+bellerophon30 if not the best ever...

bellerophon30 he like a musician and a stand up comedian in one.

that would actually have been a godlike reply

I'm glad I got into them while they were still together, about the time of Standing on the Shoulders, but hopefully they will reunite someday... somehow!!!

was wicked back then oasis all the way man wivalvwy pmsl

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Stereotype23 Now look at him....

est r!

voice of the beehive simon and garfunkel joy order for three

I forgot van hagar

+brian smth sam and dave equally sucked

+brian smth and pink floyd had three for a couple of gigs and genesis had two fine vocalists

Liam always seemed like a Twat with the spoilt child attitude. Noel always seemed more down to earth and no crap about him.

Yeah that's it, I'd say Liam's the catalyst of a lot of it. Noel seems cheerie and laid back. He seems the better guy.

@@owenfitzgerald8944 Noel holds a grudge though. Liam misses Noel and wants him back in his life.

+mynameisdudge he doesnt run the account, so technically "he" is not on twitter

Believe it or not, his voice has gotten even worse. Watch Beady Eye live at the 2013 T in the park or Ibiza Rocks from last year. The biggest issue with another tour will be Liam's voice is fucked after only a few shows.

***** You make a good point about age influencing singers as they get older. I remember listening to/watching Robert Plant during the Led Zeppelin Celebration Day concert, particularly during Stairway, and he just can't get to those notes anymore....and to his credit, he didn't try. He sang the entire song in a lower register, and it sounded great. Different, but great. With Liam, who knows, he was never a good singer, the wrong brother was the singer, it should have been Noel the entire time.

bellerophon30 Liam's sound defines Oasis, and he was a much better singer than Noel until around '98ish

***** You raise some great points, and the only way I can disagree is by simply saying that I just don't really dig the sound of Liam's voice. It's a matter of pure taste, and leaves aside all the other factors. Noel wrote great songs that would have been better served by a more skilled vocalist. It's an accident of course, one assumes that he wrote the lyrics to bend to his brother's talents, but it's true, for me. Noel's solo album is better, for me, than his Oasis stuff primarily because I'd rather listen to him than Liam, even though nothing on it is as good as Wonderwall or Supersonic (or my sneaky favorite Lyla). But I do concede your other points. What I would love to know is the reason that Beady Eye broke up, one wonders if Liam's solo record will be available sometime in the next year or so.

bellerophon30 Apparently from some of Noel's latest interviews Liam's given up the "music game" & is concentrating on Pretty Green and that Beatles movie he was producing. I think it's probably a good decision as sales for BE were atrocious, actually sold less than DGSS, which is hard to believe but true unfortunately. They broke up coz they just weren't a "going concern" business wise......in other words making a loss financially. I've seen both Beady Eye and NGHFB's live in the same venue in Sydney and there's absolutely no doubt who the better band was/is........Noel's concert was INCREDIBLE!!!!!! I had NG withdrawal symptoms for 3 - 4 days afterwards. Liam was in good form but their songs just didn't cut it. I agree with u regarding Liam as a vocalist.....he was never really a "classic" rock vocalist say in the style of Freddie Mercury, Roger Daltry, Elvis or Robert Plant.....he never had the range or technique and in some instances his vocals were quite whiney, nasally and frankly annoying.......but for him it was more about the 'style', snarl & swagger rather than the technique. He comes more from the school of Johnny Rotten, Bob Dylan, John Lennon, Neil Young etc.....in other words not great vocalists but had a certain individual style and "sound" that was all their own and made them stand out from the crowd.

It's called The Wrong Beach by Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds.

(Stranded On) The Wrong Beach

betpow well Jonathan Ross used to work for the BBC for a long time, and now does a chat program for ITV and this was early years which was why Noel said "i'll reform Oasis once you get back on the BBC" hehe! :)

Yuri muckraker thank you

betpow no problem! your very welcome :)

betpow what the kumars of No. 42? i dont understand ????

Eloquently put

pizzaDhut Well I wanted to be as clear and concise as I could.

You certainly have been! Although had you wanted to be accurate you would not have called him a working class hero but a talentless moron who is truly not worth listening to. Nice hair though.

It's you that replied to my comment not the other way. But you got one thing right, he's rich......and he's Labour, which means he's a hypocrite. The fact he has no talent is possibly a coincidence, but actually most Labour supporters have no talent, or ability, or morals.

he was now he hates all of the main parties equally as we all should because they're all mongs