I pretty much agree. I'm a huge fan of Geoff, but on revision this book left something to be desired. I think it works best (as you say) if you already have some knowledge and want to know which throws/sweeps have the highest success rate outside a night club, as opposed to on a mat. I can't remember if it's my copy of Judo or one of the other in the series, but aside from the misspelling of some moves, there is a totally blank page in the middle of the book.