WW2 historian here. AIM is absolutely on point, The German spent so much resources on tanks like Panthers, Tigers and the Dreaded Maus that they didn't built a Luftwaffe backup. They gradually lost planes to Red Airforce and couldn't replace them. German obsession with quality and Soviet pragmatism about quantity turned the tide of war

Incomplete transfer of population between India and newly formed Pakistan was one of the worst policy decisions, it can result in another disastrous partition of India bcoz Islam as a political doctrine never changes.

Not doing Population exchange in 1947 between India and Pakistan is worst policy decision

I always learn so much whenever I learn to historical stuff from Abhijit iyer mitra...TOTAL DELIGHT!.

Ashoka infact laid the foundations of totalitarianism and cult of personalities of future. And here we adorn him as a saint.

Looking forward to second part!

AIM was exited in explaining but the ICICI is not in the mood.

thanx a ton guys....it was very informative and eye opening...

Very good discussion. Very informative.

Very well articulated AIM👍🏻

Outstanding podcast

Vault sounds very good. Will check it out

Engine maths doesn't work out, unless dead weight of engines are problem in case of all 4 failing. The probably of all four failing is lower than all 2 failing, that is common sense. Using 2 engines vs 4 is mostly to do with economics and maintenance issues.

In Meerut we have several multi millionaire butchers...

3D printing cannot be applied on a scale. It is not for mass production.it is good for prototype or any specialized product which is required in small numbers.

16:54 I fact checked this info on many news websites, auto websites but I didn't found the info you gave. What I found was that in the top 10 list most unreliable cars were American manufacturer. Maybe because American consumer are more demanding.

It has been a year. Where is part 2 of this? 😂

Man..what an intellectually stimulating discussion!!...keep this type of discussion coming...topical discussions are overrated

Constructive analysis

Denmark economy contributor was from insulin sales of Bovine/Pork origin and later with synthetic ones.

okay, so let me elaborate near 22:00 about the maths AIM used to explain where he confused with 'redundancy' with 'attack surface area' : Case 1 : you need AT LEAST ONE engine to function properly in that case having 4 over 2 actually improves probability because (assuming 50% chance of an engine failure)... the probability of failing all engines is (1/2)^4 i.e. 1/16 in quad engine and in double engine, the probability of failing is (1/2)^2 i.e. 1/4 which is 4 times the quad engine. SO, BY INTRODUCING 2 MORE ENGINES, YOUR PLANE IS 4 TIMES LESS LIKELY TO FAIL. Intuitively, in case of 4 engines even if 2 fail, they'll still be as good as double engine. THIS IS REDUNDANCY && THIS IS HOW ALL DISTRIBUTED SYSTEMS WORK (INCLUDING KZfaq). Case 2 : you need ALL the engines to function properly to fly. In that case, the probabilities are now reversed, i.e. for a 4 engine machine, the probability of proper functionality is now 1/16 and probability of dual engine working properly is 1/4. THIS IS DUE TO AN INCREASE IN THE 'ATTACK SURFACE AREA' THAT COMPROMISING EVEN ONE COMPROMISES EVERYTHING && THIS IS WHY HACKERS TRY TO BREAK INTO AT LEAST ONE MACHINE TO COMPROMISE EVERYTHING. Now, of course this is a very simplistic explanation but, it's enough to point out the mathematical flaw.

do release it in shorts/parts as it increases the reach.

(don't consider these to be listicles) 1. 4:33 german overengineering 2. 24:11 the turkic habit of hostage taking in iran 3. 31:50 nordic socialism sweden norway 39:00 denmark 42:00 finland 46 4. 48:34 mercantilism

Colonial expropriation has to be counted in terms of today's money (that is with inflation related adjustment). One pound sterling in 1890 would buy you lot more in quantity than it does for the same product today. Similarly per capita is not a good yardstick of living standard of the masses be it from past or present; it has to be median household income (to adjust for income/wealth disparity between the political elites, ruling classes, influential traders close to echelons of political and military power and the grassroot masses) and that too measured in terms of PPP (and not exchange rate), corrected for historical inflation. The british narrative of the british subsidising India (just because the british colonialists stopped diverting Indian taxpayers' money into bearing the expenses of the India Office in London after 1919 that anyway used to be absorbed back into the british economy through british staff of the India Office in London spending their salaries and also the extraneous charges both of which were spent inside the british economy mostly much like US financial assistance to Afghanistan) is a myth at its best. Flight of Remittances of british colonial staff "earned" in India (ostentaciously high compared to contemporary west) to Britain continued after 1919, so did the monopoly profit by british mercantilists out of the Indian colony treated as an appendage of raw materials as well as a captive market and these british "investors" did not really acquire original assets in India through any remitting of their british homeland capital funds to India but instead acquired by rerouting of savings made by them on earnings they made in India locally most of the time, both through terms and conditions favorable to them under the auspieces of the colonial reign. As per economist Gurcharan Das, "The British government transferred its surplus revenues back to England. Since India consistently exported more than she imported in the second half of the 19th century and early 20th century, Britain used India’s trade surplus to finance her own trade deficit with the rest of the world, to pay for her exports to India, and for capital repayments in London. This represented a massive drain of India’s wealth." So, after East India Company's monopoly ended, Indian producers began exporting their products as well. However, rather than gold and silver, the British dealer used to pay Indian exporters in “Special Council Bills.” SCBs functioned similarly to checks, allowing Indian manufacturers to withdraw funds from colonial offices. However, the British regime played a trick by paying the money using funds collected from India’s own tax revenue. So technically there was no export revenue inflow into the Indian economy despite export from India. India's cumulative export between 1900 and 1928 was the second highest in the world but India remained a trade deficit country instead of becoming a trade surplus country because of this con pulled off the british colonialists. How do you counter that? In October, 1931, the British colonialist regime also depressed silver and gold prices in India and raised interest rates with the resulting money famine pushing Indian masses to sell their gold and silver savings that were shipped to Britain. In a nutshell, nett colonialist expropriation of India continued with almost equal vigor between 1920-1947.

When is part 2?

Sir if you could kindly list the reading list and recommendations for these topics, that would be awesome. I would love to learn more about them but I just don't know how to go about it.

Great insight into compilation of data, definitely worth a listen. What I don't understand why are listeners asking AIM about India's future for him its all dim and grim. He is an ivory tower thinker. The ground reality is as follows why industrialization is still not full on. 1) Capital is very expensive in India, while in west is 1-2%, in India it can be anything from 6-11% this is a major killer. 2) Infrastructure: Now BJP is building it relentlessly, prior to it there was none. 3) Because of point 2 land is expensive, i.e. to get a land to get ready for manufacturing you need road, electricity, water. 4) Trained Labor and casual Labor shortage, has AIM ever checked on what sort of labor shortage India has ? because India is practically a capitalist's society buttered by socialism and lack of communication links means getting good and cheap labour is very challenging. Appreciate if AIM can ready this comment and get back !! Rather than being a critic if he can offer solution then he will see what challenges lie ahead for the system.

Kushal this is working fine. You sound normal

Sound is perfect

WHERE is 2ND PART (6-10 policies)

@kushal Sir, can you make the list of the books you two used as a reference and add it to the description?

Masterclass.

Thanks

I am happy with your opinion

4:33:- German Quality 24:10:- Iranian hostage policy 31:50:- why socialism fails 48:34:-mercantilism is not capitalism

My like for abhijeets face on thumbnail 😅😅

Is there a part 2?

Sounds good

Posting this before watching - Hopefully Demonitisation makes it to the list or at least gets an honourable mention

The microphone is ok engineered. No change in sound quality

Since we have to 'liberalise' our economy in the 90s due to sheer desperation then, how more you think is the best way to modernise more. What policies should our Indian government at Central level adopt to improve our weak areas? Will soviet style 5 year plan help in the future too?

Actually you guys should do an I depth podcast on socialism

all the best

Hey Kushal ,ask abhijit to write a book depicting future india, showing the probable state of india due to lack of industrialization. Similar in format to George Orwell's 1984. Say, abhijit iyer mitra's 2047(or even later)

Hi Sir, Could you do a video on the Northeastern States of India. The current situation and why there is disparity between Northeastern States and rest of India. If you can enlighten about the Insurgency in Nagaland and the Special Status of Northeast States. Big fan, Thank you.

This conversation is more civilized than sham show

PLEASE EXPLAIN Abhijeet hamesha bolta hai ki industrialisation humesha autocracy ya dictator ship me hua hai ya hota hai toh kya koi bta skta ki 1920 me America ne industrialise kiya tha lekin tab toh vaha democracy thi.

poora europe economy conflicts aur colonies par hi chala.

post the paper that you mentioned you would in the video description - so that others can read it.

AIM is wrong... Indian growth under UK was zero, it's a big line. Till about 1990 there was no growth.

Mike is excellent

The best is the worst enemy of good enough 👍

Sound is nice bt check outside that would be more appropriate

AIM should stick to this which he is good at analyzing defence tactics, policies, implementation instead of lecturing on bollywood which he does not have knowledge of.

Having four engines and using all four does not mean redundancy. Redundancy is important. It means if one thing fails, you have a backup. The probability of failure does not increase.

The part 2 of this topic, was it not made or I can not find the link?

Sound quality is good

There is only one policy behind all wrong policy in the world's history -अति सर्वत्र वर्जयते।

Please Abhijit do one on indian metallurgy

Is there any book or article through which we can understand how Brits start subsidizing India after 1911 and this economic disparity under mughal rule.

AIM is a genius!!! S’he knows so much!

Make short video of this please

AIM is wrong .... about Britain subsidizing India from 1911 .... by then they had introduced a financial system that was later perfected by Bretton Woods .... around that time they introduced a system of allowing Indians to export .... but all payments had to be in the form of a British paper which could only be encashed into Indian currency at London. In addition there were taxes.

Interesting conversation. But there appears a lot of vehement holding on to some analayses... the underlying fact should be very solid for that.

❤❤❤

where is the link to the paper mention at 1:02:05 ?

Iam sure even if 3D printing may not have existed AIM would find another reason that why India can't Industralize.

Haleluya hilake lagale ruya 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

What about other 5 policies??

AIM confusing complexity with technology. Higher the complexity lower the reliability.

1:12:50 Interesting.

In the first example, wasn't Prussia even before German unification and consolidation came about, counted amongst the foremost military states even though it was smaller in size compared to France or Austria or England? So there must have been some excellence there and not the case that all things German were shit quality

Cant find part 2

22:30 can anyone comment the link of that article!!

Not doing complete population exchange between United Pakistan We can solve our internal problems (casteism, gender issues) way faster if we are not much polarized which was reaction to Islamic fundamentalism

Abhijit feels so proud destroying Scandinavian Socialism😂

Bring him again!!!!!Bring him again!!!

The microphone is sounding quite OK...

Air bus vs Boeing by whom? Could you please it spell it

Yaar, ye bhai har bar depress kar deta hai 😅😅

Abhijit puchi😘🐥

Dear AIM, wish I had a history teacher like you. One question .... at 59:25 of this video you mentioned 655 families 'controlled' 70% of the national income, please help me with the source and the families. 🙏

Part-2 ka link hai kisike pass?

Jai Shri Ram

is 2nd part released or not? anybody ?

3-4ft water for dzire thoda zyada ho gaya :p

U ALL ARE MOST IMMATURE N LESS KNOWLEDGEABLE U TUBERS, i IMPLORE PLESE WATCH MIND BLOGGING ANALYSIS FROM EXTREMELY PATRIOTIC GAURAV PRADHAN ON CANDID MEENA SHOW, HIS DEEPEST KNOWLEDGE ABOUT INDIA'S THOROUGHLY THOUGHT OUT POLICIES WILL RENDER U SPEECHLESS. JAI HIND, HAMHARA BHARAT MAHAN UNDER MODIJI'S LEADERSHIP,VANDE MATARAM 🙏🙏🙏💪💪💪🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

Abhijit , please don’t smoke on the show. Our Youngsters watch you .

क्या है ये? मेरे तो सब दिमाग के ऊपर से गया।

What was the rational for freight equalization in India

Didn’t realise Kusal is so shallow. Thanks to Abhijit for the really knowledgeable session

1:10:26 Mostly because of who? I didn't understand can anybody in the comments let me know?

Is Tara ka show banaya karo

You recommend RAGA to fulfill your prescription ?

Reservation is also one the worse policy decision

Russia-Ukraine war actually benefited India. India stood with Russia and did not allow it to become a Chinese Vassal.

Failed invasion of Russia by napoleon & Hitler proved worse for both the country. Napoleon abandoned France and Hitler committed suicide after Russian invasion of France and Germany.

1st July is celebrated as Doctor's day in the name of Dr Bidhan Chandra Roy who was the WB CM from 1948 to 1962 (until his death) So this 'CM" and practicing Dr contributed in Nehru's plan of deindustralising the most industralised state in India. I never knew about this man before today. 🙏

I see no difference in the audio. Or rather, the difference is not noticeable.

Full internal colonization currently being done by the 2 Gujarati masters of Mitra 😂