I love how she explains very clearly exactly why her husband picked up muffins and how it had nothing to do with Amber and the lawyer just goes "mUfFiNs?!?!"

The little smile on Johnny's lawyer's face is priceless. He knows Amber's lawyers are gonna make a fool of themselves. This doctor is simply amazing. She is calm, composed, not rushing to answer. Major props to her.

I’m actually a little surprised that elaine didn’t ask whether the muffins were blueberry, chocolate chip, something else or assorted. How very restrained of her.

“May I clarify what occurred so we can stop talking about the muffins?” Hahaha! Love how she made the lawyer look even dumber.

She was incredible. Her phone is going to be ringing off the hook with attorneys seeking her as an expert witness.

"HOW DARE YOU HAVE MUFFINS WITH YOUR CLIENTS!" ... said nobody. Ever.

Does the lawyer not know what a psychologist does for a living? Did She really think she could trick this witness into agreeing to something not true?

This psychologist is impeccable as a witness--Intelligent, articulate, confident. No hesitation, no tendency to be thrown off track by the attorney, assertive about her answers when questioned a second time by the attorney, in an attempt to trip her up.

She’s a married woman and Amber’s lawyer is suggesting she had dinner and drinks alone with Johnny when it was with his whole legal team! 🤦‍♂️

What I find fascinating is how a simple off handed comment like, “let’s thank my husband for the muffins today,” which had nothing to do with ms heard suddenly got twisted into being all about her.

I LOVE this witness. The way she corrects and shuts down the attorney is priceless.

She had to explain the muffin incident to the lawyer like she’s explaining it to a 4 year old. We love this psychologist, take that W babe🫶

That muffin question was ridiculous. Johnny’s team probably didn’t object because they knew it made her lawyer look crazy

I really enjoy when a witness not only realizes a lawyer is being accusatory and misrepresenting info, but makes that apparent to the jury and audience.

The way she closes her eyes and giggles after saying "I asked him to pick up the muffins for me" is fascinating how confident she is.

Imagine being called into court to deliver a testimony about muffins…

That psychologist is on another level. Her ability to cut through the BS in real time is both beautiful and terrifying lol respect. Fixed lol

When your defense hinges on a muffin incident, it's probably time to offer a settlement.

The fact that prior to this clusterfuck of a trial, Elaine Bredehoft was considered one of washington’s top and respected attorneys is honestly one of the saddest career downfalls I’ve ever come across..

14:08 The lawyer giggled like a schoolgirl tricking her neighbor into giving her extra candy on Halloween. Truly unprofessional. I genuinely don't know how this woman became a lawyer.

I’m glad she clarified what happened with the muffins because things were starting to get out of control.🙄

Amber Heard’s lawyer is an embarrassment. Not only did she make herself look incompetent over the makeup mishap, she now shows herself to be a condescending, even snarky woman. If I were Heard, I would really regret having her as part of the legal team.

This is embarrassing...if you want to lose your trial hire these lawyers

I can’t get over how hostile this attorney is towards this witness.

The difference in professinal integrity between these two women is night and day. What a wonderful witness and psychologist, and what a rude and unprepared lawyer. It's almost surreal to follow this exchange

The level of incompetence coming from that lawyer is off the charts.

The way that this Psychologist is verbally destroying this lawyer in her own game is actual GOLD!

I love a strong woman who doesn’t need to be acidic and mean to get her point across! Unlike the lawyer!

"You're incorrect, that is not correct" what an absolute legend

This lawyer is repeatedly, unnecessarily combative. This is a weak attempt to rattle the witness and it's failing, miserably.

The way she keeps her emotion in check, calm with full of integrity. Is it only me or anyone else who feels I can watch her testify all day

How do some of these lawyers actually acquire a law degree and begin practicing? This lawyer is an embarrassment.

Yes the muffin story was stupid and unnecessary. But that lawyer broke the number one rule of the courtroom: don't argue with the judge. Especially don't do it looking and acting like a teenage girl going "but mom!"

This trial started out sad, then moved to be absurd. Now it's just downright hilarious. Like how dare she bring muffins, that's just rude!

The fact that Ambers attorney makes a big deal about her meeting with Johnny Depp & his legal team is so bizarre, why wouldn’t the person hiring someone meet & vet the person… Also, it’s so obvious that Amber’s attorney is suggesting the only reason the forensic psychologist gave Amber a borderline personality diagnosis is because that is what Johnny wanted her to say. In fact, her getting to meet & speak with her patients partner or ex-partner actually gives her a much stronger & more full understanding of what Ambers day to day typical behavior looks like. I’ve participated in many IEP meetings as an educator. Most thorough & comprehensive evaluations done on someone rely on a variety of input. In the situations I’ve been apart of, when a child is evaluated for a learning disability or if they are refered for testing due to behavior related issues, there is always evaluations sent home for a parent to complete, the child’s teachers are asked to complete 1 or 2 different assessments usually one more focused on how they interact with peers, adults, handle disappointment, show empathy ect. In addition to an evaluation which focuses more on academic competencies. The best, well rounded & most comprehensive assessments include input from multiple people in the persons life. ESPECIALLY when your looking at a personality similar to Ambers; a sneaky, vindictive, hateful, jealous, envious and overall un-likable person. I’d LOVVVEEEE to know how many life long friends Amber has, people that have known her since elementary or middle school, (even highschool) and are still friends with her today! How many people does she have in her life that they feel they can count on her if needed?! I’d put money on ZERO!! She is the kind of person that rolls through people, becomes incredibly close to someone, they accept her & show her love & affection & security/trust, and when she decides she doesn’t like how something happened SHE EXPLODES! The forensic psychologist explained it so perfectly. Being friends with or around someone with that kind of personality disorder/mental health issue is both physically & mentally & emotionally draining on the other person. The relationship will eventually end up NOT BEING WORTH THE TIME & ENERGY!!!

All my respect to this lady. She full on destroyed Amber's lawyer!

It is so disgusting to see a legal team try to make something out of nothing. To take facts and twist them then not let the witness answer other than a yes or no. This is manipulation to the extreme.

Wow, this psychologist is one of the smartest and most highly qualified people I've seen. And this lawyer is the complete opposite.

I love how the lawyer keeps rolling through her own narrative, continuing on while literally being told “no. That is not correct.” And just barrels into the next question like she got the answer she was hoping for 💀

Amber: “Muffins? Really?!” Amber’s Lawyer: “Yeah, Amber honey, we’re down to that.”

This lawyer is completely lost and it’s literally embarrassing to watch her.

She answers so specific, so accurate and careful. She is very very intelligent.

This is so sad. Imagine how much Amber has paid for this muffin lawyer lmao

4:40 The way Heard's lawyer says "didn't you?" at the end of every manipulative question she asks boils my blood! I'm not a violent person, and I am only saying this as a hypothetical, but I would love to give her a right smack to the face. She is rude and incredibly aggravating to listen to.

The way she shuts the lawyer down with “that’s incorrect”… she has ice water in her veins.

the lawyer literally just puts lies into the other woman’s mouth and is always proven wrong😭😭 this is so embarrassing

This psychologist easily had the best testimony

7:06 love how that dude in the front (Johnny’s lawyer i think? Sorry I’m not that invested) writes some note and gives it to Johnny and then they both smile at each other. Probably also roasting Amber‘s lawyer lmao

The amount of times she said "that's not correct" blows my mind, that lawyer truly does not know what she's saying

Her line of questioning was so laughable that I was half expecting her to ask what flavor the muffins were

This forensic psychologist’s testimony was amazing to watch. She’s incredible at breaking down the complexities of her work to help the jury understand Heard’s many psychological long-term issues that clearly predates her relationship with Depp. The way Heard’s attorney grasps for straws and tries in desperation to “create” the narrative she seeks is pretty sad. Heard’s whole legal team is just obnoxious and rude. The ridiculous angle of the muffins? Really? 🙄

My favourite part is when she tries to say the Psychologist didn't diagnose AH with a personality disorder and then proceeds to read out a report of her diagnosing AH with said personality disorder 😂

I like this doctor. Very well spoken, intelligent, and up front. I love that she keeps correcting the lawyer.

The lawyer is really trying to trip her up by using sneaky wording to fabricate an “ahha I caught you” moment. But there is nothing to catch. You can tell the witness clearly sees what the lawyer is trying to do with her insistent choice of words and fast paced delivery, but she is not falling for the cheap tactics and maintains her already shared truth. Of course this would be frustrated to deal with, but it’s quit comical how bad the lawyer is executing it!

"Your husband commented about Amber's muffins, correct?" "Did your husband attempt to pay for Amber's muffins?" "Were Amber's muffins your husband's personal favorites?" "Why are Amber's muffins so good?" "Why did your husband choose these muffins over others?" "Does your husband have a muffin fetish?" "Are you aware muffins carry a negative female connotation?" "Is your husband the proverbial Muffin Man?"

I like how she discredits what the other doctor says by respectfully giving her opinion as she answers the lawyers questions about her recollection to the other doctors testimony

At this point listening to these lawyers trying to make her look innocent is exhausting, because the truth is so vividly there on Johnny’s side everything they say just sounds like another one of Amber’s lies.

A lawyer once said to me, “Lawyers never lie in court. Instead, we attempt to fashion the truth to meet a particular objective.” That’s what Amber’s attorney is attempting to do. She appears to be failing.

9:14 "go to page 261," brrruuuuhhhh she sounds so over it lmaoooooo!!!! I just noticed even johnny was laughing cuz he could tell she was over it 🤣

I do kind of feel bad for the lawyers, taking such a famous case knowing you’ll lose and a majority are rooting against you would suck.

This is so ridiculous. Ambers lawyers knows she is guilty and done. Now they have to find some nonsense stuff

I hope people who see this start realizing this is how court works. It’s not about finding the truth. It’s about telling the better story.

This freaking lawyer was trying to lead her into admitting she told her husband about meeting with Amber Herd. WTF! Telling her husband WHO she was meeting would have been a breech of Dr/patient confidentiality PLUS it's a HIPPA violation. Did Lawyer lady seriously think she was going to admit to something like that and put her license at risk?? Like SERIOUSLY? This absolute beast of a professional wasn't about to slip or engage in this idiots whiny attempts to trap her. BRAVO to this wonderful Psychologist. And yes, this lawyer sounded seriously whiny because she wasn't getting her way in leading the witness through speculative questions.

We should rename this little gem "When Karens pass the bar". If the attorneys have the same effect on a jury as they've had on me, the lawyers alone may tank Heard's case. Ugh. It would be different if the questions were not so obviously taken out of context. You should be able to put forth an effective argument with the right wording and in proper context, without tailoring them to what you would like them to mean. Well....unless you just don't have much of a case. Then you get THIS.

I love that she has to contain her laughter over this muffin story. Like its so ridiculous she has to tell a story as mundane as "My husband picked up muffins for me and I offered one to Amber Heard"

Even Johnny’s team is having a hard time keeping a straight face as this fool tries to put words into the mouth of the witness. They’re essentially laughing at how ridiculous her line of questioning is.

What we REALLY want to know is what's the diagnosis Dr Curry arrived at for Attorney Bredehoft?

dam depp hit a home run with that psychologist, her explanations are explained eloquently, and she knows what not to say or how to counter their questions.

I cannot STAND the lawyer questioning over and over the freaking muffins. She also got the makeup wrong. And Amica cream. What a lovely record she has of screwups. Amber gives real DV victims a bad name, and they have a hard enough time being believed. I'm a nurse who has had to deal with DV victims, and poor JD shows the symptoms of being abused without any doubt. Makes me sick that someone who is a real DV victim may not be believed and this case cited as why.

lawyer: "do you know the man who brought you the muffins?" witness: "do I know the muffin man? yes. yes I know the muffin man"

The desperation of Amber’s female attorney that gets her bloomer in a twist over muffins proves how very weak her client’s case really is!

I couldn't stop laughing at the second hand embarrassment I was getting when Amber's lawyers kept bringing up the Muffins, like it had ANY significance on the case and didn't just waste everyone's time with such a pathetic line of questioning.

The forensic psychologist is better at her job than AHs lawyer is at hers

If the attorney for Heard is obsessed with muffins, then you know her case is in trouble!

“That goes to bias”.. that statement tells you the kind of people they are when facts don’t go their way

The forensic psychologist witness had me glued to my seat, she was so amazing and full of enlightening information, really loved her. It is clear that Johnny has lived in a form of hell with Amber and to be able to bring the truth out in this way is an absolute must.

Is it anymore pathetic when an attorney is objected, the judge sustains, yet the same attorney proceeds to pause and visibly sigh in frustration and have the nerve to question the judge and pout like a child for not being able to do her job. How has this “team” made it to this level of clientele? I wouldn’t trust them to argue muffins are baked goods.

That lawyer shot herself in the leg with the "Gaslighting" question. Like Damn! What a way to dig your own grave

4:20 the classic line😂. "-It goes to bias your honour😩" lmao

“Did you have drinks with Mr. Depp?” “And his legal team” “Are you denying you had drinks with him?” “No. With Depp and his legal team, I’m giving you the whole answer” -angry lawyer noises- This woman is shredding her reputation, not by representing a guilty client, but by defending her with muffins and blatantly demanding partial answers when full answers are provided.

I admire the psychologist, looks very smart and presenting facts to the point.

This psychologist is a beast!!! Wow she took that lawyer to school

"She displayed SYMPTOMS" because you see, just because you have all symptoms of a heart attack does not mean you actually have it!

This attorney is so considering and disrespectful and her unprofessional and rude nature is such a clear reflection of her floundering because she is so insecure in her case and her offensive. This psychiatrist is incredibly composed, articulate, and intelligent and I am utterly impressed and satisfied watching her eat that lawyer alive.

“May I clarify what happened so that we can stop talking about the muffins?” Priceless delivery by the psychologist about how wasteful in time this was @5:42 Also the way the lawyer says maffins is just, it makes it worse for me LOL

Amber’s team makes me believe we could all make it as a lawyer.

Wow I had to double check who’s lawyer this was. Are they trying to lose?

An unstable lawyer trying to use a word salad against a mental health professional. That is priceless. This witness is AMAZING. LOVE HER! This lawyer is horrible. If Amber actually had a case, her lawyer isn't doing her any favors.

Imagine trying to twist words and play mind games with a psychologist

How did this woman ever become a lawyer? She tries to bully people when when her imposed narrative doesn't hold up to reality and crumbles into petty backtalk when she's rightfully shut down by the judge.

that psychologist is so professional and eloquent. its a delight to listen to her.

Muffins were for the office and his wife, not for Amber Heard. Geeesh! I can’t believe the lawyer is twisting a kind gesture into something else!!!

I swear whenever she gets objected, no matter how fair it is, she always goes NYEEEEEGHHHH ITS NOT FAIRRR

The looks on Depp's attorney's while this charlatan makes a fool of herself in questioning her is PRICELESS.

Seemingly, the lawyer underestimated the psychologist, and her ability to resist manipulation.

This woman makes me smile. I want to be just as collected as her.

The lawyer is just “speculating “ so that’s how she wants to run with it to give it light. No need for a storyline on Muffins! I love how the psychologist stands her ground. 👏

I had to come back to this video because everytime someone mentions the muffins... ...and then Elaine... I immediately think of a Seinfeld episode 😆 or how this could easily *be* a Seinfeld episode 🤦‍♀️ ...and it's just too much. 😅🤣😂😂

It's always fascinating to see medical professionals and lawyers interact. Doctors, scientists, and anyone practicing the various fields of medicine and science will rarely give you a concrete, simple yes or no because what's considered true at the moment can always change and a lot of things need explanation. It's why the word "impossible" is rarely used, it's always "improbable". There's always a chance that things can change and no matter how well versed you are in the field, you can't always be certain. Lawyers on the other hand will often want concrete yes or no answers because they need to eliminate context in order to win a case. Start trying to explain something that's detrimental to their defense and they'll shut it down, asking again in different ways until they get the answer they want. One of them needs to explain context in order to bridge the gap between professional and the public. The other needs to eliminate context in order to sway the public to their side.

This lawyer has a terrible way of delivering her questions, she’s all over the place trying her best to trip this witness up and she fails.