Really? Then you must really be bugged how oversimplified the Silent Hunter 4 sonar is. When you read the manuals you read all about the acoustic vs the supersonic, with all the filters available to the real sonar operators and realize that submarine simulation is in its infancy. It just isn't that realistic.

RockinRobbins13 lol its not that it bugs me, its just weird haha. dont get me wrong, i couldnt do it in this game cause its not at all like how we do on my ship.

I should hope not. Real sonar operation is a team concept, not an individual pursuit. And I trust we've learned a thing or three since WWII. And of course now you don't need an exact solution anyway. You get one that's adequate, send out the MK-28 and it does the rest.

RockinRobbins13 absolutely. its and art and a science. i love me some ASW

There was no HD when this video was made. It shows the process clearly and nine years after it was made is still the only video on You Tube showing sonar only attack with the position keeper. He's no longer making videos and this one is clear enough that my cat understands how to do the attack.

Hi RockinRobbins13! Always wanted to talk to you. Thanks for the support and advice thru the years. I've been playing this simulation since Silent Service on the Atari 800XL. My question:How do you use sonar only approach against convoys with escorts listening? Again, nothing but the greatest admiration. Good Luck and Good Hunting

bit late, but did you ever work this out? Using sonar-only against merchants with warship escorts is really difficult. :(

With the game sonar it is very, very difficult to do sonar only targeting with convoys. Mostly you can only position your boat so a single target is isolated from other targets. Mix in the escorts and then they can know you're out there and what direction you are, but don't know your exact position. That's bad enough that use of active sonar around escorts isn't really advisable.

_"Originally published _*_by Werner Sobe_*_ on __Subsim.com__ in _*_July of 2007_*_ "_ Always helpful if one's able to read. Both video titles *and* descriptions. Thus the uploader can obviously not try HD at any _'next time'_ , for he's not Werner Sobe. And in 2007 when the video's originally published (in a forum and not even on YT) YT was first 2 years in existence and still KZfaq and not the Googletube of today.