We test the NOCO Genius 2. I have been asked about the NOCO 2 so I bought one to have a look and see how well it works.
Пікірлер: 54
@captiveimage2 жыл бұрын
Exactly what I was looking for. Battery charges are two a penny, and lots of them claim desulfation processes. Seeing that this charger actually appears to is good to see. The detailed analysis of the output characteristics is exactly what I wanted too. There's loads of people out there 'reviewing' this device, but it's limited to 'will it charge a battery', which is a given really. Sticking the battery on the sharp end of a desktop PSU will charge the battery, so it's not much of a test. Having seen that this unit is doing the do as advertised, happy to splash the cash. So, thanks for the very informative and interesting clip. Did you build the battery emulator yourself? Impressive bit of kit regardless.
@razenby2 жыл бұрын
Glad you found it useful. You are right - you can charge a car starting battery with any cheap charger or power supply . The profile of the charge and the accuracy of the set voltages are is more important for repeatedly cycled leisure batteries or battery maintenance applications. The battery emulator is just an adaption of the test system I wrote to check my switch mode power supply designs. It can load cycle and the DC side, cycle the AC mains voltage, subject the UUT to mains input dips, brown-outs and over-voltage surges. The Schaffner transient burst generator injects up to 4KV spikes in the mains line. You would be surprised how many bit of consumer kit are easily destroyed during real-world mains simulation tests!!
@markjones84373 жыл бұрын
Another great vid !
@razenby3 жыл бұрын
Thanks.
@josemedeiros0077 ай бұрын
Good video, great information.
@razenby7 ай бұрын
Glad it was helpful!
@markdauncey9273 жыл бұрын
Good to see a charger that knows what it's doing - not having to restart manually is a good idea. I like the pulse charge at lower voltages which ought to do a decent job of cleaning up the plates of a discharged battery. Looks like it would carry on for as long as needed on a real battery. Presumably their 5A charger (better for a normal sized battery that has discharged significantly) does the same. It's good that it doesn't assume that sub 7 volt from the battery means it's a 6V battery. This one is really only a maintenance charger.
@razenby3 жыл бұрын
Yes, seems good. I have one problem to investigate as I saw the output go wild couple f times. It doesn't like and capacitance connected across the probes at which point is does strange things. Neglecting the traditional output filter inductor and employing an Aluminium Polymer cap in its place the output filter is maybe an innovation too far. If connected to a battery and nothing else it seems to work but if any part of connected device has a capacitor it does strange things. When I get to the bottom of it I will release a video.
@The_Last_Post3 жыл бұрын
@@razenby did you get to the bottom of this problem? How are you getting on with the charger, as I’m after buying one
@razenby3 жыл бұрын
@@The_Last_Post It has been maintaining our JAG in the garage. Seems to work OK. Hasn't failed,. Probably turned on for 5 weeks straight so far. The one I have here is lacking an inductive filter one the output side. It doesn't like capacitive loads across the clips.. Works OK with the car connected. I didn't investigate further.
@The_Last_Post3 жыл бұрын
@@razenby thank you for replying so quickly, interesting about the inductive filter. Does that mean it was missing from the factory or it could do with one fitting? Would be good to know what type/value needs fitting and where. I understand if you’re not interested in further investigation
@skysurferuk3 жыл бұрын
Just found you, great content. Thanks! Subbed.
@razenby3 жыл бұрын
Welcome aboard!
@Rob-wx2rq10 ай бұрын
Your videos are excellent and I wish I had the test equipment you have available at hand. It would be great to see you do a deep dive analysis of the Schumacher SC1280 / SC1323 battery charger. Not sure if they make or sell a version in the UK? Best regards and thank you for producing these great technical analysis videos.🥇
@razenby10 ай бұрын
Maybe one day! Ill get back onto it soon. I have been designing high efficiency 300W switch mode power supplies for use in horticultural lighting but that is done now..
@josemedeiros0077 ай бұрын
Why do you want a Schumacher charger? I have a older 1 amp Schumacher manual charger I bought in 2012, and a Schumacher 2/10/50 amp manual charger I bought in the 1990's. As far as I know Schumacher automatic chargers do not have a desulfate mode like Noco, CTEK and Pulse Tech chargers do. Noco also has a force mode to charge a battery that is below 1 volt, most SMART battery chargers will not charge a battery at that voltage level, and a good reason to buy a Noco Genius charger or have a older manual charger to get the battery voltage up first.
@Rich38623 жыл бұрын
I have AGM batt in my car. Voltage while car is running/charging sits anywhere from 14.4 - to 14.7. So I believe this is a great charger. Every now and then based on voltage and ambient temp the voltage would jump and sit around 14.9 - 15.1 for desulfation.
@razenby3 жыл бұрын
If the battery is good, and the voltages maintained then why regularly etch the plates with desulfation if it isn't required.? Seems a destructive thing to do - Anyone think this is a good idea?
@diy_Lab3 жыл бұрын
Thank you 👍
@razenby3 жыл бұрын
Pleased you found it useful.
@jrm1632 жыл бұрын
Could you please do an analysis on the Battery Tender by Deltran? It’s an interesting one! Though the manufacturer explicitly denied their products having desulfurization function on Amazon, I find the tender delivers pulses in maintenance mode, which essentially is a desulfurizer in my opinion. I don’t have more advanced equipment to dig more into it, but their products are very popular, even more popular than Noco. Thanks!
@razenby2 жыл бұрын
Thanks for the tip. I will look out for one. After testing my view is that reviving a modern battery by Desuplhation is an urban myth based on the old very heavy, built like tank, not sealed, wet cell lead acid batteries. They did respond. However modern, car starting VRLA batteries are made to be as light as possible and to last out the warranty . Desuplhation is more likely to do further damage. See the other comments.
@jrm1632 жыл бұрын
@@razenby I think it really depends! Nowadays the lead wet batteries are built with different qualities: the more expensive, the better. Walmart EverStart Maxx series comes with 3 years free replacement, and can easily get 6-7 years life. The VRLA batteries are more designed to fail on cars, as you can’t even maintain them! And if they sat in the engine compartment, the heat would dry them out prematurely! AGM batteries are of this type!
@jrm1632 жыл бұрын
@@razenby Another interesting thing is this: kzfaq.info/get/bejne/geB_hKti2d3UeWw.html , and seems to be effective in extending wet lead battery life. How do you think please?
@jrm1632 жыл бұрын
@@razenby BTW, the Battery Tender Junior model is the most popular one! The old version is hard to find, since it has been replaced with a newer version.
@SteveSnowman Жыл бұрын
Great info, thanks. BTW, I just bought a NOCO GBX75 if you are looking for more content ;-) I've been binge watching Magic Smoke lately too.
@razenby Жыл бұрын
I haven't had much success with the reliability of the jumper packs that I bought. Let me know how you get on with the NOCO GBX75 . Thanks for watching.
@valleynomad2 жыл бұрын
Interesting video.
@razenby2 жыл бұрын
Thanks for the visit
@valleynomad2 жыл бұрын
@@razenby I just got an NOCO Genius 2 for my BMW 328 which has an 8-year old 90AH AGM battery. However, it acts somewhat different from what in your video. It has stuck in the first 25% stage for 5 hours even though the voltage was already 12V when charging started. According to your video, the charger should output at least 1.5A constant current at that voltage with a total charging power around 18W. But mine seems to send out smaller current in pulses as I can see that the 110V AC side input power varies between 1W and 4W (I use a portable power station with an AC outlet and wattage display). The average charging power is about only 2.5W... Update: Now it works fine with about 2A output current after I repositioned the clips. The charger seems to be sensitive to any resistance in connections. It even refused to charge when I tried to use my Fluke77 to measure output current.
@btfd13373 жыл бұрын
Thank you for your videos. Any harm in using a Noco 2 vs Noco 5 to occasionally top off and maintain a larger 90ah lead acid car battery? I've got a car garaged that gets driven once a week or two, so just looking to top off the battery every so often. Speed of the charge doesn't matter to me - more concerned about what's best to use for the health of the battery. Thanks in advance for your help.
@razenby3 жыл бұрын
There is no issue - It will work fine. In fact it will do a better job on maintaining a large battery as only small currents are required and accuracy is more important. I maintain my 120 aH Jaguar battery whilst is isn't being used.
@valleynomad2 жыл бұрын
@@razenby Is it safe to say that even Noco Genius 1 will work fine for maintaining such big battery?
@naughtyprimez3 жыл бұрын
Hay there, im looking for a charger for two cars, one is a 45ah and the other is 60ah. would this genius 2 do the job? To keep the batteries in good condition. I try and alternate the cars, but one will probably be sat for a week or so before a run out. what do you think?
@razenby3 жыл бұрын
The genius 2 is slow but would get you there for both batteries and maintain either well. In any case the battery supplier recommends only a 3A charge current for this size battery.
@pacmancalgary3 жыл бұрын
This is far too technical for someone like myself, but I suspect the intended audience is much smarter than me. Will this charger work for a 6v AGM battery? I know Noco makes one for 6v AGM but it's significantly more expensive. Also, would this be adequate to charge a full sized car battery that has been run down due to leaving the lights on in the car for a few days or would I have to at least go for the Noco Genius 5 amp model? My preference would be the 2 if it works as they are on for a good price right now.
@razenby3 жыл бұрын
Hi James, the force mode on the NOCO should recover the battery. Disconnect it from the car first. However the battery will be ruined if the voltage at the terminals has dropped bellow 11V for any length of time. Even a few hours is enough to severely damage it. The 2 amp charger is excellent for small batteries (~50aH) as the charge current is within the manufacturers specification which is usually 3 Amps. The AGM mode is for 12V batteries only. AGM uses a higher charge current for longer and has a higher termination voltage. You could connect 2 x 6V AGM in series.
@josemedeiros0077 ай бұрын
I am fairly sure that only the Noco Genius 10 has a 6volt AGM mode to charge with, and they are $99.00 dollars on Amazon, but they also have a repair mode, and can be used as a 12 volt power supply.
@diycarguy62413 жыл бұрын
Hi. What was the open circuit voltage of the battery BEFORE you started charging? Thx.
@diycarguy62413 жыл бұрын
Nevermind. I hear later on that this is a being done on a test rig, not an actual battery. I believe the initial desulphation pulse stage only occurs on batteries below a certain OCV.
@razenby3 жыл бұрын
@@diycarguy6241 I believe the initial pulse charge when the OC battery voltage is low (~
@diycarguy62413 жыл бұрын
For lithium, I should have said withOUT any repair or desulphation)
@razenby3 жыл бұрын
It may be the right thing to do but a right pain if you are impatient to go to work and the battery has just discharged coz the light have been left on. Makes you wonder what damage is done to a low battery that is jump started and then driven and subjected to the alternator.
@diycarguy62413 жыл бұрын
Normal = 14.4V, AGM = 14.7, :Lithium =14.5 (with any repair or desulphation disabled)
@razenby3 жыл бұрын
At 25 degrees C?
@user-ew3qj5sn2p2 ай бұрын
I wonder if it will repair a flat battery
@razenbyАй бұрын
Depends how flat, The flatter for longer the less likely that it will make any difference. ...
@markellis42292 жыл бұрын
Have you tested top don battery chargers yet
@razenby2 жыл бұрын
Nope, never heard of them.
@markellis4229 Жыл бұрын
@@razenby I’m surprise you haven’t because people rave about them Top Don tornado 4000 it would be really interesting if get a sample of one of them one day because you give a really honest review about products
@razenby Жыл бұрын
@@markellis4229 If someone sends me one I'll test it. Ravers usually rave about their purchase to assure themselves that they made the correct choice so feel good about it. No doubt it was better than their impression is a subjective and not real-world.
@markellis4229 Жыл бұрын
I do really like your channel you really do know what your about with electrical and electronic items .one of my relatives had the same knowledge as you and I was the only one in my family what was so interested to try and learn from him but I don’t have the luxury no more because he s not there so I’m glad Iv have fond your channel 2 years ago
@jusb10663 жыл бұрын
This charger at least is competent, not worth 50 quid though, wish they skip the charging modes , and just work when you plug it in
@razenby3 жыл бұрын
The early LEDs relate to a deeply discharged battery. Have a look at the curves in the next video (release later) you can see the Noco charge cycle. i.e. It may not be a fault that it rams up to throbbing green end light as this is the normal bulk charge for a safely depleted battery.