Basant which is actually hindu calender season during winter(Indian), that was ancient Utaraayan hindu festival,we celebrate it on every 14th January Utarayaan(uatar{north}+ayan{towards})=From this day u can see Sun slightly towards north to south side instead of east to west side So we celebrate it as a change in seasons throughout india with different different name too Season changes so farmers start their work from this day too so ppl celebrate for that reason too Its not banned in india everyone celebrate it with joy In some states(mine-gujarat) ppl celebrate by flying kites so u r right that represented india

The only explanations I can think of are: the Blip messed up Eid and the citizens of the MCU voted to paint Lady Liberty green and forget about the Captain America shield.

Thank you so much for this Dakota. We are constantly amazed on how your brain works. The dedication to getting the MCUTimeline correct is really appreciated. Love the idea of INTENT. It is easy to be black and white on these ideas, but that the writers and directors have other motivations when depicting things on screen. Also, thank you for being sensitive to these nuances, instead of casting it away, just because it doesn't fit your narrative. That is just one of the reasons why we appreciate your take on the Marvel Timeline. This type of care, sets your MCUTimeline above all others (in our opinion). Again, thank you.

Thanks so much for these videos! It's a lot of fun to imagine what a mega-cut of these movies and shows in chronological order would look like. I really wanted Ms Marvel to be in autumn of 2024 in part because I didn't want the Statue of Liberty's color to be a mistake and it felt more appropriate for the DoDC agent introduced in No Way Home to quickly reappear in Ms Marvel. Also I like it best when the movies and shows cross over on the timeline. No Way Home takes place over what looks like late June of 2024 to sometime in December of the same year. That's almost a 6 month period, so it makes the most narrative sense for other stories to be happening at the same time. Unfortunately, there does seem to be enough evidence to suggest that 2025 makes a little more sense for Ms Marvel. Currently, my favorite order has: - Far From Home/No Way Home until the scene with Peter, MJ, and Ned on the roof on their first day back at school - the 'current day' body of Eternals (due to Phastos' home clearly looking to be shortly before Halloween because of the autumn leaves in his front yard and a carved pumpkin on an outdoor bench) - No way Home picking up with the scenes where Peter starts getting college rejection letters and continuing until the battle on Liberty Island is over and Andrew & Tobey et al disappear. - Venom also disappears in the No Way Home mid-credits scene - the "2 weeks later" scenes from Eternals w half of them leaving on the Domo and then Arishem abducting others a little later. The post-credits scene w Dane and the sword can go here too. - Multiverse of Madness in its entirety - Eternals mid-credits scene on the Domo w Pip and Starfox - No Way Home starting with J Jonah Jameson saying it's been a few weeks since the battle on Liberty Island and then Peter walking to find MJ in the snow/later swinging in Manhattan in the snow. - This snow is then on the ground throughout the Hawkeye show. (w flashbacks placed earlier in the timeline) - The Black Widow post-credits scene would be placed during episode 4 of Hawkeye Putting Ms Marvel in late 2025 does leave a big gap though. Maybe it will be filled by Wakanda Forever or She-Hulk?

something I was confused by was Kamala traveling back to 1947, I know the bangle did that and the show makes it seem like a predestination loop, but with how time travel works in the MCU, she would have probably just created a branched timeline, rather than having always done that. it's super weird.

And for anyone wondering "why is the holiday the most important factor in placing Shang-Chi if it's not the most important factor in placing Ms. Marvel?", it's simple: The plot of Shang-Chi *depends on* the Qingming Festival specifically, as it's the only time Wenwu can reach Ta Lo safely with his troops. It being a holiday for the dead also fits thematically with Ta Lo being a city of heaven & with the Dweller tempting Wenwu with false promises of his dead wife. The plot of Ms. Marvel *doesn't* depend on Eid Al-Adha; Kamala could've saved that kid at _any_ outdoor public event, & Eid was chosen for the reasons Dakota specified in the video. The plot _does,_ however, depend on it being early in a school year, also for the reasons Dakota specified in the video.

Are you still planning on doing videos like these on "Captain Marvel", "Avengers: Endgame", "Spider-Man: Far From Home", "WandaVision", "The Falcon and the Winter Soldier", "What If...?", "Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings", "Eternals", "Hawkeye" and "Spider-Man: No Way Home"?

Another banger video! Keep up the good work! After seeing that whack official timeline they released back in 2018 and seeing how in depth you go, I've trusted your placements much more the actual company since about 4.0 I think.

That avengers tower and statue of liberty thing really annoy me for some reason. C'mon Marvel.

Several people have asserted the d+ timeline placing moon knight at the end wasn't a mistake, it's meant to be a temporary placement. The real time frame depends on when titles like Blade take place, which is suspected to have Moon Knight. I agree and am sure they just wanted to keep the timeline open. But fatws being swapped with eternals and iron man 3 being swapped with dark world is reason enough to worry about the validity of the d+ timeline.

Totally understand your reasoning but I think i will go with centering the story around Eid than the school year. I feel like it is way more important than the school yesr. It also lines up more with spring in Pakistan (if you squint a bit haha).

Been watching all of your "When does MCU takes place" and i love it.... It's kinda short but very informative and thank you for that... But some of movies or series timeline are not found in this playlist... Some are in othee playlist... I love it when you put in one playlist so we could watch it from start to end... Others are missing... Like Captain marvel, endgame and hawkeye...

I can’t wait to watch this on my MCU watch (using 7.0). I’m up to captain America the winter soldier

Perfection! Great video again. You are improving and becoming more perfect every passing video. I remember older versions of timeline. Ahhhh, years passed but in a good way thanks to your timelines!

Eid is a moving holiday depending on the lunar calendar. Eid al-adha occured in September in the years 2015, 2016 and 2017 and will occure again in the years 2047, 2048 and 2049. So it's not impossible that the MCU simply has a different Lunar Calendar than our real world. And you know what that reconciles? Moon Knight's placement in 2025. If the phases of the moon are different in the MCU, the phases of the moon in Moon Knight might work with a 2025 placement. And why would the moon phases be different in the MCU? Well simple: If Khonshu can change the phases at his whim and the Moon Knight is stronger during a full moon, I'm certain he has manipulated the moon many times to give his various avatars power boosts throughout the years during difficult battles. Especially during the time that the Ennead were worshipped and wouldn't banish Khonshu for messing with the sky. Over-time, that added up and threw off the MCU's lunar calendar and thus the various moving celebrations like Eid and Easter. I'm gonna do some more research on this and DM you if I have more concrete evidence! Thanks for all the work you do!

Loved the video, as always. Keep up the great work!

I honestly don’t understand how you’re so good at this lol, thank you again for your work!

Thanks Dakota, these videos really help. I have decided to do a full watch through of the mcu in chronological order using your order not Disney Plus’ order. I’m excited to see where I am Groot takes place as it looks like an origin story for Groot so it might take place quite early on the timeline. Thank you for all of your work.

I think that the actual time that this takes place will be revealed in The Marvels. As to whether it actually makes sense is yet to be seen but personally I think that it may be retconned to take place in late March.

Great video as always! Just wanted to bring this up, you mentioned around 10:33 that there are no Muslim holidays in fall, which is technically true, but only because all Muslim holidays fall on the Hijri calendar, which is a lunar calendar that moves around 10 to 11 days on the regular solar calender every year. So they *can* fall in, well, fall It's just that the most prominent ones don't in the year this movie takes place in I know you probably already know this, but I wanted to leave it here as a PSA Again, great video! and thanks for putting in the effort to pronounce words as accurately as possible, kind gesture

Always love your breakdowns and judging by the ending the Marvels may actually take place right after Ms. Marvel, but I still look forward to the breakdown when the movie drops.

i love this channel so much!! thank you for all the work you put into these videos

Great video. I totally agree with your assessment that the series doesn't have to occur on the actual date of the Eid celebration and rather that the series happens when it makes the most narrative sense (i.e. Fall of 2025). For what it's worth, I think the same can be the case with Shang Chi and that it could occur when the Disney+ timeline places it (i.e. July 2024) rather than when Qingming Jie occurs in early March. Just my 2 cents on that. But great video. Very nice work!

Amazing video again, also I don't know who confirmed it but I saw on Twitter that Thor: Love and Thunder chronological place is between The Falcon and The Winter Soldier and Moonknight just as you put in your Timeline!! So congrats on that 'cause it proves that all the effort you put in doing these videos is not wasted and helps a lot of us to have a better understandement of this universe!

Love your vids man! Me and my girl are watching the shows/ movies in your CORRECT ORDER! I can’t thank you enough and I just joined your patron! I’ve got a request though, I was wondering if you could make a separate timeline (or incorporate it in with the MCU timeline) for the x-man/mutian movies and shows. I plan on watching all of them + the none marvel licensed movies such as legion the older blade movies and Howard the duck right before Dr.strange MOM. Thanks once again we’re on shield season 3 episode 8 and everything is flowing magnificently, your the GOAT

I know it's old news, but they have since edited the Statue of Liberty to bronze.

man, i would have loved to have the full image of the timeline but i dont have patreon subscription , but i can still check the timeline in the video, but anyway KEEP UP THE GREAT WORK, you deserve more subscribers

Heya man, loving the content, It's nice to see someone else care about and put so much working into keeping record of the whole MCU timeline like I've tried before, now I know you're a very busy man but I was just curious, what do you use to make and edit your whole timeline page that includes everything?

Nice video. You should do review of the Marvel movies, also more timelines of other franchises.

Fully agree with the September placing but I'll stick with 2024 just because I don't like the idea otherwise that it jumps so far ahead in the present day.

Just after Hawkeye. Fits well after the past credit scene. Hawkeye goes into January. There is a Chinese New year sign.

This is a bit of a shot in the dark, but would the trees be out of sync due to the blip? Thanos eliminated half of all living things. Surely that means half all trees as living things must’ve been dusted too? So would the trees that got dusted in Summer 2018 and then blipped back into existence in Fall 2023 still be in their summer phase?

Hi geekritique, love your videos, so I might have han aprox and the next projects of the mcu somewhat based in the show From the marvels trailer, it look like its start where ms marvel ended, secret invasion must ocurred during may to octubre, since we see everret ross in the trailer and maybe hes running fron the feds (from wakanda forever) and nick fury is present in the trailer (in now way home its menciont he hasnt been to earth in a year), the president during secret invasion has to happened something for him so general ross can be the president, so captain america 4 can be early 2026 and thunderbolts can follow up closely That what ive gather but who knows

I wonder if it would've been better to just try to commit to having this be set in June. But I guess the foliage would've just been distracting so it's probably a bit lose/lose here.

Hi, I'm a big fan of your work. I have a question. Can you do a same video like this but with phase 5? Do you have to watch phase 5 or can you do it just jet? Because I also want the best phase 5 time-line in MCU. Does it work?

14th of March is Pi Day, and maybe hallal man sells pies....

Great video. put that in its spot in my mcu calendar. I have 2 questions though (not about this video though). 1. Now that Thor: Love and Thunder shows that Thor was on earth half the time between age of Ultron and ragnarok and how there was a darryl cameo in new Asgard, do you think the Team Thor shorts are now canon? 2. are the I am Groot shorts canon?

Have you heard: I am Groot is canon and takes place after GotG 2.

I wonder what the mcu timeline will look like when phase 6 ends

Hmm...a different opening, nice.

Love to see it Dakota!!

Great video man! I always assumed it was summer 2025 based on Eid alone but yeah I think you're right in saying that the show went with going in the route of showing representation than actually going by where the show is actually set which as a Muslim myself I don't mind and actually love especially when they did an amazing job at it!

I would ignore the misplacement of Eid, I would chalk it up to Eid being placed in fall to the “Marvel Universe” because Eid changes date every year. given that, it can be explained that on Earth 616, Eid took place in Fall of 2025

They fixed the green statue of liberty scene if you go back and watch it its copper

Great video! Is "When Does the MCU Take Place?" videos still being planned for the 2019 & most 2021 releases?

This was excellent

If we conclude that Ms. Marvel's Eid takes place in September, wouldn't that mean that we can't assume that any holiday falls on the same day of the year that it does in our universe? And as such, wouldn't that throw Shang-Chi's placement into question as well as our ability to use the pumpkins on Phastos's porch in Eternals as evidence? And if holidays don't have the same dates in the MCU as in our universe, we can't assume that the school year is the same in the MCU as in our universe, which might throw off some of the other Spider-Man/Ms. Marvel productions.

Yo! Will the new original shorts on Groot be canonical? And if so, are you also gonna adress their timeline placement? :D

I think Multiverse of madness was misplaced. We know Multiverse of Madness takes place after No Way Home. And no way home take place a little before Hawkeye. So idk why Hawkeye is placed afterwards

Do Movie/Series review, I'm pretty sure more people will sub to ur channel .. or doing some breakdown of each episode of D+ show, reaction to SDCC reveals something like that.

I blame Kang for the time fluxes.

Time to kick back, relax, and learn about something that won’t put me to sleep

(MCU) Peter Parker would be 19, based off the current MCU Timeline, right?

It takes place in March as it occurs around Eid al-Fitr

Loved the video I've been looking for a logically accurate timeline for the MCU for a long time. Glad to have stumbled upon this channel and subbed Small issue I have is the placement of Eternals however. Based on Ajak's own words the Thanos snap happened five years ago - placing the Eternals in 2023. Tiamut's emergence was postponed by the snap, which means right after the Avengers brought everyone back again the Emergence would be imminent, so it would suggest that Eternals happened very shortly after Endgame. Maybe it predates WandaVision? What do you think?

Id really like to download an updated image of timeline. I subscribe and keep up with all your content. Please don’t lock the one good timeline behind another paywall like disney+.

I think this can be interpreted either way! Jeez i remember version 1.0 of this timeline 😂 simpler times

Is it like this Loki What If...? WandaVision Eternals Shang-Chi The Falcon and The Waiter Soldier Moon Knight Thor Love And Thunder Is That the Timeline 🤔🤔🤔

Note no shield on the Statue of Liberty either.

I appreciated the inclusion of history, religion, and culture I am not as familiar with. Unfortunately, that was the best part of the show to me. I didn't feel immersed in the MCU while watching. I think if they had drawn attention to some of the things that had impacted the world more consistently (like the altered the Statue of Liberty) I may have been more drawn in. A cameo somewhere from someone else would have also been welcome.

So it is not longer free?

*gasp* I'm not the first one here this time😱