[Q/A] Cutting The Chaff: Rafale & What Ails Defence Procurement In India | Abhijit Iyer Mitra |MMRCA

  Рет қаралды 70,879

Sangam Talks

Sangam Talks

Күн бұрын

Main Talk: • Cutting The Chaff: Raf...
Abhijit Mitra answers questions on the misinformation being spread about the Rafale, and the larger macro impact it has on the defence of the country as well as the state of defence commentary and education in the country.
Abhijit simplifies the defence procurement process, gives us the background and sets the context. He proceeds to walk us through the Rafael deal, the scandal surrounding this deal and it clarifies the historical issues with defence procurement in India.
About the Speaker: -
Abhijit Iyer-Mitra is Senior Fellow at the Institute of Peace & Conflict Studies. A Defence Economist, he has regular columns in the Economic Times & Business Standard as well as bylines in all major dailies and the New York Times. He also has co authored two books, one on military reforms and another on Afghanistan and has several academic publications to his credit dealing with defence and foreign policy. Prior to his current post he coordinated the National Security Programme at the Observer Research Foundation, was visiting scholar at Sandia National Laboratories (Albuquerque) & at the Stimson Center (Washington D C). His hobbies include flying recreational aircraft and scuba diving and he is the proud parent of two dogs and a cat.
Join us on Telegram : t.me/srijanfn
Follow Us on Social Media :
Twitter : / srijanfn
Facebook : / srijanfoundation
Subscribe to Srijan Talks: bit.ly/2PU6JxG
More About Us : srijantalks.org/
#Rafale
#MMRCA
#SrijanTalks

Пікірлер: 188
@pilotcyborg.gaming
@pilotcyborg.gaming 4 жыл бұрын
Abhijeet is an intellectual we need more people like him and specially we need quality teachers to teach this in schools
@balbhattfromthirdofsevenof7496
@balbhattfromthirdofsevenof7496 4 жыл бұрын
Read to know why Abhijit Iyer Mitra is highly placed Pro American useful RW IDIOT. What is this nonsense he is comparing air force pilots with infantry man. What is the idea not to have latest tech in one squadron to start with. This idiots was advocating American fighter jet F 35 and arguing to stop purchase S400 Missile Defence Equipment. And how many countries developed F-35 or F-22 asshole there is difference between manuf spread so that every stakeholder benefits from manf activity as compared to development fund contribution and actual development and Manuf. DRDO as if it was acting independent and there were no Dalals and bureaucracy to undermine the efficiency. From American F-35 (Still perfect search for Japan's F-35's first crash) to Soviet Mi-24 Heli how many decades it took with multiple monumental failures and money in spite of military industrial complex being there took, stop this classroom example idiot. 36% says God about technology transfer how you arrived that ? Heard about Brahmos ? Satellites are they about precision, quality control and communication devices and integration of things. 40K USD what is PPP? idiot how Ihat is not true for ISRO? So global supply chain is only one way phenomena or two way i.e. your own Mohan-OEM-German example ? "We Invest in human being and not in platforms " or vice versa make up your mind ? what are you ? Brain Damage Drama Queen American-liar-Mitra? Ass holes they are very well trained (300 Hrs) ever heard of that ? What this guy thinks this is video game you open the box and start learning? They can fly unforgiving Mig 21 just like that? They can kill F-16 by Mig 21 by fluke ? This fart is telling you that upgrading to Iphone is difficult from bar phones , so pilots are shepherds ? Info processing is easy because of new age tech or difficult make up your mind! Israel got all the support from the west.for decades.. gas bag! How use of russian language by navy helped in deceiving during indo-pak war. So middle east russian mission were done in American and european jets? So second biggest defence supplier country is garbage supplying to 45 Countries and producing next gen weapons 1.Kinzhal 2.S500 3.Avangard 4.Poseidon 5.Burevestnik 6.Cyberwarfare? Then why american stole Mig 21 jet and Mi 25 heli to study. There is difference in quality and price of each manf say in case of Automobile. Even Merc & BMW are not that great reliable quality they used to be, ask any good trustworthy mechanic. F-35 EOL in 2050 we are still MiG 29 does not prove it's robustness? If operation & maintenance is not done even american will not stand up to the performance levels, in fact russian machines are far better in taking such beating then those fancy ones. China buying russian Su for fun or scrap value? F-35 is perfect ?? Japan dropped one in sea, and why Mitsubishi is developing it own Next generation Jet. Why Turkey happily swapped it despite being committed manf partner in fav of S400 and Sukhoi? If american ones this rabid Brain Damage Drama Queen American-liar-Mitra trying to sell are so great? Integration of Systems The SU-35MKI was tailor-made for Indian specifications and integrates Indian systems and avionics as well as French and Israeli sub-systems, so stop talking baloney. and do you guarantee future integration of russian missile or any other system from other country with rafael ? For all the reasons from geo-political this integration will always be a challenge until unless you become one supplier dependent, in fact that is also not possible in real world. Unless you have one end in your control either the equipment / aircraft / weapons systems. You are dependent period. That is also why we need to have indigenous 5th G Aircraft. Will american do it for you ? They are going to give away tech as russian do ? Never kept all eggs in one basket (Mirage and Mig) MMRC Rafael is far better in certain capability integrated technology, long range capability and smart weapons no doubts BUT Su-30 MKI supermaneuverable air dominance is one of the best fighters in the world in aerial combat. The redflag exercises between USAF and IAF demonstrate this. ....and he calls it failure ? Su-30 has a chance against the F-22 ->> www.ausairpower.net/APA-Flanker.html But what is the cost ? and isn't it high maintenance cost ? So over all high cost of purchase (Twice) as well as high maintenance cost (30%) and factor in more for currency issues, so fleet from 80% vs Sukhoi 50% is any way becomes offset against each other? But in terms of delivering weapons which fighter is meant for can it really do it all ? No. it carries a smaller less capable radar and fewer missiles than the Sukhoi. Su-30 MKI can employ many varieties of anti-ship missiles like3 × Kh-59MK,4 × Kh-356 × Kh-31A While Rafale on other hand has only MBDA AM 39-Exocet anti-ship missile. Su-30 MKI also employs varieties of Anti-Radiation Missiles like KH-31P and DRDO Anti-Radiation. Sukhoi (from 1995 era) has been backbone for two decades for IAF and will be continue to be so even after rafel procurement of one Sq is complete.When F-35 is getting obsolete in 2050! So here he conveniently forgets that it also needs technological upgradation as per is own admission in last four decades? Gas bag can you afford to buy Merc / BMW for all your sq. and they are really worth Despite the Sukhoi Su-30MKI is the most modern fighter jet in IAF inventory it is failure how? Why they are increasing the production ? why they are upgrading to SU-35 standards? The Su-30 MKI has also given a fillip to the DRDO, which has designed and developed the aircraft’s electronic countermeasures suite, including the radar warning receiver and frequency hopping radios and identify friend or foe system and engine upgrade. Su-30 MKIs are being upgrade to the ‘Super Sukhoi’, which has features similar to a fifth generation aircraft.
@balbhattfromthirdofsevenof7496
@balbhattfromthirdofsevenof7496 4 жыл бұрын
@@JATMYNAME YOU HAVE ANYTHING TO SAY ON SUBJECT OR JUST POKING AROUND. There are arguments and there are facts. And yes I have written it from my knowledge, what you want me to do? go and recheck all the instruments which measure specifications. Who the fuck are you to ask who I am? or to challenge or to suggest, with that attitude, on what I should or shouldn't do. Add fucking value to the discussion or get lost. Is it clear now or you want more clarity
@balbhattfromthirdofsevenof7496
@balbhattfromthirdofsevenof7496 4 жыл бұрын
@Ancient Bharat Is chutiye ka ja choos aur angrezi sun phir, apni galwan mat mara.
@SamvedIyer
@SamvedIyer 3 жыл бұрын
@@balbhattfromthirdofsevenof7496 He did not oppose latest tech in any squadron. He said that introducing latest tech does not solve the institutional malaise of lack of technology.
@balbhattfromthirdofsevenof7496
@balbhattfromthirdofsevenof7496 3 жыл бұрын
@@SamvedIyer Listen to rest of it and go through the complete text by me. I have argued on the basis of only what he said and as he said it. As far as his understanding of defence technology goes he talks >70% garbage.
@dpkchohan
@dpkchohan 4 жыл бұрын
Every single time i listen to this guy I absorb the information and feel upgraded. Thanks do much Abhijeet sir
@balbhattfromthirdofsevenof7496
@balbhattfromthirdofsevenof7496 4 жыл бұрын
Read to know why Abhijit Iyer Mitra is highly placed Pro American useful RW IDIOT. What is this nonsense he is comparing air force pilots with infantry man. What is the idea not to have latest tech in one squadron to start with. This idiots was advocating American fighter jet F 35 and arguing to stop purchase S400 Missile Defence Equipment. And how many countries developed F-35 or F-22 asshole there is difference between manuf spread so that every stakeholder benefits from manf activity as compared to development fund contribution and actual development and Manuf. DRDO as if it was acting independent and there were no Dalals and bureaucracy to undermine the efficiency. From American F-35 (Still perfect search for Japan's F-35's first crash) to Soviet Mi-24 Heli how many decades it took with multiple monumental failures and money in spite of military industrial complex being there took, stop this classroom example idiot. 36% says God about technology transfer how you arrived that ? Heard about Brahmos ? Satellites are they about precision, quality control and communication devices and integration of things. 40K USD what is PPP? idiot how Ihat is not true for ISRO? So global supply chain is only one way phenomena or two way i.e. your own Mohan-OEM-German example ? "We Invest in human being and not in platforms " or vice versa make up your mind ? what are you ? Brain Damage Drama Queen American-liar-Mitra? Ass holes they are very well trained (300 Hrs) ever heard of that ? What this guy thinks this is video game you open the box and start learning? They can fly unforgiving Mig 21 just like that? They can kill F-16 by Mig 21 by fluke ? This fart is telling you that upgrading to Iphone is difficult from bar phones , so pilots are shepherds ? Info processing is easy because of new age tech or difficult make up your mind! Israel got all the support from the west.for decades.. gas bag! How use of russian language by navy helped in deceiving during indo-pak war. So middle east russian mission were done in American and european jets? So second biggest defence supplier country is garbage supplying to 45 Countries and producing next gen weapons 1.Kinzhal 2.S500 3.Avangard 4.Poseidon 5.Burevestnik 6.Cyberwarfare? Then why american stole Mig 21 jet and Mi 25 heli to study. There is difference in quality and price of each manf say in case of Automobile. Even Merc & BMW are not that great reliable quality they used to be, ask any good trustworthy mechanic. F-35 EOL in 2050 we are still MiG 29 does not prove it's robustness? If operation & maintenance is not done even american will not stand up to the performance levels, in fact russian machines are far better in taking such beating then those fancy ones. China buying russian Su for fun or scrap value? F-35 is perfect ?? Japan dropped one in sea, and why Mitsubishi is developing it own Next generation Jet. Why Turkey happily swapped it despite being committed manf partner in fav of S400 and Sukhoi? If american ones this rabid Brain Damage Drama Queen American-liar-Mitra trying to sell are so great? Integration of Systems The SU-35MKI was tailor-made for Indian specifications and integrates Indian systems and avionics as well as French and Israeli sub-systems, so stop talking baloney. and do you guarantee future integration of russian missile or any other system from other country with rafael ? For all the reasons from geo-political this integration will always be a challenge until unless you become one supplier dependent, in fact that is also not possible in real world. Unless you have one end in your control either the equipment / aircraft / weapons systems. You are dependent period. That is also why we need to have indigenous 5th G Aircraft. Will american do it for you ? They are going to give away tech as russian do ? Never kept all eggs in one basket (Mirage and Mig) MMRC Rafael is far better in certain capability integrated technology, long range capability and smart weapons no doubts BUT Su-30 MKI supermaneuverable air dominance is one of the best fighters in the world in aerial combat. The redflag exercises between USAF and IAF demonstrate this. ....and he calls it failure ? Su-30 has a chance against the F-22 ->> www.ausairpower.net/APA-Flanker.html But what is the cost ? and isn't it high maintenance cost ? So over all high cost of purchase (Twice) as well as high maintenance cost (30%) and factor in more for currency issues, so fleet from 80% vs Sukhoi 50% is any way becomes offset against each other? But in terms of delivering weapons which fighter is meant for can it really do it all ? No. it carries a smaller less capable radar and fewer missiles than the Sukhoi. Su-30 MKI can employ many varieties of anti-ship missiles like3 × Kh-59MK,4 × Kh-356 × Kh-31A While Rafale on other hand has only MBDA AM 39-Exocet anti-ship missile. Su-30 MKI also employs varieties of Anti-Radiation Missiles like KH-31P and DRDO Anti-Radiation. Sukhoi (from 1995 era) has been backbone for two decades for IAF and will be continue to be so even after rafel procurement of one Sq is complete.When F-35 is getting obsolete in 2050! So here he conveniently forgets that it also needs technological upgradation as per is own admission in last four decades? Gas bag can you afford to buy Merc / BMW for all your sq. and they are really worth Despite the Sukhoi Su-30MKI is the most modern fighter jet in IAF inventory it is failure how? Why they are increasing the production ? why they are upgrading to SU-35 standards? The Su-30 MKI has also given a fillip to the DRDO, which has designed and developed the aircraft’s electronic countermeasures suite, including the radar warning receiver and frequency hopping radios and identify friend or foe system and engine upgrade. Su-30 MKIs are being upgrade to the ‘Super Sukhoi’, which has features similar to a fifth generation aircraft.
@peaceful1658
@peaceful1658 3 жыл бұрын
@@balbhattfromthirdofsevenof7496 I agree su30 was the backbone of IAF But what about the availability of su 30?? Hardly 50% bro...that’s the case with most of the Russian planes..it’s like demanding wife...that’s why he is peddling for western ecosystems. Being developing nation we can’t spend too much for service & maintenance of the planes. Now our geopolitical situation got changed so we can go for US made or western jets like f21(f16 block 72). Tell me one good reason not to buy f16???
@peaceful1658
@peaceful1658 3 жыл бұрын
@@balbhattfromthirdofsevenof7496 if super su was nearly fith gen fighter, why mirage 2000 was used in Balakot???🤣🤣🤣 Now you may say Su30 is air superiority....then why it did not shot down f16s next day??? (Off course it evaded AAMs)
@siddharth_behere
@siddharth_behere 4 жыл бұрын
Every paragraph he spoke had a new piece of information I did not know. How many people of his calibre exists to analyse so much of knowledge!
@sanketkapale809
@sanketkapale809 4 жыл бұрын
Abhijit is absolute intelligence... always nice to hear him...so informative 🤗
@jyotishj7582
@jyotishj7582 4 жыл бұрын
Vivekananda said Give me 100 energetic young men and I shall transform India , this applies to present India our government needs more men like Abhijit Mitra to make India great
@balbhattfromthirdofsevenof7496
@balbhattfromthirdofsevenof7496 4 жыл бұрын
Read to know why Abhijit Iyer Mitra is highly placed Pro American useful RW IDIOT. What is this nonsense he is comparing air force pilots with infantry man. What is the idea not to have latest tech in one squadron to start with. This idiots was advocating American fighter jet F 35 and arguing to stop purchase S400 Missile Defence Equipment. And how many countries developed F-35 or F-22 asshole there is difference between manuf spread so that every stakeholder benefits from manf activity as compared to development fund contribution and actual development and Manuf. DRDO as if it was acting independent and there were no Dalals and bureaucracy to undermine the efficiency. From American F-35 (Still perfect search for Japan's F-35's first crash) to Soviet Mi-24 Heli how many decades it took with multiple monumental failures and money in spite of military industrial complex being there took, stop this classroom example idiot. 36% says God about technology transfer how you arrived that ? Heard about Brahmos ? Satellites are they about precision, quality control and communication devices and integration of things. 40K USD what is PPP? idiot how Ihat is not true for ISRO? So global supply chain is only one way phenomena or two way i.e. your own Mohan-OEM-German example ? "We Invest in human being and not in platforms " or vice versa make up your mind ? what are you ? Brain Damage Drama Queen American-liar-Mitra? Ass holes they are very well trained (300 Hrs) ever heard of that ? What this guy thinks this is video game you open the box and start learning? They can fly unforgiving Mig 21 just like that? They can kill F-16 by Mig 21 by fluke ? This fart is telling you that upgrading to Iphone is difficult from bar phones , so pilots are shepherds ? Info processing is easy because of new age tech or difficult make up your mind! Israel got all the support from the west.for decades.. gas bag! How use of russian language by navy helped in deceiving during indo-pak war. So middle east russian mission were done in American and european jets? So second biggest defence supplier country is garbage supplying to 45 Countries and producing next gen weapons 1.Kinzhal 2.S500 3.Avangard 4.Poseidon 5.Burevestnik 6.Cyberwarfare? Then why american stole Mig 21 jet and Mi 25 heli to study. There is difference in quality and price of each manf say in case of Automobile. Even Merc & BMW are not that great reliable quality they used to be, ask any good trustworthy mechanic. F-35 EOL in 2050 we are still MiG 29 does not prove it's robustness? If operation & maintenance is not done even american will not stand up to the performance levels, in fact russian machines are far better in taking such beating then those fancy ones. China buying russian Su for fun or scrap value? F-35 is perfect ?? Japan dropped one in sea, and why Mitsubishi is developing it own Next generation Jet. Why Turkey happily swapped it despite being committed manf partner in fav of S400 and Sukhoi? If american ones this rabid Brain Damage Drama Queen American-liar-Mitra trying to sell are so great? Integration of Systems The SU-35MKI was tailor-made for Indian specifications and integrates Indian systems and avionics as well as French and Israeli sub-systems, so stop talking baloney. and do you guarantee future integration of russian missile or any other system from other country with rafael ? For all the reasons from geo-political this integration will always be a challenge until unless you become one supplier dependent, in fact that is also not possible in real world. Unless you have one end in your control either the equipment / aircraft / weapons systems. You are dependent period. That is also why we need to have indigenous 5th G Aircraft. Will american do it for you ? They are going to give away tech as russian do ? Never kept all eggs in one basket (Mirage and Mig) MMRC Rafael is far better in certain capability integrated technology, long range capability and smart weapons no doubts BUT Su-30 MKI supermaneuverable air dominance is one of the best fighters in the world in aerial combat. The redflag exercises between USAF and IAF demonstrate this. ....and he calls it failure ? Su-30 has a chance against the F-22 ->> www.ausairpower.net/APA-Flanker.html But what is the cost ? and isn't it high maintenance cost ? So over all high cost of purchase (Twice) as well as high maintenance cost (30%) and factor in more for currency issues, so fleet from 80% vs Sukhoi 50% is any way becomes offset against each other? But in terms of delivering weapons which fighter is meant for can it really do it all ? No. it carries a smaller less capable radar and fewer missiles than the Sukhoi. Su-30 MKI can employ many varieties of anti-ship missiles like3 × Kh-59MK,4 × Kh-356 × Kh-31A While Rafale on other hand has only MBDA AM 39-Exocet anti-ship missile. Su-30 MKI also employs varieties of Anti-Radiation Missiles like KH-31P and DRDO Anti-Radiation. Sukhoi (from 1995 era) has been backbone for two decades for IAF and will be continue to be so even after rafel procurement of one Sq is complete.When F-35 is getting obsolete in 2050! So here he conveniently forgets that it also needs technological upgradation as per is own admission in last four decades? Gas bag can you afford to buy Merc / BMW for all your sq. and they are really worth Despite the Sukhoi Su-30MKI is the most modern fighter jet in IAF inventory it is failure how? Why they are increasing the production ? why they are upgrading to SU-35 standards? The Su-30 MKI has also given a fillip to the DRDO, which has designed and developed the aircraft’s electronic countermeasures suite, including the radar warning receiver and frequency hopping radios and identify friend or foe system and engine upgrade. Su-30 MKIs are being upgrade to the ‘Super Sukhoi’, which has features similar to a fifth generation aircraft.
@shalabhpradhan529
@shalabhpradhan529 4 жыл бұрын
"It doesnt matter if cat is black or white till the time it catches mice".....this was not said by mao, it was said by Den Xiaoping
@yashwantsingh5005
@yashwantsingh5005 4 жыл бұрын
I am sitting from past 1.30 hour listening to both of his videos, And now i was all wrong about everything, he is an true intellectual.
@tinguzz
@tinguzz 4 жыл бұрын
It is pure joy and absolute entertainment (well also insight-fully informative!!) to listen to this guy, I watched both the parts and time simply evaporates. Thanks a lot Sir.
@akshatgupta8523
@akshatgupta8523 4 жыл бұрын
Amazing talk and QnA, I think I've learnt more from these 2 hours than I've done in my entire life from reading those articles and newspaper by so many mediatypes.
@avm4377
@avm4377 4 жыл бұрын
I am amazed. How come he knows so much. Hats off to him.
@abhinavpandey1243
@abhinavpandey1243 4 жыл бұрын
Just watched completely 🙏 brilliant it is
@GTR-93
@GTR-93 4 жыл бұрын
SO INDIAN BERAUCRACY IS CORRUPT. THE ROOT PROBLEM IS OUR EDUCATION
@ajinkyajay
@ajinkyajay 4 жыл бұрын
I now realize why in ancient times killing the knowlegeable was greatest sin. You loose soooooooooo much of information, knowledge and intelligent brain that could make sense out of it. Hats off Abhijit !
@lancer2134
@lancer2134 4 жыл бұрын
Abhijit is simply brilliant. Its opened my eyes about 100% technology transfer & intercommunications of various defence equipment (jammer, radars, missiles to EV suites). We have to go long way in order to consume new technologies. We need to correct our approach otherwise again it will take decades to competes.
@swamisampuurnanand
@swamisampuurnanand 4 жыл бұрын
This channel should have a viewership of over one a million with equal number of subscribers.
@andibandi5501
@andibandi5501 4 жыл бұрын
One of the most original thinkers in India today
@rohitroll2119
@rohitroll2119 4 жыл бұрын
Loved the cut the chaff with abhijit❣️
@bhaskarsharma9130
@bhaskarsharma9130 4 жыл бұрын
Excellent talk !!! Thanks Abhijit.You are really wonderful!!! Thanks Srijan!!
@AnandRajappan
@AnandRajappan 4 жыл бұрын
Such a interesting and wonderful knowledge Sharing session and a am very happy that we have such a great analyst to speak the facts /truth. Interdependence is the norm of future generations, for sure. I wish we develope india to be atleast 30 to 50 of holding that knowledge base, with us. That should be an acceptable goal to set for our nation. May be more, if you compare the knowledge that ISRO has built within it. And thank you for such an enlightening talk, Sri Abijith Iyer Mitra
@thekiminthenorth504
@thekiminthenorth504 4 жыл бұрын
Abhijeet is such a gem.. what a treat listening to him
@beahumanbeingfirst
@beahumanbeingfirst 4 жыл бұрын
Brilliant discussion
@JAVEDZULFIQAR
@JAVEDZULFIQAR 4 жыл бұрын
Just Wow...... Invest in human being not in platforms......very very wise
@time1T
@time1T 4 жыл бұрын
Always a pleasure to listen to Abhijeet
@regnauldmortimer4952
@regnauldmortimer4952 2 жыл бұрын
What an incredible guy....surely someone will listen????
@All-pervading
@All-pervading 4 жыл бұрын
Today I learned a lot from this video 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 Thank you so much Sir🙏🤗
@brucevilla
@brucevilla 4 жыл бұрын
Thanks for Uploading.
@asimghaffar9910
@asimghaffar9910 3 жыл бұрын
I'm from Pakistan . A great man with wisdom and knowledge & strong grip on his subjects
@balajipurushottam5040
@balajipurushottam5040 4 жыл бұрын
This man is simplyyyy superbbbbbb
@Thoughtflux
@Thoughtflux 4 жыл бұрын
Very nicely put!
@neethan30
@neethan30 3 жыл бұрын
The only reason the F-35 had 25 countries working on it, was to lower the cost, the U.S.A could have easily built this aircraft within their own ecosystem.This als includes projects like the eurofighter typhoon. If the UK wanted to they would have built it on their own with higher costs to factor for. India already has a military ecosystem in place, how much of that ecosystem is relevant to absorbing the rafale project is yet to be seen, however, rather than having a tantrum, we could put our minds together which I am sure they are already, we can figure out how to absorb the rafale within our existing ecosystem.
@neriv5500
@neriv5500 3 жыл бұрын
What has been in place for decades cannot be changed overnight. However, "there is work in progress" Plus, as patriotic or fanatic it may sound, we cannot underestimate the potential of New Bharat. How wrong Abhijit has been proved vis a vis today's China-US interdependence.
@yoppindia
@yoppindia Жыл бұрын
world is not an ideal place. Chinese know how to copy things, but still they buy Russian aircraft and engines.
@AchalMaheshwari
@AchalMaheshwari 4 жыл бұрын
Absolutely on the face...Truth can be painful for some
@mukeshagrawal577
@mukeshagrawal577 3 жыл бұрын
Amazing discourse.👍👍
@utkarshjangid3374
@utkarshjangid3374 4 жыл бұрын
Excellent Details of the deal.
@SidharthMiddela
@SidharthMiddela 3 жыл бұрын
Brilliant!!
@gabbarrf1745
@gabbarrf1745 4 жыл бұрын
Very informative.
@abhipatil1618
@abhipatil1618 4 жыл бұрын
So Q & A was more informative than lecture...
@sharvansharma1313
@sharvansharma1313 4 жыл бұрын
Awesome video
@draloksharma
@draloksharma Жыл бұрын
Great session
@nathansekhar2840
@nathansekhar2840 3 жыл бұрын
Brilliant analysis by Abijit Iyer Mitra. Nathan Sekhar Sydney Australia.
@vivanranjan261
@vivanranjan261 4 жыл бұрын
PLEASE MAKE MORE VIDEOS WITH ABHIJIT
@kabitamallik143
@kabitamallik143 4 жыл бұрын
Excellent bravo.
@ajaysinghthakur389
@ajaysinghthakur389 4 жыл бұрын
Some one pls make this genius defence minister / MEA
@ajinkyajay
@ajinkyajay 4 жыл бұрын
No. Then he has to be loyal to party and won't be able to criticise BJP-Indian govt. It's best he is in this position where he can influence defence policy while being critical of govt
@ajaysinghthakur389
@ajaysinghthakur389 4 жыл бұрын
@@ajinkyajay AGREE THEre are disadvantages of being part of estabilishment . But Its better to utilize ones expertise/knowledge for betterment of nation, rather than use it in public forums for debates or seminars. Even I have never seen him in main stream media. His views is limited to ones attending the seminars or on youtube .
@ajinkyajay
@ajinkyajay 4 жыл бұрын
@@ajaysinghthakur389 He doesn't appears much on mainstream media - True. But, he is part of a 'policy making' think tank of India - Institute of Peace & Conflict. This think tank along with another think tank - ORF, (usually) have huge influence on India's defence and foreign policy. I didn't realize it until my friend did internship at this institute. They do a lots of stuff which is highly confidential (hence lesser contact with popular mainstream media).
@ajaysinghthakur389
@ajaysinghthakur389 4 жыл бұрын
@@ajinkyajay OK . GOOD. THEN ITS BETTER HE REMAINS THERE ONLY
@ashokmisal2002
@ashokmisal2002 2 жыл бұрын
Knowledge retention, professional knowledge and professional competence...archive of knowledge. Revamping of education system, strategic thinking....merit base education.
@kishorjamatkar9436
@kishorjamatkar9436 4 жыл бұрын
Hats off to u abhjit
@nishantshetty84
@nishantshetty84 4 жыл бұрын
Groups of Think tanks like him should be included in drafting the policies and decision making
@vik_saras
@vik_saras 4 жыл бұрын
Super talk
@JoyousNightjar
@JoyousNightjar 4 жыл бұрын
Great explanation!! Simple day to day example I can add is all these new smart phones. It was difficult for my father to understand & use all features in his phone. Had more difficulty in using whatsapp. I can do it better than him but my 9 year old son uses features of modern smart phone better than me. He can also play games on that screen where I can not clear 2nd or 3rd level of that game.
@ThakurRaman08
@ThakurRaman08 3 жыл бұрын
This Guy is genious.I must say.
@balachandarkrishnamurthy8965
@balachandarkrishnamurthy8965 4 жыл бұрын
I think he is underestimating our flyers learning capability. True learning phase is challenging but airforce will have SOP and strong training platform
@nishitdronographer718
@nishitdronographer718 4 жыл бұрын
This guy is a mine of knowledge!
@AnandAKGupta
@AnandAKGupta 4 жыл бұрын
The system needs to keep adapting itself, but we need a balance between change and constancy too.
@SantoshGairola
@SantoshGairola 4 жыл бұрын
Nice talk. Would be nice, if you mention the date of actual recording. That will be helpful.
@ansharmani
@ansharmani 3 жыл бұрын
Informative and Yet satirical humour at its best too 😹
@jyotishj7582
@jyotishj7582 4 жыл бұрын
Abhijeet sir said interdependence at present is the norm , England invited for its Tempest sixth generation fighter jet , India can contribute for its development in this interdependent world
@sahilsolanki6099
@sahilsolanki6099 4 жыл бұрын
Guys plz upload more videos of Abhijeet
@balbhattfromthirdofsevenof7496
@balbhattfromthirdofsevenof7496 4 жыл бұрын
Read to know why Abhijit Iyer Mitra is highly placed Pro American useful RW IDIOT. What is this nonsense he is comparing air force pilots with infantry man. What is the idea not to have latest tech in one squadron to start with. This idiots was advocating American fighter jet F 35 and arguing to stop purchase S400 Missile Defence Equipment. And how many countries developed F-35 or F-22 asshole there is difference between manuf spread so that every stakeholder benefits from manf activity as compared to development fund contribution and actual development and Manuf. DRDO as if it was acting independent and there were no Dalals and bureaucracy to undermine the efficiency. From American F-35 (Still perfect search for Japan's F-35's first crash) to Soviet Mi-24 Heli how many decades it took with multiple monumental failures and money in spite of military industrial complex being there took, stop this classroom example idiot. 36% says God about technology transfer how you arrived that ? Heard about Brahmos ? Satellites are they about precision, quality control and communication devices and integration of things. 40K USD what is PPP? idiot how Ihat is not true for ISRO? So global supply chain is only one way phenomena or two way i.e. your own Mohan-OEM-German example ? "We Invest in human being and not in platforms " or vice versa make up your mind ? what are you ? Brain Damage Drama Queen American-liar-Mitra? Ass holes they are very well trained (300 Hrs) ever heard of that ? What this guy thinks this is video game you open the box and start learning? They can fly unforgiving Mig 21 just like that? They can kill F-16 by Mig 21 by fluke ? This fart is telling you that upgrading to Iphone is difficult from bar phones , so pilots are shepherds ? Info processing is easy because of new age tech or difficult make up your mind! Israel got all the support from the west.for decades.. gas bag! How use of russian language by navy helped in deceiving during indo-pak war. So middle east russian mission were done in American and european jets? So second biggest defence supplier country is garbage supplying to 45 Countries and producing next gen weapons 1.Kinzhal 2.S500 3.Avangard 4.Poseidon 5.Burevestnik 6.Cyberwarfare? Then why american stole Mig 21 jet and Mi 25 heli to study. There is difference in quality and price of each manf say in case of Automobile. Even Merc & BMW are not that great reliable quality they used to be, ask any good trustworthy mechanic. F-35 EOL in 2050 we are still MiG 29 does not prove it's robustness? If operation & maintenance is not done even american will not stand up to the performance levels, in fact russian machines are far better in taking such beating then those fancy ones. China buying russian Su for fun or scrap value? F-35 is perfect ?? Japan dropped one in sea, and why Mitsubishi is developing it own Next generation Jet. Why Turkey happily swapped it despite being committed manf partner in fav of S400 and Sukhoi? If american ones this rabid Brain Damage Drama Queen American-liar-Mitra trying to sell are so great? Integration of Systems The SU-35MKI was tailor-made for Indian specifications and integrates Indian systems and avionics as well as French and Israeli sub-systems, so stop talking baloney. and do you guarantee future integration of russian missile or any other system from other country with rafael ? For all the reasons from geo-political this integration will always be a challenge until unless you become one supplier dependent, in fact that is also not possible in real world. Unless you have one end in your control either the equipment / aircraft / weapons systems. You are dependent period. That is also why we need to have indigenous 5th G Aircraft. Will american do it for you ? They are going to give away tech as russian do ? Never kept all eggs in one basket (Mirage and Mig) MMRC Rafael is far better in certain capability integrated technology, long range capability and smart weapons no doubts BUT Su-30 MKI supermaneuverable air dominance is one of the best fighters in the world in aerial combat. The redflag exercises between USAF and IAF demonstrate this. ....and he calls it failure ? Su-30 has a chance against the F-22 ->> www.ausairpower.net/APA-Flanker.html But what is the cost ? and isn't it high maintenance cost ? So over all high cost of purchase (Twice) as well as high maintenance cost (30%) and factor in more for currency issues, so fleet from 80% vs Sukhoi 50% is any way becomes offset against each other? But in terms of delivering weapons which fighter is meant for can it really do it all ? No. it carries a smaller less capable radar and fewer missiles than the Sukhoi. Su-30 MKI can employ many varieties of anti-ship missiles like3 × Kh-59MK,4 × Kh-356 × Kh-31A While Rafale on other hand has only MBDA AM 39-Exocet anti-ship missile. Su-30 MKI also employs varieties of Anti-Radiation Missiles like KH-31P and DRDO Anti-Radiation. Sukhoi (from 1995 era) has been backbone for two decades for IAF and will be continue to be so even after rafel procurement of one Sq is complete.When F-35 is getting obsolete in 2050! So here he conveniently forgets that it also needs technological upgradation as per is own admission in last four decades? Gas bag can you afford to buy Merc / BMW for all your sq. and they are really worth Despite the Sukhoi Su-30MKI is the most modern fighter jet in IAF inventory it is failure how? Why they are increasing the production ? why they are upgrading to SU-35 standards? The Su-30 MKI has also given a fillip to the DRDO, which has designed and developed the aircraft’s electronic countermeasures suite, including the radar warning receiver and frequency hopping radios and identify friend or foe system and engine upgrade. Su-30 MKIs are being upgrade to the ‘Super Sukhoi’, which has features similar to a fifth generation aircraft.
@muneeshsharma8649
@muneeshsharma8649 3 жыл бұрын
Bhai fan ho gaya tera
@naruvimama
@naruvimama 3 жыл бұрын
I disagree with the self reliance part. Sweden with a population less than Chennai - dominates many areas including 5G The strength of India in the long run is the scale and technology. We must be aiming for technological dominance, and a sub goal of reaching self reliance atleast in few areas should be a national priority that should drive us there.
@darumer123
@darumer123 4 жыл бұрын
@Abijeet Is this pheran you are wearing??
@Lovepreet-yt3fg
@Lovepreet-yt3fg 3 жыл бұрын
Also one hidden feature of rafael that went undiscovered was that it can fry samosas in mid flight
@anonranger6428
@anonranger6428 3 жыл бұрын
makes sense
@JoyousNightjar
@JoyousNightjar 4 жыл бұрын
Everybody who is questioning the importance of training visualize this. Previously cars were without reverse camera. Now they do. If u r using one with camera now, try parking one without a camera. Most likely the one u were using b4. U will find it difficult.
@ravichandel8690
@ravichandel8690 4 жыл бұрын
i am the virgin marry wale line sahi thee
@SaurabhSharma2804
@SaurabhSharma2804 4 жыл бұрын
When was this discussion actually held? Everyone is wearing warm clothes, and the Rafale deal is out of public discussion at this point of time.
@tanujsabharwal6435
@tanujsabharwal6435 4 жыл бұрын
Derence procurement must be simplified inorder to be potent force
@kaushlendrasingh859
@kaushlendrasingh859 4 жыл бұрын
Do one talk about how we literally can improve Tejas or make MMRCA
@ravichandel8690
@ravichandel8690 4 жыл бұрын
sirji right to recall aur trial by jury par bhi video
@ravichandel8690
@ravichandel8690 4 жыл бұрын
sir make video on iranian weapons manufacturing and isreal weapons manufacturing.
@mr.lagankumar7353
@mr.lagankumar7353 4 жыл бұрын
Abhijeet sir, would it be better to bring fresher pilots to fly Rafael planes.
@mdkhan40
@mdkhan40 4 жыл бұрын
I searched mohan kumar udyog on google ,bing etc .....but havent got any link
@mandeep5993
@mandeep5993 4 жыл бұрын
Actually, it is M Kumar Udyog (MKU). Kanpur, India. www.mku.com/en/index
@manassurya2019
@manassurya2019 3 жыл бұрын
The audience is unable to grasp the importance of how much access to technology at an early age can change the neurology of the person itself, and how helpful that can be for that person when he has to handle high tech equipment like fighter jets, where 3-4 screens give you visual information simultaneously. Now, kids in first world countries have started playing VR games, with a full VR headset. Less than 0.1% of kids in India have VR headseats today. Think of what type of a disadvantage that will be for Indians, when there will be VR augmented military equipment in the future.
@JASHVEER22
@JASHVEER22 4 жыл бұрын
Training at the OEM plus initial learning curve should mitigate the issue of pilot training.
@anupdhormale4062
@anupdhormale4062 3 жыл бұрын
What is long form of DPP
@arunkanwar79
@arunkanwar79 4 жыл бұрын
We have French Mirage, Jaguar...in our fleet..not just Russian
@randhirkumar403
@randhirkumar403 4 жыл бұрын
To SrijanTalks you are adding old video's which were made in winter and now winter is going to come in 2 month, what's the point spreading knowledge late, please do some improvement
@yoppindia
@yoppindia Жыл бұрын
as usual Abhijit is brutal.
@aayushroy0609
@aayushroy0609 4 жыл бұрын
Nagas are tough as nails. At my SSB is Bhopal, there were two Nagas who were clearing circuits like hot knife through butter. We need to deploy more Nagas on the Jihadis.
@letmethinkv
@letmethinkv 4 жыл бұрын
Why not you become tough as nails.
@satyampandey2222
@satyampandey2222 4 жыл бұрын
@@letmethinkv because it's a cultural thing, that requires training and upbringing that would be unacceptable by the government
@letmethinkv
@letmethinkv 4 жыл бұрын
@@satyampandey2222 thats bull crap..... government doesn't stop you .....its you. Go join gym....if no money do at home....read literature about warriors......like sikh warriors.....brain wash your kids do whatever it takes.
@vijulthapa1069
@vijulthapa1069 4 жыл бұрын
That guy is dope man!!
@user-ns4ek5jw1l
@user-ns4ek5jw1l 4 жыл бұрын
42:45 👍 Everest of Intelligence.
@balbhattfromthirdofsevenof7496
@balbhattfromthirdofsevenof7496 4 жыл бұрын
Read to know why Abhijit Iyer Mitra is highly placed Pro American useful RW IDIOT. What is this nonsense he is comparing air force pilots with infantry man. What is the idea not to have latest tech in one squadron to start with. This idiots was advocating American fighter jet F 35 and arguing to stop purchase S400 Missile Defence Equipment. And how many countries developed F-35 or F-22 asshole there is difference between manuf spread so that every stakeholder benefits from manf activity as compared to development fund contribution and actual development and Manuf. DRDO as if it was acting independent and there were no Dalals and bureaucracy to undermine the efficiency. From American F-35 (Still perfect search for Japan's F-35's first crash) to Soviet Mi-24 Heli how many decades it took with multiple monumental failures and money in spite of military industrial complex being there took, stop this classroom example idiot. 36% says God about technology transfer how you arrived that ? Heard about Brahmos ? Satellites are they about precision, quality control and communication devices and integration of things. 40K USD what is PPP? idiot how Ihat is not true for ISRO? So global supply chain is only one way phenomena or two way i.e. your own Mohan-OEM-German example ? "We Invest in human being and not in platforms " or vice versa make up your mind ? what are you ? Brain Damage Drama Queen American-liar-Mitra? Ass holes they are very well trained (300 Hrs) ever heard of that ? What this guy thinks this is video game you open the box and start learning? They can fly unforgiving Mig 21 just like that? They can kill F-16 by Mig 21 by fluke ? This fart is telling you that upgrading to Iphone is difficult from bar phones , so pilots are shepherds ? Info processing is easy because of new age tech or difficult make up your mind! Israel got all the support from the west.for decades.. gas bag! How use of russian language by navy helped in deceiving during indo-pak war. So middle east russian mission were done in American and european jets? So second biggest defence supplier country is garbage supplying to 45 Countries and producing next gen weapons 1.Kinzhal 2.S500 3.Avangard 4.Poseidon 5.Burevestnik 6.Cyberwarfare? Then why american stole Mig 21 jet and Mi 25 heli to study. There is difference in quality and price of each manf say in case of Automobile. Even Merc & BMW are not that great reliable quality they used to be, ask any good trustworthy mechanic. F-35 EOL in 2050 we are still MiG 29 does not prove it's robustness? If operation & maintenance is not done even american will not stand up to the performance levels, in fact russian machines are far better in taking such beating then those fancy ones. China buying russian Su for fun or scrap value? F-35 is perfect ?? Japan dropped one in sea, and why Mitsubishi is developing it own Next generation Jet. Why Turkey happily swapped it despite being committed manf partner in fav of S400 and Sukhoi? If american ones this rabid Brain Damage Drama Queen American-liar-Mitra trying to sell are so great? Integration of Systems The SU-35MKI was tailor-made for Indian specifications and integrates Indian systems and avionics as well as French and Israeli sub-systems, so stop talking baloney. and do you guarantee future integration of russian missile or any other system from other country with rafael ? For all the reasons from geo-political this integration will always be a challenge until unless you become one supplier dependent, in fact that is also not possible in real world. Unless you have one end in your control either the equipment / aircraft / weapons systems. You are dependent period. That is also why we need to have indigenous 5th G Aircraft. Will american do it for you ? They are going to give away tech as russian do ? Never kept all eggs in one basket (Mirage and Mig) MMRC Rafael is far better in certain capability integrated technology, long range capability and smart weapons no doubts BUT Su-30 MKI supermaneuverable air dominance is one of the best fighters in the world in aerial combat. The redflag exercises between USAF and IAF demonstrate this. ....and he calls it failure ? Su-30 has a chance against the F-22 ->> www.ausairpower.net/APA-Flanker.html But what is the cost ? and isn't it high maintenance cost ? So over all high cost of purchase (Twice) as well as high maintenance cost (30%) and factor in more for currency issues, so fleet from 80% vs Sukhoi 50% is any way becomes offset against each other? But in terms of delivering weapons which fighter is meant for can it really do it all ? No. it carries a smaller less capable radar and fewer missiles than the Sukhoi. Su-30 MKI can employ many varieties of anti-ship missiles like3 × Kh-59MK,4 × Kh-356 × Kh-31A While Rafale on other hand has only MBDA AM 39-Exocet anti-ship missile. Su-30 MKI also employs varieties of Anti-Radiation Missiles like KH-31P and DRDO Anti-Radiation. Sukhoi (from 1995 era) has been backbone for two decades for IAF and will be continue to be so even after rafel procurement of one Sq is complete.When F-35 is getting obsolete in 2050! So here he conveniently forgets that it also needs technological upgradation as per is own admission in last four decades? Gas bag can you afford to buy Merc / BMW for all your sq. and they are really worth Despite the Sukhoi Su-30MKI is the most modern fighter jet in IAF inventory it is failure how? Why they are increasing the production ? why they are upgrading to SU-35 standards? The Su-30 MKI has also given a fillip to the DRDO, which has designed and developed the aircraft’s electronic countermeasures suite, including the radar warning receiver and frequency hopping radios and identify friend or foe system and engine upgrade. Su-30 MKIs are being upgrade to the ‘Super Sukhoi’, which has features similar to a fifth generation aircraft.
@justsayniks
@justsayniks 4 жыл бұрын
N Ram and the “The Hindu” and notorious for hypocrisy.
@AnandDwivedi
@AnandDwivedi 4 жыл бұрын
Same applies with Naxal vs CRPF areas. CRPF is trained by army officers in Belgaon who don't know anything about Guerrilla warfare. Moreover IPS officers deputed there they don't know the basics of warfare they just enjoy there. CRPF Gurgaon acadamy does not teach them well as army officers are incapable.
@balbhattfromthirdofsevenof7496
@balbhattfromthirdofsevenof7496 4 жыл бұрын
Facts about CRPF is right but doesn't fit to IAF.... Read to know why Abhijit Iyer Mitra is highly placed Pro American useful RW IDIOT. What is this nonsense he is comparing air force pilots with infantry man. What is the idea not to have latest tech in one squadron to start with. This idiots was advocating American fighter jet F 35 and arguing to stop purchase S400 Missile Defence Equipment. And how many countries developed F-35 or F-22 asshole there is difference between manuf spread so that every stakeholder benefits from manf activity as compared to development fund contribution and actual development and Manuf. DRDO as if it was acting independent and there were no Dalals and bureaucracy to undermine the efficiency. From American F-35 (Still perfect search for Japan's F-35's first crash) to Soviet Mi-24 Heli how many decades it took with multiple monumental failures and money in spite of military industrial complex being there took, stop this classroom example idiot. 36% says God about technology transfer how you arrived that ? Heard about Brahmos ? Satellites are they about precision, quality control and communication devices and integration of things. 40K USD what is PPP? idiot how Ihat is not true for ISRO? So global supply chain is only one way phenomena or two way i.e. your own Mohan-OEM-German example ? "We Invest in human being and not in platforms " or vice versa make up your mind ? what are you ? Brain Damage Drama Queen American-liar-Mitra? Ass holes they are very well trained (300 Hrs) ever heard of that ? What this guy thinks this is video game you open the box and start learning? They can fly unforgiving Mig 21 just like that? They can kill F-16 by Mig 21 by fluke ? This fart is telling you that upgrading to Iphone is difficult from bar phones , so pilots are shepherds ? Info processing is easy because of new age tech or difficult make up your mind! Israel got all the support from the west.for decades.. gas bag! How use of russian language by navy helped in deceiving during indo-pak war. So middle east russian mission were done in American and european jets? So second biggest defence supplier country is garbage supplying to 45 Countries and producing next gen weapons 1.Kinzhal 2.S500 3.Avangard 4.Poseidon 5.Burevestnik 6.Cyberwarfare? Then why american stole Mig 21 jet and Mi 25 heli to study. There is difference in quality and price of each manf say in case of Automobile. Even Merc & BMW are not that great reliable quality they used to be, ask any good trustworthy mechanic. F-35 EOL in 2050 we are still MiG 29 does not prove it's robustness? If operation & maintenance is not done even american will not stand up to the performance levels, in fact russian machines are far better in taking such beating then those fancy ones. China buying russian Su for fun or scrap value? F-35 is perfect ?? Japan dropped one in sea, and why Mitsubishi is developing it own Next generation Jet. Why Turkey happily swapped it despite being committed manf partner in fav of S400 and Sukhoi? If american ones this rabid Brain Damage Drama Queen American-liar-Mitra trying to sell are so great? Integration of Systems The SU-35MKI was tailor-made for Indian specifications and integrates Indian systems and avionics as well as French and Israeli sub-systems, so stop talking baloney. and do you guarantee future integration of russian missile or any other system from other country with rafael ? For all the reasons from geo-political this integration will always be a challenge until unless you become one supplier dependent, in fact that is also not possible in real world. Unless you have one end in your control either the equipment / aircraft / weapons systems. You are dependent period. That is also why we need to have indigenous 5th G Aircraft. Will american do it for you ? They are going to give away tech as russian do ? Never kept all eggs in one basket (Mirage and Mig) MMRC Rafael is far better in certain capability integrated technology, long range capability and smart weapons no doubts BUT Su-30 MKI supermaneuverable air dominance is one of the best fighters in the world in aerial combat. The redflag exercises between USAF and IAF demonstrate this. ....and he calls it failure ? Su-30 has a chance against the F-22 ->> www.ausairpower.net/APA-Flanker.html But what is the cost ? and isn't it high maintenance cost ? So over all high cost of purchase (Twice) as well as high maintenance cost (30%) and factor in more for currency issues, so fleet from 80% vs Sukhoi 50% is any way becomes offset against each other? But in terms of delivering weapons which fighter is meant for can it really do it all ? No. it carries a smaller less capable radar and fewer missiles than the Sukhoi. Su-30 MKI can employ many varieties of anti-ship missiles like3 × Kh-59MK,4 × Kh-356 × Kh-31A While Rafale on other hand has only MBDA AM 39-Exocet anti-ship missile. Su-30 MKI also employs varieties of Anti-Radiation Missiles like KH-31P and DRDO Anti-Radiation. Sukhoi (from 1995 era) has been backbone for two decades for IAF and will be continue to be so even after rafel procurement of one Sq is complete.When F-35 is getting obsolete in 2050! So here he conveniently forgets that it also needs technological upgradation as per is own admission in last four decades? Gas bag can you afford to buy Merc / BMW for all your sq. and they are really worth Despite the Sukhoi Su-30MKI is the most modern fighter jet in IAF inventory it is failure how? Why they are increasing the production ? why they are upgrading to SU-35 standards? The Su-30 MKI has also given a fillip to the DRDO, which has designed and developed the aircraft’s electronic countermeasures suite, including the radar warning receiver and frequency hopping radios and identify friend or foe system and engine upgrade. Su-30 MKIs are being upgrade to the ‘Super Sukhoi’, which has features similar to a fifth generation aircraft.
@mr.lagankumar7353
@mr.lagankumar7353 4 жыл бұрын
They will be fresh with no backlog.
@dr.nandishpurli4074
@dr.nandishpurli4074 4 жыл бұрын
bofors too same
@vijayghunowa6160
@vijayghunowa6160 4 жыл бұрын
In the whole he is just denigrating all the possibilities questions he has been asked and in his perceptions there is only one single answer to raise the salary issue. I think he don't know how the daily living costs is so high in the West compared to India, BELIEVE ME EVEN IF INDIAN GOVERNMENT WILL DO WHAT HE WANT AS HE HAS SAID THE HUMAN WILL CONTINUE TO INDULGE IN CORRUPTION. हरि ॐ हरि ॐ हरि ॐ हरि ॐ हरि 🙏 🕉
@vishaltiwari6336
@vishaltiwari6336 4 жыл бұрын
Too simplistic approach! Things are not as simple nor are they as bad as he mami he sound! Training especially is a rigorous process every pilot undergoes a whole lot of itinerary process from his selection to his flying a particular type of aircraft! Only the best go up and qualify to fly not just anyone and everyone!
@satyampandey2222
@satyampandey2222 4 жыл бұрын
Yes, he does not account for the mental capacity of the pilots and the amount of training they go through, even he could get comfortable with the videogames of today if given enough time. He speaks as an expert in too many things. Just like how his "everyone be like china" thing turned over it's head.
@ajaytiwari6502
@ajaytiwari6502 4 жыл бұрын
At 33.44 Abhijit says western country QC manager gets 40,000 USD and in India 2000 USD a year are these figure correct.Min living wage in Huston (US) is 14.60 $/hr= 42000 Per Annum.so QC manager bhik mangta hai kya (on a lighter note) Just asking may be he has mixed up the figures.However his talks are very educative and among the bests on social media.His defence knowledge is top notch.I suggested in Sekhar Gupta's cut the clutter show that if one wants to listen about Defence then should tune in to Abhijit .
@a753951852
@a753951852 4 жыл бұрын
What abhijit is it pointing to at 7:00 is the actual dirty politics that goes in our government (or in any government to be frank) between civil servants.. This is a grim reality of a bureaucratic infighting that leaked into public domain..
@BharatVibes.
@BharatVibes. 4 жыл бұрын
someone needs to make him shadow of PM, wherever he moves......
@tanujsabharwal6435
@tanujsabharwal6435 4 жыл бұрын
It comes from tibet
@balachandarkrishnamurthy8965
@balachandarkrishnamurthy8965 4 жыл бұрын
But good point wrt technology independence but still China is still dominating the global platform. So hard d difference?
@OpinionSquare
@OpinionSquare 4 жыл бұрын
WONDERFULL.. AAP DEFENSE PAR HI BOLA KARO... DUSRE TOPIC PAR AAP GUR GOBAR KAR DETE HO
@Rajan112358
@Rajan112358 4 жыл бұрын
I disagree on that our pilots won't be able to handle french jets because they are more customed to Russians one's ... Every field offers similar challenge ... See banking for one... I would say our pilots are cream of the bulk .. they would be able to change from Russian to any change .
@AnandRajappan
@AnandRajappan 4 жыл бұрын
Very positive thinking but we should be practical as well, Abhijit is not challenging the capabilities of our pilots, he is saying to change the basic structure in terms of manpower training, etc. We have to improve ourselves for sure.
@ravichandel8690
@ravichandel8690 4 жыл бұрын
mku ltd kanpur ki company hai
@GurpreetKhokhar
@GurpreetKhokhar 4 жыл бұрын
We'd like to know your views on su 57
@CharlieNotChaplin
@CharlieNotChaplin 4 жыл бұрын
Follow him on Twitter
@balbhattfromthirdofsevenof7496
@balbhattfromthirdofsevenof7496 4 жыл бұрын
Read to know why Abhijit Iyer Mitra is highly placed Pro American useful RW IDIOT. What is this nonsense he is comparing air force pilots with infantry man. What is the idea not to have latest tech in one squadron to start with. This idiots was advocating American fighter jet F 35 and arguing to stop purchase S400 Missile Defence Equipment. And how many countries developed F-35 or F-22 asshole there is difference between manuf spread so that every stakeholder benefits from manf activity as compared to development fund contribution and actual development and Manuf. DRDO as if it was acting independent and there were no Dalals and bureaucracy to undermine the efficiency. From American F-35 (Still perfect search for Japan's F-35's first crash) to Soviet Mi-24 Heli how many decades it took with multiple monumental failures and money in spite of military industrial complex being there took, stop this classroom example idiot. 36% says God about technology transfer how you arrived that ? Heard about Brahmos ? Satellites are they about precision, quality control and communication devices and integration of things. 40K USD what is PPP? idiot how Ihat is not true for ISRO? So global supply chain is only one way phenomena or two way i.e. your own Mohan-OEM-German example ? "We Invest in human being and not in platforms " or vice versa make up your mind ? what are you ? Brain Damage Drama Queen American-liar-Mitra? Ass holes they are very well trained (300 Hrs) ever heard of that ? What this guy thinks this is video game you open the box and start learning? They can fly unforgiving Mig 21 just like that? They can kill F-16 by Mig 21 by fluke ? This fart is telling you that upgrading to Iphone is difficult from bar phones , so pilots are shepherds ? Info processing is easy because of new age tech or difficult make up your mind! Israel got all the support from the west.for decades.. gas bag! How use of russian language by navy helped in deceiving during indo-pak war. So middle east russian mission were done in American and european jets? So second biggest defence supplier country is garbage supplying to 45 Countries and producing next gen weapons 1.Kinzhal 2.S500 3.Avangard 4.Poseidon 5.Burevestnik 6.Cyberwarfare? Then why american stole Mig 21 jet and Mi 25 heli to study. There is difference in quality and price of each manf say in case of Automobile. Even Merc & BMW are not that great reliable quality they used to be, ask any good trustworthy mechanic. F-35 EOL in 2050 we are still MiG 29 does not prove it's robustness? If operation & maintenance is not done even american will not stand up to the performance levels, in fact russian machines are far better in taking such beating then those fancy ones. China buying russian Su for fun or scrap value? F-35 is perfect ?? Japan dropped one in sea, and why Mitsubishi is developing it own Next generation Jet. Why Turkey happily swapped it despite being committed manf partner in fav of S400 and Sukhoi? If american ones this rabid Brain Damage Drama Queen American-liar-Mitra trying to sell are so great? Integration of Systems The SU-35MKI was tailor-made for Indian specifications and integrates Indian systems and avionics as well as French and Israeli sub-systems, so stop talking baloney. and do you guarantee future integration of russian missile or any other system from other country with rafael ? For all the reasons from geo-political this integration will always be a challenge until unless you become one supplier dependent, in fact that is also not possible in real world. Unless you have one end in your control either the equipment / aircraft / weapons systems. You are dependent period. That is also why we need to have indigenous 5th G Aircraft. Will american do it for you ? They are going to give away tech as russian do ? Never kept all eggs in one basket (Mirage and Mig) MMRC Rafael is far better in certain capability integrated technology, long range capability and smart weapons no doubts BUT Su-30 MKI supermaneuverable air dominance is one of the best fighters in the world in aerial combat. The redflag exercises between USAF and IAF demonstrate this. ....and he calls it failure ? Su-30 has a chance against the F-22 ->> www.ausairpower.net/APA-Flanker.html But what is the cost ? and isn't it high maintenance cost ? So over all high cost of purchase (Twice) as well as high maintenance cost (30%) and factor in more for currency issues, so fleet from 80% vs Sukhoi 50% is any way becomes offset against each other? But in terms of delivering weapons which fighter is meant for can it really do it all ? No. it carries a smaller less capable radar and fewer missiles than the Sukhoi. Su-30 MKI can employ many varieties of anti-ship missiles like3 × Kh-59MK,4 × Kh-356 × Kh-31A While Rafale on other hand has only MBDA AM 39-Exocet anti-ship missile. Su-30 MKI also employs varieties of Anti-Radiation Missiles like KH-31P and DRDO Anti-Radiation. Sukhoi (from 1995 era) has been backbone for two decades for IAF and will be continue to be so even after rafel procurement of one Sq is complete.When F-35 is getting obsolete in 2050! So here he conveniently forgets that it also needs technological upgradation as per is own admission in last four decades? Gas bag can you afford to buy Merc / BMW for all your sq. and they are really worth Despite the Sukhoi Su-30MKI is the most modern fighter jet in IAF inventory it is failure how? Why they are increasing the production ? why they are upgrading to SU-35 standards? The Su-30 MKI has also given a fillip to the DRDO, which has designed and developed the aircraft’s electronic countermeasures suite, including the radar warning receiver and frequency hopping radios and identify friend or foe system and engine upgrade. Su-30 MKIs are being upgrade to the ‘Super Sukhoi’, which has features similar to a fifth generation aircraft.
@CosmicValkyrie
@CosmicValkyrie 4 жыл бұрын
@@balbhattfromthirdofsevenof7496 Learn to use english instead of google translate. i tried reading your text wall, but you can't write. You're shitting on your keyboard and hoping it makes coherent sentences.
@balbhattfromthirdofsevenof7496
@balbhattfromthirdofsevenof7496 4 жыл бұрын
@@CosmicValkyrie One who speaks better english aren't better at whatever they are claiming they are good at and that is fundamentally the point of communication. Get you fundamentals right!
@thedroidbha
@thedroidbha 4 жыл бұрын
Abhijit, what you say is true, but I think you are too pessimistic in your attitude, most young pilots are not grandma...
@dr.nandishpurli4074
@dr.nandishpurli4074 4 жыл бұрын
head count
@rahulnanda93
@rahulnanda93 4 жыл бұрын
40:20 That's why we need Indian way off teaching Gurukul because it concentrate on the development of human being.
@t.s.p1864
@t.s.p1864 4 жыл бұрын
We strongly need change in our education system, current education system kills creativity within the individual. I would like to press a eg- people are cursing pubg in India here and their. It's conceptual idea was formed by a guy who was in his late 30's Brendan Greene India as a society has this negativity towards anything new or disruptive, still it's utter shame that we Indians still don't have that million dollar gaming industry in focus, if you observe keenly we as society is just a consumer not a creators why. Thank to British education system. Our mobile phones operating systems forces us to change the mobile model but we aren't changing education system. India me teachers wo log bante he jinhe kahi or naukri nahi mil rahi.
@saptarshi7587
@saptarshi7587 4 жыл бұрын
Mr. Abhijit is telling, as if the air force pilots are recruited and immediately asked to fly the fighter aircraft. They are given rigorous training and then they were put in an aircraft. Our software and hardware engineers are also from similar back ground and doing world class work. So, change your narrative.
@harindersingh3706
@harindersingh3706 4 жыл бұрын
www.rbth.com/blogs/stranger_than_fiction/2015/08/07/flanker-fury-how-the-sukhois-blanked-the-typhoons-12-0-in-british-skies_382281
@gabbarrf1745
@gabbarrf1745 4 жыл бұрын
No one believed it pappu lost.
@ravichandel8690
@ravichandel8690 4 жыл бұрын
f16 why america dont want to transfer
@reviewandinfo8863
@reviewandinfo8863 4 жыл бұрын
he hates russian equipment... so dont take him seriously on russian equipment.. su30 mki is vry capable fightet ..ignore his opinion 😏😏😏
@ak06041
@ak06041 4 жыл бұрын
And he also says our military don't intermingle with outside world, then what the fuck is all those military exercises we do with other countries.
@reviewandinfo8863
@reviewandinfo8863 4 жыл бұрын
@@ak06041 brothet he is US agent for marketing US weapons.. american lobby recruits such typ of man who hv influence on indian public... dont take em seriously.... su 30 mki is vry capable fighter nd s400 capability is far better than american pac 3 missile system
@reviewandinfo8863
@reviewandinfo8863 4 жыл бұрын
@@ak06041 brother OTA is giving training to foreign army personnel.. indian Air force,navy ,army all r interconnected wid whole world ..scout master chaimpiyanaship won by indian army lately.. army defeated chinese ,russian, american armies in dis championship... abhijit aiyer mitra is a pessimist american agent ..ignore him 😏😏😏
@harindersingh3706
@harindersingh3706 4 жыл бұрын
www.rbth.com/blogs/stranger_than_fiction/2015/08/07/flanker-fury-how-the-sukhois-blanked-the-typhoons-12-0-in-british-skies_382281
Weaponizing Victimhood
58:09
Pondy Lit Fest
Рет қаралды 54 М.
Vivaan  Tanya once again pranked Papa 🤣😇🤣
00:10
seema lamba
Рет қаралды 34 МЛН
100❤️
00:19
MY💝No War🤝
Рет қаралды 18 МЛН
THE POLICE TAKES ME! feat @PANDAGIRLOFFICIAL #shorts
00:31
PANDA BOI
Рет қаралды 24 МЛН
Bharat Shakti-  India and the changing world
1:32:07
Pondy Lit Fest
Рет қаралды 52 М.
The Big Picture - Rafale: Where is the scam?
22:13
Sansad TV
Рет қаралды 37 М.
ABHIJIT IYER MITRA - INDIA AT 75: THE NEED FOR JUDICIAL REFORMS
32:00
Pondy Lit Fest
Рет қаралды 20 М.
Defending India - the state of our affairs || Abhijit Iyer-Mitra
49:55
What Changed In India After The Bronze Age?
1:19:34
The Cārvāka Podcast
Рет қаралды 67 М.