Just watched Maguire score an own goal that nearly cost us two points, and Ronaldo score a hat trick that won us the game. Who are we letting go again?

Maguire: Scores an own goal today, should stay Ronaldo: Scores a hattrick today, should go

"Ahh Maguire, I have never seen any footballers taking the defense apart like he does." Ronaldinho "Maguire is the most difficult player I have ever defended against." Luke shaw "He is the one player I've always had to keep an eye on during the whole match, he is simply unpredictable." Victor Lindelof "Every move he generates with his skills terrifies me." Raphael Varane "When he is in the box, Maguire is the toughest player I have ever had to deal with." David De Gea "There's no player running towards goal I fear more than Maguire." Wan Bissaka "At 80m, he is a bargain. He is the most consistent defender I have ever seen." Sir Alex Furgerson "He sees the spaces between defenders that no one else can." Mesut Ozil "He can play for both sides, such a class player." Roy keane "The greatest false 4 in history." Pep guardiola "This guy, he is feared even by his own teammates." Patrick Vieira "Give me Maguire and 10 pieces of wood and I will give you 11 pieces of wood." Zinedine Zidane "When Maguire leads a counter attack, we all rush back on goal to defend." Paul Pogba "Harry's sheer presence in this United squad is crucial to our success, he is simply irreplaceable." ~ Liverpool, Chelsea, Arsenal, Man city "He is class. If every team had a player in their team like Maguire, they wouldn't need opposing teams." Xavi Hernandez "He is the best player I have ever played with." Mohammed Salah "There are two goals in the field, Maguire, he can score anywhere he likes. He is a phenomenon." Pele "He is the one player every club wants to have in the lineup.... . . ....Of the opposing team." Paolo Maldini "Everyone makes mistakes, even professionals, what Maguire does isn't.. Just pure skills." Neymar Jr "My only mistake was not being as consistent as him." Phil Jones "Maguire is the most kind hearted opponent I have ever faced." Roberto Firminho "I have never seen any CB playing the art of Onside trap as well as Maguire." Carles Puyol "He was born to defend his team from winning." Gary Neville "Don't judge a goal by its side, a goal is a goal." Harry Maguire "I almost lost my career because of him." Mr bean

This was actually really insightful look into the psychology around the club and the fans. It was supposed to be an exercise in being a bit nasty and brutal, to hold the current squad up to the Keane standard, to the Man U who won trebles. Conclusion: nice people, heart in the right place, but in complete denial about what needs to happen.

You already know the list is wrong when you see Maguire in the Stay category.

Dave: "The defence is one of the big issues at Manchester United and needs to be sorted" Also Dave: *Selects to keep 6 out of the 9 defenders in the squad*

Rory is spot on with EVERY take. Love him, get him on again!

This guy doesn’t know what he is doing😭😭😭they should bring Mark Goldbridge to do one of these. Personally I’d let Maguire, Rashford and McTominay go and keep Ronaldo

Am I in a parallel universe where Rory speaks more sense than anyone else about a club he doesn’t support?

As a Liverpool fan, keep Maguire at Man United. This is hilarious

As a Man City fan please keep Maguire, he is a gift that keeps on giving!

Sure, keep your defense, they’ll come in handy as bench options. Shaw and Wan-Bissaka have 1 or 2 more seasons to show what they’re really about. Dalot can be a great player. Lindelof seems like a good backup option. Maguire should just leave, unless he’s cool with being a backup.

I find it funny how the non United fans can see that Maguire isn’t good enough but the United fans don’t. The guy seemed more sure on Maguire than Varane. Criminal (Maguire own goal today)

This aged well. Ronaldo just scored a hat trick. Eat that, Dave.

Dave once mentioned to put Darren Fletcher in man utd all time XI... So the maguire one is not that shocking

Rory choices shows why ManU aren't able to find the right manager, Rory is the only one of the 4 to be accurate

Love how Dave proceeds to keep most of the players who are a problem at united. Baffling. Rory knows more about united than united fans.

Embarrassed as a united fan to see some of the players Dave wants to still keep. United should only keep 4 players in my opinion

Rory’s take on rashford really aged well didn’t it.

When talking about big games for this club and specifically Scott McTominay, the fact that he put Leeds United in the same category as Liverpool and Man City is BEYOND me

I love Rory. He just knows what he’s talking about man. He’s not even a United fan but he knows the level United should be operating at.

I had so much respect for Dave. But honestly a Chelsea fan can clearly judge things better than him. His opinion has dented all Man U fans to be incompetent and I dont think he speaks for all of us. Do this segment with Gold bridge and hear a fan with standards, speak the truth about what needs to be done in this club.

I’d love to see Dean Hendo at Everton or West Ham, and maybe get into the England squad

I wouldn't sell Matic unless two defensive midfielders are brought in. He's the only actual defensive midfielder in the team.

The fact Maguire is still a regular starter is bad in itself but the fact he is still captain is actually unbelievable & shows how much of a circus the glazers & the board have made the club. Maguire is the worst captain the club has ever had, and that’s not an over exaggeration

When you have a moderator that says that he keeps Maguire, Fred and Rashford and decided to sack Ronaldo from the team says everything how much he understands football. Man United deserves much better!

Really good video, good debate. As a complete neutral I'm baffled. Depends what level united want to be at. When I was growing up united was the best at everything. If I look at city, Liverpool and Chelsea, united maybe have three or four players at best who would get in their squads as squad players, not starters. If united want to get back they need a massive clear out

Williams at 21 is a definite stay. Is an academy product, stepped in very well in 2019-20. Used the wrong way in 2020-21 (should have gone on loan) and has had a great loan move to Norwich, worked his way into a first choice, player of the month and probably one of top 2 or 3 players ona premier league club. Should get another chance under a new manager at United, especially if you are keeping Donny VanDeBeek.

As a united fan I'm worried by this man's selections, thank you Rory for being a sane voice..... Maguire and Mcfred to stay and pogba to go is so unbelievably wrong on so many levels. Maguire alone has been a laughing stock every game this season because of his performances, how can you back that

If these guys had the opportunity to buil United, they would've surely asked Ronaldo and De Gea to leave immediately and would've begged Maguire to stay😂

Wow Rory has been absolutely spot on throughout, he's right about Maguire, wan bissaka and Pogba

Depends. How much money do I have to replace? How many new players can I bring in? With no limits, I'd only keep a few players and sell most of the squad.

For this kind of topic Goldbridge needs to be there, would have been really fun.

Whoever is holding Dave's family hostage to keep Maguire in the squad, please let them go. 🙏 Scott McTominay a fan favourite.... yea of Liverpool and Citeh fans.

"Scored one goal in 2022", my man, Ronaldo took this personally and made it four goals in 2022.

Actually agreed with the list all the way, until the end. You can't keep Rashford and Maguire based on previous form and then sell Ronaldo just because he'd hit a small slump in his performance.

I think Rashfords biggest defence being his charity work says a lot

Thanks for having me on. Loved it.

"Stat man" Dave highlighting once again the issues with basing your opinions solely on stats

IM a Chelsea fan and even i see you have a star in Maguire. His stats last season were phenomenal. if theres even a chance he can go back to that you need to keep him.

Soon as he said Maguire stays you know it’s going no where .

Maguire: STAY Ronaldo: GO This aged woefully! 😂

Love to see Statman Dave living the dream

dave: rashford is in a bad spot but i'd keep him also dave: ronaldo has only scored 1 goal in 2022 (now 4 obviously)

Rory a million % on maguire , he’s a great player playing in a back 11, was clear to see the sort of English bias aswell when they were just trowing varane in the stay category even do he’s our best defenders and has be top class in the games he’s played

Dave again shows how little of the game he understands. Rashford runs fast and nothing else. Fails in every other category

I know a lot of people don’t want Maguire to stay over recent performances. It has been terrible - but keeping him would be the smart decision. Last season he was solid for us, he shouldn’t captain - he can be our backup center half. Hope he regains form next season under a new manager. And not being a captain improves his performances

MAKE THIS VIDEO AGAIN WITH THE CURRENT SQUAD

Rory is spot on for almost everything ! Coming from a man utd fan....Maguire , rashford should go ...they are not the level of true Manchester United

Now Ronaldo scored a hat trick against Spurs, then he'll probably carry this team to top 4 and there will still be people like Dave who's gonna want him to leave.

Tell us you have no football knowledge without saying you have no football knowledge: “Maguire: Stay”

Dam this aged well. Guy literally bagged a hattrick against spurs and single handedly won them the game. The guy talks about stats so much and misses the most important one. Goals win games and this guy has an abundance

Statman Dave has lost it having Maguire stay. To us rival fans we love this choice

The fact that this man instantly and without question put Mctominay in Stay tells you everything you need to know.

You already know the list is wrong when you see Maguire , McFred in the Stay category and CR7 go category

Rory is one of the most knowledgeable football youtubers. Great man

Mctominay? How about mentioning his inability to receive the ball from the back four and progressing the ball forward. Doesn’t know how to use his body with his back to goal. Could’ve really hit a nail on the head with why United struggle so much and need the overhaul. The midfields inability to control the game and look comfortable with the ball/ good movement, is nonexistent.

Rory absolutely spot on with these. Dave going off emotion and English bias.

Maguire out! Ronaldo in! Rory makes more sense than the United fan. Also he keeps assuming we’re not getting Poch…

fren is really good in his role box to box we saw that agianst tottenham he going foward giving kety pass know when to do back heel knows when to play wall he is really good when he have real cdm behind him

These guys really said last season maguire was one of Uniteds stand out players🤣🤣🤣

Dave wants repeat the past 4 years for United. Maguire, mctominay, Rashford, etc… they haven’t been good enough for 2 years but let’s just keep praying it works

I’m not a United fan so I love seeing their misery right now but literally everyone except Varane and Sancho needs to be sold and possibly De Gea but I feel like he needs a new challenge

We need a clear out: GO: Henderson, Jones, Maguire, Pogba, Matic, Mata, Lingard, Martial, Rashford, Greenwood, Cavani Bring back: Van De Beek, Diallo, Garner. (Promote Hanniball) Recruit: Rudiger, Rice, Kane

I’m a united fan, and Maguire should either be sold or be a bench player. Bring in someone like De Ligt, Skriniar, Koulibaly etc.. to partner Varane. We need 2 world class CBs, like we did with Ferdinand and Vidic.

How anyone can say De Gea, the best player for united this season, needs to go but Maguire, one of the worst players and captains United have ever seen, stays is baffling. How much are United paying you for these crap opinions?

I think they're doing partiality, because how can you add Maguire to the stay group

How could you put MaGuire in Stay And Ronaldo in Go ? And also say defence is a problem and put 6 defenders out of 9 in stay? 🙄🙄 You're seriously out of your mind mate .

This man said to keep maguire, what a joke. Doesn’t represent all united fans or be here on this show

3 goals today you know nothing about football

I'm typing this as we go in terms of where I might disagree . First of all, Deano has to stay. De Gea doesn't have many years left and we can't be looking back in the market at that popint. With Phil, I don't mind giving him a chance. But really depends on his wages. With Harry Maguire, he has to go. His price tag is weighing too heavy on him. It's best for both the club and him that he goes. I think Rory/Dave have got it the wrong way around with Dalot and AWB. AWB is a much better player and everytime I watch Dalot I am reminded of how mediocre of a club United are right now. He is not spectacular in attack, and his defending is attrocious. With AWB, you know you at least get a good defender. He led the league for blocks/tackles for couple of seasons in a row. Needs some improvement in his positioning a little but I think that's coachable. With TElles, I'm on the fence. He's great going forward. He's just absolutely terrible at defending. He has the heart just not a good defender with his reading of the game. I'd even be willing to let Telles go and keep Brandon instead. In midfield, Pogba has to stay. What a generational talent. I know this shouldn't discuss transfers in. But a great DM is all we need to unlock him (see the French national team or even his partnership with Pogba during Project Restart as the perfect example of that. McT is a 50/50 for me but I'd keep him for depth and also that intensity during big games like Fletch used to be in our peak teams. For Anthony, I'm biased but he's one of our most talented No 9's. I think he works well in a fluid system as opposed to being a classic 9. So I'd actually keep him. Absolutely with Dave here on Rash. Even last season, he was amazing until his injuries caught up towards the end. Had a bad Euros because of it. Should never have went as he should have just done the surgery before the Euros. The penalty miss in the final has also obviously hurt it. He's just struggling to recover from both of those. But I think he'll come good again soon. And absolutely on point with CR7/Cavani. Exactly the reason why Anthony should stay too haha.

Stay (Starter): De Gea, Ronaldo, Bruno, Varane, Dalot, Shaw, Sancho Stay (Squad Player): Lindelof, Fred, Cavani, Telles, Wan-Bissaka, Elanga, McTom, Diallo, Van de Beek Go: Maguire, Bailly, Jones, Pogba, Mata, Rashford, Greenwood?, Lingard, Grant, Heaton, Henderson, Matic, Martial, Pereira, Williams

Just came back to this vid because i still cant believe what was said here... Howler! Maguire "stay" -> own goal Ronaldo "go" -> hat trick 🙈🙈🙈🙈

People don’t realize that Rashford has never been good enough, but the love from media and fans have always covered that up by making excuses for him, he needs to take some responsibility too. Again, how Maguire and Luke Shaw are in the “stay” category while Pogba and Ronaldo are in “Go” category baffles me, this guy is confused.

I'd keep Bailly and Jones and ask Maguire to leave. Maguire has cost us more goals than any other single player... really not good enough.

Fred has tallent it’s there and he’s played well the last few games. Scott mctominay has passion but he’s just not good enough for this club

I wonder how many of the STAY players would get in the Liverpool, City, Chelsea, Arsenal and Totenham teams

Players like McTominay and Shaw to stay? They’re literally 2 of the biggest reasons United have been massively underachieving since Mourinho left.

Game after this, Fanny MacGuire had another howler and scored ANOTHER OWN GOAL

Yes a lot of these players aren’t United “standard” but unless they’re gonna drop a billon in the transfer market this summer they have to start somewhere and build up slowly

Flipping heck, just the discussion around Maguire and Varane is hilarious. You'd think Maguire is the one with 4 CL and a world cup medal! Maguire is NOT Man Utd standards, how the hell he made the Stay section is just crazy talk.

How Luke Shaw has managed to fall in the “stay” category is ridiculous. His and Maguire’s mistakes have caused more goals this year than anyone else. He’s awful, and totally overrated.

Maguire is only good if you have the fall back on his side ticking in close, and have deep lying cover in front, so the opposite of Ralf wants to play or Ten Hag

Questioning De Gea and Van de Beek's abilities is delusional

rory was spot on with his opinions mctominay and maguire just aren't good enough

The way these lot talk about McTominay it's like he's Roy Keane, he's consistently below average and people hype him up for doing the bare minimum once a month, epitomises how far our standards have dropped

When they was talking about maguire I had to check three times if the video was “11 days ago” or 11 month ago 😂😂😂 and watching the rest of this Iv come to the conclusion that these are delusional 😂😂if I was at united there’s probs about 4/5 players that are a stay but as a city fan I’m enjoying this squad so keep them all 😂

The ronaldo should go part really aged well😂... As he scored a hat-trick in the game against Tottenham.. i am not a har core ronaldo fan but letting him go is a bit disrespectful i think.

as a united fan , I disagree with dave on maguire and also rashford. maguire was fantastic for leicester city because of the style of play and the team with which he played. but if united want to be anywhere near the likes of man city, liverpool,chelsea then he is surely has to go . also rashford has done outstanding work for the community and children, but coming after from the injury , he hasn't been the same rashford. so I think probably , if united want to keep him and he is not at his previous level , then the new manager has to make a tough call.

i was so disappointed with them putting Maguire and mcfred in the stay category smh.

You say ronaldo should go cause of not pressing and defending but you keep maguire in This is what we call madness and lack of understanding football

Scoring goals is only one part of many in football. When you have someone who only does one thing, he makes the rest of the team orse, which is the problem with Ronaldo. Defenders need to be able to transition the game and pick attacking passes. Attackers need to chase and win the ball back once it's been lost. Utd have a lot of players who only defend, or only attack, and then often, do neither well.

The end of this video aged so beautifully. "He's only scored one goal in 2022" 🤣🤣

Why does McTominay keep getting off the hook? He was at fault for one of the goals against City didn't bother tackling Gundogan.

For me personally, the rebuild phase for Man Utd needs to start when Erik Ten Hag takes over. It's hard on the whole team yes, but you can't just lug around a team of lifeless personnel around and play games without the hunger to win. Just like life, all good things must come full circle and come to an end and in football, this doesn't mean the end. This is only the beginning of a new era. I sincerely hope Man Utd will rise up from the ashes like a phoenix and fight for more titles again.

This is my extended Version on what we need to do at Man Utd no matter if Erik Ten Hag or Mauricio Pochettino takes over as manager. (STAY) David De Gea Dean Henderson Victor Lindelof Harry Maguire Raphael Varane Luke Shaw Alex Telles Bruno Fernandes Paul Pogba Fred Scott McTomaniy Jadon Sancho Anthony Elanga Marcus Rashford Cristiano Ronaldo Tom Heaton (LEAVE) Eric Bailly Phil Jones Juan Mata Nimanja Matic Lee Grant Diego Dalot Anthony Martial Jesse Lingard Edinson Cavani Tahith Chong (CALLED UP) Hannibal Shola Shoretire Alvaro Fernandez Zidane Iqbal Alejandro Garnacho Charlie Savage D,Mani Mellor (RETURNING) Ethan Laird Amad Diallo Brandon Williams Axel Tuanzebe Teden Mengi James Garner Donny Van De Beek Facundo Pellistri (SIGNINGS) Antonio Rüdiger/Ronald Araujo Declan Rice/Amadou Haidara Rúben Neves/John McGinn Erling Haaland/Harry Kane (SQAUD) Sqaud Size = 37 (GK) David De Gea Dean Henderson Tom Heaton (RB/RWB) Wan Bissaka Brandon Williams Ethan Laird (CB) Harry Maguire Victor Lindelof Raphael Varane Antonio Rudiger/Ronald Araujo Axel Tuanzebe Teden Mengi (LB/LWB) Luke Shaw Alex Telles Alvaro Fernandez (DM) Declan Rice/Amadou Haidara Scott McTominay James Garner (CM) Fred Charlie Savage Ruben Neves/John McGinn Hannibal Zidane Iqbal (AM) Bruno Fernandes Donny Van De Beek Paul Pogba (RW/RM) Jordan Sancho Amad Diallo Shola Shoretire (LW/LM) Anthony Elanga Alejandro Garnacho Facundo Pellistri (ST) Erling Haaland/Harry Kane Cristiano Ronaldo Marcus Rashford D,Mani Mellor

The bloke making the decisions is deciding all off of emotion.. Rashford’s stats are arguably pretty impressive BUT he doesn’t improve on his game and spends 80-85mins being terrible but he can always have a moment. Depends what you want from the player really 🤷‍♂️

Keep maguire he is helping all man utds Rivals atm, so good times as an arsenal fan

jokes aside with maguire being a bomb scare if him and varrane can become a partnership with de gea as club captain it could be fine. id add pogba into this too with consistency he can perform right now nothing at utd is consistent apart maybe being consistently subpar

When are Man Utd fans going to admit that signing Maguire was a mistake, he is not a top level defender, not saying they should get rid but he is an expensive squad player, the fact that he is captain reflects badly on the team, they need a new leader in the dressing room