I had a similar reaction. I heard it for the first time and thought I must have heard it a thousand times before. All the little elements, some expected, some not, perfectly placed to create a little pop music miracle. Josh has a marvelous technical brilliance, and his performance is really heart-felt as well, and Carson has a sort of innate ease and fluidity that makes his performances always feel authentic. They just harmonize like mad, you can hear all those years of friendship. These guys are fantastic.

Agree on every point! Yes, a masterpiece for certain.

Could not agree more

I knew why, and I was still stunned!

Thank you for your kind words. But Josh and Carson did the heavy lifting.

I've been trying now for about two years to replicate that solo - or even come close to it with no success. On Josh's channel this solo was compared to George Harrison's solo on Til there was You - there is no comparison - I knocked that solo off in minutes - but Josh's solo here is way above that.

@@45156 that makes sense. But Josh’s is clearly more intricate and much longer. Blows my mind every time I hear it.

FYI, I recorded the sound directly from the mixing board.

I have ears and I approve this comment😉

If you're interested in technical details, the sound quality is so good because I recorded directly from the mixing board to a digital recorder and, later, synced that sound with the video.

I thought so! Credits also to the sound guy doing a terrific job!

The other two being Reina and Toni by any chance?

Oh, so true. I'd rather be in front of a big auditorium than just my family.

50 people were in the bar. I filmed only one song. 18,000 people have enjoyed the KZfaq video. You do the math.

hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha bet you like edm