Some songs and vocals are just magic. This is one of them. Just timeless.

So thankful you have finally found Tommy Edwards. A fantastic singer that passed way too soon. He had so many wonderful songs, a real vocal artist. Please listen to more of his tunes.

One of my favorite songs of all time Tommy Edwards wow rest in peace

The music to this song was written in 1911 and named Melody in A Major. Charles G. Dawes VP under Calvin Coolridge co- wrote the lyrics becoming the only VP to write a Number 1 song. This was a beautiful version of this song. The wonderful orchestral backing certainly gave Tommy Edward's lovely voice a great platform to sing this perfect song. This was also covered by Cliff Richards and The Shawdows. Great reaction Harri. Thanks Harri and Cynthia. Beautiful choice. Cheers from Canada 🇨🇦

I rarely say it....but....this song is dreamy. So smooth and rich.

Thanks Harri, I danced to this song and many like this back in the day. Thomas Jefferson Edwards was the first African-American to reach No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100.

I was 10 when this song came out. Made me wish I was a singer because it was so perfectly done.

What a magnificent voice!

Used to hear this song on my college oldies station, brings back great memories. What a voice!

I transferred this song from an LP to a Maxell cassette in 1973, when I was stationed in Japan. I still have the tape and it still plays: absolutely beautiful rendition!!!!

What a beautiful song. Thank you for your appreciation of such talent.

Exactly, his voice is phenomenal especially backed by that orchestration.

Oh this is very dreamy and full of great memories. Thanks Cynthia and Harri.

Sweet memory from my teenage years! Slow dancing with wonderful boys to this song! Thank you for sharing. ❤️

This takes me back to courting times with my sweet husband. Thanks for playing and appreciating this gem.

This is so beautiful, reminds me of my dad, he played this alot. He loved his oldies.

Hi Harry, a great oldie, I remember my mom playing this on the record player when I was little. Thank you for a great memory! Love your reaction!

I’ve loved this song for many years

Interesting note about this song. Tommy Edwards recorded this song in 1951 which had a different arrangement and only reached # 19 on the charts. By 1958 sound recording had improved and Tommy recorded this song again with a lush arrangement and it became one of biggest hits that year and went to # 1 for 6 weeks!

One of those beautiful songs that we used to dance to. Lovely to see you appreciating it, all those years later !

I probably heard the first three seconds of this song thousands of times while watching television as a kid. It would always be on those informercial ads for 'Best Songs of the 50's". I can see my mom and dad dancing to this at the officer's club on Hamilton AFB when I was little boy. Classy selection, Cynthia, and great reaction, too, Harri

This is one of my all time favorites. So were the songs by the Platters - and I agree they sound a lot alike. Probably the reason I loved them all so much. Thanks, Harri, for keeping this brilliant music alive.

Wow...a golden oldie I had forgotten. A couple of years later my best friend and I were having sleep overs, writing fan letter to Johnny Mathis. How simple life seemed, but in retrospect, not for everyone.

How funny. Many mornings as I make my coffee, I sing this song for some unknown reason, and it takes me back to my early teen years. I love this song. Good to see it is being heard by someone new. This was great at dances so you could dance next to some pretty girls and hold them close. By the way my favorite dance partner then was a girl named Cynthia.

Finally! I remember slow dancing in the high school gym to this.

Have not heard this song in decades, yet I knew every word. Fantastic memories.

A lifelong favorite.

Hi Mr. Harri, A great voice and a great song.. It is hard to beat the oldies.. ♠W.G.

One of my all time favorites!

I'm so thankful I have a music loving family. My mom played all these great songs while I was growing up.

How strange. I was singing this to myself out of nowhere just this afternoon (inner jukebox on constantly)! Love your always soulful reactions, sir. Carry on✌️

Harri and Cynthia, thank you, I love this song and haven’t heard it in many years

Love this!! Such as beautiful song. Another from the era I'm sure you would enjoy is Hold Me, Thrill Me, Kiss Me by Mel Carter. I also think you'd love Tears On My Pillow by Little Anthony & The Imperials. Great doo-wop in that one!! So much music, so little time. . . . . . . .

Carl Sigman wrote the lyrics to the melody by Dawes in 1951. Edwards had the first released version of it in the same year and it was a mild success. It wasn't until a stereo version of it was released in 1959 that Edwards reached #1 on the charts. Many notable covers of this have been recorded: Cliff Richards hit #2 in the UK charts in 1963, Bing Crosby covered it in 1969 on hs album of "contemporary" material, "Hey Jude/Hey Bing!", and Van Morrison's rather faithful rendition was part of a medley of 2 songs in his 1979 album, "Into the Music" (people should give that a listen...Van does a splendid job). Thanks Cynthia and Harri.

Cynthia - Before Tommy completed the opening, "Many a tear," I instantly recalled his distinctive vocals and what was going on in my young life at the time. For me, that is yet another wonderful aspect of great music. You chose such a song and vocalist. That's saying a lot for someone who finally found his TV remote after nearly an hour of looking everywhere (I thought 😁). Terrific submission and wonderful review, Harri.

Harri … beautiful song! Thank you for sharing 😊

So special to me,every time I hear it I tear up. It was my moms fave. She gave me the 45 and I just played it every day. Wore it out. gave me my love for doo-wop. When my mom died in 75,I putbthe 45 in her casket just before they closed it. She taught me to dance with it. Thanks mom so much.

wow....beautiful memories !!!! thank you fran NM

I can remember dancing to this song.... It's one of the most beautiful songs of my childhood and I agree that it reminds me of the Platters...

Nancy Wilson " How Glad I am " You will Love her great song !

He voice was pure class! Don't remember any of his other music, if he made it.

Such an amazing voice; He reminds me of Nat King Cole... Another artist to love...:)

I can't believe this was your first time hearing this wonderful ballad. Tommy Edwards sang this live on the Ed Sullivan Show watched by millions and hit it out of the park. I think he was the most modest, self-effacing personality to ever appear on national television. There were in those days, 2 kinds of dance "slow" dancing and "fast" dancing. This was a slow dance number, and you could watch couples on the dance floor in an embrace that wouldn't quit. I remember this like yesterday, the high point in American music for young people.

I love this song since it used to played on WCBS-101FM in NYC when they played 50's-60's oldies. Great song.🎼🎶🎶🎵

Thanks Cynthia & Harri this Tommy Edwards recording a favorite from the time I was young & danced around the living room with my parents💜 He is probably why I love R & B and crooners from the day. I think I’ll listen to it several times and dance around to Tommy Edwards beautiful voice 💎💫😊🇨🇦

First black man to top the charts. He had so many, many hits. Play more.

I always loved this song. It was a hit when I was a kid. I was blown away many years later to actually hear Bob Dylan cover it in a concert in the late 70's and he did a beautiful job of it and backing vocals were excellent!

It was #1 on the charts in 1958. I was only 6 yrs old and still remember all the words. Thanks for the memory!

Harri you're doing a great job with your reactions. You know growing up I listened to all type of music and it did not matter to me from what race. I love this stuff - music is a source that should unite us all black or white, etc...................

This is my all time Favorite song of all time. I could listen to it over and over. This is a beautiful beautiful song. I have loved this song forever. Enjoyed your music . Thank you .

Harri,youve finally did my favorite male singer of all time, tommy edwards,he was from richmond virginia and lived from 1921-1969,gone way too soon, some other hits were, please love me forever, please mr. sun,ive been there, love is all we need, the morning side of the mountain, he was one of the 1st singers to successfully sue the record company for back royalties-RIP TOMMY

This is an excellent choice, Harry! When we were young girls in the late 60's and early 70's, my parents used to play their records and dance in the living room on Friday nights, my Dad would sing to my Mom, and this was one of the great songs I grew up with.

One of the best dancing song of it’s time ❤

Love this song ... brings back such memories! Thank you for reacting to this ... we need to hear more of him! God bless you

Sadly, stupidly, never had a name to associate with this beautiful and beloved doo-woppish classic. Now I know. Thank you, Cynthia and Harri, a welcome start to a busy day and the weekend to follow. Much love, my friends ❤️

One of the most played songs during the 50s. Many of other hits…. Other Side Of The Mountain. Mr. sunshine. ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

Wow- what a voice, what a song. Thank you. Your videos are such a mood enhancer!

Was born in London in 64 brought up on this music and I feel sorry that people don't even know about Tommy ,the doo woop ,Sam Cooke, Otis ,platters, Dell's, Ray Charles God Bless Bless Them all many before and after the Greats that made beautiful music and song ,❤

This used to be my favorite song way back then. Songs make memories for the future. Each song recalls a memory, some sad , some glad.

I am an old guy that grew up listening to music like this, and it thrills me to see newer generations "discovering" something so beautiful that has been brushed away by time. To me, music was born in the 1930's, and it died in the 1960's. Maybe one day a new generation will bring it back to life!

This is pure sonic joy.

I remember hearing this song and similar coming out of my stepfather radio. This is so smooth. I loved watching your reaction Harri.

I'd love to hear someone react to Little Willie John's "shakin". Yeah he wrote "fever" too. And don't forget Tony Williams with the Platters :)

I was born in 1954 and I learned to dance standing on my Daddy's feet to this song! I have his album!!! More great songs on it.

Wonderful song, is a diamond.

One of the most perfectly performed and recorded popular song ever recorded 😀😀😀😀

Such a wonderful song, 1958 huge hit👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

I first heard this 37 years ago. I was driving listening to Steve Wright in the afternoon and it came on as part of his golden oldies. It was before the internet and I had to stop the car because his voice was simply so beautiful, it bought me to tears and I simply had to capture who was singing it. 3 years later I was working with a company who could get hold of any record, past present. I asked them to get this along with Green onions for my then future wife. They produced both. To listen to it on 45, with the interference is amazing. On our wedding night this was the song I danced with my wife too. Tommy Edwards, you're a legend! In incidentally, this was the 5th No 1 ever on the US billboard eventually selling approx. 3 million copies.

Lovely song Cynthia 🥰 Did not know it before 😊😀 Thanks Harri

Lawdy lawdy, this iconic song has been in some cinema for sure. Fantastic number.

Everything comes together in this track. Tommy's voice blends perfectly with this arrangement and the backing vocals...Such an improvement on Tommy's earlier recording....

how lucky I was to have grown up during the 50's and 60's music.

Nat King Cole sings this as well. I love both versions. The lyrics are so very romantic. What ever happened to romance in music????

Puts me back in my kitchen after school dancing and singing to the radio. Another big favorite. Love watching you enjoy the music, Harri! 💚💚💚

My dad would blast this high in the car when i was little.we didnt care if he was black or white,its a beautiful song.i grew up still loving that song and the way he did it.we were in an old buick my father had and it was just heavenly with the console radio just perfect

When I was a teenager in the 50’s Tommy Edward’s voice was just so perfect for slow dancing with the boys at out Friday night at the Teenage dances.

Harri...I knew you would like this song !...It has special meaning to me....Funny, how when you are about to turn 77, you can remember so many events in your life like they happened just yesterday. This great song is one of those moments. I heard it at my first " Y " Teens Dance. My first dance and she was beautiful. Puppy love at first sight ! Lou Anne, I can still see her in my minds eye...1958...Bloomington Illinois. Peace !

👍 ! Top pick ! What a voice ! ( Suggestion : The Velvetones . The Glory of Love !) Doo - wop at its peak ...

One of my all time favourites. Brings back so many memories of great times. ❤ Others have covered this song but they cannot touch this version. IMHO.

Man oh man, do you have a world of sounds and singers you've yet to hear and are going to love. You're on a wonderful journey.

Have you ever heard Tears on my Pillow by Little Anthony and the Imperials?

Kinder gentler classy stuff.

Oh I remember slow dancing to this song. Brings back so many memories.

Takes me back to memory's of my mother at home in the kitchen with the music playing in the background in the 50's thank you. Peace out.

My Dad had this record when it was out... 1958.....I was barely 3 years old and digging it... he would bring his stereo outside in the summer and blast it in our carport ........ I thought it was called "Hole In The Game".. haha....Priceless memories and a fantastic record......

Fantastic pick Cyn. Had this great song on my future lists. This was on the soundtrack of the movie "Mischief" which has the best soundtrack of any movie ever. IMO. A great collection of 50's and 60's hits from Elvis,Fats Domino,Tommy Edwards,The Platters,Little Richard, Chuck Berry, and many others. It starred Doug McKeon and the late Kelly Preston(Mrs. John Travolta). It is a great movie about teenage angst. Tommy Edwards was such a great voice. Marvelous reaction Harri. As usual. 🙃👍🇨🇦🇺🇸🤴🇬🇧

Johnny Mathis “The twelfth of never” touching lyrics.

What a singer and song..JUST LOVE IT..

Love that vintage plate reverb.

This brings back wonderful memories of my dad. One of his favorite songs. Thank you.

Great song! Tommy Edwards was an R&B singer & songwriter. "It's All In The Game" was his biggest hit in 1958 but he did some other songs such as "Please, Mr. Sun", "Love Is All We Need" etc. "It's All In The Game" was also recorded by Cliff Richard & The Four Tops. Several of his songs became hits for other artists such as "A Fool Such As I" by Elvis Presley, "Please Love Me Forever" by Cathy Jean & The Roommates & later by Bobby Vinton & "Morning Side Of The Mountain" recorded by Donny & Marie Osmond.

That was my father's favorite song. Brings back a lot of memories.

Hard to beat the oldies. Especially compared to much of garbage today.

Tommys album has all great songs. Hall of fame worthy. Rare feat - no skip songs Top 50s romantic songs.

Thanks for helping to relive one of the fondest memories of my childhood. It was of us as a family in the kitchen of our home in RAF Faldingworth, a small supportive base set deep in the green Lincolnshire countryside of England. We lived in a small simple terraced, 2 rooms up - 2 rooms down, enlisted man’s ‘married quarters’. It was 1964 and I was about 11. My father, and my two younger brothers and I were scrunched around a corner nook eating dinner which was an evening meal after Dad got back from work, except for Sundays when dad would open up the dining table in the living room. Mum cooked roast beef or chicken, roast potatoes, carrots, brussel sprouts, and Yorkshire pudding to sop up the gravy, and there was always something special for dessert. But on this occasion mum was at the sink doing the dishes with her back squarely facing us trying to hide how upset she was about something - I didn’t know it at the time but dad had just informed her that he was being sent on a one year ‘unaccompanied tour’ to Bahrain, in the Persian Gulf. My dad was a true gentle-man who had more integrity than any man that I ever met, and mum loved and respected him dearly. They both had the heart of a lion. We were kids and hadn’t yet noticed mum grimly clattering her way through the pots and pans, but dad sure did. Unhappy wife, unhappy life. He slipped away from the dining table and came up behind mum and put his arms around her and started softly singing “It’s all in the game” in her ear. She stiffened and muttered, “Oh, not now, leave me alone.” Dad gently persisted and eventually got her to turn around. As dad pulled her to him she reluctantly put her head in his shoulder and mumbled into his chest through quiet tears, “You silly man.” That was the closest thing that I ever saw to mum trying to push her husband away but even then she wasn’t really pushing hard and dad wasn’t letting go! The next thing you know Dad was crooning away and waltzing mum around the kitchen floor while she half cried and then half laughed - and then she held him tight. They stayed that way.

The Other Side Of The Mountain was another hit. Also Mr. Sunshine. He had many beautiful hits. ❤❤❤

One of my favorite songs of all time

I purchased this album for my sister maybe 1960, Love Tommy Edwards, Earl Grant, Nat, Johnny Mathis. There has to be some of those today but where are they. Beautiful, Beautiful Music.

One of my favorites gir slow dancing in the 50's at school dances!!❤

I have always loved this song.