Rate my first edit, btw pin? I’m a new editor and needs some support

Both of them traumatised Maggie for life

Phillip sliced Hershel's neck with Maggie witnessing it. Negan mashed Glenn's head with Maggie witnessing it as well💀💀

durability still goes to governor he was shot in the hand and still kicked rick's ass

The governors smile still gives me nightmares. 💀💀

Negan: are we pissing our pants yet Governor: *pulls up with a whole tank*

Governor was insane killed a few walkers with his bare hands to protect that little girl in season 4, I forgot her name.

Imagine if Governor meet negan instead of tara's family

Governor wins. Before Negan could take a wisecrack joke, he'd already end up with a golfstick at the back of his head fr.

The governor is the probably the best written villain in twd

Negan wins in a fight, he used to be Sports Teacher and killed an entire armed Biker Gang with nothing but a bat

fun fact: if you look at the governors notebook he has over 100+ Confirmed human kills, which is more than anybody in the whole series, so Michonne and Rick had no idea who she was dealing with

Governor realistic villain when Negan is more comics like

Fax💯 Governor is so underrated.

Fax. Governor physically slams negan

Durability, Endurance BIQ and feats go to the Governor

Bro, seriously... You are THE GOAT! I think you are one of the only big creators that agrees with me in this debate. Both are strong characters but Governor stomps! I got alot of hate on my vid, but this was certainly a W bro💖

Two best antagonists on the show. Peak edit

Song name?

Negan destroys the Governor. He has superior emotional intelligence

The governor was quite dangerous, however I think that Negan would win.

Negan would lose if it was just him in “Too Far Gone”.

Negan looks like he's drunk

Governor >>> all villians

What made Governor a real nightmare was him being absolutely unpredictable, best villain written in the show

my man really said governor has better weapons… lucile: kneel down.

The governor smile is so f**king good.😫

TV Negan is scarier than TV governor. Comics governor is scarier than comics Negan

Battle iq goes straight to governor bro

Negan was literally left alone by Beta to fight a horde and still survived with nothing but a stick till morning. He takes strength and stamina.

The thing about negan is that he hesitate sometimes here and there That how he almost got killed by rick Governor in the other hands Just dont fcking care and ends you

You really put battle IQ on Negan nahnahnah hahahah

To be fair, the governor was just insane

Everyone knows that the governor is the goat villain of twd 😂

What Governor and Negan have in common? *The smile*

Michael Myers vs. Negan & The Saviors

Governor wins in a one on one fist fight, negan wins in a group.

Negan le boss

There should be a series about Negan,Governor and Beta taken and put it in Predator planet and how these three tries to survive from predators .

iq should go to the governor

Govonor had a tank😂😂😂

Governor get the durability

Song?

mega W goat edit

Imo I'd rate em like this Strength - Negan - beat a guy half to death pre apocalypse and put him in the hospital. Negan dropped Simon and crushed his windpipe with his bare hands. Threw Rick out of a window. Rammed Rick into a wooden boarded door and opened it. Threw his doctor in a fire. Threw a woman into a wall and busted her head open, killing her by mistake. Knocked out Brandon with a rock and knocked out a whisperer with a shotgun. Speed and Agility - Negan - escaped Rick's gunfire while running threw a tight space and dodging Rick's attacks, moving passed walls and walkers. Dodged Simon's punch and caught another. Dodged Rick's and Maggie's flying axes and dodged a whisperer charging at him. Durability - Philip - Lasted a nice after Michonne stabbed him through the back and before Lilly came up and shot him. Weapons - Philip - He had a tank. IQ - Negan - Tactical expert, outsmarted Rick and Simon, good at reading people and surprised Rick with making a deal with Jadis. BIQ - Philip - Did better at taking down Rick's group. Combat - Negan - Good at boxing and wrestling - Beat a guy half to death, good at throwing and ramming people, good at catching and dodging punches, He also threw Simon off of him when bit his fingers, hit Simon with a 3-hit Combo and caught one of his punches and gave him a right hook and when Simon tried to slam Negan, Negan wrestled Simon off and sweep-slammed him to the ground with impressive impact. Skills - Philip - More skilled with weapons and protective wall building. Power - Negan - Overpowered Simon is 49 seconds. Overpowered Rick in 41 seconds in their first fight, overpowered Rick in 16 seconds in their third fight and overpowered a group of whisperers in a short time. AP - Negan - . Threw Rick out of a window. Rammed Rick into a wooden boarded door and opened it. Threw his doctor in a fire. Threw a woman into a wall and busted her head open, killing her by mistake. Knocked out Brandon with a rock Stamina - Negan - Lasted a good while running dodging and fighting Rick in their second fight and escaped him and didn't seem tired. Plus, he rode bikes pre-apocalypse. Endurance - Negan - Showed no pain from Rick, Daryl, Carver and Simon's punches and didn't hesitate to pull a knife out of his leg. He did show pain when one of the Commonwealth troopers hit him with a gun but then overcame it in a few seconds and gave the trooper a shove. Experience - Negan - Still alive. Feats - Negan - Don't wanna make this too long.

The guy who is savage and in control wins

The governor is the best villain

Bro, Let’s go Owen vs Brandon Carver

Endurance to Bryan

Depends if it is face to face governor might win but like if it takes a couple of episodes negan might win because of prep time

Governor seemed way more evil and creepy to me. You can tell that Negan liked to play the role of the evil one, because that’s where circumstances brought him, while governor was scary af. That little zombie girl? The things he tried to do with Andrea and Michonne? The satisfaction he had in killing Hershel like that? Those scary smiles? Creepy creepy creepy creepy

If those two were to team up this would be an insanely dangerous duo to face

Fire🔥

Feats and Durability to The governor

The problem is the governor’s got better swag

if michone didnt had to mess with him governor would be 1 more great community leader instead of a villian. he is just a broken father figure

Power,stamina and skill goes to negan

Governors reckless and psychi while neganIs laid back calm and collected

All fun and games till I bring a tank

La FUERZA y ARMAS van a NEGAN y la VELOCIDAD y la DURABILIDAD van al GOBERNADOR pero el EDIT esta CHIDO🧟‍♀️🧟‍♂️💀☠️💪👊👍👌

I only know the governor so don't call him Philip

Goated edit🔥

negan slams.

IQ knowledge and endurance to the governor even though hes a really annoying villain we have to speak fax

Governor takes all

Very good music💥🤟👍

Negan my second fav in TWD

The actor who played Negan is an AMAZING actor. Can't say the same about the govenor.

Dude you are like the BEST editor. This edit is so 🔥🔥🔥 and full of fax!!! Great job! I also really love the edits where you have the imaginary conversations at the beginning. So unique and such a fun idea. 👏👏👏

If it was a hand to hand fight to the death I’d put my money on the Governor

they are both the same person. But one had a kid, the other wanted one. Imagine both had one and lost it...

Have u seen the fight between Rick and Negan? Then compare how Rick did against the Governor. Enough said. Governor is a monster

Let's get the facts straight: A fight with Rick is brought in the Governor's favor, where the Governor beats Rick, but everyone forgets that Rick was exhausted, fainted from hunger, did not sleep much, his leg was injured or broken, but Rick continued to fight. They also say that the Governor defeated Merle. At that moment, Merle was beaten by 7 guys, Merle fought them off. Negan showed much more: Killed and strangled the big Trevor, when Negan had an accident and was injured, Rick with a weapon could not kill him, he dodged Rick's bat blows, dodged Rick's flying Axe. In the final battle, Rick won because he said about Carl, Negan quickly adapted when he himself killed a group of bandits in a bar and freed a man, defeated Carver by cunning - threw sand in his eyes. Speed, agility and intelligence go to Negan. That's not all Negan showed. I haven't watched Dead City yet. Negan has been in more fights than The Governor. Fought with Rick, Fought against the Commonwealth, recaptured Commonwealths, occupied outposts. The skill will also go to Negan. He knows how to merge with the Walkers, even the Governor could not, the Governor has 1 eye, this makes it very difficult to see and notice better. Negan built the Empire and change himself, the Governor could not and died. Rick offered to split the prison and live in peace and forget everything, but the Governor wanted to kill everyone and died himself ... I think that Negan> The Governor. Many people still say that Negan is just a PE teacher, But they forget that the Governor was generally an office worker...

Govener takes iq and knowledge negan take’s strength

Governor can kill walkers with his bare hands when Negan on the other hand has to use a bat or a stick shovel like s9

W goat

Jim hopper beats Negan in h2h mid difficulty

Negan Smith 👏🔥

Durability and endurance goes governor

O cara da todos os atributos pro Negan, pro governador vencer. O Negan sola

strength negan, durability govenor, endurance equal, combat slightly Negan, Negan high to extreme diffs

Please do Michael vs billy from stranger things day 4

Battle IQ goes to the governor

W

All these comments saying Negan wins. First of all Governor would win. Heres why. In all honesty, Negan needed his Army to make him powerful. As the Governors army needed his leadership to be powerful and dangerous. Also the governor took out like 20 walkers in a row surrounded coming at him. He blank shot a dude in the head with an AUG from a few meters away. He also has insane knife skills and combat hand to hand. Negan is so lazy and sits all day. Governor has power. The Governor beat the F out of Rick he just got third partied too. Not to mention his Power and Skill being far higher than Negan being a lazy dude. 😂😂😂 y’all trippin hard

The difference between The Governor and Negan is that The Governor did everything for his people and Negan had his people/enemies do everything for him. Ultimately The Governor raised an army of people who couldn’t fight and Negan and the saviors relied too much their enemies making them weak without them.

IM NOT GROWING A GARDEN

Love this battle edit it states only facts also what is the song you used?

W edit and fax, The Governor would smoke Negan!

Negan is much more tactical planner so that's gonna be the Governor's downfall.

IQ and Battle IQ goes to the Governor, he managed to defeat Rick multiple times with pretty smart cunning tactics such as the Bread Truck with Walkers in it, or the time when he decisively able to raise and train an army the Saviors under Negan were mostly bad people who had families yes but mostly were bad people who just didn’t care about other lives and were experienced in fighting. Meanwhile the army of Woodbury had regular citizens which were trained pretty damn well, I personally believe plot armor is what made them loose. Other feats the Governor has is able to come back from the loss of his daughter which was turned and ended up running an entire group again taking leadership of it in a cunning way. Negan is much more charismatic and has more competent lieutenants with micromanage his army and the Saviors, Negan is generally only there for the big things such as what we saw when he was bashing people’s heads in. He has more of a cult of personality to him and his people, his lieutenants controlled groups that joined the Saviors without them he’s nothing. The Governor meanwhile was able to easily manage his town and his army able to do military and domestic affairs while protecting their borders with general success, Milton Mamet helped the Governor with domestic and scientific affairs but mostly it was the Governor’s ideas. I believe Negan also was simply influenced by Eugene’s good old mr smart man Southern talking acting like a scientist but in reality he was playing Negan. The Governor was able to make use of a civilian army to defeat U.S Military veterans, while being able to keep people in his town and make it prosperous being organized and well developed the Saviors were more or a rough rider organization that followed their lieutenants such as Simon. We also have to realize that Negan relies more on scare tactics than actual military tactics, as he believes people will submit to him if he bashes one person’s head in or a few spreading fear amongst the people or well the Saviors and their protectorates such as the Hill top or the Kingdom. Generally Negan just has a charismatic personality to him while being a leader makes him form a cult of personality around him. The Governor is a statistics, tactics, and strategic person who knows what he is doing and is able to be successful in how he does it. The battle of the prison was basically a strategic victory for the Governor even though he died, he basically forced Rick to abandon the prison and Rick’s group basically was cut down till they reached Alexandria. Overall IQ and Battle IQ goes to the Governor

Negan was never a villain whereas the governor was but the governor was the worst one

8-6 governor wins

Durability to governor

Experience goes to Negan only because he lived longer. While Negan was hiding with his wife the Governor had Woodbury in full effect doing raids all over the state.

I beg make the governor vs Glenn rhee

W+fax🔥🔥🔥

Se os dois lutassem no mano a mano com certeza a vitória seria do governador.

Governor would stand no chance against the Negan Army

The governor >>