You kidding me? Comparing Star Wars and Star Trek is like comparing Lord of the Rings and Game of Thrones. They are completely different

Which is better? It depends. If you like action and adventure, it's Star Wars. If you like complex storylines and philosophical discussions, it's Star Trek.

I think Screen Junkies need to scrap the "most overrated" question because people consistently don't understand the question properly.

When in doubt, include the term " nuance "

Where my trekkies at!?!?!? I really need to know that I'm not the only one who likes Star Trek better even though Star Wars is still so amazing

I wonder why Andy didn't disqualify John when he trashed Private Ryan. Joe Starr dared to do so some months ago - and he was asked to leave the table... which was pathetic.

Also noticed a lot of pitty points given to Mantz... definitely with the trick question. I wish there was 3 judges so you'd have to at least have two votes to get the point, would be less controversial or biased.

That was an amazing way to spend 2 hours. That 1 vs 1 format worked so well and the fact that it features the Matz/Rocha rivalry made it even better. Really looking forward to more of March Mania.

why do people constantly compare ST and SW? they're so different. It's like comparing Game of Thrones to LOTR. Yeah, both are fantasy, that's about it.

I don't care about the topic, I could watch these two guys arguing all day long.

Their arguments on the Moonlight vs La La Land are actually really good! Like Rocha's argument on La La Land was incredible lol

As much as I appreciate Mantz's passion, Rocha totally nailed all of his arguments.

The best "drop the mic argument" regarding Star Trek is this: When Nicholle Nicholes wanted to quit Star Trek, she attended a party, where she was introduced to a Star Trek fan. And that fan was nobody else but Martin Luther King, Jr. And MLK told her not to quit because her simply sitting on the bridge as a communication's officer was giving hope to million of people's of colour in the US. That convinced her not to quit and when she told Gene Roddenberry about it, he hugged her and cried, saying "Finally somebody understands what I'm trying to say." And that's what Star Trek is. It's not as entertaining as Star Wars, but that's not the question. It's not what's more entertaining, but what's better. And if you look at the entire franchises, Star Trek beats Star Wars without much effort. And the closing argument should be "The first speech censored, the first thought forbidden, the first freedom denied, chains us all irrevocably. The first time any man's freedom is trodden on, we're all damaged." - Jean-Luc Picard in Star Trek: TNG 4x21.

Movie Fights: Screen Junkies vs. Cinefix! Make it so.

I swear, Mantz and Rocha are flat-out hilarious when they argue. This is GOLD. They need to be on more movie fights episodes.

this is one of the best Movie Fights I've ever seen. thank you guys for the great fight! I'd love to see more strong fights/questions like this!

While Star Trek fans have grown up to be scientists who try to invent things like the tricorder or warpdrive, star wars fans are still trying to use the force. Good luck with that.

two hours and twelve minutes?! Max Landis must be on this week.

Andy is so biased against John, it's ridiculous .

Man, they tried so hard to keep Mantz in the game on this one. Rocha was mopping him up for the most part.

ET is by far the most overrated Spielburg film. Even as a kid I was like meh. It's a decent b movie, that in no way deserves all the praise it gets.

Best is the best Ridley Scott movie

I can't believe no one picked ET for round two

JOHN SHOULD'VE WON WAY EARLIER ON. Andy was only trying to level the field by giving Scott points. John was clearly the better fighter!

my choices Spielberg’s Most Overrated Movie: minority report absolutely , thanks mantz Best Ridley Scott film: gladiator Best Bill Paxton Performance: master sergeant farrell, edge of tomorrow the next Meryl Streep : Saoirse Ronan Moonlight vs La La Land: 20th century women Star Wars vs Star Trek : each of them have its own merits, i love them both, but with a slight edge to star wars

Rocha V Mantz III!!!!!! LET'S GOOOO!!!!

Brie Larson vs Emma Stone? Damn, I have to go Brie Larson on this.

This week was lit. Good shit, guys! thanks for the show

As soon as I saw the title "Star Wars vs Star Trek" I knew it was going to be Mantz vs Rocha, yes! So excited! Go, Rocha!!

who is that beautiful specimen in the back?

wow this was one intense fight. keep it up. finally a new episode that reaches the level of the old ones. best show on youtube

This was freaking brilliant, these two are great fun!

How the fuck did none of them pick Gladiator as best Ridley Scott movie? Appalling

Andy: We have an audience here! (Five people + Dan) "Audience"

Thank god the french Canadian woman finally let them know it's pronounced Ville-nuv. Rocha won this fight. He could have easily been 5-1 if Signore didn't just hate Rocha so much that he couldn't stand to see him win.

Their arguments are so good that I wish all fights were filled with information and facts like this. xD

Please do one with Cracked's Daniel O'Brien, his massive knowledge of pop culture would be a awesome for this, and he is incredibly funny too! Also do one with Matpat, for the same reasons.

The clear choice that everyone missed in Round 2 was Crystal Skull. Everybody I know hates it but for some reason it's Certified Fresh on Rotten Tomatoes.

Just realised that Scott Mantz is Max Landis in 40 years, both in looks and personality.

Did anyone notice how high Mantz's voice got after he found out he had to defend "Moonlight"? It was hilarious!!

EPIC & COLOSAL FIGHT...!!!! More movie fights like this please !!!!

31:31 that look...I just died laughing

I love watching these two fight. They're so passionate! I hope the rest of March Mania fights are at this level or above.

This fight was incredible. Good work guys!

I can't believe I sided with Rocha but he's 100% right about Star Wars

At 1:53:00 two dudes on the top right show there support for moonlight.

great episode tho! really love both these guys

When the poll is 78% to 22%, but the judges says fuck it, I'm going the other way.

Andy gave Mantz multiple pity points throughout the entire episode. John brought the passion each argument. Andy didn't want it to be a blowout so he kept giving pity points to Mantz and it eventually came down to the final question which let Mantz win on a technicality. John deserves to go for the belt and if he isn't one of the people we can vote then that would be a discredit to the show

I think the trick question would have been more fun with star trek vs star wars. Wanted to see mantz fight against star trek.

It has been a while since I have watched a movie fight, this one did not disappoint 👌🏽👌🏽👌🏽😂😂

Jyn's father's death was an incredibly powerful moment? HAHAHAHAHA! Thanks, I needed that one, you a funny guy, Rocha

That was complete and utter bullshit giving Scott the win for the Star Trek argument. Yes, his opening was impressive, but Rocha went on to fucking own that game, just as he did with all the others.

To be honest, I think, Andy just manipulated the scoreboard to stretch the show. For me, Rocha won the argument that Brie Larson will be the next Meryl Streep. 4 -1 the end, Rocha's victory. It was difficult to watch this show. It was very long and very loud at times, it was tiring. I like the "one vs one" format. It may be interesting to continue this way and, in order to leave no doubt about tendentious judgments, adopt the format of 3 judges such as in Boxing or UFC. 3 different judges with different thoughts may have a fairer result.

really good one!

guy totally roasts that fan in the pants. lmao

I feel so damn childish but every time Rocha said "handjob" I lost my life 😂😂

Emma Stone plays Emma Stone in everything

This was incredibly awesome! Best fight in a long time!

Love the intro's when Rocha walks by Dan... Great stuff guys!

The tricky thing is Rocha is a better fighter, he's more aggressive, faster But Scott is so likeable, passionate, impossible to hate

RIP Movie Mantz for the second time this week 1:30:32

GREAT job Scott and John for such an amazing show! I haven't laughed and enjoyed such a moment on Movie Fights since this show! Round 6 is worth watching this entire show!

20 minutes in I am understanding how this vid is two hours long when most Movie Fights clock out at 1 hr, these guys go in!!

For the last question I would've said, Sherlock Holmes: Game of Shadows... The rivalry between Holmes and Moriarty is so delightful, even though the movie, while terribly enjoyable, isn't fantastic.

LOTR>star wars & Star trek

that slow zoom in on Dan while he was fact-checking the first round made it look like someone was about to shoot him or something

Finally an entertaining movie fights. Mantz and Rocha know how to argue and speak.

STAR TREK

Poor Rocha, deserved by a mile to win this one. Perfect case of one person collecting pity points to keep the fight on, and then go on and win it in the end. Would have been great to see Rocha go against Dan, he would have been a real threat to his championship.

27:39-27:46 is when Rocha channeled his inner Dexter from Dexter's laboratory

Rocha wiped the floor with Mantz on nearly every question. He should have won.

I really don't understand the hate and bias against Rocha. Every time he's on the show, he argues with a ton of passion, which I love, because it shows that he cares. He's always prepared and knowledgeable of the topics, he brings up good points and always articulates his points well. I felt like there were a few rounds he should've won instead of Mantz, ESPECIALLY the Moonlight vs. La Land trick question round. Rocha was much more convincing in his argument and displayed no difficulties in defending La La Land over Moonlight whereas Mantz clearly was bullshitting the whole time. P.S. Both the blonde and brunette are really hot. I couldn't take my eyes off them each time they cut to that couch.

John definitely should've won Star Wars. You bullshitted that judgment to keep him in

I love how Andy enjoyed how irritated Mantz was to argue against La La Land haha

This was amazing!

this episode was better than all January and February shows combined!

"Which is the best Honest Trailer?" "Who is the worst Screen Junkie?" "Which movie should be made into a video game?" "Which video game should be made into a movie or TV show?" "What is the best non-animated G-rated movie?" "What is the best animated P-13 or R-Rated movie?" "What is the best live-action Disney movie?" "If you could watch films from only one year for the rest of your life, which year would you choose?" "What is the best film trilogy?" "Who is the best actor/actress who is 25 or younger?" "What is the best movie that was the first or second movie by its director? "What is the best movie starring a Canadian in the leading role?"

Damn, all this argument and I ran out of popcorn.

Andy's face when they start talking over each other! 😂

Mantz's reaction to the trick question was priceless

Really solid arguments for both guys, though I must say that I've never disagreed with Andy's rulings in a single episode as many times as I did in this one. Great job by both competitors!

ONE OF THE BEST MOVIE FIGHTS EVER, these guys need there own show where they debate movies.

Whenever these two are on together it feels like a competition of who can yell the loudest

Wait Scott Mantz has to argue against La La Land? That would be like me arguing against Lord Of The Rings.

Bull@#÷% Rocha hammered Mantz INTO THE GROUND IN THE STAR WARS/ TREK fight

Love these two guys so much!

One of the best fights so far. So much better when they really care about the win.

*SPOILERS ON THE END/WINNER* Question was which movie FEATURES the best rivalry. Rocha made arguments why it was the best rivalry, and yes that rivalry spans multiple films. I think Andy got stuck upon the emphasis of the movie portion. I never care for who deserves to win these fights otherwise, these fights are meant to be fun, but if you're going to base on that premise, I say Rocha was robbed.

You gotta love Mantz, it's rare to see such a happy, joyful guy, who's full of passion in what he does.

Love Mantz, but he wasn't a big enough Blade Runner nerd to win that first argument. The Blade Runner influence rabbit hole goes so deep, there are practically music genre's based on Blade Runner's aesthetic.

I absolutely love when you guys do TRICK QUESTION!!!

Poor Joe Starr. Didn't he get thrown off of a movie fights for trying to make the same or similar Private Ryan argument as Rocha?

About the Star Trek vs Star Wars fight, i would like to see more constructive answers about the opposite franchise from both Mantz and Rocha, the ones they gave seem a bit vague and more like a "your sucks because mines better" argument, but thats just my opinion... and maybe try to hear one another instead of talking consecutively louder and louder :D

Their reactions to the trick question in round 6 was hilarious. So many reactions and gifs within a couple minutes.

Love Dan's comment - "I had to argue for Jurassic World, guys, SO NUT UP AND ARGUE!" Classic.

STAR WARS FOR LIFE!!!!

Holy shit they're copying Schmoedowns so much, they have the audience cam and now intros too ? Okay.

LOL - why does Andy always sound amazed that the match goes down to the last question??!! Even when he's giving the point away he doesn't even sound like he knows what he's talking about.

that was one of the best fights I've seen in a long time...