My reread in March I realised Perrins trial wasn't actually about Perrin, it was Galads arc. It was almost all about making Galad grow, open his mind, become less black and white and start to see nuance. I loved Galad in this book, his growth and learning was so good.

I think the one big flaw in Ewgene was that even if Rand was clear to her with his plans she always would had thought she knew better, since she was already in the ship that the tower needed to control the dragon and be in charge; which let's admit it honestly it wouldn't have worked well.

I love the ‘ you can call me rand Sedai’ moment and where egwene and perrin meet in telanriod and he sais’weaves are useless’

Well it was Rand’s intention to get Egwene to do the legwork for him to get all the political figures in one place and he did that by announcing the destruction of the seals to Egwene.

Merphy could you share your thoughts on Aviendha's Rhuidean sequence. It's one of the most gut wrenching moments of the whole series and my favourite too.

Egwene “I’m the only one allowed to be arrogant” Al’vere

The testing is just another example of why Nynaeve is, was, and always will be, the best.

What has two thumbs and finally started wheel of time? This guy. Thanks Merphy and the community for this recommendation.

Moraine has known she would marry Thom from the start due to a Min viewing. There are subtle hints/foreshadowing throughout the books.

So Thom and Moiraine. One of those things that makes a reread better. I admit there is not much but there are a couple subtle comments here and there. They make me smile.

Forging the hammer was sooooo good! Will LAN be a badass in book 14? Don’t think you’ll be disappointed.

I think you are spot on about the Egwene Rand conflict. The miscommunication though I feel is inevitable due to the changes in Egwene's personality since she became a leader of Aes Sedai. She has internalised the sense of superiority most Aes Sedai feel (about their views and knowledge) and is unwilling to engage with others very respectfully (unless they are fellow Aes Sedai or Aiel wise ones). She grew up with him, knows his true character, knows about cleansing of Saidin and other things Rand has done, despite which she is unwilling to giving Rand the benefit of the doubt or just talk to him in a more personal (where her courtiers are not present) to understand his proposal. Instead she questions his sanity and asks him if he is willing to get his sanity tested. That part is incredibly annoying.

To be fair, lengthy interactions with the Tower haven't ended well for him so far.

Did you recognize the farmer who meet Rand in the beginning of book? We meat in book 1, keep an eye for him in book 14 (one of Mat scene)

Rand became the Dragon...He chose when to sheath the sword. I'm really enjoying watching you take this journey. Most disappointing character in the series? Gawyn. Matt will always be my favorite.

“My name is Nynaeve ti al’Meara Mandragoran. The message I want sent is this. My husband rides from World’s End toward Tarwin’s Gap, toward Tarmon Gai’don. Will he ride alone?” Chills every time. Also, one correction. Perrin's forging of the hammer is the first instance of a power wrought weapon since the breaking, because Aes Sedai have been prevented from making them via the oaths (and traditionally men couldn't of course). Unless the Seanchan had damage make weapons and we didn't know about it or something. So, yes, it's a very powerful moment. Nynaeve's testing is also awesome. I'm also surprised you didn't mention the Rhuidean glass columns in here.

Upon reread, looking for the hints, Thom and Moiraine pairing makes TOTAL sense. But they are both such subtle people. But even from Emond's Field in book one they show the immense respect they have for each other. I had a similar reaction the first time though.

What Mat does at the end of the book was great I feel the responsibility he feels for everyone he cares about. I also believe he cares about Morraine.

As much as I agree that Rand could have explained himself to Egwene and solved that conflict in one go, you have to remember that she has spent the entire series saying 'down' whenever he says 'up'. She takes the Aes Sedai stance against him - considering him a conqueror, a man who can channel, and a ruler who ought to submit to the White Tower, and it means she would never accept any explanation he gave her about breaking the seals.

Said it before and I'll say it again. Merphy, you're gunna want to do two videos for next book. One for the beginning and end of the book, and one for the 200+ page Last Battle chapter.

My favorite 2 scenes in this book is the Perrin-Eqwene encounter in Tel'aran'rhiod . Perrin shows absolute control in the world of dreams. Eqwene's reaction is awesome! I also love the forging of the hammer scene, simply amazing!

The end with mat leaving the tower. I must have reread that section a dozen times but i still get chills at Mat's realization

Every time somebody gets through the entire series, it's so cool to me (because so many people drop out)! You did a great job finishing the series, did a great character-by-character review, and made a great video! Thank you!

Spoiler alert: Hopper dying was like when Dobby died. Bummed me out hard. And the forging of the Power-wrought Hammer was awesome. Another spoiler for those not that far in the series: Mat actually did die in Fires of Heaven. He was just brought back because Rand killed Rahvin with balefire. Aviendha as well.

I like Mat a lot because I just find his scenes to be a breath of fresh air from all the moronic decisions/communication failures that I felt plagued the rest of the characters (your Rand x Egwayne complaints for this book is how I felt for most of the conflicts across the whole series, though I still enjoyed it). And something Sanderson has said kind of stuck with me. Something along the lines of Mat being one of the most difficult characters to write because of how he is always saying one thing, thinking another, and often doing yet another. Which I just find kind of fascinating and interesting to read.

"The dragon is one with the land and the land is one with the dragon."

I remember when i finished this book i was so exited that i got out of my bed, screamed, and ran around the house doing star jumps to try and expend some of the energy and excitement that i built up. This was at 2am after reading for 3 hours. The family was not happy.

Nynaeve became a much better character in this book and all of rands scenes were incredibly satisfying. This was honestly one of my favorite books of the series especially mat rescuing moraine and aviendhas scenes in rhuidean

Can't believe this series of 14 or 15 books only covers about 2 year's or so in continuity, what a crazy 2 year's for all these characters

Finally there, I found this channel just before you took this journey and now the conclusion is knocking. Take your time with the next book, you only get to finish the series for the first time once. 😁😁

The forging of the hammer gives me goosebumps every time. Such a fantastic scene, I love the artwork on the copy you have where he's holding the hot hammer and there's a wolf head in the flames. So cool, I have a print of it on my wall

I always loved perrins coming into himself in this book, especially the forging scene. You mentioned wanting to reread the tower scenes. Check out the channel Reflections of Sound. They put Thom's song there into actual song and interweaved it with the audiobook there and it is absolutely fantastic. Video is called "BOOK 13 SPOILER!! Wheel of Time: Sweet Whispers of Tomorrow (Audiobook & Song Mix)"

I've always seen the interaction between Rand and Egwene as actually a calculated plan to get her to do some of his work for him, getting her to assemble the nations/armies that he does not explicitly control.

I recommend reading the prequel New Spring now, before book 14. It’s not necessary but it gives two key characters more depth. I know you may be impatient to see how it ends but if you are going to read New Spring, now is the time.

RJ from the beginning said that the heroes would be reluctant heroes. Just nobody wants to face that kind of oddss

Rand miscommunicated with Egwene intentionally because he knew how she would react. Her will to bring everyone to the last battle to oppose Rand breaking the seal is what he wanted. He needed everyone there to eventually sign the peace treaty, and he knew by getting Egwene to oppose him, she would ensure everyone would be at that meeting.

rand's being circumspect with egwene in regards to his plans is just him manipulating her so he doesn't have to do so much heavy lifting in preparation for the last battle

Found your channel this week and must say that I love it. Of course I haven’t gone through all your content, but as a huge Harry Potter fan i appreciate your detailed reviews. Funny thing though, I’m also on my first read of WOT starting book 14 now. Keep up the good work!

I know it's subjective, but 14 is by far my favorite of the series. Hard to say why without spoiling anything, so I'll save it for the review. 12 was like "congrats, you made it through the slog, have a cookie", where 13 is more of a calm before the storm. One thing you mentioned here about Rand weaving 100s of times, but still drained himself, I wonder how that plays out in the last battle..?

To me "A memory of light" is the best book

The cool thing about how the gholam was defeated is that RJ set it up in fires of heaven when it was explained that people who fell off the edge of a skimming platform fall forever.

0:39 i've been into this series since 94 or 95 (i can't remember for sure, i was like 10 or 11). the shadow rising is to this day my favorite, so much happens there, two of the main characters really establish themselves in this book, and one gets set up to really have some fun. and the side characters really start to shine, it starts to feel like a bigger world.

Enjoy book 14. It's one hell of a ride!

I hope you take the notes on the last book and make a bit longer in depth video.

Matt "gave up half the light of the world to save the world" and it's another situation of him almost frivolously putting others ahead of himself. If you are looking for more Lan, book 14 is for you!

I just finished this book for my first time. Loved it. I also kind of think that Sanderson was poking a little bit of fun at the Thom/Moiraine quick romance with how he wore Mat's reaction to it. So funny🤣

One of the many amazing things about re-reading WoT is how the relationships that seemed to come out of nowhere the first time through are actually there all along. It's just generally not focused on. With Thom and Moiraine, it's because the viewpoint characters are generally rather young and don't pick up on much of what goes on between the adults. My favorite example of this is Nynaeve's chapters in book 1. They are amazing on re-read because her crush on Lan is there all along, and will seem to be impossible to miss, but it tends to be completely invisible to first time readers.

You totally called me out, lol. 12/13/14 are my favorites, even when I'm rubbish remembering them. And Towers of Midnight definitely altered my concepts, of and provided some truly twisting dark. I can't wait to hear your thoughts on A Memory of Light!

the reason lan has no page time is because other characters are catching up with him. he is already that awesome.

I just finished book 14 last month (second time) and i'm really excited for you Merphy. That book is phenomenally exciting.

Without spoilers, Jordan isn't afraid to kill off fairly major characters. Tarmon Gaidon is a bloodbath, without saying who dies get ready. And yeah Elayne and Gawyn are so stupid, Tigraine must have had some seriously strong genes that Galad and for that matter Rand aren't drooling morons

I have checked out the first wheel of time book from my workplace thanks to you. Hope I like it!

Can't wait for you to finish the series, including New Spring, then give impressions of the series as a whole. Maybe you could include your thoughts on how they might tighten the TV series into something they can actually finish in a reasonable number of seasons.

I originally each of the Wheel of Time books as they came out and just recently reread them for the first time since the final book was published and it's very interesting to see your first-time persepctive on this series. I have to say that I am with you on the abruptness of the Moiraine-Thom love! I didn't remember that at all from my first read of the series and it surprised the heck out of me in my reread; it was definitely just out of nowhere.

Wow! Your channel is growing so fast! We’re almost at 150k and it only feels like yesterday you were 50k♥️♥️♥️

Watching you review these last few books makes me want to reread the series

I think the lack of communication between Rand and Egwene is pretty consistent for them. Throughout the series we see them struggling to connect with each other.

Prophecies--I am the chosen Ta'veren--The flame will grow I Feel the heat, I'll keep on breathing After all there's no tomorrow Wheel of time!!! Save my soul, find a way And if I fail, will it all be over? Oh wheel of time!

At least with the Moiraine and Thom thing Mat was in the same boat as the rest of us

I agree about book 12! I just finished book 13 and up until this point, 12 is my favorite. So excited to read the last one!

I'm reading this now and am 4 pages from the end and have been in shock for a day after Talmanes read Verin's letter. I'm afraid to read further. This was the most fulfilling single book I've read with all the payoffs. It's almost enough to cause WOT to pass Mistborn as my favorite series of all time. Incredible! I have the same problem with Egwene as I always have. She is patient and respectful to the White Tower and it's system, but she still has an arrogance that women need to be in charge to save the world from bumbling men. While Rand informed her of his plans as opposed to discussed, she formed a coalition to oppose him rather than hoping to understand what his motivations are. It's possible that Rand approached her as he did because he knew she wouldn't wish to reason self-assured that he must be wrong.

GOD bless you Merphy your thoughts are exactly mine. Every bit. love your reviews I just finished the 13th book and am going to the 14th

Good morning, everyone. I hope you're all well. WoT seems like a great series but I don't think I'll check it out until after I read LoTR. This should be a great vid anyway because Merphy.

Love your prediction🤭 can't wait for your thoughts on book 14. It's so amazing and sad and wonderful and exciting and terrifying and everything

One of the things about that Rand/Egwene scene that always strikes me every time I read it: Rand is a out-manipulating the manipulators. He goes in with two huge problems. He leaves with none. Hear me out. The dude is a General in the last battle. He somehow has to assemble his army from all corners of the continent. The only way for him to do so is magic, but the people he was planning on using (the Ash'a'man) are somewhat unreliable. He's also got to deal with the sisters constantly second-guessing him, trying to steer him their way, etc. They are 125-year-old-magical superwomen, and as far as they're concerned he's barely 20. Solution? Tell the sisters that he's going to do something they will have to directly oppose, and tell them the only for them to oppose him is coordinate a massive Traveling operation to get the Amies of everyone to the Fields of Merrilor.

Just finished it, sad I only have one more to go. Been like a good friend to me

Love your WoT reviews. Will become a top level patron if we can get a massive hour+ review of AMoL and giving thoughts on the series as a whole.

Beast-mode Perrin in full flight is so satisfying to read that I think it somewhat likely RJ made a conscious choice not to spoil us with him and save that impact for later in the series. If we had gotten full beast Perrin for eight straight books it would have been much less thrilling in the final books. I do love the forging scene though, its such a heavy build up for Perrin to be fully unleashed. Its like DING! he's done, you can take him out now he's done.

Wonderful summary. I love how you break it down character by character. And yes, Lan will rock in book 14. Enjoy your read of the last book. And then the New Spring.

After listening to your videos and starting to listen to the audiobook for the first book, seeing the way words and names are actually spelled is constantly surprising. 😂😂

I read WOT for the first time last year. Then this year, I re-read Eye of the World and went straight to A Memory of Light. It was interesting to re-read Eye of the World after finishing the series because I could see the growth of the characters and the the plot development. I think you’ll love A Memory of Light. I’m looking forward to your review.

Yea, the trial did not make a lick of narrative sense. The reason Perrin's arc _appears_ to be the slowest, and he is STILL doing the same ol' same ol' in book 13, is because Sanderson redid his Jordan completed mid series arc. If you go back and re-read Perrin's last Jordan chapters you can tell that his arc is completed and he is now ready to . . . _lead for the Last Battle at the end of_ _Knife Of Dreams._ Some of this was actually resolved way back in book#8. The problem is, as great a writer Sanderson is, he failed to properly research Perrin's story line when he took over( _similar to what happened to Mat here, too_ ) and thus we got a retelling of Perrin's mid series story arc, but in a much bigger Hollywood style picture. The making of his new hammer is a perfect example of this, however, Perrin's narrative now feels like a square peg being forced into a round hole. Sadly It appears that Sanderson needed to get back to writing his own books and thus failed to give this great series the time and attention that it deserved for it's grand final. I do agree with your takes on Mat and Lan.

Love you Merphy!😘😘❤

Most of the merit of getting rid of the Gholam is Mat's but it was also the Aes Sedai's input that made them solve the problem ultimately.

The only thing that I was shocked to see you leave out was Aviendha's trip to Rhuidean. I thought that that was one of the most interesting (and heartbreaking) parts of the book. I agree that this isn't the best book in the series, but that's likely a function of the set-up role that you mentioned repeatedly. It also suffers slightly from the fact that Perrin and Mat's stories are happening parallel to Rand and Egwene's in The Gathering Storm. My predictions for the last one are that you will be pleased with the developments of many of the characters, shocked by several moments, and that you'll cry *at least* twice. It's so good; you're gonna love it.

In MOL You'll have some of the best Lan, his scenes in last book are one of the high points of the book (probably series) one scene expacially

Nyneave is a character who rejects the White Tower, while Egwene embraces it. One is better then the other in my eyes.

I love Lan's parts in this book. It was best of all in this book for me.

Another vote for you to read New Spring before A Memory of Light. It gives some important background information on a few characters.

rodel ituralde! androl! olver! love them sooooo much

Zen Rand returning to Tear is my favourite scene and why I'm so scared for Michael McElhatton playing Tam. The battle in the world of dreams was so damn epic, Perrin and Egwene and getting to see the dreamwalkers finally just awesome

where did you get such a beautiful set of this series? I’ve been looking for sO long for a full set but I can only find them being sold in groups of three...

You are about to experience an amazing moment in your life. AMoL is right up there with the best. I'm so happy for anyone who falls in love with this series.

In Memory the chapter titled "The Last Battle" is like 300 pages of edge of your seat action where you won't put the book down. Finish all errands, eat a meal, and don't plan on moving for a few hours. When I read it the first time I started it before going to bed late one night and was up till almost sunrise heart racing for most of it. Be aware

I can't wait to see your Book 3 Fire review

I love Mat as the comic relief in this series. He tries to act so tough and act like he doesn’t care about the cause, but deep down he’s a good heart. To me, he’s basically the “ Han Solo” of the series. Lol

Perrin's rise is awesome in this book. Such an awesome fella finally finding his space and strength. How he throws off balefire is just the best.

When they get to the hammer forging scene in the TV show they better have some EPIC music in the background.

last one before the crap hits the fan, grats on making it to the end :)

I was waiting for you to mention the Noal reveal

I"ve been waiting for you to read this one!

As some others have said already Rand not taking his time to explain his plans to Egwene is part of his plan, he needed her to gather every leader he's not involved with.

Plot armor comes off in Memory of Light. It's a great one, but basically one long sequence of battles. It's a little exhausting.

It took me so long to like Mat but by this point I love him. One of my favourite characters

The Moiraine Thom romance was actually foreshadowed in a number of places. Reread and look out for it.

Thank you!

Those books introduced me to Sanderson.

I believe that Perrin's hammer is the first power wrought weapon forged since the age of legends, though it has been a while since I read the books.

Perrin's arc is one of my favourites, from insecure little boy to the wolf king. He's possibly the only person to ever benefit from Sevanna, it forced him to accept leadership. The trial kind of had to happen, Perrin had to win over the whitecloaks and then the forging of the hammer and rescuing Galad it was such a good arc. And of all the people in the series to get a redemption arc, I was really surprised Dain got one Also my favourite part of the gholam battle was that the Kin got to take part and get revenge. Seeing them growing in confidence like that has been good too

13 was one of my least favorites. I loved 11 and 12.... but i really think 13 was weaker on characterization and showed the biggest changes between authors. I felt that Mat's character changed alot and they were most obvious in this one. And... Egwene gets on my nerves.