Being a union member I can tell you that there was a period where the unions were overreaching in their demands. I can also tell you that is no longer the case. We want to make a living and to be able to support our families. Somehow conservatives have painted union as wanting too much and making the US anti-competitive in the world; that average worker salaries should not be based on a minimum amount, but the lowest amount a manufacturer can get away with paying - while still giving bailouts and low interest loans to corporations and the wealthy that far exceed that of all those workers combined. We need to change people's minds about what unions are and what they actually do for the common worker.

Starting to wish I didn't choose "working class" as the phrase for my drinking game today

Dr Phil dodging a red hot bullet at the end. 😂

Dr Phil admitting that he’s part of the “eff your feelings” gang… “I barely care about my own feelings.” 🙌

Polyamory. I don't want two people being permanently angry at me.

I wish the audience stoped applauding, gets in the way all the time of the discussion etc.. frustrating

I was a supervisor for several years at a major hospital system. You literally are forced to take anti-union training. Whatever you want to call it. How to report organization, what to say and not to say. They made it abundantly clear they will not be negotiating with any union. Edit: Which by the way should be a huge red flag to regular employees. A corporation doesn’t go to lengths to try to bust something before it even happens if they don’t fear it for some reason. If they don’t want it and are afraid it, it’s probably in your best interest to want it.

Would never have imagined it, but Dr Phil and Bill Mahar should get a show. The way they combine and antagonize the other on issues is hilarious 😂

Whoever this Batya woman is kept asking if we were better off four years ago in 2018. Four years ago was 2020

Batya missed the main reason why unions are less popular now. That is due to Ronald Reagan’s union busting, specifically of PATCO. I wish someone mentioned this in the show.

I am a member of the union. And at least in my industry, some of these unions aren’t interested in the benefits of the workers they supposedly support, rather they provide the company with workers. Unions are good in theory but they come with a host of issues themselves.

Maher and Dr. Phil make a first-class comedy duo.

Best ending of overtime ever 😂

Been a union member over 40 years, good wages, medical, and a pension.

"I don't care how you feel, I barely care how I feel. I'm talking about the facts." Well said.

I’m a Union member and as a member I find it so unfair that an immigrant becomes a Union member just by buying their way in, while the us citizen has to be built through apprenticeship and go through the ruff times while the unskilled migrants get the top benefits

Tim, button up your shirt, you look like a budget version of Tony Soprano.

Bill and Phil - new duo! Great together. 😊 Bravi, great show!

Go Dr. Phil . Smart guy and takes no BS.

Dr. Phil is so much cooler when he's not walking on eggshells.

dang dr phil doesnt look like he can even move his face anymore

With regard to workers and unions, Tim and Batya are BOTH right. Tim is correct that Republicans have been working to diminish and undermine worker rights and unions for DECADES. But Batya is also correct that Democrats have all but abandoned them -- not just over immigration but because they've switched their focus from economics to demographics. They've become obsessed with "minorities" and "diversity" and have almost entirely forgotten courting WORKING CLASS people (their former base), REGARDLESS of color or demographic category.

Watching Dr. Phil dunk on Maher has made my day

Batya Ungar-Sargon, my new hero!

Dr Phil got it right. Some questions are just too stupid to answer.

Regarding the Unions, they're both right . Republicans have been waging war on them for decades, and Unions took a immigration policy stance that directly hurts their members

100% right on Batya!

America first! 🇺🇸

My first job was a retail job at a big national retail chain, and I remember expecting the onboarding training videos to be about the history of the company and about the company's distinctive culture; instead they were about the danger of unions, how unions would be bad for the employees, and about employees' responsibilities to report and stop any potential union-organizing activities they hear about or encounter, or risk losing their job

Regarding Bills point about the SCOTUS delay of the Trump immunity case, I was disappointed that the elephant in the room wasn’t addressed. That being why did Jack Smith and Merrick Garland wait until 2023 to indict Trump. Truth is they delayed it way too long and this could have been settled by now.

Batya absolutely dominated🔥🔥

We need more legal immigration and less illegal immigration.

So obvious Dr Phil has been on tv for years. Definitely better than most guests

I was a union supporter since I was a child, coming from generations of blue collar union members. I was a union member until I discovered that my union had fixed a union election, called my union rep about it, and he screamed at me about all that the union had done for me, and hung up. Then, when I needed help, they were useless. I left the union and have not joined another.

First time I've ever seen or heard of this lady, but I'd be fine never hearing her try to yell every point she has ever again.

The lady is 100% correct and spot on. It happened to a lot of us in Georgia & TN because of migrants. I will be voting for Trump, the borders need to be closed. It pisses me & other Americans off! We are fed up with it too! It shows in our votes on super Tuesday!

Dr phil is launching his own tv station in April so he's looking for viewers on all sides. So now he is taking out of both sides of his mouth

Right to work doesn't ban unions, it just means you can't be forced to join a union just to work somewhere that has a union.

Phil hasn't been a doctor for years, that's never stopped him from bloviating!

Bill Maher and Phil McCraw are fucking hilarious together. Put them on a show

Dr Phil and Bill Maher need their own show together. Hilarious.

Bravo. Truth is beautiful

The public in this show applauds anything...

Geez.. the clapping is unbearable..

I hated how bill cut off Tim to ask that stupid question to Dr phil at the end, which he didn't even try to answer.. Tim was saying something important

i actually loved dr phil's answer

Thanks God we had Bantya in the panel, a light of knowledge and truth. Telling Bill all the show that he was wrong in so many issues was priceless.

According to the American Psychological Association, approximately 40-50% of first marriages end in divorce. The divorce rate for second marriages is even higher, with approximately 60-67% of second marriages ending in divorce.

Under Biden, the auto workers got one of the best deals ever, increased wages and working conditions. Unemployment is down, wages are up. Thanks Biden!

I hope Dr. Phil flossed after that Bill M snack .

Bill- this is what bothers me about when people make these pronouncements about the way another person lives their life- Dr. Phil- YOU ASKED ME! it took me out 😂

Fact check from Wikipedia.on the lady in red, 12% of the US workforce are union members, not 6%. mostly in govt. or law enforcement

Like the last question when everyone looked at Batya 😂

The minimum wage should be at least $20. Since 2009 CEOs salaries have increased by 400%. This is shameful. SPREAD THE WEALTH! 8:24

Dr Phil was literally my favorite guest EVER

I saw Dr Phil on Rogan talking about people living high on the hog when they're on foodstamps and unemployment. The way he misrepresented and flat out lied was remarkable.

You don’t take a cognitive test unless their is a concern. Dr. Phil and Dr. Oz have become a joke.

Natural gas is being replaced by lower cost solar and wind power

She just can't stop losing her s***.

I saw the episode where he read out the quote by the Jack Posobiec quote - "We're here to overthrow democracy completely, we almost got it done on J6, but we will endeavor to get rid of it and replace it with this right here (holds up a cross)" to the applause and "amens" of the crowd and co speakers. Batya Ungar-Sargon tried to dismiss this quote during the discussion as though Jack were joking, but it really does not seem at all that he, or the crowd is joking in the video.

I love watching Dr. Phil put Bill in his place.

I wish my politicians sounded like Batya

Whoa!!! Batya Unyar-Sargon👍🏻

Maher and Dr Phil should have a show together. As they are so different. Their pre show interview was funny.

this is most pro republican show claiming to be balanced FYI UNIONS DON'T HIRE ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS AND CAR MAKERS ARE MOSTLY UNION IN THE NORTH

4 millionaires thinking they know what's best for common Americans. I need a show where 4 people making 50-100k are treated as experts on what's best for rich people.

Dr Phil got RIGHT under Bill's skin... That was entertaining

The people of ohio made a big mistake not electing ryan to the senate. JD Vance, are you kidding me

Batya Ungar-Sargon is head-and-shoulders smarter and more articulate than anyone else sitting at the table.

Thank goodness Batya is here

She has the facts wrong about the Teamsters-they haven’t given the RNC $45K. I’m a Teamster and we just had a meeting the other day. The $45K is still sitting on the Teamsters desk. They explained that it’s just put aside so the Teamsters can attend and have a presence at the RNC convention. They feel it’s important that we attend and have a presence of members at both the DNC & RNC conventions this year. $45K is just the amount put aside to make that happen at the RNC convention. There’s another amount put aside for the DNC convention too.

One of my friend's is a union worker at tva ( a plant that provides power/electricity.) He worked at the plant for 47 years. An undocumented immigrant was hired. My friend's hours got cut down to part-time. The migrant got 40 hrs plus over-time hours making less wages than my friend. My friend was loyal to the company for 47 solid years, a very hard worker, never missed work, and was laid off. He had to just retire early, be cause the union and tva screwed my friend. Also, the migrant hit my friend several times. Bosses did nothing about it! The truth! The lady on this show is spot on correct to what happens to union and loyal American workers! The average American blue collar worker. Close the borders! Americans lose our jobs, get lower wages, and get screwed over by migrants, & our companies/employers hiring the migrants for less wages to save the company money! Open borders and migrants kill our jobs & wages! Truth! We are fed up with it too! I will be voting for Trump, because he completely understands this problem!

Oh BOY!! This Woman is CLUELESS!! WOW!! Stupid talking points...

Dr. Phil is the f’ing GOAT lol

Godamit Bill, when she asks are we better off in 2018...the answer is YES. Record low unemployment, record high stock market, inflation getting better...just have the balls to answer her.

That woman was just so horrible in every way. Newsweek was once a credible news source.

free palestine

The final nail in the coffin for unions was pounded in by Ronald Reagan.....

Dr Phil totally discredited himself when he went all ....Jerry Springer on his program. I can't believe Bill Maher would be on the same show as him.

As a son of a union worker who dedicated 39 years of his life to the union and the end lost his job to foreigners. I really don't like union bosses I wish they go back and represent the working people.😢

This is the perfect moment to ditch the duopoly. Support 3rd parties and independents. Stop being held hostage by corrupt liars.

Don’t you love when your denied a job because you don’t speak a foreign language in America?

Tim Ryan got it right about the right to work states. Union busting started under Ronald Reagan.

Interesting to see Bill demand that Dr Phil be politically correct.

One thing I hate about bill is he does zero actual research nowadays. If writers don’t tell him he doesn’t know but he keeps talking like no one else knows either.

The cost of living is the problem not wages. Who controls the costs of living? Wall Street. Once Wall Street drives up prices, that gives a greenlight to privately held companies to do the same until it saturates the whole economy.

Unions have always supported the Democrat party not the union members!

Ryan, were YOU on that picket line?😮

Credit to Bill for bringing on three reasonable people

I’m convinced dr Phil is an alien

She's just regurgitating crap she read instead of actually going to the Unions and seeing for herself.

Auto workers will vote against Joe cuz of NAFTA? HUH! This woman is not on.

Bill single Dr.Phil married What one seems happier ?

Just last week a bunch of Google contractors made a union in Texas and demanded better conditions from Google. Google just laid off the entire team… Ironically while they were speaking publicly about how great they all did for forming a union to “speak truth to power”. … Well you spoke to power and power spoke back… Don’t get mad when it says something you don’t like. Everyone in the west has a consensual relationship with their employers, they don’t owe you a job and you don’t owe them your value. If you don’t like it, market your value somewhere else. I guess this is what happens when education changes focus from value to emotion.

The degree to which Maher is uninformed is astonishing!

Phillip Calvin McGraw the ultimate opportunist, if Opera Winfrey had not been called down to Texas to court for slamming the meat industry no one would ever know who Philip Mcgraw was or is

Fair play to Tim Ryan for standing his ground on unions.

Bill was close on the marriage statistic. STATS: 41% divorce rate in first marriages, 60% of second marriages, and over 70% of third marriages end in divorce. I first learned these stats watching Dr Phil.

Anyone who owns a business knows how horrible unions are.

Also, the UAW supports Biden, so there's that BATYA. Sheesh.