No video

Oshi no Ko and how NOT to portray a mental health crisis | Video Essay

  Рет қаралды 761

Tommylmao

Tommylmao

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 19
@Tommylmao
@Tommylmao 4 ай бұрын
Thank you for watching! More anime video essays can be found here kzfaq.info/sun/PLshwllJZkgbrU21AkPkj_mxGdiDaPPrpZ&si=7vIvvbmYr4sWNdPS
@Lazar-TS
@Lazar-TS 4 ай бұрын
BIG CRITICISM against this video: The friend group going "you had us worried 😭You should've confronted us about it so we could have helped!!!" is *'textbook* victim blaming' and wrong?!? Victim blaming here would be "You deserved to get harrased for inflicting a face scratch on Yuki!", which did NOT happen. 4:37 You partially misunderstood Aqua's character at first... He always cared deeply (NOT AT ALL OPENLY) for the people around him since the first time we see him (as Gorou Amamiya). Dismissing that because of the "dark determination" facade is a bit wrong. He protected Ruby with the fake phone call, wore the silly-ass duck mask AND imitated the goofy voice, just to help the group (and mainly Kana) improve It's also why it would make less sense for him to support Akane emotionally. As established, he's not direct with his support, and whilst other members may have been there for her, he instead focused on helping her *practically* by clearing her name, with his *skills* as a video editor. I don't see why you critique this as it would fall more in line with your former impression of Aqua's character. Next, you admit yourself that medical practice and psychology are ENTIRELY different things... then state that there's enough overlap for a GYNECOLOGIST to be able to help a suicidal person's mental state? If anything, if you wanted to give it a stretch like that, he should've been able to perform first-aid on Ai when she got stabbed, but even that didn't happen. Aqua confronting the director literally WAS his way of helping Akane. I don't know what you expected him to do... Call her, get her adress, visit her and give her a massage and a kiss on the cheek?? The reason blame falls upon the director is because he's in charge of what parts of the show to portray and how to portray it, and (this is literally stated) he chose to portray Akane as a villainess to create an 'interesting rivalry'. She was basically pressured into it (part of the pressure stemming from her manager). The management not dealing with the backlash directed towards Akane was the cherry on top. Also the director was likely just the easiest person to reach at that moment (and it's a lot easier when it comes to storyboarding). Lastly, as someone who's undergone a suicide attempt myself (with someone being there to stop me), once I've experienced my life take a turn for the better, I've become A LOT more resistant to suicidal thoughts. I can only project onto Akane, but this is how I would explain it. Once she's been saved, you see her be sorry for what she's done, she GETS ASKED (by Aqua iirc) whether she wants to continue, to which she *agrees.* Her friends then also *help* her by creating that edit, as well as proposing the idea of "playing a character to protect herself". This support is what I think helped and sped up the process of her getting to a better place. So yeah, Akane doesn't just "shrug off the same traumatic environment", there's actually been a lot at play here. Oh, and: THAT STALKER INCEL ain't NOBODY'S DAD 😭😭 I doubt bro had a fatherfigure himself 💀 (Rather manipulated by the actual "father" to kill Ai, where the first time he failed and Gorou died as casualty. I get it, you meant that the guy was indirectly responsible for their death, but that just sounded so wrong...) Thanks for actually reading. This one was quite lengthy. TL;DR: Akane is best girl. Go watch *[Oshi no Ko].*
@user-hg7tj6kn1i
@user-hg7tj6kn1i 4 ай бұрын
i simply cannot agree more as also i would like to add a another arguement, the director that aqua argeues to you said is well not completly oof the hook but not in the most wrong well i disragee because well they could have just NOT USED THE SCENE and not only does he have no guilt in his mind but also so laughing and you tell me thats not wrong? or did you just not watch the anime lol and yeah he also made it so akane was looking like the villan, over all great comment and this is one of the worse video essays that i have honestly every watched and im not the pearson to leave hate like ever, but this is honestly just to bad not to make a comment on but i do think the resolution ark but come on what do you expect like three episodes on recovery? please make a response to explaine yourself like jeez this is actually making me mad.
@buihoanglong6053
@buihoanglong6053 4 ай бұрын
While I think the show was a bit fast on the resolution of the arc, I feel Aqua still cares for Akane after the arc, since they started “dating” and hang out together more. Aqua has been having his dark emo personality ever since his mother dies so he wouldn’t try to save her right away, and I think the reason Aqua was there for the very last second is because he’s representing our desire to save Hana Kimura in real life, if we had been there to save her. Overall, great video!
@Yuni_VO
@Yuni_VO 4 ай бұрын
first 🫣
@topfranluis1
@topfranluis1 4 ай бұрын
Thank god I didn’t start watching it
@Lazar-TS
@Lazar-TS 4 ай бұрын
Bro what?!?1 It's like the best thing we've gotten in years.
@topfranluis1
@topfranluis1 4 ай бұрын
@@Lazar-TS JoJos Bizarre Adventure is right there, dude. Also, having you so vigorously defend such an incest heavy show is kinda weird
@Lazar-TS
@Lazar-TS 4 ай бұрын
@@topfranluis1 I've watched JJBA. I've been a fan for a long time. Also, incest heavy??? What? You're the one who has brought this into discussion. That sounds a lot like projecting. You're the bizarre one. Besides, you don't even know that because you haven't seen it... I'm not defending, I'm straight up debunking baseless arguments such as the one you've just made...
@topfranluis1
@topfranluis1 4 ай бұрын
@@Lazar-TS Buddy, you literally came in here and called this show the objectively best of all time, you’re absolutely defending. And after watching this video, there’s no way I’m gonna be watching it anyway. Why did you even click on this video if you’re gonna shame other people for not thinking that this is the best show of all time?
@Lazar-TS
@Lazar-TS 4 ай бұрын
@@topfranluis1 I'm sorry, don't put words in my mouth, I said neither objectively nor of all time. "In years" doesn't mean of all time since the beginning of the universe, it literally means within 2-3 years. And that was AN OPINION (thus subjective). Learn to read before writing, learn to understand opinions before having them 🙏 I'm not shaming anyone ffs, it's called a suggestion. You know, like when JoJo fans infamously suggest their beloved series to the point of obnoxiousness, just as you did in your first reply? Like dude, if you're gonna pull stuff out of your ass just to hate, just go back to twitter.
[SPECIAL EPISODE] Blade Tells Kafka to Sit on His Face
0:21
The CUTEST flower girl on YouTube (2019-2024)
00:10
Hungry FAM
Рет қаралды 3,5 МЛН
Whoa
01:00
Justin Flom
Рет қаралды 48 МЛН
Analyzing Usada Pekora and Hakos Baelz's INSANE CHESS GAME!
17:51
What your backpack says about you!
8:20
MVPerry
Рет қаралды 12 М.
Addressing The WORST Fairly Oddparents Video on YouTube
19:24
Alpha Jay Show
Рет қаралды 126 М.
Angsty Girl Bands Bonanza
14:49
Vlusky the Husky
Рет қаралды 1,2 М.
The Controversial Politics of Persona 5 | Video Essay
10:27
Tommylmao
Рет қаралды 2,6 М.
Hollywood's Obsession with Ambition
22:12
Thomas Flight
Рет қаралды 115 М.
/vt/ - Vtuber Thread Simulator 3.0
6:35
Tommylmao
Рет қаралды 3,1 М.
Narrative Complexity in My Dress-Up Darling | Video Essay
9:39
Tommylmao
Рет қаралды 1,2 М.