Now I'm convinced that vocal trainers under JYPE changed after 2019. Itzy has only Lia, Twice has 3mix but Nmixx literally has 2 AA vocalists and rest being decent WA, not including Bae who is still a weak but even if she tried to rid off her approach like she did now she'd eventually be WA as well. I know that Lily and Haewon would be good vocalists no matter what, but it's really amazing to see how dancers and rappers have vocal tehnique as well.

My two cents after Kiss after letting it marinate (and since this is a proper Nmixx song after like 738 years) Lily sustained her notes really nicely this time around and she even added vibrato, we love that for her. Her little staccato adlib sounded great too. In general, that's some good ass high mixing. Haewon has so many lines and understandable, she really knows how to modify her technique to the concept, she was able to sing cutesy with that signature kpop nasal sound at the start and then by the end of the song she went all out with the open and clean belts. Really happy that Sullyoon got the opportunity to showcase some ACTUAL complex adlibs. It looks like after Lily and Haewon, Sullyoon is gonna be given the ad libbed lines in the future. Bae sounds SOOO good without the stylistic approach. Albeit her technique in Kiss is also a bit stylized with a light and soft singing approach, she was still able to showcase grounded moments with it. Overall while there's nothing super noteworthy in terms of improvement since for most of the song, all of the vocals were pretty tame and they only starting going full out at the end, it's still really great to see more exposure for their vocals.

Jinni sounded lovely but she only got two lines... #LetJinniSing Listen to how pleasing Bae's voice sounds when she isn't singing with her usual stylistic technique. Sullyoon actually doing some heavy ad lib work, I wish they just made it louder instead of blending it witb the background vocals (that's how the og goes but still). Slaymixx doing it again!!!!1!1!11!!

Listening to Kiss again and that was definitely Lily’s best E5 by FAR. I’ve been hearing some talks that it contains a bit of support, or at least attempted to keep a neutral larynx 👀 But I mean she’s gonna get to fully supporting E5 at this rate so it’s already impressive that the quality of her E5 has improved. Ahhh I can’t wait for NMIXX’s comeback!

we’re getting a Sullyoon MIXXTAPE! ig they’ll be doing these occasionally to keep us occupied until the cb

so the kiss project was just released and BAE FINALLY LEFT THAT STYLISTIC APPROACH FOR ONCE!! we shall celebrate cuz she sounded sm better than usual. Lily’s sustained highnotes were nice as well.

Sullyoon's mix sounded pretty balanced in her Mixxtape. More balanced than usual anyway. Prolly 'cuz the song's key is in a comfortable range for her.

aespa did so good singing Yeppi Yeppi live, their energy and vibe was so different

Since I can't find more videos, it seems like my girls sang Yeppi Yeppi and ICU live, but Savage doesn't seem like it. Anyways I'm happy we're getting any material finally 😌 After watching more fancams Black mamba, Yeppi Yeppi, ICU, Next level were live. Illusion, Savage and Girls didn't seem like it, but we will eventually hear them live as well.

everyone sounded so good in kiss and lily was going off at the end lmao

æspa sang YEPPI YEPPI pure live without heavy backtrack. They sound so good and confident!

I hope other female vocalists who seems to be underestimated at first should be re-analyze more, we may never know what potential they could hold.

kzfaq.info/get/bejne/lZado9J7uNTHg2w.html Sullyoon sang stay by BP in her mixtapes . I am convinced all the girls are trained in all three (vocal,dance and idol rapping) proficiently I never expected her to rap this good . As for vocals I don't particularly think she showcased something extraordinary but isn't her midrange very strong . This also goes to show that you don't need to have an unique voice to make a song sound heavenly I actually prefer this to the original like most songs nmixx covered( I am biased as well lol)

Lily just mixing her ass off and Haewon sounding so open in her improvised lines for the final chorus. This is too good. kzfaq.info/get/bejne/pc-DoNqrtcCzf6M.html Edit: Pretend I did it right the first time.

Shoshi is coming soon!!!! Aaaaahhhh queens are back!

Awesome video! I’m glad to see Hayoung appreciation. Her Bb4’s didn’t sound bad at all

Heejin has made her appearance on the community tab 😳 I am surprised as always lol but she’s really talented

Hope there will be members of Purple kiss next week😂 They will be releasing songs! !

omg Nmixx's remake summer song will come out on July 31. They're gonna remake Kiss by Rainbow (song from 2009) and the og song is just full on vocals so hopes are high 🤓🤞🏿

Great vid 🌸🌸

Don't you think you to move up Lily to AA-P? Or keep her remain on the AA?

Btw, if lily consistently keep the approach like her C#5 in let it go cover (that well-supported). Where would she land?

Wow i not expect Hayoung have support range

It’s already former fromis member in the community post😢

Wow, Hayoung can sound pretty solid.

YASSS

Any updates on viviz or Gfriend members?

Please.. stop being so desperate to try and make these singers go up the ranks or add a note to their "supported range." SUPPORTED RANGE isn't even a real thing taught in schools, its just a pseudonym created by the vocal community 😭 Y'all are willing to grasp at straws to try and get your faves up on some random ranking in the internet that y'all don't even care about the vocal pedagogy aspects to back up your argument anymore 💀

What do u think about Sullyoon "Stay" cover??

RV stans probably the most delusional stans out there, just saw they said Joy outsingings Ningning 😂 I know They underestimate aespa a lot now they believe Joy is better than nn, who's gonna tell Giselle alone outsings Joy 😂

hayoung is a bit underrated her voice is so powerful ;-;

Jinni vocal in the teaser and she still got cut off PLEASE LET MY DAUGHTER SING 💀💀💀

is gyuri low w-a or does she still not have the proper engagement?

I’ve heard some people say Yujeong (Lightsum) is the 2nd best song we in the group. I think she might have cleaner moments than Juhyeon.

Thought on Nmixx remake project??

hello there, sootzubae! i'm wondering, are you familiar with produce 48 contestants's vocal? if you did, may i ask who is the best vocalist on the show? (i bet it would be either goeun or yunjin)

i don't mean to question too much but i wonder what's some contents/reasonings for heejin in high w-a?

Can you include songsun (tribe main vocalist) in next video? I want to know her ability

Opinions on Woo!ahs vocals?

Would really want to know your opinion about nmixx's latest karaoke vlive. Anyways, great video! Keep it up : )

I thought Jiwoo would get more lines, but that's okay, at least bae ditches the THROATY HELL GOAT approach

Can someone please help me find a kpop vocal channel? It has vocal analysis of Minnie (g idle) and rosé. Please I wanna watch those videos again. The thumbnail of the Minnie video had Minnie in her blue flower outfit from hwaa era

Hi, do you mind if I ask for the vocal analysis of red velvet and aespa? From vocal analysis videos that I've watched in tiktok (which seem trustworthy), some of them ranked Wendy > Ningning > Seulgi >= Winter > Karina >= Giselle > Joy . But I need some elaborations on that, especially Karina, Giselle, and Joy, because they are kinda confusing especially since I heard somewhere that Giselle is now better than Karina. I'm sorry if this request is too much, a comment for the response would be highly appreciated, thank you so much.

Who’s here after Fromis 8 announcement 😭🤧

Hayoung supporting is the most mind blowing thing I've seen (also, the opaque notes means it's shallow right?)

I think Gyuri is going to focus more on acting, but hopefully she does some OSTs and a solo debut, because girl has a gorgeous voice (sounds a bit like BLACKPINK Jisoo with some support and less throatiness and chest pulling) and good potential.

random but can someone rank yuri (izone/soloist) yeonjung (ioi/wjsn) and chungha (ioi/soloist)? thanks in advance

and gyuri left ...

Yay you finally posted this video, nice video as always. I feel like the issue with hayoung was that she was mostly tight, nasal, throaty and heady so that's why it was hard to tell if she had enough support.

what do you think about "Updating ae-VOKALL" most recent video ? i'm curious about Karina's C5 and Giselle's B4. edit : i heard that both of Giselle's B4s in Savage (Music core encore + Inkigayo encore) are supported?

Is NingNing getting bolder in their recent live singing materials or in their Girls era? If so, then is she good enough to enter Low AA? I honestly disagree but that's what some people are telling me on TikTok

hayoung sounds very small and light

i saw your community's page and there's like 3 members of loona being in the w-a tier. if we only consider chuu, yves, heejin and haseul as their vocal line, would that make loona's vocal line is better than iz*one?

first!

Unrelated but i hope you can check out nmixx recent karaoke vlive there are videos on youtube

hey sootzubæ, i know you've seen nmixx's recent vlive where they sang "let it go", right? my question is, did lily supported the sustained eb5?

any reason on why hayoung was originaly ranked in non vocalist initially?

unrelated but did nayoung from lightsum trained elsewhere before cube? shes good compared to other female vocalists under the company

Haewon is getting the nayeon treatment I am starting to think that she is the face of the group (well she is talented so she deserves it but I worry she will get hate) lily and her sustained note is out of the world . I think both jiwoo and bae ditched the stylistic approach which makes me wonder that they were trained both ways for singing technical and stylistic Overall I thought I was listening to red velvet for a second and now I can see why there is a general comparison between lily and wendy . And sullyoon also sounds like joy sometimes . They gave me dejavu with red flavor

Sootzubæ pls do a vocal showcase for SNSD's Forever 🥺

Despite having a similar stylistic(indie) approach, why is Rosé a stronger vocalist than Minnie? What are their differences in their technique?

can Chaeyoung-fromis 9 support? i love her vocal

Just knew that the Bb3 is pronounced as B flat 3👁👄👁

0:29 what's the song

Chaeryeong from itzy belted a new F#5 in racer

Someone in another comment section said Jian (Lunarsolar) is A and Eseo is W? I am a little skeptical but they have some cool harmonies

what do u guys think abt newjeans' member vocal on hypeboy?? they don't sound bad at all, and surprisingly there's not alot of heavy vocal processing and autotune as we see in most hybe's song we love to hear that

Sootzubae, are you danik vocal on tiktok? You have some similarities, if I see it correctly.

Hayoung is shallow or support fully??

did you see karaoke of Nmixx?

If we compare both at their best I lean more towards Chuu over Hyaoung, idk her consistency though...

How would you rank twice and nmixx vocalist?

Is it wrong for me to hope aespa singing live on their fanmeeting? bcs theyre gonna perform all 8 songs😭

Qual a classificação delas??

Hi guys👋🏻 This is Nmixx vocal ranking with small analysis kzfaq.info/get/bejne/hrh2oK2UmeC-pI0.html In the analysis she put Sullyoon 3rd above Kyujin and she said that Haewon is the closest member to achieve resonance and Lily didn't achieve any resonance+she put Lily in AA-P tier Do u agree with the ranking and the analysis??

What date isac will be held?

I did a ranking for 3rd gen girl groups as a whole (not just vocal lines) 😃 please correct me if you think I’m wrong or if I should add someone 1. Mamamoo (4/4)- 3.75 2. Bestie (2/4)- 3.00 3. Red Velvet (3/5)- 2.20 4. Gugudan (4/8)- 1.63 5. Oh My Girl (4/6)- 1.50 6. Twice (5/9)- 1.11 7. IOI (4/11)- 1.00 8. WJSN (4/10)- 0.90 9. Pristin (4/10)- 0.90 10. Lovelyz (3/8)- 0.88 11. Gfriend (1/6)- 0.83 12. Blackpink (2/4)- 0.75 13. Weki Meki (2/8)- 0.50 14. April (2/6)- 0.50 15. CLC (1/7)- 0.43 16. Dreamcatcher (1/7)- 0.29 17. Momoland (1/6)- 0.17

Is Minyoung from Sixteen mid-A???

Source for the last clip?

I saw a video miihi from niziu is actually an average vocalist? So all this time she's the main vocal not nina?

Was sullyoon and kyujin quite full in the vlive karaoke?

Hayoung is the main dancer of fromis?

What Lily (NMIXX) tier?

Bada use light coordination like ningning right? Yet shes on Above Average tier, so why cant ningning go their🤷🏿‍♀️

omg... Gyuri left fromis9...

New pfp #whodis

and their tiers? both weak? I'm not familiar with fromis_9 UPD: Hayoung seems W-A, looking at her supported range

so aespa promos have ended without an encore....SM going to hell!! anyways they do have upcoming singing materials. 30J a fanmeeting where they will prob sing live a couple of songs, I've notice that nowadays they always do BM live sadly it doesn't really showcase that much, winter c5s are usually nice here thoo. they will sing yeppi yeppi wich is great bt sadly it got choreo (i want them to do normal cover,just singing). Then 2 or 3 days of a Japanese showcase at the beggining of August. At the end they will hold 4 smtown concerts where Winter just confirmed that she have a solo stage!! (prob a cover with a nct member or something like that). I assume It will be similar for the rest of aespa! Now if we are lucky we could have some proper singing materials like a recording behind or some covers cause ning said in a fancall that she have covers she wants to upload but she have to be allowed :-( cant wait hahah

does anybody know why people are putting tzuyu in E+/D- now like when did she support.

This person claims ningning can consistently support d5’s and that she now has c#5/d5, I know she has supported a few d5’s but I don’t know if you would consider them consistent for her or not? (I’m aware they made videos for other members too, can some confirm if they are true?) kzfaq.info/get/bejne/l9Wdi7yE0Kfao40.html

people are saying lily is B+ and Haewon is B thoughts? (personally i disagree)

Did you have any social media because I want to ask you some questions