The defendant seems so nice, I can't even imagine him cursing the way he said he did. lol

The defendant is a very nice gentleman

The plaintiff doesn’t even know how a warranty work. I’m a mechanic and I promise you the plaintiff is wrong on all levels

Coming to court with absolutely no evidence 🚩🚩🚩🚩

I would take my vehicle to the defendant, he seems like such a nice guy. The southern accent is my favorite, it reminds me of home. ❤️

Defendant: the Auto Zone rep asked was he using it as a commercial vehicle. I said 🗣 🎙 “YES, BUT DON’T SAY ANYTHING, IT’LL VOID THE WARRANTY.” 😳😂 I love how the defendant DRY SNITCHED on the plaintiff. That was the plaintiff’s karma, broadcast in front of millions! 😂😂😂

The plaintiff creeps me out. Puts off a strong psycho vibe

He got an estimate and diagnosis from a shop that didn't even see the van. Does his own "oil consumption test" then tries to sue on an engine he has a warranty on. Don't understand why the plaintiff is even there.

JM gave the plaintiff ample amount of time to get proof of the errors. Defendant did nothing wrong in issuing that warranty.

I would have ZERO qualms about outing the plaintiff for using his vehicle commercially! He’s suing the guy! The gloves are off! 🤷🏽‍♀️

Defendant did excellent job of describing repair.

the defendant reminds me of my grandpa nice but will curse you tf out lol and tell your business on accident lmao

2003 Dodge Cavaran he should have just junked that garbage instead of changing the engine and transmission.

Plaintiff seems creepy as hell.

The plaintiff is out of his mind. Why didn't they speak with the hallway guy? 🤪😧😜😧🤪

I get King of the Hill vibes from the plaintiff's voice. Close your eyes and imagine Hank Hill! Damn it Bobby, get some propane!

This was such a waste of time. Have they never seen the show? Bring evidence, people.

i believe this mechanic...

The plaintiff came to court with hear-say as his only evidence. (ha ha ha). And if he has managed to drive such long distances (being a commercial vehicle), that his tyres are bald, then no wonder he is consuming oil. The plaintiff is too intense, I don't think this is over for him, if I was the defendant I would get a restraining order against him. The judge should have awarded the defendant something or else at least given a warning to the plaintiff about staying away from the defendant...

He revved up a controversy.

Oil consumption can kill a catalytic converter so if it was still good before the engine was replaced it's very possible that it does have excessive consumption, unfortunately, proving consumpton can be difficult. As for the warrantee, if he can't find a shop that will take it he needs to contact the warrantee company and if they can't find him a service provider they're the ones he needs to sue.

Plaintiff looks like he hasn't slept in a week.

I never ever ever EVER want to be around people like the plaintiff much less do business.

Wait...no Doug Llewellyn? No summary from Harvey? What's up with that?

i had a volkswagen like that once......GREAT gas mileage, but you had to put a quart of oil in every week.

Why spend so much money on such an old car?

He needs to document. It could be many things including valves. If it's RINGS he needs to do a COMPRESSION TEST which he did. Mechanic seemed reasonable. Customer seems angry and trying to get over on this professional. If vehicle was being used as a commercial vehicle, all bets are OFF. Guy has no proof at all that there is anything wrong with the car. Some customers are just difficult- seems to be the case here. That said, I don't trust most mechanics...at all. Recent one never rotated tires- I took pics before and after- not rotated. They lied to me to my face and charged me. Most are very dishonest. If you find a good one- value him/her. Judge got this right.

What a wonderful articulate man. Wow.

those "extended warranties" are actually service contracts. they dictate how the repair will be handled. a mechanic has to agree to the terms before any work is done. the mechanic has to do extactly what they tell them or not get paid. what the mechanic is told may not even fix the problem.

A quart of oil per 700 miles for a caravan is about right. Nothing wrong with that engine

The plaintiffs issues isn't the work that he had done on the van its the make and model of the van that's the issue. Unless both the transmission and engine were both brand new, if they are rebuilt he will forever have issues with this van. Dodge Caravans are notorious for tranny issues and their engines are just as bad.

13:40 Sounds like the plaintiff is the Dr. Jekyll / Mr. Hyde type OR a Bi-polar bear🐻‍❄ I'm glad the 🤩defendant🤩 came out on top. Now, get that man's beater van off your property asap. Have it towed and trespass him from your premises permanently, bro.💯

Codes for a cat can indeed be linked to oil issues. Could also be the reason for the smoke out of the tailpipe. There is alot more to oil issues than snap on and consumption tests. Nothing beats good old fashioned "just have a look".

You can’t be too smart still driving a caravan which is worth $1500 in mint condition. Also the oil lost could’ve been from a bad rear main seal.

Van owner trying to get a free motor. For a 100 bucks most dealerships would tell you wants wrong, guy phony as a three dollar bill.

The plaintiff kinda looks like he has no ears at certain angles.

Nicest defendant in forever. I hope he's doing well ❤️ The plantiff is a BULLY😡😡😡

I read that book. My favorite author.

Ken just wanted to exercise his privilege

This defendant seems patient and kind in spite of all that stress. God bless him.

Tom Green needs to chill.

As a dealership we can choose to turn down warranty companies because it IS a big hassel and whatever the warranty doesn't Pay the customer owes. And then the customer is pissed at us because they think we charge too much and no, it's your extended stupid car shield you bought off the TV or flyer. ONLY PURCHASE MANUFACTUERER WARRANTY. THATS THE ONLY WARRANTY THAT WONT SCREW YOU OVER!!! The outside companies are stupid. Yes they are cheaper but you get what you pay for then

At 15:18 At the very end when the judges are talking together, she seemed VERY hostile towards her husband when she said 'you have absolutely zero imagination and you don't appreciate fiction...' Wow did she almost forget she was on camera?...

An engine is going to burn oil until the rings are broken in and seal properly also if you baby the engine too much the rings won't seat properly you need to accelerate so the rings are forced against the cylinder walls if you lug the engine too much the rings will never seat. My new motorcycle used up a quart of oil in 300 miles I had to check and add oil every 2 days now that it's broken in no problem

I believe everything the defendant says!!

John is definitely the yin to Marilyn’s yang. The wooden block to her gavel. The frijoles negros to her arroz.

At first I thought this was going to be one more car mechanic case that involved a bootleg side-job mechanic and junkyard parts. I was wrong... thos plaintiff is an idiot and apparently the defendant put in a legit engine from Autozone with a warranty. The plaintiff just doesn't want to take no for an answer. No free engine, sorry cuz.

it sounds like whoever did the honing was wrong

I am just impressed neither accused the other of using racial insults. When a white man and black person have arguments race insults get involved 90% of the time

I new a guy who's rings didn't seat he poured Ajax cleanser down the carb it smoked something fierce but the grit in the Ajax got the rings to seat.

I like the defendant. Don't trust the plaintiff at all.

The defendant says he's not going to say anything about the plaintiff using his vehicle for commercial purposes but that's exactly what he did he blurted it out on National television, obviously if the plaintiff is doing that and hiding it it's wrong you're committing fraud, but don't act like you blurted that out by accident that was completely intentional and on purpose, also the plaintiff comes into court claiming that there was something still wrong with his vehicle after the defendant worked on it but comes in with not one ounce of evidence, he thinks the judge is just going to rule based on what he's saying and no evidence whatsoever? How hard would it have been to go and get something in writing from a reputable shop? And if none of the shops want to deal with your warranty that's a personal problem you need to buy a better warranty or come out of pocket, people absolutely blow my mind these days!

guessing the main issue was not fixed on the car so guy wanted to take back and not spend anymore on it.

The plaid shirt guy looks really familiar.

So the engine blew a rod? Wouldn't that be due to not having enough oíl?

my first thought was 'he has a warrantee but says he wont deal with the guy who supplied and fitted the motor' alarm bells start ringing seems the motor was fine for 6 months other wise he would have complained sooner, normal people want things sorted as soon as possible if the motor is going through that much oil id say the plaintiff abused it somehow

Maintenance on any vehicle is a risk every time something goes wrong which it will. It's not a matter of if, it's when. But a person's attitude can be as difficult or more than the job you need done.

did he really have a blue beard?

It would have been cheaper for the plantiff to buy a new used vehicle. What a dummy.

Plaintiff lied, imo. The defendant would have found the problem...if one existed.

Steam better not come from any part of my car but anyways the plaintiff wasted time coming to court with no evidence