Proud of the defendant... Things happen in life and for his age he handled this case better than most grown people. Period.

This young man(defendant) will go far in life💜

Judge was wrong. Plaintiff was in a dangerous area, stopping on a curve and partially in traffic. The Plaintiff should have lost.

This young man has a bright future! His parents should be proud of him! More of a man than most grown folks!

The defendant said he had moved it, multiple times before the boss chimed in. If she wasn't screaming over his testimony, she would have heard him.

I disagree with the judge. Plaintiff was partially in the street he is liable for his own damages. The pictures were taken after the plaintiff moved his car. The judge was too busy "flapping her gums" to hear the young man say that. Smh like the officer said he was impeding traffic.

The boss didn’t coach the teen. The teen had already said that the photo was taken after the plaintiff had moved up a bit.

I’ve been a professional driver for years and I don’t understand her judgment.

I believe the judge made a bad call, she ruled the wrong way today in my opinion

She does not listen 🤦🏾‍♀️ the defendant was very clear in his descriptions and twice she claimed he didn’t say what he clearly said. How do you know more than the officers who arrived on the scene? She shushed the owner cuz he wasn’t there, then proceeded to speculate how the accident occurred herself 😑

I agree with everyone here. She ruled wrong with this one. The young man already said the pic was taken after the car was moved up. She felt a way because the business owner put in his two cents. Her “reasoning” sounded almost personal. Weird

I love this young man, he handled everything so well. Wishing him the very best!❤️

This is a head-scratcher on JM's verdict; that said, the calm, accountable defendant handled himself well. Plaintiff, a bit whiney and behaved as if his actions played no part 🤷

I had to watch the entire case. I think she should have split the amount of 2900 between the defendant and plaintiff. The plaintiff was sitting in a dangerous spot and the police report stated he was impeding traffic. On the other side, the defendant did his his car. The car was not moving and the truck was. They both shared some responsibility.

Her rulings are starting to seem more from a personal stand point then what the law actually says because if he wasn’t stopped there illegally his car wouldn’t have gotten hit !

The defendant reminds me of our son, he worked for a landscaping company for a couple summers post high school graduation, brought back some great memories! The parents of the defendant should be proud, what a well composed, respectful young man.

On a narrow street it is so easy to be parked in the middle of street or the other side of the street while dropping someone off. See it all the time here, especially when doing a delivery.

Quarter pounder. Passener. Estabmamen. Sorry, my dude, but you could learn from this 17 year old. I have a lot of respect for young adults who work hard- and yard work is a ton of work. Even if it's his fault according to this, sh* happens, it'll be okay. He'll be extra careful in the future and that's never bad! I'd be proud of him if he were my boy.

I think the judge Miss when the little boy said it’s after they move up a little he said that before his boss said anything

That young man was very articulate!

Before the defendant handed the pics on the phone over and before his boss spoke, he said “in these pics we had moved up a little” and because she didn’t hear him she yelled at him and the boss when it was her mistake. She actually does that alot

I love how Douglas follows her to the monitor. My Mans been doing this too long. It's no need but it's like a reflex.

There's something to plaintiff having the defendants client card who happened to be a cop. Then the ticket making almost no sense and being thrown out of court...

Hey PC Family I'm trying to catch up with all the episodes I missed..this man said a quarter pounder😂😂and the defendant did say it was after he moved it before his boss asked

Good to know the judge can just go "ehhh I think the police report is wrong" and make a call completely off opinion. This is why I am terrified of court. Innocent or guilty, some random person gets to decide your fate.

OMG if he hit the car he had to be driving on the wrong side of the road.

Oh my gosh the Judges conversations afterward sometimes have me in stitches. Judge Schlesinger reminds me so much of my husband (We'll be married 36 years on Tuesday!) a story for every occasion!

73.56% of the time, the loser of the case says, “It is what it is.”🤣

if you are on the road, even if the guy was in the wrong spot. You must keep control of anything, be it a bike, motorcycle, car or truck.

So, I guess the defendant should've driven into opposing traffic to avoid the plaintiff's parked car.

He drives a Buick LeSaviour with quarter pounders. Defendant came around corner and he hit the curve.

The defendant had plenty of room to get around or wait for the plaintiff to move.

...The Plaintiff claims the kid refused to give him his insurance info (and the kid agreed that he did refuse) yet he expects us to believe that the kid handed over to him the credentials of an 'Officer Johnson.' It makes no sense.

in Ont Canada, a car isn't a classic til it's a minimum of 20 yrs old. It can be in mint condition, but it needs to wait a bit before it's a classic. I want to see pix of the bend and where the plaintiff was parked.

I'm very impressed with how this 17 year old conducted himself.

The boss didnt speak for him or put the idea in his head. The young man stated pics were taken AFTER he moved up a little bit.

Not me thinking that something is really called a quarter pounder on a vehicle! Im terrible 😂😂😂

Quarter pounder lmaoooo

Illegally parked? Did he have his flashers on? Was he out of traffic? Why no insurance claim filed? The insurance covers that claim.

The tickets were written weirdly. ?????Slow speeding????? 🙄😏

We really needed our mounted Steet Map and magnet model cars for this one. Lol 🚗🚗

I wish this young man the best life has to offer. He conducted himself so well. I bet his parents are very proud of him. I feel it's the plaintiffs fault because he WAS IN THE STREET. In the pictures you can kind of see the car angled in the street. She was wrong with this one. So now that poor kid has to pay almost 3000 dollars. Ridiculous. 😮‍💨

His "mint condition" 2003 car ? 🤣🤣🤣

Kid underestimated. It happens. Hopefully he learns how to account for the trailer and stop if it looks sketchy. You have to account for dumb moves otters make, unfortunately.

Leave that boy alone and let him continue doing a good job

Lol you know homeboy got fired after this

Good call judge.

Dude sounds like Patrick Mahomes 🤣💀

I have to disagree with JM at this time, the plaintiffs car was in the right of way! May you have a blessed week to all the commenters

Quarter Pounder 🤣

Defendant was in the wrong, Judge was wrong

A 17 year old operating a company truck WITH a trailer? That's a recipe for disaster and liability for the company.

Defendant clearly said the pictures were after it was moved. He never changed JM just didn’t hear. I think she is wrong. Also she always says to call police then now she isn’t buying the police report.

I wonder if anyone ever mentions the comments or if she notices her Mistakes because she didn't hear someone because she does it often

judge got this one wrong the cops got it right he stopped his car where it was sign posted you cant she only had the plaintiffs word for it he was only stopped to let someone out looking at the diagram its a silly place to stop

I feel the judge got this one wrong…. I do.

Anyone else hearing the parts from Airplane! In their head "The white zone is for immediate loading and unloading of passengers only, there is no stopping in the red zone" 😂😂

Quarter Pounder?? Chi Eye have flatlined, Through right There lmao 🤣😆🤣

11:50 noooo way on those green Crocs 💀

You slowdown going into a curve anyways, you don't know what's around the corner or ahead!

His car isnt even worth $4,000

IRREGARDLESS

When he said Buick I was hoping he was going to follow up with deuce and a quarter not LaSabre 😊 That kid seems to have been in the center not Papa Buick. Officer Johnson hmm, Papa Buick got that card from somewhere (young kid) a pigeon didn't drop it from the sky. Glad he'll get his car repaired.

The young man/defendant sounds like Jermaine Dupree

The kid didn't stay in his lane. He is guilty.

11:47 In that picture it looks like there is plenty of room to pass with a truck and small trailer.

That’s crazy

Jeez that's plenty of space...u could fit a semi there. I think he was just inexperienced understanding the trailing tracks of the trailer

SO, how was the defendant supposed to know he needed to make a wider turn? Should you always make a wider turn when pulling a trailer? When I park/pullover street side I; pull as close to the curb as possible, and push my sideview mirror IN if parking. When rounding corners on my town, I've definitely been REAL close to a few cars that were unexpectedly parked and slightly sticking out, so I understand how that aspect happened. On my street people park on both sides, unfortunately most of the people on my st don't want to use their driveway/parking area🤔, and there's always someone who is 6in or more away from the curb. It's really difficult coming out of my driveway in any vehicle, and we ALWAYS have to swing out to avoid hitting someone's car.

I disagree with the judge. If your car is stopped in a place that makes other cars have to swerve to not hit other cars; if it obstructs other vehicles traffic its his fault. Of course tickets don't accidents, his obstruction of traffic does.

If something is in your way, you STOP. If you are not sure you have room to pass, you DON'T proceed and hope for the best.

He means hes pulled over on the shoulder and half still out near the line. I think

I hope the owner does not take the money out of his pay… he should file his insurance. The plaintiff did not have insurance?

While I think she didn’t listen and was stupid many times. You can’t get away with hitting something stationary even if it’s parked poorly or illegally.

The old man should have moved up

2:10 Did he say several, ten years? WTF!

Bad verdict this time. He got the ticket from an unbiased 3rd party which clearly stated it was the old man’s fault.

It’s the case of mowing down a Buick

"You folks"

The car was NOT in mint condition......I guarantee you that....

I've always heard of unconscious bias and didn't realize how prevalent it is until I starting listening to these cases without looking at the litigants. If your honest with yourself you will recognize it and it's not really ok. Makes you wonder how it much it affects people in power such as judges, police, doctors and such. It's not suppose to happen but certainly does and surely can't fuck someone's life over.

Wait… when the plaintiff said his car 🚗 was in "mint condition" I was honestly expecting a souped up vehicle, with Mack Daddy rims and bling. Aesthetically, I was COMPLETELY underwhelmed 😩👎🏾 by the cars average appearance. Sorry 🤷🏾‍♀️😂

I actually disagree. No parking means no parking and whether he had the car on or not, he was parked and not moving. He was at fault. I rarely disagree with Judge Milan but I do on this case.

The plaintiff's dentures are WAY too big for his mouth🥴

no cell phone photos?

That street is wide how did he hit the car

LOOOOOL they used a soundboard or were pretendng to be the officer johnson soundbaord. I am positive.

Physics? Centripetal force, right?

I understand why some disagree with the ruling, but it was right because it corresponds with the law 🤷🏾‍♀️

SMH

the plaintiff seems confused/mistaken about what actually happened, I seriously doubt the little boy told him he worked for any officer...annnd there's no such thing as a "mint condition" Buick LaSabre, they've always been trash😅

You all must need glasses because even in the pictures the plaintiff's car was not in the opposing lane. He pulled over onto the right side of the road and whatever portion of his car was angled was still in the right lane, not the opposing left lane. If a driver coming around the corner is driving too fast and cuts the curve too sharply, then yea ... there's going to be an accident, as there was here!

Everyone driving a Buick should get a ticket, even arrested...

Buick LaSabre? Classic car?? I don't think so. It may be gorgeous but Classic...not so much.

I cannot even believe that judge is so dense on this case. I'm only, not even, halfway through.

Bad Ruling. If an accident is caused by someone doing something they're not supposed to be doing, then THEY are responsible for the accident and NOT the person that hit them. Obviously, there are some exceptions, as there are with most things. But in this case, the plaintiff caused the accident and is 100% responsible. Unfortunately, the fake pretend wanna be "judge" has a very flimsy grasp of the law. Even then, it is usually ignored and replaced by her emotions.

He should never ever stopped in the road! Just be ause you weren't ticketed does not mean you weren't eligible to be cited !

I disagree with her judgement on this case 🥴

I'm surprised that the defendant's age and inexperience wasn't brought up during the case, as clearly, this was the overriding factor!

Completely agree with JM’s judgement!