Dominican: Puedes a provar.

If you think about it, most languages started off by being "incorrect". Spanish and Italian are Latin languages, but obviously are different and aren't like actual Latin either. But you wouldn't tell the speaker of either that they are wrong. The changes are correct, but not the same as their mother tongue.

Jaq Neebe I’ve heard it called proper Spanish

2900 Lieutenant I still feel like them handling it this way, with “neutral” Spanish, is way less classist than calling it “proper” would be though.

All languages have a neutral/proper/educated/formal version.

@@rollenmuziek There is no "neutral" Spanish. It's a symmetric pluricentric language with no "Dachsprache." There is a broad consensus on certain things mentioned in this video, but her position on lexical variations is questionable.

Thank you for this! I feel like your explanation should have prefaced this video.

That depends on where the Dominican comes from and the educational background. If they did not receive any education in regards of that, they will not be able to neutralize their accent nor pronounce all the letters from words completely.

This is so true, I work at a call center in Spanish and despite the fact we all Dominicans we can't talk the clients like that

Jose Carvajal An educated Dominican from dr will for sure speak correctly, but the people that have no education over there which is unfortunately a lot!!

Dominican Spanish: hebzljeagdkwkkzjd blaheiselzgesmxmdep

Lollipops and unicorns 😂😂😂

wtf is fuistes ? xD

dandre clarke eso es fuiste* pero mal dicho fuistes*

@@ninetails114 You went= Fuiste, though I have heard some Mexicans and South Americans saying fuistes...💁🏻‍♀️🤷🏻‍♀️ But I think that's wrong...🙅🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️

@@zlumi428 It is, a lot of spanish speaking people make the same mistake. Here, across the pond (Spain) It is the same, you hear a lot of people saying "fuistes", "dijistes", "cogistes", etc. and It is completely wrong.

creo que nadie pronuncia cada letra... es uno de los principios con los cuales el latin vulgar evolucionó en las lenguas romance modernas. Muchos latinos van a EEUU y sus hijos jamás pasan por un sistema escolar hispano, por lo tanto lo único que saben de español es lo que escuchan en sus casas... es.. raro

JAJAJAAJAJAJAJAJAJAJ

Laughs in Puerto Rican

Jajaja la verdad es q los andaluces nos comemos muchas letras

*laughs in Caribbean*

fuiste instead , but its basically the same

it's a word that we use in Spain a lot soo

@@ashenone3050 yes but she was correcting him for skipping or adding just one letter. She said it wrong so she must also be corrected.

@@hinkab agree

Ashen one tengo entendido que "fuistes" es incorrecto, por más que la gente lo use

Same

Y e s. Bring me all the flavours! The neutral Spanish simply works as a bridge between them

Neutral Spanish doesn't exist and it's not natural for native speakers. The only people that study that are actors in Mexico or USA for tv. Many hispanic people there speak Spanglish and they think that are speaking Spanish so they need it. Nobody else study that because anyone with a bit of formal education at school (all Hispanics study the same grammar and language at school) can tell what's slang and what's not. That's the only important thing in order to communicate with anyone anywhere but we dont need to change our own regional accent to do that. Beside that most of people doesn't know or care what is "neutral" Spanish, only actors working in those two countries.

@@jguillermooliver i think there are levels of neutrality. i'd say few may care about it in the most entreme sense but you cant tell me south americans dont care when they are trying to understand caribbeans. it almost feels like an entirely different language.

It's the same language with differents accents. It feels different for you but Spanish is not your native language. Unless one of the speakers use a lot of slang on purpose there's not problem to understand anyone. It doesn't matter if they are from the caribe or anywhere else we understand each other but you are not a native so you need to practice more if you can't understand because I have no problem. The same may happen in your same city with people of different ages, education, and so on if they speak with slang that you don't know and they stick with it. Also happened but much more in English because we don't change spellings, but you do, we speak the same language. Only foreigners are always asking the same. Yes, we understand each other but American Hispanic people in USA speak Spanglish so they need to study real Spanish, we don't. English speaking people really need to study neutral English because I know you don't understand certain accents from UK and Ireland, jamaica, ebonics an so on, but it's your language so I can't be sure but you don't tell me what we can understand and what we can't or what we need. You clearly don't have the understanding to say so.

you do not need the apostrophe in Caribbean.

🇩🇴 gang

DR Spanish:urhdhdjdjjsjsjskskskkd PR Spanish: I was leally tiled like vely tiled at wolk Cuban Spanish:(muffled voice like you got back from the dentist) o hello ol pal amigo thing

G88 Blue 🇨🇺🇨🇺✊🏽✊🏽

Raymundo Ramirez 💥🇩🇴✊🏽🇩🇴💥

@Private Citizen did I say anything peverse? No entonces calmate gracias

Private Citizen JAJAJAJSJ

@Robertico Artesano she THIIICICICICI

She is sexy I ain't gon judge u Lol

estoy de acuerdo

😁 poor guy, I feel for him.

Damn I feel that I fail my first spanish test in Freshmen in HS, i know Dominican spanish but not neutro so i fail the pronunciation, and the spelling.

The spanish of an educated dominican person is perfectly intelligible. This is not the case with the person in this video and unfortunately the same apply for the majority of dominicans. 😞😣

Luis Moreno the education is Dr is not like in here but still I don’t think speaking in dialects or with a country’s slang makes you dumb or ignorant or some shit like that you feel

@@jeremyrdlamaxima7052 I would fail that shit too tbh lmao

fuite in argentina lol

@@ojberrettaberretta5314 same in PR...I think a lot of latinos kick the S to the curb honestly...

@@ojberrettaberretta5314 Sonaste, mejor dicho.

In the DR we straight up say "Fuite" and kill the S everywhere 😂

Ojberretta Berretta DR too 😂 we really don't like the letter S at the end of words.

It really depends from what part of DR he's from.. The best speakers are from the Capital or Santiago City..

Geo Gmz él no es de ninguno de esos lugares. Honestly I love the way he speaks, it has a beautiful rhythm in my opinion ☺️ when he wants to teach me something specific, he switches to a neutral accent but like a child, I pick up on the “bad” things more easily 😝

Lol I get what you mean. I had a Dominican boyfriend and also have Puerto Rican family and it’s just weird listening to neutral version 🤣

I’m dominican and can’t understand other spanish speakers

@@UmYeaSoWhat So I guess you say "Coño" or "Vaina" every 10 sec.. 😅

Totalmente JAJAJAJAJJA

It's not wrong pal

Token Teran Aea mongol

@@ahuman6284 si que lo esta

Exactamente

Leon Salas Burgermeister 😂😂

Eso eh vedah así eh como se habla y la gente lo entiendo no hay que tar diciendo tanta palabra si igualmente se sabe lo que tu dice ya tu sabe

POH'

Totalmente de acuerdo. Gracias por la corrección.

Exacto.

Lo vi/escuché y me dio "rash" mental, jaja.

Por dios, vine a decir esto. Casi muero.

@@EstherHermida oiga profe tiene que hacer otro video así con Gabriel por favor . 💯

Jajajajaja Sin ofender pero no son la mejor opción para alguien que quiere aprender español.

Un do tre kuatro nooo no asi no e

It is flat out wrong kid, sorry.

Actually 'dijeron' is wrong too, we should be using the Latin 'dīxērunt'

Mattis Torede no seas bobo

Mattis Torede how about we use TU MALDITA MADRE. You’re really trying too hard to sound smart now.

@@MattisTorede ¿Para que diablos vamos a adivinar la pronunciación del latín vulgar? Además ni siquiera hay fuentes de cómo se hablaba el latín vulgar.

That's niiice that they're your favorite to teach 🙄

Just cause they speak regional spanish it doesn’t mean they don’t speak it well, this is insane. How they don’t speak “well” they’re own native language(?) This is very eurocentric, besides the fact that you’re probably not a native speaker yourself, so you cannot determine what’s right or wrong based on your textbook spanish.

@@Raphinhalove1 I am a native speaker, born and raised in Mexico actually. In fact, most of my students come from a Mexican background, and many of their parents come from towns similar to where I grew up. The type of regional Spanish I'm referring to is what we call "del rancho"...where you can have words that are very specific to that area, and many words are pronounced wrong, such as saying nadien instead of nadie, muncho instead of mucho, gomitar instead of vomitar, etc. It's not eurocentric to expect my students to improve their Spanish to a more academic level and to want to teach them the correct way to pronounce words or a different way of saying something. It's called progress and if you're offended by that, then stay with the bare minimum mentality, idc.

Bruh let em keep their accents neutral spanish boring as fuk 🇩🇴🇩🇴🇩🇴🇩🇴

@@Raphinhalove1 exactly

Lissette Same here, girl. Ain’t nobody got time to pronounce ALL the letters! We’re in a hurry to get the message across, hahaha

Gracias por este comentario, es una vaina pronunciar todo. 🇵🇷🇨🇺🇩🇴🇭🇹🇯🇲

That was the one thing that threw me for a loop when I first started dating a Dominican man. He never spoke the entirety of a word. And it was always so fast I'm like, hold on, speak into this translator real slow like cuz you lost me buddy! 😂😂😂😂 I'm slowly starting to learn the ebs and flows of Dominican Spanish so we can communicate better. He's learning English too. But I would never want him to lose his way of speaking. Though at times difficult to decipher, it's still pretty darn sexy to listen to. 😁

It is not actually hard, in formal settings we dominicans speak neutral spanish all the time.

upper class Puerto Ricans pronounce it very well, i think it has more to do with socio-class, rather than being from the Caribbean here is an example Dominican kzfaq.info/get/bejne/eNuUa7KIy7bNmnU.html Puerto Rican kzfaq.info/get/bejne/r76DjJWnppmvemQ.html Cuban kzfaq.info/get/bejne/p7Z_o7GFy9mUqZc.html

exacto amigo así también paso con el latín

100%

It does. She herself says it. Removing accent and pronouncing letters. This makes it neutral for everyone to understand. If you speak with missing letters, how is that proper? I have to admit Mexicans mark all their letter, as Colombians do. However, Colombians tend to stretch the first vowel in the fist syllable in words.

Maybe at Spain?

Zukhulemto_22 haha no they are worst

Agree. I am not a professor nor a teacher, it's a habit of Spanish speakers to give titles to people that may or may not have. For instance, anyone with a B.A. or B.S. is called a "licenciado" in Mexico. A "dialect coach" works with actors who may or may not speak Spanish. A Dominican actor may be acting as a Mexican in a scene and s/he wants to sound more authentic; that's when the producers call in a coach. (See beautiful Dominican actress Dania Ramirez and Puerto Rican Shalim Ortiz in the second season of the TV series Heroes (I was their coach). See William Levy in Mexican telenovelas and then listen to his normal Cuban speech here. He has a very Cuban accent, yet speaks clearly. The interviewer is Jorge Ramos, a great Mexican news anchor and author, has a very clear Mexican accent. They are both speaking Spanish and understand each other. They are not using too much slang, the reason they do this is so that the audience from different countries can easily understand. kzfaq.info/get/bejne/oKhnp7pevJ7dg3k.html. Take a look at Adamari Lopez, a PR actress, acting in Mexican soaps. I first watched in a Mexican telenovela her when she was very young. I didn't even know she was from Puerto Rico until I heard her in an interview. That'll give you an idea why "coaches" exist. After the word "cut" is said the actor returns to being who s/he is. Gadiel doesn't need a "coach" because he's got his followers that love him just the way he is. He doesn't need to speak Spanish flawlessly to have appeal. In fact, that may make him even more likable. But he's an entertainer, most of us are not and we may be dealing with different parameters. Living in the US allows us to meet Spanish speakers from 20 different Spanish speaking countries. Surprisingly we can all understand each other if we keep it "neutral". But the funny thing is that if you live in one country, you'll never know you speak differently. It's only when you come to this melting pot that you realize that not everyone speaks the same way. For me language and the way people speak is fun. I'm a language nerd. I'm a word gatherer. I don't lecture, I share what I've learned. Of course, it's a lot of fun to hear regionalisms because of the different meanings in each country. These are fun slang words to test your friends in: bicho, concha, guagua, bollo, papaya.

She wasn't being critical. Gadiel was speaking a form of Spanish that is unique to his country of origin that may not necessarily be understood by fellow Spanish speakers, especially those who are not exposed to it the same way Colombian, Venezuelan, Castilian and Mexican Spanish have in media, which in fairness to those aforementioned varieties, also have their own localisms that may be proven problematic to fully comprehend (Like I don't understand why some Mexicans end their sentences with güey). If I were from say, Cuba, and I happen to be in Argentina or Uruguay for business, I probably would not be able to understand right away the locals' colloquialisms, let alone their accent (with their doble L's having a -sh sound), and likewise for them to me. Both Gadiel and Esther had a lot of fun doing this and very educational on the part of Gadiel. FYI, I'm learning Spanish hehe.

@@jlhabitan50 Thank you for explaining it beautifully. Learning the slang will be a fun part of language learning as you advance in your studies.

@@EstherHermida You're welcome. :)

Vemos

Exacto!

Yo soy dominicana y hablo perfectamente, en todos los países latinoamericanos hay gente que habla mal.

Para que sepan

Angievaldezvizcano Valdez Vizcaino Es por un asunto de regionalismo, pero tienes totalmente la razón.

Shanae Scott haha. Exactly. I’m Jamaican and Dominican. I barely speak any of the three languages right. 😂😂

I'm a Louisiana-Creole and to a French person; we are the Jamaicans to French (accent wise.) Nuff respect to Jamaica 🇯🇲

Is jamaican creole/patios not taught in school? My creole is taught in school.

@@gcc2313 you must be a Haitian 🇭🇹???

@@gcc2313 No we use english in school. Some colleges teach it as a course though.

Creo lo mismo que tú. Aquí en comentarios de otras personas veo que confunden Español neutro con acento neutro, dos cosas que son muy diferentes. En el caso del segundo si diría que no existe, uno diría que trata de hablar en acento neutro, pero siempre uno logra reconocer el origen.

@@cpelaezd Exacto! Suave Bro!

Exacto

Not in the north of Spain, but in the south and in the Canary Islands they do and I can't stand it.

Not Peruvians

v0calbeatzlaughs Mexicans don’t do that :/

@@noface____ I have to disagree with that

Siii especially los caribeños from the people I know what I hear but Mexicans do it too so I know it's not just them😁

Right🤣🤣

It was him who edited it🤷🏻‍♂️

🙋🏾‍♀️🙋🏾‍♀️ her Spanish was confusing me😂💀💀

@@imalexaliaandkpopsnatchedm7948 feel you 😅

Habemos.. hay.. ¿a que te refieres?

Qué va, en situaciones formales uno habla lo más neutro posible en nuestro país.

Yo odio ese "habemos" y el "ello hay" 😂.

They don't pronounce the words correctly.

OCT POD “correctly” is relative. Brits don’t correct Americans on how to say certain words. It’s relative and whatever is more comfortable for the person. You know what I mean?

OCT POD we do

well, yeah, the cea televisa of televisa developed the neutral spanish

yeah, strong Betty la fea vibes

I agree, especially when they talk fast. I am used to Mexican Spanish, it doesnt have all the dropped letters.

We love you 🇩🇴

@Daniel Moreno bc it's not "neutro". I mean, It sounds VERY Latin (which isnt bad) but for exemple, they pronounce the "c" like an "s".

@@sandru42 "s" is more clear to hear than the "z' sound

Tu no puedes reirte, tienes que verlo y aprender, te hace mucha falta!

@@sin4503 por?

@@sandru42 Bueno, teniendo en Cuenta que solo el 15% (me he inventado El porcentaje pero mas o menos) de Los Hispanoablantes en el Mundo hablamos con la "c" de España creo que lo neutro seria Como lo habla LA mujer del video...

corle1 Gracias por esa información! Muy bonita tu patria. Hace unos años visité Punta Cana de vacaciones. Qué recuerdos. Un saludo a todos los buenos dominicanos.

@@grandpatzer Para añadir... Lo único que "desminicaniza" tu ejemplo es la parte de "tío joder" que en dominicano sería "loco" o "mi loco".

@corle1 Para el caso de República Dominicana al menos 95% eran andaluces/canarios y la otra minoría era VASCA. Aún existen registros como "abur" que viene del vasco "agur", que significa "adiós". Esto se dice en el sur dominicano.

dante dante Vascos hay en toa parte jaja

@@grandpatzer NO LO CREO...

Lol I've been saying that shit wrong my whole life! 😂

Estudien sus verbos..

LOL MEEEE

Look it up in the dle.rae.es/ dictionary.

Yo siempre e dicho Dijieron 😌😌😌😌 I thought 💭 I was correct my whole life 😂😂

not more than in argentina tho

I worked with majority Dominican clients but have to say Chilenos drop so much slang. Argentinos don’t have much experience with.

@@crazy4beatles chileans just dont talk properly they all have almost a speech impediment

@@ojberrettaberretta5314 Ouch. I agree with you, but, not everyone in the whole country talks like that Greetings :D

manny1up That’s true but saying “usté” rather than “usted” isn’t slang, it’s incorrect Spanish.

Anttonia Paz como que no se puede Xd

@@starlord7916 obvio se puede

Y yo que pensaba que el chileno tenía uno de los acentos más neutros de Latinoamérica (?)

@@bakaotani12 es de los más difíciles jajaja

HaeSoo12 Nooo hablamos muy mal jdjsjs a veces no nos entendemos ni nosotros mismos

Exacto. Si vas más al centro, la J es más "aspirada"(a excepción de MX) si bajas al sur es más neutral pero si ya vas muy al sur la J es más cerrada(CHILE) donde la lengua se aplasta contra el paladar para pronunciarla. Ejm: Neutral: Agenda (a-jen-da) Central America: Agenda (a-hen-da) Chile: Agenda (a-jien-da)

Jackeline Castañeda En Mexico la J es aspirada a excepción de la Ciudad de México he notado que no aspiran la J.

@@KK-lo8ki en México la j no es aspirada yo he vivido en varias partes de mi país por Dios, primero enseñando sobre ensordecimiento vocalico y ahora aseguras que aspiramos la j? No hables sin conocer por favor.

Ismael Santana you’re not the only one

Berryxsubliminals it sounds naco

Estoy aprendiendo Español y creía que fue dijieron también.

Mixtape Mania No es una gran diferencia yo lo sigo diciendo

Berryxsubliminals por qué no mejorar?

cellophaneboy se me olvida y lo digo automáticamente pero talves un día

C R huh?

@C R, spoken like a person who doesn't understand linguistics. No one is born knowing the grammar of a language; you have to learn it.

C R what the hell is correct Spanish? Do you think Latin Americans are being taught in incorrect Spanish at school? The distinction between the C S and Z have nothing to do with writing correctly. 😂

@C R, Imma keep it real with you chief, I'm not reading all that.

kzfaq.info/get/bejne/eNOCZdF51q_ehH0.html

Hablamos de América, no de la península.

es increíble como hay gente tan estúpida que no comprende que el acento neutro es el utilizado en el doblaje, hecho así para que todo Latinoamérica entienda, si no, habría que hacer un doblaje para cada país del continente, es el español del México de los años 40, limpio, claro de entender para los extranjeros, totalmente seseante, diferenciándolo del acento español.

Español latino es la lengua en si, es una lengua latina. Es español americano y español europeo. Los latinos son del Lazio en Italia.

I'm from America, and I'm a Louisiana Creole, and I speak Louisiana-Creole French 🇫🇷... Just imagine what the French say about our French lol 😆

👏👏👏👏👏

es increíble como hay gente tan estúpida que no comprende que el acento neutro es el utilizado en el doblaje, hecho así para que todo Latinoamérica entienda, si no, habría que hacer un doblaje para cada país del continente, es el español del México de los años 40, limpio, claro de entender para los extranjeros, totalmente seseante, diferenciándolo del acento español.