Truly

No different than what Maddie and Kaylee felt.

yes agree

@@citizendame6329 they were asleep

@@TR-jc8pc no they weren't. Dylan, directly below Maddie and Kaylee, said she heard Kaylle say "someone's here". They were in bed most likely but not fast asleep. They were found in bed, yes, but not unconscious when attacked. At least Kaylee wasn't. And neither were Xana and Ethan. Only unconfirmed sleeper is Maddie now.

My book too!

My mom always said if I go down, I better go down fighting.

💯💯💯 RIP Xana. 🕊

Indeed. RIP Sweet angels!

I really believe in resurrection here on this but under God's Kingdom. If I'm going be faithful till the end I'm might see many of those beautiful people that list their precious life's for this nonsense.. it's terrible that many bad people do not like to be close to Creator just stick to the evil one and harming peaceful families

we haven't come to know nothing but CONFLICTING statements. Only thing believable is top floor got attacked 1st , then second floor, and that X fought as much as she could.

I believe someone who does this sort of thing is possessed by Satan himself. Mark 5 King James Version

Humans hit the highest of highs and lowest of lows of all animal's behavior

@@AJFresh69 that's a jaundiced view. Maybe most all horses and some serv dogs hit even a higher high than most of the human race. And a serial killer may well hit lower than the worst dog or horse..;(

Not human…Satan in the flesh

💔 😢

Then came Dylan who claims not to have heard anything other than a "cry" and "I'll help you" from Xana and Ethan's room. I hope they don't let Dylan get away.

@@aikapalis4219 stop blaming her not all details are out & Dylan wasn’t the only survivor what did Bethany hear? Still a lot to learn

You know she definitely had plenty of time to SCREAMMMMM for her life when E was attacked in her presence. So DM is a lying piece of ...work. and completely evil for not calling 911! I'm sure even E had time to make noise and the struggle had to have made enough NOISE in that hallway for frikin DM! Pisses me off!

Its infuriating. To many of us. Because it was so unnecessary!

@@es4242 we’re you there??

Gidday Mate Aussie here😇 yes Ive been following too, its so disturbing Im so glad they have someone in custody This particular crime gave me chills, poor kids just starting out in life😖 Send❤to the Families

Uh, she's not reading your post.

Also Xana's mother is arrested in Spokane Washington for trespassing.

If your fingers are shopped off - wouldn't you scream loud enough that Dylan hears it ?

@@TheNewsAnchorYouTrust What does her mother's charges have to do with this?

Watch. Out. China. Cell. Phone. And. Corp. Media. Both. Needs. To. Be. Stopped nnow

Unimaginable 😢

I think so too :(

They can not tell too much especially in the beginning of the crime, they want to build a good conviction, so I understand LE for not telling the public or family , this world is so screw up , stop 🛑 the killing and get HELP PLEASE!!! it affects me and I don't know these innocent people, just STOP KILLING AND GET HELP, PLEASE!!! Idaho 4 will never be forgotten, RIP beautiful souls,JUSTICE IS ON ITS WAY , LOVE YOU KIDS 💘😍 parents hang in there, LoVE YOU ALL , I JUST WANT PEACE, ✌️✌️✌️

Only for legal reasons. It'll ALL come out. Trust me. It always does.

MARY ANN: Good point, and I agree. Yet we must steel ourselves that once this gets into the courtroom, as tough as it will be, every detail of horror will be known. My hope now is that he will not plead out to avoid his trial.

People were mad that the coroner shared "so much" but it sounds like she was actually holding back a LOT.

No matter what he gets, even if he gets the death penalty, it won't be what he deserves. Being executed is a lot more humane than dying a horrific death like these young adults did.

It's not amazing it's fairly typical. Instinct to fight for one's life

@@H3yItzKevin now that’s just plain disrespectful! Shame on u mister! 🤣😂

If you say so, Brian?

@@citizendame6329 aww, do you feel better now? Did it help your poor, low seIf esteem to try disputing a basic compliment about a m*rdererd girI? Lol. Get well.

!!!!!!!!!

Well said. These babies were tough. They were smart. I hope their poor families know that we wont forget them.

❤❤❤❤

YES!!!!

awesome

@@Maripossa909 I don't think she saw all of them, but she definitely heard it. This was not a peaceful or quiet murder how did everyone else not hear all the commotion surely there were screams. 😢

@@Maripossa909 only E. she wasn't present in top floor to see the 2 girls get deleted.

@@GingerNinja1 DM is deaf and dumb, not calling 911 immediately...oh wait, i forgot she had BRAIN FREEZE.

She probably didn’t care and she was On drugs

@@GingerNinja1 yeah I forgot about that

Agreed!

@Sunflowers, I agree.

I totally agree.

Yep noticed that also … Ethan could have been hurt at the door and stumbled back to the bed and passed away there, but then again she never said ALL of them

That's what I thought.

If “ALL” is true too bad the surviving rm mates didn’t show some of the same strength and bravery

Its instinct anyone getting stabbed or about to and cornered is gona fight! Even a coward is not gona just accept it with no resistance. However , a coward would hear it and realize whats possibly going on and hide till he's gone . He either purposelessly left survivers or didn't know they was there . I doubt her fight made him leave any quicker... Thats my opinion tho. We all have an opinon

Imagine being stabbed and not fighting back. You’re just going to let someone stab you over and over and just do nothing ? That has to be incredibly rare.

@@judithgzlz7013 i wonder if the roommates have called 911 and ambulance, would some of them would survive???

I'm sure they ALL fought back hard, not just Xana. Remember Xana was the last to be killed. By the time the killer got to Xana, he had killed three other people.

That’s “News Nation’s Fact-Driven, Unbiased Coverage”. 😂

Yep, October is in "direct conflict" with what the police reports say.

October. November. Same thing. They both in the fall am right next to one another lol

@@jaymesnin Well if Ashleigh is going to criticize the coroner for what she believes is: "in direct conflict" from the more recent report... you'd think she herself would at least get the correct month right of when the murders took place.

Came here to see if anyone else caught that 😂

How painful and horrifying.

I did too.

I think this is why Brian left the other roommates alive. I think he was targeting the entire house but Xana fought back so hard that she scared him away/tired him out before he got to the others.

There’s a lot of spin on this interpretation of evidence, assuming the story is true. The first and foremost question is why the leak? Unless it’s intentional, done for some mysterious reason by LE, is it worth risking your job and a contempt of court ruling? Is there so much money available that an investigator would risk it?

@@jimbrown9817 Really small town & police dept. I imagine, w/in 24 hrs, 100% of the dept knew many details. Not long after, the victims family as well. Just my fair chance guess, but say: 30%+ told someone - friend, confidante, spouse, etc. Then, 40%+ of them pass it on (further removed, greater probability - another guess.) Repeat... can see how quickly info gets out. Also Important to note: it increases the likelihood of getting misconstrued as well!✌️

I've heard about this. Do you remember anything else mentioned from that report?

@@honhae2025 it was locals saying he was found out of bed and in the hallway. That was all.

Banfield never said Ethan was FOUND in the doorway. She discussed how it’s possible the attack STARTED in the doorway and he was pushed into the room.

@@Missundaztood-jc6qg it was one of the first rumors out of this case, I remember. The report did say that Xana was the first one found but did not detail her location.

Well looks like maybe someone was on the bed. The blood dripped down the side of the foundation of the house.

Grace, I'm so sorry this has happened to you ⚘⚘⚘

I am so sorry for your terrible loss of your boy.

He needs to be quickly put to death not a long drawn out 5 or 10yrs on death row. There is nothing that can bring these families any true peace but that could maybe help start the healing

So sorry for your loss 😞

I am so sorry for your loss. I can't imagine how terribly heartbreaking it is to lose a child.

Also, a puncture wound to the neck could be fatal if the jugular is hit.

Ethan was in bed, Xana on the floor inside the room.

@@bewell6019 The arrest affidavit says Maddie and Kaylee were found in a single bed. Like I said Xana was found on the floor and “also in the room was a male, later identified as Ethan Chapin”.

@@bewell6019 They literally say in this video that he was in the doorway.

@@curtf9813 Maddie was in bed under the covers and Kaylee on top of that bed. She was alerted to Maddie being murdered, closed Murphy in her room and went to help screamed and fought but was killed, falling/pushed onto Maddie's same bed. Ethan goes out to investigate and is not armed at that point, but checking wtf is going on. He retreats quickly to the room to find anything, maybe a pillow ffs. Then gets killed on the bed. Xana was further inside the room and hears Ethan screaming for her to run out now! As she does, BK is able to reach and kill her too, as she collapses to the floor near the door still inside her room (though visible from the bathroom too).

I doubt it. He was covered head to toe - mask, gloves, thick winter clothing.

What a ridiculous comment. Anyone would claw their way out of a single knife fight. It's not bravery its instinct. She likely wasn't thinking of leaving her DNA on him, only surviving. Quit romantacizing murder cases.

You're absolutely right, your comment was ridiculous yet you felt compelled to leave it anyway. Boring! Now, I'll allow you to have the final word, and then you can go and spread your misery elsewhere 😏

@@openorwap5412 yeah, keep walking because you know you're wrong.

She wasn't thinking about DNA and she certainly wasn't thinking that she should spread it around, knowing she couldn't overpower the murderer. She was fighting for her life. Period. When confronted with a knife-wielding maniac dressed in all black in your home in the middle of the night, you fight. She likely couldn't run and was cornered by him. She would have been in a state of terror with her adrenaline pumping. Cuts on the hands from grabbing at the knife is something found in victims of stabbing murders. It is a common reflex to grab for the weapon that your assailant is using, even though it will only hurt you to grab at a blade with your bare hand. I'm sure Xana did everything she could to survive. I feel so bad for her and her friends. It's heartbreaking. But let's not make a superhero storyline up about this horror. Xana wasn't trying to spread her DNA. She was trying to live.

she was raised by her dad

@@nikkimclay5474 yeah so was I, doesn’t change shit

@@nikkimclay5474 Raised by her dad or not, it was still sad that her mother was in that position.

@@jillian9183 as a child psych I believe it does change shit

@@odessa72 sure was sad especially as shes still an addict but she had a great dad & paternal aunt, which many kids dont get, by all means Xana was a thriving & successful young woman.

and so.... now the accusations are starting again are they mary m. What does m stand for ? MOPHEAD perhaps!.

I truly want to give them the benefit of the doubt but you wouldn’t imagine an attack like this would be quiet by any means to an otherwise ‘silent’ sleeping household

@@jessice293 right, especially if ur bedroom is right below theirs. It sounds like he started in the top floor and attacked kaylee and maddie then maybe thats why ethan was in the hallway because him amd zana heard the commotion and he was going to see what was going on but got attacked next. Then that may have been when Xana was whimpering out of fear when he was coming at her and she may have been trying to get away from her which is why he tried to convince her that he was "trying to help" her. Ughh i wish this was just a night mare. But i really hope this man pays dearly for what he did.

@@Insertcatchienamehere That's also how I pictured it.

How can a camera from another house pick up a whimper, the dog barking and a loud thud but the roommates heard nothing? I'm not buying it.

They were party girls. They lived a dangerous lifestyle.

@@BERNARDO712 They may have been party girls but being so didn't necessarily attract this sicko killer to them. Most kids do party in college. They in no way are responsible for what happened to them. These days it's dangerous to go to McDonald's for an ice cream cone. One never knows when or where a mass murderer might strike. And I hardly would call going out to McDonald's a dangerous life style.

Never will have justice or closure, unfortunately this is a life sentence to the families 😒

@@BERNARDO712 Party girls... I suppose your the one person on Earth, that never ever attended a party or parties ?? If you & I attended a party or many parties.. What does that make us?? A party boy.. And... A party girl ?? I THINK NOT..!! So... If we were SLAUGHTERED at home, where parties took place.. I'm guessing, you'd think it'd make your MOTHER feel really great, reading some IDIOT called her DEAD child a party boy, PLUS..He pretty much deserved it. It doesn't sound so Kool now, does it ?!! NOPE !!

Yes

Remember, they'd just received food at 4 a.m. So if he, killer, (I refuse to use his given name) came in shortly after 4 he just missed the delivery guy(how lucky for him), went immediately upstairs and murdered the girls , Ethan and Xana must have heard THEIR crys, and Ethan steps out just as killer is leaving, so that's when he killed them. Now just when did the other roommate see him? Before or after he killed E &X? Her room was right across the way! Will we ever know a'll of the horrors they all went through

Understandable. But I'm quite tired of all the lying from authorities in this case. Say 'no comment' instead of lying. They were not all found in beds according to the PCA.

zana said someone's here,ethan went to go into hallway and was attacked

She probably shouldn't have done an interview

Even with the right technique and assets some investors would still make more than others, as an investor, you should’ve known that by now, nothing beats experience and that’s final, personally I had to reach out to a stock expert for guidance which is how I was able to grow my account close to a million, withdraw my profit right before the correction and now I’m buying again

@@peterwilliams6361 Hi , please who is the expert assisting you and how do I reach out to them?

@@DavidVelasquez9 The broker I'm in touch with is *ASHLEY AIRAGAHI . I came across her in a Bloomberg interview and got in touch with her. You can use something else. For me, her strategy works hence my result. She provides entry and exit point for the securities I focus on

@@peterwilliams6361 Thanks for sharing, I just looked her up online and I would say she really does have an impressive background on investing

thank you ? why the hell do we need to know this ? imagine their families hearing this ?

@@nikkimclay5474 thank you! My thoughts exactly.

@@amandab806 its shocking isnt it, beyond humane

🤢

@Mimi ty, it's so freaking sad and unfair 💔

Exactly! But nobody here appears to even get that! It's INCREDIBLE. Makes me sad and dumbfounded!

@@mirosderegil exactly 💯 😢😢😢

There was the talking, dog bark, SCUFFLE, THUD TO THE FLOOR and WHIMPER sounds... All heard many feet away across the parking lot on the neighbors security camera! It was heard in the house by any survivor too.

If you think Xana didn’t scream while having a knife cut her fingers, while she is defending herself, and just seen her bf get his mf neck slashed, you’re naive as hell.

The affidavit doesn’t say “DM didn’t hear screams.” It lists a few things she heard and saw, but there will inevitably be more to the story that comes out at trial. Also real life is not always like horror films where people scream bloody murder at the top of their lungs. Sometimes people go into shock or just start fighting back or cry or have other responses. We have to wait until trial to get the full picture.

That's what's really confusing because there were survivors that didn't call the police til later that day..how did she not hear this?

Exactly.

Yes!! Thank you!

Or he could have been on his way to the bathroom to take a piss after a heavy night of drinking. Jesus, you people just assume shit and make up wild stories in your own heads.

If that's true than the surviving girl in the same floor would be even more sus

@@irenesara455 Just stop.

It was a 'no contact' delivery. The driver wasn't met at the door, they just left the food.

Nah… he was already IN the house prior to 4 am, when DoorDash dropped off food. I think he was either already there lying in wait when the kids came home from their outings OR he snuck in once they were all home and in their rooms - very likely at least one door or sliding glass door was left unlocked. The UnSub had a plan and went with it. Hopefully an actual timeline will come to fruition during a trial.

@@adeleferguson663 no he wasn’t if you read the affidavit they have him on surveillance at 4:04 am still driving. And it says that he left through the sliding glass door on the second floor so I’m assuming that’s how he entered as well.

@@adeleferguson663 UnSub? You must watch a lot of Criminal Minds. Anyway, the Sub is certainly no longer Un.

@@allendracabal0819 , while I agree with the general consensus that the guy that has been arrested may very well be the guilty party, I also agree with hearing all the undisputed proof as to why he is THE ONE who actually committed these crimes. In this world we now live in where we are all tracked in some manner or another, one would think the average joe would have at least some “clue” that his moves, calls, locations, can be tracked. BK was a criminology student working towards a doctorate (or masters?). Either way, he cannot be an imbecile to get to that point. IF he is the Un, then he’s either a lot dumber than the average person OR had some psychotic disorder that he hid for many years. This crime makes zero sense. Why that house? Why those girls? - poor Ethan was just in the wrong place at the worst time. I agree it looks bad for this guy. He was in the same area, was allegedly seen by others on that campus when that was not the college he attended, found the girls on their Instagram and actually messaged one a few times. How stalker-ish is that weirdness? It’s going to be nearly impossible to find a jury of this guys peers who has zero clue as to what’s been said and/or speculated on. His lawyers will be busy trying to get him freed on technicality.

Correct, 11-22. Address: 1122 is what caught my attention

the affidavid confirms the witness heard crying from her room.

Dumb question. Why doesn't Xana get off of Tik Tok and call 9-1-1?

@Abdou Touzani 'Thought' she heard crying...It apparently wasn't loud enough or concerning enough to the roommate...I Would think if she was fighting for her life, possibly saw her man being kxlled...there would of been a lot more than 'thought she heard crying' going on..ya know!? It's all so devastating 😔

@@orangehoof I’m sure she was in shock & it probably happened so fast. This is tragic and I feel so sad that she saw Ethan being attacked before she passed away. 🙏🏻

@@orangehoof she probably didn’t have time and probably most likely wasn’t Evan on tik-tok. Like they say!!

This is so sad to hear😢

@@bridget999 I agree, It certainly is 😢💔

@@Sean_B_ yes very sad but who are these sources the information came from? Can we believe this? I don't know.

@@tami.1111 She says sources with knowledge of the investigation, I believe, but she didn’t say who or which sources, so I don’t know unfortunately.

No. D_eath penalty. I dont want my tax money going to feed him. That or let him starve. Idc

🩷💖🩷🩷

You mean bryan kohberger was in that house

Justice would be just a grain of respite for what the loved ones are going through. The horror this man has subjected hundreds of loved ones and also the community at large is immeasurable. What an EGO to want to be so famous for such an atrocity. And he's done it. Everyone is talking about this. I just can't get over the surrealness of the 4 young people's murders. They went to bed and now they are gone. My love and compassion to all affected.🧡🕊️🙏

I was thinking the same thing

If he would have knocked on Xanas door, DM would have heard that.

@@outoftime7740 You think? Apparently she can't hear too well at all. I'm sure Xana screamed as loud as she could watching BK kill stab her Ethan.

@@boycee1 You don't know that. If Xana screamed as loud as she could. Obviously she didn't. Bethany heard nothing. So stop punishing DM for seeing him.

She's only a nurse the testimony will come from the medical doctors she is not qualified to determine the cause of death just report the findings of the medical doctors

@@mischaraine1645 Bingo

I can’t get over Dylan’s actions or lack there of. I’ve read numerous comments defending her actions as “fight or flight” response. Dylan didn’t fight nor did she flee. She simply went back into her room and failed to do anything. Had she locked herself in her bedroom and waited an hour? I would be a bit more sympathetic.