I love how Nightmare fluttershy seems more animalistic as she turns away from other ponies and now only socializes with animals

Ok I like this, this is the biggest “fuck you” to that one guy- WAITTTTTT IT IS FLUTTERSHY

"She's the new face of going postal" has NO RIGHT to be as funny as it is with how flippantly you said it XD

I love the idea of her not speaking. Like all she can do is make hissing bat noises, I think that would be cool

I genuinely thought you tricked us again 😭😭😭

IT FINALLY HAPPENED WE WERE NOT FOOLED!!!

Maybe because she's a local cryptid she has a title rather than a name. Something like The Phantom of Everfree or The Ponyville Vampire as like a jumping off point

Love that we didn’t just get nightmare fluttershy, but also nightmare derpy! So happy that u included some aspects of flutterbat into the nightmare design!

I refuse to believe the thumbnail is flutters- oh damn she actually did it

Hmmm…how about Countness Flutter-Brash….because Shy is the opposer of Confidence…and Brash is one of the antonym of shy, and she can be the kindest of the nightmares.

Oh my goodness, it wasn’t a lie- Edit: Discord simping for evil flutter shy was not on my bucket list but I’m happy I got to see it

Oh my god i love nightmare derpy thats too adorable 😭😭😭😭 i imagine she delivers all the wrong letters to all the wrong addresses bringing pure chaos upon equestrias postal! AND fluttershy?! Double yay!!

I cant even imagine feeling so entitled that you say someone not drawing what you specifically want "disrespectful" 😭 like its never that serious- sorry you were dealing with those rude people i personally loved the bit :3

That’s kinda interesting that you did derpy hooves, the most unlikely character to have a nightmare form, and nightmare fluttershy’s design is cool!

Count-Fluttera? Batty-shy? Whatever name you chose or whoever makes the most bomb name choice in all of youtube history, I'll still love this series ✨

It's less a part of her character but there are also many scenes where she's singing/singing to her animals so maybe it could also be a siren like thing where she lures animals and ponies into the everfree forest with her voice?

Countess Shy? also HELPPP discord being head over heels for nightmare flutterbat is so funny and totally in character for him

going off of flutter-bat maybe it could be Flutter-Bite?

Love both designs! Dracushy (Dracula+Fluttershy) or Bloody Butterfly would probably work? Also, fun fact, Butterflies will drink blood if given the opportunity!

I think Fluttermaus could be a fun name for Nightmare Fluttershy. Fluttermaus being German for bat is the closest pun i could think of. Love this series!

When you did the whole "not doing fluttershy" bit, I thought it was funny and didn't take it to heart I think some people need to chill out about ponies being turned into villains

Her design looks so dope. I came up with some names for her: 1) Flitterfall 2) Flutterfake 3) Floral Fiasco 3) Floral Fury 4) Fauna Fool 5) Flora Faunarude/Faunatude 6) Folklore Faux

The little discord simpin in the corner is so accurate to his character

Really cool design for Derpy's Nightmare form btw! Love the fade on the hair :D Oh, and Fluttershy's design is SO GOOD!!!!

Nightmare Derpy would lose your mail just to laugh at your frustration

SHES ACTUALLY DONE IT-

Mailstrom. Perfection. Almost makes me forget how terrible you were for stringing us along 😂 (was still expecting Spike so this was still a surprise lol)

Rarity should be a nightmare pageant Queen

At first, I thought you’d go with the Ponies of Dark Water comic idea for Nightmare Fluttershy, but hey, this Flutterbat-like concept is just cool! Favorite of the lot, with Apple Hijack and Pinkiacci right behind her, wonderful job!

Discord and her would make a great villian couple. I imaging flutters still being her normal self to only discord, and them just doing evil stuff together.

Ignore everyone it's YOUR channel And I LOVE Derpy Hooves

Beast Monarch sounds rlly cool for Nightmare Fluttershy and fitting since beast is for, well, beasts aka animals and monarch for the ruling/control and the butterfly species.

Honestly, I was fully prepared to wait another week for Fluttershy and watch a Derpy Hooves nightmare video, LMAO! I love the art and just the way you draw and design them is mwah! ✨ French kiss. ✨ Fluttershy looks amazing, I love her wings and the little bat-shaped collar she has around her neck it's so cool! The idea of Rainbow Dash using a mirror on Fluttershy and defeating her by having her use the stare against herself is such a great concept! I also love Mailstream even though it was a joke to get rid of the mad people, she's so silly and such a goober and her version of being evil is giving people paper cuts is just so charming.

Yoooo this is awesome! Nightmare Fluttershy has this graceful anger vibe to her and it's amazing. I feel like Nightmare Fluttershy would be so reclusive she wouldn't give herself a name but, in the vein of The Phantom of The Opera, recieves a name from those she haunts, like The Pegasus of The Forest or something similar. Both characters find disgust in themselves and become reclusive to the point of harming anything that comes close, accident or not. I love your interpretation of her shyness overtaking Fluttershy mentally and becoming aggressive as a result! Definitely my favorite Nightmare-ification from you!

I think that "Sanguinare-Shy" or "the Sangui-mare" would be a good name for her. Sanguinare means "to lose blood/to bleed" so it fits the vampire bat vibes and it has nice alliteration to keep shy in her name, or can be a pony pun. And yes I only thought of the word because of the skyrim name for vampirism disease, but it was good inspiration

Im sorry but Discord in the corner cracked me up Also what about Count Shockwave or something like that because of how she can freeze animals in their place lol

Discord and NM Fluttershy boutta be THE power couple of Equestria

As a fun fact, original Dracula could actually control animals (usually wolves) Also, despite being a joke, I love Nightmare Derpy

Came for flutter-shy, stayed for derpy. Edit: oh.

I lowkey want to make a fanfic with this version of nightmare fluttershy

I actually love that you keep duking your audience out. It reminds people that artists/content creators are not their workers that comply with every demand that they make.

Fluttershy looks dope! Also I was very willing to watch this video be about the derpy pony XD

i could see fluttershy getting fed up with ponies hurting animals and becoming an advocate for pony extinction

Name idea for Nightmare Fluttershy: Medushy.

I thought it was so funny you kept choosing what you wanted to do! I Sometimes that's just how it is being an artist. I loved the Derpy Hooves design as well! I'm enjoying your art for your art, sorry people are being so entitled.

ur absolutely insane for edging us like this omg😭 but fr the entitlement is crazy, this is literally your channel and u can do whatever u want ??? why is that so hard for some ppl to understand bro

it took me almost 2 mins to realize ur not drawing flutter like oh my gosh that was just hilarious i love derpy hooves!!!

hey i was excited for derpy!! the paper cut scoundrel! i think for fluttershy an interesting idea could be done with her living in the everfree forest, where she tries to expand the forest's reach and take over ponyville for the animals? since she doesn't want to interact with people and i feel like also it could be an attempt to get the animals to like her again.

I can't believe, the nerve!! That you didn't trick us again for lolz and actually delivered Fluttershy hahahahahha. I personally thought it was hilarious how Flutters got sided twice. Great work with the design and I can't wait to see more.

evil fluttershy real.. i can die peacefully now but seriously, your art is great and i appreciate all the work and creativity you put into your videos!

I knew it! I FUCKING knew it! I knew Fluttershy would be here!

i was thinking villian fluttershy would be more batpony than postal pony.

THE WAY THAT YOU MAKE HER LOOK LIKE HER BAT-PONY LOOKING FORM IT'S JUST- *cheff kiss*

THERE'S MY ART LET'S GOOOOOOO

honestly i was down for the bit if you saved flutters for last.

I like the idea that in this situation Discord is the one to redeem Fluttershy and bring her back to reality since she had been the main drive for his redemtion.

Fluttershy is my favorite pony Tysm for doing her!!

Hearing fluttershy would have stone ponies around her place reminds me so much of draculas tale! I love the unintentional comparison ☺️

Seriously laughed at the mail puns!

Jane’s a nightmare version of herself, instead of Jane Gumball we have Screwball, and she specializes in creating online fires with the power of polls!

Fluttershy is beautiful she's giving me Queen of Vampires ❤️❤️❤️

Countess Shy? Flutterbeast? LOVE your designs btw your style is such a vibe

YOU DOUBLE TRICKED US OMG

I think it would be interesting if the nightmare force turned into a vampiric parasite, infected an animal, and tricked Fluttershy into caring for it before making the animal bite her and transferring over like magic rabies lmao.

The animals running way thing makes a ton of sense when you considered what happen in the season one finale

Yay, I have honestly been enjoying this series. So while it's sad that it'll end after next week, I'm alright with that and excited for what's next!!! And I love Nightmare Fluttershy and Derpy!!!

I think the name count flutterbat would be nice Cuz you mentioned the vampire concept

I could see fluttershy turning herself into a vampire cuz she maybe believes that her connection with the animals may be stronger if she turns herself into one.

fluttershy's nightmare name being shyaway, 98% because of the bit at the start of this video lmaooooo

I was a little mad at first, but I can understand when the inspiration decides not to flow when it comes to a specific project. I love your work

Fluttershy turning to a queen of the Everfree Forest would be awsome, so maybe Ever Shy, representing her rejection of pony company in favor of nature. Her becoming posesive over the forest in a desire to force then to love her by trapping them in the forest with her. Or, for a different story, she grows tired of ponies and other thinking creatures hurting animals and nature, and turns against Pony Kind, claiming the forest and all within, using the power of the Everfree Forest to take over Equestria.

Worth the wait!!!! This is lovely!!!!

Ooo I love this nightmare Derpy design, ya know, I really think this might be some of your best work! very compelling story, just, perfection! alright, now that all the entitled folk have moved on, I love this Fluttershy! I think its fun to have someone who is so different, and I think a lot of the nightmare variations had unique and interesting relationships with other ponies in general, with Apple hurting anyone that wasnt her family and corrupting them, Rainbow wanting to control them for their adoration, Pinkie seeing them as objects to force happiness onto--so having one that just wants nothing to do with other ponies is fun! Maybe beasts are leaving the forest in droves, fearing for their lives because nightmare Flutter is actively controlling any beast that cant manage to escape, turning the forest into a prison without realizing it. She thinks shes saving them, but really shes stifling and trapping them or something also making her a vampire is great, awesome work as alwayd and I'm sorry some folk were pieces of shit!

blast, you've gotten us again! expertly fooled us into thinking we were receiving our beloved yellow horse, only to pull a fast one by delivering a cross-eyed equine instead!

Queen of the bats should be her title

Honestly i knew you would still troll people when u get to fluttershy lmao Also - you making nightmare fluttershy based on flutterbat makes me wonder what would a nightmare fluttershy based on werewolves look like, since wolves are also reclusive/shy and well-animals lol

This whole thing is too funny to be mad at😭😭😭

You almost bamboozled us with the fake-out with Nightmare Derpy there. 😂 But at long last we've finally cornered you into releasing our Nightmare Flutters. Next up, our last of the Elements to corrupt: Rarity. 💎 We've already seen Nightmare Rarity happen in the comics, but what would be your take on her villain-ization?

Great video. You should do Nightmare Bulk Biceps next

I like how pink the hair is

Discord being smitten is so real 😭😭 Also, I thought of "Crittershy" being a somewhat good name for her

Aw, I was so excited for evil muffin horse

girl i love you. my jaw was on the floor this was so funny

honestly...hell yeah o h i was actually so ready for this not to be a fluttershy video

Fluttershy thinking she is Dracula 💀

I'd love to see the CMC as nightmare versions! It would be awesome to have the cutie mark cruel-saders to complete the set!

Nightmare Fluttershy name ideas: Fluttervania (Fluttershy + Transylvania) Flutter Fang Flutter Bite Count Bat Culling Shy Flutter Shroud Coffin Shroud Count Shy Vein Helswing Flutter Night Moon Shy (Play on "Moonshine") Dracushy Nightshy (like Nightshade)

Needs more vampire/fruitbat in the design but that's just me

When I saw Discord looking at her with heart eyes, it drew a brief wheeze out of me! XD

Derpy bonus, I see this as a win win

We got a Draculutterdusa and we love her! I expected a flutterbat fleeing her friends who tried to kill her after becoming a vampire in that one episode then turning evil but a cryptid fluttershy is extremely amazing

Dracufauna or Lady Piercing would be neat, playing off of Dracula and the whole biting/pointy motif. Not very Fluttershy, but it's what popped into my head.

Love every nightmare design of the mare6! Maybe Flitterscare would be a good name? So tricky to name lol

I think it would be cute if she had little horns like discord (he has horns, right??). I also feel like the first version is unironically pretty good lol like that's what Fluttershy thinks the worst possible thing she could do is, but when she actually is corrupted she actually goes feral.

My god who cares that it wasn't Fluttershy the other time? Just be happy she's doing art for y'all

whenever i open youtube it immediately goes to this video lmao

FINALLY ITS HER TIME TO SHINEEEEE I adore this design so much 💖

Honestly the Flutter Shy bit was really fun! Seeing the teasers and trying to guess who it was other than Flutters!

I think Count/ess Dracushy is interesting!

THEYVE BEEN EDGING US FOR SO ONG BRO THANK GOD WE FINALLY GOT FLUTTERSHY