You can't understand these poems until you read whole poetry. In Shikwa Allama Iqbal complaint about failure of Muslims nowadays and in Jawab e Shikwa he told the reason of failure, as our ancestors were hardworking, contributed a lot in science and different things. So in Shikwa he was complaining and in Jwab e Shikwa he told the real reason of failure, as we all know the reason of failure.

There were only a few parts of Shikwa and Jawab e Shikwa included in this performance. If you get a chance to read the whole poetry you'll see all the questions were answered one by one.

For context on poetry, the second part is not from Iqbal's poetry. The actual Jawab that Iqbal has written is incredible, even better written than the Shikwa part if I may say. It's directed at Muslims and almost insults/ tells them off rather than comforting. Really interesting poetry

Greetings from Pakistan. This time yourself really made us wait patiently for your wonderful reactions. Your reactions are the most original ones around and second to none. Best wishes for the channel. With warm regards

You have choosen wrong video... you should listen to zia muhiuddin. With subtitles... and jawab e shikwa part is the best

He did not change any lines, he wrote another poem 'Taranay e Milli'. The poem you talked about is 'Taranay e hindi', a different poem.

It's pure poetry...ke Muhammad(saw) say wafa TU ham teray Hain.......apko samj nhi ayega.....mushkil hai apkay liay........

Shikwa means complaint. Allama Iqbal complaints about the poor position of muslims in this world and asks god why he isn't doing anything. And Jawab e shikwa (Answer) tells the arguments of God against these complaints. This is deep and contextual

Your Ananlysis was Truly Awesome Sister... Even lthough you admit that you didn't know the context of certain words and terms. Lots of Appreciation from Pakistan 🇵🇰

The coke studio one is just a small portion of Shikwah and Jawaab e Shikwah. you have to watch the full poetry dubbed by Sir Zia Muhiuddin on KZfaq to completely understand the poetry.

Many people reacted on this song but no one try to Understand as you did. I really appreciate this. I love your reaction how you understand the things logically .

jwab e shikwa ka maqsad satisfy krna tha, iss lea softly play hua.

Most people don’t like this rendition but I think it has its own merits

this is basically a conversation sort of between human and his creator. Human has alot of questions and then his creator answers.

Madam why Allma iqbal changed?? When Jinnah was known as ambassador of hindu muslim unity and he changed why?? Kindly look the characters of Hindu leaders of that time..they forced both great leaders to Change thier.minds

The basic message of this poetry is that nowadays younger generation of Muslims complain why we are suffering today. In reply God says that you are not as committed and sincere in pursuit of truth as were ur ancestors. Reference of Hatim . He was famous in Arabia for being extremely generous.

Jawab e sikhwa is not that easy to understand it has some references that you have to know 1st Then you are able to understand

Would love for you to be more consistent with the reaction videos. Your reactions are the only original reactions on youtube atm.

Good to see you after a long time with this song❤

nice one, thank God at last you reacted again.....

Lots of love from Pakistan 🇵🇰 I love your way to explain well explained really appreciated much respect 🎉 Keep it up ❤❤❤❤❤

Male part is not written by M Iqbal, only two verses was from Allama s poetry

Awww thank you ananya. Finnaly ❤

I love your reactions because your reactions are very different than other reaction videos

Poet of the nation

this compostion and this style is originally composed by the father of Abu Muhammad and Farid Ayaz (the qawwal group) . The great, Munshi riyazuddin Qawwal qawwal and it is complete Shikwa Jawab e Shikwa is about 36 minutes. that was too good. And Natasha was genuinely a banger Farid Ayaz are good in other qawwalis butthis version is not upto mark because they have tried to mix other poetries in it and it become normal.

you should listen this in zia muhayudin's voice✅

You should listen the zia muhiuddin

Bhai kamal hai .aap kaat diye kaffar ke lashkar kisne itne jhoom.ke sun rahi hai

Always Love your reviews...❤ Yeah... energy in the first part was matchless... But the composure of the 2nd part was also great... though these lines were not by Iqbal... Since the 2nd part was not exactly Jawab e Shikwa, it couldn't have the same energy or the same level that you were talking about because, i feel, it was more like a qawali and obviously by a different poet... But still I feel the fusion was very smooth and calming... Also I suggest you should read Shikwa & Jawab e shikwa... Line by line with proper meaning... You would surely love it... Support from Pakistan...❤🔥

sister if really want to listen sikwa jawab e sikwa in question answer form you should listen that is sung by Amjad Freed Sabiri

I like way you explain ❤❤❤❤

They literally destroyed Iqbal's poetry by adding their own lines. You should read original Shikwa/Jawab-e-Shikwa.

Ananya u have a great sense of music.

React to Shikwa and Jawab e Shikwa recited by Zia Muhiuddin. You'll definitely like it.

I think you’d really like neer bharan from coke studio!!

Welcome back 🎉

Why do we suffer a lot of wait for your reaction video???? 😢😢

Counter questions don't mean that there isn't any answer actually Counter questions are the answers but counter question shall be asked from one who surely know the answers of that questions like Who created you as we all know God created us all so these are universal truth

Loved your reaction. Plz consistently make reaction videos.Even though personally, I also loveee the Shikwa part much more than the Jawab. But it's much more enjoyable if you understand the poetry, so I still listen to it.

sister this video is not on full version of shikwa jwab e shikwa and have some mistakes too. I've read full book so I want you to read full book's translation ,it is easily available on google . Basically an ordinary Muslim addresses Allah in shikwa that I'm suffering although I did everything for u, he talks about his trials and in jwab e shikwa, Iqbal writes a reply from God that u did nothing for me, it were ur ancestors, true Muslims, you are not good Muslim anymore but you can achieve ur lost status if you truly know ur place and love PBUH, this whole book is very interesting

Allama ne Jab Sikhwa Likha, Kufr Ka fatwa laga (that he is amongst the disbeliever) or jab Allama ne Jawab e Shiqwa likha tog Rahmatullahi hogaye (amongst those who have recieved God's mercy). Eisa kyun hua ? Eisa isliye hua Kyun ke Shikwa E Shikayat hai ek Bande ki/creation ki uske Banane Wale se/creator se. Jab koi banda apne Khuda ko hi challenge kare ya usse shikayat kare toh kufr kehlayega but little do they know, Allama Iqbal Was something else, phir jab Jawab e Shikhwa likha toh Allah ka Jawab hai uske bando ko jo Allama Iqbal ke Kalam se hum tak pochcha, jismein khuda keh raha hai kyun Pareshan ho raha hai bande kya tera mudda hai, humne toh dene ka wada kiya hai or phir Or bhi Jawab shamil hai Jawab e Shikwa Nichodh ye do line hi hain Ki Muhammed se Wafa tune Toh hum tere hain Ye jahan cheez hai kya Loh o Qalam tere hain, Yani Muhammed ﷺ se wafa karne wale jo chahein takdeer mein likhte hain. Or ye Makam Wali Allah ka hai.

Hello Sister... First of all my sincere compliments for this reaction..... But a suggestion (as I believe, there is always room for some improvement).......... If you want the true essence of Shikwa - Jawab e Shikwa, please listen to it sung by Amjad Farid Sabri and Naeem Rufi. A humble suggestion!

THis song doesn do even 1 % Justice to the original Poem By Allama Iqbal. Shikwa & Jawab e Shikwa. This is a cringeworthy rendition of the two legendary poems. My humble suggestion to check out the poems

you should watch poetry one by one shikwa and jawab

Sister ap scholar hai

If you're interested in whole shikwa jawab shikwa its best sung by NFK , with whole question and answer.. here they just picked few verses which doesn't provide context

Hello sis, is mein shikwa ak bandy ka apny Allah(God) se hai or us shikwa ka jawab Allah(God) apny us bandy ko deraha hai or isi ko hi jawab e shikwa kaha jaata hai.anyways lots of love and respect from Pakistan 🇵🇰🥰

Nice one Waseem tahir Nottingham uk 🇬🇧

You should listen to shikwa and jawab e shikwa by Amjad Sabri and Naeem Abbas. It's longer than this but it's definitely worth it

Natasha Baig ❤ sista

Its not easy to understand the philosphy of the bigest of all philospher of asia Allama muhammad iqbal

React on 'Bonobibi' from Coke Studio Bangla, Season 2 please. 🇧🇩

try Gorakh danda from nescafe basement you will like it

Coke studio Pakistan 🇵🇰 15 come ❤

They did not do justice to the original poems. One of the only times when the CS missed their mark with re introducing the classic to the new generation.

coke studio pakistan ka naya gaana aaya h Pashto language me , kal se 10 baar sun chuka hu aap please jaldi uska reaction upload kar dijiye

Ananya, you should check out Kahan jaoon by very very unique n progressive Pakistani band Bayaan.... it really will mesmerize you. plz do it soon

When Alama Iqbal Wrote Shikwa tye people at that era took it negatively hence Alama Iqbal wrote Jawab-e-Shikwa

Everyone knows that Iqbal wrote lyrics of Sare Jaha se Achha, but very few know that Pt. Ravishankar composed the popular original tune of Sare Jaha se Achha ( today's time) in the 1940s, which we still use today. 😅😅 Pt. Ravishankar doesn't get enough credit for his great musical compositions like Sare Jaha se Achha. I appreciate you mentioned about Tarana-e-Milli because very few pakistani people know about that. Tarana-e-mill is nothing but radical political ideology of Khilafat. ( global Ummah)

If you read whole poetry then you will understand and it will shook you from internal

Original song sung by Nusrat sahb. Listen to that as well.

Wow. Allama Muhammad iqbal Rehmatullah Aleh was an amazing so great legend great poet, scholer politition, First Iqbal wrote shikwa with Almighty Allah.. then Iqbal wrote Jawab shikwa as like answer to the human in responce of shikwa, outclass poetry as like answer from the Allah... But the singers would sing the original pure lines of Iqbal's jawab e shikwa. And these are few lines but the whole poetry of shikwa and jawab e shikwa is very long and outclass must read it thoroughly.

It's said that, you are the product of your time. That was a time of struggle, two back to back world wars, British were squeezing evey last drop of resource for the war effort, using "divide & conquer" strategy, and much more. This resulted in unrest in the indian society. This is when Iqbal adopted"esprit de corps" ideology. This shift is clearly reflected in the latter part of his career.

Allama Iqbal is great Muslim leader❤

U should go for reaction of shikwa and jawab e shikwa poetry version with ertugrul ghazi cinematic version..

Lady I don't know who you are, but I like you. You should do more videos likes this.

Bhai khatarnak cute ho yar tm

Bring more of Iqbal please.

sister naraz met hona ap ka reaction phle bar dehka hen del kohs ho geya mger 1bat hen k us poetry ko 1smjhdar muslman hen smjh skta hen jawab e shikwa men allah jawab de rhey hen k muslmano tum boht azem kom teh mger tum kohd ko bohl gey ho or muslim ke eyes open kr rhey hen allah

Lols what a reaction jesy dhinchak poja ko Lata ka song smjhany bitha Dia hehe hehe sorry sir reaction sy phly Allama iqbal ki Shiri smjho😅😅😅

Why don't you give reaction on ADAM Coke Studio, it is also sung by Abu Muhammad and Fareed Ayaz and it is in persian but the music love it... Lot's of love from Pakistan 💙

| Ilallah| Sounds of Kolachi from the same season is also worth watching and underrated gem. Do check it out.

Its not like that... Shikwa ALLAH se kiya ja raha hai or jawab mn ALLAH pak jawab de rahey hain it's like that ♥

Madam Pakistan season 15.14april SE start ho Raha h

@ananya dwivedi..if you doesn't know the meaning of lyrics you always feel bore...my suggestion is for you, first understand the meaning of lyrics then listen it, i am pretty sure, you will not feel bore during it songs, bcz complete shikwa and jawabe e shikwa is very big like more than 30 min..and don't feel bore while listen it.

Originally Iqbal wrote this as a conversation between a Muslim Human and ALLAH.. in first part, Muslim Human is complaining and then Allah answered in 2nd part

Hii ap ko jawab e sikwa pura sunna chaye Allama iqbal sune

Pointlessly reaction

I appreciate your interest but you will have to read it in Urdu to comprehend it fully. A very intelligent review though 🙂

Insan na is dunya mein fitna aur shar se bhara ha aur na shukar bhi jitna bhi do nahi peat bharta aur ki khowaish karta ha asal mein uska peat moat bharti ha aur khuda ki nafarmani karta ha aur nainsafi karta jo dil chahte ha wo karta ha ya janta bhi ka ya galat ha aur garib aur maskeen ka mal khata ha aur apna mal par itrata ha aur garib ko zakat ya uska haq nhi deta asa insan allah se sawal karna ka qabil ha jo bara insaf karna wala ha phele apna ap ko aik a acha insan banye phir khuda se sawal kare khuda deta ha ya nhi khuda na hume is dunya aur rehna ka tarika bhi batya ha agar amal kare kesi sawal ki zaroorat nhi pare gi

Ki Muhammad se wfa was full answer to the whole question but you don't know the context that's why. But admin your efforts and courage of knowing.

You tried and we appreciate that. But even urdu speaking ppls such as myself can't understand what he wrote. Its not even the 2% of shikwa/jawabeshikwa. Dr Allama Md Iqbal was a genius. He wrote Shikwa as a complain to Almighty from a Servant( the islamic scholars from that time even gave a fatwah that ALLAMA IQBAL is KAFIR cuz he's unthankful and complaining to Almighty) but than he wrote Jawab e Shikwa. An answer and a return complain from Almighty to his Creation and Jawabeshikwa is A Masterpiece. i had to research it for almost a year running for explanation round & round asking every damn teacher, scholar and Urdu literature Master. And believe me i still can't explain properly what he wrote. As a Muslim we got the Message but the meaning of this Poem is still a mystery. Ps:: sorry for my English its a lil tuti photi

Shikwa was written by Allama Iqbal in 1909 I think, and Jawab-e Shikwa was written in 1913. So you've listened only 2,2 lines of each part. So you can not understand the context of the poetry.

Agr ap iss poetry ko samjhty na tu apko pta lgta k dono part ghazab k hain

Age bhi hai .. Kiski hebat se sanam sehme hue rehte the ..mih ke bal gir ke allah ho ahad kehte the...mubarak

Coke studio k or bhi track pr reaction den ap.... season 9 or 10 k track par

This is just a fraction of the original, the orignal Shikwa and Jawab e Shikwa is very very long. 80% is omitted from this.

I request again react on The Artist season 1 Ahmed jahan zeb

It's just the tip of an iceberg you have heard you should study about these poems SHIKWA and JAWAB E SHIKWA more.... It's a very controversial poems of their times

Season 15 coke studio first song Aaye Aaye released.

Mam what about Aaqa Song reaction

Shiqwa me Jo Jo shiqwa hua hy us ik ik ka jwab, jwab e shiqwah me hy

React On Umran Langiyan❤ By Ali Sethi And Nabeel, You will Definently Love That Song

Hi its not that simple to understand this

Aap sangeet se judi videos pe hi react karti hain lekin agar aap poetry samajhne ke liye zia mohiyuddin ki padhi huyi poetry suney on shikwa and jawab e shikwa. Yeh wala video mostly poetry ki chaah puri nahi kar paa raha tha.

I think this is not the right version. It seems broken , missing verses in between

It is something above your understanding, just listing to 15 minutes of shikwa and jawab and then arriving to a conclusion is not something you can. To understand the shikwa and jawab e shikwa you must know whole circumstances and background, then you might get to the conclusion. And secondly this is not full shikwa and jawab e shikwa

ayo watch allahu akbar

You can't understand this poem until you understand the Islamic concepts