i don’t know how dr. grande manages to pump out so much compelling content but i’m definitely not complaining, thank you for all your hard work!

His abuse of Brenda didn’t come out until after the police started to think he committed the murders. So no one can say people think he’s guilty because of that abuse. He was already suspected of being guilty of murder. The abuse just gave them yet another motive.

I don’t even know how I found dr. Grande… but I’m so glad I did. His dry ass jokes are hilarious and I really enjoy his informative videos.

The fact that the killer didn't go into Brenda's room, was familiar with the layout of the house, and owned a pair of Asics shoes is enough evidence for me to have no reasonable doubt. It could have been his wife on the computer to creat an alibi. She was in on the idea of taking over the newspaper business.

Something inculpatory that was missed here: Robert left his wife alone in the house with the bodies. The house was safe then of course but Robert shouldn't have known that. The killer could still have been hiding somewhere.

Robert sounds guilty, but as Dr. Grande says seeming guilty and having enough evidence of guilt legally are two different things.

I love Dr. Grande; receiving a notification of a new video always puts a smile on my face. Just wanted to add my two cents regarding the prisoners' reaction to Robert yelling at the elderly prisoner.. While prisoners are not always the best representation of humanity, they have their own code and mistreating the elderly is typically frowned upon, at least according to the people I've talked to that have done hard time.

I'm sneaking this video in during my classroom's rest time. Clearly, I'm addicted to Dr. Grande's channel. "Hello, My name is Tami and I'm addicted to Dr. Grande's hypothetical analysis's and his dry wit humor..."🥰❤️

hey Dr Grande, was wondering if you'd ever consider doing a video on "learned helplessness" just a mental health topic I've been interested in lately

He had means, motive and opportunity plus the blood and shoe box. Where is the murder weapon? He probably had ample time to get rid of it later. He cleaned his garage that same day. It seems he was the only possible suspect, even without knowing about the abuse of his niece, which I believe. She is absolutely credible. The police would have a profile for him that couldn’t fit any random attacker unknown to the family. I think he’s guilty in every way.

Since Robert did abuse Brenda for many years, he deserves the prison time he got. It does make sense that he would murder the entire family in order to gain complete access to Brenda and coincidently inherit a successful business. I would think if he'd gotten away with this, Cathy would have met an "accidental" death in the next few years. The guy is a monster!

As per your usual style, your final thoughts on this tragic case are explicit, concise, insightful and aptly portray your unbiased sensitivity. 😊 I will once again thank you, Doctor Grande for not disappointing your viewers

As always I thoroughly enjoyed your analysis and breakdown of this case. You manage to add greater insight into a case I’ve heard numerous times. Tragic story! But again thank you for your respectful and interesting perspective.

Watching Brenda speak about the case on 60 Minutes Australia, you can really feel this deep sadness in her voice. Bless her friends and school principal for being such big support for her.

Look at your numbers! 889K and counting. Happy to say I have been watching your videos since 40K. You must be doing a lot right.

Such a sad case again. Poor family & officers having to find them/work on scene😣 Thanks Dr G😊💜💜

This is a tough one! The one fact that he didn’t go in her room means that it was definitely someone close to the family.

Thank you for the early upload, Dr. Grande 💜

This murder happened in the suburb over from me. Still impacts many around here to this day. Very tragic.

Another interesting case and analysis from Grande. Thank you so much.

Can you analyze the psychology of Albert Pierrepoint? He was one of Britains last hangman who executed around 435 prisoners, including 200 nazi war criminals, Britians last executed female, and one of his friends. Despite this, he was apparently always cheerful and discrete and lived to the age of 87, dying in his sleep. So I wonder what was behind his ability to do this.

Great analysis Dr Grande. Hope you are having a great day!

Thank you Dr Grande for great work. Much appreciated ❤

I used to live in North Epping in the street over from where they lived- Eastcote Ave. At the time I was addicted to scratch lottery, so was a regular customer at their newsagents. Very friendly guy, lovely family. His kids would sometimes be behind the counter after school. RIP

I’m Amazed at all the content you put out. I appreciate your time and dedication. I hope you take care of yourself. Enjoy your family.

Good evening, Dr Grande. Hope you're doing well! You're certainly working hard! Much appreciated! Thank You.

I think for most people, uncertainty is an uncomfortable feeling. We tend to prefer resolutions to situations even if that does not align with the truth. It’s difficult for some people to say “I don’t know” or to not come up with a rebuttal when debating a subject, even when the knowledge about the topic is limited. However, in tragic cases like this one and so many others, the hunger for justice at any cost may be detrimental in reaching an adequate verdict. There have been so many cases where people were wrongfully convicted due to an emotional reaction and desire for closure by the jurors. This is probably a very human response to events which, unfortunately, does not always provide justice. In this case, I tend to agree that he actually did the deed but there is plenty of reasonable doubt. If I was a juror, I don’t think I could come up with a guilty verdict. Dr. Grande, on another note, I think you are an outlier. It appears to me that you are more preoccupied with finding the truth no matter which situation you encounter. That’s a fantastic trait to possess, in my opinion. Well, this review was absolutely brilliant, thank you so much. ❤️

Your videos along with your astute, insightful and attentive analysis are amazing.

Poor Brenda. Wow. Never heard of a judge accepting 11 out of 12 jury votes since that’s not done in the US. I was happy about it though. Must have been torture for Brenda to keep going through trials.

Good morning Doc. I just came across your channel and I absolutely love it. Your humor is too much, plus your analyses are very interesting. There is an old case that always intrigued me. It is Dorothy Eady and her claims of reincarnation. Im curious if you ever looked into this? Keep "killing" it, Doc.

Good morning Dr. Grande! 🍃🍂🍁 So happy to see your upload but so sad I can’t watch it immediately.😞

Not intended as a false joke, double innuendo. "*_Robert may have struck people the wrong way_*. " Definitely the wrong way when done with a mallet and hard object. Your analysis always strikes me the right way, Dr. Grande, encouraging my intellect, modulating my emotions, and calming my humour and the tendency to find fault. Great Job Dr. Grande, your purple shirt indeed shows empathy with the purple cactus on your shelf.

It’s important to remember that the full information of the trial is not readily available and it is presumptuous to assume he did not meet the threshold for a guilty verdict. This was a very prolonged case and one could believe that that was to obtain all the evidence and not rush. Dr grande I am a fan but I think casting judgements on legal cases with minimal information undermines the criminal justice system. If you look in to appeal courts you would see that they frustratingly slash sentences for the most guilty convictions. Given you do these videos daily there must be a limit to the amount of research you conduct, combined with this information not being as dispersed in Australia, compared to America. Just some ethical considerations given you are not a trained legal professional.

Aw yeah baby new Dr.Grande

Thank you again for your work. And purple shirt!!! 💜 Love it

Wow!!!...these murders were brutal, it's easy to see why people wanted someone held accountable, emotions must have been running very high.

Man you keep pumping quality content like this and I’m thinking if I should quit my job and watch your videos full time.

But what about him leaving while Kathy was making the emergency call? It just seems odd to leave her there

I see 1 million subs in your future very soon! I love your content! Thank you sir!

Well done mate! Cheers 🍻

Has anyone noticed when it comes to a crime in Australia..it always seems botched up or like circus in court. It worries me that the cops are so incompetent ...its only this case...there are so many!...its like a kangaroo court..and the poor aboriginals..God save them

You can tell from the way you cover certain cases that you really love your family Doc🥰

Great analysis Dr Grande. This case, has always been polarizing. But in reality, he was jealous of the Lin parents. I believe he did it ,I've never heard of Brenda being assaulted. Great analysis . Thank you Dr Grande.

I think this guy's guilty as sin but the notion that the judge "would accept an 11-to-1 guilty verdict" is terrifying.

Thank you Dr, from a Subscriber in Australia 🇦🇺 🧡

Thanks, Doc.

I recall this case. Thank you Dr Grande for doing this case, such a shock for the one girl that survived by being away on a trip. sicko Brother in Law!! having to live with your abuser must have been awful for her!

Always interesting. Peace 💕🇺🇲

I imagine, based on humankind's inhumanity to fellow humankind, there is a plethora of cases to pull from. Thanks for all your hard work Dr Grande!

Love to you and your family !

Ooo almost 900k subscribers!

I just realized Dr Grande upgraded his filming space. Congrats on the beautiful studio/room :)

Man your channel is blowing up!

Hey I love you Dr Grande but as others have pointed out, you missed a few things here. And he only had two trials because of the jury not being able to reach a verdict, the others were false starts so I don't think it's fair to say he had 4 trials, which would definitely be not cool. That SOB is guilty as hell and I'm glad he's one of the inmates in Australia for whom life really will mean life. Brenda can't even find solice in her aunt's side of the family now because they blame her for her abuse and him committing the murders to get more access to her. After she lost her whole family, he just made her lose more and more. Don't know how she could ever trust someone again.

Purple is a Holy color

Great video 📹

I’ve known about this case but not about the evidence against the uncle for the murders. Thank you for shedding light on that

We don’t call a news stand a news agency in the UK. A shop selling newspapers, along with sweets and other goods, is called a newsagent’s or paper shop. A booth selling papers somewhere such as a station is a newsstand or paper stand or sometimes just a kiosk.

This should have been longer, no offense Dr G, but there were a quite few things not mentioned here, which will no doubt be brought into the comments if not already. Which is worse, a guilty murderer being free due to legal failure (or success if you are their defence lawyer), or an innocent person going to prison? This is why we need Wonder Woman’s lariat of Truth or whatever she calls it. Imagine!!! I doubt anyone here in Australia who followed all the news after this event thinks he was innocent.

Great analysis ! Can you analyze the case of Gloria Williams and Brian Coulter in the case of them abandoning children for months and one found dead?

Hey Doc, would you consider analyzing the Korean serial killer Yoo Young-chul as featured in the Netflix documentary The Raincoat Killer? I found the case very interesting and absolutely brutal, but they really didn't get much into his background or potential profile :(

Culturally Irene wouldn’t be able to raise Brenda alone as a male would need to be head of the household of all the children and Irene. He’s guilty. Brenda came out on 60 mins australia and spoke of the years of abuse sustained by this monster.

I can't believe that Brenda is the only surviving member 🥺💔

A very clever way to find employment.

Hey Doc. Curious what state your in? Love your work, by the way. 👍👍

It's not "News agency" it's "Newsagents" -- at least it is in the UK. Not sure if the term is different. "News agency" makes it sound like they're journalists. Just thought I'd point that out. Big fan, keep it up!

Perhaps they were murdered by a disgruntled customer who couldn't get a particular magazine at their stand?

This is Heartbreaking!💔💔💔💔💔

People say killers have no soul. But in Robert's case, having a sole caused most of his problems.

Hammer Time!!!!

Good morning. Do you have any thoughts about the case of Nelson Cruz and Judge Shawndya Simpson?

I'm glad to see Harvey Two-Face back on the side table.

Addicted to the Grande 💪

How the heck does someone bludgeon 5 people with a hammer and they find NO blood or weapon evidence affiliated with the assailant Come on 🤦‍♀️🙉

someone definitely know perfectly the house....how could other stranger do it by closing breaker and enter the house without breaking the door...robert has the key and can move around the house without lights.....

Interesting explanation on the case, I'd not heard of it before, and I always enjoy your videos. Just have to point this out though - 'mortified' means 'embarrassed' or 'ashamed', it doesn't mean 'shocked'. I hear it used wrongly all the time and it really bugs me! XD

Dr. Grande I would love if you could do an analysis of the show “The Maid” on Netflix.

I sincerely appreciate Dr. Grande's sense of humor and especially his occasional "dad jokes." Having said that...I do not understand or appreciate the good doctor's satire over the human response of being shocked at witnessing a verbal assault of an elderly man. Also do not appreciate his following comment to the effect of everyone in jail claiming to be innocent of everything. It is almost as if the doctor is making light of, or even disputing, the fact that innocent people are incarcerated every day.

It's not only Anger that made this guilty verdict, but also the Fear of not knowing who the real culpable could be.

Doc, would you be open to maybe once a week making longer, more in-depth video for a serial killer series? 30 min to an hour?

The police have surveillance video of him cutting up a shoe box and flushing it down the toilet? Was the camera inside the house, inside the bathroom? I wouldn’t think that would be a legal police tactic...

How did not one of the 5 not be able to call for help or run away? It doesn’t make sense since they were so badly beaten. That would take a bit of time.

I felt the same way as Dr. Grande. How could one person kill all 5 people in a bloody crime scene like that and had nothing on him? No murder weapon, no bloody clothes/shoes, no evidence whatsoever in his car ... Also, by not killing Brenda, she would inherit her parents' home and money, Robert had NO financial gains. Thanks for raising your reasonable doubts.

“The verdict was achieved through emotionality not rationality” is highly patronizing to the fact that a judge, someone who specifically specializes in law and reason, found it acceptable to decide on a 11-1 jury. The judge found that the one outlier was actually the one being irrational.

hi, Dr.

The fact that the accused's computer was used during the time of the crime does not mean he was using the computer. Someone was using it, perhaps his wife to give him an alibi.

He did it.

Thanks for the video. Interesting and funny as usual. Just a small point. It is newsagent, not newsagency, in England anyway, so I assume also in Austrailia.

The deceased’s sister supporting her obviously guilty husband is reprehensible. She gave them a place to live and this was how she was repaid; by the business end of a hammer.

Please don't defend him. Brenda herself has said the whole reason he did this was to force her to live with him so he could continue the abuse. He was obsessed with her.

Please cover the killer of MLK, James Earl Ray?

Disturbing the peace of inmates by screaming at them is clearly beyond redemption.

would you analyze the ongoing case in Houston right now of the abandoned children found in an apartment with the skeletal remains of one of the siblings?

Bludgeoning 5 people takes a lot of rage though. The only plausible reason is Brenda’s dad confronted him somewhat. Still there’s so much circumstancial evidence I would not have voted a guilty verdict. This is also clearly a case of police/ legal pressure to find a culprit

No similar crimes before or after this spree killing. That particular family was targeted and nothing stolen. The guy groomed and manipulated a sexual relationship with their daughter using coercive control, she remained silent for many years after the crime. It’s not the first time one assailant has killed multiple sleeping victims. Yeah, he did it.

I dont think that “no witnesses to the crime” would be considered exculpatory evidence.

Difficult case. It seems to sit on the edge of reasonable doubt, which is rare. It is quite difficult to commit multiple murders face to face without leaving much evidence. If that evidence is not there, it raises some questions. There seems to be important missing details. The nature of the relationship between Robert and Brenda, and victims' response to it seems very relevant. Was this an ongoing relationship? What actually happened? What did Brenda have to say about it? Were threats made between the parties? These questions play heavily into potential motive. I would speculate that perhaps Brenda's parents were threatening to report Robert's crimes or force an end to an ongoing illegal relationship. Robert chose a time when Brenda was not present and the motive was either to eliminate a threat or to take revenge. Brenda would have knowledge of these details but yet they do not seem to be available.

Haha I don’t think it was the screaming that shocked the other inmates 🤣 It was the disrespect towards an elderly person that most likely stunned them.

I just heard of a murder-suicide allegedly involving 2 juveniles and 2 adults in Colorado Springs. It appears the house where this event occurred is huge and in a sprawling subdivision of large lots. The supposed adults were owners of a gun store. Maybe in a few months, Dr. Grande can analyze this situation and the people involved. In a nutshell, I'm going to guess the "law-abiding" perpetrator who had a gun (or guns) for "protection" used the gun to solve his/her problems, whatever they were. Or one of the "juveniles" just hated his/her family.

PLEASE Do the William Miller 911 Phone Call