السلام علیکم ورحمۃ اللہ وبرکاتہ اللہ تیرا شکر ہے تو نے ہمیں غامدی صاحب عطا کیا اور ان کی ٹیم عطا کی سچی تحریک

I had never find anyone so comprehensive, calm, logical and Softly spoken like Mr JA Ghamdi

logical and research oriented approach

More I listen this person more I’m becoming his fan.

The best explanation I have ever heard in my life! ❤️

Mann karta hai aapko sunta hi jaau. Kya adab ka lehza bakhsha hai aapko Allah ne😍

Allah ap ko sehat or lambi umar ata kare ameen you are a asset for muslims

I love you great Islamic Scholar JAVAID AHMAD GHAMADI, Love you and salute you and salaam alaikum to you from me and my family from Maryland the United States of America.

Why is this video not with English subtitles? It should be made in multiple languages with subtitles.

Kudos and like for the Interviewer. Job well Done..!

Ghamdi sb Ma Shaa ALLAH bht he sabir insan hain. ALLAH in ki hifazat karey ore omer mn barkat ataa karey, Aameen

❤❤❤ Ghamidi sb Allah Kareem bless you long life with health! Amen. Thank you Hassan bhai and back up teams with sincere heart. ❤❤❤AlHamdoLillaH AlHamdoLillaH AlHamdoLillaH ❤❤❤Allah Almighty ❤❤❤ we having Ghamidi sb versatile approach scholar surgeon physician Ghamidi the great!❤❤❤ Ali khan Queens NY

Leave my KNOWLEDGABLE DIFFERENCES ASIDE, JAVID AHMAD GAMDHI SB IS UNDOUBTLY THE ASSET OF THE WORLD OF KNOWLEDGE.

Its great blessing to have ghamidi sb in our time.

Jazakallah

The interviewer is questioning awesomely

26:08 JazakAllah khaira

I m waiting 4th part.nice

His words are more than dimonds

Imam Hussain A. S. was killed by a unjust, tyrant and unlawful ruler. It is irony that some brothers from sunni community is hesitant to call him a zalim and leave this to Allah. A Muslim should have courage and honesty to distinguish between zalim and mazloom

No one is like Sir Ghamidi in the whole muslim world

جزاک اللہ

Very informative...last questions...perfect

Mashallah mashallaah kiaa zauban ki rawani atta frmai hayy Allah ny...jb gamdi sahb bolna shoro krty hain tu mjal hayy kahun roknaa pryy sochny k liee kbi hmmmm aaannn krny pry

May Allah Almighty bless you always

Ghamidi Sahib...May Allah bless you with healthy and long life. Keep on serving Islam and the Muslims. Modern world needs scholars like you.... Thanks. I wish to have a via a via conversation with you. I pray Allah to fulfill my wish. Thanks a lot.

Great 👍🏻

Excellent👍👍great Islamic scholar

How can i contact al Mawrid for asking questions ?

The Karbala Event kay aas paas charon taraf ghoomtay rahe magar KARBALA bari mushkil say halaq say nikli - wah wah ?

Jazakallaah

This series is incomplete??

Part 2 is worth listening!

Can anyone suggest some good book on history based on Neutral approach?

Where is its third part??

یہ تمام جھگڑا ہی اللہ کے رسول ص کی جانشینی پر شروع ہوا اہلسنت کے نزدیک اللہ کے نبی ص نے کسی کو جانشین نہیں بنایا بلکہ شوری پر چھوڑ دیا جو صاحب عقل لوگوں کے لیے ہضم کرنا مشکل ہے !

This was said then that peoples of china knew how to make paper from wood, as it was very costly and most of text was written, on bones, animal skins, and leaves, and off course on paper too, so to learn the Technique he said seek knowledge even it is in china, some said it was only a reference given as it was very fare away, from Medina, or to show the importance of knowledge. Gods know the best.

غامدی صاحب کی بات سمجھنے کے لئے ضروری ہے کہ پہلے ہم اپنے پرانے تصوّر کو الگ رکھ دیں اور پھر عقل سے ان باتوں کا جائزہ لیں۔

Announcement: duniya ka sab say khush naseeb banda mil gya hai. Naam hassan ilayas hai. I wish I were you hassan bhai.

GHAMDI's THESIS OF REAL POLITIK IN ISLAM Just watched a few video's by Javed Amed Ghamdi a prominent Pakistani religious scholar discussing the historical back ground of the Incident of Karbala- This is actually a series of 4 videos which describe the succession process after the death of the prophet ( pbuh). I had always regarded Mr. Ghamdi a very rational person and found his videos quite educative and also based on rational thinking. His basic thesis in this case is is that the process of succession of the prophet was r recognition of the realities on the ground and coming up with a solution which would be best for the preservation and progress of the Islamic Empire- i.e. real-politik. ( e.g. giving the quaraish the right to choose rather than the whole muslim Ummah etc. ) As for Karbala he says that this was a natural consequence of the non recognition by Imam Hussain of Yazid who in turn was the only leader that Mauvia could have nominated to preserve the Islaimc kingdom - else there would have been civil war. ( He actually mentions the recent khashogghi inicdent in suport of his thesis that such refusalsresult in these type of incidents). Albeit sounding brutal to me ( my being a Shia) I could go along with his thesis based on real plitik. My only critiicism is that after adopting a real politik basis for action it is not possible to move back to a moral criterion. Therefore, first it is not acceptable that one can attach any moral superiority to those who have adopted this startegy- e.g one cannot say that they cannot be crtiicized or condemend because they are the companions of the prophet. They are as much subject to criticism or condemnation as any other historical figure who as adopted similar techniques-e.g. Stalin, Hitler, Putin or other tyrants who live in the pages of history. Secondly the progress of the Islamic Kingdom looses all moral basis as a religion. It would then be absolutely correct that Islam was spread by the sword- Ghamdi actually says that in time sof such uncertainty- the sword descides what needs to be done- Secondly this perspective then also deprives the under dogs of all times for any recourse to moral or humanatarian objections for crimes againt them by the tyrannical counterparts of their time- e.g. The Crimes against the Palestinians as by the Israelis. Also, this explains the violence that is associated with Islam today- so why the criticism of Islamophbia- Perhaps BOKO Haram, ISIS and Al Qauda just view if the appropriate strategy from their perspective of what is the state of the World. Also it seems rigging elections to suit political situations has been a basis in Islam since day one, so why all the surprise that democracies do not flourish in Islamic countries? My message to Mr. Ghamdi is that yes adopt a real politik basis for interpretation but recognize that once you have done this, then there is no going back. You cannot have it both ways-e.g. citing a religious basis for these actions. This is a pact with the devil and ,there is no reprieve.

Jo waqiaat kurbala k barey mein Sahaba Kraam RA se narrate hoey hein onki hesiyet kia hy?? Plz answer

sir please clear the sound level as in all of your videos in this channel and afterwards. thank you.

I guess no human being is free from prejudice; even Ghamdi under the influence of his father who was one of the founders of Jamat e Islami

Sensible and knowledgeable discussion

Learning a lot from Jawed sb. Jazakallah

MaashaaAllaah Ustaad ji. JazaakAllaah Khaer. Please Chk Sound system..

Mr Ilyas, you wont be able to rewrite tragedy of Karbala . This is clear victory of a mazloom over a zalim

واقعہ کربلا غامدی صاحب کی روشنی میں

غامدی صاحب کی آواز کئی دفعہ صحیح نہیں آرھی ھوتی۔۔

toooo humble

Could someone please tell me where it is written in quran about khulafa e rashideen and there numbers? Or the number imams of shia? Why have muslims have been arguing to impose those bits as part of deen?

He has discussed the other matters. leaving aside the topic statement in part 1..2.. 3..why only one part is discussed...without referring to the the actual topic.

legend Ghamdi sb

subhan Allah jo hadis ko historical record kehty hain wo deen sikhyn gy.

Voice fault

غامدی صاحب سے سوال ہے کہ زبح عظیم جس کا قرآن میں ذکر ہے کہ اے ابراہیم علیہ السلام ہم نے آپ کی اس قربانی کو زبح عظیم سے بدل دیا تو کیا آپ ہمیں اس زبح عظیم کے تصور سے روشناس کرائیں گے کیا ؟

None of the sects has been established without historical biases. That is true. However, when viewed in the light of principles laid by Quran, few events can be analysed. For instance, can Ghamidi sahab defy that foundations of 'mulookiyat' were laid by Muavia bin Abi Sufyan? Can he defy that Ali, despite being one of the closest to Holy Prophet (saw), was not present in the 'shura' for the first caliphate? Ghamidi sahab remained ambiguous, because ambiguity favors his stature.

Its beating about the bush! This discussion arouses the listener to infer what is averred. Isnt it established that offspring of Prophet were killed brutally? Who did it? Werent they Muslims? Were they justified in doing so?

i always hear true who dont keep beard

Good discussion but horrible audio. Too much high level Urdu to actually comprehend the message.

جاوید احمد الغامدی الناصبی

Assalamu Alaikum

Yazid pleed na waris e Quran tha, na warise Rasul.S. Na ye Islam Ka numainda tha na awam Ka. Na ye khilafate Bila fasl ka numainda tha kun k Kisi Imam ki ( nas)k baghair khalifa bna bna tha. Oar na hi vo Khikafte Rashida ka numainda tha. Kun k vo shurai khalifa nahi tha. State power se khalifa bna tha. Ye Amire Sham Ka bigrha hua awara Londa tha. Jahannum k is Jamadar ko 56H, me os k valid ne Jannat va Ummat k Syed o Sardar, Sahibe Drud o Slam. Jin pr Sadqa hraam. Radhke Shams o Samar. Ht. Ibrahim.A.S. ki duaey imamat ka Samar. Rajule Azeem. Maniye Zibhe Azeem. Rijis o Nijasat se pak. Parvarda Aghoshe Rasul.S. Fateh Mubahela. Mavaddat e Ajre Resalat. Yani Farzand e Rasul.S, Jigar Gosha e Ali o Batool.S.A.,Ht. Imam Hussain.A.S. pr tarjih de kr khalifa namzad kya tha. Jis ki os waqt bhi Ami Aysha.R.A.,oar Imam Hussain.A.S. smait akabir sehaba oar Sehaba zadon ne shadid mukhalfat ki thi. Jis k natijay me Ami Aysha.R.A. ko shaheed kr dya gya.( Ibne Khaledun). Ht. Abu Hurrera.R.A, Abdur Rehman ibne Abi Bakr 59.H, me wafat pa gaey. Abdullah ibne Abbas nabina ho gaey. Abdullah ibne umer ne 60 H me yazid pleed ki beaat kr li. Jab k Imam Hussain. A S. Oar Abdullah ibne Zubair ne yazid pleed ki beaat se inkar kr dya. Oar Maddna se Makka tashrif le gaey. Jab Ahle Kufa ko malum hua k Imam Hussain. A.S, ne yazid pleed ki beaat nahi ki to onho ne aap ko apni traf se himayat k khatut likhay. Ahle Kufa k khatut Makka me aey. Madina me nahi. Yazid pleed ki jabri beaat tamam bilade Islam ne ki. Sivaey Imam Hussain. A.S, Abdullah ibne Zubair oar Ahle Kufa k. Jis pr yazid pleed ne Kufa k moatdil governor Noman bin Basheer ko mazul.kr k Basra k zalim trin nasbi governor ibne zyaad malun ko Kufa ki imarat Ka charge bhi de dya. Os malun ne Able Kufa pr mazalim k oagarh torh diay. Sarkarda afraad ko qatl ya qaid kr dya.Oar awam ko dra dhamka kr sath mila lya. Phr tanha kr k pehlay Kufa me Ht. Muslim bin Aqeel.A.S, oar on k 2 kamsin bachon ko shaheed kya. Phr Karbala me Imam Hussain. A S., oar on k khanvaday k muaaddas Khun se Holi kheli. Varna na Sanehae Karbala runuma hota na radde amal me matam.

So should we not give azaan/Iqamah in the ears of the new born????

Maseehi biradri dunya mae ek barray pemanay pr hai unk pas bakaida sboot hain,kitaab hai apne aqaid ko saabit krne k liye pr hm muslmaan udhr tou manne se inkar kr dete hn un tmam sbooton ko tou phir in ikhtlaafi mozuaat pr hm itne jmm kiu jatay hn?yha b tou usi perspective ko istmal kia jaskta hai na

Who were the lakhmids and the ghassanids?

Akhir nasbiyat samne aa hi jati Hain

غامدی صاحب مکمل پھنس گئے اپنی لوجک میں۔ واقعہ کربلا کی کہانی اور قرآن مجید و احادیث کی کتب اور سیرتیں ہم تک پہنچنے کے ذرائع ایک جیسے ہی ہیں۔ 🙏

Karbala u need see in hades not history if u Muslim 100/0

Misleading the innocent brian.....he must read the Moulana Moududi book "Khalafat o Malukiat. His opinion is from established history and others opinion are from non established history. Any selected caliph has a right to appoint and fired the governors. When Hazrat Ali removed the Amir Muyavia, he doesn't have a right to revolt. He can come and meet with Hazrat Ali personally. But he provoked the people of Syria, against Hazrat Ali. He would definitely denied the hadees of Hazrat Amar e Yasir regarding his killing by group of revolt. It is better we all must research thoroughly and critically. Otherwise such kind of people would mislead us.God help us.

Allah ki panah apse manni chahye janab

واقعہ کربلا کی وجوہات کو سمجھنا ہو تو مودودی صاحب کی خلافت و ملوکیت پڑھو کہ وہ تقریبا حرف آخر ہے۔

Nasbi duniya o akhirat m zalil hote rahen gy

Gamdi sahib aap siyasat (politics) ki aarr lekar Yazid Maveiya our Marwan ka mukabila Rasool e pak our uss ki aall (اھل بيت )cy kar rahee hain. kia يزيد پليت جيسا يا ابو صوفيان جيسا ھماري نبي پاڪ کي ھمسري کر سکتا ھۓ aap apni tarekhi knowledge ky bilkul ULAT kar raheee hain . Ye aap kiss ko bachany ky liey

Allah ki lanat ho jhooton par. InshaAllah Allah ka azaab nazil ho ga dushman e Ahlaibait a.s par

Planted to detract Muslim.

Aapni islamic history ka dushman...... Sab kuch books mein mention ha.. Listen to molana ishaq faisalabad walay

its easier to fool people instead let know that they are being fooled ! مطلب یہ کہ ڈھاپ تے لیلم ٹھینگ چوکییتا چغلم ڈھینگا ڈھاپ تلے ٫ دوسرا مصرا موصوف سے تم ابھی ابھی سن چکے ٫ اس گفتگو میں حسین کا نام تک نہیں

Ghamdi cleverly undermining the entire incident of Karbala as nothing happened. The news even came to India at the time of Karbala event. After watching his videos I believe he is short sighted in some Matters.

Gumrah karo jawano ko...

کربلا کا واقعہ ایک سیاسی جنگ تھی اس کا اسلام کے ساتھ کوٸ لینا دینا نہیں ہے

seedhi si baat hey. Hazrat hussein wanted to be khaleefa. Koofi haramzadon nay dhoka kiya. LEKIN PHIR BHI QASOOR HAZRAT HUSSEIN ka hey. mukammak tehkikaat kiye beghair karbla nahee jana chahiye tha. Nabi paak SAW ka tamaam khandan hi mer wa dita.