It's been implied in the books and by Hermione that although Sirius is a good person at heart, he's quite the broken and damaged person thanks to his upbringing and his unfortunate gene pool. It's sad that unlike him, his brother Regulus could show his best attributes when he felt cornered.
@b.m.28573 жыл бұрын
He was actually really broken by the long years he endured in azkaban... His isolation and guilt of the death of his best friends.
@margheritarobba31642 жыл бұрын
Excuse me, how was regulus not broken or in any case a better person then Sirius? He was a deatheater until he realised that meant discriminating people (was he a simpleton?). Meanwhile, Sirius was a good person who didn't understand creatures had a right to live). None deserved to die, both died young, as jerks.
@ilovehotpink73613 жыл бұрын
What if Voldemort is calling his death eaters and one of them is on the toilet Sorry mY lOrD I wAs DoInG mY bUsInEsS
@alexashley91403 жыл бұрын
😂
@nickcaputo53853 жыл бұрын
Apperates pants down my lord I was about to wipe
@jodiejebb90283 жыл бұрын
That I think would be funny to witness
@mrmikef103 жыл бұрын
Yeah or when one is rawdogging his wife... They’d both pop up right?
@jmaurice723 жыл бұрын
This comment was made so much better by the fact that I'm on the the toilet right now doing my business
@joaquinmurgarodriguez20993 жыл бұрын
I didn’t even know he stopped trusting remus
@minhajnizam50903 жыл бұрын
He memtions it in the 3rd book wjen they're in the shreaking shack
@herbertnedkailipuahilof.47323 жыл бұрын
Neither did I, your videos are outstanding and insightful! Go Slytherin💚🖤💚🖤💚🖤 (props to my own Hufflepuff 💛🖤💛🖤💛🖤)
@WxlfieEditz3 жыл бұрын
I never even knew that he stop trusting him
@dhivyadharshini21413 жыл бұрын
Same here. I was actually shocked when i read the title of the video
@srushtibirewar51993 жыл бұрын
If you carefully real 3rd book and specially the part when remus told harry how he find them you will understand
@yumichan82773 жыл бұрын
I do believe, that the same goes vice versa: After Worm Tail made it look like he Sirius killed him along with several muggles out in the open, Remus didn‘t know better as to trust the commonly told tale. Only when Harry mentioned he has seen Peter Pettigrew on the Marauders Map, did. he start questioning the past and reconciled with Sirius. So, Let’s be fair - they‘ve wronged each other, but eventually also made it up to each other, renewing their friendship. :)
@SoumalyaHomRoy3 жыл бұрын
Harry telling Lupin he saw pettigrew is only in the movies though. In the books he didn't see pettigrew in the map. 🤔
@klaudiagrob3 жыл бұрын
Harry sees Pettigrew only in the movie. He doesn't see Pettigrew in the book.
@JuanMataCFC3 жыл бұрын
Harry never saw Pettigrew on the Map. that's only in the movie. in the book, Lupin comes into the Shrieking Shack asking "where is he, Sirius?" and Harry has no idea who he's talking about.
@swopekat3 жыл бұрын
I think It's implied that Sirius stopped trusting him first. He's the one that ensured Remus wouldn't know about the change in secret keeper to Peter. Remus stopped trusting him because he still believed that Sirius was the secret keeper and Lily, James, and Peter were all dead. I still like Sirius though, but that was unfortunate.
@katiem23472 жыл бұрын
@@SoumalyaHomRoy Yep. In the book it was Lupin who saw Pettigrew on the map.
@willowwhisper65753 жыл бұрын
They should have used the Unbreakable Vow alongside the Fidelius Charm, as an extra security measure. Wormtail was such a coward that he would rather lie than losing his own life.
@Denem553 жыл бұрын
But the secret keeper has to tell the location to the ppl who wants to visit lily and james or check on them.
@not-so-happypappypatton3 жыл бұрын
Petra Tanyi They could’ve said tell absolutely no one because someone could also use Polyjuice potion.
@Denem553 жыл бұрын
@@not-so-happypappypatton they told Bathilda because she regulary visited the Potters, they also told Dumbledore because we know he visited James and Lily, and also Sirius knew about the location, we saw in Lilys letter, that Lily asked him to come over. Of course they needed to check everyone - probably with a similar method that they used in the 7th book with the security questions - but they stil needed to share the location to some ppl. They had a baby, if something had happened to them they needed ppl to look on Harry - like how Sirius rushed to their home when they suspected that something happened, and how Hagrid took baby Harry after his parents death. As you know even tho Wormtail told Sirius and Dumbledore and Bathilda and probably a few other ppl, it's only the oroginal secret keeper who can share the secret with someone new. So for example Bathilda couldn't tell the location to anyone even if she knew because the spell doesn't let her to do it. This is the point of the fidelius charm
@lixxielix3 жыл бұрын
@@Denem55 👑👑
@jellyfishathogwarts3 жыл бұрын
@@Denem55 The unbreakable vow could have been for not telling Voldemort
@skyrogue19773 жыл бұрын
All it took was one bad choice for a decade of friendship to unravel.
@chillstudy82233 жыл бұрын
who?
@ryankueter83963 жыл бұрын
What?
@Sai-iz3ep3 жыл бұрын
Where?
@mistyseas3 жыл бұрын
Snape saying Mudblood Was a mistake
@ryankueter83963 жыл бұрын
@@mistyseas K
@rustydaboyrobot3 жыл бұрын
Except, Sirius KNEW it was Pettigrew in the end. Prior to that, Sirius may have had doubts about Remus...picking Peter proved that. More and more werewolves were flocking to Voldemort, and that certainly casts a small sliver of doubt. Oh, not because I think Sirius believed Remus would jump to Voldemort, but Sirius knew how fear and distrust from the wizarding community plagued Remus; how without Dumbledore Remus would have never attended Hogwarts. That would have been where Sirius may have thought Remus switching to Voldemort as a valid safety move, but i dont think he ever REALLY thought it was Remus that betrayed James and Lily...he certainly lept to the conclusion it was Peter quickly, and then underestimated Peter yet again. While in Azkaban, Sirius had his worst feelings bombard him over and over, and Im sure his doubt of Remus, even a small one, plagued him. Having said that, Remus is the one who actually had real serious doubt in his friend Sirius; it was not an even exchange of mistrust.
@raven14363 жыл бұрын
You didn't just jump to Peter right away he knew it as soon as he heard because even if Lupin knew where the Potters were he couldn't have told anyone the only one who could was Peter Pettigrew so it's pretty obvious who betrayed James and Lily Potter
@rustydaboyrobot3 жыл бұрын
@@raven1436 That's about the betrayal of James and Lily. Sirius knew it was Peter that told.....someone. That someone couldn't have been Lupin...he already knew. The mistrust is prior to that, and over Lupin's loyalties. That's what Sirius apologizes for; he COULD have picked Lupin instead of Peter and did not, because he wasn't sure. Sirius had a habit of underestimating people..or beings, he had no respect for...Peter, Kreatcher, Bellatrix. He completely respected Lupin, but not werewolves in general, which leads to his mistrust.
@JuanMataCFC3 жыл бұрын
i don't think Remus ever suspected that there was a rat (literally) in the Order until news of the Potters' death broke out. at that time he still believed Sirius was Secret-Keeper, so that plus the news of Sirius apparently killing Peter was what made Remus reluctantly accept that Sirius was the traitor.
@flaviapetrorossidefigueire60443 жыл бұрын
Before the potters died Remus didn’t mistrusted Sirius, he actually trusted him, it was Sirius who mistrusted him first , it was only after the potters death that he mistrusted him bc he thought he betrayed them, well and he doubted sirious obviously bc there were evidences telling that sirious killled Peter And betrayad the potters, how was him soposed to know peter had a brilliant plan of using his transformation as a rat tu run for more than a decade and cutting his own finger to be seen as dead? I mean, sirious was the one who mistrusted him first, and then all left from Peter was a finger so he thought the obvious like everyone else, even dumbledore and the Wesleys mistrusted Sirius after that. But later in the 3 movie both Sirius and lupin realized it was actually peter, and than they started to trust eachother more than anybody else again, and oh the way they hug eachother is so powerful, like they’re saying “ I’m sorry “ and “ I’ve missed you” at the same time you know
@acquadute6333 жыл бұрын
100 th like
@prabhjot1986able3 жыл бұрын
Also, Snape missed the part of the prophecy that "the dark lord will mark him as his equal"
@mstarot27933 жыл бұрын
I figured Lupin gave Sirius fleas at some point and Sirius never forgave him.
@Yara-on5hm3 жыл бұрын
Sounds legit...
@immanuelwarshawsky26843 жыл бұрын
underrated
@tumbleyyahee88243 жыл бұрын
I see the Marauders, I click, it’s that simple.
@Denem553 жыл бұрын
I truly don't think it was because of the lycantrophy. S was not biased like that. They were very young when the war started, just between 17-21, freshly out of Hogwarts and that's when Remus had to realise what the real world had in store for him. He was an outcast, he graduated with top grades yet he couldn't find work, he was struggling financialy. I don't think he would have accepted money from James or Sirius, most likely he was ashamed of his situation, and started to grow distant from them (there is no reference to James giving money to Remus I don't know why you included this in the video). We know that Remus worked at odd jobs, he most likely missed a few order meetings or missions even due to this struggle, and he came up with some lousy excuses, making him look suspicious. And this would hurt Sirius more than anything - he was the least emotionally mature, ha was abused as a kid, the marauders meant the most to him. He was hurt that R started to grow distant and it made him angry. Plus also there was Peter. He only needed to point out Remus's odd behavior, to be less suspicious himself. He fanned the flames to Sirius's anger towards Remus, to make himself the secret keeper. I think when Remus and Sirius blame themselfes for James and Lilys death, both of them are right. Remus had a tendency to sink into his self-pity, and don't ask for help even if he needed it. Sirius is was too quick to get angry and hurt and he acts out. So yeah they fucked it up
@flaviapetrorossidefigueire60443 жыл бұрын
Yeah , They has a strong bond but they mistrusted eachother, Sirius prior to the Potter’s death and lupin after it, since the evidences pointed the guilt towards Sirius. But later they realized that was peter and started to trust eachother more than anybody else again, and their hug and reunion was so powerful, like they were saying “ I’m sorry” and I’ve missed you at the same time
@flaviapetrorossidefigueire60443 жыл бұрын
Also idk about Sirius mistrusting or not wearewolves, I mean , I don’t think so but maybe he thought that they had more tendency to go to Voldemort since they were hated buy the wizards community so maybe Voldemort could brainwash them against the wizards, so that’s why he mistrusted Remus too
@ushas72553 жыл бұрын
Perfect... that's well summed up ...
@jaymoto24593 жыл бұрын
NGL I would love a prequel series on the first Wizarding War that would delve into how the Potter’s and the Longbottom’s thrice defied the Dark Lord and the fight with the Order of the Phoenix. 👀
@mrmikef103 жыл бұрын
Amen dude! That’d be amazing!
@poetscotty3 жыл бұрын
I'm sad that Sirius died and didn't see Harry grow up 😭😭😭
@abrarahmed74263 жыл бұрын
I know Sirius is good he will never do that
@hermionegranger23863 жыл бұрын
Ya.....
@faithfullyfaith1993 жыл бұрын
I thought you said glad.
@andrewgamez79732 жыл бұрын
I've been rereading the books and if I could change the books a bit I would change mostly book 5 and 7. I mean I'd let Sirius show up in person at hogwarts when he wanted to meet Harry at hogsmeade and even show up at a few d.a meetings as a "outlaw" teacher. I would have written Minerva join in the help too. Sirius would stay in her office until late at night then slip out as a dog in the honeydukes or whopping willow paths. Now he would still have died but not in that book but at voldemorts hand in book 7 during the battle of hogwarts protecting his friend lupin or in honor of Harry's life after Harry "death". Tonks wouldn't die but maybe get seriously hurt. In book 5 I'd would have killed someone still but not Sirius.
@anjum38472 жыл бұрын
@@andrewgamez7973 Absolutely. It almost seemed as if he was brought in just to bring about some emotion and life to the story, nevertheless it was a clean job done. His character had the worst fate, from being ostracized by his family, losing 2 of his closest people, cheated by one , chucked in Azkaban accused of betrayal and murder , had to live off rats while being on the run and lock himself up in his parents home he hated over everything - all of this to be sucked into a frikking veil. He did have his douche moments when he bullied Snape and with Kreacher the house elf, but that against everything else he had to endure seems so unfair to me. Even his death served no purpose, all anyone benefitted from him was from material things he possessed - the motorcycle, two way mirror, Grimmauld palace, Firebolt. The other deaths - say of Snape, Remus, Tonks, Mad eye, Dumbledore - although none of em deserved it, all had left a mark, got to accomplish something, but Sirius, he was just gone ,just like that. His potential was criminally under utilised , i dare say Rowling wronged his character. It'd have been so much better the way you said ,having seen the end of war, killed a couple death eaters (presumably Fenrir greyback), maybe get to see Snape's version of things in the Pensive along with Harry for that'd be one strong moment of realisation given the history he shared with Snape. He is hands down my fav character in the franchise, wronged, yet Brave, and loyal till the very end .
@MrPoem-rq7pz3 жыл бұрын
I always kinda wondered that. Their bond was so strong. Thanks for explaining!
@jeremyguillory54403 жыл бұрын
Imagine what happened if Remus was the secret keeper instead of pettigrew
@MrRjhyt3 жыл бұрын
I can't condemn Sirius. His family upbringing primed him for a life of mistrust.
@sifilore94623 жыл бұрын
Next video, The Entire Aftermath of the Battle of Hogwarts. How things went before the Golden Trio sent their children to school. Not counting The Cursed Child, only before Albus Potter went off.
@katemendoza74493 жыл бұрын
I'm a simple girl. I see HPF I click
@sourdough_bagel3 жыл бұрын
@Chloe Mendoza Me too 👍👍😆😆😊😊😁
@klaudiagrob3 жыл бұрын
I guess it is because he thought that Peter Pettigrew was too stupid to pull off something like that. Remus was his easy guess. I guess it's maybe because of his bringing up and Remus being a werewolf. Many werewolves decided to join Voldemort in the First and Second Wizarding World. Times were dark and people didn't trust each other.
@salutetherank21053 жыл бұрын
It's interesting to hypothesize the meaning of a person's animagus or patronus. Peter animagus was a rat. Sirius was a dog. James was a stag. Peter having a rat animagus meant that his fundamental character was a "rat". He ratted out the Potters to Voldemort. Sirius was a dog as dog's are loyal creatures. He was always loyal to his friends. James being a stag could mean his love for Lily (Lily's patronus a doe) or his character being assertive and forthright.
@jasongannon70882 жыл бұрын
Deers also appear powerful but are often prey
@nicolecepero-rai59033 жыл бұрын
I disagree with your statement that Voldemort “scared/intimidated” Peter into being a double agent. It takes away his agency. It was Peter’s choice to look for the big bad. Please let’s not rewrite the story of the biggest rat( pun intended) of the series
@freddymeng3 жыл бұрын
No, Peter was just too much of a coward and when voldemort confronted him, he accepted out of fear
@shreyaajith17043 жыл бұрын
Voldy didn’t have to deal with much resistance from Peter bc he was such a coward and didn’t care for his friends that he must hv gone over without to much fuss
@michaelhowze81983 жыл бұрын
@@freddymeng Yeah but he accepted so that just makes him a cowardly rat. Your making his situation worse not better.
@freddymeng3 жыл бұрын
@@michaelhowze8198 i know he's a terrible person, I'm just pointing out that he didn't choose to seek out evil
@Jusilau3 жыл бұрын
@@michaelhowze8198 that's what he was trying to do.
@babie44053 жыл бұрын
I'd love to see a video on death eaters pre goblet of fire and before voldemort came back, how they were getting on with their lives and if some of them even shamelessly gloated about the fact that they served him, and what happened to those who refused to believe he was back. Always look forward to these videos ✨
@ShivamKumar-lh5xp3 жыл бұрын
True loyalty and expected loyalty... Probably the best thing to recognise in life
@valeriaprado1663 жыл бұрын
I read the title of the video and was so confused until I remembered wolfstar isn't canon.
@CurrentlyABoredPerson3 ай бұрын
nah fr right there
@w0t3rdog3 жыл бұрын
Imagine the scene: The first wizarding war, Voldemort is winning on all fronts, both in Britain and mainland Europe. You are not willing to join him, but not suicidal enough to fight him... what do you do? Pocket bunkers. You send letters to all your friends and family, how to make a bag or whatever work like scamanders/moodys trunks, to create enough space for you entire family to live comfortably and infinitely, and the spell to become the bags secretkeeper (Bill became Bill and fleurs secretkeeper, so it must be possible). Suddenly everyone you know and care about have a secret hideout that cant be found except through treachery. You might get bored, but if the lock down have taught me anything, I can handke isolation quite well. Now, sure, Voldie might win if people dont take the fight... but if you are safe, its only muggles that suffer. So win-win I guess.
@montecristo25533 жыл бұрын
You're such a Slytherin, mate, I'm proud
@user-dx8nl9qm9d3 жыл бұрын
Would do this, But I would use it only to have a portable home. And I'd still fight.
@w0t3rdog3 жыл бұрын
@@user-dx8nl9qm9d it would be a useless fight, as literally only a fatefull fluke could end the war in anything but defeat for "the good guys". I mean, leaving your hidey hole increase your risk of death by... infinite %. As your odds of death by deatheater was 0 while hiding.
@silk_sonic69863 жыл бұрын
According to Phineas Nigellus Black you're a slytherin 'cause he said that when the situation comes they always try to save their own skin and not care about other wizards or in this case muggles...
@w0t3rdog3 жыл бұрын
@Gaius Wyrden well, if Europe was plunged into chaos, I am sure non-european muggles would become aware of the magical world, and find ways to detect magic. It would be like back in the days, before the magical community had a ministry rather than government.. muggles vastly outnumber the magical kind, they just dont have the adequate information as of yet. All it takes is for Macusa or any other government to break the statute of secrecy and openly cooperate. And you risking your life just makes the muggles sheltered. Imagine instead if the barriers between magic and non-magic would fall, with wizards and soldiers joining forces? With nukes and wyldfires, snipers and bombardas. I dont care how immortal Voldie is, a couple of nukes ought to destroy him whenever he gets a new body. Sooner or later, he runs out of horocruxes. A .50 cal ought to tear his head off his shoulders, and disintegrate however powerfull wand he might be holding. From 1000m, he wont even hear the bang before the bullet hits. So getting up a protective spell isnt gonna cut it.
@kaenachoo47833 жыл бұрын
Just wanted to say HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO TOM FELTON aka Draco Malfoy! 👍🏻⚡️⚡️
@RheaElise3 жыл бұрын
Sirius' story keeps me from rereading further than book two :(. For anyone longing to disapparate into the wizarding world: did you know the first Harry Potter audiobook, narrated by Stephen Fry, has been made publicly and freely available to everyone on Audible? You don't even need an account. They have this section on their website called Stories, with all kinds of free audiobooks for "kids of all ages" ;), including Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone (several translations are listed as well). Stephen Fry does all the voices so well, it's a treat to get to listen to him read the book to us ^^.
@vaibhavk13423 жыл бұрын
This is one of or the best Harry Potter channels ever! I love your content keep it up
@GK-we6gi3 жыл бұрын
I'm currently reading the fanfic "Potter" and it adresses that topic too! So thank you very much
@abrarahmed74263 жыл бұрын
No Sirius is good he will never do that
@GK-we6gi3 жыл бұрын
@@abrarahmed7426 you're reading it too?
@nancyjean34713 жыл бұрын
DHSKDHSJDJD POTTER IS SO GOOD 😭😭
@GK-we6gi3 жыл бұрын
@@nancyjean3471 ohh yes it is!
@keijuna13353 жыл бұрын
ahh where can i find this??
@minhajnizam50903 жыл бұрын
This is the first time i watched a video as soon as it was uploaded
@helios32173 жыл бұрын
I’ve wondered this for a long time
@RomanHistoryFan476AD3 жыл бұрын
I do wonder why don't the order and ministry just gather up all their forces and fight one big decisive battle with Voldemort's smaller forces, sheer numbers would surely overrun them right. Dumbledore i reckon could cripple or destroy Voldemort's body at least. especially if he has support from other high-level wizards. How is a wizarding war fought anyway.
@drpuffington_3 жыл бұрын
I figure it's more of a shadow war. Up until they took over the ministry Voldemorts followers were mostly striking from the shadows and that's not to mention a lot of death eaters we very influential purebloods who could puppeteer things behind the scenes. Their main weapon was fear and it's one they utilized well I suppose.
@RomanHistoryFan476AD3 жыл бұрын
@@drpuffington_ Yeah but at some point you got to take the centre of control eventually. to win so surely when that moment arrives The ministry and the order of the phoenix would be able to fully muster their forces and defeat in one pitch battle Voldemort. Maybe JK Rowling just lacks knowledge on how wars are finalised. Make me wonder why the rest of the world did not send aid though, surely the rise of a dark lord in the UK would be an issue that needs to be stomped out.
@psyche.r3 жыл бұрын
CHARLIE WEASLEY AND HIS GANG WOULD'VE COME TO HOGWARTS WITH DRAGONS LIKE, EVERY DEATH EATER WOULD BURN
@RomanHistoryFan476AD3 жыл бұрын
@@psyche.r wonder why he did not.
@michaelhowze81983 жыл бұрын
@@RomanHistoryFan476AD The MoM was hardly unified in opposing Tom. As he says above alot of very influential wizards backed him. The conclusion if the war would've been a turnover. From the more "liberal" wizard faction to the purblood faction.
@slewy63513 жыл бұрын
Welcome my friends! Thirteen years it's been, and yet, here you stand before me as though it were only yesterday. I confess myself... disappointed... Because there was no link to the marauders fan film which you used in the intro.
@lr1x3 жыл бұрын
I agree I loved that movie and didint give credit that's not cool
@gaganc72503 жыл бұрын
HOGWARTS : Legacy is coming on ps5. !!!! Looks like the game all potterhead wanted.
@Tamervlogz3 жыл бұрын
i want it to come on ps4
@gaganc72503 жыл бұрын
@@Tamervlogz well, i don't even have any of Ps, but i am still excited.
@herbertnedkailipuahilof.47323 жыл бұрын
@@Tamervlogz it WILL be released on PS4 :) as well as xbox, PC both versions of the Ps5 and i believe 1 more console. Happy Hogwarts exploring! Go Hufflepuff💛🖤💛🖤
@Emaariee3 жыл бұрын
Tamer vlogz same here
@jeffythedinosaur27923 жыл бұрын
It’s on everything but switch
@Sandrasaki8003 жыл бұрын
I've never clicked soooo fast. Great video, fam, keep up the great work!!
@emilythatblonde3 жыл бұрын
Yes!! More videos about Lupin and Sirius thank youuuu
@bradymac21583 жыл бұрын
Man I really wish they'd make a movie series or even a Netflix show series about the rise of voldemort & the order of the phoenix. Really go into everything in great detail so we can understand just how insanely powerful voldy was & itd get us closer to harrys parents/marauders
@susanpotenzano13283 жыл бұрын
I don't think he mistrusts Lupin. I think he had that Marauder mindset of they could outsmart anyone. This caused him to be blind to Wormtails odd behavior. Arrogance, which runs rampant in this series was a tragic flaw for several characters
@ayeshamailk49283 жыл бұрын
Gryffindor is red Ravenclaw is blue I'm a HARRY POTTER fan So are you 🖤 Tysm for the likes ♡
@sourdough_bagel3 жыл бұрын
@Ayesha Mailk 👍👍👍😁😁
@ayeshamailk49283 жыл бұрын
@@sourdough_bagel ❤
@pawesomeperil18853 жыл бұрын
Bellatrix: Hey Lupin! Will you miss this man? *points to Sirius* Lupin: Well yes, but no. Bellatrix: soo I no kill? Lupin: Well yes, but no Bellatrix:MAKE UP YOUR MIND!!
@Alexa-rv4dr3 жыл бұрын
This just made my day :)
@pawesomeperil18853 жыл бұрын
@@Alexa-rv4dr :)
@Alexa-rv4dr3 жыл бұрын
:>
@LillithO3 жыл бұрын
Why is Harry Potter so good I can’t stop binging these vids
@godofchaos95713 жыл бұрын
Or he did trust Remus but didn't want to put him into any more danger. Hear me out. Obviously, Remus was already in danger because there was a war going on. But, out of all of them, he was also in more danger because of who he was, a werewolf. And, since most of the other werewolves were on the other side of the war, most people believed that Remus would be on the other side of the war too. His friends knew the truth, as did the Order, but that was really it. So, when you think about it, the reason Sirius didn't want Remus to be the secret keeper is that it would put Remus into even more danger. Not only would people come after him to get the secret, but people on both sides would also gang up on him. The bad side because they wanted to know and they had werewolves but even the good side, people would think he'd tell. No one would trust him and he'd be in danger. And the reason he didn't tell Remus about the switch? Same reason. If he told Remus about Peter, there would be a chance that someone would tourtue Remus about information on Peter.
@darija98733 жыл бұрын
I don't really think that.... I mean, he didn't tell Dumbledore about the switch either. And not to the Order. But to Sirius, I think James, Lily and Harry would be more important than Remus so saying he didn't make him the secret keeper is kinda bad... Who ever is the secret keeper has to be 100% trustworthy. Sirius switched because they thought it was obvious he was the sk because he's James' best friend. And choose Peter because that would be the less obvious choice. But he still had to take the trust into consideration and I think he didn't trust Remus enough and convinced James and Lily he was the spy.
@mariacastano89783 жыл бұрын
I have a question, why instead of making sirius or peter their secret keeper they didn't make james or lily the secret keeper? And then no one could ever betray them cause james would be inside the hidden location (the potters house), we know this is possible because in the seventh book bill was the secret keeper while he was inside the hidden location
@TheHappytan3 жыл бұрын
Woah I never thought of that 0-0
@michellewilt44792 жыл бұрын
I always wondered that myself.
@tomtinkersrezlife2783 жыл бұрын
Great work as always dean keep it up my friend
@analis_s28 күн бұрын
For every wolfstar fans: Sirius was the one who did the wolf "prank" on Snape, he wanted Snape to get or killed, bitten or spooked and absolutely ignored how it would be for his friend to find out afterwards of what he could have done. If not fir James it would had happened. Next Sirius was suspecting that Remus bc of his wearwolf curse is the secret spy bc why not. So if they are soooo close almost romance explain this, make this make sense. He always cherished his friendship of James and was severly loyal to him and Lily but well not to other 2 narauders
@garrys2483 жыл бұрын
Thanks Dean, that info shared about how the ministry treats known werewolves, His resistance to Tonks makes more sense now...and also why there would be an underground for werewolves to escape the eye of the ministry, and their society.
@blturn3 жыл бұрын
I love your stuff, but man, that 13-second intro is so long.
@pii12513 жыл бұрын
Yeah, it is definitely overkill xD - Voldemort vs Harry Potter fighting scene transforming into broken glasses that are repaired and the deathly hallows drawn on top of it with the words "Harry Potter Folklore" appearing - way too complex completely unnecessarily :D
@lyndsaybrown84713 жыл бұрын
It's real long, but he paid for it so why not.
@pii12513 жыл бұрын
@@lyndsaybrown8471 Because it's kinda dumb
@HarryPotterFolklore3 жыл бұрын
Well it ain’t going anywhere
@blturn3 жыл бұрын
@@HarryPotterFolklore How lovely
@Lonarix13 жыл бұрын
It’s been almost 17 years since the Prisoner of Azkaban film was released. And it’s just now that I realized Sirius was played by Gary Oldman. 😅
@Edward-nf4nc9 ай бұрын
What I find ironic is that Remus proved to be a loyal friend to James and Lily, and was fond and protective of Harry at Hogwarts, but during the second war he didn't seem to trust Harry when Harry told him Snape was planning against them, and said "your blinded with anger", knowing Harry blamed Snape for Sirius' death "Dumbledore trusts Snape, I trust Snape", yet he and Snape had been enemies at Hogwarts! I think Remus was the most shocked to hear that Snape had killed Dumbledore and likely now knew how Sirius must have felt when he realised he'd been wrong about Peter Pettigrew and like Sirius before him, blame himself for Dumbledore's death and not trusting a true friend! His renewed trust in Harry is likely why he chose Harry to be his son's Godfather. He was someone he knew could be trusted, and with Sirius and Dumbledore dead, Harry was likely the person he trust the most, save his wife I'm sure! There could be some canon proof to this in that Remus was there when Harry used the Resurrection Stone to help him be brave enough to let Voldemort kill him, yet Dumbledore was not there! Dumbledore knew Harry could do it so maybe he didn't feel the need to be there, but Remus was there because he knew Harry needed his help, so he was there, not looking over his son! A true friend! Shame on you Sirius!
@MegaSpideyman3 жыл бұрын
Delighted your still doing Harry Potter stuff. Would be easy to stop due to recent controversies, but delighted you're not.
@henrywayne57243 жыл бұрын
MegaSpideyman Rowling, Rowling, Rowling. *sigh*
@alicianieto28223 жыл бұрын
My sympathy for the Potters dropped significantly the instant I realized they did not have to work a day in their life.
@justadjustor89933 жыл бұрын
🤣🤣😂😭
@WolfRaven1193 жыл бұрын
It would be really cool to see a theory on how Dumbledor would survive Azkaban.
@b.m.28573 жыл бұрын
Hey Dean! I would like to point out something that you missed in the video, since some people in comment section is claiming Sirius was a coward and not a loyal friend. Voldemort was one of the best legilimens in the wizarding world so he would have somehow drawn the information out of the victim before killing them. So Sirius was definitely not a coward but a strategist who thought Voldemort would go either after him or lupin and he could never imagine such significantly important role would be given to wormtail. So this was never about not the fear of getting tortured or being a cissy, it was always about keeping james lily and harry safe. Also he was not completely trustful of Remus's intentions as you mentioned which was but a rather obvious mistake which anyone would have made for which he suffered in azkaban for a very long time. Sirius valued his best friend's and godson's life much much more than he valued his own and in the end he died protecting harry, his god son.
@rozi-nozy-dozy22593 жыл бұрын
Woah, I never knew that! Thanks HPT!
@kechkur28003 жыл бұрын
This is so reasonable dean I like how you explain everything to have it make more sense
@martinstallard27423 жыл бұрын
Could you do a video on why Dumbledore didn't obliviate Snape of his knowledge of the prophacy
@robertcowan76103 жыл бұрын
Dumbledore was willing to sacrifice people, regardless who or how close, if it served his greater goal. Despite changing at a young age for the better, he remained always subject to allowing atrocities to occur, even by his own design, if it served what he judged to be " the greater good".
@MatthewJones-jg4eu3 жыл бұрын
@@robertcowan7610 i have always loved his more cold blooded attitude
@MaxEditzCoolThings3 жыл бұрын
Awesome video!You are my favorite Harry Potter youtuber.
@aevenova97803 жыл бұрын
If Harry Potter is a horcrux at 1 year old, why does he age? Nagini is a also a living a living horcrux, but she seems to be immortal. Hmmm....?
@rosellastar4683 жыл бұрын
There is a difference between being immortal and aging Harry Potter could have been immortal but still aged or Voldemort could have done something to make nagini immortal
@elliekelly88333 жыл бұрын
"My favorite character is umbridge" -Said no one ever
@richardsharpe59253 жыл бұрын
Thank you for your videos.
@gyselalvarez39183 жыл бұрын
no no no they had there moment of distrust and general shock and disbelief but i know that my man lupin and my sirius went back to being everyones favorite gay couple
@justanotherteen56013 жыл бұрын
I see Remus, I click, I’m simple like that
@sohanakapoor18913 жыл бұрын
Knock knock who’s there You know You known who Correct
@rahatjahan88743 жыл бұрын
why was peter a gryffindor if he was such a big of a coward
@battleriteroyalevietnam84473 жыл бұрын
If i remember well, they choose pitergrew because he is too weak to be a candidate for the secret holder, which sirius think anyone with their right mind wont target pitergrew but turn against sirius instead, and by his death, he buying time to protect potter. But then peter offer his friend to his lord.
@bananaoohnanaHEY3 жыл бұрын
I flippin love your intro.
@dika_hilman3 жыл бұрын
This is a great topic! Love the video
@crow_g16393 жыл бұрын
You stop uploading lol either way I am happy you are back
@thegeniusjunkie30823 жыл бұрын
Dean I love your videos
@spidaranubis3 жыл бұрын
I love how more and more HP channels use the Snape and Marauders movie in their videos, I mean it's probably best fan-made movie I've ever seen, and I'm glad it's more or less considered canon by fans instead of cUrSeD cHiLd and shits like that
@joelthomas65173 жыл бұрын
I just remembered that Ron's paternal grandmother was a Black as well.
@kllk12ful10 ай бұрын
Meanwhile poor Viktor had no idea if his girlfriend Greta and his best friends Wilhelm, Friedhelm and Charly were still alive and yes he was very very briefly with Friedhelm who risked his life to save his (Viktor was a German Jew and if it was found out that Friedhelm a German Soldier was consorting with a Jew and given how Friedhelm was already the little brother of a 'coward' and 'deserter' he would've been killed) and it would be the first and last time Viktor would see his young friend alive as Friedhelm was killed three days before the war ended and it would've been another year before he was reunited with Wilhelm and Charly who survived physically but died inside and he would lose his girlfriend- Greta was shot for defeatism just barely over a week before the war ended and his parents were murdered in the Holocaust
@rebeccagreggforeman49363 жыл бұрын
Love this commentary!
@yankeenobonagu6411 Жыл бұрын
batteling overpowered enemies is always a one man job ~dumbledore, snape, voldemort
@CatalinaCNV3 жыл бұрын
I love this channel!
@thelovebugs93883 жыл бұрын
Great video! There was a werewolf shown in this video, 4:26, that is next to Remus Luppin. In my humble opinion, that is a better example of a werewolf, versus the one used in The Prisoner of Azkaban. I'm unsure why the 'type' of werewolf in The Prisoner of Azkaban was chosen, maybe because they didn't want such an 'aggressive' looking creature, instead keeping it within the framework of the books as fantasy. I'm curious about what others think.
@aidanwotherspoon9053 жыл бұрын
Imean, the idea with using Peter instead of Sirius was a bluff. That Peter’s courage was so questionable that no one would possibly think he would be secret-keeper. Which means the identity of the Potter’s secret-keeper was a need to know basis and Remus didn’t need to know
@alisonfarrell57373 жыл бұрын
Love alll your vids
@kechkur28003 жыл бұрын
This video was notified to me 3 days late
@tylersmith94653 жыл бұрын
Great job 👍
@tapuchris33293 жыл бұрын
I love your videos!
@beccajanestclair3 жыл бұрын
Honestly, Remus shouldn't have forgiven Sirius for the "prank" Sirius played on Severus Snape when they were schoolboys. He practically tried to use Remus as a murder weapon!
@Alexa-rv4dr3 жыл бұрын
Yeah, but Remus has always been so kind-hearted that I don't think he could hold a grudge for awhile.
@darija98733 жыл бұрын
I think he did forgive him after a while but lost his trust in Sirius after that. I mean, James, Sirius and Peter were Remus' best friends and he didn't have any choice did he? That's similar as to why he didn't stop them from bullying Snape. He was afraid they won't be his friends anymore. He forgave Sirius but never fully trusted him and that's why it was so easy for Remus to accept the news of Sirius being the spy. He didn't even question it...
@commonsense78333 жыл бұрын
Pretty sure Pad Foot just wanted to spend his life with Prongs hidden on the mountain with the broken back🤔
@rebecca131619933 жыл бұрын
I would of suspect wormtail because he looked like he done something and no one knew where he was.
@Tacitus_kilgore_rdr23 жыл бұрын
Love the new intro
@tylersmith94653 жыл бұрын
Family business back in swing on the road so far
@liamshaughnessy624610 ай бұрын
4:22-9:32 lol ❤❤😅😅😢!
@maxs90623 жыл бұрын
I don’t blame Sirius for thinking of the possibility. I would as well if I were in his position, but I wouldn’t overlook Petter’s cowardness as a potential sign of betrayal. By the way, are you going to give us your thoughts on Hogwarts Legacy one of these days?
@christianmarshal61173 жыл бұрын
I thought the entire reason Sirius recommended using Peter over Reamus or himself was because he was one of the trusted members of his group that, of the three possible members, was the last one that would likely be suspected. Everyone would suspect Black to be the secret keeper first, he was James’ closest friend and a very powerful wizard and a respected member of the Order of the Pheonix, Reamus Lupin would be suspected next since he was also a close friend, powerful wizard and respected member of the Order werewolf or no but Peter Petigrew? Hunched over frightened little boy who seems more like a groupee tag along in their group then an actual Marauder... no one would suspect he’d be given such a vital and respected position... or so he thought.
@wpcgg77863 жыл бұрын
what if voldemort won the first Wizarding war
@copperdapuppers10203 жыл бұрын
You must be secretly Voldemort if you ever say Dolores Umbridge is your favorite character
@k2splashy4313 жыл бұрын
Hi love ur vids
@karinlarasatii3 жыл бұрын
This is cool, but the true reason is that Lupin was in a mission for the order..
@bilsburrito81513 жыл бұрын
i love the new intro
@nickvell44253 жыл бұрын
Remus Lupin was the best teacher in Defense Against the Dark Arts 😍🍫
@Holly-bn3py3 жыл бұрын
I love your videos
@noellschulte14183 жыл бұрын
Okay the intro 100/10
@liamshaughnessy624610 ай бұрын
🕛 0:00-9:32. Time ! 📺⏰⏱️⏳🕰️
@tylersmith94653 жыл бұрын
How 3 magic brothers ilivermornys and Salazar slithering all related