Sim Update 5 Performance Comparison - Still limited by MainThread! - Microsoft Flight Simulator 2020

  Рет қаралды 13,652

Flying Theston

Flying Theston

Күн бұрын

Doing a quick comparison between Flight Simulator 2020 Sim Update 4 and the newly released Sim Update 5 which has promised to bring much needed performance improvements.
There are definite FPS improvements on the graphics side, I'm seeing around 20fps increase, but the limited by MainThread issue is still present, this was supposed to be eased by spreading the CPU intensive jobs across multiple cores, but that doesn't seem to be the case (at least not for me)
Maybe this is a bug in the first launch that Asobo will iron out? Let's hope so!
Comment down below with your findings and whether you're seeing better, worse or the same performance.
The scenery used is Wellesbourne Mountford - EGBW and can be downloaded for free at: flightsim.to/file/1191/egbw-w...
The test PC specification for this comparison is:
AMD 5900X CPU
Nvidia MSI Suprim X 3080Ti
Rog Strix x570 Gaming f Motherboard
32GB 3600Mhz HyperX Ram
Samsung 980 Pro 1TB NVMe M.2 drive
0:00 - Intro
0:10 - Running in Sim Update 4
2:58 - Running in Sim Update 5

Пікірлер: 82
@b1lleman
@b1lleman 3 жыл бұрын
There seems to be a bug on the monitoring display from the sim that you are using, at least for now on update 5. The GPU latency is always 0.000 so it seems to 'think' it's limited by mainthread. But when I set render resolution lower it speeds up enormously indicating a GPU issue. Cheers.
@Baleur
@Baleur 3 жыл бұрын
Runs a 3080 and gets 60fps solid while the game is absolutely maxed out. "So its running kinda okaaay i guess" ............ Are you kidding me?
@light3267
@light3267 3 жыл бұрын
it's gonna be okay right?
@WadeFrick
@WadeFrick 3 жыл бұрын
Yeah...at least he can play it, after the update I can't play at all and he's complaining?
@NC700_68
@NC700_68 2 жыл бұрын
considering how insanely expensive his build is, i somewhat understand.
@petrpan5790
@petrpan5790 2 жыл бұрын
i have pretty much the same setup as he does except for a 5800x instead of a 5900x. and when im sitting at 3rd party airports such as flightbeam denver, i get below 25fps "limited by main thread". so that definately is worth to complain.
@flightsimflyeruk
@flightsimflyeruk 3 жыл бұрын
Interesting, thanks. Thanks also for your SDK videos. Really, really useful.
@152driver1
@152driver1 3 жыл бұрын
Just done similar test at EGBW with Flying Theston scenery installed. My system has an AMD Ryzen 5 3400G with GTX 1660 Super graphics card. Prior to the update I was only getting about 18 FPS with Hi-End settings. After the update getting mid 40's with Hi-End and even high 30's with Ultra. I've also repeated a low level flight up the Thames with all the London landmarks visible, which was previously pretty well unplayable even with Medium settings, now getting mid 20's with Ultra. So I, for one, am immensely pleased.
@SuperGoldenv
@SuperGoldenv 3 жыл бұрын
I’m finding that any photogrammetry I have put in the sim now slows it right down. Without I’m seeing 60 plus FPS. Wondering if there will be a new method of creating in blender to use the same benefits of the update?
@treasureboxrecords3193
@treasureboxrecords3193 3 жыл бұрын
Hi, thanks for your amazing videos. Do you know how to turn off the white dot in virtual cockpit when looking around?
@johncoady446
@johncoady446 3 жыл бұрын
Nice upgrade but some of us have found deep holes around the lakeshores in the US. In front of Burlington VT, I used a floatplane to taxi into one of these holes on the waterfront, and the plane fell some distance 200 ft? down to a featureless blue sphere. Anyone have a theory?
@paulmitchell3608
@paulmitchell3608 3 жыл бұрын
Won't load a flight now crashes halfway on load screen, can't say I'm suprised
@pm.5813
@pm.5813 2 жыл бұрын
Hi, absolutely great Video. Can you tell me how to move around in the secenery as in 2:30`? Thank you...
@deepredson
@deepredson 3 жыл бұрын
So much answered. Thank you again! Multi-threads next time maybe?
@williamstapleford3875
@williamstapleford3875 2 жыл бұрын
Wanted to say thanks for all the SDK tutorials but it now seems that the newest SDK has changed alot of what was done before. Specifically looks like the folder structure has changed. Scenery that used to work that I made no longer works. If you ever have time again could you do a basic update on the newest SDK version. Specifically dealing with creating/modifying airports. Noticed also that with sim update 5 the live traffic and weather are not working. The SDK with developer mode on really pushes the cpu and GPU even with the simulation paused. Im running a 2080super and I7-10875H MSI GE75
@CCitis
@CCitis 3 жыл бұрын
At least you could DL it. I am 5 hours in and it says it is DLing 123 Gbs.... ouch
@MrLathor
@MrLathor 3 жыл бұрын
Only so many process can be distributed to other threads in this type of simulation game. The main thread will always have the perform the heavy lifting of the complex physics calculations. They moved secondary process (AI, Glass Cockpit etc) to other threads, so it should be a bit better, but it’s never going to suddenly result in every thread having equal usage. Many games that don’t have such significant main CPU process (IE, not intricate simulators) can move processes around more easily and still have minimal latency.
@tedburg6042
@tedburg6042 3 жыл бұрын
I have an old x58 computer with a xeon 5675 at 4.4 ghz and a 1660 super. At 1080p I was getting 30 to 35 fps. With update 5 I am getting 55-60 fps. This was a fantastic update for me. I monitored all the cores with MSI afterburner. My main thread dropped from over 80% utilization to 40 % after update 5 and everything is much smoother. I can understand a 4k system being gpu bound, but don't know why you didn't see any performance increase at 2k. This was with live traffic on.
@FlyingTheston
@FlyingTheston 3 жыл бұрын
Great to hear reports of some people getting good performance boosts! It could just be an issue with certain hardware configurations, much easier for Asobo to focus work on the Xbox as they know exactly what the hardware will be, PC is much more of a hit and hope approach.
@Mike-fu3xd
@Mike-fu3xd 2 жыл бұрын
I got no FPS gain after downloading sim update 5; it is the same as always. Can somebody please tell me what I did wrong! I’m quite upset
@joshyoung6879
@joshyoung6879 2 жыл бұрын
hello mate, do you have anti aliasing turned on in nvidia control panel
@omniultima4747
@omniultima4747 3 жыл бұрын
I downloaded your scenery to test it out myself as well. Here's the funny thing. I test ran on 1440p and 4k with your EXACT same settings awhat I get was a disappointment. I never get past 45fps and I'm really frustrated. My system is z590, 11700kf, RTX3080, 32GB RAM Any suggestions? I have the lastest update of pretty much everything.
@FlyingTheston
@FlyingTheston 3 жыл бұрын
Did you try turning off things like the AI Traffic and reducing the road traffic, airport traffic, etc?
@CRAZYHORSE19682003
@CRAZYHORSE19682003 3 жыл бұрын
I noticed a MASSIVE improvement. I have a very mid range PC an I7-7700 GTX-1070 and 32 Gig of ram. I was running the game at mid range settings with a resolution scale of 70% on my ultra wide monitor that has a native resolution of 5120x1440. I was pulling about 20 FPS. Playable but choppy as heck in some areas. After the update I am playing on high end with terrain detail set to 200 and resolution scale of 100%. It is silky smooth and I am very happy.
@FlyingTheston
@FlyingTheston 3 жыл бұрын
That's great to hear someone is seeing a massive improvement!
@CRAZYHORSE19682003
@CRAZYHORSE19682003 3 жыл бұрын
@@FlyingTheston I still have all AI traffic maxed out. I will have to zero it out and see how much of a difference it makes. Running in Ultra in a city I get about 20 frames a second. Technically playable but I would accept slightly less quality for a silky smooth performance.
@Devinci297
@Devinci297 3 жыл бұрын
I'm getting 20fps more. rtx 2080, i9900k. On ultra I'm at 51fps in Tokyo with any GA aircraft.
@tooomba
@tooomba 3 жыл бұрын
wow! that's a great result. I've never had more than 30-40fps in such places with rtx 3070, ryzen 7 @ 4275
@Devinci297
@Devinci297 3 жыл бұрын
@@tooomba I used to get 30 to 35fps there before the update. Now I'm about to test VR performance as well
@WadeFrick
@WadeFrick 3 жыл бұрын
Yes, but what is your screen resolution is it or 3840×2160 at 100 % scaling or is it less, that makes an enormous difference.
@Devinci297
@Devinci297 3 жыл бұрын
@@WadeFrick 1080P at 100% scaling. But I have two more 27in/1080p monitors running as well. So I can probably get better performance by unplugging them.
@happygamer4932
@happygamer4932 3 жыл бұрын
Yeah bc they turned the Graphics down :( the clouds look so much worse
@Boba3d
@Boba3d 3 жыл бұрын
Considering SDK videos, firstly thank you for all tutorials those you did for us. I learnt a lot out of them. Secondly maybe you could cover some SimObject tips, something simple and easy such as custom windsock or flags? :P :D Would be grateful.
@fat696
@fat696 3 жыл бұрын
this!
@patfish3291
@patfish3291 3 жыл бұрын
Same here! I'm on a AMD 3960X (24 Cores) with a RTX 3090 and FS2020 still not use more than 10-20% of my CPU power (Mainthreadt is limited) which leads to only 50-80 usage of my GPU. I get 30fps in VR a Ultra in London which is ok, but it could be much more if FS2020 would only us 50% of my CPU
@SJkopa
@SJkopa 3 жыл бұрын
I have a 5950x and a 3090. How many frames do you get in update5??
@FlyingTheston
@FlyingTheston 3 жыл бұрын
You can see in the video above the sort of frames I'm getting in Sim Update 5
@danielpena-un8vl
@danielpena-un8vl 3 жыл бұрын
I did not know traffic had that massive impact on FPS.... pretty crazy
@sithiradulanjithgalhenaged6974
@sithiradulanjithgalhenaged6974 3 жыл бұрын
It has a massive impact on most sims. Even XPlane.
@caribbaviator7058
@caribbaviator7058 2 жыл бұрын
Until the sim gets ironed or we are stuck on an old code and expect intel or amd to release 7ghz cpus!!!!
@sneaker6792
@sneaker6792 3 жыл бұрын
For some reason I get way better fps in manhattan(40-50) than alaska (20-30 and other regions in the world since this update, what the hell? Any idea why?
@FlyingTheston
@FlyingTheston 3 жыл бұрын
I wonder if a lot of the "under the hood" improvements are for the photogrammetry data and just the auto gen scenery has not had a performance boost? Are you running any custom scenery in the area you're struggling with?
@sneaker6792
@sneaker6792 3 жыл бұрын
@@FlyingTheston I did more testing and found the problem. I don’t have any special scenery. So when I fly VERY close to the ground in alaska and other regions, I drop to 10 fps for some reason, while flying with 50 feet or more altitude is perfectly fine (50fps). Airports are the exception to that fps drop. In addition to that, whenever I put one of the widgets like the vfr map on an external window (like on my second monitor), I lose up to 20fps!!! What!? When the window is in game, no fps loss. When I tested New York yesterday, I had no vfr map, but when doing my ‘’bush’’ trip in Alaska, I did have my map, which explains the terrible fps I had back then.
@Jimbo-in-Thailand
@Jimbo-in-Thailand 3 жыл бұрын
😁👍👍 Glad you're back F.T.! - I'm just now converting my X-Plane custom Roi Et, Thailand (VTUV) airport scenery. I've got a problem I hope you can help me with. I need to modify the default VTUV airport 'ramp' textures that aren't so accurate and need to be modified. Also, for some reason MS also used airport textures for the terminal building parking lot so I can't tweak textures in the parking lot. I haven't found a way yet to modify or delete them. Also there's no taxiway lights or taxiway/runway signs. I tried to add an airport option to my scenery but must be doing something wrong as it wouldn't accept VTUV airport code. And I really don't won't to delete the whole default airport and start over as it's mostly OK as is. PLEASE help buddy! Edit: I'm also using an old SDK version. Terraforming is still a crap shoot! Better to install the latest SDK? Do I have to go thru Windoze and manually delete the older version then install the new one? Thanks! As always, Cheers from Thailand! 😁
@FlyingTheston
@FlyingTheston 3 жыл бұрын
it's always worth being on the latest SDK version. You should be able to add an airport but not turn off existing features. When you add an airport in the SDK it marks the existing airport area as custom but only deletes the existing things you tell it to (in the tick boxes). To provide custom graphics, you're probably going to need to use the apron tool and apply custom textures that way.
@Jimbo-in-Thailand
@Jimbo-in-Thailand 3 жыл бұрын
@@FlyingTheston Well I installed the latest SDK and now everything is completely screw'd! Now it not only won't build my scenery but every one of my custom 3D models that I have successfully imported from Blender during the past few days are listed as "unknown". Also when I click Build, the console windows opens but is greyed out when finished. Behind it is a popup message that says the build is finished but also saying something about exporting that I understand and agree and I must click yes. The popup is hiding behind the console window so I have to keep hitting the Escape key to get it to show up. After that I tried to load myscenery but it's all screwed up and has reverted back to the default. Edit: I've spent hours trying to solve this and come up with this. I found out that the current SDK vsn 13 does indeed ignore all of my imported models from Blender. The Build Console repeats this error for every one of my models. _"[Sketchup_primitive[0] defines "TANGENT" data, but we do not currently support importing tangents. The data is ignored]"_ Of course, I also had successfullly imported the default Blender cube that I textured as a test, and even it didn't show up. Ironically, my custom scenery that I created and installed this week up until downloading the latest SDK looks incredible in the sim. Don't know why those gawd-dam SDK developer clowns had to screw it up for many of us! I really need the last SDK version that works with the MSFSToolkit 0.40.0 for Blender. Got any tips? Thanks!
@photoeducationbydaniel
@photoeducationbydaniel 3 жыл бұрын
Microstutters are caused by the 60FPS, your stutters will go away and you'll have green bars when limiting the FPS to 30. Where you say you didnt see stutters I saw microstutters galore :-)
@dillon17
@dillon17 2 жыл бұрын
This is still not fixed after Sim Update 7... cmon microsoft and Asobo.. please..
@ags911
@ags911 3 жыл бұрын
DX12 and maybe Windows 11 might fix the CPU stuff
@gatechecked
@gatechecked 3 жыл бұрын
No heavy city comparison?
@FlyingTheston
@FlyingTheston 3 жыл бұрын
there are other youtubers who are doing such comparisons, I can do one if people really want, but there will be plenty of that content on KZfaq already
@staceylawing3175
@staceylawing3175 3 жыл бұрын
I gained only 2-3 fps...sad
@gammaraider
@gammaraider 2 жыл бұрын
It's funny how some systems benefitted hugely from the performance update while others hardly did. On my 10900k/RTX3070 it made hardly any difference. (running 3 screens @1920 on Ultra) Still hovering around 40 fps, limited by mainthread. Maybe gained like 4 fps. I'm not complaining but after hearing from my buddy who gained like 20 fps I was hoping for more.
@dillon17
@dillon17 2 жыл бұрын
Mate, even after sim update 7, im still limited by mainthread, and we have the same specs... I cant get above 40-45fps and bad stutters.. Microsoft and Asobo need to fix this asap, I cant play the sim.
@gammaraider
@gammaraider 2 жыл бұрын
@@dillon17 The stutters are strange, I don’t get those. I don’t get very high fps but it does run very smooth, no jittering at all. Are you running low on memory perhaps? Disk swapping may explain it
@yaosio
@yaosio 3 жыл бұрын
Why not go to new york city and really hammer the game?
@FlyingTheston
@FlyingTheston 3 жыл бұрын
As mentioned in this video, there will be plenty of comparisons of New York and other cities, I don't just want to do what a lot of other KZfaqrs will do.
@rahulrathnakumar785
@rahulrathnakumar785 3 жыл бұрын
There's a bit of a misunderstanding here. They did not say you will not be limited by MT. They just optimized the cpu thread usage. Since you have a 3080Ti, you would more or less always be limited by MT in 1440p.
@FlyingTheston
@FlyingTheston 3 жыл бұрын
This isn't correct, I'm not CPU bottlenecking the GPU, what they claimed was they would move some CPU intensive tasks over to the other cores rather than do it all in the main thread. You can see in the video in Sim Update 5 I'm actually getting worse FPS when the AI traffic is turned on and ramped up meaning more of that processing is being done on the main thread and not being handed off to another CPU core. The GPU will only be bottlenecked by the CPU when the CPU can not keep up with the requests of the GPU, the AI traffic is a CPU computation and won't be bottlenecking the rendering by the GPU.
@rahulrathnakumar785
@rahulrathnakumar785 3 жыл бұрын
@@FlyingTheston You are right about the CPU being unable to keep up with the GPU, causing bottlenecks. But the AI traffic appears to be a known issue as I've seen it on a couple of discord servers. Yes traffic is CPU intensive, but so are other compute tasks. I think we can make a comparison by eliminating AI traffic on SU4 and SU5 respectively. I'll report when I'm done installing SU5, as i tested it last night with SU4 & no AI traffic. only road traffic
@FlyingTheston
@FlyingTheston 3 жыл бұрын
@@rahulrathnakumar785 it was suggested that Sim Update 5 was supposed to move the AI traffic off the main thread to alleviate the problem. Even with AI traffic on in Sim Update 4 I was getting around 50/60fps (hitting 70/80fps without it) but in Sim Update 5 I was only seeing around 40fps with AI traffic on and can get around 80/90fps without it on. It may be a bug or something that Asobo have done the work but it's not offloading it as expected, or something to do with my setup or settings, or just they never did offload the AI traffic off the main thread. I'm sure over the next few days we'll find out more. Be interesting to see what others report back!
@FlightDeckMagazin
@FlightDeckMagazin 3 жыл бұрын
Using the SDK and Build, there is a message after the project build process, I must upload to marketplace. But this message is BEHIND all other windows and I can not click it. The only way is to press Alt F4, which close the build messages with errors. So I can not see, which errors occur during a build. Result, it is not possible to develop with the SDK. And the airports are shown as history are not the airports shown there before the update. And if I set my airplane to an airport will not this airport to history. Useless and confusing. Loading time of the sim is not better than before, it needs to much time compared with X-Plane. And as a developer my opinion, this software is developed like we did it in FS2004. It is old garbage. Only pretty pictures.
@Baleur
@Baleur 3 жыл бұрын
What are you even talking about "still limited by mainthread". Of course it is. You're running a 3080....... There's no CPU on the market that can keep up with that gpu. In any game.
@FlyingTheston
@FlyingTheston 3 жыл бұрын
this isn't a CPU bottleneck, this is because the CPU tasks in the sim are being maxed out on the main thread, this isn't the CPU bottlenecking the GPU
@kevinbrook7033
@kevinbrook7033 3 жыл бұрын
The whole point of the update was that Asobo have moved certain tasks that previously had to go through the main thread to other cores. He has a 12 core processor so AI traffic should get its own core. Previously MSFS only made use of 6 cores so those of us with multi core CPU's weren;t getting any benefit from them. Sim Update 5 is supposed to change that.
@jmalmsten
@jmalmsten 3 жыл бұрын
Me, with my head firmly in the world of film and video production and playback, for me 2K = 2048. Maybe 1920 when generous. 2560 for me is 2.56K... or usually rounded down to 2.5K. But not really relevant to the topic, I guess. :P
@czesiek77PL
@czesiek77PL 3 жыл бұрын
Of course you will still be limited by MT. They didnt say otherwise
@FlyingTheston
@FlyingTheston 3 жыл бұрын
I believe they did say that they would spread the load of CPU intensive tasks across more cores prior to the DX12 update. I'm actually getting worse FPS in Sim Update 5 with the main thread limit over Sim Update 4, it certainly shouldn't have become worse.
@simtime7591
@simtime7591 3 жыл бұрын
yep they did, they said this is one of the things they were going to fix, including putting the glass screens on their own thread.
@tehsideshow
@tehsideshow 3 жыл бұрын
1st
@FlyingTheston
@FlyingTheston 3 жыл бұрын
yes you are
@42LGK
@42LGK 3 жыл бұрын
you are alway limitied by something. thats just how it works...
@FlyingTheston
@FlyingTheston 3 жыл бұрын
yes but it shouldn't be worse in sim update 5 than sim update 4 with the AI traffic on. Sim Update 5 was supposed to improve things
@Michael-cs6hy
@Michael-cs6hy 3 жыл бұрын
and AMD is better than Intel or Intel is better than AMD.............. blah blah blah blah
@FlyingTheston
@FlyingTheston 3 жыл бұрын
depends how you compare them. Intel has more letters than AMD, but AMD tends to have more capital letters than Intel
@z3miro
@z3miro 3 жыл бұрын
Yoooooo bro you are serious you are in spectator mode you are not even in a cockpit wallah just to have views
@m0r94n
@m0r94n 3 жыл бұрын
1st
@m0r94n
@m0r94n 3 жыл бұрын
@@Great-Documentaries only a complete loser would cyberbully someone for a youtube comment
Microsoft Flight Simulator | Troubleshooting Sim Update 5 | CTDs and TBM
21:31
New FS2020 Google Maps MOD for the entire world!
14:27
SweViver
Рет қаралды 1,5 МЛН
Зачем он туда залез?
00:25
Vlad Samokatchik
Рет қаралды 2,9 МЛН
Sigma Kid Hair #funny #sigma #comedy
00:33
CRAZY GREAPA
Рет қаралды 30 МЛН
Microsoft Flight Simulator | Sim Update 5 | New G1000NXi
37:13
OverKillSimulations
Рет қаралды 16 М.
No More Lag: Two Most Important CPU Settings for Microsoft Flight Simulator
2:14
Flight Simulator 2020 MUST-HAVE Freeware | 12 Addons that YOU NEED!
8:10
Simulation Channel Deluxe
Рет қаралды 222 М.
Stop the Stutters and Improve Performance in MSFS!
15:40
OverKillSimulations
Рет қаралды 37 М.
Reduce Stutters in MSFS | NVidia Settings
9:48
twotonemurphy
Рет қаралды 41 М.
EA SPORTS FC 25 | Official Reveal Trailer
2:07
EA SPORTS FC
Рет қаралды 9 МЛН