You forgot the John player who always comes back to the game just to finish off old business

i’m hosea, trelawny and arthur. i know i’m delusional 😭

Charles Smith,players thats just out here to survive,a bow and a shot gun,go hunting,help people,make a few dollars and just enjoy

You may not believe me and laugh at me, but I once suffered from depression and Red Dead Redemption turned out to be the cure

Hosea and Arthur. Straight up. It's just too good to give up on.

I like people who play RDO to support Rockstar. Indie companies like Rockstar need all the support they can possibly receive.

Me I’m the uncle type of player, to lazy to do anything to improve my financial situation in the game and just parasitizing in the whatever near saloon getting drunk 😅

I’m an Arthur player sadly. I’ve still got that hope.

I like how chill players most player are. I remember being super high and getting my first invite to the moonshine pub, couldnt stop smiling. Also made sure to do not play online much before I discovered the whole map in Singleplayer, way more immersive.

Hosea's profile is probably closest to my playing, but I had hopes for a player type of Charles: An experienced lone wolf, solo player, helping others, only pvp'ing to defend himself, prefers to be in the rural parts of the map-away from the cities. Gathers his income from hunting and gathering more than robbing and killing. That would fit me 100% :)

I'm very much a Hosea, but still with a touch of Jack. I take a break when it gets a little stale, but sometimes I log on just to go hunting and enjoy the scenery.

Hosea I play once every few months just to ride around and think about the good days of RDO. But also John, Online was the Dutch Gang equivalent to us players and i feel like John riding around just remembering old times and fights

I'm the player who has nearly 2 million dollars and around 6k in gold. My only goal now is to get to rank 1000, currently 960 so I grind for xp.

This video made me log back in. Haven't played since November back in 2022. Is nice to be back in my tavern, playing the banjo. Good times.

Clever how you correlated character with player type. Hosea here, still embarrassed about running away from that bear. Maybe some Dutch, too.

I'm a Charles, with a bit of Hosea. Only log on a few times a month, enjoying the scenery, helping out other players with story missions, bounties, etc., patrolling for griefers, and sometimes just maximizing my bounty to add a little spice to it 😆

It’s so true and funny how the rdr2 fans hate Micah while 50/50 of them are Micah online.

I guess I’m a combo of Dutch and Hosea. Rank 1000 with plenty of gold and money but still love to grind for awards. That said, I also love to just ride around the map and get immersed. I also have a little bit of Arthur in me cause, delusional or not, I still believe they haven’t completely abandoned it and will continue to play forever. Great video!

Respect man...As a player who quit playing RDR online this video bought happy old memories. I can only hope one day Rockstar will make an update worth coming back to.

😂 Great video Cat. Must have taken some thinking to match the characters!

Great video cat, as always... I find myself in all of the types, except the newbies, unfortunately...

I am a Jack Marston raised by an Arthur Morgan. I am fairly new to the game and I am already hoping for more stuff to be added.

I'm definitely a Hosea, I've personally stopped worrying about unlocks and completion. I found that I enjoy the world, creating my own fun and head canon in RDO, I've been playing since early 2019 and still find i play it regularly to immerse myself into my own role. If you'd like to know, my character is a blind bounty hunter & gun for hire, which always creates fun and interesting shenanigans

I want all the Outlaw basses back😅

How are you not bored of this game yet? You've been playing since the beginning, it's crazy how you still manage to make content!

I seem to be a mix of like 4 of them, Dutch, Hosea, Josiah (besides the posting part, i just enjoy making outfits), and also Arthur.

Hosea. Love fishing and harvesting herbs... and a little bit of Josiah Trelawny

Hey! how's it going Cat? I think I'm definitely a Hosea/Arthur type of player. I love just chilling with my friend in my moonshine shack and just generally riding around doing bounties. I still have hope for the game though, even if the chance is really small, I still hope Rockstar will return to fulfill this games enormous potential.

Living in the city I find it relaxing to just ride around, grinding, but also want to complete a CTA solo. Moving onto RDR2 story soon. Only did the first 20 minutes a year ago. 3 super high rank griefers killed my horse and me with explosives yesterday, while on a resupply run, and DAMN was I mad! Just changed lobbies. Sent a message but careful with language since got bans in the past. If had my mic on I would've vented!! 🤬

I fall under at least 4 of those, lol. Good job, Cat!

Combo of mostly Hosea with a sprinkle of Uncle. I absolutely love going on trail rides just for the atmosphere, fishing and just chilling out but once in a while I will tear it up getting totally blitzed and reminisce the good ol' days with some Remember When stories by the fire.

I definitely see myself as a Hosea/Immersion-like Player. Starting the game from time to time to play a mission or two and just enjoy the environment or go fishing, which I still enjoy since the game released.

I... guess I fit into 3 categories, though only one of them is more true than the other two. See, I play every morning with my husband to do dailies. Even if it is just 1 daily (depends on what has been going on that day), so just for the Daily grind I fall into the first category. Though not so much as to save all the money for properties in the future, but rather because the dailies give me a direction. Next is the Trelawny category, because yes I have almost all clothing items and will attempt to get all of the limited stock items that I can, but mostly to have outfits that fit to the horse that I am riding (mostly native-style outfits). But I do still thoroughly enjoy the world, and do quite a bit of hunting and fishing, so there is where the Hosea shines through the most.

No likes, no more beans discounts

Hosea described me almost perfectly but I do believe there will be more updates

I am a mix of Hosea, Josiah and Arthur. And I don't have a Halloween pass since I've been playing recently. I really like the Wild West setting and I like to poke around in the wardrobe to look cool) well, I hope RS will make content for the game again (I want my own house and a small plantation)

this is a great video

I'm a Dutch, Arthur and Hosea. Working on earning lots of money to buy all clothes and best equipment for horses , despite knowing the game is likely dead I still hold hope or it coming back to life.

I'm some Arthur Morgan - Trelawny type guy... But the thing I do the most is just being on Valentine waiting for some action, a duel, a shooting... and waiting for the game to have an update :(

hehehe I am a high level pvp player thanks to you actually because you always gave great tips. But I dont just go kill people for no reason. If someone trolls or tries to kill me I go full explosive arrow and sniper mode. Apart from that I always enjoy helping new players and still love replaying the online story missions

I play for the Daly challenge streaks. I have 2 characters. I keep them 2 weeks apart so I can maximize the spread. If I don't have time , I make sure to do 1 each day at least. The highest characters get priority. 1 level is 634. 1 is 324. Thinking I might just stop for the summer.

I honestly get on RDO every night at 2am just to do a daily challenge or two in order to keep my streak. Occasionally, however, I'll stay on for a bit longer just to do tasks like Moonshine or Trader.

I'm easily Dutch and Trelawny. I see RDRO as like the old fashioned version of GTAO, as I used to grind on there and create outfits. From 2019 to 2022 I was pretty consistent with playing both, but I started to get tired of the repetitive nature of GTAO after almost a decade actively playing it. RDRO is still fresher to me and has better graphics, with overall much calmer lobbies as I don't like doing combat with others very much (being a lone female character I feel like I get extra targeted too). So I usually stick to Collecting and Trading alone in public lobbies, while occasionally joining random posse's to help out others. I'm almost always broke because I love creating outfits, which pushes the cycle of grinding lol. A few times I've latched onto another like-minded player, but they'd always fall through after a while and stop playing.

I fall into the new player. 8 months playing game mode,then last month i seen the really good monthly update. Went from lvl 1 to 97 in 30 day's. Love your content on RdR @pvpcat

Excuse me, recently I’ve been struggling to find any decent pictures of the ability cards on the internet. I see that you’ve got some pretty high quality ones in a few of your videos, can you tell me your source so I can have high quality images of every card to print out and make real cards of them

I was Dutch in May grinding was a good deal with double payouts! Mostly bounty hunter or Hosea any other times like hang out at the Moonshine Shack. OH Abigail... almost every other day situation for me.

I'm with you Cat, as hopeless as it is😩 I'm still hoping rockstar will add new content. I also love just riding around in the game, it's so beautiful. So I will keep playing. Thank you for continuing these videos. I know it must be difficult to keep them going for a dead game, but we, or at least I, appreciate you!

The recent XP bonuses have gotten my hope up for something. I'm hoping for a time skip, so we have the same map as in the epilogue. That would open the world up in a perfect way to add slow moving cars that are barley slower than a horse but allow us the player to get around with 3 other friends

Hosea is definitely spot on for me!

I'm definitely type 4. I occasional come back to RDO for a month or so just to have some fun. Recently I started replying story again.

Number 5 caught me off guard😂

Every year, my friends and I go back into Red Dead for like a week

I miss playing this game... Might reinstall it and check up on my dude

Im new to the game on level 32 and grinding moonshiner role and bounty hunter and i love it 😂

I suppose but your definitions, I'm mostly Hosea with a bit of Trelawny thrown in. But to combine the two and add in a love of shootouts working with other players, I would say I'm most like Javier (a bit vain, enjoys fishing/immersion, dreamer, will go down with the RDO ship because what else is there?). 😂

Cat I have never heard anyone discuss how often to clean weapons, what’s your thoughts? I clean mine all the time, can you let them go to a certain point before it affects performance? As always thank you, I have been watching you for years, with your help I’m level 165 now and feel confident that I’m not just gonna get smacked while playing, so thanks again.

I'm probably Hosea and trelawny, I haven't even finished the online story mode or even unlocked everything I'm still level 27 haha. But I love playing online because. 1. Create your own character. 2. The open world is beautiful and I appreciate the effort rockstar put into it. 3. The weapons and clothings. 4. The horses. 5. The gameplay and mechanics. 6. The hunting and fishing I find myself enjoying the sceneries alot.

I'm most definitely Hosea, with a touch of Josiah & Dutch to keep myself from not going bored. And also, what character would represent the one who likes to seek out friends to play with? 'Cause that would be what I fall back on when all three of the previous playstyles have failed to engage me.

Bro i'm playing the old Red Dead Redemption game on Nintendo Switch and it's a blast.

Thanks Cat. Im still hoping that r* will do the right thing and add some new dlc.

I play sometimes, almost every time though I get randomly blown up. And I mean I can be in the most remote part of the map alone and blow up. Also sometimes my horse will randomly stop and kick me off like there's a predator nearby when there isn't, not run away, I get back on and it's the same thing. Idk if this is hackers but I can tell you it's consistent

I'm a mix of Dutch, Hosea and Arthur. Sometime I'll hop on the just enjoy and do some missions but I also believe it's too good to just be abandoned. The ones that just go around shooting people for no reason are the worst. I agree if they want to do that pick a game that focuses on that kind of game play. Red Dead is more for the chill players, IMO.

I'm a Sadie Adler player, I finished the story, platinum the game, and played online until level 120s. I'll return if need be. I was determined to do it all.

I was the Arthur Morgan type of player for the longest time.. And even when most of my faith in Rockstar had already died down, I still held onto some hope that things might change some day. But that time is long gone now.. These days I'm more a Hosea.

I'm definitely a Hosea. Even counting Baconman's 8th archetype, John.

I found myself identifying with Hosea and Arthur. Completely ignored the last double payout month, and just messed around with old missions that I enjoyed. I keep my eye on your channel for potential updates, and to see if the game gets something new. So much wasted potential.

RockStars games (GTA etc) are all "hacker supported" in the fct that online PvP allows (therefor condones) hackers/cheaters etc. The serious one that can turn your player into a turtle, every time you log in, with a script. The Devs seems to encourage this, by not blocking Dev Modes to players

I am a combination of the immersion and the fashion. I think there was one more that you missed though. I would call it the "babysitter", most similar to Charles Smith. It's a very high level player who invites low level players to their posse to lead them through moonshine and trader deliveries as well as other high rank activities not available to low levels. They do it because they enjoy helping new players earn some money/gold and to also let them experience the more fun content in the game, in the hope they will keep the player base active. It is important when doing this not to just dominate the enemy, always act more like their bodyguard and let them enjoy the content even if it's sometimes hard to watch them do things less than 100% efficiently.

I’m new to red dead online but I’m here for the extra red dead content because I already beat the game story like 5 times

I got to rank 500, went back to playing storying mode, only go online once a month for the free community outfits.

When I came across trelawny in online I forgot he was in story mode too. I also rediscovered Alden in story mode looking a bit older. Not sure if Angus is in story mode.

Only game where you can be a treasure hunter/geologist, wandering the wilderness, most times I pretend I have no horse and use the wild ones while freeroaming getting collectibles, really sells the immersion I'm an explorer in the 1800s Sadly, this game takes so much time to play, I barely get any time to play it and only play when I know Im going to have no interruptions

There are people like Karen, hanging out at the moonshine shack with their friends, just chatting and drinking moonshine till drunk, while drunk in real life at the same time.

Went on there the other day..just to say hi and pay respects to my old friend. My cat past and we were moving..of course the box that got lost was his stuff. Named my dog after him while he was alive..sadly the only thing I have left of him. Was a good 13yrs with my Drew.

I shacked up with someone back in the 90s for several years and she always told me you will do till something better comes along. I always thought she was joking. She was not. Well like her nothing better has come along so I keep playing RDO .

never stop making videos

I also have little hope play since beta but also enjoy helping low levels pvp mostly but never shoot first and enjoy the surroundings of the game even the places i already been so many times also outside map

"They spend so much on outfits that they're always broke" Bro did not have to call me out like that ☠️

I like it mainly for the missions with characters that we care about, like Bonnie, Sean, Sadie & Jake, etc. We wouldn’t ever have been able to see the Adlers together if it wasn’t for RDO.

6 is me lmao. I just spent 430$ of my 500$ on the same belt buckle, just because I was indecisive about how each color variation looked on my new outfit. Even though I still need to upgrade my moonshiner shack.

I was a Jack last year. This year I'm a Hosea, only coming back to RDO when I want to experience the old west through the eyes of my own custom character(s). Also a bit of a Josiah, admittedly. Cool story though; last year I was free roaming in the desert and was being chased by a "Micah." I ran to one of the abandoned homesteads and then was able to headshot him from yards away with my Navy Revolver; no deadeye or aim assist, and I also had my reticle disabled. He put up after that.

I’m number 4, I don’t have everything but I’ve been playing since release so I’ve done and seen everything there is to offer, i just hop on to have some fun with my buddy and immerse myself in the world

I still play on PS5. (ShootinRopes77) and I'm now level 152. I'm more of a collector/trader but love doing bounties/player bounties. I also am known as a Griefer "baiter"......I will go into different towns in hopes that I get fired on. I never fire on any players unless fired upon first. Either way I love how intense it can get. Great game.

I had a friend buy it recently, I offered to jump in RDO with him and rediscovered how fun RDO can be. It breaks my heart that cheaters and R* are slowly killing this game.

I am neither anyone on this list. I compared my self to an old man who's done everything, bought evey outfits got the roles and killed my fair share.I haven't gotten back into he game since April and most times I see just low level players thinking they can fight high level players. It's like seeing starving dogs who have nothing to eat nip at anything. It's bitter sweet.

Looks like I'm Jack! Last month i finished story mode for the first time ever, and then started playing online. In only may i spent over 70 hours in RDO, and besides of encountering some cheaters nuking whole cities I was having fun all the time!

I wish there was more in depth character customisation almost like fallout. property’s would be nice

Man, I don’t even know. I feel like all the strangers. Looking for something and finding out what that is exactly. Also kinda like a dog chasing a squirrel. I’m just doing stuff.

I’m Jack, Arthur and Hosea. Jack: I started playing the game 2 and a half months ago and saw its wasted potential. Arthur: I still have hope in RDO’s upcoming updates. Hosea: Roaming freely and hanging out with players and even modders in Valentine and doing some bar fights for the fun of it.

How do I get that jacket at the beginning of the video

im a mix of hosea and trelawny i only ever hunt or make outfits, sadly i joined kinda late and missed some of the cool limited edition clothing :( i dont really have to worry about many griefers since im always in defensive the lil scumbags still shoot my horse from time to time tho

I think for me I'm a mix between Hosea, maybe a little bit of Josiah but idk cause I do still just play the game and I don't care much for the monthly clothing discounts. Though I guess I'd also be like Arthur Morgan in a way. I don't think it'll be anytime soon but I'm still hoping one day we get something.

I still feel like im just starting still even though iv had rdr since release

I honestly forgot red dead online even existed because of how long it took me to complete the story I mean I told myself I would try it after I did everything in the main story but then I just never did

I finished everything, all the roles, stable slots, guns, camp, 10 custom outfits but I still play just to help my lower level friend. I just kinda follow them around and help them with whatever they’re doing or help them level up some of their roles. I don’t play alone anymore because I just don’t know what to do. And I’m not one to enjoy the scenery that much. Maybe because it’s too realistic, like there is nothing fantastical (fantasy-wise) about it. It’s still very beautiful but still not much to do. Maybe if they kept exploration to be more rewarding I would still play

hosea crossed with arthur.. i have everything i can buy in the game, have an excess of gold and dollars and mostly play to help the new starts find there footing. While hoping that we get the update that will allow us to finish the last part of Mrs Le-Clerk's missions as we still have the sister to deal with 😜 and what happened to being able to sell horses like the tutorial says we can do but was never implemented !!!!

Me and my friends play every Monday.. for around 2hrs.. beat each other up, throw each other off waterfalls.. endless fun. Best way to start the week.

i still play red dead online bc i like new austin, i dislike playing as john because he cant swim, and i spam the strawberry initiate bounty because it feels so damn good to kill skinner brothers and unlike most games when you kill someone in red dead it actually feels like youve killed them. which is extremelly satisfying for me.

I noticed one of the guys that tried to kill you in the clip was the same one who tried to jump my mates too 💀

Im not really playing rdo, its like when a good monthly update drops or i wanna play, i play for 2 months and then quit for half a year, but its true that this game has a lot of potential and is very underapreciated.