Willem Dafoe's face getting a bigger smile every time Peter kept punching him on the face was amazing

I just hope that Andrew Garfield knows that everyone was happy he came back as Spider-Man

The fact that the series came full circle eight movies and almost 20 years later with Peter trying to stab Norman with his glider and having Tobey McGuire’s Peter stop him was just. Perfection.

The scene where Andrew Garfield's Spider-Man saves MJ really got me. That man's a great actor. And I appreciate that they didn't hit you over the head with the scene's meaning-- if you watched TAS2, you knew.

I liked how Tobey encouraged Andrew when he was downing himself. That scene felt very self aware, considering there were many who didn't like Andrew's Spider-Man movies. I thought that was great.

When Andrew says “I love you guys” and “I’ve always wanted brothers”. It really made me feel that he was the loneliest Spider-Man out of the three of them. He went through the most trauma and just wants to feel that sort of love and compassion again with someone. Im also glad they didn’t make Tobey look younger, it really gave him that big brother vibe and that he was the “wise old” one.

“The power of the sun…” “…In the palm of your hand.” Otto finally got to see his dream of a clean, renewable energy source, the thing he wanted most made a reality.

I like how Andrew Garfield's spiderman refused to show off his wall crawling until Ned's mom asked for his help cleaning cobwebs. Still always willing to be a friendly neighborhood guy.

When Norman says "you know I'm something of a scientist myself" my whole theatre erupted in laughter. Gotta love meme culture.

“Strong enough to have it all, too weak to take it…” Willem Defoe killed it.

Tobey stopping tom really hit me when you realize almost all his villains die in the original spider-man series. This literally means he knows what its like to have to take a life or even take it by accident(the glider wasnt tobeys fault but he couldve saved goblin at the end of the day but chose not to)and didnt want toms spidey to have to feel that. Meaning he had remorse for the lives taken in his universe. And the fact that after all that they still had that loveable comicbook peter feel at the end from andrew to tobey to tom made it just feel like a true spider-man film and the jokes about baby ironman really hit home

I teared up to for sure 3 or 4 scenes. When Tobey said to Tom "I'm sorry for May".. when Tobey finished the Tom's sentence "comes great responsibility".. when Andrew started crying after catching MJ.. This movie deserves everything!

Andrew Garfield really shined in this movie. The scene where he saved MJ and his face…his acting chops…. It was just fantastic. I hope Marvel gives something huge to Andrew. He deserves it.

The Bully Maguire editors are gonna have a field day with this movie XD

Best line of the movie - JJJ : He's at the Statue of Liberty.. Oh my God he's gonna destroy another national monument!!

Nostalgia-bait isn't in and of itself bad, it's just gotta be done right. This movie is the example of how to do it right :)

Andrew Garfield and Willem Dafoe for me definitely stood out in this movie, I loved every minute of their scenes

The scene where Andrew started to cry when he saved MJ was just heartbreaking.

Did anyone catch the part where Garfield said „Nice catch“ and Holland answered „nice throw“ referencing how Garfield passed the franchise onto Holland and how great of a job he is doing as Spiderman? I thought that was just one of many beautiful moments of mutual respect and just a wholesome part. And for the rest, I can only agree! Loved this movie. I still kinda can’t believe we got to see the three spidies come together and each bring their own chemistry! I am so grateful I made it without getting a whole lot (besides the obvious Internet leak) spoiled. I almost lost it when Matt Murdock was on screen! Did not see that one coming and couldn’t be happier!

I love how everyone has their own continuation of their own stories. Especially when Tobey and Andrew watched Tom and Zendaya and started talking about their own love stories. The happy face Doc Ock showed when he met with older Tobey Tobey talking about Ned about his best friend, Harry and Andrew's face when he heard that.... even Sandman helping Tom when he thought Tom was Tobey in the beginning (continuation of the fight in Spiderman 3)

Everyone is talking about how Andrew saving MJ..but Tobey saving Green Goblin from being impaled by his own glider is just as cool.

Andrew Garfield honestly was the star of the show for me... The scene with him catching MJ.... HIT HARD!!!

I love that the show paid such respect to every Spiderman movie and beyond that even to us fans.

Strongest quality of the movie: all three Spideys were legit on their own terms; side by side, their differences enhanced the qualities of each.

The moment Garfield lands with Zendaya and you see all that emotion in his face, I just teared up. That was an amazing moment.

When Andrew Garfield caught MJ I damn near cried with him. You could see how happy he was that he got it right this time.

One correction. Doc takes the Arc reactor with him. They really imply that the arc reactor is Otto's key to surviving "The power of the sun, in the palm of my hand."

I was a kid when Tobey was Spider-Man. To see him again literally made me tear up. It was like my childhood came back. He was my Spider-Man. Lol

Can we just take a minute to appreciate the phenomenal acting by Willem Dafoe. He stole every scene he was in.

They made what didn't work in The Amazing Spider-Man movies work very well in this movie. I'm so glad Andrew Garfield was in this.

I, actually, successfully avoided all the super spoilers. Also, I do buy Ned being able to open a portal because Strange's issue was trying to "beat a river into submission." Ned is more of a go with the flow kind of character so... yeah.

I loved that we got a Miles Morales reference, if somewhat indirectly lol. Dafoe KILLS as the Goblin-he's just so good. All the villains were portrayed well and I like that Doc Ock helps in the final battle. Did NOT see May dying but it does leave the door open for some possible Mephisto shenanigans later. It would be absolutely crazy if Sony and Marvel had the balls to do Spider-man 4 in the Raimi-verse and Amazing Spider-man 3. Although I guess this movie kind of serves as a redemption for how terrible part 3 was and the fact that Garfield never got his own third film. My unanswered questions are: Is Mysterio really dead? Will Miles Morales ever pop up in the MCU? What the hell are they doing with Venom? He gets popped over to the MCU, drops off some goo, and then gets popped back? For what purpose? Anyways....great movie! Crazy times!

Probably the best and funniest scene/line: Tom: "i was in the avengers" Toby: "that's great! What is that?!"

The inclusion of Tobey and Andrew served the story, not the other way around. That’s what makes this type of fan service different from something like Rise of Skywalker, where that was a movie created solely for nostalgia. No Way Home felt like Tobey and Andrew were passing the torch and Tom’s now moving into act 2 as his own Spider-Man.

I don't think there was a dry eye in the theater when Andrew caught MJ. Tobey's theme song also got me choked up a bit too. I didn't expect to get hit so hard in the feels by this movie but they left no stone unturned & provided closure where it was needed.

Did anybody else kinda feel towards the end when Tom's peter parker looked at MJ's bandage in the coffee shop, that maybe made him reflect in that he cant have a personal life with the ones he loves most while also being spiderman so when he decided not to confess to her with the note it was his own way of protecting her?

The way they did Matt Murdock's cameo was absolutely perfect

Can we just take a moment to appreciate Jamie Fox, Willem Dafoe, Alfred Molina, Thomas Haden Church, Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield. They all brought their A-Game. Electro was a bad-ass, and The Green Goblin was scary.

Lizard may have been a bit of a benchwarmer, but he had one line that really summed up the whole movie for me; "I told you there would be consequences!"

Andrew Garfield catching MJ made me tear up. That was the best moment I have seen in a movie in a very long time.

This wasn’t a nostalgia movie, this was a Spider-Man movie.

Tobey and Andrew’s chemistry was amazing. They were perfect together

They also handled the "nostalgia" with respect. They didn't bring them back to humiliate and replace them. They are not incapable failures only existing to elevate the new Mary Sue even higher

One of the biggest reasons this nostalgia worked was its self awareness. They knew we knew what they were doing without actually confirming it until its viewing. It's absolutely beautiful.

The 1 scene that had me sobbing was Garfield’s reaction after saving MJ…pure gut punch🥺

Tobey being the "older brother" of the group, Andrew saving MJ and redeeming himself in his eyes, and Tom at first just telling them to go home and that he doesn't care were some of the best parts of the film.

Like Logan, this felt like a culmination of 20 years. It's weird being the only 28 years old fangirl in the theater amongst 10 years old & parents because I was the only one feeling up reveals and screaming out "YES" when we finally met Andrew Garfield and Tobey Maguire😂! Well, I don't care cause their scenes together make my heart felt super warm and mushy. I'm glad they both got the second chances they deserved (like the villains). Andrew's version is a little more dorky here and I loved it & just so happy Tobey's finally find some peace (he's always suffering so much in his version). I love that Tom Holland's Spider-man has finally grown up and must dealt with life the way he never did, with no back-ups. The ending was bittersweet, Peter making all the hard choices because he's the only one who could (down to his self-sewned suit), but he really became his own man.

Jeremy I just watched Dr. Strange and they explicitly explained the power of the sling ring. When you have the ring all you need to do is visualize where you want to go, and "the clearer the picture the easier it is." Given that Ned wanted to see Peter badly it made sense he was able to do what he did. In the Dr. Strange movie he was still clouded by his pride which is why it took him some time. So actually it wasn't the lazy troupe of "character pulls ability out of their ass."

I kind of feel that Andrew got to shine in this movie because he had something to prove, that he is a great Spiderman despite the movies he was in. It's very meta that Tobey's Peter Parker was happy to be supportive and let him shine. Tobey's Spiderman has nothing to prove to anyone.

I absolutely loved Andrew’s redemption his catch was A1

This movie was just literally everything I enjoy about modern day superhero films. I think I put this up there with Infinity War/Endgame in terms of personal enjoyment. Someone here already said this was the Endgame of the Spidey franchise- that feels accurate.

I actually had no idea about Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield being in this .. best moment EVER!!

Tobey and Andrew being in the movie easily could’ve been just fan service that falls flat. But that scene where they meet and talk to Tom about Aunt May really had me wiping away tears. It really had the same heart wrenching emotion of all the Spider-people comforting Miles in Spiderverse. And their interactions at the school and at the Statue of Liberty were all just great and hilarious. They felt like real fleshed out characters in this film.

*The scene in the entire movie for me was when Andrew was able to save MJ in time. You can tell that meant the world to him and he found closure from that. What a scene! He did a phenomenal job.*

The relationship between the 3 Spider-Men was epic It can be summed up as: "if Spider-Man himself doesn't care who the best version of himself is then why should any of us? Let's just enjoy them all"

What a great movie! The attention to details was fenomenal, from memes like quote "You know i am something off a scientist myself", and the spider bromance, to the scene Andrew Garfield saved MJ, showing he refined his technique of grabbing falling ppl, -that imagine and loss of Gwen haunted him and thought of a million ways he could have done it better, and now he did The feels were real in this movie. 10/10 for me

The scene where Peter picks up the glider to kill Norman with burning anger and tears in his eyes, and Toby’s Spider-Man saving him from becoming a murderer hit me so hard emotionally. Even the fact that they added Toby, the first Spider-Man, calmly but understandingly looking into Tom’s face full of pain and anger to tell him that he knows that it won’t heal him, just…man. I would say this one had several elements of pure cinema mixed into it, and it blew me away completely.

This movie was an absolute love letter to everyone that’s been following the eight Spiderman movies over the last 20 years. I cried three different times, my theater was cheering and screaming, it was a better movie experience for me than Endgame was. This WAS Tom Holland’s origin story as standing on his own officially as Spiderman. Letting go of Stark tech, making his own classic suit. The arc of learning responsibility, losing his loved one, then ultimately learning how to be a real hero and letting go of his anger. The previous Spidermen got that in their first movies, we got Tom’s in this one. This was truly the moment where he stands alone and sets aside being a kid and becomes the struggling, simple hero on his own that we know and love. I absolutely loved this movie.

Andrew Garfield saving MJ was such a beautiful scene, brought a manly lil tear to my eye

One of my favorite smaller moments was Toby reiterating to Andrew that he's amazing. Like he had to hammer home he's the Amazing Spider-Man. Gave me a nice laugh

I love that Andrews Spidey was still in pain over Gwen and Toby's Spidey was still heartbroken about Harry Osborn. Those two things added so much integrity to them using the characters in the movie

I was mostly impressed how none of the actors phoned it in. You can tell that they all took it seriously. You got to see them act as if this was their movie too. The scene that proves it the most is when Andrew Garfield's Spider Man caught MJ from falling and you see the pain in his eyes from remembering Gwen Stacy, but also the look of relief that he caught her. That was a degree of acting I wasn't expecting from this movie.

As someone who grew up watching all these movies this is literally my childhood come back to haunt me in the greatest ways. I cried when Tobey and Andrew showed up on screen, and i think the main theme of this movie is really Second chances. Not just for the villains but also for all the Spider-Men as well. This is quite possibly the Greatest Spider-Man movie of all time

JUST saw this lastnight. Honestly, as someone who HATED the Andrew Garfield MOVIES, he absolutely stole the show whenever he was on-screen. The scene where he saves MJ was surprisingly the most emotional scene in the movie for me, and both he and Zendaya did a phenomenal job with such a short exchange. When she asks him "are YOU okay?", and you see his face... man, that was just so well-written, acted, and directed. Honestly, this movie just felt like PEAK "Spider-Man". Tons of crossovers, but done in a highly meaningful way, the "twist" of Aunt May being "his Uncle Ben" worked amazingly well, and it managed to end in such a way that I'm actually just as excited to see what comes next for Spider-Man. It's a bummer that he's essentially divorced from the MCU again, but I honestly think Spider-Man could do with a few more grounded stories, before coming back to deal with more "cosmic" threats again. I'm also a BIT bummed that Tom Hardy's Eddie Brock/Venom doesn't look like it's going to show up. I hated the first Venom, but I actually thought Venom 2 did a great job establishing the dynamic between Eddie and Venom, and I kind of wish we could've seen that version of the character(s) interact with Tom Holland's Spider-Man. On the other hand, it does open the opportunity for a completely different take on Eddie and Venom; Tom Hardy's version took some getting used to. Plus, it opens up the POSSIBILITY (however unlikely) that they could take another stab at a better version of Carnage. Just call him "Maximum Carnage", but that's the one character I genuinely want a completely new take on; someone way more savage.

When dafoe said he was somewhat of a scientist himself; I couldn’t help but smile.

Andrew’s redemption while catching MJ, and Tobey’s redemption stopping Tom from executing Norman with the glider was just incredible. Both of the previous Spidermen were redeemed and their arcs seemed to officially close. What a fantastic film.

they recreated multiple scenes from the old movies in the perfect way. They were blink and you miss it moments that dont subtract from the movie in any way and just reward fans who are deeply in love with the franchise

Saw it tonight and I legit helplessly bawled when Garfield saved MJ 🥺🥺🥺 Easily my favorite moment

The reveal of the other Spider-Men was such a great theater moment! Whole theater erupting in cheer.

Andrew Garfield stood out!! You can tell he genuinely enjoys playing Spider-Man

Yes, the dynamic between all 3 of them felt like they’ve know each other for a very long time, like they were brothers sharing experiences and helping each other. Even though they are all Peter Parker, their personalities are so similar, yet very different at the same time..

Tobey parker has been thinking long how to save the osborns, his mentor and also his best friend. Andrew Parker has always been haunted w Gwen's death. This spiderman brings the character closure I never knew that we will ever get for these 2 respected spiderman character Instead of fan service or nostalgia bait, ill take this as my personal official sequel of Raimy Spiderman 3.5 and The Amazing Spiderman 2.5 and also Spideman 3 all in one. This is the spiderman endgame. And interesting that these movies made all the previous spiderman "canon"

When MJ says it doesn't hurt anymore and peter just looks at her realising she's safer without him just hurt me. It hurt me alot

i like the scene where Tobey stops Tom from killing Norman not only having an opportunity to save him, but also prevents Tom become the killer as the media portrayed him.

I got to avoid the leaks somehow! The reveals were unlike anything a film has delivered in my life. Pure joy!

This movie. Surprise after Surprise. Deserves a 10/10. Despite the obvious jokes and characters talking over each other, I really enjoyed it.

Andrew Garfield killed it! The face he made and the way he said “Peter #3” had my falling out of my seat laughing

The scene between Otto and Tobey was so heartfelt and incredible

This movie just makes me want to see Tobey McGuire as a 40 year old Spider Man. Someone who's been doing it for 20+ years. Pretty interesting concept to me

I feel like Ned had an 'empty cup' compared to Strange. That's how he could just do it, open to new possibilities

I’m so glad the movie actually USED Tobey and Andrew’s spidermen efficiently instead of just having them show up on screen for a few seconds with performances lacking real purpose or passion

One scene I loved was when they were on the rooftop after Aunt May died. When Andrew Garfield’s Peter Parker was about to say “We know what you’re going through” but was interrupted when Tom Holland said “Don’t tell me you know what I’m going through” he just said “Ok…” The older Peter Parkers both knew it was important to give him that time to process his emotions instead of just saying “Oh but we do know what you went through” That whole rooftop scene was such a genuine one and they knew they just needed to be there to listen and support when needed

I always loved Andrew as Spider-Man, but one thing I loved about him was how he kind of put himself down. It was like a perfect balance between Blonde Peter in Into The Spider-Verse and Peter B Parker from the same film. Like he can think he sucks all he wants but he's still Spider-Man. The dynamic between those two things are amazing. When you remember that despite Toby's age or Andrew's struggles, they never gave up the suit forever. "I always get back up."

I really appreciated the little moment when Toby gets to speak with good guy doc ock. That may have been the most underrated part in the movie

I think Marisa Tomei really did a great job in her last scene of looking absolutely terrified yet putting on the brave act for Peter. She was great. A lot of great performances in this.

Andrew’s Spider-Man stole the show in my opinion. Him saving MJ was THE moment of the film for me.

I did my best to stay clear of internet leaks. Of course, I was still about 90% sure that Toby and Andrew would make an appearance. However, not once did I even consider that Charlie Cox’s daredevil would show up. And I gotta say, seeing him on the big screen for even just a couple seconds is a moment I am going to remember for a very long time. I loved the movie, and I look forward to what it opens up in the near future.

Just wanted to point out even if it seems very obvious, I love how not only the last suit we see of MCU Peter at the end is purely classic to the comics, and can be seen as inspiration from the other two Peters, but also it's his second ever suit he's made without any Stark related assistance/manufacturing.

The scene after Aunt May's death where Tom's Peter is just injured and alone, and he has to watch JJJ talk about how it was his fault was the most heartbreaking and most Spider-Man scene I have ever seen.

I love how both Tobey and Garfield had an arc where they amend the biggest regret that haunted them by preventing it from happening to Holland. Like how Garfield saved MJ mirroring what he couldn't do for gwen Stacey, and Tobey stopped Holland from killing aunt May's killer in a grief-fuelled rage, something Tobey regrets doing after uncle Ben died

So, confession. I'm a pastor in training, and my brother, best friend, and myself went to see this right around Christmas. When Garfield looked at Maguire and said the "youth pastor" line, my best friend looked at me and said "YOU JUST GOT CALLED TF OUT" I had to begrudgingly agree. HOWEVER, this is all of our favorite MCU movie. Just thought you and your audience would appreciate that lol

This doesn't get brought up, but for me who is something of a musician (myself), when the Danny Elfman scores played in some scenes... It just hit home. This movie was just on another level of nostalgia.

I actually teared up at Andrew's face when he saved MJ. A really cool moment.

An incredibly “aware” movie that did nostalgia justice. 10/10.

Tobey to Andrew: "[Andrew] stop beating yourself up. You're AMAZING." Ok, that little joke got me. Andrew Garfield really was THE Amazing Spider Man

I mean, SURE. Ned having that ability pulled out of his ass is obviously just a plot device but... In his defense 1. He didn't open the portals well and he couldn't even close them. and 2. The reason it took Strange so long to master it was because he didn't even know magic existed and had years and years of his own biases and things to break down. Ned's still young enough to where those things aren't weighing him down, and he also knows (like the rest of the world does) that magic is real so he doesn't have to be convinced of it.

Andrew and Tom being completely amazed by Tobey’s organic webbing was hilarious. I had the biggest smile on my face the entire time whenever all three of them interacted, especially when Tobey and Andrew were trying to inspire Tom.

Are we not going to talk about William Dafoe's line "I'm something of a scientist myself." that huge throwback to not only the meme but the first movie.

Just got home from the theatre No Way Home was one of the greatest movie experiences I have ever had. I loved that I missed the internet leaks for Macguire & Garfield being in the movie so that was a great surprise! Loved this film!

I thought you were spot on with everything you said. This was truly one of the best if not the best MCU movie in years imo.. the way they really took it seriously and didn't just cash in on the nostalgia, giving some characters unexpected yet much needed closure, exploring other fun dynamics in a meaningful way and not just a a marvel throughway joke after a heavy moment, the character and emotional growth and strengthening of this version of Spiderman as an interesting story to tell and all the potential that comes with the current situation.. anyway, yeah I really liked it.