Is Miraculous Queerbaiting?

  Рет қаралды 109,534

Smarty Pants

Smarty Pants

Күн бұрын

Hey so yeah. Spicy vid incoming dawg. Miraculous and the LGBT community. Should be a perfect fit you'd think. After all, new age cartoon/animated shows are breaking ground in representation. Cept, maybe Miraculous is lagging behind in more ways than one, and needlessly baiting the fanbase in the process. So enjoy. Have fun in the comments.

Пікірлер: 1 300
@tytotech9498
@tytotech9498 Жыл бұрын
I lost my mind at "Gabe's moved on from abusing his own child but now he's abusing ALL the children." What an incredible line.
@Darek-Micheal
@Darek-Micheal Жыл бұрын
yes
@emelylassiter3523
@emelylassiter3523 Жыл бұрын
Yeah it was bad enough that he had love obsession with Emily that he decided he wanted to hurt the people of Paris just for that but now he really wants to hurt the people of Paris like even if it screws his chance to revive Emily
@OpticalSorcerer
@OpticalSorcerer Жыл бұрын
It always frustrated me that none of Adrien's friends recognized how abusive Gabriel was; they just saw him as overbearing/stuffy.
@glimmerstantroop46321
@glimmerstantroop46321 Жыл бұрын
It's true and I want to slap him for it
@riotkitty
@riotkitty Жыл бұрын
I’m okay with that. Some of dem kids need their butts whipped
@darriongeorge5137
@darriongeorge5137 Жыл бұрын
Juleka and rose felt natural but ms bustier felt force with the pregnancy and how the storyboard made it look like she had a husband
@littlesparrow303
@littlesparrow303 Жыл бұрын
There are donors that lesbian couples can go to have a baby
@Blacknight6577
@Blacknight6577 Жыл бұрын
@@littlesparrow303 true but it’s not unnatural and obvious for anyone to think she had a husband in the first place cus sperm come from males aka men/husbands
@stefaniarusso
@stefaniarusso Жыл бұрын
​@@littlesparrow303 yeah totally agree 👍 👌 💯
@riotkitty
@riotkitty Жыл бұрын
Yeah…I’ll agree with Ms Busiter. Correct me if I’m wrong, but it did appear she had a husband from the storyboards. The wife was slapped on just cause.
@riotkitty
@riotkitty Жыл бұрын
@@FlawPinkin the storyboards, as I said. Also in the show’s English summaries she’s addressed as “Ms.” (Dunno about any other language tho)
@jules6735
@jules6735 Жыл бұрын
“Gabe and his long term obsession with Emily’s frozen corpse” Why did you have to put it that way🤣🤣🤣
@daughterofchatblanc
@daughterofchatblanc Жыл бұрын
Well...yes and no. In my opinion rose and juleka have more representation from season 1 to the present than any other queer relationship in the show but that's because cheek kisses, hugs or holding hands and things like that are for some reason easier to sell as "just friends" when it's between girls. I strongly doubt it was unintentional that Marc is in a separate class so that he naturally appears less and they don't have to make such touchy feely moments between marc and Nathaniel 😒 Even though canonically all 4 of those characters are queer, for the majority of the seasons their representation has been obliterated by bullshit like censorship in different countries that could have hindered the show's success so those relationships were mainly baited until season 5 when I think they gained the safety net of the show being successful enough for them to be a bit more blatant about it. So it's not so much queerbaiting as it is poor representation, since these relationships were confirmed by the writers as opposed to them being canonically straight but having shippable moments.
@kainightshade5033
@kainightshade5033 Жыл бұрын
True! I don't believe Miraculous is purposely trying to queerbait. They just have other audiences to contend with. That scene with Mrs. Bustier and her wife was cut out from so many countries. I imagine on the teams part it's difficult to juggle all of that.
@MusLaboratoris
@MusLaboratoris Жыл бұрын
I agree, censorship is main reason. No show wants to end like the Owl House - almost cancelled with short as possible finale season, just because it was too rainbow for Disney.
@jemandd1123
@jemandd1123 Жыл бұрын
i think that marc was supposed to be in the same class since nathaniel is the only one without a seat neighbour but i guess they werent allowed to do it back in season 1 since disney was very against gay back in 2015 (and still is but lesser). I really hope that in season 6 when theyll all go to a new school marc will also be in the same class.
@ericius-yy4md
@ericius-yy4md Жыл бұрын
​@@jemandd1123 marc is a year younger, so he will appear even less in future seasons. yay representation 🎉
@kairenatus
@kairenatus Жыл бұрын
I mean, I thought that too, but then they made Rose have a relationship with the Prince and it just felt like her and Juleka had just been baited the Whole Time and it wasn't just them having to "censor" it. Putting her in that relationship confirmed that they weren't actually dating. I pretty much dipped after that. It was so unneeded and kind of felt like a slap in the face to the queer fans felt represented by them.
@joeljohansson3615
@joeljohansson3615 Жыл бұрын
Many people have been asking how miss bustier is pregnant if she's with a woman. Seems like this show makes people forget about artificial ways like sperm donar.
@littlesparrow303
@littlesparrow303 Жыл бұрын
They weren't properly educated on how there are other ways on making a baby
@stefaniarusso
@stefaniarusso Жыл бұрын
​@@littlesparrow303 agree
@r.c.8268
@r.c.8268 Жыл бұрын
The problem with lesbian couples with childrens is that you have to explain how was it possible, because that is an event that does not occur naturally, that is a problem in another serie, the dragon prince where the queen of one of the countries of the alliance, is the daughter of a lesbian couple in a medival magical world
@shanenanigans27
@shanenanigans27 Жыл бұрын
People are stupid. I once saw a gay couple on Instagram who had a kid, and all the comments just were full of "how did you have a baby? gay people can't have babies! This is woke propaganda!" There were other people responding with the possibilities such as adoption, sperm donors, surrogacy, but the person kept not listening and kept just saying "No that doesn't exist, two men and two women can't have a real baby." Some people just refuse to even try to understand people different from them. And that's that. The funny thing is that single women and lesbian women were not legally allowed to get sperm donations in France (only women with husbands could) until 2021, so it wasn't legally possible for most of the show's run. I wonder if making Mrs. Bustier sapphic was a timely political move on the writer's part to show their support for medically assisted pregnancies for lesbians.
@lisaweyh-gsell4214
@lisaweyh-gsell4214 Жыл бұрын
​@R. C. If children are old enough to be explained how babies are naturally made they're old enough to learn how to make them alternatively.
@SKStar-zf3vn
@SKStar-zf3vn Жыл бұрын
I just want a Marc and Nathaniel episode. Is that too much to ask?
@stefaniarusso
@stefaniarusso Жыл бұрын
Yeah I agree
@alessandrolamera8857
@alessandrolamera8857 Жыл бұрын
I missed a thing. How and when Marc and Nathaniel became a couple.
@Orkprof
@Orkprof Жыл бұрын
​@@alessandrolamera8857 it was never shown or said on screen, but we may assume it happened after "Reverser" (Marc's first appearance). The two start working on their own comic (Nath draws, Marc writes) and since then they almost always appear on screen together. Though I'm pretty sure the only reason they're considered an item by the fandom is bc someone (more or less connected with the authors) on social media said Marc's non-binary.
@Orkprof
@Orkprof Жыл бұрын
@S.K Star IMHO they wasted a great opportunity for that in "Penalteam". The two boys got a lot of screen time in that episode, it would've fit perfectly.
@alessandrolamera8857
@alessandrolamera8857 Жыл бұрын
@@Orkprof so it’s just speculation? And I thought the only thing they wasted of Marc it’s his green goblinesque villain appearance that got wasted by a terrible villain design.
@DarkEmissary617
@DarkEmissary617 Жыл бұрын
Yeah I understand your frustration. This show really has it hard enough with how strict France is already. Their censorship can be overkill in areas.
@stefaniarusso
@stefaniarusso Жыл бұрын
Agreed
@dylansharp8471
@dylansharp8471 Жыл бұрын
Say what now?
@arnaudgerard1971
@arnaudgerard1971 Жыл бұрын
Are you french?
@TheUnamedOne832
@TheUnamedOne832 Жыл бұрын
I'm curious on the eaxt details of how
@swymaj02
@swymaj02 Жыл бұрын
I would've thought that France were kl with Queen characters.
@JustLP2000
@JustLP2000 Жыл бұрын
I honestly was okay with representation through Rose and Juleka from the previous seasons just expecting them to naturally grow, I wouldn't have considered this show lacking in this regard until that horrible moment in Migration. "I love Juleka... And all my friends" is so cowardish, either go through with it or don't tease it in such a way, seriously...
@glimmerstantroop46321
@glimmerstantroop46321 Жыл бұрын
Agreed, Julerose before this season was honestly fine imo but then they decide to give everyone a major slap in the face for no reason
@Someone-qi1rr
@Someone-qi1rr Жыл бұрын
Just accept that girls can be bffs. Stop being weidd
@daisanity6457
@daisanity6457 11 ай бұрын
​@@Someone-qi1rr Bro I can literally list multiple female and female friendships in the show bruh
@nevaehhamilton3493
@nevaehhamilton3493 6 ай бұрын
​@@Someone-qi1rr you're disgusting. You and the rest of the homophobes
@StillSomeone
@StillSomeone 4 ай бұрын
@@Someone-qi1rrAnd they can be, like Marinette and Alya. But Juleka and Rose are always depicted romantically without full on saying it. If a bunch of sets of two are doing something, it’s always the couples and then Rose and Juleka. If they’re doing a slow dance, there’s Nino and Alya, Ivan and Mylène, most likely Marinette and Adrien, and then also Rose and Juleka Oh, also it was pretty much confirmed by Thomas Astruc on Twitter, so…
@shanenanigans27
@shanenanigans27 Жыл бұрын
I'm really tired of LGBT relationships being a shocking twist almost every time. They did it in the American special and now with Zoe. Any other LGBT couple gets only hints but no explicit confirmation.
@nothoughtsheadempty5456
@nothoughtsheadempty5456 Жыл бұрын
considering that lbgt community is. minority and it is hard for them to come out, it does make sense that most lgbt situationships would only be hinted. you would see similar type “queer coding” in various shows, not just miraculous ladybug. besides, the main storyline is about ladybug and monarch so why would they focus so much on the side characters rekationships
@nothoughtsheadempty5456
@nothoughtsheadempty5456 Жыл бұрын
@@shanenanigans27 ok and no one asked for your original comment either. its a free world and i can say whatever i want so sue me bitch
@ryenguy
@ryenguy 10 ай бұрын
@@nothoughtsheadempty5456 i'd argue being a minority is actually more of a reason to show these type of dynamics and relationships. also you're assuming you can't have one without the other. if the miraculous team had any competent writing staff left (if astruc hasn't fired them all already) it wouldn't be hard to do both. have an episode dedicated to marinette and adrien. then have an episode dedicated to juleka and rose. what's so difficult?
@Justshadow451
@Justshadow451 9 ай бұрын
Me too I got so pissed of when I saw the lbgtq shit
@shanenanigans27
@shanenanigans27 9 ай бұрын
@@Justshadow451 No no, I'm not being homophobic, go away rat.
@CassieIsGae
@CassieIsGae Жыл бұрын
The thing about Ms B's wife. She had NO MENTION up until she was shown. No pictures, no hints at her being queer up until confirmation. But also, I just want one episode ONE EPISODE focusing on the relationship between Rose and Julika. Like how they got together, and how they act as a couple
@marcusclark1339
@marcusclark1339 11 ай бұрын
this, its very apparent she wasn't and the moment they decided to queer bait they half ass it in a way that can be written out of the scenes at any point
@riotkitty
@riotkitty Жыл бұрын
If there’s any character I would call queer bait, it’s Zoe. No such indication she liked Marinette in a romantic way until the episode where she decided to confess. This means nothing because it’s not unique to her, Marinette had her own harem at that point, and Adrien and her are already going out, so there’s no tension of “yes or no” either. The viewers already know Marinette will say no. Basically no point. Not to mention she’s bait for people to hate Chloe…but that’s a different topic. 😅
@riotkitty
@riotkitty Жыл бұрын
⁠​⁠@@FlawPink so nothing that can be taken as romantic then? Cool.
@riotkitty
@riotkitty Жыл бұрын
⁠​⁠@@FlawPink blushing equates to many different things. Embarrassment, anger, sadness, happiness, excitement. There’s no reason for me to think it was romantic in any way. And I bet you that she will once again fade into the background of irrelevancy with no crush on anyone. That’s bait.
@winter-starlight
@winter-starlight Жыл бұрын
That isn't what queerbaiting is.
@riotkitty
@riotkitty Жыл бұрын
@@winter-starlight Brought up proper in a single episode, immediately irrelevant, adds nothing, and never brought up again. Sounds like bait to me. It’s fine if people disagree with me, that’s just how I see it. Zoe Lee is even more a living embodiment of bait than she already was.
@playererror4044
@playererror4044 Жыл бұрын
I mean I was guessing Zoe might be gay in her first episode... a crush on Marrinette, well I thought they'd be cute but I never actually thought it would happen (Then again I expect nothing from this show, it's the best way to enjoy it)
@njivwathomassilavwe2056
@njivwathomassilavwe2056 Жыл бұрын
I honestly pegged Zoe as a lesbian from her very first episode. Marinette has too much rizz
@kainightshade5033
@kainightshade5033 Жыл бұрын
FRRRRRRRR not to mention our main girl Mari is sapphic
@FeligamiAdrizoeSworaBunnydoll
@FeligamiAdrizoeSworaBunnydoll Жыл бұрын
I honestly think Zoe is Pansexual. But to each their own.😅😊
@kainightshade5033
@kainightshade5033 Жыл бұрын
@@FeligamiAdrizoeSworaBunnydoll She's the colors of the pan flag 😭😭
@tree12branch
@tree12branch Жыл бұрын
marizznette
@crystalmuffyn
@crystalmuffyn Жыл бұрын
@@tree12branch NAHH 💀
@theresivy
@theresivy Жыл бұрын
because of course zoe goes for marinette lmao, why not literally any other girl. might as well say the entire character roster of the show has a crush on mari
@kainightshade5033
@kainightshade5033 Жыл бұрын
This is accurate. Everyone simps for Marinette 🤣 I can only wish to be a magnet like that 🫠
@carlwheezer2808
@carlwheezer2808 Жыл бұрын
they shoulda made chloe crush on marinette, and she was jealous of adriend stealing her attention. THAT would be interesting
@nicolas._.2294
@nicolas._.2294 Жыл бұрын
Becs Marinette is a Mary Sue
@marocat4749
@marocat4749 Жыл бұрын
​​yes !!! And sabrina on chloe and choe be abusive there, could be interesting.
@glimmerstantroop46321
@glimmerstantroop46321 Жыл бұрын
True and I kinda hate it
@erithrone
@erithrone Жыл бұрын
It's rare for me to completely agree with a video, but you have such a perfect take on this. You're right. There is absolutely _no_ reason they should be refraining on showing canon rose/juleka and marcthaniel, while we get to see ships like ivan/mylene be so open. We got a whole ass episode about kim and that fish girl. Yet _so_ many episodes centric on rose or juleka, and we've never even gotten to see a love confession or kiss. "Confirmation on twitter" is a joke of excuse. Can you believe that one episode that came out recently? "I love Juleka...... and marinette and nino and alya." Are you fucking serious? You may aswell call me a slur. Showing bg queer characters genuinely feels like a "here's your representation, now shut up." And I say all this as a queer person myself.
@glimmerstantroop46321
@glimmerstantroop46321 Жыл бұрын
Completely agree
@michalelkin-bronner7958
@michalelkin-bronner7958 Жыл бұрын
but rose serpertred friends form you so
@michalelkin-bronner7958
@michalelkin-bronner7958 Жыл бұрын
@@glimmerstantroop46321 rose serperted friends form juleka though
@the13thgoogler
@the13thgoogler Жыл бұрын
I feel like if there's gonna be an LGBTQ relationship in a show, there needs to be build up, like most well written other couples. Just a few mentions that a character is a attracted to a certain gender is good enough. Just telegraph it, cause unlike real-life, a show's world feels linear so if you threw a curve ball suddenly, the fans are not gonna catch it and they're gonna feel like they've been cheated.
@lecommentar9851
@lecommentar9851 Жыл бұрын
Or just introduce it like you'd introduce a straight relationship. It shouldn't be flashy both for the sake of it being equal and also not annoying
@AmyRoseApologist
@AmyRoseApologist Жыл бұрын
The owl house did it right
@Multi-FandomMadness
@Multi-FandomMadness Жыл бұрын
@@AmyRoseApologist I WAS GONNA SAY THIS Also yay another toh fan
@MeemahSN
@MeemahSN Жыл бұрын
@@AmyRoseApologist until Disney decided it wasn’t good enough and cut the show short.
@marocat4749
@marocat4749 Жыл бұрын
Just have alexis have a crush on ladybug. And play it out. I dont think she has any more definition, and then ask ,i dont know. Also cant that red raired artist be gay treated. Why not.
@OpticalSorcerer
@OpticalSorcerer Жыл бұрын
Marc and Nathaniel was such a throwaway relationship. I'd have enjoyed him and Marinette dating for a bit before parting amicably and Nathaniel and Marc get together.
@littlesparrow303
@littlesparrow303 Жыл бұрын
Yes!! In S1 I did ship Nathaniel and Marinette because I felt that they would have been cute too and then explore more for Nat. Apparently he is bisexual at this point too
@stefaniarusso
@stefaniarusso Жыл бұрын
​@@littlesparrow303 I agree with you 👍 💯 👌
@OpticalSorcerer
@OpticalSorcerer Жыл бұрын
@@littlesparrow303 In retrospect, I really wish: 1. Nathaniel obsessed over Marinette like she obsesses over Adrien. 2. Nathaniel's actions showed Marinette how invasive she's been with Adrien and she lets up.
@arnaudgerard1971
@arnaudgerard1971 Жыл бұрын
I'm sorry, I've never seen the chemistry. Compared to Rose and Juleka. Maybe a little bit in Penalteam. In season 4 / 5 they had some moments, but they were mostly overshadowed by the cringe they then put in the efforts to pressure Marinette and Adrien together. I'd say, the cutest so far besides Penalteam is Gabriel Agreste, with their diorama(s) :)
@emelylassiter3523
@emelylassiter3523 Жыл бұрын
I have never ship Marinette and nathiel 1.just like with lukanette I ship Marinette with adrien at all costs even over relationships she has with that's way more healthy 2.i don't care about nathiel and yeah his superhero costume is well not bad but really not my kind of superhero costume and yeah it was his and Marc's idea for Marinette to dress up like a man ah geez I get that if you really love her you accept her not looking good but wanting her to not look good? Ha and yeah the way you drew the disguise on the knight of your comic book it's terrible I would have ripped it if I was in one of the people of the groups places and Marinette has no overactions to it when nathiel gave the idea for her to dress like a man she sounds so excited like she actually likes to dress up like a man and yeah we don't even get a sence were she takes the suit and mustache off and she's like finally that butler outfit was disgusting and nathiel makes a comic with her (in her butler uniform) and instead of overacting she's laughing Ha so called "fashion designer" I'm glad that you actually regret it I know it because in presation you are all like that's it no more mustache desiguses yeah that's what I wanted to here that's your way of saying oh why did I even feel like I enjoyed dressing like a man? I'm a 'fashion designer' and fashion designers hate to look disgusting and yeah that's the only episode that I wish chole kept her redemption on because yeah she is the person that munplativated her and her friends to do so I'd rather have a character I don't like look good then a character I do like looking good and yeah I wish season 1 chole came back while Marinette and adrien were dating and yeah I would have any problems with the Gabriel argreste episode if Marinette hasn't sneaked into the house dressed like a man or dressed like a man overreacting and yeah at least take the mustache off I consider not take the suit off in front of everyone as everyone would see her nakket and yeah as a Lila zombie AND one of her of her "friends" 'stalking' her and adrien on their romance and 3.he compared her to chole it's better than kimnette but not one of my top ships
@impaster2166
@impaster2166 Жыл бұрын
Wow. There's a lot of canon ships in the show that revolve around long-term obsessions.
@arctixthefoxix8265
@arctixthefoxix8265 2 ай бұрын
Ikr and its unhealthy too their telling kids that its normal
@empirestate8791
@empirestate8791 Жыл бұрын
Nothing ever happens in Miraculous. Rose and Juleka's relationship moving slowly isn't queerbaiting, it's just the Miraculous writers doing their usual thing, where every plot point takes several years to be resolved.
@glimmerstantroop46321
@glimmerstantroop46321 Жыл бұрын
That makes a fair amount of sense ig
@atlashaugen4219
@atlashaugen4219 Жыл бұрын
literally. People need to realize that queerbaiting isn't characters being canonically queer but aren't in a relationship yet like.. single people exist. If someone being queer is canon then it automatically isn't queerbaiting. Yes, even if your favorite ship never gets showed
@playererror4044
@playererror4044 Жыл бұрын
The Owl House ruined a lot of romances for me in shows like this. I'm not interested in slow drawn out relationships anymore, I like seeing couples together. Also I am 100% done with baiting like this, beccause I've seen it done properly now and it just doesn't hit like this anymore.
@glimmerstantroop46321
@glimmerstantroop46321 Жыл бұрын
For me it's "Phineas and Ferb" with Phinebella. Also Juleka and Rose are my two favourite characters, them being used for queerbaiting is painful and annoying
@playererror4044
@playererror4044 Жыл бұрын
​@@glimmerstantroop46321 they are also my faves and yeah.... It's infuriating
@matthewcloyd8413
@matthewcloyd8413 Жыл бұрын
Honestly for a second it sounded like you were dissing Lumity but yeah I see what you're saying
@sunglory4488
@sunglory4488 Жыл бұрын
And I can never get over the fact how they ended Zoe's confession episode, I was like Come on! All these beautiful sayings! "love has no boundaries, no limitation, love conquers all!" How could they let these sayings go to being eye sparkles at the end.. Man so sad😖
@emelylassiter3523
@emelylassiter3523 Жыл бұрын
Yeah and I think the reason cat is the way he is around ladybug is because of the amount of years he has been locked in his home his father not teaching him must be why he's so dumb and blind sense Marinette got a backstory of why she's the way she is around adrien AND cat noir then give adrien a backstory of why he was falling in love with someone for skill rather than personality it's about time the boys get what the girls get this Is making Thomas struck look more like a girly man than a grown man child I hope he does something to prove that half of him is a manly man
@sunglory4488
@sunglory4488 Жыл бұрын
@@emelylassiter3523 well actually since season 2 when they just let Chloe's redemption arc go to waste, I lost the idea that it will gonna please me as a fan nor being improved in writings of the show, I actually do not have a problem with redemption arcs going to waste, I'm only saying it could've been written so much better. Up till now I haven't watched miraculous for hoping that Thomas will get Cat a backstory nor to see him shine once, I know this probably won't happen since Thomas doesn't care about fandom opinion. I watch it because it's entertaining and I love Kagami, Her charecter's arc always amazes me! Althou there isn't much about her in the show, I truly admire how their showing her struggles with perfectionism, trying to make friends and standing up for her sake.
@papkinn
@papkinn Жыл бұрын
Yes, they're queerbaiting. And situation is actually way worst because queerbaiting is not limited to just the show, Astruc claiming characters are queer on twitter without ever acknowledging it in the cartoon is also queerbaiting. Did you know that Alix is supposed to be aromantic, Max asexual and Nathaniel bisexual? Of course not because it's mentioned on twitter only and never brought up in the show what is especially infuriating to me as aro-ace person because it's not first time we're traded this way by media writers. Nathaniel had couple episodes and yet no mention of him being bi or being in apparently canon gay relationship with Marc. Max and Alix are literally miraculum holders and again no mention of their identities, not even a hint or a joke about them not being into dating like basically everyone else in their class, absolutely nothing. Those identities were mentioned once, fans got understandably happy and Astruc patted himself on he back for being so progressive and forgot about them completely. That's book example of queerbaiting, lazy at that. It makes me sad because bi and ace-aro spec people are constantly erased from pop culture when kids deserve to know there's more than just being straight or gay, that you can like all genders or nobody etc. Miraculous ladybug could be cartoon to help some kid discover themselves but sadly it's not if anything this cartoon makes comphet of aro-ace spec kids so much worst by portraying love as some magical force everyone needs.
@starsiadraws
@starsiadraws Жыл бұрын
THANK YOU! Finally someone who acknowledges that Twitter is not canon. I literally do not have a Twitter, so if it's not in the show, the informations is irrelevant. plus if it's not in any official material, it's basically headcanon. I also headcanon Alix as aroace, Max as ace, and Nathaniel x MArc, but it's not shown, so it's not real representation.
@papkinn
@papkinn Жыл бұрын
@@starsiadraws for real i'm so tired of twitter headcanons of the writers being only "representation" i have as aroace. We're not controversial, we're not taboo and yet nobody wants to do bare minimum of writing us into the shows. With Miraculus being so obsessed with straight romance it would really be enough to throw one joke about Alix and/or Max not being interested in relationships but we can't even have that.
@michalelkin-bronner13
@michalelkin-bronner13 Жыл бұрын
​@Starsia Draws it is it might not be the way to show rep but it's still cannon
@eeveeofalltrades4780
@eeveeofalltrades4780 Жыл бұрын
To be fair, Max being ace is the most obvious because he's never shown any kind of interest in anything except technology.
@michalelkin-bronner7958
@michalelkin-bronner7958 Жыл бұрын
its a men loving men relationship or something not a gay relationship
@lucamagic
@lucamagic Жыл бұрын
Yeah I think so. It’s been going on for a while with both Juleka x Rose and Marc x Nathaniel. Now we got Zoe and Mrs. Bustier which is shown in the series but it feels like it was a one episode thing and that they’re not going anywhere with it so yeah
@stefaniarusso
@stefaniarusso Жыл бұрын
Agreed
@asherville7163
@asherville7163 Жыл бұрын
ok but that last example isn't queer baiting, Mrs. Bustier just has a wife that is shown to be affectionate towards espeically since it's stated THAT'S HER WIFE. Queer baiting is TEASING and dangling a relationship in front of people and never going through with it. The best example I can think of is Keith and Lance in Voltron, they gave them moments, they specifically choose each other to be freed in that tv game episode, they even made FREAKIN MERCH of Klance and they NEVER went through with it. Then there was ADAM, I don't blame you if you don't know him, but as someone who was really into Voltron, I remember. Adam was teased to be Shiro's lover, but then we see him in the show, they only have ONE SCENE, where it's AMBIGUIOUS at best if they were in a relationship, and again, that's AT BEST, if you watch the scene and you had no outside sources, you'd just assume he's just a casual friend of Shiro's, casual, not even like a best friend. Adam than DIES randomly, and we get a scene where Shiro touches his name plate on a wall of those who were lost, but AGAIN, it's NOT CLEAR they were in a relationship AT BEST, if ANYONE didn't see outside stuff, I guarantee, NO ONE would have thought they were gay. No idea what I'm talking about? Of course you don't, because that's how little they cared. THAT'S Queer baiting. They LIED to us about giving Shiro a boyfriend by not CONFIRMING IT WITHIN THE SHOW, and just killing off Adam before he can have an actual impact on the plot. Mrs. Bustier? She's not queerbaiting. It's clear that that's her wife, she calls her her wife, kisses and holds her hand. It's not the best thing ever, but does it need to be? No, because gay people exist casually, I find it to be a good rep because of how casual it is, there's nothing big about it, and that's ok, and honestly, there should be more casual LGBT rep, it doesn't have to be in the fore front of anything.
@lucamagic
@lucamagic Жыл бұрын
@@asherville7163 I didn’t mean Mrs. Bustier as queerbaiting I meant Juleka x Rose and Marc x Nathaniel. With Voltron… yeah that kind of sucked but at least Shiro got married in the end except that it was with a pretty unknown character and only shown the last seconds of the show. I know what queerbaiting is I just meant that Mrs. Bustier’s wife is just not going to return at all. Which sure, I understand why but at the same time they took 2 random characters and made them Alya’s parents and they have more screen time than they should so yeah And I like the casual representation but I don’t want them to always be background characters or something people can say “they’re just friends” at
@asherville7163
@asherville7163 Жыл бұрын
@@lucamagic i just spend the past 20 minutes writing a response to this and i lost it and I'm sad so I don't feel like typing it all out again but I just wanted to say I KINDA disagree, I don't like Juleka and Rose HAVE to say they are dating or are in love, but I think the show should make it a little more obvious they are, because I can understand why they won't outright say it (they can get canceled like Owl House)
@lucamagic
@lucamagic Жыл бұрын
@@asherville7163 Yeah I was thinking the same about getting the show canceled but like you said they should make it more obvious so people don’t take them for friends cause to be honest I don’t even know if I would’ve thought of them as girlfriends if I didn’t check the fandom but it would be nice to have some representation that isn’t like that once in a while. I think I’ve just watched to many shows/movies just for those seconds or fallen for the queerbait and that makes me a bit salty to the background representation but of course I am happy for the small ones as well just wished that we could get a bit more :/
@Orkprof
@Orkprof Жыл бұрын
I was quite disappointed in seeing half the fandom cheering for Caline + Gisèle, as if the show wasn't being incredibly hypocritical about LGBT+ representation. Back in S4, after Rose called Juleka her "best friend" in "Guiltrip", many complained about the show's reticence to just admitting once and for all that the two were an item. Astruc replied that there was LOTS of evidence within the episode to get a definitive answer about that topic, yet somehow adamantinely refused to give a straight "yes" or "no" himself. Why did I say hypocritical? Because around the same time, he chastized fans by reminding them that, if they were too explicit about LGBT+ pairs, they would be censored in several countries... but wait, it's not about the money! The issue with censorsgip is that LGBT+ kids from those countries wouldn't get to see themselves represented! Too bad countries like Russia were ALREADY censoring any ambiguous scene that even vaguely hinted at Juleka+Rose or Nath+Marc, rendering Astruc's objection invalid. Cue to S5, and now the authors & the production have SUDDENLY found the guts to be more explicit: Zoé likes girls (Deflagration, Adoration), Rose loves Juleka (Migration, albeit they immediately try to cover it up), Marinette gives a surprising and out-of-the-blue endorsement to both polyamory and aros/aces (Adoration) and Caline Bustier has a girlfriend (Collusion). OK, so... what changed? And please don't tell me "something something Russia, war", because there are still lots of countries airing MLB that aren't very tolerant of LGBT+ themes either.
@dancordea9149
@dancordea9149 Жыл бұрын
Don't forget Kagami exclaiming that she loves both Adrien and Marinette (Protection). My guess is that this is the last season of the Agreste's storyline (and it was supposed to be the last of the series overall before they added more seasons with Lila as the main villain) and so they got a little bit bolder (but not by much cause Julerose and Marcaniel still haven't been explicitly confirmed in canon).
@michalelkin-bronner13
@michalelkin-bronner13 Жыл бұрын
She separated friends from you so juleka is more than a friend
@TheUnamedOne832
@TheUnamedOne832 Жыл бұрын
HER FIRST NAME IS CALINE? WHERE DID YOU LEARN THAT!
@Orkprof
@Orkprof Жыл бұрын
@@TheUnamedOne832 TBH I'm not sure if it's ever mentioned in the show 🤔 but it's on the wiki.
@Tsuki_0718
@Tsuki_0718 Жыл бұрын
Russia is censoring the lgbt relationships? lol in Turkey then even censor hetero relationships when they get too close
@DigiDestined13
@DigiDestined13 Жыл бұрын
I definitely understand why people would be frustrated. I guess for me personally, I always hesitate to accuse a show of queer baiting because I never know if I'm reading more into something than the writers intended. And that's not just with Miraculous, but with every show I watch. Like, I'm not convinced that the writers for Supernatural intended for Castiel's "I love you" to be a declaration of romantic feelings for Dean at the end of Season 15, though I know Misha Collins certainly interpreted it that way. But that's just me.
@TheAnonymouse558
@TheAnonymouse558 Жыл бұрын
"Okay, crew, I've decided it! We're going to include LGBT characters in our show! Who's with me?!" "Doesn't doing something like that tend to get shows canceled?" "Uh, add them? I meant to say imply them! Yeah, totally! Who-who's putting words in my mouth?!"
@shanenanigans27
@shanenanigans27 Жыл бұрын
I always thought France was open to depicting LGBT more than the US was... Same-sex marriage was legalized there before the US.
@kiyomi_kamimoto
@kiyomi_kamimoto Жыл бұрын
I'm French and I'm not aware that France has more issues with homosexual relationships than other countries ? From what I see on social media and with people I know, it's pretty well accepted, although of course there are exceptions, mostly with old people.
@TheAnonymouse558
@TheAnonymouse558 Жыл бұрын
Really? Huh, I thought the video mentioned it was otherwise. Then again, I'm not sure the show does much research on France either, so... Still, sorry if I offended any of you. I was just trying to make fun of what probably happened behind the scenes for the representation to be so subdued.
@shanenanigans27
@shanenanigans27 Жыл бұрын
@@TheAnonymouse558 The show is created by French people.
@kiyomi_kamimoto
@kiyomi_kamimoto Жыл бұрын
@@TheAnonymouse558 Dw I don't feel offended, it's ok to not know everything about a foreign country :) Still, the show is mostly made by french people, and they seem to show many historical points and events throughout the episodes, so I think they have some kind of good grasp of the country haha My guess is that maybe it's because MLB is not restricted to France, and is available in countries where those types of things are considered as an issue ? Still, I don't understand their fear of explicitely showing most of those types of relationships on screen. Mrs Bustier and Zoe are the most obvious, yet one out of two failed to date the one she loves, and let's not get started on Marc/Nathaniel and Rose/Juleka...
@Blacknight6577
@Blacknight6577 Жыл бұрын
The teacher having a female partner felt out of nowhere especially that she’s pregnant which obviously makes all or most of us to assume she’s with a man. If anything the main side characters should be moving forward for sure and not just side characters we don’t see much at all.
@cryingwatercolours8127
@cryingwatercolours8127 Жыл бұрын
i think maybe that was the point… it’s been done many times before, they show a character and hint that they’re straight just to later reveal they’re queer. it can be done well but i haven’t seen the episode to judge how well it was done here. but i don’t think the writers misdirection tactics are something to be criticised imo
@Blacknight6577
@Blacknight6577 Жыл бұрын
@@cryingwatercolours8127 true but it’s more accepting when they drop hints or right away show or say something that gives it away rather than just slapping it in the face like “oh hey look at this that literally came out of nowhere”
@lisaweyh-gsell4214
@lisaweyh-gsell4214 Жыл бұрын
​@@Blacknight6577 How is it a problem?
@shanenanigans27
@shanenanigans27 Жыл бұрын
I think it's because lesbians and single women were forbidden from getting sperm donations until 2021. Until then, only a woman in a relationship with a man could. So, maybe it was a political statement on their parts.
@cryingwatercolours8127
@cryingwatercolours8127 Жыл бұрын
@@Blacknight6577 maybe. personally i disagree. i think adding hints would take away from the misdirect but i suppose it’s also possible they thought of this last minute.
6 ай бұрын
What bugs me the most is how couples like Nathaniel and Marc are only official off screen. Sure in S5 we've at least seen them hold hands which was obviously about to be more. Until Marinette showed up because Adrien. Same with Juleka and Rose. It's obvious that they care about each other (sure you love your friends too Rose but be honest to yourself, you trusted Juleka with your biggest secret). I really hope that s6 steps up those romances and develops them further. Give us an episode focused on Nathaniel and Marc where Adrien and Marinette aren't shown to be in love but play the same part the boys did to bring these two together. Do the same for Juleka and Rose. Maybe spice things up for characters we've known to be straight, like Luka. Sure he's just a good friend but what if he doesn't care what gender the person he loves is? Another representation, the same could be said about Zoe. Make her get closer to Luka only for them to help each other (not get romantically involved with each other but with another person). Bonus if it's characters we've met before like Wayhem as an Adrien fan boy or whoever. But don't destroy couples they've already established. And one change to make this easier? Scrap all the Mr. Pigeon 199 episodes, no one likes those.
@nia91281
@nia91281 Жыл бұрын
I don't think it's really ok that all of these characters have long-term obsessions with other people. I mean, I just feel like we should recognize that it's a bad thing and people shouldn't act like this.
@yasseanabouelella
@yasseanabouelella Жыл бұрын
FINALLY SOMEONE NORMAL
@Anna.Feather
@Anna.Feather Жыл бұрын
Finally someone points this out, in Season 1 they literally romantics stealing people phones, stalking your crushes, being completely obsessed to an unhealthy point, etc. I have seen other shows where the protagonist have a somewhat obsessive crush, but with Marinette she is basically a yandere without the killing. Probably the g keeping her from it is to keep the show pg(This is in reference in earlier seasons, I am not fully caught up on season 5)
@michalelkin-bronner13
@michalelkin-bronner13 Жыл бұрын
​@@Anna.Feather she isn't a yandere without the killing there are some things that yandere do that she doesnt
@lucifer-librarian9562
@lucifer-librarian9562 Жыл бұрын
I honestly don't care whether a show has lgbtq couples or not but I admit that I dislike virtue signalling which in al honesty it seems Miraculous is doing
@DarkShadow-hy6iq
@DarkShadow-hy6iq 5 ай бұрын
Julerose and Marcaniel was confirmed by Thomas on Twitter 😭
@littlesparrow303
@littlesparrow303 Жыл бұрын
I always felt that Bustier wasn't into guys because we never saw hints of it. I understand they can't fully tell everyone they are together with their same sex partner so countries such as Korea can air it on TV. If not they'll just cut the Bustier kiss like they did for Owl House for Lumity. We all knew Zoe's confession wouldn't go anywhere. For Marinette if she was into girls I can see her falling for Kagami and/or Fei. The only way people can know about canon LGBT is looking online instead of it in the show
@Quake-iv3
@Quake-iv3 Жыл бұрын
That, an she’s pregnant
@littlesparrow303
@littlesparrow303 Жыл бұрын
@@Quake-iv3 there are other ways of getting pregnant like a sperm donor
@riotkitty
@riotkitty Жыл бұрын
We never saw any hints she was into girls either. Plus most of her earlier scenes are in the classroom, that would be completely inappropriate to speak about while teaching. I feel it would be better if she didn’t have a confirmed sexuality and she was just there as a background character.
@TheUnamedOne832
@TheUnamedOne832 Жыл бұрын
Ok who is Fei? I've seen people shipping her with Marinette thrice now in other comments and am completely lost
@kainightshade5033
@kainightshade5033 Жыл бұрын
@@TheUnamedOne832 Fei is a Chinese girl from the Shanghai special and the holder of the prodigious. A magical artifact similar to the miraculous only more powerful and allows it's user to shapeshift into a variety of animals.
@OfficialDeanAdler
@OfficialDeanAdler Жыл бұрын
I don’t think it’s queerbating, but I do think it’s the same issue going on with Adrinette, the reveal, the Hawkmoth defeat, and just trying to get the lost miraculous: it’s just the pandering and stretching out components of the show to keep their audience hooked. Let’s be honest, the show is holding on threads with its audience. Once those threads snap, the audience will have no reason to stay. They’re stretching this plot topic out as long as possible to get as much money as possible.
@atlashaugen4219
@atlashaugen4219 Жыл бұрын
literally like they're just doing the same things they've been doing the entire show
@OfficialDeanAdler
@OfficialDeanAdler Жыл бұрын
@@atlashaugen4219 and my suspicions have only been strengthened by this season’s finale episodes tbh. Like we are STILL DOING THIS?! I’m over the show tbh and I’m never coming back.
@mizuyamada8880
@mizuyamada8880 Жыл бұрын
This show def lacks foreshadowing
@10Bendog
@10Bendog Жыл бұрын
I usually don't defend the Miraculous writers, but I assume the LGBTQ+ representation is kinda disappointing in the show mostly because that's really all they can do. Censors, especially for a show this popular worldwide, are pretty brutal and I'm certain they are in a similar situation to where the Adventure Time writers were with Bubbline. True, the AT writers did do an overall better job portraying how close Bubblegum and Marceline were, particularly the more the show went on. However, the confirmation kiss was left for the finale, because at that point the show was over, so there was no worry if that episode got censored or if the show was stopped from airing altogether in certain countries. I think Miraculous is in a similar position at the moment. Like, they're planning to have future seasons, but the main plot lines that have been going since the beginning will be wrapped up now, so the writers a feeling more comfortable with showing the LGBTQ+ rep more overtly - Zoey confessing to Marinette (if just silently) and Ms. Bustier being revealed to be in a relationship with a woman. There's, like, 5 episodes left and I doubt Ms. Bustier is gonna be relevant in any of them, so to send off her character, they revealed her partner. I'm pretty sure that they could confirm Rose x Juleka and Nathaniel x Marc somewhere in the finale too, since it probably won't matter after that because it could be the last time we see those characters (depending on what the plans are for the future seasons). Sadly, this is still how cartoons are forced to operate, especially the more popular they are worldwide. Can't wait for a future in which this is not a problem, but that future is not now.
@kainightshade5033
@kainightshade5033 Жыл бұрын
That's true. I can blame the writers for many things but not this. This is a society problem, not necessarily their fault.
@perezgfacts2396
@perezgfacts2396 Жыл бұрын
​I repeat it society has become too driven into sponsoring foolishness, but nevertheless the writers are clearly not doing their best. The plot lines and other details would've made sense. Like Chloe becoming Mayor without any federal government intervention, or a vice mayor coming in is just foolish.
@ibrahimsasi9215
@ibrahimsasi9215 Жыл бұрын
I hope not
@Multi-FandomMadness
@Multi-FandomMadness Жыл бұрын
I understand you point, but it's definately possible to make a queer show. For example: The Owl House. The Owl House is a DISNEY show. DISNEY, and they had the main character come out to her mother. Bi flags for everyone. They kiss. They announce they're girlfriends. It's definately possible to make someone who's not the main characters (and still in the main cast) queer)
@denizkaragullu6239
@denizkaragullu6239 Жыл бұрын
I live in Turkey and they don't even show the straight kiss scenes in MLB. Also, half of Owl House is cut out. It is so fcking sad
@thatminari
@thatminari Жыл бұрын
I think it’s important that lgbtq+ gets normalized and exists without being the main character, but the way miraculous implements it is so weird, definitely feels like queerbaiting to me. I totally agree to your point.
@Someone-qi1rr
@Someone-qi1rr Жыл бұрын
Nah, mental ilnesses shouldn't be promoted and normalized. Keep iy inside your four walls or go to therapy, but pleae stop trying to brainwash kids and ruin everything
@scuffed_carrot
@scuffed_carrot Жыл бұрын
​​@@Someone-qi1rrthis comment was a month ago you goddamn moron
@CyanHope
@CyanHope 11 ай бұрын
@@Someone-qi1rrthe only one who has mental illness is people like you, wait stupidity isn’t considered a mental illness. How exactly are we brainwashing kids into being queer? Do we make legislations that makes it harder for straight kids/people to be straight? No, wait. It’s the opposite. Do we make conversion centers to make straight kids queer? No, wait. It’s the opposite. Do we discriminate against straight kids? No, wait. It’s the opposite. Your lack of brain power should be considered an illness
@nevaehhamilton3493
@nevaehhamilton3493 6 ай бұрын
It's not just queer baiting. It's an example of homophobia and discrimination against the LGBT. It insults they very nature of the LGBT community, and is extremely harmful to everyone of all ages. Disney does it all the time, and it is beyond disgusting.
@martinasera825
@martinasera825 Жыл бұрын
Mahn I tapped out at the beginning of the season so this is all new to me. The miraculous writers will frustrate you with their aimless writing. The overarching arch is an imagination from the fans and the story has no end. And if the show does end, the sour milk has already expired for anyone to be satisfied with it.
@ninadiener9806
@ninadiener9806 Жыл бұрын
Yes, agree! And when it feels like they're starting to develop an interesting dynamic they put it back in the back burner to give more time to Marinette+Adrien, which is honestly getting real old because they also don't get to progress much
@aniiinerd
@aniiinerd Жыл бұрын
Wait, Juleka and Rose aren’t dating!? I thought that they were already a couple that got together off-screen!
@ztyran
@ztyran Жыл бұрын
3:18 The gender swap Batman/Superman couple is basically more of an expy of a canon DC couple Apollo/Midnighter, a pair of Batman/Superman knockoffs that are in a relationship. So yah done before . The problem is we're told that off screen various characters are members of the Queer community being gay, bi, asexual and even non binary, but it's never portrayed on the show.
@theskiesaltiair
@theskiesaltiair Жыл бұрын
I’m so disappointed in Miraculous. I stopped watching half way through season 4 because I honestly couldn’t see where this story was going and honestly looking at it now I still can’t see what they’re trying to do with this story. If you aren’t Adrien and Marinette, then you’re not gonna get any good story and just be thrown into the background to cheer for the main couple. It’s annoying and honestly this show is just tiring to look at and watch. Don’t even get me started with the Chloe plot, this show is a fever dream now.
@glimmerstantroop46321
@glimmerstantroop46321 Жыл бұрын
Good choice, from what I heard, it's only getting worse
@eeveeofalltrades4780
@eeveeofalltrades4780 Жыл бұрын
The best character right now is Mr. Banana. He has been consistent in all of his appearances, he doesn't become dumb for the sake of the plot, and he even got some development (he's getting his own show).
@user-wt2pe1fo4w
@user-wt2pe1fo4w Жыл бұрын
despite the fact that adrienette is the worst ship in this show
@nourmamdouh3863
@nourmamdouh3863 11 ай бұрын
I am not homophobic or anything but I think that the shortage of LGBTQ characters is reasonable cuz miraculous is in the end is a kids show and in my opinion kids should not be exposed gender preference yet
@abrahamlupis9354
@abrahamlupis9354 10 ай бұрын
​​@@gabidobre5584 we only need good shows, Disney is failing miserably for poorly trying to satisfy the LGBT community over everyone in the world
@maskedkitty7350
@maskedkitty7350 2 ай бұрын
bro i hate to tell ya but most lgbt+ people know their that when their kids. i knew i was into women in the fourth grade, same for knowing i wanted to transition, i just didn’t know the words for both since i was in a religious family that kept me in the dark and the school left that stuff up to the parents, basically no media at all either to make me aware. we know as kids, and not letting people know those options are there just leads to alienation by ourselves mentally and depression. like i still have heavy depression because i spent half my life trying to find the words and way to tell family what i needed during time i should’ve known and been aloud to live as what i was, instead of being forced into a life that wasn’t me. i wouldn’t wish my childhood issues in that regard on anybody. if their gonna assume somebody is old enough to watch tapes talking about puberty like they did with my school relatively young then they can explain those other standpoints too. simple as can be.
@The_Watcher_0
@The_Watcher_0 Жыл бұрын
At this point, just don't try to have gay characters anymore, its better than failing at having them
@baalgodofrain
@baalgodofrain Жыл бұрын
As a gay man...Yes please preach, as much as I love representation, if you don't have the balls to do it, then don't
@Asra_..
@Asra_.. Жыл бұрын
literally.I'd rather they just call me a slur
@magreste
@magreste Жыл бұрын
There was literally no reason to make Ms. Bustier gay, especially now that she's a pregnant character. It barely makes sense to me as an adult, how tf will it make sense to kids? They'll get the impression that a woman can get another woman pregnant. And don't get me started on Zoe, whose character was so dry and useless Asstruck had to make her have a crush on Marinette to appeal to the dumbass queer shippers in the fandom. My god this season's such a mess.
@kiyomi_kamimoto
@kiyomi_kamimoto Жыл бұрын
Wait, I'm not lesbian or bi and I'm a bit young to have done "it", but isn't it possible for a lesbian couple to use donor sperm ? One of the two will therefore be pregnant thanks to that man's help, but the baby will still be considerate as the two women's
@magreste
@magreste Жыл бұрын
@@kiyomi_kamimoto Yes, sperm donation is a thing. I'm just saying unconventional stuff like this shouldn't be normalized, and sliding it casually into a kids' show, where the people watching are the upcoming generation, sets us up for a concerning future obsessed with being "woke" and "inclusive" to things that shouldn't exist in the first place. The kids will just get confused.
@nymfettes
@nymfettes Жыл бұрын
@@magreste pregnant lesbians shouldnt exist?
@CyanHope
@CyanHope 11 ай бұрын
@@magrestewhy it shouldn’t exist. Explain
@yoshter135
@yoshter135 Жыл бұрын
You are right, the show definitely likes to bait us. They also polybaited us with Adrien x Marinette x Kagami, and when Zoe had a crush on Marinette, Marinette said “there’s nothing wrong with having 2 partners or even 3 “
@Orkprof
@Orkprof Жыл бұрын
"Or even none". In one line, polyamory, aromanticism & asexuality. All of a sudden, out of the blue 🤔
@marocat4749
@marocat4749 Жыл бұрын
When they could easy have q polygam relationship of game, natalie and gabriel, and they all , including emily and natalie did love each other. And its organic.
@eeveeofalltrades4780
@eeveeofalltrades4780 Жыл бұрын
Yeah, that just sounds like the writers saying "look at us! We support LGBT+! Watch the show!" It's sad that so many shows are taking the queerbaiting route when the writing quality starts declining and the ratings diminish
@Someone-qi1rr
@Someone-qi1rr Жыл бұрын
Bruh, she didn't mean it that way. Yall are aick. You can love people without wanting to be with them romanticslly you knwo
@Orkprof
@Orkprof Жыл бұрын
@@Someone-qi1rr bruh, she literally tells Zoé - totally unprompted, out of the blue - something like "you're free to love the person you want, or the personS [polyamory], or no one at all [aromanticism]". And that's ok in principle, but it literally comes out of the blue and was never, ever discussed in 5 seasons. It's quite clearly inserted into the dialogue so that the authors can get points for "being good allues". Later in the same episode, when Mari is convinced Zoé has a crush on Adrien, she encourages her to go tell him... very in character for her.
@ellenoniell8093
@ellenoniell8093 Жыл бұрын
What pisses me off is that in half the countries miraculous appears in can't show realationships at all anyway and they cut out the kissing scenes between the straight characters and yet they still only add in those realationships and kinda censor the gay ones when if you deep it,its kinda pointless?? Some countries censor anything romantic anyway but they go out of their way to make the gay realationships less romantic and have less screen time and all that??? Okayy i guess
@zachmakesstuff9866
@zachmakesstuff9866 Жыл бұрын
They need to hurry up and make juleka and rose and Marc and Nathaniel canon. They’ve implied it so hard they need to hurry up and confirm it
@murakami3602
@murakami3602 Жыл бұрын
Rose said she was dating Juleka, so it's canon?
@Emily-dt1nl
@Emily-dt1nl Жыл бұрын
​@@murakami3602 in what episode
@SarahGambill-sl9dl
@SarahGambill-sl9dl Жыл бұрын
The answers is NO!!
@murakami3602
@murakami3602 Жыл бұрын
@@Emily-dt1nl I can't remember... they were talking about Adrien and Marinette and Rose said something like: "sometimes friendship can lead too a little bit more!" while holding and staring at Juleka
@user-wt2pe1fo4w
@user-wt2pe1fo4w Жыл бұрын
Marcaniel isn't canon and never will be.
@IllusionQueen4Eva
@IllusionQueen4Eva Жыл бұрын
Ms. Bustier and her wife reminds me of my elementary teacher who also brought her baby into class with her one day and came out to us that she's lesbian. She wasn't the one who gave birth to the baby, it was her partner. She was a pretty nice teacher.
@Samgreen90
@Samgreen90 7 ай бұрын
Wait, isn't the teacher… pregnant?
@polishalastor142
@polishalastor142 7 ай бұрын
Yes Actually she Born a daughter named Harmonie
@Samgreen90
@Samgreen90 7 ай бұрын
@@polishalastor142 seriously, what the hell did I miss halfway after season 4?
@polishalastor142
@polishalastor142 7 ай бұрын
@@Samgreen90 In Miraculous World New York United Heroes. Miss Bustier say she is pregnant We see her pregnant in season 5
@Samgreen90
@Samgreen90 7 ай бұрын
@@polishalastor142 I know she said was pregnant in New York special, I haven't got to watch the Shanghai one. I saw a previewing clips of Felix with the peacock miraculous and somehow stole The dog miraculous. I miss the episode where Marinette told Alya her secret as ladybug. I DID see the one where Cat Noir decided quit cuz he felt left out, pushed away, add trust issues, and had a personality change acid transform into a different cat hero (taking this more seriously). Don't remember what episode that clip I saw with Lila throwing her long hair wig in the trash and changing her eyes from green to brown (out of order). And a clip of Chloe leaving Paris crying in defeat (after her conversation with Marinette backfired). So… basically, I missed a lot!
@jamie6673
@jamie6673 Жыл бұрын
Anyone else noticed that Zoe’s clothes being the colour scheme of the pan flag.
@Someone-qi1rr
@Someone-qi1rr Жыл бұрын
I miss the good old days where I could watch cartoons without any worry of propagandas shoving into your face. People really have too much freedom nowadays .
@peacefulchaos333
@peacefulchaos333 Жыл бұрын
Keep crying
@DaisoAlex
@DaisoAlex 11 ай бұрын
​@@peacefulchaos333Keep crying and be offended forever about how people hate LGBT+
@burnedoutgraduatestudent4482
@burnedoutgraduatestudent4482 11 ай бұрын
You mean the good ol days when they literally had Donald Duck have a nightmare about the third reich aka WWII propaganda
@CyanHope
@CyanHope 11 ай бұрын
@@DaisoAlexkeep crying because LGBTQA+ people exist
@CyanHope
@CyanHope 11 ай бұрын
You clearly don’t know what propaganda is😂😂
@whateverandapathy
@whateverandapathy Жыл бұрын
Y’all do realize we still live in a time where child and family shows are getting canceled for having gay characters right? They still can’t be too blatant in a lot of cases.
@Creshosk
@Creshosk Жыл бұрын
Yeah. We can't get same sex lip kisses in kids shows in the US unless the show is already ending, let alone France where things are more strict. I think people forget that homophobia in the system still exists, and some creators are doing the best they can because of it.
@riotkitty
@riotkitty Жыл бұрын
It’s because companies want to have their cake and eat it too. The queer bait is for pandering to Western audiences and to boost their ESG scores, and designed in such a way where they can easily remove or censor these things for other countries. We don’t live in a time where shows are being cancelled for having gay characters. We live in a time where gay characters are marketing tools that can easily be removed for catering to a global market.
@powerpuff6872
@powerpuff6872 Жыл бұрын
@@Creshosk Thats the thing though, miraculous isn't sticking by their principals. They're not here to make a statement, as opposed to the owl house or steven universe, they're here to make money. Therefore the "hinting" of the existence of queer characters, minus confirmation, makes it all feel very disingenuous and ugly.
@DavidZakuzaRyutashi
@DavidZakuzaRyutashi Жыл бұрын
After what happenedwith Owl House, I can see why they aren't taking any chances.
@Asra_..
@Asra_.. Жыл бұрын
honestly if they're too coward to actually make these ships canon they shouldn't have implied them in the first place
@AntoniaGr
@AntoniaGr Жыл бұрын
For a sec I thought you were going to complain about a kids show showing "those sick things" to kids because ever since the new episode I was seeing many negative posts about it but I'm glad you talked about one of the main problems with Miraculous
@ragnarok7075
@ragnarok7075 Жыл бұрын
welp, one thing's for sure........this aint a kids' show no more.
@sharkymsm
@sharkymsm Жыл бұрын
Actually this is the reason why i stopped watching the show
@FandomShipper
@FandomShipper 6 ай бұрын
I really enjoyed this video, like, a whole lot. I have thought similar in terms of the lack of lgbtq characters in this series and it honestly sucks how after five seasons there is no clarity, there is no real proof that any apart from the two existing ones matter for some reason. To be clear these relationships are already formed while so many which seem to want to raise their pride flag are not allowed for some unknown reason. It really sucked that Zoe wound up crushed and such but considering how Marinette has been straight this entire time and in love with Adrien something tells me the writers and people behind the show were never going to give Zoe her happily ever after, though, in the time Zoe was part of the show it was never made apparent that Zoe was into Marinette or if she was I might've missed it. Marc and Nathaniel had chances but considering so much time is put into the Ladybug and Cat Noir segments what chance is there for side characters to even shine or have a moment of confession, ugh. This video was far from preachy as it spoke the truth on so many levels. I feel like when it comes down to it Adrien and Marinette were endgame, they were set up for the big kiss, the big ship, which sadly society and the shipping community have pushed for since the ship name was established back in season one. Rose and Juleka, they kissed once during the whole zombie thing but the actual kiss was never shown and technically it wasn't even a romantic kiss at that, still, considering Disney's track record with the LGBTQ Community and such, cancelling the owl house, even a series like ducktales with webby and lena, another Rose and Juleka there, the answer is so obvious when it comes to things. Least the Owl House got its two female characters together albeit a shortened season 3 and again cancelled. I feel this series could do better in terms of representation if only it tried and maybe put the brakes on Adrien and Marinette. Heck I was annoyed with the fact that Adrien/Cat Noir was coming off a bit pushy with his feelings for Ladybug, you remember those days right? It was still Adrien being pushy...had he known it was Marinette would it have changed things? Anyway yeah five seasons down and hopefully Marc and Nathaniel finally become a thing, Rose and Juleka, even Zoe finding someone. Also just curious if Nathalie or Natalie, not sure how to spell it but was it just me or did she have feelings for Adrien's mom? She seemed awfully attached to her memories of her but could be me just reading into it.
@independenthistory1621
@independenthistory1621 Жыл бұрын
9:07 if they make the relationship so minor or so easy to miss that you can’t even remember or find it when looking for it I think that also proves your point
@WarmLillie
@WarmLillie Жыл бұрын
It’s hard not to really wing, can’t blame you now. Especially since content is mixed slightly. Is it baiting, From what I have seen 50/50. Yeah the LGBT+ ship are background at the best while everything else is sailing. Not all them but some. Miraculous is a love story but the love story is written never just as that exact simple it’s complex? Especially since the show really loves to bait with everyone… Remember the future of Chat Blanc and Shadow Noir the other ship of Lukenette and Adregmi. It’s that famous of potential not used yet. When will the ship sail instead being stuck under construction.
@neonstarship6038
@neonstarship6038 8 ай бұрын
I think the point where they pulled beustie and the american heros into it is where it definitally went too far. Juleka/Rose and Nathanial/Marc was great and instead of overdosing Queer relationships they should have gone for quality over quantity. Giving those kids MORE screen time
@polishalastor142
@polishalastor142 7 ай бұрын
​@@gabidobre5584oh right Arranged marriages Being in the closet That's sad 😟
@gracegaert
@gracegaert Жыл бұрын
Yes but also, they’re in too deep to change any main character’s orientation without having the same baiting problems
@marocat4749
@marocat4749 Жыл бұрын
Nut itsbetter than nothing. Also alex is free. And luca could be bi coded.
@Commenter839
@Commenter839 Жыл бұрын
​@@marocat4749 Alix was already confirmed as aromantic. Same with Max (technically Max is ace, but in the context of a children's show that's basically the same as being aro)
@michalelkin-bronner13
@michalelkin-bronner13 Жыл бұрын
​@Commenter839 not really even though sex can't be shown in a kid show he can still be ace without being aro just that the creators can't show him not liking sex
@Someone-qi1rr
@Someone-qi1rr Жыл бұрын
Adrien and Marinette are straight. Even Chloe is. Also hompohbic.😊
@michalelkin-bronner13
@michalelkin-bronner13 Жыл бұрын
@@Someone-qi1rr marinette was already said to be not straight you being homophobic doesn't change that stupid
@TheLuconic
@TheLuconic 9 ай бұрын
I want to add that they are twisting these characters relationships. I believe its been stated that they are just friends, but you know how those higher ups with gay on the brain, ruin innocent friendships and turn them into something they are not. And that needs to stop.
@pagodrink
@pagodrink Жыл бұрын
After Steven Universe got cut short for showing Ruby and Sapphire's wedding, more and more shows were allowed to have more apparent representation (Long story short, but it was basically none existent for while). While I'm glad we are getting some, cause hopefully studios can stop worrying that their cartoon is gonna be banned in homophobic countries, Miraculous is def doing the safe option, the "Disney's first openly gay character" approach. Like, It's better than nothing, but I'm not sure how many LGBT kids are gonna relate to the minor characters when they see so little. Like Marc was apparently based on a real genderfluid person, but the series basically forgot about them.
@PonyPlays2014
@PonyPlays2014 Жыл бұрын
It's actually a huge letdown how most characters are just means to an end and only get attention when it serves the Marinette x Adrien lovesquare. They could easily make one or multiple slice of life episodes focused on the other students like MLP did with their 100th episode. The main characters were there in the background fighting something but the focus was on the rest of the cast.
@kainightshade5033
@kainightshade5033 Жыл бұрын
Of course homophobes would come out with their unsolicited opinions 🙄
@gachaleaf1551
@gachaleaf1551 Жыл бұрын
I think some of them might just be in deep denial. How else would they find this video as soon as it comes out? XD
@kainightshade5033
@kainightshade5033 Жыл бұрын
@@gachaleaf1551 LOL
@ookittythelittlecatoo8880
@ookittythelittlecatoo8880 Жыл бұрын
Brah..... You really just expected the bottom of the barrel treatment huh.
@starsiadraws
@starsiadraws Жыл бұрын
Seriously!! Who knew so many homophobes existed in the Miraculous fanbase!?
@kainightshade5033
@kainightshade5033 Жыл бұрын
@@starsiadraws I'M SAYING!! They are all in these comments spewing the usual bullshit
@rr.aionama
@rr.aionama Жыл бұрын
I would be fine if there was absolutely no LGBTQ+ rep in the show, but that includes no queerbaiting, no Bury your gays, and not making all the LGBTQ+ characters minor ones. The problem is that they’re trying to appeal to 2 polar opposite audiences at once. The thing is, it’s okay not to make everyone gay, but develop the minor character’s homosexual relationships instead of just having them.
@saffyesperas2278
@saffyesperas2278 Жыл бұрын
When was Miss Bustier married? That came out of nowhere.
@Orkprof
@Orkprof Жыл бұрын
Married, I think it was never said. She was just shown to be pregnant in the New York special.
@theasinclaire52
@theasinclaire52 Жыл бұрын
Supposedly, the cards feature additional info. For example, Kim has two dads. But I think part of it might be money. If they make the show "too gay" it'll be harder to sell the show to more conservative countries.
@Orkprof
@Orkprof Жыл бұрын
True that. And instead of just admitting that, the director on Twitter tried to gaslight his fans by saying that they shouldn't ask for more overt representation, or LGBT+ kids from those countries would be deprived of their representation by censorship. Happened around the time of S4's "Guiltrip".
@SarahGambill-sl9dl
@SarahGambill-sl9dl Жыл бұрын
That's a lie. Kim has no same sex parents that's ridiculous
@Orkprof
@Orkprof Жыл бұрын
@@SarahGambill-sl9dl and why so? 🤔 I thought it was confirmed.
@amandajohnson7797
@amandajohnson7797 Жыл бұрын
This is a big topic and I like the stab you took at it. Good way to get the ball rolling 👏
@LukiKruki
@LukiKruki Жыл бұрын
Remember how Caline Bustier got pregnant out of nowhere in the New Jork movie and now her kid and her husband are nowhere to be found because suddenly she's in lesbian relationship? Or how Marinette's "love" to Adrien made her to draw his whole life graph, to make him presents for all his birthdays, to steal his phone, to "touch" him while he pretented do be a wax statue, to break in his house with the help of on-job firefighter and later she acts like all these things never happend neither experienced any consequences but was supported all this time by her stupid ass friends? And Miraculous creator, Thomas Astruc, announced on Twitter some Miraculous p0rn comic as canon where Marinette was naked around black guys? Come on, this show isn't worth your time.
@jellycat6187
@jellycat6187 Жыл бұрын
Firstly u don’t need a husband to get pregnant U do need a male gamete but u don’t need to date/marry the person that produces the make gamete Secondly I do agree with the rest of what u said thout
@afvp9586
@afvp9586 Жыл бұрын
Wait what?! But Marinette is a minor...how does that work?
@LukiKruki
@LukiKruki Жыл бұрын
@@afvp9586 Minor or not, it's Marinette's unhealthy obsession over Adren not love. If she would love him, she will accept his denial of their romantic relationship. If she would have a common sense, she won't dare to hurt him even if it can hurt her. But she already hurt him many times, so what's a difference if she hurts him again.
@afvp9586
@afvp9586 Жыл бұрын
@@LukiKruki no no I know that, she's a terrible character that should go to prison but what I didn't understand was about the comic, since I thought a matter as the one you comment would be um harder t make canon if that makes sense
@LukiKruki
@LukiKruki Жыл бұрын
​@@afvp9586 That comic in official Miraculous media isn't canon per say but the Miraculous creator was talking about it on Twitter like it was in his mind. Anyway listen, Miraculous supposed to be light-hearthed show as the official description suggests by actually it has the most disgusting things that should happen in world like Cyberpunk 2077 than in Miraculous. That comic included. The world of Cyberpunk 2077 is created as the worst place you ever can be in, not in Miraculous world. I hope you understand what I am trying to say.
@ShapeShifterVee
@ShapeShifterVee 11 ай бұрын
To be honest, the only thing more distracting than just adding ONE episode about a side ship, IS NOT HAVING ONE AND WAITING THE ENTIRE SHOW FOR IT!!!!!
@K41Teto41
@K41Teto41 8 ай бұрын
I love the sunshine positive pink girl and dark depressed purple girl dynamic. I was a big Juleka and Rose shipper. They were my first ship in the show. But my interest has waned.
@polishalastor142
@polishalastor142 7 ай бұрын
Canonically they are a couple
@polishalastor142
@polishalastor142 7 ай бұрын
Why you interest Has waned
@clarisacalderon9555
@clarisacalderon9555 3 ай бұрын
to be honest i alwaysfelt a bit weird at shipping rose and julieka at first because they never really adressed that rose had riz with that indian prince when rose was princess fragrence who beat out chloe for attention. but that said julieka and rose ARE really cute. though i kindof wish we saw julieka nad rose become closer friend sto adrien at some point since julieka wants to be a model and adrien is a professional model and is REALLY good at supporting people and listening...especially since he actually felt like he was listening to what juleika wanted when dealing with guilt trip...unlike mari who kindof kept breaking her promise at times like bringing in others to listen and freaking out despite promising to treat rose like normal even if it all worked out. or at least adress if the aren;t offically going out because rose is sick or something at least becasue they seriously seem like they have SOMETHING going on.
@rosesinseptember
@rosesinseptember Жыл бұрын
I'm willing to give the show a bit of a pass on the queer presence since they're airing across the globe and the lord only knows other shows have gotten into trouble for that. For them to play it safe with characters so minor that it can be cut with no change to the story is sadly a reasonable choice in that regard. But MAN do I feel you about the last part, and not only the pairings. ALL characters on this show suffer from the inattetion of the writers, where we're more interested in a hundred episodes of nothing rather than take a few minutes to give these kids some badly needed depth and nuanced relationships.
@Orkprof
@Orkprof Жыл бұрын
Come to think of it... I don't think everyone in the show is heterosexual until confirmed otherwise... I'm pretty sure they're making everybody BI until co formed otherwise. In S1 Rose seemingly had a crush on Prince Ali, and since then she's been hinted to be in a relationship with Jul. Nath had a crush on Marinette, he too is now hinted to be in a ship with Marc. Marinette is widely believed to be bi by lots of fans, following a tweet where smbody asked Astruc "what about Mirabel+Marinette?" to which he said "yeah why not".
@michalelkin-bronner13
@michalelkin-bronner13 Жыл бұрын
So he might cofin marinette being bi at the end of the show not earlier because or else the show will be canceled he might not but since he said that there is a chance that he will
@michalelkin-bronner13
@michalelkin-bronner13 Жыл бұрын
Also kagami cancily has powerful feelings for both marientte and adrien and her feelings for adrien are romantic so
@michalelkin-bronner13
@michalelkin-bronner13 Жыл бұрын
But marc and juleka are homosexual mabye most but not all characters in the show are bi
@michalelkin-bronner13
@michalelkin-bronner13 Жыл бұрын
Didn't Thomas say that marinette would absolutely kiss a girl someone in the comment section said that
@Orkprof
@Orkprof Жыл бұрын
@@michalelkin-bronner13 not exactly. The rumour about Mari being gay or bi started bc someone posted a fanart of her and Mirabel from Encanto, with Mari pecking Mirabel on a cheek. The author of the tweet captioned the image: "girlfriends or what?", to which Astruc himself answered "of course they'd be!", which a huge part of the fandom took as definitive proof that Mari is gay or bi. 🤷‍♂️ Personally? I don't think she is. There's simply no evidence INSIDE the series. On the other hand, in "Adoration" (S5) they even had Mari give an open endorsement to polyamory and aromanticism, right out of the blue, so anything's possible.
@winter-starlight
@winter-starlight Жыл бұрын
I don't think you understand what the definition of queerbaiting is. Queerbaiting is teasing LGBT+ ships but then suddenly switching and they're actually straight (see Johnlock and Destiel). Miraculous has to keep it vague so that it gets past the censors of other countries, so that's what this is.
@starsiadraws
@starsiadraws Жыл бұрын
It doesn't mean they are actually straight, it means any time a character is heavily implied to be gay but not shown or the "rug keeps getting pulled out from the audience," so to speak. It's a marketing tactic to get queer people to watch the show while still being able to collect money from homophobic viewers.
@meowcoww
@meowcoww Жыл бұрын
I like that these kinds of discussions aren't just restricted to channels that solely revolve around them anymore (not that I don't like those channels, just that, if only in a small way, I think it shows progress) :)
@amandaw9852
@amandaw9852 Жыл бұрын
I agree these relationships are there to check a box, that’s what a lot of shows do because they want more viewers which = more money. Plus it’s a kid show so why focus on sexuality? Kids dont think that deeply about sexuality and neither should we. We shouldn’t focus so much on that, instead let’s just enjoy shows and movies for the story not for who’s dating who etc. And no I don’t dislike anyone, I’m just saying kid shows should focus on the story and not about sexuality. Let them have a break and relax watching a fun super hero show without anything being forced on them. I don’t think straight couples should kiss in kid shows either. It should just be focused on the story so the kids can have fun watching hero’s fight. Plus we can’t be angry that most the relationships are straight because that’s how it’s always been so it isn’t odd and majority of people are straight so it isn’t wrong for the show to have alot of straight couples logically. But yeah, shows like this and other cartoons will always add lgbt characters to score “woke points” like you said. It’s just how it works to get more people to watch the show. They don’t actually care to have a main gay character because it isn’t what they wanna do. They will only if they want more money and viewers. So it isn’t out of touch, it’s just how all shows and movies have been for years and they don’t “have” to include a relationship that doesn’t fit their show because it’s their show at the end of the day, it isn’t about us. Even though I understand where you are coming from, you want them to go through with adding lgbt characters because they hinted at it. Which I agree, if they wanna hint at it then they should just make it obvious that those two girls are dating instead of hinting at it. It does become annoying when they do that to bait viewers to keep watching but again it’s sadly what shows do because they want more viewers and money. They are corrupt so we shouldn’t be too shocked by their actions even though it’s understandable to feel frustrated:/
@user-uf6ym5pk5f
@user-uf6ym5pk5f 2 ай бұрын
You are so right, your comment is so underrated. I remember watching miraculous ever since season 1 and it is was a very important thing in my life, I honestly cannot imagine who I would be without. I wish people would just put normal stuff in kids shows and let the parents teach them about sexualities. Every family supports stuff and some families don't so they should not include something to make the kids thing of it in a good/wrong way. Honestly disney is dying. They just do it for views like you mentioned. I am so glad that I am not young and watching the show now cause I would not have understood sexualities or any of that stuff. If they are going to add gay characters in a show then make it make sense not just randomly for views. Or at least the main characters in a diffrent show.
@lail414
@lail414 Жыл бұрын
Bro you need to understand that this is a kids show they can’t force lgbt couples like that.
@jellycat6187
@jellycat6187 Жыл бұрын
Ur right We should get rid of the straight characters We don’t want our kids to think bring straight is okay now do we?
@nymfettes
@nymfettes Жыл бұрын
but its okay to have numerous scenes of adrien and marinette and any other straight couples kissing?? but gay people cant just exist in the show?
@CyanHope
@CyanHope 11 ай бұрын
“Force” you mean showing people that exist since the beginning of time? If heterosexuality can always be present in kids shows so can be other sexualities
@Howlabunga
@Howlabunga 7 ай бұрын
Did you check the wiki? according to that, Rosulika and Marcate are both canon.
@benceszilagyi8442
@benceszilagyi8442 Жыл бұрын
While I agree, I assume, and from comments it's heavily implayed that they don't want to make these ships offical, because than episodes (or the seria) could get baned from parts of the word
@austinmcneil8775
@austinmcneil8775 Жыл бұрын
I love juleka and rose’s relationship with each other in the series. I wished they were the main characters instead of what we got. What about you guys?
@glimmerstantroop46321
@glimmerstantroop46321 Жыл бұрын
Agreed, I may just be biased because they happen to be my two favourite characters (alongside Plagg) but these two are just so much more interesting than Adrienette and they are so unimportant and wasted in this show
@austinmcneil8775
@austinmcneil8775 Жыл бұрын
@@glimmerstantroop46321 for real
@polishalastor142
@polishalastor142 Жыл бұрын
They deserve to have they Own show About they relationship and life In one of my Fanfiction They are aunts for Marinette and Luka daughter from Future
@austinmcneil8775
@austinmcneil8775 11 ай бұрын
@@polishalastor142 they sure do. I really love those two cause they remind me of Luz and Amity except without the whole bullying thing you know!
@polishalastor142
@polishalastor142 11 ай бұрын
@@austinmcneil8775 oh right
@katsuminara4036
@katsuminara4036 Жыл бұрын
I honestly am not concerned about this stuff. I just want Luka to come back home!😊
@MomoKanjaki
@MomoKanjaki Жыл бұрын
Fr! I'm mad they wrote him out the show basically.
@Bella_for_you7
@Bella_for_you7 Жыл бұрын
Yknow how is the redhead teacher pregnant if she’s gay
@idontknow_666
@idontknow_666 8 ай бұрын
Honestly, I agree with all of this. And I personally have multiple points to add to this. 1. I feel the biggest reason they don't put proper Queer representation into this is because the company doesn't want a certain group of parents to be scared away. This isn't exclusive to only MLB but with multiple shows and series throughout the years. Many shows seem to want to show representation of the LGBTQIA+ community to gain a wider audience, but they also know they can't because they'll get MASSIVE back-lash from homophobes, and can end up losing an entirely different group that views their content. So I can only imagine the "hints" and "allegories" end up seeming as queerbaiting. 2. It's no secret this show has terrible writing. So, even if my first point wasn't a problem for them (if it is/was, to begin with), the chances of them exploring same-sex relationships would probably end up disastrous. Either because they just suck at writing relationships, or because they'll end up leaning into a harmful trope or stereotype, or both! Because this is miraculous. And I'm thankful they would NEVER dive into gender identity because I don't even want to know what the hell they would cook up. But really, it's unfortunate we can't even get our main cast of characters developed. At least we have fanfics and headcannons, lmao. Though, if this stupid show really will get more seasons (I think about 8 seasons is the amount they plan on having), I certainly hope they can at least try to do something with our (possibly) canonically Queer characters. :)
@ashvv
@ashvv Жыл бұрын
i honestly liked the zoe unrequited love episode as someome who has been pining over a straight girl for years and i thought it was pretty realistic. - a queer person
@Zen-ft5fj
@Zen-ft5fj Жыл бұрын
A gay relationship doesn't need to be the center of attention to count as representation. It doesn't need to be the center of attention. An on screen gay kiss IS REPRESENTATION. It's not queer baiting, queer baiting would be having Ms bustier blush around her spouse, yet never say that was her spouse, and have that continue for the rest of the series until she eventually gets with a guy. Don't know if you're in the community, but, I am, and I was ecstatic to see actual rep after SEASONS of waiting. Rose and Juleka was queer baiting, but then again, Rose said she loves SPECIFICALLY Juleka in the disk. Zoe wasn't queer baiting, she explicitly came out of the closet to a crush. Queer baiting and actual rep are two different things.
@Castformsupremacy
@Castformsupremacy 11 ай бұрын
You don’t need LGBT representation Gen Z is already woke enough The show is already bad enough You don’t need a force LGBT relationship to ruin the show anymore
@abrahamlupis9354
@abrahamlupis9354 10 ай бұрын
​@@gabidobre5584 but not on kids shows, dude
@jessicablueheart9772
@jessicablueheart9772 Жыл бұрын
Ok i gotta say the teacher one felt out of know where . Like in the show we havent heard of her partener before like ever. So this seems to come out of the blue. They could have at least gave us some hints to this.
@riotkitty
@riotkitty Жыл бұрын
Yeah same here. If she had a husband it would still feel forced af. Just she’s suddenly pregnant, and suddenly has a partner. Like what
@user-uf6ym5pk5f
@user-uf6ym5pk5f 11 ай бұрын
@@riotkitty Actually in the new york special it was confirmed that she is pregnant but they never said that she has a partner.
@elizaalmabuena
@elizaalmabuena Жыл бұрын
I'm mainly annoyed at the mostly L relationships. Granted, they can consist on cases that are other orientations and representations which just happen to result in female-female relationships...... but Marc/Nathaniel are the only potential male-male pairing I can think of, with Nathaniel maybe being Bi as him being attracted to Marinette was confirmed.
@anonymouspersonhere1000
@anonymouspersonhere1000 Жыл бұрын
Their just afraid that they’ll lose viewership that’s all.😑
@_AstaLily
@_AstaLily 4 ай бұрын
There’s four canonical LGBT relationships. Marcaniel, Julerose, Miss Bustier and her partner and the New York pairing.
@Keenidy
@Keenidy 11 ай бұрын
tbh we dont need lgbtq representation. lgbtq people want everything to be abt them (take it from a lesbian) there is more important representation like neurodiversity and disability. not just lgbtq.
@Chris_Mlr
@Chris_Mlr 10 ай бұрын
​@@gabidobre5584she said she is lesbian but i agree with you
@eleonor45
@eleonor45 Жыл бұрын
I'm sorry if anyone in the LGBTQ++ community got offended by this. I didn't even notice this up until now. Like, I knew about Juleka x Rose, the uh.. red haired shy guy with the black haired guy (sorry I'm bad at names here) and now the teacher. For me it was like "alright, representation is nice" but really, there never really was an episode about solely a couple like this. I hope we'll get a special episode ^^
@raebaby4600
@raebaby4600 Жыл бұрын
My viewpoint on it is that miraculous started before these other shows like owl house so it wasn't as acceptable/easy for them to do obvious LGBT stuff with it. Since the show started so long ago it started in the more "childish" mold rather than having the freedom that shows have now. At this point they have more freedom but I feel like they probably don't want to push these ideas too much outta fear of upsetting parents of the current young fans or somethin like that
@_AstaLily
@_AstaLily 4 ай бұрын
People are saying there were no clues to Zoe’s liking girls but in Deflagration she literally said to Scarabella “well, not yet anyway” about them being a couple I literally said right then “um zOe, ThAtS a BiT gAy” lol
@clover8250
@clover8250 11 ай бұрын
Well at the end of the day does it really matter? And plus there are certain countries which show miraculous that overly censor lgbtq+ plotpoints so it’s probably partly creators trying to have episodes allowed.
@lexudary.
@lexudary. 11 ай бұрын
I aint seen a cool black character in the show so until that happens the show is at a all time high of mid.
@burnedoutgraduatestudent4482
@burnedoutgraduatestudent4482 11 ай бұрын
Max?
@NA-kz5po
@NA-kz5po 11 ай бұрын
Max and Alya but the show doesn't even care
@lexudary.
@lexudary. 11 ай бұрын
@@burnedoutgraduatestudent4482 he's not cool (Also my pfp is my oc and he's called Max so I was confused for a second and yes he is black)
@lexudary.
@lexudary. 11 ай бұрын
@@NA-kz5po Max is the stereotypical need while alia is just a bad friend
@000Dragon50000
@000Dragon50000 Жыл бұрын
Very typical large corporation behaviour, honestly. Genuinely telling stories about LGBT characters? Nah. Attempting to cheaply profit off those identies by plopping a few in the background and going back to ignore us? Absolutely.
@riotkitty
@riotkitty Жыл бұрын
They wanna have their cake and eat it too. They’ll dangle gay characters in front of people to pander, but put em in easily editable scenes to erase em in the global market to make money from countries who don’t like em .
@drybones4930
@drybones4930 Жыл бұрын
5:39 okay, that caught me off guard. That was hilarious 😂
@CarlytheQueenofChaos
@CarlytheQueenofChaos Жыл бұрын
The thing with LGBTQ+ relationships in miraculous is that there are only straight and gay characters, less gay characters than straight ones and that makes it look like yeah either you are straight or gay and less people are gay. It's giving fck on the spectrum vibes. Where bisexual characters? Where trans characters? I mean I am not saying that every show should represent every single sexuality, since we basically have an infinite amount of sexualities and gender identities, but I'd like shows to have more than just straight and gay. Like a non binary character would so fit into the role of an animal hero, where people are like bro we don't even know their gender and then bam they don't even identify as one gender specifically. This is in my opinion such a missed chance. Or for example a trans girl who is looking quite like a guy still but turns into a girl hero, because it's magic, it doesn't even need an explaination. Honestly that is such a cool opportunity. Or just minor characters that show up once or rarely but are clearly gay couples or dressing androgynously.
@hdeyadplayz3436
@hdeyadplayz3436 Жыл бұрын
First!! Love the content keep it up!❤️
The Lost Miraculous Comics That Are Actually Insane
18:25
Smarty Pants
Рет қаралды 44 М.
small vs big hoop #tiktok
00:12
Анастасия Тарасова
Рет қаралды 28 МЛН
So Disney Just Hates Romance Now, Don't They? (Wish Re-write)
29:36
All Miraculouses Ranked! Season 5 Edition
20:08
Smarty Pants
Рет қаралды 181 М.
Miraculous Suit design tier list
18:22
Dragon empress
Рет қаралды 910
Miraculous Ladybug is hilariously dumb...
14:05
Alex Meyers
Рет қаралды 3,8 МЛН
a recap if you stopped watching miraculous ladybug
49:22
Amanda Todhunter
Рет қаралды 1,1 МЛН
THE KISSING BOOTH Is Stupid And Creepy | Cynical Reviews
22:42
Cynical Reviews
Рет қаралды 4,7 МЛН
The REAL Reason People Are Leaving Miraculous
9:31
Smarty Pants
Рет қаралды 176 М.
Normal vs Psychopath vs Rich How to heal a cut on your finger ☝️❤️‍🩹
0:19
I Outsmarted My Bully Brother And Ate His Cotton Candy🤫😎
0:33
Giggle Jiggle
Рет қаралды 10 МЛН
Когда все обошлось 😮‍💨 | Королева Двора
0:16
Аминка Витаминка
Рет қаралды 4,3 МЛН
Эмоции💫 | Тгк: D1ashenka✨
0:22
D1ashenka
Рет қаралды 2,6 МЛН
Все мы немного НИКА!
0:17
Привет, Я Ника!
Рет қаралды 2,8 МЛН