An adaptation from DS version should be in the Mario 3D All-Star for switch..

NDS = Better 3D Models and More Details. N64 = Better Textures and Sound Quality

I actually played the DS version before the original N64! TBH, I love both of them! Regardless of which game has better graphics or textures or whatever, they’re both pretty much the same game. However what I really like about the DS version is that it has more variety, more levels, and more to offer! Playing as Mario is fun and all, but having the option as playing as either Yoshi, Luigi, or Wario as well after you save/unlock them, and they all have their own unique abilities designed for certain purposes in the game, can’t go wrong with that! While it is true that the DS version doesn’t have analog, but I didn’t mind the D-pad since I grew up with the DS. Besides if you play this game on the 3DS, problem solved via the 3DS’s analog... If there’s 1 thing we can all agree on, is that this game needs to come out on Nintendo Switch!

SM64: _Exists_ SM64 DS: _Better Graphichs_ Super Mario 3D All Stars: _It's just evolving... but backwards..._

You can argue about the quality of the textures, lighting, sound an about the colour palette. That's all personal preference. But the models and environmental details are clearly much more polished and better looking on the DS.

The NDS version lacks texture filtering, but it looks better in the rest.

N64: Analog control. NDS: *Everything else.*

They should've waited to make a 3DS remake than this game. Lack of analog was always a bother to me.

I grew up with the newer version

Man I wish they could remake this exact game on the switch. It would be cool of they could get it to look as good as oddyssey.

I don't remember the DS version being quiet in the palace

The interesting thing is the Nintendo 64 version uses way more polys (especially in mario's model) than the Nintendo DS version but they're just made better and way more efficient so less is really more, the Nds version also does have higher quaity textures and it's really impressive that those more detailed textures actually work together and make mario look more detailed even tho he's really less detailed in a way

I grew up with the DS version, but I can go play the 64 version and have just as much fun. I prefer the DS just for the extra content, but it's not a deal breaker at all.

I would prefer a DS port on the switch with Mario Odyssey's camera controls but I honestly don't mind! As long as we get something in the end (love the video btw)

They should have ported the DS version of Mario 64 to the 3D All Stars collection.

0:27 look! Advanced Fish AI!

It would be nice if they gave us the ds version for the switch edition

Imagine if the version in 3D All-Stars had the analog control of the N64 version, the graphics of the render96 project, and the added content and level design of the DS version. That would be amazing.

The lack of analogue control never once bothered me in SM64DS, since it really reminded me of playing Spyro with the original PS1 controllers, where it simulates the feel of full 360 degree movement with only 4 directions.

On 1:18 😂😂😂😂 that stone face block on the n64

I thought the video was made 3 Years ago.

Besides the highly improved character models, I also think the textures look a lot better in the DS version. They have a clearer sense of direction, they look more cartoony and Mario-like making them fit a Mario game better, plus the palette of Bob-Omb Battlefield is much nicer to look at. Many of the original textures give a kinda "stock" feel. The only problem is that they lack bilinear filtering, but that's the DS hardware to blame and I don't think it looks bad. But if they had it, I'd consider the DS version's graphics better in almost every way.

Great comparison. I actually love that less-saturated grass in the DS' Bob-omb Battlefield - even though I was a N64 kid and haven't played the DS version.

Esto si es un remake xd

Being an early 2000s kid, I actually grew up with both. My first console and game was a N64 with SM64 on it. Then I got a DS, and SM64DS. While I do prefer the N64 version, the DS version had amazing qualities and it allowed me to play my favourite game ever on the go. The main issue is I often mixed up what belonged to any of the versions, like I'd often forget Wario isn't in the original one!

Can’t Nintendo just port this game over to the Nintendo Switch?? They must keep it alive forever, and revive it every 15 (or so) years!

We need a SM64 ON SWITCH

While the DS version looks better, there are some changes that are not as good. The grass color at level one in the DS version looks puke green compared the N64 version which is light green and the pink bomb characters look less lively (like they're bored or something). I also find it funny how there's a wall missing in the DS version at 0:37.

The typical argument that the N64 is better is because of better resolution and easier controls. But the fact is that the DS does in fact have better graphics, more detail and is not only the same game but with more added to the foundation. The DS version is basically the complete full potential that the N64 version had but didn't reach. The DS version had all the same worlds plus more, mini games, multiplayer and more playable characters. I remember when I was a young child all my friends and I always talked about how we wish Luigi was playable in SM64 but wasn't. That was of course until the DS version came along and not only was Mario playable but Luigi, Wario and Yoshi as well. The DS version is just a better version of the game and there is no denying that. Resolution or even graphics for that matter doesn't make a game better than another. You play games for fun wide gameplay experience. Which the DS version obviously hands down has more to offer gameplay wise. More stars to collect, more worlds and more characters = longer and better gameplay experience. As for controls, that excuse is just nit picking. The controls worked perfectly for me. You just have to get use to it. If you play with the DS controls longer you'll get use to it. The real and only reason anyone would say the N64 version is better os because of Nostalgia reasons and nostalgia reasons only. Resolution and controls is simply just an excuse. I mean I completely understand nostalgia reasons completely because I have those all the time. Don't get me wrong it's all opinion based. If you like the N64 version better That's fine but don't act like your opinion is fact because it's far from it.

Es mi imaginación o Mario corre más rápido en NDS que en N64

I wish they used the Mario 64 DS version for All Stars. The other one is a serious downgrade imo. Yeah, its the original and has Charm, but man is it rough. Would have preferred a remake or a port of the DS version

I grew up playing the 64 version. Still remember the store displays when it came out

Never truly understood the problem people had with the DS version of the game, I completed it as a kid 100% with no problems. The fact that theirs no analog controller was never that bad. I would take the DS version over the N64 any day it has way more to offer. Along with Animal Crossing Wild World I would say this tied with being perhaps the Greatest game to come out on the DS to show off the DS's true Potential and both games came out early in the DS's lifespan. Super Mario 3D Land sucked compared to Super Mario 64 DS. And while I'm at it Mario Kart DS also had more to offer than Mario Kart 7. And Super Mario Sunshine is the best 3D world Mario Game in my opinion and would love to see a remake or sequel on the 3DS.

I honestly wish I could bring the DS extra features to the N64 version, then it would be the best.

looks different but Mario's design and the twomps are different for DS and 64. I prefer DS version.

N64: world looks better, Mario looks shit DS: Mario looks better, world looks shit

I like the ds version only because Yoshi is my favorite character but the game should have waited till the 3ds much like Zelda & Starfox

I always remember it to look better on the DS, I never played N64 version but whenever I saw a video about it I always thought that it lacked something. Be it design or detail (I'm not saying it's worse just that the quality is different)

Am I the only one who doesn't have a problem with the DS controls?

Most of the people complaining about the NDS version are entitled to analog sticks. What's the issue, dude? Too poor to buy a 3DS?

Wow the DS version is way better. The only issue I can see is the control, but if you play it on a 3DS with the circle pad then you are all set.

tipico alguien español pone titulo en ingles en el que no hablas y el video se llena de ingleses

The fuck happened to the colors in the NDS version.

I like the DS version. I don't care about the analog stick. Fight me.

It's an Amazing game, now I miss my nintendo DS :c

Both games are Great! I grew up playing the DS Version💙

I wish this game didn't get remade until the 3DS. The DS version felt really lacking without a circle pad. If this had Ocarina of Time 3D treatment it would've been so damn great.

Whenever people were talking about how amazing it is that 64 games like Ocarina of Time can run on the 3DS, even with improved visuals, I always have a brief moment of flashing back to my childhood playing this game and think to myself “this has been done before, where were you for that?”

0:52 look at the door perfect example of texture filter

So which version is coming to the switch?

DS is better but N64 is more nostalgic.

N64 will always be my favorite this was groundbreaking back in the day

Wait your NDS Princess Peach castle doesn’t have music, strange, mine does

the DS remake has more content, which makes it better by definition.

The sound effects for the N64 version are a little different than usual. Listen to the double jump at 1:29, and if you're a fan of the NTSC version, at the very least, you'll notice what I mean. Is there a regional difference in sound? Was it a recording issue?

La Versión de NDS Tiene 4 Personajes Jugables Con Carateristicas y Habilidades Distintas,Nuevos Jefes,Nuevos Niveles,150 Estrellas (30 Más que en el Juego Original),Minijuegos y Los Personajes no Están Horribles como en la Versión Original Mátenme estos Argumentos Con Argumentos Válidos y no con cosas Como "La Versión Original es la Mejor Porque es la Original" o "Todos los Remakes son Malos"

I never noticed that bomps don't have a face on the DS version

Wow everyone is Too much with Nostalgia even tho the DS is the Best One!

In the Nintendo Ds and Nintendo 64 are the same but different graphics trust me I used to have these games

Soon we will have an N64, NDS and NS comparison.

When I heard no music in peaches castle for the ds I was like bruh who dafuq made this

Super Mario 64 would fit perfectly in the 3D Land style

There's something so beautiful about the 64 version. It seems like a lot of effort went into every aspect of it. There was passion and the final product is art. The DS version just seems like a passionless reskin. It's okay, but it doesn't come anywhere close. Just the birds leaving the tree at 0:21 shows it all.

I hope there will be an official Super Mario 64 Remake for the Nintendo Switch. They should use the Super Mario Odyssey Graphics and character models from the game! But I hope they still keep Mario’s SM64 voice and make them all sound higher quality just like they did with his SM64 voice clips in Super Smash Bros. Melee. Replacing the original voice would ruin the overall feel of the game and the historical value of the character. :(

DS is the objective winner, the color palette of the original was nonsense and a muddy mess, and the DS remake also has far superior models and textures

Remake Mario 64 and Sunshine for the Switch then I’ll be happy. Edit: LETS FUCKING GOOOO

1:42 My unpopular opinion: SM64 looked better, because the darker area towards the floor gave the impression of a bit of ambient occlusion.

Funny how a lot of youngins actually GREW UP with the DS version...it has qirks but ultimately is the better game....THATS the one that needs an upscaled port

The DS version does suffer in the sound department. The music sounds fine, maybe a little less fidelity, but the sound effects and voices can be pretty low-quality. There is also some variety missing in sound effects that play and mario's voice clips. Even though NDS cards support up to 512MB of storage space, this was a launch title and the rom is only about 9.3MB, not far off from the original N64 cartridge.

I still prefer n64

I think DS is way better. I also had way less problems with the DS controls. THe N64 version had me ragequit multiple times because of the controls. That didn't happen on the DS, they worked around not having a stick very well. It's the better version by far.

I don’t know but when I was a kid this game make me feel weird the emptiness on the game I never understand the game what it was about to this day every time I see a video I feel like a emptiness maybe the game makes you feel that way since is all empty and weird

I'm just disappointed that Nintendo DS doesn't have texture filtering like Nintendo 64 and GameCube before it. Also it doesn't have some kind of Analog Stick. Estoy decepcionado de que Nintendo DS no tenga filtrado de texturas como Nintendo 64 y GameCube antes. Además, no tiene ningún tipo de Stick analógico.

you weren’t lying when you said “HD”

justamente estoy volviendo a jugar el super mario 64 ds y algo que note fue que la musica es mas alta en el n64 que la version nds

1:50 I thought it was creepy how there was no garden in the N64 version then in the DS version there was a garden. Pretty creepy.

The Ds Version has Sharper Graphic's and Better Colors!

I think SM64DS graphics are better

For the people complaining about the DS version not having an analog stick just use the 3ds or an emulator like DraStic on Android phones you can connect a Bluetooth controller with and an analog stick

Graphics-wise the improvement was not enough (like the remakes for OOT and MM) to persuade anyone to pick the DS version over the N64, but it does come with Luigi, Wario and Yoshi so with those additions it became the definitive version.

Why nintendo Switch didn't put the DS graphic option..

The DS version is my childhood

They both look great in HD.

It would have been interesting if they would have included the DS version in 1080p with analog controls. I feel like the collection would have been much better if they would have included the DS version alongside the N64 version.

Good old Mario 64 on the ds.

NDS is better

Gracias por estos videos amigo! 👍

I grow up with 64 IDC how better the dc is I would never replace my dear childhood game

Deberian hacer un remake de este juego para 3ds , como hicieron con el ocarina y majoras , solo falta mario y banjo y kazooie para cerrar con broche de oro la 3ds como la mejor portatil de la historia

La resolución en N64 se ve mejor, en NDS los gráficos son mejores En cuanto a contenido el remake de NDS me parece mejor, ahí hay mas estrellas, mas personajes jugables, agregaron nuevos jefes, etc. Sim embargo, no cabe duda que ambos son bastante buenos y no pierdes nada jugando uno u otro :)

If someone can make a PC port of the DS Remake and add the sound quality of the original game, that would be perfection.

grew up with the ds version, it's very interest to see the n64 one

BGM神‼️ ってか、日本人見てる人いる？？

I played this game with Nintendo DS

Played DS before N64, but I love the charm of the original, while also love having Yoshi, Waluigi, and Luigi playable as well as the variety in forms of playable minigames, more levels, multiplayer, secrets, differences in map geometry, etc. It all may not seem like much, but it really adds more to an already great game without going overboard.

I grew up with both. I like both. N64 feels prettier but DS has more things to do

The DS version is much better.

Las texturas y el modelado de Mario en NDS son mucho mejores, ademas en NDS hay mejor framerate.

I can't believe it's already been 14 Years since NDSver was released.

Crazy how a small ds can run a n64 game but with better graphics and more. Technology is evolving!