only because he was dreadful as a manager! he never wanted to be a pundit

@@jamesrowland2002how is he dreadful as manager lol

@@muhdpeepguess you don’t know about his managerial career

​@@jamesrowland2002 So is Gary Neville, but yeah. Old footballers go into punditry, nothing new. At least Roy's the best of them all lol

@@theriac1148he was great for sunderland

Judging by his success, his methods worked.

Yes also worked to some of his family members to get a job at man utd's team

@@pedrodavid9079so what?

3d chess

What an absolutely bizarre take on that situation. He didn't do anything of the sort?

the "manager" at my job is the same...sets up workers to create drama....

@@am5790 Yeah, managers tend to do that. SAF had a purpose which is better than the sociopaths in the real world.

Set up? Keane didnt have to, and shouldnt have said what he said, in the dressing room fine, but not to the media!

​@@leonboinczak3346roy keane is roy keane dont send him to the media room simple as

He didn't call himself out on that game. Going through each player is the managers job not the player on TV. He was engineering his way away from the club. He was past it then wanted his pay day at Celtic. He goes off on 1 on that thing he does about the way Steve Bruce and Bryan Robson were treated by club when leaving. Strange how he didn't say anything at the time especially Bryan Robson who he was effectively replacing. It must have been carrying that trauma around with him for years or was he acting up for the cameras. Never heard Byran Robson complain or Steve Bruce. Then he starts ripping through his family. Martin maybe I'm wrong but don't think we've had a better scout since. Darren not a great player but better manager than keane. Cathy Ferguson a lady. Doesn't mention his wife possibly getting neuro tertiary syphilis from the players he was managing so he could stay in job. Probably cause I've never heard of it same way never heard anything about Lady Ferguson. But on don't Roy would have liked his players going live on TV about 1 of his many poor performances as manager of slabbering at him in the dressing room. It's not don't mess with Sir Alex. Any manager that would let that happen has no control over team. Maybe players done that with Keane maybe thats why he had little respect from his players. No player is bigger than the club. What sort of president would that have set for the rest of the players. That's how you end up with toxic dressing rooms. Like ten hag is trying to fix now. When sir Alex was at Aberdeen can't remember the player but was going to be out for a few games. Sir Alex tells him no drinking while your off. Player goes out to pub orders bicardi and coke gets tap on shoulder and sir Alex is standing there. He'd followed him. He knew his players. That's the difference between keane and Ferguson or 1. That's how sir Alex won things with Aberdeen and United. keane it's his fault it's they're fault. Was finished as a player then maybe he might become a exceptional manager and not just exceptionally crap. If it had been any other player same thing would have happened. But don't remember any of us United's naturally gifted players Robson, scholes, Giggs, Rooney, Bruce, berbatov, vidic, cantona to name but a few under sir Alex going on TV or ripping through players publicly if anything they tried to help them and bring them on. Cantona left because he missed a chance in champions League he should have scored to him not good enough to play at that level anymore. Keane engineers a way out cause he was finished. Also on separate note Rio Ferdinand in unlikely event you read this you should seriously look into to places your charity or whatever it is picks out ie CHOICE HOUSING. If you didn't know what you were doing your a fool if you did you a scummy scummy fella try it again and thing there will be a different chain of events. You can take this whatever way you want perhaps take it look in and publicly call the out. Or don't and show yourself for the person you must be

Don't think it's that he wanted him out but knew he was in his last legs and took the opportunity to make a power move which in the short term would sting but long term was right

@@jamesbarry9477so he was right above you with his comment

@@jamesmilne6351 are you a slow brain? He made the best of the situation

Spot on.

Actually roy won the argument with him and he couldn't keep him around after losing the argument so shipped him

Facts

Vaguely remember that, he absolutely ripped into the whole team

@@raygrimes9203 that's a good thing

@@colezee7640 it certainly caused an uproar

@@raygrimes9203 ain't on him

It’s not his position to be critical of individual players publicly. The fans enjoy it but it’s very poor for team moral. Just look at how toxic Roy keane was as a manager, enough said

There's a difference between doing it on the pitch and in an interview. I also assume that he could have been excused for that mistake but then decided to keep fighting with Fergie about it. And he doesn't take that lightly.

Keane was im charge on the pitch, Ferguson off the pitch

Aye but no publicly

Undermining the coach in front of the team is what broke the camels back.

Yeah, it's like asking a kid if they want sweets. Keane is never happier than when slagging others off.

That was all part of a well constructed plan! They wanted him gone! Ferguson knew Keane would react!

T.E.A.M.,all that Keane said shoulda been said in the dressing room,when asked as a pundit say what you want but he was still a Man U player at the time so no doubt he was in the wrong, he did it to ingratiate himself to the fans.

Tbh tho he probably went above and beyond on what he said 😂

​@@albertpaterson2314hang on he was asked to give his opinion by the the clubs tv station which is a public domain and part of the club then the manager says no body should talk about players in public ? Then why ask him to give his veiw on a game they played badly in what was he supposedto do? Say they played well when they didnt smells fishy to me

He’s a knob.

Gerrard, Veira, Scholes, Lampard all better.

⁠@@KevinSmith-wp9qsnah he’s on that level

@@KevinSmith-wp9qsespecially if you’re naming veira

@@jaydenyoung4851never in a million years son

Inaccurate - the players are on a rotation with regards to who is doing interviews for MUTV. Roy Keane Biography 2014 - A swap was done I think it was Gary Neville who covered the spurs game for MUTV instead of me . And the producers asked if I'd do the game, away at Middlesborough when I got back from holiday. They lost 4-1 - disaster; United were awful. And that just happened to be the game I'd be doing! F*cking hell. Later on I'd think, if I'd just done the Spurs game the week before', 'If I hadn't broken my foot', If I hadn't gone to Dubai', If United had beaten Middlesborough.'

@@Nikos169 You’re incredibly naive if you think Fergie didn’t know exactly what would happen if he got Keane to a 4-1 defeat by Middlesbrough

@@paulcasey4282 You’re the naive one. I know the story inside and out mate. Do some research - it was meant to be G Nev doing the interview that day, but Roy had to step in.

@@Nikos169 Do you know what naive means? Even if I’m wrong, that would make me presumptuous perhaps but not naive.

@@paulcasey4282 So we’ve gone from United to an English lesson. Ok 👌🏼 Look up Roy Keane & Gary Neville, off the ball. Uncut. You may find it interesting.. Also you are naive due to your lack of experience on the matter at hand 😉

Low key he was talking about how cold his timberland boots got

I had to watch it, he really did say shiver me timbers

😂😂😂😂

😂

Bro really just explained what we all just heard.

Gayyyyy

Pathetic 😂

​@@alexdyke9225Yes you are!

I'm sure they cry for you spending all that money watching them 😂😂😂😂

​@@bert454crying over millionaires 😂😂😂 sad fuck

Analysis, not rip into.

They are the entertainment division, were you not entertained?

Absolutely correct 💯 per cent

​@@groot_man_They knew Roy Keane is no nonsense They knew exactly who they wanted after losing 3-1 they wanted Roy Roy wasn't even a fan favourite to get nominated MUFC TV knew exactly Roy would get clicks

I’m certain they didn’t ask him to rip the players, they asked him for his analysis. And from what Keane has shown us to be his personality, what would we expect his analysis to be after United play shit?

And now get paid to do that exact same thing😂

That's what I call DESTINY 😂😂

Yeah agreed, and I think Aubameyang should also have been shown more respect by arteta

They didn’t show Ronaldo any respect either

@@MF_JONESauba was shit , at least RK was a decent player

​@@ezekielx7536You mean Ronaldo didn't show his team mates any respect when he publicly humiliated them in his interview with Piers. Fergie was spot on ridding Keane. If you have a problem with the team, you see the boss, not go public and bring the club into disrepute. No player is bigger than the club. That simple.

Almost as bad as Arsenal fans treating wenger, oh no, it was bad but Wengers treatment is easiest worse treatment of a legend throughout english football history

Great comment ✊

Plausible theory.

And what did Keane do after he left united? Oh that's right helped celtic get knocked out by clyde who were down a division at the time the game ended 2-1 clyde but could've easily been 5 or 6 for them Keane was ran off the park and looked out his depth by the genius attacking football and brilliant tactician that Graham Roberts 😂

@@Johno1992 whats that got to do with what fergie did to keane. Keane had barely a season left in him when he went to celtic as he retired the following year. Fergie could of handled it better but chose not to and has a history of it too just look at what happened between him and dalglish when he was still playing. Fergie made keane his enforcer on and off the pitch and when it didnt suit he got rid. Was it the right decision yes did he deal with it the right way no. Either way this bad feeling started way before that season. It actually started in pre season in portugal over a villa keane wasnt happy with for his family.

This team above all else mentality will not work in today's generation of players

How do you know what was said? It to this day never made it's way out to the public. All that has been said about it by ex players who were in the room when it was played back was that it was very harsh and that he went a bit too far with what he said.

No but no one unless they were leaving the team even got harangued by SAF to the press let alone a player hairdryer treatment behind closed doors everything else’s fault outside of them that’s why players respected him so much Roy could say that on the pitch that was his job as captain but not off the pitch

You watched it?

Yup. Keane was 34. If he was 26 it would’ve been a very different story.

Well said! Keano remains unreplaced!

and footballers age like dog years and we all know what happens to a dog when he gets old no matter how loyal of a servant he has been. Take him around the shed and put shogun to the back of his head@@TPRM1

⁠​⁠@@alexeyjurukovski7335 They won the UCL in 2008 tho and Keane left in 2005. I would say he replaced fairly

Or Roy just fucked himself by becoming bigger than his boots

How the hell would you know that

Then you're a very poor judge of men.

@@homegrown7993and you’re an excellent queer to judge it otherwise

Bollocks

Correct

@@KlimtEastwood can't find it

Ferguson wasn’t the player though learn this ..

No he wouldn’t have he would have found excuses for everything that’s literally what he was famous for in press conferences to his players behind closed doors of course he would have that’s what endeared him to his players he would always go out to bat for them infront of the press even if behind closed doors he was totally lambasting them

Yeah I'm a Liverpool fan and I totally agree. Says what he sees. His book is a good read too.

He dumped beckham in his prime. Van Nistelrooy, Stam.

@@Donavan37Stam was getting on and Rio was a brilliant signing the one player you forget is Forlan slipped and missed one penalty because he wore short studs when fergie told him to wear longs and never played again for United

In the prime of his career Roy wouldn't have gotten so big for his boots & thought he was untouchable

@@wargey3431 After he left United 2004-2005 and 2008-2009, Forlan earned the Golden shoes as the top scorer in all of Europe.

He is the most watched, not probably 😂

I'd pick prime kante over Keane all day

Xabi Alonso

​@@jj18365small kante would get his butt kicked all game in that old hyperphysical premier league. N keane would look like a snail in todays fast game.... both r great but different era

@@yourdad-rq1zm that’s a pretty fair analysis tbh 👌🏽 makelele on the other hand jhezzz 😂

@@AG-kb7yb Xabi played part of a double 8 role at Liverpool, he was only a full blown 6 at Real

Cue arsenal/Liverpool fan replying about how SAF bullied him etc

And the players were saints under ferguson. Rooney, giggs etc

​@@jd-rm4ezdefinatley nobody else could compete financially at that time

Completely wrong. United doesn’t need him. It’s that philosophy that is keeping them down. That and other things. SAF is the ex they can’t get over. Mourinho said whenever you did something everyone would say “sir alex didn’t do it that way”. They’re stuck in the past. He was relatively weak tactically especially compared to pep and players today don’t respond to the hairdryer technique. He’s a legend but a dinosaur. It’s time to leave him in the past.

​@@Jearbearjenkins, exactly. Sir Alex was a great, great manager in his time, but the management of players and the game have changed. You cannot use yesterday's weapons to fight most of today's battles. ​

Lol Sancho's killing it once he's out of Manchester. He's not the problem.

@@thraasherhell 3 goals in 18😂😂😂😂 ‘killing it’ hes a flop

@@thraasherhell United living in ur head all you comment about is this😂😂😂

What waffle, they enheter many wins afterwards 😂 it went downhill in 2013 when fergie left, ok when he left it went to shite

Keane is not a great manager obviously, his track record. I think Keane and Lampard suffer from the same thing as managers. They think everyone should have the same skill set and passion as them and no one does. To be a great manager you have to learn to use people's weakness and strength appropriately. Some need a pat on the back, some need a kick in the back. And some are going to be exceptionally great at some things and somethings they are not. Your job is to figure out a system to suit everyone to succeed. Not to think everyone should be exactly like you and that will make them be successful.

@@jachovdalseg3647to many players kept on reputation contracts to long managers who were not hard enough on the players and owners who treated it like a business not a sports team

@@wargey3431 alot of factors. Stil shit did not go bad until 2013. Starting with David moyes who just did a mess after fergie

I disagree Keane was negotiating over a contract extension and he wasn’t quite the same player. All very unfortunate. But I’m a liverpool fan - so happy tbh but this wasn’t beginning of the end they won the prem and champs league double after Keane left and Man City were the first team to achieve that last season. No beginning of the end was when City won their first Prem title on final day - when United thought they did it and Rooneys contract negotiations oh and Sir Alex I think advising that Moyes would be good to takeover (when Mourinho thought he would get it)???? For me that was like Gerrard giving his blessing for Roy Hodgson??????!

He was the club!!! Not saying it’s supposed to be like that, however, you cannot disregard all the evidence that proves Sir Alex lead United to success.

I always used to think I was the only one who saw Ferguson this way. The man won a lot but I was never a fan of his narcissistic bully personality. Folks need to watch Roy Keane's version and then decide.

@Luke-ul3xf A team/club is the sum if its parts.. without going into too many details.. The 1st PL title was won thanks, amongst others.. to Eric Cantona.. the last was thanks to Robin Van Persie's goals despite an-end-of-an-era squad..

@scatmann5839 Ferguson's narcissism prevented him from preparing an eventual successor.. He had the power, the club's backing, and the time to do so.. but he chose not to. Why? After 27yrs in charge and then what? No legacy? Nothing but memories to inherit..? He wasn't pushed out via the back door, like Arsène Wenger was.. He should have prepared the future being such a 'fantastic visionary'.. especially as many still consider him to be 'incarnation of the club'.. As the French saying goes 'Après moi.. le déluge!!' (Literally: After me, the flood..!! [After me catastrophy follows]..!!) This is generally regarded as a nihilistic expression of indifference to whatever happens after one is gone.. Who hasn't noticed his pink-face in the crowd shaking his head in pretend disbelief at the failings of the Moyes, Giggs, VanGaal, Mourinho, Solsjækr, Carrick, Rangnick and ten Haag teams..?? The genius didn't forsee any of that?

Rubbish. Keane is the bully, he is never happier than when slagging players off, even now, hasn't changed.

Very very successful for a 'prat'.

his job is to play, not criticized other players, it's SAF job to tell players what to do

@@TheDarkKnightRacist as a captain that’s exactly what he’s supposed to do.. he’s the man to implement the manger’s standards on field. And to do that you need some power and respect yourself .. that of which Fergie felt threatened by and then acted like a bitch. Just my opinion.

@@captaincringecpt1717 as a captain, LOL, name me any team captain in history that goes to media and destroyed their own teammate in press ? and by winning more EPL titles and another UCL is a bitch, than if he's a bitch, what are you ?

It's not Keanes job to try and publicly humiliate his team mates. By that stage, Keane was well past his best so he should of been more critical of himself and his loss of pace by then! Fergie didn't need to show is authority at the club. By then he was well and truly the boss. No player is bigger than the club and it's the club that Fergie is protecting.

He did what he was asked you wetwipe

SAF sounds childish in this situation

How Roy was asked to analyse the game and he did

I agree with you about the club but he only told the truth and we that watched the game aren’t stupid what else could Keane say

AF is a bum though!! He did RK wrong! A bum is a bum, it's in their blood!

Mendieta bis back then

I agree. Most people are chatting rubbish here. They also think saf himself set roy keane up to do the mutv interview. That's not true at all

Right 😂. When it comes to shit like this, I always back players (genuine) . Everytime I learn something new about saf, it just gets funnier how much of a bitch boi and a bully he was.

Yeah, Keane was very naive. There had been tensions between them leading up to that point. He'd had a big argument with him in their pre season campaign.

He is though? Check the trophy case my friend results speak for themselves. On fight with keano doesn’t change that regardless of who’s side your on

So this makes him not the best ever? I don't get your point.

Captaijs do that in the locker room not the media.

It’s because instead of when the gaffer came in to tell him to pipe down and not do it again he had a standup row with him infront of the other players that’s why if he had said sorry won’t happen again boss he’d have been fine

There never was a player like him 😂😂😂🤦🏽 But I agree. We never bought a midfield general after that.

You won 3 League titles in a row and a Champions League after this in a more competitive Premier League era than the 90s, what are you on about?

You literally won the UCL in 2008 😂😂

There have been a lot of no nonsense managers who weren't power obsessed, bully. They can emulate but they don't need to. They're better in their own ways 😂. Saf old school bitch boi that's all.

No he doesn't, he was asked to give commentary on the game not systematically dismantle your own teammates in the public media. Then when called out by your manager, dig your heels in and have a row with him too.

🙄🤦

Lmao you want a wanker like Alex Ferguson who can’t take criticism? No thanks.

Don’t liken Pep to Fergie. Pep has had it easy. Fergie built an empire. Pep slotted in to one that was paid for

What are you saying? Talking about managers and suddenly something political? Are you delusional?

@@myaphextwin807That’s why the big clubs have given Pep offers right?,That’s why Barcelona a “small” team gave him a job offer,Bayern and Manchester City right?

Right. Liverpool is the biggest British team anyway 😂.

What was he supposed to say when confronted with a dismal display on a platform he was contractually forced to be on?

@@porcupineinapettingzoo tact and diplomacy, show a bit of loyalty to his club and employer. But Roy's only loyalty has only ever been to himself and his over inflated ego.

@neilburns8869 Was he signed for tact and diplomacy in a studio, made captain for his talent in media situations. If you wipe your company's database you should be fired if you're in IT, if you're the cleaner and told to backup the company's files onto the server and delete them instead, that's on whoever is asking.

SAF alt account huh 😂

@@porcupineinapettingzoothe thing is he stood in because Gary was unavailable as a loyal captain does he said I’ll do it gaffer He shouldn’t have gone and done that and as soon as he had he should have said sorry gaffer I won’t do it again instead he had a stand up row with him in the changing rooms and no one who questioned sir Alex’s authority in such a way would play again even the captain