Welcome to the They Sure Get Along Club, how They Sure Get Along are ya?

If the little sister took Luna's place in the last ending, the title screen would had been renamed "Lucy"

The normal ending: "Forgotten, but not Gone" The secret end: The host is lost therefore the original is paradox-ed out of existence

It's funny that my name is Luna and i just got a new book for my birthday. Hope i don't stop existing.

I think this is a classic case of Golden child/Neglected child family situation gone horribly wrong. It looks like the parents didn't pay any attention to Luna before Lucy disappeared. Hell, even when they left and with Luna not being around, there wasn't so much as a, "Where's Luna?" And when they were sitting at the table, it was like Luna was a ghost, going unnoticed by her own family as they lavished Lucy with attention.

Im disappointed that the word "cute" isn't in the title

It's pretty simple, Manly. You lose the card game, you go to the shadow realm.

The tune she hums at 7:30 ish is the Hide and Seek song in Korean!!!! When you’re the seeker, instead of counting you sing that song a few times and then go looking!

It seems like the parents were lavishing Lucy with affection, and ignoring Luna completely. Like how they were praising Lucy with "That's our princess, so talanted!" Right in front of Luna, as though she didn't exist. The cherry on top of that interaction being when you try to talk to the mom and she says, "I'm busy right now Luna, let's talk later." That kind of thing builds resentment. It makes sense why Luna trapped Lucy in the book, it doesn't make it any better or excuse it, but it explains it. It also sounds like it may've been going like that since Lucy was born, from how the woman who gave Luna the book was talking. Though it also sounded like Luna may not have wanted to do it at first, but eventually went through with it, possibly either due to being worn down, or some kind of corruption.

This is why parents or people should never have a favoritism.

That alternate reality secret where everything was reverse. That showed Luna's parents in her room in front of the book meant that "this would happen if you were trapped with your sister in the book forever."

It looks like Lucy really loved Luna ): It's too bad Luna was overcome with jealousy damn that's really sad

Is nobody really gonna talk about how smart Manly was to solve everything at the end and get that secret ending?

Tfw you realize you just sealed away the only person who gave you undivided attention and genuinlly cared about you.

My theory about the secret ending. Luna did love her sister, she was just upset with her neglectful parents. When Lucy saw the picture they both decided they were better off without them. So they pieces out together, hopefully to go torment their parents instead. Edit: the real question is who is that lady who gave Luna the book. She looks like Luna, maybe it's Luna's real mom. They doted on Lucy after finally having a kid that was all their own and to punish the parents the real mom (a witch) decided to gift her child with the means get back at them for neglecting her kid for their own... Or it's Lucy from the future who spent her teen years way into magic because she was tired of being in her you see sisters shadow.

I personally think the Secret ending is best but my theory goes this: You know how fulfilling spirits wish makes them go to the afterlife, i think that happend, Lucy went to the afterlife and perhaps her memory came back to the real world because her soul was free from the Book Dimension, while you were let back in your world, because her wish was fulfilled so her book chapter was free too. Though there are other cases As she just dissapeared that doesnt mean she died, so prehaps she was revived, and you came back with her what supports this well its simple, Lucy isint necesarilly dead she is just trapped in the book, and the symbolism where they both dissapeared i think they mightve both been revived And also Theres still a possiblity that she wasnt exactly the one making the choice, but she was being controlled like a puppet, what makes me think that, well, as you see in the game it is said she looked sick when she was trapping her sister in the book, which makes me think she was possesed by the book itself

No one say it before so I´m gonna say it. At min 46:57 the morse code says "Save us"

Manly: "Wait a minute, how come you didn't pick up the plates yourself?" Me: "It's a mom quirk. EVERY MOM HAS THIS."

If I had a nickel for every RPG Maker horror game starring two young girls where the villain is actually the innocent one who was screwed over by the protagonist, I'd have two nickels. Which isn't a lot, but it's weird that it happened twice.

The fact. that Lucy's is trapped in side a book is creepy af.... imagine suffering in a infinite loop in darkness and loneliness can only interact with the person that trapped you.

I think this is my favorite theory I’ve come up with/seen. Luna was clearly neglected by her parents while her sister was praised and held on a higher pedestal. One day someone shows up and manipulates Lunas feelings of resentment, channeling that anger towards her sister. Lucy is then trapped in the book, left alone with only a deep hatred for her sister and loneliness. The secret ending shows Lucy realizing Luna isn’t that different from her. In the past, Luna felt like she didn’t exist just as Lucy does now. Luna wanted to be loved by her parents again the same way Lucy longed to. So in the end, they both disappear in peace because the sun rose and they didn’t get back into the book. (The final fragment of theory is based on the details, when Luna is first trapped, she’s in a black void later being warped into a distorted version of her home. I’d like to think the book is the void and the distorted home is the regular home but in the eyes of those trapped in the book. While Luna is still in the regular home, Lucy mentions she needs to get back into the book by sunrise or else she will stop existing entirely.)

This hero is just going Brrrrrrrr with those videos one After another , don't over do yourself Manly

I think the ending implied that Luna went with Lucy into the other dimension. The screen title is blank after all indicating that no one is there. As for the message. Morally what Luna did wrong of course but it does seem to be a direct result of neglect from her parents. After all the family interactions made it pretty clear that Luna was more or less ignored by her parents while they had enough time to adore Lucy in front of her. Its also seems like Luna wasn't totally on board with the idea as the woman who gave her the book was whispering honeyed words into her ear about it. Though honestly it seems like her anger was misdirected, as it often is with children. The fault did not lie with Lucy, though in the mind of a child like Luna its easy to see where she could have made that mistake, but with her parents. It was their fault that they put so much adoration onto only their younger daughter. When the child is first born because obviously a baby needs more attention but at the ages they were the parents really should have able to show equal love to their kids... even more so they are terrible parents for not realizing Luna was unhappy. The family picture was incredibly concerning. Not smiling, bags under her eyes, general demeanor suggesting depression.

"You want your parents' love back like the old days" oof. Hitting close to home 😔

I guess that since Luna is a kid she gets the "I can be an asshole pass", but, well... She did literally turn her sister into her OC.

I think how this game tackles parental neglect is actually pretty interesting. I don’t have siblings but I do have a inattentive Mother and a dead-beat absent Father. As an adult I realize my Mum wasn’t the best in the whole “supportive parent” department, so in a way I kinda sympathize with Luna, if I was in her position I might want to do the same. She’s a child with horrible parents and saw an opportunity to return to the days when she was happy and loved. Of course there’s no justification for what she did but uless you know what it feels like to be so desperate for love and attention, especially at a young age, you’ll never understand the potential trauma that comes with having parents that don’t care about you

it’s a bit cliché, but i do like the little details with their name meanings. luna is obvious, but lucy means light! though honestly my first association was lucifer the morning star lol

Few things as satisfying as Manly saying "seeeeecret"

Wow, RPG maker horrors. Good old times

I think at the end when the book disappeared it ties more to the "door that you couldn't open" thibg, like Lucy grabbing the drawing is accepting the love of her sister, the same person who made Lucy vanish and loose all her memories, opening her heart would signify a "new hope" for Lucy to come back, and when Luna dissapeared i think is more like regret, regret for vanishing Lucy and regret for being just an awful sister, the book dissapearing is just the story ending, when you end a story you usually never read/watch it again unless you really like it, this story obviously wasn't a story that Luna or Lucy enjoyed so they just moved on, they could have destroyed the book, or leave it in a shelf or atic, idk

Well the sister lost the card game so it's only fair for her to be in the shadow realm.

I was not expecting the piano song to be Happy Birthday so my heart just stopped for a second

Yo, can we talk about how the parents basically forgot Lucys birthday? As I see it if your parents go shopping for your present the evening before at closing time they probably fucked up hard. So much for "Lucy gets all the love" lmao

When I play or watch someone play games with bitter ending like this, I always (or sometimes) want there to be a 'good-bad ending.' Like, a secret choice to stay in this world, willfully sacrifice yourself, etc. that's not just a simple "You Died" game over.

The art gives me dream of gluttony vibes.

"I mean the graveyard, i mean the deck" Yu-gi-oh reference lol gotta love it

Poor Lucy. What I interpreted of the Secret Ending was that finding the drawing made Lucy remember her memories and possibly, having Luna stay with her? The witch mentioned anyone who stays in that world would be erased from existence. Luna disappeared from the title screen, so I wonder if it's because of that? Edit:grammar

Game : Luna KZfaq : FNAF Hotel : Trivago

20:48 a piece of the notes to the happy birthday song

This makes a lot of sense in a manner. Since Lucy was born Luna has been ignored, such neglectment from the parents will build up resentment within Luna. I also find it curious that Luna decided to resent her sister instead of her parents. Then again, it seems like Luna desires her parent's attention and affection. So it makes sense that Luna would decide to get rid of Lucy, even if she wasn't completely on board with it. When the woman gave her the book and explained to Luna what it does, it seems like she was nudging Luna to do it. Luna seemed a bit against it at first since Lucy was her sister after all. Lucy never done anything bad to her, in fact, Lucy was the only one that acknowledged her. Lucy played cards with Luna and actively listened and cared about her, unlike her parents. At first, it doesn't make sense why Luna would do this to someone who actually cared for her. Still, the build-up of resentment and being neglected seemed too much for Luna. In Lucy's diary, she points out how Luna was acting strange. So this wasn't just a sudden snap but a gradual build-up to that snap. In the flashback, the father refers to Lucy as "princess" while actively praising her with the mom in front of Luna. Luna felt like she didn't fit in, out of the family. Ignored and such a feeling could cause a motive like that. When Luna tries to talk to her mother, she brushes her off. She was just praising Lucy just moments before and talking, so why does she not have time to talk to Luna now? That's because their parents only cared for Lucy, they see Lucy as their daughter. Their pride and joy, even when Luna was clearly there. Luna would've done it, even if she knew that she'd be getting rid of Lucy 'forever'. Once Lucy was gone, Luna obtained what she wanted, the affection from her parents. Though she remembered the words from the lady, being in the book for too long will transform one into a monster. That one mustn't let that monster out. Lucy had apparently transformed into that monster and while I'm not sure how Luna feels. Regret? Proud? For getting rid of Lucy, it seems like there was no choice for Luna. Either get rid of Lucy forever or let things return to how it was. This time even worse since there won't be a Lucy, there will only be Luna and no one else. Truly alone. Aajjajajajaja what am I even talking about, I have ELA class right now lmao

I see manly I click don’t u agree? edit: what are these l I k e s

No matter how many times I see this style for a game of any kind it doesn’t fail me to fall in love thanks for the 124 likes!! I wasn’t expectin dat!! Wow haha happy thanksgivin I’m thankful for all 124 of yall n of course Manly

44:37 has the biggest secret of all- piano charts!

When he was playing the card game and said " Exodia!!!" I lost it. Great refence Manly 😂😂

Some things I've noticed throughout this game is that Luna bears a heavy resemblance to the book and the one giving her the book. She also wears a moon necklace meanwhile all of the other family members don't have any resemblance to the cards, books or anything at all which could have to do with the secret ending. Sure, the supposed mom has white hair and the one who gave Luna the book also had white hair but I don't really know what to do with that. Everyone else's faces, except for Luna is blackened out. Even when playing as Lucy, her face is also unintelligible. Only when you get to the next picture including all family members and the drawing of Lucy do you actually get to see some of her face. Of course this might also just be a style or a preference but in the secret ending Luna's face ALSO gets blackened out. Another thing I'd like to point out is that in the earlier family photo nobody had any resemblance to the card and Luna didn't have her moon necklace. I have no idea what this could suggest but for some reason it seems important. Also when Luna gets transferred in the book and gets pieces, the only items she gets besides the family photo is the moon and a puzzle piece including a sunflower, nothing else. Luna's family seems also really song based while she seems to not be as song based. But considering the fact that we don't get that much information about her and just the fact that she was neglected, I don't know for sure. She seems out of place when it comes to the family. Her mom sings and her dad plays the piano. Lucy also plays the piano meanwhile Luna supposedly doesn't do too many musical things. Maybe a bit of this could suggest that she isn't actually blood related to her family? There are also a lot of other stuff in the game that might point at this too. For example, her having a strong resemblance to the book. Maybe she's actually the daughter of the one giving her the book? Also in the diary Lucy mentions Luna looking and acting as if she was absolutely obsessed with the book. Could this possibly be because the book affected her in the spiritual sense? In the secret ending and the normal ending the same drawing of Lucy is shown. The other one being Luna showing it to her mom and the other one having Lucy look at it. I don't know exactly what kind of worth the drawing is meant to show or have. But maybe it's the developer's way of saying Luna still cares about Lucy. The secret ending is also very vague, but I can try to make a few interpretations. Either one, they both went into the book together. Two, they both came into the real world. I also think there might be more reasons but that's pretty much all I could gather.

I thought with how Lucy asked Luna not to leave her, Luna going to “their secret place” was symbolic of her choosing to remain there with Lucy as she chose to continue playing hide and seek in that hidden room rather than go out of the door

I feel like it's the parent's fault because when having a family you need to give attention and giving compliments to all your kids than just one cause that would make the other kid feel like they aren't accepted or loved anymore by their parents which made the older sister jealous from her little sister and caused all of this. If maybe the parents weren't paying so much attention to the little sister and treat one another equally then that whole thing wouldn't happen

Okay, but can we talk about how amazing the art style and character design is? Like, damn, it looks really cool.

Holy hell man. She condemned her little sister to an eternity of isolation and damnation over petty jealousy?! I feel sorry for her I really do, but Lucy didn't do anything wrong. She just existed. Boy, am I upset at the parents.

When ManlyBadassHero says: "What is this place?" *in a shaky uncertain voice of fear and confusion* My thoughts: The prison where they store those who draw the disney channel logo

That lineless style combined with the pixelated one makes me go ❤️_❤️

Ah yes, I love watching Manly plays FIVE NIGHTS AT FREDDY'S again.

"Looks like someones going to the shadow realm, Jimbo" - Luna

The idea of vanishing my little sister from existence (despite how annoying she is) makes my heart drop..so how was Luna able to do it?? ;_;

And thats on a one-sided sibling rivalry

The fact you also love Kaiji fills me with joy

"All cards will be sent to the grave yard." *smiles in yu-gi-oh

Can we appreciate how in depth he went into hot dogs and steaks lmao

37:48 Dear my *daughter*, Lucy Happy Birthday! _A few lines later_ When you're all grown up, you will be a great *man*. Yep, nothing wrong there!

That Kaiji talk out of nowhere really got me, I love that anime to bits

Luna your sister needs to know why you put her into that book of yours

spoilers. I see everyone is hating on Luna but i feel like we should be hating on the parents more... The parents obviously loved lucy that made Luna feel left out. Im not excusing what she did, but damn, the parents are to blame for this as well. If they love them equally, Luna wouldve been happy, got attention and wouldn't have been jealous and trapped lucy

I hate favoritism, every child should be love equally by their parents no matter what. What luna did was wrong but by how the parents ignore her and focus on her sister out of favoritism is just as wrong if not more.

Manly are you having family issues? Do we need to talk

Ah yes- this is definetly Five Nights at Freddy's from 2014.

my take on the secret ending: throughout the game youve been collecting/seeing all kinds of things related to memories of lucy but aside from the book there is essentialy no core memories or items about luna except her drawing of lucy. This might mean that when lucy took away luna's last connection to the real world she just got removed from reality aswell.

Going to blue flag day with Rick. Very excited

I love how KZfaq is like : Yes, this is definitely Five Nights at Freddy's

Im not sure how early i am..depending on the number of comments, but sure.

Aww just some sisters playing hide and seek. How wholesome :)

this is so awesome. also dude, you should totally play Doll Eye. its a psychological horror that i have a feeling youd like

Ah yes,the "cute" horror games I love these types! Also,Thanks for uploading gameplay videos every day manly!❤

In the family photograph Lucy smiles happily and Luna has no expression, but in the photo where Luna is alone, she smiles. And that is so creepy. It makes me feel like Luna didn't have any feelings for Lucy at all... Like she doesn't fell any guilt, or remorse. And the end of the game too, after just passing through that experience of seeing her sister, and how she resents Luna for what she had done, it doesn't affect Luna at all, she goes to sleep to supposedly have happy dreams... It feels like she never cared for Lucy in the slightest... but in turn, it seems that Lucy did care for her sister, and that makes those pictures really eerie.

Ding Dong i know you can hear me open up the door i only want to play a little

The artwork is a delight. Those lines are smoother than butter

You should have more subscribers your narrative voice is spot on.

It’s worse then symbolic murder, honestly I wouldn’t do that to my worst enemy! Like holy shit. That’s some next level shit.

I usually can’t stand horror game youtubers but idk these videos just feel like comfy I guess, keep them coming big fella

I'm at such a loss here. You play horror games, which could possibly give me nightmares. But your videos are so calming that it helps me get cozy enough to fall asleep. Idk what to do xD

I love your voice, it really has that narrator feel to it.

Man Luna sucks I actually came here to comment because I paused the screen when the game first crashed around 44:37 and I see piano charts and how to read notes, and I really admire that because Manly went all the way to learn how to play it. That made me smile.

The perfect contrast between a calming voice and a scary butt-chilling game I hope you don’t stop playing my dude :}}}

thank you for playing!😊❤

Interesting, a story where you kinda want to kick the ass of the main character, even if you can empathize with them a little.

6:48 Oh no, my worst nightmare! A rhyming ghost!

I like you, you dont act stupid u are smarter than i seen some youtubes and u do great videos u deserve a sub totally

Yay new vid I love ur content!!

I know it’s only been 21 minutes since you posted and I haven’t finished the 50+ minute video! But I wanted to say I appreciate the daily uploads and amazing game play! Your videos are on my top list of first thing I look forward to each day. No matter what.

“Children have yet to be able to learn about the value of lives” Well...this just remind me about this quote

Parents, this is why favoritism shouldn't work, if you ignore the other child long enough they'll meet a suspicious person who'll willingly give them a book about murder

Dude, never forget that you are amazing

I think the best way to translate the secret ending is this: When you find the third secret, the mirrored house and go to your room, you find your parents with the book. The normal ending see's you 'escaping' the book in the first place, however the person giving her the book says it turns people into monsters. I think what may have happened, is that they got themselves both trapped inside of the book, yet only one of them was truly aware of it. Time is eternal and their game essentially repeats over and over again, think witch's house. The secret ending is possibly both of them realizing their reality and coming to terms with it and they either... move on, or keep playing or maybe they do escape? It would make sense since one of the secrets is playing as lucy, meaning the sisters can kind of swap places. Maybe I'm thinking too meta in that sense though, but after experiencing meta games for so long, wouldn't surprise me in the slightest.

Afternoon manly. Hope it's going well

I think in the secret ending Luna fully regrets her actions. But Lucy can never came back to the real world. So Luna decides to stay with Lucy in the book world. They'll never be lonely ever again.

cmon manly!! play coma cutting class and coma vicious sisters, dude!!! >_< Ive been waiting for a long time PAL!!! nice vid btw

I can see why Luna got jealous of her sister, since her mother was so aloof about paying attention to her before bed time. When you were exploring the "Secret ending" path, you were a shade exploring the books and hiding places. I think that you were diving into the book to get your sister BACK. I think that Luna trapped Lucy in the book THAT day, and the passage of a single night made her go crazy in the book. So by immediately seeing the mistake and trying to Find the sister means that no harm was actually done. You find the happy sister picture in the secret place, and bring her back out. Then you leave the shadow realm as well.

im the one that forces my brother to play hide n seek lol

I enjoy watching manley's videos alot

I loved the artstyle of this game, seemed really cool!

"I'm good at watching anime"