephine scenes that nobody wanted or asked for

@@jaredschmidt8013 😆

At least they showed... Spain wasnt shown... Bailen was the first defeat of Napoleon :p

I Hope extended Version will BE better

Film also didn't have: Ulm. Marengo. Eaylu. Leipzig. Movies are a time economy. I think the real issue is the film didn't know what it wanted to be: drama about Napoleon's life or a war film and by trying to be both it diminished the potential of both.

Yes, ridiculous nonsense. And there are plenty of sources to make sure to get this right, but no one bothers. Take a look at the Duellists, another otherwise sumptuous historical movie, but the French invasion of Russia just looks embarrassingly silly. It seems that when it comes to Russia, the West's brain goes off the rails.

He was criticised for his historical inaccuracies over two decades ago in Gladiator. Why are you shocked? It's entertainment.

There were asians in the Russian army at that time - Bashkirs, Tatars.

@@claremontcowboy7409 Then why am I not entertained?! 😂

I didn't see anything stereotypical in it. There were many Bashkir and Tatar warriors fighting in the Russian army.

Это Антарктида.) Бородино в Антарктиде же)

That is the movie for Westeners who think that everything on the east is Mordor.

@@DK-yc9qo hahahahaa

No, the Russians lost all their battles to the French and lost their army due to Winter! And the Nomads in Russia, dozens of nations, they defeat and the Russians piss on themselves

Napoleon actually invaded Russia in this movie by sailing to canada and then along the northern coast and then he landed in Kamchatka

Совершенно верно мой друг,история циклична 🇷🇺🇷🇺

​@@kos_znamya да циклична. В данный момент идет цикл 1914 года. Когда идет война , весь мир враг - а далее революция и распад.

@@kos_znamya история повторяется и теперь Путин пытается повторить успех наполеона. Пока за 2 года с одной из сильнейших армий мира дошел до Авдеевки. Но то ли еще будет. 5-10 лет захватнической войны, пару миллионов жизней славян и до Нью Йорка дойдет, села Нью Йорк в Донецкой области недалеко от Горловки.

I had italian ancestors in both invasions in napelonic and ww2 well you know what they said about invading Russia 3rd times a charm just kidding hope I don't have to do that

​@@issstari954would be fun

My sentiments exactly

And speaking english 😅

and I thought Black Hawk Down is badddd

Yep. Stupidity and bullshit. As the whole movie.

🤣🤣🤣

it has one of three oscars that we have if im not wrong , plus it was most expensive picture in the world during decades if im not wrong

"Waterloo" 1970 by Bondararchuk is awesome too

Napoleon tv series from 2002 is also better then this movie

@@dejuren1367Back then they had.

yes

these were cossack scouts, and they were used quite frequently

А то что они в шубах в июне не смущает?)

@r.m2072 in the west of Russia? huh? You think someone would find this reasonable to bring east-asian looking people from literally other edge of continental empire? Cossack culture lies origin from slavic people, who were obviously later were interconnected with late colonisation of Siberia, the thing is the innumerous asian population haven't layed significant mark on ethnic slavs who moved there, but the question remains, why would you even bring Baikal Cossacks who's obligation was to control the river outposts in the eastern edges of the empire to the Napoleonic battlefield in the West of Russia, where the abundance of common slavic population are ready to serve and protect the land their forfathers sowed

@m i dont know what your argueing here bro it is well documented that tsar alexander used cossack scouts during the napoleanic invasion, the russian army had like 600000 people recruited from all over the empire...i dont know why they look asian in this crappy film but they were definetely being depicted as cosacks , the ambush and recon and harassment was their bread and butter

@m During the Napoleonic Wars (1799-1815), the Cossacks were Russia's unique and plentiful supply of irregular cavalry. They were employed as skirmishers, raiders and scouts, and their tactics of harassment and harrying caused great problems for Napoleon's Grand Armée as it retreated through Russia in 1812. Dont know why they looked asian in this crappy film but that is what they were in this scene .

Yes. My thought also. His life such a grand and complex situations. A movie could accurately portrait everything.

Phönix has Not the Voice of Napoleon

@@germaneurope5213 Even Napoleon could not conquer us in the Republic of Montenegro.

Agreed!

@@aneozivota5699 has nothing to do that Phoenix sounds very gay.

Еще и в валенках и дубленках!!! 🤣

Вообще-то такие шапки служили хорошим защитным шлемом от сабли. Конусообразные шапки Кивер именно были высокими для защиты головы от разрубания режущем предметом.

И трава желтая, как в конце лета хотя пишут июнь , а в декабре снега почти нет, хотя по брюхо коню должно быть.

Меховые шапки спасали от жары. Еще римляне это просекли, когда в мехах ходили по пустыням Парфянского царства

Krim Tatar

Вот кто обосрал Лувр!

It was not the Russians who entered Paris but all of Europe, supported by British gold. The Russians alone never defeated Napoleon. Borodino is a French victory: the Russian losses were much higher than the French, and with the retreat of the Russian army in the night that followed the battle, the doors of Moscow were wide open to the French. Balance sheet: huge losses Abandonment of the battlefield Moscow open city = how to interpret history to make it a victory?

@@mlipeck Territory was not important to Russia. They treated it like the Navy treats water.

@@mlipeck Actually in Wiki they said that: "The French lost about roughly the same number of soldiers as Russia". It seems correct estimation because if the victory of France was so undisputable why Napoleon later on could not win in Maloyaroslavets and had to return via the same devastated region (Smolensk). So your opinion about the huge Russian losses is not correct.

uh no he didnt flee to paris. he continued to fight in battles quoted by wellington as showing his true genius, and most of the fighting was between him prussia and austria

@@Vlad-sv8tz Strange, We don’t have the same wiki ... This is mine. Battle of Borodino French Commanders: Napoleon I Louis Nicolas Davout Michel Ney Eugène de Beauharnais Joachim Murat Russian Commanders: Mikhail Kutuzov Piotr Ivanovitch Bagration † Michel Barclay de Tolly French forces in presence 130,000 men including: 102,000 infantrymen 28,000 horsemen 587 guns Russian forces present 138,000 men including: 110,000 infantrymen 9,000 Cossacks 19,000 militias 624 guns French losses: 28,000 dead or injured 13 guns captured Russian losses: 45,000 dead or injured 100 to 200 prisoners 15 - 60 guns captured We notice that the French and allied forces were a little less numerous than the Russians. About the Battle of Maloïaroslavets: It took place on 24 October 1812 during the War of the Sixth Coalition, during the Russian Campaign, between the vanguard of the Grande Armée, commanded by Eugène de Beauharnais, and the forces of Alexander I. The Franco-Italian troops could not break through to the south, forcing Napoleon to evacuate Russia by the road already followed on the way, by a devastated region and lacking provisions, turning Russia’s retreat into a disaster. French Commanders: Eugène de Beauharnais Napoleon Bonaparte Alexis Joseph Delzons † Russian Commander: Dmitri Dokhturov Presence forces: 15,000 French and Italian against 20,000 Russians Fatalities: 5000 killed or wounded French, 6000 killed or wounded Russian We see that this battle had fatal consequences for Napoleon, but on the purely military level it cannot be compared to the battle of Borodino, and cannot represent either the demonstration of a military superiority of the Russians. The Russians never decisively defeated Napoleon: Austerlitz victory of Napoleon Eylau victory of Napoleon Friedland victory of Napoleon Borodino victory of Napoleon. Even the passage of the Berezina can be considered as a demonstration of Napoleon’s military genius. The Russians thought it was time to strike the blow and capture Napoleon. He escaped them with his Imperial Guard by making absolutely remarkable arrangements. After the disastrous retreat of Russia Napoleon managed to reassemble an army with which he would fight against the whole of Europe coalition for 1.5 years, with many victories that forced the admiration of his opponents. Its final defeat is due to numbers. And the Russian presence in Paris was only possible thanks to the uprising of an entire continent. Without the coalition of all European forces the Russians would never have succeeded. But all this does not detract from the Great Russian Patriotic Spirit who has shown on many occasions his strength and determination. But Napoleon is above men. He is one of those geniuses who transcend human history. His work is not only military. Its Civil Code has served as a model for more than 80 countries around the world! The list of all his work would be too long ...

😂😂😂

гугля кто париж брал будет казах👆

@@forestdruid2816 упоролся,монгол))))

@@forestdruid2816 🤣🤣🤣

Точик тоже чут чут брал Москву раскажыти об этам!@@forestdruid2816

This. Could’ve been dope if they took their time with it

Right after I finished watching this, I was thinking a 10 part HBO miniseries could have been amazing.

I think that this movie, no matter which direction they would take or what they would decide to do, had no hope whatsoever just because Ridley Scott was in charge. He is the first, second and third problem with this movie. Never had a chance.

This is the only idea that makes sense literally a trilogy or two parter

The idea of telling Napoleon's life, even just while in power, in a single film was ridiculous from the beginning.

He was captured. He was lucky. There was a film about how a Frenchman was captured by the peasants.

My ancestor was French) He was captured by the Cossacks who were covering the retreat of the Russian army to Moscow. He remained with them until the end of the war, then went to join the regiment in Kuban. He took a local wife and had many children. Later he took part in wars for the Kuban Cossacks. Such different fates for people from the same war.

Scott even messed up big style with the waterloo part too.

@@stevekay5486yeah - the aging Emperor was suffering from hemorrhoids for some of the day, and Scott has him leading cavalry charges - simply absurd (stick to the Duellists instead)

Ну так-то, его прототип по "Гладиатору" реально баловался гладиаторскими боями.

Погугли -римский император Коммод

Почему нет? Он конечно с шашкой наголо не скакал но командиры той эпохи брали непосредственное участие в битве на передовой

​@@user-tt6fq5tu2i Потому что Наполеон был артиллеристом, а не кавалеристом.

Однозначно. Только о жестокости партизан к французам и Толстой упоминал. Ну а в связи с событиями на Украине - объективности в фильмах, где Россия будет упомянута , не жди. Кстати от российских патриотов с "незаконченным начальным" объективности тоже не жди: они такой поросячий визг поднимают, когда узнают, что Россия и "наглосаксы" в то время были в союзных отношениях, а Наполеон обещал крепостное право отменить, ибо это "позорнейшее явление в среде образованных европейских(!) народов".

@@Shurikova666такое позорнейшее, что существовало во многих государствах Европы. Например в Австрии было отменено только в 1848 году. После революции.

@@8Celestial Суворов скончался в 1800 году. При чём здесь он?

В этот раз надо повторить все до Ламанша, чтобы не на 100 лет запомнили, а на 500!

валить надо их за слова их@@Shurikova666

Потому что на Западе не принято говорить о победах России.

True Borodino should have been shown in more detail, and Scott definitely should have shown the battle of Berezina, big bummer! So many crazy things happened there that could have been included in a dramatic reenactment of the French tragedy: - The French moved to cross the river and narrowly avoided Chichagov's men on the western Berezina bank -The engineer/ pontonier corps secretly disobeyed Napoleon's order to leave bridge building equipment behind during retreat, allowing them to bridge the Berezina when they reached it. They built 2 bridges in the cold water, some dying of hypothermia. - The massacre of cold and hungry French stragglers trying to reach bridges by the Russian vanguard - One of the bridges collapsed twice but the engineers somehow managed to repair it! - Marshal Victor's rearguard taking heavy casualties but managing to hold the Russians under Wittgenstein so the French can evacuate to the other shore. -Chichagov later caught up but not fast enough to completely stop the French on the western shore of the Berezina This is why books and documentaries are better!

I feel you, bro. I did a college presentation on Waterloo, and that battle scene was super disappointing and mediocre.

Those famous diesel engines of the Napoleonic times: ...

And you dont comment on history when you dont read history. Napolean incaded russia in june of 1812, genius. By august he was already settled in smolensk some 200 mi from moscow. Even when he occupied moscow the weatherwas reported as being mild. What you and ridley scott dont seem to get is that it was the RUSSIAN RESPONSE that kicked napoleans ass. Not the weather. Even if we backtrack to the battle of the pyramids, weather was ALWAYS an issue with the french army. Napolean lost more men to heat and desert than he did to the ottoman army. And yet we dont mention weather here. Why!? Because the ottoman army of 40000 strong lost to napoleon army of 10000 max (not even bc he split his 10 in half to to fight the british at acre) So again. What shouldve been underscored was the russian military attacking all of his supply depots, cutting off his LOC. and then using cossacks to trail his exhausted men. They also used effective scorch earth tactics that forced his army to move without food or sleep. Thats why he lost. The winter was simply a backdrop.

lost most of his troops to typhus, and logistical issues in the summer.

Спасибо за совет, начал просмотр - Клавье, конечно, потрясающий и харизматичный актёр, мне кажется более убедительным в роли Наполеона (вообще его только по комедийным ролям знал). Не в обиду Фениксу - он тоже талантливый актёр, но, видимо, сам фильм (режиссура + сценарий) слабый.

хорошо что не евреи и то ладно. поду в зеркало гляну может я тоже коренной москвич-монголоид )

смех смехом, но против французов действительно использовались крупные калмыцкие подразделения, и гипотетически можно предположить, что Скотт решил запечатлеть столкновение с одним из них )

@@rin4en Добровольческие подразделения не славянских народов, на которых не распространялась воинская повинность, появились далеко не в июне, а несколько позже. Они уже принимали участие после Бородино

в российских исторических документах легко найти информацию об участии нескольких полков калмыков в войне 1812 года, в частности одного из них - в Бородинском сражении@@user-wj4ol3xx2r

21 век! И они называют себя культурными, цивилизованными людьми.

No, the Russians lost all their battles to the French and lost their army due to Winter! And the Nomads in Russia, dozens of nations, they defeat and the Russians piss on themselves

Except for the Crimean war the Russo-Japanese war and the First World War

@@karaltar7914 ....LoL. Russia always wins back (and bigger), some years later. Same happened with those wars. The Turks, Japanese and Germans still have a kind of National PTSD today. That's why Russia's enemies perish "with the same sword".... If the enemies 'win' one round, they soon lose the entire fight, horribly.

@@karaltar7914well Crimea belongs now to Russia and during ww2 Russia destroyed all the Japanese forces that were occupying north China and took most of the Japanese northern islands 😂😂😂

@@karaltar7914 why so salty, coping much?

The presentation of the city is very strange. It looks like real building in the Kremlin (Terem Palace) with something that looks like Ukhtomsky's Red Gate (that was standing miles from the Kremlin), and with something that looks vaguely like the Mexico City Metropolitan Cathedral...

You mean the weather’s victory over France?

​@@DCBrick of course, the weather is a problem only for one side, so it was with Hitler's forces in ww2. We, Russians are in one team with weather and it has no negative effects on us. No points for you on this victory sir, it was just weather

@@user-zb4nv2hy2qthe russians are more prepared for winter, they’re used to extreme cold and the invaders ignore the climate factor a big mistake, the courage of the russian soldier is above questioning.

The list of things which the authors did wrong is very, very long.

Из медведей сделали шубы чтобы выжить в морозном июне

unfortunately, they are out from budget:)))

Где это русская земля ?

Реванш Будет 🇺🇦🇺🇸🇺🇦🇺🇸🇺🇦

До мозга костей что ни на есть русская

@@z.z1045 Поверь Орк зашифрованный ✌🏼😎🇺🇦

russians are setting their cities ablaze then?

that is startling to behold account of. napoleon led the biggest army into russia, favor was on the russian side that didnt budge as they vacated, then a blizzard drops in mid october who couldve planned that??? truly

​@@gibblewaywhen Braveheart came out everyone thought they were Scottish, then the Viking series on History channel people with 1% Scandinavian DNA thought they were Vikings, I think Mel Gibson should have played Napoleon

Soldiers always the ones who suffer the most, but I would not conclude Napoleon to megalomaniac simple out of soldiers bad fortune

thanks for the interesting comment

So... you exist because of Napoleon. Sort of.

True. Most of his army died because the supply lines were overextended, not because of the Russian winter. Invading Russia was a disaster from the start.

A huge part of his army ( not the French but the troops from the other European countries he recruited) actually deserted during the end of summer/beginning of fall. They realized that this campaign was doomed and got the hell out of Russia. But Napoleon in his hybris & arrogance, though himself invincible and his French troops still followed him without question.

Смоленская битва похоронила надежду Наполеона разбить русскую армию по частям в 16-19 Августа 1812 г. Барклаю де Толли и Багратиону угрожали разгром поодиночке. Они отступали, ведя ожесточённые арьергардные бои. Советники Александр предлагали отвести 1-ю Западную армию к лагерю близ Дриссы и принять главный удар Наполеона, а 2-я армия атаковала бы фланги и тылы врага. Но отказались в самый последний момент от плана, убедившись в правильности позиций и численном превосходстве французов. Прорыв Багратиона через Могилёв не удался. Армии успели соединиться лишь под Смоленском. Войско Наполеона растянулось, но попытка русского контрнаступления провалилась. Неверовскому удалось сдержать авангард Мюрата. Русские части укрепились в Смоленске, но не чтобы отстоять его, а для того, чтобы задержать неприятеля и переправить армию через Днепр. Им это удалось. Наполеон достался сгоревший город. Его армия уходила всё дальше от провиантских баз и растягивала коммуникации, а русская, несмотря на тяжелейшие удары, оставалась боеспособной.

Почему Наполеон шёл на Москву, если столица была в Петербурге? Он гнался за русской армией, а та отступала к Москве. Барклай де Толли пошёл на соединение с Багратионом, а дорогу на Петербург закрыл, оставив 1-й корпус Витгенштейна. Прикрывая свой левый фланг, Наполеон направил против Витгенштейна корпус Удино. Гусары Кульнева застигли врага на марше и атаковали. Французы были вынуждены остановиться в Клястицах. Не позволяя противнику сосредоточить силы, Вингенштейн развил наступление. Артиллерия Удино оказалось бессильна перед Павловскими гренадёрами, провавшимися по горящему мосту, и конницей, форсировавшей реку вброд. Удино отступал к Полоцку. Для его усиления Наполеон направил корпус Сен-Сира. Витгенштейн надёжно прикрыл Санкт-Петербург, сковал значительные силы французов и не позволил им принять участие в Бородинском сражении. Победа русских под Клястицами стала одной из первых в войне 1812 года.

Thi si Hollywood's version. In real life they would have been tattered and straggling.

Let's run back faster.

С ответным визитом в Париж из Петербурга прибыл Российский Император со своим войском😂.

This can be said about the whole movie :((

The problem with movies/shows these days is that they are all about instant gratification and shock value. They treat us (the audience) like we are dummies.

Invading Russia speedrun any %

LULE

And it took only twenty minutes to secure Omaha Beach in Saving Private Ryan. Who knew!!

europeans always die trying smth against russia

@@reimuhakurei9409 Apparently you want to tell us about the Crimean War and the siege of Sevastopol in the mid-19th century

​@@reimuhakurei9409and russians always suck in each war. In Napoleon's campaign there was weather, in wwll the US and UK saved it, in Japanese and Finland wars just lost, just like getting lost in Ukraine

​@@user-fj3nr3nv4c4% от общего объема вооружения советского союза было передано по ленд лизу. Сша и Англия помогли, но уж точно не спасли. Это им приспичило в 44 открыть второй фронт, что бы успеть хоть как то западную Европу оставить за собой

apparently about napoleonic war and ww2@@maxp5964

хорошо подмечено, тоже перематывал.

Я тоооооже. Невозможно это смотреть.

I think they are supposed to be Kalmyks(mongols) lol

@@bisratgetachew8286 They fought bro. If you look at the current Russian defense minister, you will understand. And you'll find out that Kornelov, the general of the Russian white Army. They are the only Asiatic people living in Europe.

@@danzanpurevjargal221 i know but if you are going to represent invasion of russia in 3 mins the kalmyks should not be the representatives ...unless they have an agenda to represent russia as "Asiatic hoarde".

No, the Russians lost all their battles to the French and lost their army due to Winter! And the Nomads in Russia, dozens of nations, they defeat and the Russians piss on themselves

@@danzanpurevjargal221 Shoigu is from Tuva though and that's in Asia.

basically NATO

Don't mess with Russia. The message is still valid

same as in 2023 but now they have the O$

@@user-bi9jq8eu4j I think overall 650k invaded to 225k on the Russian side.

Logistics is always what makes or breaks an army. He would have done better to withdraw to a city on the coast of the Baltic and resume his assault in the spring. Taking Moscow doomed his army.

Об этом не снимут. Западники всегда стараются замылить свои провалы и обесценить наши успехи.

The jungles of vetinam were far worse men chopped to pieces by 50 cal fire

.50 cal fire? lol @@45thnewsbrigade-tacticalop60

On the flip side though, you had better medical treatment and off duty life (an economy with products you could buy to make you happy, etc.) during napoleonic times, they didn’t even know about germs. Let that sink in

>Ancient battle tactics >ancient mate, this was like 200 hundred years ago. Literally fucking nothing compared to human history. also movie got everything wrong. No one was fighting like this.

@@45thnewsbrigade-tacticalop60Subjective opinion

You do not know that those 20 nations sent him to get rid of him!!! And you are so deceived that do not ask how it was that those who supported him with weaponry fought him afterward!! They have fooled you!!!

No, netflix would make Napoleon a black lesbian.

In each new episode, he will take his ass out of Russia

​@@Callahan757575ahahahaha

John David Washington as Napoleon.

@@Callahan757575bru 😂😂😂😂😂

Agree! 👍🏼

I suggest looking up (if you already haven't) the four part Napoleon documentaries on the KZfaq channel People's Profiles

And they would've made more money. More story telling time, more detail and more films! More people taking an interest in history!

Ты бесспорно прав

Да какой Макрон - Бонапарт! Всё, за что брался, провалил. "Жёлтые жилеты" бьются с полицией во французских городах. Влияние в Африке потеряно. Всё, что он может - петушиться во всех смыслах этого слова.

Yes. The movie is rushed af

This movie suck ass. Battles were too over simplified and small scale. Everyone was barely using formation or their fkin guns. The patriot was actually better at battle scenes lmao. Napoleon wasn't charismatic at all. I dont see anyone following this awkward ahh emperor of a man. Ridley scott rlly englishfied Napoleon

Napoleon in this movie? “What is Spain?”

@@ogeraldo1388Haven't even seen the movie yet and just said this to myself watching this lol

Praying this gets cleared up in director's cut

😂😮😅Да, но мало кто знает об этом. Сейчас в школах этому не учат.

november is pretty cold tho !

​@@GenevybesДа холодный!! Но это осень!!! Зима ещё впереди!!! Вот там холодно. 😅😊😮😊😅

What about master mind tactical warfare general Kutuzov who defeated Napolean

Yeah, they never talk about Kutuzov who is historically considered the most successful general in the history. Can't make proper depiction if your writing is mediocre.

This is nowhere near as good as the 1967 movie

​@@jacktattisisn't that what he said?

@@justincohen4823 Yes and I was agreeing.

@@jacktattis gotcha 👍🏾

Few minutes for Borodino...not a good job.

And in 2 years Russia can't finish a invasion of a country right next door .

3000 самолётов, 2.600.000 солдат, 6.000 танков были уничтожены у захватчика. На этот раз город был спасён. Эта сражение невероятного масштаба.

​@@johnysky6066 Мужчина из США намного умнее. Деньги, деньги и ещё раз деньги. Это хорошая инвестиция в наше общие благополучие. Только я тут главный. Мне положено по закону больше как и моим друзьям по бизнесу. Ничего личного.

@@johnysky6066 the Mexican-American vlogger who is now living fruitfully in Siberia?

100 years later a German man defeated Russia 😂

It was necessary to save the army of Russia. Napoleon did not even think about how to protect his empire. It was a defeat.

Napo was scared to retreat oyver the same land he ravaged for supplies on the advance to Moscow. He was probably correct, but somehow, the French didn't have maps? ot a route to the South. In the end he had to run back the road they knew. It's a mis-statement that Napo lost 500,000 men. He only fielded 200,000+ at Borodino. All the other units where guarding the flanks. Flanks that were 800 miles long, EACH. There are a lot of war diaries online that describe the actions on the flanks. Dialy harrassments. My fav is the little town that was "walled" in history, they'd let small groups of scavaging French in, hst and feed them. Then slaughter them at night. There is a lot of info with the Austrians fighting sevearl battles on the Southern Flank.

@@SuperChuckRaney Do you have any links for some of those diaries?

@@alexgaelsotorodriguez3870 no but there is one that survives that details the sicknesses they had as the walked back from Moscow. Seems most of the men had lice, those lice carry the deseases like ticks do. Sooo, based on those entries, they exhumed some men buried in a common grave. There clothes were FULL of dead lice. There are a few you tube vids of this

Вырезали Бородино, т.к. это был фактически проигрыш Наполеона - он не смог уничтожить русскую армию.

Это вы еще не видели что они из Карениной сделали)

I thought it was only noticed in Russia)

Whole europe unites against russia every century? 😂

One in a century ?

@@Gutvald Once. Like one time per period of time. I

@@BGSGBF when did whole europe unite against russia in war?

Долгих лет Германии тоже!

20 народов. "Двунадесять языков"

не сэкономили, а разворовали бюджет. Классика киножанра. Киноделы зарабатывают во время съёмок.

😂👍

@@mars4964black LGBT non binary woman

How russian's 10-th grader read War and Pease by L. Tolstoy Boys: Read only battles, skip high society life Girls: Read only high society life, skip battles

@@mvenmass💯💯

​@mvenmass Yep when I first read War and Peace, it was said to be a difficult book to read. I skipped the high society stuff and the political jibber jabber and read the battle scenes. That was when I was 18. I then started reading Bernard Cornwell's Sharpe series set in the Napoleonic Wars. It too goes into the politics and high society and stuff. But I was also watching the Sharpe TV series. So I read everything and loved it. Have recently read War and Peace all the way through and loved it.

His relationship was used as a vehicle to show who he was as a person. If you wanted a Michael Bay movie you picked the wrong one.

@@jessepassage425 From the trailers I expected to see lots of napoleons conquers. His rise and fall in his battles and tactics. I understand the political part and relationship, but felt like we got too much of that and too little of what people truly remember Napoleon by: An Emperor of the French Revolution.

This movie was made from a completed Netflix TV series with one hour edited out .Hopefully when the full TV series is shown with the extra hour added back in it will improve .

They actually made a series, but not this type, but a better one

worst movie i've seen in a long time. it took everything to complete it

"commanders have better things to do than to try and kill one another"

Watch war and peace. Great Soviet Film.

Ridley Scott is also a has been. This should have been a series not a movie.

at some point he apparently complained about the script to Ridley Scott. I really hope he was complaining about how dogshit this script was and not because he was the one who actually made this script happen

@@Elliesbow This movie was made from a completed Netflix TV series with one hour edited out .Hopefully when the full TV series is shown with the extra hour added back in it will improve .

I would have liked to have seen William Shatner as napoleon

@@Crashed131963 Apple TV not Netflix and I still think it will be shit. Just more scenes with Josephine

Come to Cleveland

Its a Russian tactic, keep people around you underestimating you, what do you think Putin is doing, Nato expands into ukraine covid breaks out, cripples american & europes economy, has enough hypersonic nukes 10 times over to level all of europe & america

Raise you New Orleans

@@reycesarcarino4653 Detroit

@@brittking3990 Katrina says otherwise

People see just as much and do more their stories are best

Why do you want to hear from horses when humans have eyes, a bigger brain, live longer and also saw the same events?

​@@tyrellcobb4665 but humans lie a lot and distort stories

I’ve often wondered and felt a bit sad about that!

The use of horses in war over thousands of years of warfare was the most extreme form of animal cruelty and suffering . And often the reward for all their hard work and dedication and suffering for their human masters was to be rewarded by being killed and eaten . Such a tragedy

😂 🇲🇫💪 vive la France .

Napoleão também disse, depois de voltar da Rússia: "do Grande ao ridículo é apenas um passo..." 1812.

Для Наполеона, как и для других диктаторов, люди были мусором. По моему про Наполеоне погибло около 3 миллионов человек, сущий пустяк для "великого человека".

🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺💪🏻💪🏻

annihilated. There i completed your sentence.

Truth be told he was defeated in Russia 🇷🇺 ,he went to Russian with 600,000 men and returned with only 40,000 ,560,000 men loosed their lives that shit is crazy !!

​@@jermainemyles1825 It's the untold deaths that really baffles the mind. During his attack and retreat both sides from Russia to western Europe used none stop scorched earth tactics. The troops might as well of all stayed home and just starved their own populations. The warfare was mass murder. The tactics were mass murder. Culling peasants . That's all it ever was, ww1 and 2 were no different. Mass culls of peasants.

@@jermainemyles1825 All of his defeats from 1813-1815 occurred because he himself scuttled his Grande Armée and had only inexperienced teenagers left to enlist. Without 1812, the Bonapartes would still reign over a large part of Europe today.

Победа в войне 1812 года - заслуга не только генералов и солдат, но и организованной системы снабжения. Её возглавлял Егор Канкрит, генерал-интендант 1-й Западной армии. План обеспечения армии продовольствием, фуражом и снаряжением составляли заранее. По направлению к западной границе были построены военные дороги, склады - >, укомплектованы части для их охраны и сопровождения обозов. Это помогло на первом этапе. Чтобы избежать грабежей, реквизиции у местных жителей проводились под расписку. Впоследствии казна приняла их в счёт налогов. Губернии жертвовали деньги, транспорт, продукты. Так, Псковская губерния оказала помощь воюющему на её территории корпусу Витгенштейна на 14 млн рублей. Тяжёлую зиму 12 года армии помогло пережить снабжение из южных аграрных губерний. Канкрину даже удалось сэкономить: из выделенных на войну 426 мил было потрачено около 400. Почему из-за санкций на территории Казахстана запрещено смотреть фильм про Наполеона. Мне очень интересно. В какой стране я мог бы посмотреть фильм про Наполеона. Я бы купил билеты в эту страну. Во всех странах Азии запретили показывать фильм про Наполеона. Это национальное достояние всей Западной Европы. Запретить. Почему вы не хотите поделиться своими фильмами с нами? Вы там были? Хотели? Попробуйте?

Наполеон начал военную службу как артиллерист. Он считал: > и не раз доказывал это. Нельзя было отставать и России. Да! Да! Накануне войны 1813 года русская артиллерия стала одной из самых передовых в Европе - благодаря успешной реформы. Удалось добиться единообразного вооружения армии, ввели стандарт на производство оружия и материальной части, орудийные команды начали готовить по единой системе. Скорострельность была в 2 раза выше, чем у французов: от установки оружия до самого выстрела проходило не более 30 секунд. Тактика артиллерии в атаке: дуэль с батареями противника, чтобы не дать обстреливать наступающие войска. В обороне главные цели - атакующая пехота и кавалерия врага. Пешая артиллерия - батарейная и линейная - поддерживала пехоту. Конная - могла определить помочь кавалерии. Модернизированная артиллерия стала грозной силой - настоящим > Война - это в первую очередь наука. Умереть на войне много ума не надо. Храбрости недостаточно. Побеждает тот кто лучше учился.

No mention of the great redoubt charges. No mention of napoleons refusal to send in his guard, no massive charges into the complex Russian trenches. Granted this is probably still the best depicted battle in the movie

@@eddiemoran8044 This movie is not a blow by blow documentary depicting the minute intricacies of Napoleonic battles. It's a character study about the big man himself. If you fail to grasp that, you're a bigger fool than old Boney was.

​@@claremontcowboy7409 funny how it's a character study that completely neglects the real attributes napoleon was described to have. This isn't a character study it's a hit piece

YT search "War and Peace, Part Three". Its epic Soviet move with english subtitles inspired by Leo Tolstoy's War and Peace novel. Almost all this part is about Borodino battle and all movie is about russian perspective of 1812 war with Napoleon. I dont think we will see better movie version about Borodino battle that this in our life time.

@@claremontcowboy7409 a charcuterie study about the greatest tactical commander of modern history. Yet they don’t show any of his tactics. Neither in this battle nor any others. As for his character outside of warfare they complete mangled what any person remotely familiar with the real man would’ve known. No showcase of his political manuevers. A complete skip over of Talleyrand. And the whole Josephine story was overblown. And you swoop as low as to call somone names as a point of argument. If anyone is the fool it’s you my friend.

Well, not without nukes anyway.

​@@scottb4579Did u hear about dead hand?)) Mudachila))

@@scottb4579 Which it still has over 4000 at its disposal, son

Russia was conquered in World War I.

Кем​@@InternetDarkLord

That’s because napoleon is a British national who betrayed britain

It's made primarily for an American audience. They aren't going to have him speaking French because then no one would see it, and having him speak English with a phony French accent would have been stupid. He wasn't even a native French speaker anyway. He was Corsican, so his native language was Italian. He always spoke French with an Italian accent, which really would have confused audiences.

🤣🤣🤣

@@kitchenaidwhiskeyjones People hate reading movie subs for almost 3 hours .

@@Crashed131963 Exactly why they just went ahead and used English. 🤷

Means the movie was bad lol.

No, the Russians lost all their battles to the French and lost their army due to Winter! And the Nomads in Russia, dozens of nations, they defeat and the Russians piss on themselves

😂😂😂 Я поздравляю тебя. Ты даже не представляешь как тебе повезло стать частью истории. Это лучше чем фильмы смотреть в 3D. Освободи людей из Центральной части страны, защити людей из Восточной страны от Западной части страны. Только не надо там всё смешивать. Они уже и без вас там все перемешались. Главное не давай чужеземцам ползать у себя на заднем дворе. Осваивай территорию. Скажи спасибо Ленину за наше счастливое будущее. Следующие поколение обязательно всё развалит, продаст. Чтобы было интереснее жить. Наверное лучше работать на благо общества, семьи.

Меня всегда интересно было - почему великие империи вторгались в Россию? Чего они тут забыли? Мы не лезем же к ним. Почему они так быстро забыли как погибли их империи?

​@@lmagine_sky2920в случае с Наполеоном, Россия первая шла войной на Францию, причём несколько раз.

Don't make sense because there are many genes from europe and asia on your land You as an example could be from england, denmark, sweden or ireland

The true cold, with temperatures around -20 degrees at night, only happened after Napoleon had left the army, when the last remnants of what had been the Grande Armée staggered back onto Prussian territory. During the retreat, the weather had even been comparably warm - the Berezina was not frozen. Extreme bad luck for the French.

@@josefavomjaaga6097 -30-40 degrees, my friend. -20 is quite usual for Russian Winter. Just put on your hat

And the moral of the story is : Don't fuck with mother Russia ! Russia defeated the french empire, the Ottoman empire and the third reich !

​@@Dead4ev1 it was the winter cold that got napoleons men killed

@@luvbootys of course it did. French soldiers, germans soldiers all of them died only because of the cold 🤡.

yes, the winter killed many men over many different wars. @@luvbootys

@@Dead4ev1 winter comes every year