First of all I want to say that I enjoyed every bit of this!😍 you made it very interesting to watch ! I've not seen the new Spider-Man but will definitely watch it now, just for the fun of it since you scored it 3 😂😂Keep up the good work !

Tom Holland is 21, not 15

"holland is in his mid teens" he's 21 not really close to the characters real age, but i guess it's closer than maguire and garfield were

Gwen Stacy is best girl, especially since she was the one Peter really loved.

It's almost impossible to replicate the magic created with Raimi. He knew what he was doing and everything came together in unison. It cemented itself and will live well on for many years to come.

In homecoming at the car scene all I could imagine is him screaming because I’m Batman Got that joke from HISHE

Sam Raimi *>>* Marc Webb *>>* Jon Watts.

Tobey always. His fight with goblin.... The best always

one guy said the lizard look like a goomba from the Mario Bros movie Couldn't say it anything better than that comparison

I think you just MIGHT be a LITTLE biased towards the first movie. Homecoming wasnt that bad of a movie

I think we can all agree that the best spiderman is...spectacular spiderman xD

never seen somany triggered homecoming fanboys

I never thougt of TASM that way...

Props to you for having your own opinion and sticking with it!

What about the rubble scene, that was very emotional and dark

In my opinion, this movie had little to no emotion.

1. Spiderman 2. Amazing 3. Home coming

I think you make some good points but I feel as though in some cases you miss the point of what a scene is trying to, like when Keaton's character shoots the guy and then says he thought is was the anti-grav gun, the point of that isn't to make him look like a big baddy, his character isn't that, he wouldn't try to kill someone, he's an everyman trying to protect his family, not a killer, that's why he works as a Spidy villain. Stuff like that just made some arguments feel not as well thought out, especially in regards to Homecoming, the movie is nothing incredible but it felt like almost everything it did well you sold short or just didn't mention.

This is facts Spider-Man: 9/10 The Amazing Spiderman: 7/10 Homecoming: 3/10

I think homecoming is a fine MCU movie but not a good Spider-man movie.

To be honest, I love all of the movies. Yes, even Spiderman 3 and The Amazing Spiderman 2. To me they all have somewhat of a significance on Spider Man and have the villains make their mark in each movie. Although I must say, I do not like the more humorous route they gave with Tom's Spider Man. The two movies might as well have been called "Stark's Apprentice".

Do you... hate the MCU?

The raimi movies are the best trilogy ever fight me

1: Spider-man 2: the amazing Spider-Man 3:Spider-Man homecoming

I dont know why the amazing spider man 2 and spider man 3 are hated

I'm a kid. I'm 17, if I was spiderman. I would be bugging happy Hogan too. All the time lol. Plus spidersense doesn't work with people he trusts. In a comic, spiderman went back home and aunt may thought there was an intruder and knocked him out with a vase or pan I think...but since Peter trusts aunt may, his spidersense doesn't go off, because he trusts her. So the Ned thing with Homecoming doesn't bother me.

Lowenthal>Maguire>Holland>Garfield

During Sam Ramis spider man I cried when uncle Ben’s death

I honestly kind of agree with you in this one. The thing is Homecoming wasn’t that bad in my opinion. I just wished there was more darker scenes. (3/21/20)

Wow, the dislikes and likes are almost the same amount. I wonder why... cough* homecoming fans *cough*

Peter Parker is a shy, awkward guy. Yep, Tobey displays that. He isn’t perfect, and often struggles to make ends meet. Again, that is present in his performance. He struggles to talk to women. Bingo once again. He has an affinity for science. Sure, he didn’t make his web shooters, but this is shown through subtleties in the dialogue, for example when he’s talking with Octavius. These are some of Peter Parker’s most well-known traits, and Maguire nails each one of them. In summary, he’s the kind of guy some people will be- a nerdy, awkward dweeb who isn’t flawless and makes mistakes. It’s in sharing these every day, common struggles that leads us to connect with the character, which means that nobody quite has a relationship with their viewers/readers in the way that Peter does. I personally feel like there was a decision made in production to make this version of Peter Parker a far more ‘realistic’ one to better fit a live action environment. This links in with previous points; he’s shy, insecure, gets pushed around a lot and can't catch a break. There are some versions of Spidey in which Peter can be relatively confident outside of his suit, however this isn’t one of them. I think this works for the better- Maguire’s performance is essentially what I think a real life version of this character would be like. If he gets bullied and doesn’t have many friends, well of course he’d adapt to become an introverted character over time. Bully victims are not naturally confident- it takes time to overcome something like that, so then it makes perfect sense as to why Pete acts like he does; eventually becoming more confident throughout the films. People who say, "Tobey cried 50 times in every film." SMH. Tobey cried 6 times through out all 3 movies, twice in SM 1, once in SM 2 and 3 times in SM 3 that's when it starts to get ridiculous by the 3rd film but first two films he does it at appropiate times and I counted how many times Andrew Garfield cried in both TASM films and I swear to god, I'm not making this number up, 10 times in both ASM films, 6 times in TASM 1 & 4 times in TASM 2. Why do people give Andrew a pass on that because they say, "He doesn't look ugly when he cries unlike Tobey." Seriously, nobody looks like a model when they cry, they scrunch their faces up & look like a total mess, also the second time he cries in Spider-Man 1, it's because he's still feeling guilty about Uncle Ben and feels regret about what he said to him the last time they had a conversation, "I can't help thinking about the last thing I said to him, he tried to me something important and I threw it in his face." Also it's the day of his graduation, something that Uncle Ben would've attended had he not been murdered and he was Peter's father figure who raised him since he was a boy. And it's important for the movie to address the impact of Uncle Ben's death on Peter because it's the whole reason he becomes Spider-Man just like it's supposed to be. So HOW can you not sympathize with Peter and the regret that he's feeling?? People who say Tobey's Spider-Man never joked around, they're either ignoring the ones he did say and blatantly lying or they weren't paying attention. Spidey is supposed to be throwing around some wisecracks and irritating his enemies but he has to have some seriousness to him and I feel like that was sorely lacking in ASM 2 where he just didn't know when to shut up to the point where all it seemed like he was more concerned about how many one liners he can throw at his villains instead of helping people. Spidey is not Deadpool. He's not someone who throws snarky remarks out of his mouth every time he talks. There's more to him than the comedic side which is what I think a lot of Spider-Man fans have forgotten about. Sure it's great to see Peter Parker transform into the fun webslinger, but Spider-Man joking around as often as he did in the comics can only be taken so far if we meant to believe that he's a real dude, that's why the one-liners in the Raimi trilogy were never taken to a point of excess where they became so tedious, it robbed the scenes of any potential investment but that also doesn't mean that he's not still fun to watch or that they don't still make me wish I was Spider-Man. He clearly shouts to the world how much he loves web slinging and has an upbeat attitude every time he talks and he still busted out the one-liners, he just only ever did it when the circumstances were lighthearted enough to warrant them... Spider-Man 1: "That's a cute outfit. Did your husband give it to you ?", "Well, beats taking the subway, don't mind her, she needs to use the elevator.", "Hey kiddo, let mom & dad talk for a moment, will ya !", "You have a knack for getting in trouble.", and "It's you whose gobby, out of your mind !" Spider-Man 2: "Workout, plenty of rest, you know, eat your green vegetables.", "It rides up in the crotch a little bit too.", "Here's your change !" & "I have a knack for that." Spider-Man 3: "I guess you haven't heard, I'm the sheriff around these parts.", "Look at little goblin junior, gonna cry ?", & "A few minutes ago would'nt been so bad." Tobey's quips felt so natural and perfectly timed when the situation, scene, or moment had enough levity and was light hearted enough to warrant them while Andrew's quips were so forced and obnoxious to the point where he might as well be Deadpool. Again, Spider-Man is not just about making jokes and that's it, when serious shit hits the fan, he's supposed to shut up and take the situation seriously. If you go to level of joking he does in the comics and translate that into film, you're gonna have the risk of making Spider-Man coming off as an asshole and that he's more focused on being funny then actually saving people and him blatantly making the situation worse and insufferable while doing it. That really came to life in ASM 1 & 2, especially in TASM 2 where Spider-Man is too busy making jokes while Rhino is driving that truck crashing into cars with people possibly in them and probably died. Spider-Man is not Deadpool ! Seriously, watch the first ten minutes of The Amazing Spider-Man 2 (that video is even on KZfaq). When Rhino crashes into all those cars with his truck, Andrew only saves Max (who later turns into a villain) and doesn't even TRY to catch at least one of those cars (when we clearly saw he'd be able to do that). The people in those cars most certainly died and he didn't care, even worse, he was all bubbly and jokey when he talked to Max and seemed to think of himself as a great hero in that moment. I'd rather Peter dance around like an idiot in SM3 than him clowning around with the Rhino and not really seem to care that he's is more than likely killing people in the armored truck. Before you fanboys tell me, "He's supposed to be that way, he doesn't know when to shut up, he's supposed to cocky and all that. He does it to piss off his enemies." I know, that execuse has been made for a long time but that doesn't mean the movie is any better than any of the previous ones. Also he doesn't really seem that concerned that Rhino mowed down a bunch of people while he's swinging away from the armored truck, not to mention that Rhino shoots his AK out into the air possibly firing into these windows on these neighboring buildings, he doesn't sound concerned at all ! It's all because the writers and Sony were more interested in pleasing the fans who complained that Tobey didn't make enough jokes, in other words: they went for quantity over quality. In Raimi's trilogy, they portrayed him in a more serious manner where he still throws his one liners but at the appropriate time because he was more concerned about helping others than being funny for the sake of it. But when people like Aunt May, Mary Jane, or innocent civilians are directly put in harm's way, that's when it all stops being funny and it's time to get down to business, that is Spider-Man ! Now the emo Peter scenes, look I'm not one of those people who's gonna throw an actor completely under the bus because of those one or two scenes unlike a lot of Spider-Man fans who still not forgiven him for that, seriously grow a pair & move on if you got over George Clooney as Batman maybe you could do the same with Tobey. Is it dumb ? Yeah it's dumb, really dumb BUT I think it kinda works because Peter has been treated like a nerd & a geek his whole life who's never been cool ever, doesn't know what being cool is like, and hell probably doesn't know what "cool" is so that's him thinking in his head what being cool is like. It's supposed to awkward & stupid, you wan't him to stop doing it & it shows that Peter Parker is not supposed the bad boy, looking at you ASM 1&2, yep I said it ! That being said the second time it happens in the jazz club, that's when it's like, "Okay, WTF are you doing ? One is enough, there's no need for more."

Spider Man 1>Homecoming>>>>>>Amazing Spider Man

I love Spider-Man Homecoming. But it seems like people refuse to see the flaws of the Movie.

You did not piss me off, sir. I agree with your opinion completely. I love Sam Raimi's Spider-man the most.

Even though I enjoyed the Amazing Spider-Man films, I have to admit that I laughed my ass off in the scene where Uncle Ben gets shot because he dived at the gun. Great video :)

This is from 4 years ago I wonder what he thought when Spiderman no way home came out.

Finaly someone who doesn’t put Spider-Man homecoming as number 1, thank you

Lol, what do you mean by amazing spiderman 2 had memorable fight scenes, all I remember was blue Jamie foxx playing the itsy bitsy spider with dubstep.

Relatable characterization is the biggest home run for me. My favorites ordered from best to worst are: #1. Sam Ramy's, Toby Maguire's Spiderman. #2. Feeney's Tom Holland's Spiderman. #3. Andrew Garfield's Spiderman.

Pretty sure Tom Holland is 22, not in his mid-teens

Actually you are incorrect. In New York firearms are illegal, so it made sense for Ben to stop him

We've seen the uncle Ben stuff 2 times before. Everyone knows why peter is Spider-Man, they were smart by ignoring this. Audiences probably would have sighed and just waited for the "I'm sad uncle ben is dead" part to pass. Also he's been Spider-man for 6 or so months before the movie starts. I think that's a suitable enough time to grief over someone's death. I'm not trying to hate, I just disagree on some points here. I still find your video enjoyable though, ^~^ my point is that Marvel wasn't Trying to deal with uncle Ben, that wasn't their point or align with their interests. This is supposed to be about a 15 year old kid, who enjoys being a superhero. But you did still bring up a few good points and arguments.

This video is pretty one sided if you ask me

He has no inspiration in MCU AND YOU DONT KNOW ENDGAME HUH

In homecoming Parker cares more about stark than his uncle

Tom Holland is actually 21

I like Maguire Garfield And Holland But I like raimi’s films more than Garfield’s and Holland’s Sorry guys.......

You probably already know this now but Tom Holland wasn't in his mid teens when he did homecoming, he was in his 20s.

Spider-Man 10/10 Spider-Man 2 10/10 Spider-Man 3 5.8/10 The amazing Spider-Man 8.5/10 The amazing Spider-Man 2 6.5/10 Spider-Man homecoming 9.5/10

Nah, I Really like TASM's Uncle Ben. He was trying tonbe a good father. A more strict and protrctive father. Sure, he was a bit strict. But, he was also how a parent in thrse days would be.

It's probably due to that Civil War had a different writers to Homecoming, in fact, Infinity War also had Spidery sense and it Civil Wars's writers.

Well actually, Tom Holland is in his early 20s, but still young enough to be an accurate Spider-Man!

Glad to see another honest opinion and I completely agree. SM1 >> TASM 1 >> Homecoming.

The Raimi is the best. Best soundtrack, best fight scenes, best storyline, best villains, awesome nostalgia, nuff said.

My opinion for three movies 1. Spider-Man 2002 9/10 2. Spider-Man Homecoming 2017 8.5/10 3. The Amazing Spider-Man 2012 7.2/10

Hey dude, when Spider-Man: Far from home comes out, you should compare it to Spider-Man 2 and The amazing Spider-Man 2 Great comparison by the way! you really know what makes a good film, Keep up the awesome work :)

I just thought Homecoming was just too silly and lacked emotion.

TASM is good, its sequel just ruins it

I wish we could have seen SM4, as Raimi seemed to know clearly what went wrong with 3 and wanted to rectify it but the studio seemed determined to keep on interfering...

2:32, it's meant to show uncle ben actually acting upon the "great power great responsibility" quote

1.Spiderman (2002) 2. TASM (2012) 3. Spiderman homecoming (2017) I prefer the 2002 version of spiderman 😀

Uncle Ben is replaced by Tony Stark, driving the emotional plot even more

I don't want Peter to end up with MJ in Far from Home

I’m still waiting for Spider-Man 4 I’m probably never going to see it :l but I still won’t lose hope

Spiderman 2002, 2004 and 2006: Best agility and Wall crawling. Amazing spiderman 1 and 2: Best sence of humor and spider sence. Spiderman homecoming, infinity War, end game and far from home: Best spiderman suits.

Actually Tom is In his early 20s 😂

Being a huge Spiderman fan I hated homecoming so much that it took me almost a YEAR to watch far from home and I haven't even bothered rewatching homecoming

Homecoming was "meh" for me. The Vulture though... _man._

Flash: *beats up children and smacks Peter in the face* Peter: *makes Flash look a bit stupid* Ben: What's your problem Peter?

When it came to The Amazing Spiderman, I didn't give a shit too.

I don't disrespect your opinion but I liked spiderman homecoming

Funny I found likability in all 3 spidermen as characters for different reasons.

Story 3 the amazing Spider-Man 2 Spider-Man homecoming 1 Spider-Man Peter Parker 3 The amazing Spider-Man 2 Spider-Man homecoming 1 Spider-Man Spider-Man 3 the amazing Spider-Man 2 Spider-Man homecoming 1 Spider-Man Villains 3 the Lizard 2 Vulture 1 green Goblin Action 3 Spider-Man homecoming 2 the amazing Spider-Man 1 Spider-Man Tone 3 Spider-Man homecoming 2 Spider-Man 1 the amazing Spider-Man Love interest 3 Liz 2 mj 1 gwen Music 3 Spider-Man homecoming Spider-Man The amazing Spider-Man Conclusion Spider-Man 10/10 The amazing Spider-Man 7/10 Spider-Man homecoming 5/10

I found the Amazing Spiderman's scene with Uncle Ben, Peter and Gwen - happening after the _did you humiliate that boy_ scene - pretty funny and Uncle Ben is quite dad-like in it. ;) Uncle Ben sees a random *running* person dropping a gun: people with legally registered guns who haven't done anything wouldn't need to run; i that situation everyone then is bound to assume the gun is illegal and the man did something not good. And calling Uncle Ben moron for accidentally getting shot during a struggle....I doubt many others would have had the guts to attempt stopping the thief. In Raimi's movie, Uncle Ben looks and sounds more like an older brother than the father figure he's supposed to be; and by the way, in that movie Ben dies almost the same way as in Webb's version: he may not attempt to stop the thief physically, but he still gets in his way. And Garfield's crying is actually more realistic....I mean, would you able to speak coherent words like Raimi's Peter does when you face a shock like seeing your uncle/dad dying? I sincerely doubt it, you'd just utter intelligible words like Garfield's Peter does.

Tobey Maguire is my favorite Spider-Man and he deserves that 7/10, and I agree with the Andrew ranking, But I can see why you do not like Toms portrayal, but it actually works, if tobey or Andrew were in the mcu, Homecoming actually might have been much worse, I give Spider-Man Homecoming 7/10

I agree with the things you said Eric but I prefer Homecoming over The Amazing Spider Man

Im never fond of "the amazing spiderman" not nerdy enough for a Peter Parker

I love Keaton in anything he does, plus I like how he's trying to take over the world, he's just a construction worker turned arms dealer.

I really can't understand why this video (like a few others you've made) has such a bad like/dislike ratio. Even if you disagree with his opinions, you can still appreciate the effort that went into making the video, and the fact that he explained his views in great detail. It seems like people who thought Homecoming was 11/10 of whatever just dislike the vid because they disagree with you, and I don't think that's the right response. Comment saying you disagree, and why (don't just insult him and say "nah you're stupid"), don't just hate on the vid.

i just saw one of ur recent videos lately and now im watching this and i hv noticed how everything about ur videos has changed and improved so i just wanted to say keep it up mate ur getting better every vid and PLEASEEE upload more ur videos are sooo enjoyable

2:12 the way he said milk lmao

Hmm, I really enjoyed this video as it’s very well done! But after calculating this ranking system /3... your Spiderman 1 score is accurate but the Amazing Spiderman should be a 6.6 (averaging the 2, 1, 3, 2, 2, 3 out of 21 (3x7 topics) = 0.6666) and Spiderman Homecoming would be 0.47619 or 4.7/10 according to your rankings added together and divided. No hate or anything, just something I thought was off. Once again really well done video Eric and I subscribed. Can’t wait for Far From Home to come out so you can do a “Spiderman 2 vs Amazing Spiderman 2 vs Spiderman Far From Home” 👏

To quote Bobsheaux in his "Batman 66: Return of the Caped Crusaders" when referring to Uncle Ben in the MCU: "The pain still there. He just managed to work around it." And they do reference it when Peter said "what she been through" when talking about Aunt May and the death of Uncle Ben.

Excellent commentary, as always!

This video still holds up today and is one of your best works

Can I just say that I appreciate you giving credit where credit is due for the original Spider-Man. A lot of people tend to forget about how good it was and you gave some very good reasons why it was good. If I'm aloud to add one more thing to your review, is that all the side characters in the first Spider-Man movie were the best casted. I'm serious, it has the best casted side characters of any Spider-Man movie, from JK Simmons' J Jonah Jameson to Rosemary Harris's Aunt May. Well I still do love Spider-Man Homecoming, I do agree with you that Spider-Man 2002 is the best Spider-Man😉👍👍👏👏👏🕷

I don't get why people hate amazing spiderman 2...it was way better than amazing spiderman 1 and yeah, while the villains suck, like, really suck, the emotional tension and baggage in Peter Parker is really felt. It has a lot of emotion, but it lacks good pacing and villains.

Favorite to least is Tom, Andrew, then Tobey threaten me as you want

I recently saw homecoming for the first time and I was disappointed with many aspects of it. I'm glad that this video covered most if not all of the issues that I had with it.

Why did you place Spider-Man homecoming LAST in terms of stories? Is it because it's not a classical ORIGIN story? Don't tell me you're not bored of Uncle Ben's death by now. I'm glad the MCU moved on. If they didn't, they would have been forced back into the same old stories much multiple TV shows, comics books and movies have shown time and time again.

Childhood Memories Tobey 💓💖 My Favourite Spider-man

DC has the dark Knight trilogy marvel has the captain America trilogy but Sony original Sam Raimi Spider-Man trilogy

Everyone: Maguire doesn't quip. Maguire: That's a cute outfit, did your husband give it to you?

Tobey spiderman movies beat all other spiderman movies

Just watching this video to get prepared for your new three-way Spider-Man versus video who else is watching this video getting ready for the three way Spider-Man versus video

Excellent Job tackling 3 movies Keep it up 😁👍

I just searched for spider Mann v spider man v spider man... And came across a youtuber giving all the points to Tom.. I pissed in his comment section and went further down to find this master piece..😍 The truth has never been spoken like this before

every so called comic fan says homecoming is perfect spiderman , Mehhh ! for a movie its a mess for me its just sucks .

Great video again ! My favorite movie is Raimi's Spider-man 2 , Alfred Molina as OCK is amazing. Homecoming wasnt bad movie for me at ll, but I must agree with you its childish, turn your brain off and watch marvel's silly jokes.

Now that we have 3 tom spider-man, we find out there isn't and never was an uncle Ben